since the discovery of the fractional quantum hall effect@xcite , the properties of two - dimensional ( 2d ) interacting electron systems in a strong magnetic field have attracted persistent attention . historically , almost all the efforts were directed toward the study of the strong magnetic field case when only the lowest landau level is occupied .
some attempts were undertaken @xcite to extend the analysis to a larger filling factor @xmath5 .
however , they were all limited to the case when the energy of the electron - electron interaction is much smaller than the inter - landau level spacing , @xmath6 , with @xmath7 and @xmath8 being the magnetic length and the background dielectric constant respectively . under this condition
, one can describe the system in terms of one landau level only ; the effect of mixing of the other landau levels was either neglected or taken into account by perturbation theory@xcite .
in a weak magnetic field , the typical coulomb energy exceeds the cyclotron energy @xmath2 . in this case , one can start from the fermi liquid theory in zero magnetic field .
the concept of fermi liquid usually enables one to neglect the interactions between quasiparticles when determining their energy spectrum in the vicinity of the fermi level .
this concept is based , first , on the screening of coulomb interaction , and , second , on the constraint on the phase space allowed for a scattering event@xcite .
landau quantization of the non - interacting quasiparticles in two dimensions creates a system of discrete levels .
the existence of energy gaps between the levels affects adversely the screening , which involves the low - energy excitations of the electron system .
in addition , if the fermi level coincides with a landau level , the system of non - interacting quasiparticles becomes infinitely degenerate , and even a weak interaction lifts this degeneracy .
this may result in a non - trivial fine structure of the partially filled landau level ( pfll ) .    in this paper , we study the low - energy properties of the system with a partially filled high landau level@xcite ( the level index @xmath9 equals to the integer part of @xmath10 $ ] ) . by integrating out all the other degrees of freedom , we derive the effective interaction between the electrons occupying this level .
this procedure is valid for a weakly interacting electron gas @xmath11 , and at sufficiently large filling factors , @xmath12 .
( here @xmath13 is the conventional parameter characterizing the interaction strength . )
the effective hamiltonian enables us to develop a microscopic theory of the thermodynamic and tunnelling densities of states , and a description of spin excitations . in the tunnelling density of states
, we find a pseudo - gap with a characteristic width @xmath14 , which confirms the result of the hydrodynamic approach@xcite .
the thermodynamic density of states and spin excitations are characterized by the energy scale @xmath15 .
both energies are smaller than @xmath2 .
it makes our theory complementary to the conventional fermi liquid picture@xcite which is valid in the energy range @xmath16 .
the paper is arranged as follows .
[ peds ] is a qualitative discussion of the energy scales relevant for the problem , and the summary of our main results .
[ sec : hamiltonian ] is devoted to the rigorous derivation of the effective hamiltonian describing the low - energy physics . in secs .
[ sec : td ] and [ sd ] we apply the effective hamiltonian to study the thermodynamic and the tunnelling density of states .
the spin excitations are discussed in sec .
let us first consider an incompressible electron liquid with an integer filling factor @xmath17 . because of the gap @xmath2 in the spectrum , an external in - plane electric field @xmath18 can not be screened by the 2d electron system .
instead , it causes only a finite polarization per unit area , @xmath19 .
the polarizability of the incompressible 2d electron liquid reduces the interaction @xmath20 between two point charges embedded into it , @xmath21 where the two - dimensional dielectric function @xmath22 is related to the polarizability @xmath23 by@xcite @xmath24    at small wave vectors , the matrix elements of the dipolar moment between adjacent landau levels , @xmath25 , give the main contribution to the polarizability , @xmath26 ; here @xmath27 is the electron density on a landau level . the characteristic spreading of the electron wave function on a high landau level is equal to the cyclotron radius @xmath28 , and
the estimate of the dipolar moment is @xmath29 . substituting @xmath23 into eq .
( [ chi ] ) , we find : @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the bohr radius .
( [ chilong ] ) is valid only at small wave vectors , @xmath32 . in the opposite limit ,
@xmath33 , a large number of landau levels participate in polarization of the 2d electron liquid .
therefore , the standard thomas - fermi screening holds : @xmath34 formulas ( [ chilong ] ) and ( [ chishort ] ) match at @xmath35 ; the corresponding value of the dielectric constant , @xmath36 , is large in the weak magnetic field limit , where @xmath37 .
the dielectric function for arbitrary @xmath38 is given by eq .
