Instruct: Classify the given Amazon review as either positive or negative.
Query: Great Value

I just ordered my 4th pair of these since 2005 (all shiny brown.) The heel colar does wear quicker than the rest of the boot. And the shiny black/brown models have what looks like a vinyl coating over real leather. After about 1 1/2 years of daily use I wear through the vinyl coating in the toe kick area and have to replace them. The boots are kind of heavy and not the most comfortable shoes you'll ever wear but I can't complain for the money. Style-wise look great with jeans or slacks and can work in a pinch for business casual (I wouldn't wear them every day in that environment though.) I have a few other boots in my collection and none are as versatile or inexpensive as these Alley Cats.