Instruct: Classify the given Amazon review as either positive or negative.
Query: Routine Chaplin shorts - which makes them better than most other silent shorts

Shoulder Arms:The trenches of WWI through the imagination of an Army recruit - and with an anti-war message at the end. A good but not great Chaplin short.The Idle Class:Lots of great bits, of course, and a decent mistaken identity story. Not tightly structured as Chaplin's better work though.A Dog's Life:A routine Chaplin short - which makes it better than most other silent shorts.A Day's Pleasure:Although Chaplin hadn't yet perfected his cinematic timing and pacing, that doesn't detract much from the joys of this Chaplin short. A few sequences go on a bit long but the opening sequence in particular is a gem.The Pilgrim:An escaped convict is mistaken for the new pastor of a Western town. As with most Chaplin shorts it's basically a series of gags strung together - but built around a slightly stronger than usual plot.have not yet seen the rest of this collection.