quantum spin chains are physically realized in quasi - one - dimensional magnetic compounds .
these are crystalline materials with magnetic ions arranged in exchange - coupled chains that are isolated from each other by non - magnetic ions .
the elementary magnetic moments are localized on the sites @xmath3 of a one - dimensional lattice , which makes them distinguishable .
the associated spin operators thus commute if they belong to different sites of that lattice , @xmath4=\imath\hbar \epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma } s_{l}^{\gamma } \delta_{ll'}$ ] .
the hilbert space of a spin-1/2 chain with @xmath5 sites is conveniently spanned by product basis vectors @xmath6 , @xmath7 .
prominent among the many models employed in the context of quantum spin chain compounds is the spin-1/2 @xmath0 model , @xmath8 it describes a uniform nearest - neighbor exchange coupling with uniaxial anisotroy .
periodic boundary conditions are assumed .
we distinguish ferromagnetic coupling @xmath9 from antiferromagnetic coupling @xmath10 , and the planar regime @xmath11 from the axial regime @xmath12 .
important special cases are the @xmath1 model @xmath13 , the @xmath2 model @xmath14 , and the ising model @xmath15 .
one persistent challenge through decades of experiments on quantum spin chain compounds has been the interpretation of the observed intensity spectrum in terms of constituent quasiparticles @xcite .
the chief motivation of the work reported here is to shed new light on this very issue .
the approach taken is eclectic in nature , combining older and more recent results for the unified purpose of understanding the quasiparticle composition of the @xmath0 spectrum more thoroughly .
the strong interest in the @xmath0 model is sustained not only by its direct relevance in experimental physics , but also by its amenability to exact analysis via bethe ansatz .
the solution of the @xmath2 model was , in fact , the very problem for which bethe originally invented the method in the early days of quantum mechanics @xcite .
the bethe ansatz allows for a characterization of all many - body eigenstates as composed of quasiparticles that scatter off each other or form bound states and thus turn into different quasiparticles . over the years
the same basic idea has been successfully applied to many different kinds of systems and situations including interacting boson and fermion gases with contact interactions @xcite , the hubbard model for electrons on a lattice with on - site repulsion @xcite , and for bosonic and fermionic quantum field theories including the quantum sine - gordon and thirring models @xcite .
the @xmath0 spectrum can be generated from different pseudovacua by the systematic creation of quasiparticles with different exclusion statistics . in most cases
these pseudovacua are states of lowest energy ( physical vacua ) .
an overview of the different kinds of quasiparticles that have emerged from analytic work on the @xmath0 model is shown in fig .  [
fig : qpzoo ] .
the boxes in the top row represent quasiparticles whose names are derived from jargon used to describe coordinate bethe ansatz solutions .
these quasiparticles are characterized by strings of complex momenta with common real part and different imaginary parts @xcite .
one - strings are unbound magnons , two - strings are bound magnon pairs etc . small ( large ) imaginary parts indicate loose ( tight ) binding @xcite . at @xmath16
the strings are constituent particles of ( degenerate ) multiplets of eigenstates with total spin @xmath17 .
these multiplets split up energetically at @xmath18 .     model . for @xmath19 ,
the pseudovacua of spinons and solitons are at the bottom of the spectrum .
the pseudovacuum of the string particles is at the top in the axial regime ( @xmath20 ) and moves downward in the planar regime ( @xmath21 ) , reaching the center in the @xmath1 limit and coinciding there with the pseudovacuum of jordan - wigner fermions.,width=453 ]    at @xmath22 the energy levels join up in new degenerate configurations , reflecting different symmetries @xcite . a more natural classification scheme for the @xmath1 spectrum
is then based on string fragments .
hence the name _ broken strings_.
these fragments are closely related to the free lattice fermions that emerge from the jordan - wigner representation of spin-1/2 operators @xcite . at @xmath23
the imaginary parts of the string solutions grow in magnitude and diverge as @xmath24 .
hence the name _ stretched strings_. the tightly bound strings are related , in the ising limit , to localized domains of reversed spins on successive lattice sites .
the exclusion statistics of these domains is similar to yet subtly different from that of the strings .    the boxes in the bottom row of fig .
[ fig : qpzoo ] represent quasiparticles that are complementary to the string particles .
the string pseudovacuum contains the maximum number of spinons or solitons .
the spinon and soliton vacua contain strings at maximum capacity .
whereas the string particles have integer - valued exclusion statistics , the spinons and solitons are realizations of fractional statistics @xcite .
they are both semions but with different pseudovacua .
the exclusion principle for semions is , roughly speaking , halfway between those applicable for fermions and bosons .
if it takes @xmath25 particles to lower the number of orbitals in a band available for occupancy by one , then @xmath26 describes fermions , @xmath27 semions , and @xmath28 bosons ( as a limit ) .    the string particles and the semionic particles are natural building blocks for the systematic construction of a complete @xmath0 eigenbasis from different pseudovacua .
the configurations of string particles and semionic particles are both unique and preserved in every @xmath0 eigenstate .
the ground state ( physical vacuum ) of the @xmath0 antiferromagnet @xmath10 coincides with the pseudovacua of the semions .
the spinon vacuum is unique and coincides with the non - degenerate ground state of the @xmath0 model at @xmath29 for even @xmath5 .
the soliton vacuum is twofold and coincides with the ground state of the @xmath0 model at @xmath23 for @xmath30 .
let us briefly illustrate the relation between the particles from the top and bottom rows in fig .
