Instruct: Classify an Amazon review as either positive or negative.
Query: OneRing Rocks

I was one of the fortunate ones to obtain this book at the Los Angeles Book Fair the day of its release. And even luckier to have a signed copy!! It is an easy read for those who are Tolkien fans, but by no means scholars. And for those who want a more in-depth discussion, it's there. This book is well written, well thought, and does not condescend or speak above it's readers. It's just right!!The impressive views from the various writers provide a nice blend of perspectives; culturally and educationally. Once, I started reading it, I found myself reading "just one more article,' then one more, then one more, until I read the whole book in one sitting. And I still pick it up and reference it time and time again because it is so well done.If their is a Tolkien fan on your gift giving list this is the book to have.