Instruct: Classify the given Amazon review as either positive or negative.
Query: Great floor liners - way better than WeatherTech

I bought a pair of these for my Ford Ranger. These fit very well, and more importantly they have curve up quite high on all 4 sides. As such they "corral" a fair volume of melted snow. I purchased a set of WeatherTech's "DigitalFit" floor liners for my car and while they also fit very well they do not curve up very high at the back and after my first winter drive with the WeatherTech's I removed them and won't use them again. There was only 1 or 2 ounces of water from melted snow in the driver's side liner which slopped out the back all over the carpet. I have gone back to my trusty old Pants Saver mats, which don't fit as well but hold a lot of melted snow.