[ fig : qpzoo ] with two simple scenarios , one in configuration space and the other in momentum space . in the ising limit
, @xmath31 has simple product eigenstates .
the ferromagnetic state @xmath32 is the unique pseudovacuum for domains of consecutive flipped spins , @xmath33 , as shown in top part of fig .
[ fig : qpis22ar ] .
the twofold nel state , @xmath34 , @xmath35 , by contrast , is the pseudovacuum for antiferromagnetic domain walls of the kind @xmath36 , @xmath37 as shown in the bottom part of fig .
[ fig : qpis22ar ] .
these domain walls ( named solitons ) have effective spin @xmath38 .
the integer - valued exclusion statistics of domains is associated with the fact that neighboring particles must be separated by any positive integer number of lattice sites .
the fractional exclusion statistics of domain walls , on the other hand , is associated with the fact that one of two lattice sites may be shared by neighboring particles .     at @xmath24 in real space ( lattice of @xmath5 sites ) .
they are either domains of flipped spins embedded in the unique vacuum with all spins up ( top ) or domain walls embedded in the twofold vacuum with all spins alternatingly up / down ( bottom ) .
, width=453 ]    in the @xmath1 limit , @xmath31 is equivalent to a system of @xmath39 free lattice fermions in a band @xcite .
the ground state corresponds to the intact fermi sea at @xmath40 as shown in fig .
[ fig : xxfermvspin ] .
the entire spectrum can be generated systematically via particle excitations @xmath41 , hole excitations @xmath42 , and particle - hole excitations @xmath43 .
the fermi - sea ground state can be viewed as the pseudovacuum for semionic spinons .
we introduce a threshold momentum @xmath44 that varies with @xmath39 .
when a fermion is removed from the intact sea , @xmath44 slightly increases to generate not just one but two vacancies in the interval @xmath45 of the band .
these two holes are then identified with a pair of spin - up spinons . when a fermion is added outside the intact fermi sea
, @xmath44 slightly decreases to produce two particles in the region @xmath46 .
they are identified with a pair of spin - down spinons .
a fermionic particle - hole excitation leaves @xmath44 unchanged and is interpreted as a pair of spinons with opposite spin orientation .
the entire spectrum can thus be described in the form of spinon configurations .     at @xmath22 in reciprocal space ( fermionic band with fermi momentum @xmath47 ) .
they are either spinless jordan - wigner fermion or semionic spinons with spin @xmath38.,width=453 ]    the main goal of this work is to identify the relationship between the string particles and the semionic particles for @xmath31 at @xmath48 in particular and to illuminate how this relationship can be tracked between the three points in parameter space . in sec .
[ sec : ba ] we set the stage for this investigation by reviewing the relevant bethe - ansatz representations that best serve our purpose .
we then discuss the quasiparticle composition of the @xmath0 spectrum in the @xmath2 limit ( sec .
[ sec : xxx ] ) , the ising limit ( sec .
[ sec : ising ] ) , and the @xmath1 limit ( sec .
[ sec : xx ] ) .
the coordinate bethe ansatz for @xmath31 uses the magnon vacuum @xmath49 with energy @xmath50 as its reference state . the bethe form @xcite of any eigenvector in the invariant subspace with magnetization @xmath51 , @xmath52 has coefficients of the form @xmath53 determined by @xmath54 magnon momenta @xmath55 and one phase angle , @xmath56 , for each magnon pair .
the sum @xmath57 is over the permutations of the indices @xmath58 .
the @xmath55 and @xmath59 satisfy the bethe ansatz equations ( bae ) , @xmath60 the energy and the wave number of an eigenstate with magnon momenta @xmath61 are @xmath62    reasons of practicality dictate the use of different transformations of the bae in the regimes of axial anisotropy @xmath12 , planar anisotropy @xmath63 , and isotropic exchange @xmath14 .
it is convenient to introduce rapidities @xmath64 , @xmath65 which renders the limit @xmath66 smooth from both sides .
the bae thus transform into @xmath67 where @xmath68 the bethe quantum numbers ( bqn ) @xmath69 of integer or half - integer value reflect the multivaluedness of the logarithm used in the transformation .
they are subject to restrictions that will be discussed case by case .
the energy expression in becomes @xmath70    note that we are , effectively , dealing with a single anisotropy parameter , @xmath71 , that is real in one regime , imaginary in the other , and zero at the isotropy point .
this parametrization is particularly useful for tracking the spectrum between the axial and planar regimes across the point of higher rotational symmetry .
slightly different parametrizations are more adequate for the exploration of the limits @xmath24 in the axial regime and @xmath72 in the planar regime .      at @xmath23
we use the transformation @xcite , @xmath73 instead of ( [ eq:6 ] ) , to bring the bae ( [ eq:16plj3 ] ) into the form @xmath74 - \imath }        { \coth(\eta ) \tan \left[(z_i - z_j)/2\right ] + \imath } ,          \qquad i = 1,\dots , r.\ ] ] the associated trigonometric bae are @xmath75 where @xmath76 the second term in ( [ eq:13 ] ) ensures that the set @xmath77 remains the same as an eigenstate is tracked across the axial regime @xcite . here
@xmath78 is the floor function ( integer part of @xmath79 ) .    for the analysis of solutions that include complex magnon momenta we invoke the string hypothesis for the rapidities
@xcite : @xmath80 the index @xmath3 distinguishes rapidities belonging to the same string ( of size @xmath81 ) .
