Instruct: Classify the given review as either positive or negative.
Query: Keeps butter soft...but it falls in the water

Maybe I'm doing something wrong by putting too much water in the bottom, but mine isn't working properly. I may see if amazon will exchange it for another. It doesn't seem to make an "air tight" seal at all. Mt butter was very soft, but it fell into the bowl of water. I really wanted to like this product. Meh.