Instruct: Classify the given Amazon review as either positive or negative.
Query: First thoughts of a new student

I purchased the CDs first, not realizing that the printed book would not be included in the expensive audio package... so there was some serious frustration when I finally realized that another purchase (and wait) was necessary before the set of CDs could be used. The CDs alone are virtually useless, since the audio language lessons they contain don't have any English whatsoever and apparently rely on the textbook to explain the meaning of the phrases being spoken!Aside from that little clarification, I would concur with those other reviewers who note that classroom study, and/or cultural immersion with native speakers as guides, is really desirable for learning a language - especially one as unfamiliar to most English-speakers as is Navajo. This book and CD set probably does as well as one could hope, but it isn't - and can't be - ideal.