the index @xmath82 distinguishes different strings of the same size .
the string ansatz ( [ eq:104plj3 ] ) produces only asymptotic solutions of the bae ( [ eq:19plj3 ] ) for @xmath30 .
the finite-@xmath5 corrections are , in general , exponentially small , and not all finite-@xmath5 solutions fit the string template ( [ eq:104plj3 ] ) @xcite . however ,
neither corrections nor exceptions affect macroscopic systems . in the ising limit , where the spread of imaginary parts in ( [ eq:104plj3 ] ) diverges
, all corrections and exceptions disappear even for finite @xmath5 .
a given string solution of ( [ eq:19plj3 ] ) with magnetization @xmath51 is described by @xmath54 rapidities that breaks down into configurations of strings such that the constraint , @xmath83 is satisfied , where the set @xmath84 identifies those sizes of strings that occur in a given eigenstate . with the functions
@xmath85 we rewrite eqs .
( [ eq:19plj3 ] ) in the form @xmath86^{n }     = \prod_{j \neq i}^r \varphi_{2}(z_{i}-z_{j } ) ,     \quad i = 1,\dots , r.\ ] ] when we substitute the string ansatz ( [ eq:104plj3 ] ) into eqs .
( [ eq:106plj3 ] ) we obtain @xmath87^{n }      = \prod_{(m',\beta ) \neq ( m,\alpha)}\prod_{k=1}^{m'}\ ;    \varphi_{2}(z_{\alpha}^{m , l}-z_{\beta}^{m',k } )     \prod_{k\neq l}^{m }    \varphi_{2}(z_{\alpha}^{m , l}-z_{\alpha}^{m , k}),\ ] ] for @xmath88 and @xmath89 , where @xmath90/2\big ) }         { \sin\big([z_{\alpha}^{m}+\imath\eta(m+1+\nu-2l)]/2\big)}.\ ] ] to determine the real parts , @xmath91 , we form the product of all eqs .
( [ eq:107plj3 ] ) for fixed @xmath92 : @xmath93^{n }     = \prod_{(m',\alpha ' ) \neq ( m,\alpha ) }    \left[\prod_{k=1}^{m'}\prod_{l=1}^{m }    \varphi_{2}(z_{\alpha}^{m , l}-z_{\alpha'}^{m',k})\right ]     \left[\prod_{l=1}^{m}\prod_{k\neq l}^{m }    \varphi_{2}(z_{\alpha}^{m , l}-z_{\alpha}^{m , k})\right].\ ] ] each expression in square brackets can be simplified massively , producing the bae for the @xmath91 , @xmath94^{n } =      \prod_{(m',\alpha ' ) \neq ( m,\alpha ) }     \varphi_{m'-m}(z_{\alpha\alpha'}^{mm ' } ) \varphi_{m'+m}(z_{\alpha\alpha'}^{mm ' } )     \prod_{l=1}^{m-1 } \left[\varphi_{m'+m-2l}(z_{\alpha\alpha}^{mm'})\right]^{2 } ,   \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath95 .
the associated trigonometric bae , @xmath96 @xmath97 depend on a set @xmath98 of bqn that reflects the specific string combination of any given eigenstate .
the energy and wave number of that state are @xmath99 \mathrm{mod}(2\pi).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the range of the @xmath100 will be discussed first for the case @xmath16 in sec .
[ sec : isotropic ] and then for the axial regime including the ising limit in sec .
[ sec : ising ] .      at @xmath16
we retain the rapidities from ( [ eq:6 ] ) , the trigonometric bae in the form ( [ eq:15 ] ) , and the energy expression ( [ eq:16 ] ) .
the string hypothesis now reads @xmath101 the bae for the real parts @xmath91 are eqs .   with ( [ eq:108plj3 ] ) replaced by @xmath102 the associated trigonometric bae for
the @xmath91 then take on the form with @xmath103 from ( [ eq:8 ] ) and @xmath104 from ( [ eq:7 ] ) .
the energy and wave number of an eigenstate specified by the set @xmath98 are @xmath105   \mathrm{mod}(2\pi).\ ] ] the string hypothesis sets the range of the @xmath100 ( with @xmath106 implied ) as follows @xcite : @xmath107 where @xmath108 is the number of @xmath81-strings ( distinguished by running index @xmath109 ) in the eigenstate .
note that the range of allowed values becomes narrower for all sizes if a string of any size is added .
the @xmath100 for a given combination @xmath110 and a given value of @xmath81 are either all integers or all half - integers such that the border values of the range ( [ eq:10 ] ) are realized .
the bethe state characterized by a set @xmath98 is the highest - weight component ( i.e. the state with @xmath111 ) of an @xmath112-multiplet with total spin @xmath113 the other components of any given @xmath112-multiplet are generated by the addition of magnons with zero momentum .
these have no effect on the energy or the wave number .
consider the case of a highest - weight state with total spin ( [ eq:11 ] ) that only contains 1-strings .
suppose this state is specified by the following set of bqn subject to the constraint ( [ eq:10 ] ) : @xmath114 the rapidities @xmath115 derived from the bae ( [ eq:1 ] ) , @xmath116 are real and , with rare exceptions , finite .
the member state with @xmath117 of the same multiplet has one extra rapidity , @xmath118 , representing the additional magnon with @xmath119 .
the bae ( [ eq:1 ] ) for this state are then satisfied with the same @xmath115 , @xmath120 and with @xmath121 if we set the bqn as follows : @xmath122 in the more general case , where the highest - weight state under consideration contains strings with @xmath123 , the shifts in the already existing bqn , @xmath100 , and the value of the new bqn , @xmath124 , will be different . in sec .