( [ simpleepsilon ] ) , see sec .
[ sec : hamiltonian ] .    as it follows from eq .
( [ chilong ] ) , polarization is irrelevant only for interactions on a very large length scale , @xmath39 , where @xmath20 is given by the unscreened coulomb interaction , see fig .
[ figpot ] . at a smaller scale ,
@xmath40 , polarization is important , and eqs .
( [ potentialq ] ) and ( [ chilong ] ) yield : @xmath41 a t @xmath42 , according to eq .
( [ chishort ] ) , thomas - fermi screening takes placer , and the potential has the form @xmath43    the renormalized potential eq .  ( [ potentialq ] ) is significantly smaller than @xmath2 .
therefore , unlike the bare coulomb potential , the renormalized interaction does not mix landau levels .
this observation enables us to construct an effective theory of the low energy properties of the electron system .
similar to the strong magnetic field case , @xmath44 , the corresponding hamiltonian is just the energy of interaction between the electrons restricted to a single , partially filled landau level .
the main difference is that in our case the interaction potential ( [ potentialq ] ) is much smaller than bare coulomb potential , and the pfll has a high index @xmath9 .
although still unsolvable , this low - energy theory is much simpler than the original one , where all the landau levels were relevant .
armed with the effective theory , we are able to estimate the characteristic energy scales which control the low - energy dynamics . in order to make these estimates
, we employ the hartree - fock trial function , based on the one - electron wave functions of the @xmath45-th landau level .
( see secs .
[ sec : td ] and [ sd ] for more details . ) at small electron concentration on the pfll , @xmath46 , the separation between electrons on this level exceeds the size of the wave function , @xmath47 . in this case
the system under consideration is equivalent to a classical crystal of point charges interacting via potential ( [ potentialq ] ) . in the extremely dilute limit , @xmath48
, the polarization is not important , and the usual coulomb repulsion between the electrons of the pfll is not modified . in this limit
the electron system of the pfll does not differ from a wigner crystal of electrons of the lowest landau level in the strong magnetic field regime .
however , due to the polarization effect , there is a wide region of electron densities in the weak field regime , @xmath49 , where the coulomb repulsion in the crystal is replaced by the logarithmic potential ( [ potlong ] ) . in this case , the static properties of the electron crystal are equivalent to those of the vortex lattice in a thin superconducting film@xcite .
we apply the developed picture to study of the energy dependence of the tunnelling density of states .
we find a suppression of the tunnelling density of states ( one - electron spectral density ) at energies close to the fermi level @xmath50 , which is similar to the known results@xcite for a small filling factor , @xmath51 . in the latter case , despite rather different approaches , all the authors@xcite find a `` gap '' region of width @xmath52 ( here @xmath53 is the total electron density at @xmath54 ) .
such a gap can be easily understood : @xmath55 equals the coulomb interaction energy of an extra electron with a `` frozen '' 2d electron system .
if there were no relaxation of the system at all , the density of states would vanish at energies @xmath56 .
the relaxation processes smear out the threshold in the density of states ; however , the suppression is still strong at these energies , because the characteristic relaxation time exceeds @xmath57 in a strong magnetic field . for a weak magnetic field ,
there are two stages in the evolution of the system after an electron tunnelled in . on the short time scale , @xmath58 , the polarization of the medium
is formed , and the potential induced by the additional electron acquires the form ( [ potentialq ] ) . at larger time scales ,
only the electrons of the pfll can be re - distributed .
the latter processes are slow , which causes the suppression of the tunnelling density of states .
the corresponding gap is determined by the interaction of the tunneled electron with its nearest neighbors , @xmath59 .
for a broad range of the filling factors of the pfll , @xmath60 , the width of the gap is : @xmath61 it is worth noticing that @xmath55 depends on the interaction strength and on the electron density on the pfll only logarithmically .    at larger concentrations , @xmath62 ,
the single electron wave functions are still orthogonal to each other , but the densities corresponding to these wave functions have a significant spatial overlap . because of the strong repulsion between electrons at short distances , one could naively expect that the interaction on these distances gives the main contribution to the energy of the many - electron state .
