Instruct: Classify a review as either positive or negative.
Query: Tamara Marsh's Review

The giving tree is a very good book for any kid to read,and it is very calming but I personally fell that itwasenT giving enough and it diden't have enough of an edge to it .And I am not just saying that eventhough it is a children's book.But I saw through all of thoes flaws and gave this book a good score.