[ sec : xxx ] we will treat the strings as interacting particles and examine their exclusion statistics .      the string ansatz at @xmath125 @xcite will not be used here .
simplifications and residual complications that occur in the limit @xmath72 can be seen in the raw form ( [ eq:16plj3 ] ) of the bae .
there are two categories of solutions , both of which are ubiquitous .
regular and singular solutions are distinguished by the absence or presence of pairs of critical magnon momenta with @xmath126 , which make both the numerator and the denominator in ( [ eq:16plj3 ] ) vanish as @xmath72 .
all regular solutions produce real magnon momenta from @xmath127 , whereas singular solutions include critical magnon pairs that are either both real or form a complex - conjugate pair @xcite .
the latter can be interpreted as fragments of strings that exist throughout the planar regime .
since all critical pairs are associated with a twofold degeneracy of eigenstates with equal wave number , the singular features as imposed by the bae in the limit @xmath72 can be removed by unitary transformations .
this erases , at @xmath22 , all traces of the string nature , at @xmath128 , of complex solutions .
the magnon momenta thus regularized are @xmath129 the associated bqn are integers for odd @xmath54 and half - integers for even @xmath54 with range @xmath130.\ ] ] their relation to the bqn ( [ eq:10 ] ) and ( [ eq:30 ] ) of the @xmath112-multiplet states will be discussed in sec .
[ sec : xx ] .    the regularized bae solutions ( [ eq:33 ] ) describe hard - core bosons .
the phase shift is @xmath131 for all two - particle interactions .
these hard - core bosons are equivalent to the jordan - wigner fermions @xcite that have been instrumental in most studies of the @xmath1 model .
we are now ready to explore the relationship between the complementary quasiparticle compositions of the @xmath0 spectrum .
we begin in sec .  [
sec : xxx ] with string particles and the complementary spinon particles for the @xmath2 case . in sec .
[ sec : ising ] we then discuss the effects of axial anisotropy on the strings and their relationship to ferromagnetic domains in the ising limit .
complementary to these domains are the soliton particles in the shape of antiferromagnetic domain walls . in the planar regime
the strings evolve differently .
what remains of them in the @xmath1 limit are fragments that act like hard - core bosons or , equivalently , free jordan - wigner fermions .
complementary to the latter are again the spinons as will be discussed in sec .
[ sec : xx ] .
the very structure of the coordinate bethe ansatz suggests that the strings ( [ eq:5 ] ) can be interpreted as quasiparticles .
there exists a universal energy - momentum relation as implied by ( [ eq:9 ] ) .
the particle interaction is encoded in the set of momenta ( or rapidities ) dictated by the bae and in the phase shifts associated with elastic two - particle collisions .
the exclusion statistics of strings is determined by the rule ( [ eq:10 ] ) governing the range of bqn and by the relation ( [ eq:11 ] ) governing the capacity for strings in a highest - weight state of given @xmath112 .
the total number of @xmath112-multiplets with string content @xmath132 becomes the solution of a standard combinatorial problem : @xmath133 where @xmath134 are statistical capacity constants and statistical interaction coefficients , respectively , that are specific to the string particles @xcite .
taking into account the @xmath135-fold degeneracy of each multiplet , this classification accounts for the complete spectrum , @xmath136 with the dependence of @xmath112 on @xmath110 given in ( [ eq:11 ] ) .    to illustrate the string composition of the @xmath2 spectrum and to explain its relationship to the complementary spinon composition we consider a chain of @xmath137 sites .
in table  [ tab : comstrn6 ] we list all combinations @xmath110 permitted by ( [ eq:11 ] ) .
also listed is the range of all @xmath100 present in each combination as inferred from ( [ eq:10 ] ) .
the distinct configurations of @xmath100 thus allowed produce the highest - weight states of all @xmath112-multiplets as shown in fig .
[ fig : stringn6 ] ( left ) .
the quantum number @xmath112 depends on the combinations @xmath110 via ( [ eq:11 ] ) and the wave number @xmath138 depends on the configurations @xmath98 via ( [ eq:9 ] ) .
each row of @xmath100 in fig .
[ fig : stringn6 ] ( left ) represents the distinct string motif of an @xmath112-multiplet .
the solution of the bae ( [ eq:1 ] ) thus specified is for the highest - weight component of the multiplet .
the non - highest - weight components are characterized by additional bqn as described at the end of sec .
[ sec : isotropic ] .
the role of these additional bqn will be discussed in sec .
[ sec : ising ] for @xmath23 ( see fig .  [
fig : stringn6plus ] ) and in sec .
