Instruct: Classify the given Amazon review as either positive or negative.
Query: I had to have these replaced 3 times and they were ALL tarnished!

I had terrible luck with this item. I had to send back for replacement 3 times and all 3 sets were tarnished!! I ended up getting my money back because they could not send me a set that was not tarnished! annoyed because I ordered the matching guest book and toasting flutes and really wanted the cake serving set! I guess I will have to find it elsewhere! Only thing good I can say is that Amazon customer service was quick about trying to send replacements and then giving me my money back!