Instruct: Classify the given review into positive or negative sentiment.
Query: Great Live Album

I initially thought that this album was pretty bad. Liam's signing was awful - too dark and raspy. However, after a few times listening to the album I began to realize how well his singing fit with the rock-and-roll atmosphere. There are a few gems on here; I particularly like the cover of the classic "Hey, Hey, My, My". Of course, the greats are in here - "Live Forever", "Don't Look Back in Anger"," Wonderwall", "Supersonic"... though unfortunately many of the best songs are left out, especially those from their third album Be Here Now. But all in all, it is an excellent live album that will be appreciated by all devoted Oasis fans.