[ sec : xx ] for @xmath125 ( see fig .  [
fig : stringn6minus ] ) .    .string composition @xmath110 of all @xmath112-multiplets for @xmath137 .
each row describes a distinct combination for a total of 7 .
each combination produces @xmath139 multiplets for a total of 20 .
each multiplet represents @xmath140 states for a total of 64 .
associated with each string in a given combination is a bqn @xmath100 of the range shown . [
cols="^,<,<,^,^,<",options="header " , ]     -multiplets of the @xmath2 model for @xmath137 in the string representation ( left ) and spinon representation ( right ) .
the quantum numbers @xmath112 and @xmath141 of each multiplet are stated on the far left .
the positions of the numbers @xmath142 and the vertical lines ( left ) mark the values of the @xmath100 and their range .
the @xmath143 , emphasized by circles , are markers for the spinon configurations ( right ) , where they are reproduced as small circles .
each square on the right represents a spinon .
the set of squares is complementary to that of circles with the same range .
the number @xmath144 inside each square marks the spinon orbital .
the energy of each @xmath112 multiplet is stated on the far right.,width=377 ]    elements of the string motif serve as the template of the spinon motif of the same @xmath112-multiplet .
spinons are specified by their spin and momentum quantum numbers .
the spinon interaction depends on the particle momenta and ( in general ) also on the particle spins .
the unique @xmath2 ground state for even @xmath5 is the spinon vacuum .
the ground state for odd @xmath5 is fourfold degenerate and contains exactly one spinon .
the total number @xmath145 of spinon is restricted to be even ( odd ) for even ( odd ) @xmath5 and can assume the values @xmath146 .
counting the spin - up spinons @xmath147 and spin - down spinons @xmath148 separately produces the relations @xmath149    it is useful to introduce spinon orbitals associated with distinct spinon momentum quantum numbers @xmath150 .
the wave number of any @xmath2 multiplet can be expressed in terms of the spinon orbital momenta as follows : @xmath151 the range of @xmath150 depends on both @xmath5 and @xmath145 : @xmath152 the number of available orbits to @xmath145 spinons , @xmath153 , thus decreases by one for every two spinons added , @xmath154 , which is one way of recognizing the semionic nature of spinon particles .
the exact exclusion statistics of spinons is encoded in the number of ways @xmath155 spin - up spinons and @xmath156 spin - down spinons can be distributed among @xmath157 accessible orbitals .
the spinon multiplicity expression @xcite , @xmath158 @xmath159 is cast in the same general form as its string counterpart ( [ eq:19 ] ) .
summation of @xmath160 over all allowed values of @xmath161 accounts for all @xmath162 states .
the complementary relationship between the string and spinon particles is reflected in their motifs . in fig .
[ fig : stringn6 ] we show the string motif and spinon motif of all 20 @xmath112-multiplets for @xmath137 side by side .
the number of spinons contained in each eigenstate of a given @xmath112-multiplet is equal to the number of vacancies left by the 1-string bqn , @xmath143 , across the range ( [ eq:10 ] ) . in fig .
[ fig : stringn6 ] ( right ) we have marked the positions of the @xmath143 by circles and the vacancies by squares .
the number inside each square denotes the orbital @xmath150 to which every spinon belongs .
the available orbitals depend on @xmath145 via ( [ eq:23 ] )
.    the rules for assigning spinons of particular momentum quantum numbers to orbitals must ensure ( i ) that the @xmath150 reproduce , via ( [ eq:24 ] ) , the wave number @xmath138 already known via ( [ eq:9 ] ) and ( ii ) that the permissible spin orientations are consistent with the quantum number @xmath112
. the allowed combinations of spinon orbitals are encoded in those @xmath112-multiplets that do not contain any strings with @xmath123 . here
the positions of the 1-strings , i.e. the circles in the spinon motifs , play the role of delimiters between successive spinon orbitals .
a spinon orbital with @xmath163 spinons has an orbital spin @xmath164 , @xmath165 .
if all @xmath145 spinons are in the same orbital such as in the first two motifs ( numbered from top to bottom ) this spinon configuration represents a multiplet with @xmath166 .
any distribution of spinons into multiple orbitals represents more than one @xmath112-multiplet .
the multiplets represented are determined via the decomposition of tensor products of orbital spins .
for example , if we have one spinon with @xmath167 and three spinons with @xmath168 , that decomposition reads @xmath169 .
the associated multiplets with @xmath170 and @xmath171 are found in motifs three and thirteen , respectively .
the configuration with two spinons in each of the same two orbital represents three @xmath112-multiplets according to @xmath172 .
they are found in motifs four , fourteen , and twenty , respectively .
the systematic application of these rules assigns a unique spinon momentum and spin content to every @xmath112-multiplet .
the energetic split of different @xmath112-multiplets associated with the same spinon momenta is caused by a coupling between orbital spins . in the haldane - shastry model , which has higher symmetry , that coupling is absent and these particular @xmath112-multiplets remain degenerate @xcite . in the @xmath1 model , which has lower symmetry , even the @xmath112-multiplets split up energetically as will be discussed in sec .  [ sec : xx ] @xcite .
the translation and reflection symmetries of @xmath31 dictate that every state with wave number @xmath138 can be transformed into a state with wave number @xmath173 and the same energy , implying that any state with @xmath174 is its own image .
these transformation properties are reflected in the string motif @xmath175 and in the spinon motif @xmath176 as is evident in fig .