however , for the fully spin polarized electron system of the pfll , the orbital part of the many - electron wave function is antisymmetric , and vanishes whenever two electrons have the same coordinates .
this suppression of the wave function amplitude compensates the large value of the interaction potential at @xmath63 . at larger distances , @xmath64 , the interaction ( [ potshort ] )
decays rapidly , and the corresponding contribution to the hartree - fock energy turns out to be smaller than the contribution of the long - range interaction ( [ potlong ] ) , see secs .  [ sec : td ] and [ sd ] .
this results in the saturation of the logarithmic growth of the gap @xmath55 with the electron density : at @xmath62 the gap in the tunnelling density of states is @xmath65 this estimate was obtained previously in the framework of the hydrodynamic approach@xcite .
we turn now to the discussion of the spin - flip excitations .
the orbital part of the many - electron wave function of such an excited state is no longer antisymmetric .
therefore , the energy of such an excitation , @xmath66 , is determined not only by the bare zeeman energy but also by the extra interaction energy associated with the change in the structure of the orbital wave function . because the orbital part of the wave function is not antisymmetric , the interaction on a short range ( @xmath67 ) now does contribute to the energy of the state .
this corresponds to the well known exchange enhancement of the @xmath68-factor@xcite .
following ref .
we analyze the exactly solvable case of a pfll which has a completely filled spin - polarized sublevel . flipping the spin of a single electron
affects the exchange interaction of this electron with all the other electrons of the _ same _ landau level .
all the lower landau levels carry equal number of electrons of both spin polarizations , and do not contribute to the energy associated with the spin flip .
therefore , only @xmath69-th fraction of the total electron density participates in the exchange enhancement , and the corresponding contribution to @xmath66 is approximately @xmath45 times smaller than the exchange energy per electron at zero magnetic field . for a 2d electron gas with fermi wave vector @xmath70 ,
the latter energy is of the order @xmath71 , and the contribution to @xmath66 is of the order @xmath72 .
the rigorous result obtained in sec .  [ sw ] differs from this estimate only by a logarithmic factor . for the effective @xmath68-factor defined by the relation
@xmath73 we obtain @xmath74 if the filling factor @xmath75 is odd . here
@xmath76 is determined by the zeeman splitting in the absence of the interaction , and it is usually small ( in @xmath77 the value of @xmath76 is only @xmath78 ) . for the even filling factors , the value of @xmath66 is determined solely by @xmath76@xcite .
we see that in the weak magnetic field , the energy scale of charge excitations @xmath79 is parametrically smaller than the energy scale for spin excitations @xmath15 .
this is qualitatively different from the situation at low filling factor , @xmath51 , where both these excitations are characterized by the same energy scale @xmath80 .
we start from the full hamiltonian of the system @xmath81 where the hamiltonian for non - interacting electrons , @xmath82 , is given by @xmath83 \psi_{n , k}^{\dagger}\psi_{n , k}. \label{h0}\ ] ] here @xmath84 and @xmath85 are the landau level index and the guiding center coordinate respectively ( we adopt the landau gauge ) . the fermionic field operators in eq .
( [ h0 ] ) satisfy the standard anticommutation relations @xmath86 , and @xmath87 is the chemical potential ( we include the energy @xmath88 into @xmath87 ) . to simplify the notation
, we omit the spin indices .
we will also neglect the zeeman term @xmath89 in all the intermediate calculations .
this is legitimate because @xmath90 and therefore all the effects associated with the small zeeman energy can be included in the effective hamiltonian after the fast degrees of freedom are integrated out .
electron - electron interaction is described by @xmath91 where @xmath92 stands for the normal ordering , @xmath93 is the electron density operator , @xmath94 , and @xmath95 is the average electron density . the electron annihilation operator @xmath96 is related to the operators @xmath97 by @xmath98 , where @xmath99 are the single electron wave functions in a magnetic field .    in order to develop the effective low - energy theory , we notice that the expression for the partition function , @xmath100 , can be written as @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the trace over the fock space of the pfll ( @xmath45 is the index of the pfll , @xmath103 is the inverse temperature ) and @xmath104 means trace over all the other landau levels . at low temperatures , @xmath105 , eq .
