Instruct: Classify a review as either positive or negative.
Query: Win for Apple (and me)

I see many people like to bash this particular item. I don't know if they leave in on the floor and purposefully try to step on and break it or what. I simply misplaced mine original dock during a move and had to replace it. The first one worked perfectly well as does this one. I keep in in a drawer. It's out of potential harm so it won't break... really people. Get a grip. If it doesn't work for you then buy a 3rd gen shuffle already. For me, I'm happy. :)