[ fig : stringn6 ] .      in the following
we describe three ways of generating the spectrum of the ising chain , each producing a distinct set of quasiparticles with different exclusion statistics .
we begin with the analysis of the string solutions of the bae from sec .
[ sec : axial ] .
to arrive at a non - divergent spectrum in the ising limit of @xmath31 we rescale the exchange coupling as follows : @xmath177 the rescaled energy expression ( [ eq:17plj3 ] ) of the bethe ansatz in raw form thus becomes @xmath178 evidently , real magnon momenta contribute only summarily to the energy , namely via the first term in ( [ eq:31plj3 ] ) .
non - vanishing terms @xmath179 can only come from complex @xmath55 with infinite imaginary parts .
we first track the highest - weight states of the @xmath112-multiplets from the @xmath2 limit to the ising limit .
for these states , all solutions that are real at @xmath16 stay real and all solutions that are complex at @xmath16 have imaginary parts that diverge as @xmath24 .
the non - highest - weight states evolve far less uniformly .
the additional rapidities , which are all equal to @xmath180 at @xmath16 , become , in general , finite and thus contribute to the energetic split of the @xmath112-multiplets . in some states , the extra @xmath64 stay real , in other states they combine to form complex pairs .
it appears that this transformation from real to complex rapidities takes place throughout the axial regime .
here we focus on the end product at @xmath181 , where the ferromagnetic domains in ising product eigenstates become the natural quasiparticles .    expanding the trigonometric bae ( [ eq:1 ] ) of the axial regime about the ising limit produces , in leading order , a set of linear bae for the real parts of the rapidities , @xmath182 where the new set @xmath183 of bqn , related to the original set @xmath98 by a shift that depends on @xmath5 and @xmath108 , has the same range ( [ eq:10 ] ) @xmath184 which guarantees the correct number of states from the highest - weight type .
as the first step in the solution of the linear bae ( [ eq:87 ] ) for these states we introduce the quantities @xmath185 equations ( [ eq:87 ] ) summed over @xmath109 can thus be brought into the form @xmath186 with @xmath187 guaranteed to be positive .
equation ( [ eq:90 ] ) is solved by matrix inversion .
substitution of the solution @xmath188 into ( [ eq:87 ] ) yields the rapidities @xmath189 more explicit solutions in compact form for the situations where only 1-strings or only 2-strings are present read @xmath190
@xmath191 if a single @xmath81-string with @xmath192 is present we have @xmath193 with @xmath194 .     eigenstates with @xmath195 for @xmath137 in the string representation ( two columns ) .
the quantum numbers @xmath196 , @xmath112 and @xmath141 of each state are stated on the left .
the vertical lines indicate the range ( [ eq:10 ] ) of the @xmath143 .
the positions of the numbers @xmath142 between the vertical lines represent the values of the @xmath100 for the highest - weight states ( with @xmath111 ) .
the additional bqn of the non - highest - weight states ( with @xmath197 ) are all located on the outside . in the ising limit
each state evolves into a translationally invariant linear combination of ising product states with domains of lengths as indicated on the far right in each column.,width=491 ]    in fig .
[ fig : stringn6plus ] we have reproduced the bqn of all 20 highest - weight states for @xmath137 at @xmath16 from fig .  [
fig : stringn6 ] and have added the bqn for all 22 non - highest - weight states with @xmath195 .
the additional @xmath143 of non - highest - weight states , obtained for @xmath16 as described at the end of sec .
[ sec : isotropic ] , are located beyond the range of the @xmath143 for the highest - weight states ( vertical lines ) .
the choice of the extra @xmath143 and the associated shift of the @xmath100 already present is not unique in most cases .
our choice was guided by the aim to avoid multiple @xmath143 of the same value and to restore the symmetry relations described at the end of sec .
[ sec : xxx ] . for states with @xmath174 , which are their own images under the symmetry transformation , neither goal was fully achievable for @xmath137 .
the @xmath143 configurations are asymmetric in several instances and two identical @xmath143 are unavoidable in one instance .
these aesthetic flaws pose no problem for what follows .    to the right of each string motif in fig .
[ fig : stringn6plus ] we have added another motif in the shape of a ket .
it identifies each string solution as tracked from @xmath16 to @xmath181 with an ising eigenstate as composed of linear combinations of ferromagnetic domains .
we have already introduced these domains in the context of fig .
[ fig : qpis22ar ] .
here we use a notation conducive to linking ising product eigenstates with obvious domain composition to bethe eigenstates with specific string structure in the limit @xmath181 .
let the set of @xmath198 product vectors with @xmath199 flipped spins that are generated from one such state , @xmath200 , via translations be represented by @xmath201 .
let @xmath202 represent the set of @xmath203 translationally invariant linear combinations of all product states that contain @xmath204 domains of length @xmath205 subject to the constraint @xmath206 .
any set of the latter kind is constructed from one or several sets of the former kind with matching domain content .
for @xmath137 there are seven sets of translationally invariant ising eigenstates at @xmath195 thus constructed :    [ eq:91sub ] @xmath207    in fig .