( [ z1 ] ) acquires the form @xmath106 where the effective hamiltonian @xmath107 is defined as @xmath108    let us emphasize that , in general , the low frequency properties can be described only by means of the effective action which includes a retarded interaction . the description by an effective hamiltonian with _ instantaneous _
interaction is possible only if the characteristic time of the retardation is much smaller than @xmath109 , where @xmath110 is the maximal energy scale which is considered within the effective theory .
this condition is met for the problem under consideration .
indeed , the summation in eq .
( [ heff ] ) involves inter - landau level transitions only .
these transitions are associated with the energy gaps not smaller than @xmath2 . correspondingly , the characteristic time of the retardation related to such a transition is @xmath111 . on the other hand , we saw at the sec .
[ peds ] that the largest characteristic energy @xmath112 is still parametrically smaller than @xmath2 , which enables us to neglect the retardation .
we now turn to the calculation of the effective hamiltonian ( [ heff ] ) .
the simplest way to proceed is to use the hubbard - stratonovich transformation : first , we introduce auxiliary scalar field @xmath113 to decouple quartic in @xmath96 interaction part of the hamiltonian ; second , we perform the summation over all the fermionic degrees of freedom not belonging to pfll . after that
, we integrate out auxiliary fields by means of the saddle point approximation and thus obtain the effective hamiltonian @xmath114 .    below
we implement this procedure . performing the first step of the hubbard - stratonovich transformation , we find for @xmath115 from eq .
( [ heff ] ) @xmath116 where @xmath117 is the imaginary time ordering , and @xmath118 vector @xmath119 represents time and space coordinates , @xmath120 .
the domain of integration over @xmath121 is : @xmath122,\ x \in [ 0 , l_x],\ y \in [ 0 , l_y]$ ] , where @xmath123 is the geometrical size of the 2d system .
we will omit the planck constant in all the intermediate calculations .
the measure of the functional integral in eq .
( [ decoupling ] ) is determined by the condition @xmath124 and the function @xmath125 is defined by the equation @xmath126    the density operator is @xmath127 where the fermionic operators in matsubara representation are @xmath128 , and @xmath129 . by introducing the infinitesimal positive time shift @xmath130 into definition ( [ rho ] ) we preserve the normal ordering of the fermionic operators in the interaction hamiltonian , see eq .
( [ hi ] ) .    after the decoupling is performed , the fermionic part of the hamiltonian in eq .
( [ decoupling ] ) becomes quadratic , which enables us to make the second step of the hubbard - stratonovich transformation , i.e. to carry out the trace @xmath104 over the `` fast '' fermionic degrees of freedom .
the result depends solely on the variables belonging to the pfll :    @xmath131 \phi(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1 $ } ) \tilde{g}_{\phi}(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1$},\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_2 $ } ) \phi(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_2 $ } ) , } \label{f2}\\ & & \displaystyle{g_n(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1$},\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_2$})=-p_n(\mbox{\boldmath $ r_1$},\mbox{\boldmath $ r_2 $ } ) e^{(\tau_2-\tau_1)(n\omega_c-\mu)}\theta ( \tau_1-\tau_2-\epsilon ) } , \label{gn}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ ugly1 ] where the @xmath118 vector @xmath132 is @xmath133 . in eqs .
( [ ugly1 ] ) @xmath134 is the projection of the fermionic operator ( in matsubara representation ) on the pfll , @xmath135 , operator @xmath136 is defined as @xmath137 .
projections of the density operator @xmath93 and of the hamiltonian @xmath82 on the pfll are given by @xmath138 and by @xmath139 respectively .
( [ gn ] ) , @xmath140 is the projection operator onto the pfll@xcite ; @xmath141 is the average electron concentration on the pfll .
operator @xmath142 in eq .  (
[ f2 ] ) is defined in such a way @xmath143 .
this follows from the anticommutation relation for the fermionic operators @xmath144 .
the green s function @xmath145 is the kernel of the integral operator : @xmath146^{-1}\hat{p}_{n}^{\perp } , \label{g}\ ] ] here @xmath147 is the projection operator onto the space of functions _ orthogonal _ to the states of the pfll @xcite , and @xmath148 is the hamiltonian of an electron in the magnetic field and in the external potential @xmath149 : @xmath150 the function @xmath151 describes the evolution in the external field @xmath149 of electron states constrained to the landau levels @xmath152 .
this constraint is implemented by the introduction of the projection operators @xmath147 into eq .