[ fig : stringn6plus ] we have identified each of these 42 states with a particular bae solution in the limit @xmath24 .
the identification is straightforward for the highest - weight states .
each bqn @xmath100 represents exactly one domain of size @xmath208 . however , the evolution of the non - highest - weight states between @xmath16 and @xmath24 is far less predictable .
the extra bqn are all of the type @xmath143 at @xmath16 and the associated rapidities are real and infinite . in some cases
all extra rapidities stay real .
the domain structure of these states is determined by the @xmath100 just as in highest - weight states .    however , for the majority of non - highest - weight states some of the rapidities that start out real at @xmath16 turn into complex - conjugate pairs at @xmath23 with imaginary parts that diverge as @xmath24 .
this metamorphosis necessitates a reconfiguration of the associated bqn ( not shown in fig .
[ fig : stringn6plus ] ) . of the 22 non - highest - weight states for
@xmath137 only six do not acquire additional complex rapidities between @xmath16 and @xmath24 , namely those states for which the string content encoded in the @xmath100 matches the domain content encoded in the ket .
the identification of the bae solutions in the limit @xmath24 with ising eigenstates of specific domain content may be less certain in longer chains where states with different @xmath209 but equal @xmath196 are degenerate .
that is the case for the two sets of states @xmath210 and @xmath211 in a chain with @xmath212 sites , for example .
however , it seems reasonable to assume that this degeneracy is absent at @xmath213 in most if not all cases and thus guarantees that the bae solutions have , in general , a unique domain content in the limit @xmath24 . even though the systematics of the transformation of some bae solutions between @xmath16 and @xmath24 appears elusive at present , the systematics of the endproduct , namely the domain structure of the ising spectrum for arbitrary @xmath5 , is well known .
an ising chain of length @xmath5 can accommodate domains with @xmath214 consecutive flipped spins .
domains of size @xmath215 are treated as distinct species of independent particles .
the capacity for domains is restricted by the relation @xmath216 the total number of ising eigenstates with domain content @xmath217 is governed by a multiplicity expression somewhat similar to ( [ eq:19 ] ) yet different @xcite : @xmath218 @xmath219 the capacity of the system for domains is controlled by @xmath220 and the statistical interaction between domains by @xmath221 .
all domains have the same energy , @xmath222 .
the statistical mechanics of domains for the ising chain has been carried out exactly @xcite , reproducing familiar results .    in the context of fig .
[ fig : qpis22ar ] we have already qualitatively described the antiferromagnetic domain walls ( solitons ) that are complementary to the ferromagnetic domains . among the four distinct bonds in the general product state @xmath223 ,
the bonds @xmath36 , @xmath37 represent solitons with spin @xmath224 , @xmath225 , respectively , and @xmath226 , @xmath227 are vacuum bonds .
close - packed solitons with like spin orientation reside on successive bonds ( e.g. @xmath228 ) , whereas close - packed solitons with opposite spin orientation are separated by one vacuum bond ( e.g. @xmath229 ) .
each of the seven sets of ising eigenstates ( [ eq:91sub ] ) contains a specific number of spin - up and spin - down solitons , @xmath230 all solitons have the same energy , @xmath231 . the multiplicity expression for solitons @xcite
, @xmath232 @xmath233 is similar to expression ( [ eq:25 ] ) for spinons .
solitons and spinons are both semions but have different pseudovacua .
whereas the spinon vacuum was found to be unique , the soliton vacuum is twofold , consisting of the two product nel states , @xmath234 and @xmath235 or linear combinations thereof . the soliton vacuum , like the spinon vacuum ,
is realized only in chains with even @xmath5 .
here we investigate what happens to the highest - weight and non - highest - weight states of the @xmath112-multiplets in the presence of planar exchange anisotropy , particularly in the limit @xmath22 .
we have seen that in the axial regime there exists a tendency for real bae solutions to become complex .
as @xmath24 all imaginary parts diverge , binding the magnons tightly into domains . in the planar regime , there exists a trend in the opposite direction . at @xmath22
all bae solutions can be regularized as stated in sec .
[ sec : planar ] , making all magnon momenta real . all strings with @xmath123 break up into 1-strings .
the configurations allowed by the set ( [ eq:34 ] ) of bqn , which describe regularized solutions , produce the complete spectrum for arbitrary @xmath5 .
eigenstates with @xmath195 for @xmath137 in the string representation ( two columns ) .
the quantum numbers @xmath196 , and @xmath141 of each state are stated on the left .
also shown on the left is the quantum number @xmath112 of the multiplet at @xmath16 from which the state evolved .
the states are listed in the same sequence as those in fig .
[ fig : stringn6plus ] .
the positions of the 1 represent the values of the @xmath143 from ( [ eq:34 ] ) and constitute the motifs of the ( broken ) string configuration of the @xmath1 eigenstates .
the motif of the complementary spinon configuration is marked by the squares ( spin - up spinons ) and diamonds ( spin - down spinons ) as explained in the text.the momentum quantum number @xmath150 and the spin orientation @xmath236 of each spinon present in that state are given to the right of the dual string / spinon motif .
, width=491 ]    in fig .
[ fig : stringn6minus ] we show the configurations of @xmath143 of all 42 eigenstates with @xmath195 at @xmath22 for @xmath137 in the same sequence as the corresponding @xmath112-multiplet states at @xmath16 have been listed in fig .
[ fig : stringn6plus ] .
all multiplet states at @xmath16 that contain only 1-strings keep the same configuration at @xmath22 . in the other states ,
all @xmath143 stay in the same position except the pair of @xmath143 that have identical values in fig .
[ fig : stringn6plus ] .
they are replaced in fig .
[ fig : stringn6minus ] by a pair of distinct @xmath143 .
furthermore , each @xmath237 in fig .
[ fig : stringn6plus ] is replaced by two @xmath143 in fig .
[ fig : stringn6minus ] and the one occurrence of a @xmath238 is replaced by three @xmath143 .
whereas the general rules for these substitutions still elude us , the constraints imposed by symmetry and conservation laws eliminate any ambiguity for the case @xmath137 shown here .
the resulting configuration of @xmath143 produces , via ( [ eq:33 ] ) , the exact configurations of jordan - wigner fermion momenta in a periodic chain @xcite .
the statistical mechanics of the regularized 1-strings is that of a system of free jordan - wigner fermions @xcite .
each @xmath1 eigenstate thus identified by its composition of 1-strings has a unique composition of spinons .
the rules for inferring the spinon motif from the string motif are consistent with the rules described in sec .
[ sec : isotropic ] for the case @xmath16 but there are some noteworthy differences .
the lower rotational symmetry at @xmath22 , which splits up the @xmath112-multiplet degeneracy , makes it possible to assign to each @xmath1 state not only a spinon configuration with unique momentum quantum numbers but to the spinons in each orbital also a unique spin orientation .
the spinon motif is encoded in the string motif of each state shown in fig .
[ fig : stringn6minus ] as described in the following .
( i ) consider the vertical lines dividing the space of the @xmath143 into two domains the inside and the outside , the latter wrapping around at @xmath239 .
( ii ) every @xmath143-vacancy ( small circle ) inside represents a spin - up spinon ( marked by a square ) and every @xmath143 ( 1 ) outside represents a spin - down spinon ( marked by a diamond ) .
( iii ) any number of adjacent spinons in the motif are in the same orbital , i.e. have the same momentum quantum number @xmath150 from the set ( [ eq:23 ] ) .
two squares or diamonds that are separated by @xmath240 consecutive 1 s have spinon quantum numbers separated by @xmath241 .
( iv ) the spinon momentum quantum numbers are sorted in increasing order from the line on the left toward the right through the inside domain @xmath242 and toward the left with wrap - around through the outside domain @xmath243 .    the spinon motif of fig .
[ fig : stringn6minus ] establishes the much needed link between spinon motif of the fermion representation at @xmath22 introduced in refs .
@xcite and the spinon motif of the string representation at @xmath16 introduced in fig .
[ fig : stringn6plus ] . unlike the solitons at @xmath24 , the spinons at @xmath22 are not free . nevertheless , an exact statistical mechanical analysis of spinons at @xmath22 is possible @xcite .
away from the ising limit , the solitons become interacting particles as well .
they can be tracked all the way from @xmath24 to @xmath22 .
a comparison between the spinon composition and soliton composition of the @xmath1 eigenstates can be found in ref .
the long - established integrability of @xmath31 imposes stringent constraints on the nature of the interaction between quasiparticles of any kind , reducing it , effectively , to two - body scattering events . as a consequence ,
these quasiparticles have infinite lifetimes and can thus be regarded as structural elements of the @xmath0 eigenstates .
this makes it possible to systematically generate the complete spectrum from the pseudovacuum of one or the other set of quasiparticles .    in this work
we have discussed two complementary sets of quasiparticles , one set being the basic elements of string solutions of the coordinate bethe ansatz and the other the semionic spinons or solitons .
our focus has been on developing interlocking motifs for each set of quasiparticles for the purpose of tracking them across the axial and planar regimes of @xmath31 .
starting from the symmetry point @xmath16 in parameter space we have identified opposite trends , in the two regimes , in the evolution of string particles , which can be thought of as bound clusters of magnons . in the axial regime ,
the strings show a tendency of increasing tightness in the binding within each cluster ( rapidities with growing imaginary parts ) and a tendency of merging clusters ( real rapidities becoming complex ) .
the endproduct at @xmath181 are ferromagnetic domains of flipped spins . in the planar regime ,
the strings appear to loosen up and break apart . at @xmath22 it
is possible to transform away all complex rapidities and with them any trace of magnon clustering .
the free magnons behave like hard - core bosons or free fermions .
for @xmath19 the pseudovacuum of string particles is located at the top of the spectrum throughout the axial regime and then migrates down toward the center of the spectrum in the planar regime .
the ground state ( physical vacuum ) of @xmath31 is unique in the planar regime and twofold in the axial regime .
it can be identified as the pseudovacuum of spinons or solitons , respectively .
we have given detailed descriptions of spinons at @xmath22 and @xmath16 and of solitons at @xmath181 , including their relationship to the string particles .
what remains to be investigated is the metamorphosis of the string particles between the special points @xmath48 in parameter space .
this is work in progress .
of particular interest is an analysis of the transformations for which we have given here only qualitative descriptions and the impact of these transformations on the motifs such as displayed in figs .
[ fig : stringn6]-[fig : stringn6minus ] including the effects on the complementary spinon and soliton particles .