( [ g ] ) . at @xmath153 the function
@xmath151 is defined as @xmath154 in accordance with eq .
( [ rho ] ) .    the first term in eq .
( [ f ] ) results from the summation over the fermionic states with @xmath152 , and represents the `` thermodynamic potential '' of electrons in these states in the field @xmath149 . the function @xmath155 is defined as the kernel of the operator @xmath156 with @xmath157 from eq .
( [ g ] ) .
here , the factor @xmath158 comes from the spin degeneracy .    in order to perform the integration over the auxiliary field in eq .
( [ ugly ] ) , we employ the saddle point approximation .
it means that one has to expand the functional @xmath159 , see eq .
( [ f ] ) , and the operator @xmath160 , see eq .
( [ f2 ] ) , up to the second order in @xmath149 .
we start from the expansion of the operator @xmath161 .
it contains explicitly a factor , which is bilinear in @xmath149 , and therefore we can replace @xmath151 in eq .
( [ f2 ] ) by the green s function @xmath162 of an electron in the absence of an external field , @xmath163 . then , eq .  ( [ g ] ) enables us to find the explicit form of @xmath162 : @xmath164}. \label{g0}\end{aligned}\ ] ]    when expanding the first term in @xmath159 , we use definition ( [ f ] ) and the solution of eqs .
( [ g ] ) , ( [ hphi ] ) up to the second order in @xmath149 , and we obtain : @xmath165 where @xmath166nl_xl_y/\pi\ell^2 $ ] is the thermodynamic potential of the system of noninteracting electrons on the completely filled landau levels .
the third term in the functional @xmath159 , see eq .
( [ f ] ) , is already bilinear in @xmath149 .
substitution of eq .
( [ fe ] ) into eq .
( [ f ] ) yields @xmath167 where the second term describes fluctuations of the field @xmath149 which are renormalized due to the integrated out degrees of freedom .
the kernel @xmath168 equals to @xmath169 where @xmath170 coincides with the dielectric function calculated in the random phase approximation@xcite : @xmath171 here , the polarization operator @xmath172 in eq .
( [ fullepsilon ] ) is given by @xmath173 \left[\tilde{g}_{0}(0 , 0 ; \mbox{\boldmath $ r$ } , \tau)+g_n(0 , 0 ; \mbox{\boldmath $ r$ } , \tau ] \right],}\label{polarization}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the functions @xmath174 and @xmath175 are defined by eqs .
( [ g0 ] ) and ( [ gn ] ) respectively . the explicit form and the asymptotic behavior of @xmath172
are presented in appendix [ ap1 ] .    within the approximations made , we can transform eq .
( [ ugly ] ) to the form of a gaussian integral over the auxiliary field @xmath149 .
the result is @xmath176 } \nonumber \\ & & \displaystyle{\times\exp\left(\frac{1}{2}\!\int\ !   d^3\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1$}\!\int\ !
d^3\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_2 $ } \phi(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1 $ } ) \phi(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_2 $ } ) { \cal s}(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1\ !
-\!\xi_2$})\right ) } , \label{almostthere}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath177 is obtained from operator @xmath142 , see eq .
( [ f2 ] ) , by replacing @xmath178 with @xmath174 .    before we proceed further ,
let us emphasize that the saddle point approximation can be justified only if the characteristic value of the fluctuations of the auxiliary field @xmath149 is small enough .
the estimate which will be presented later in this section shows that the expansion quadratic in @xmath149 is parametrically valid for the weakly interacting electron system at large filling factors .
now , we are in the position to perform the actual integration in eq .
( [ almostthere ] ) .
operator @xmath179 , see eq .
( [ f1 ] ) , is a linear functional of @xmath149 , whereas operator @xmath177 , see eq .
( [ f2 ] ) , is quadratic in @xmath149 ; because the fluctuations of field @xmath149 are small , the typical value of @xmath142 is much smaller than that of @xmath179 .
if we neglect the term @xmath177 at all , the functional integration in eq .
( [ almostthere ] ) can be easily performed .
the calculation is further simplified if we approximate @xmath180 .
it is valid approximation for the description of the low - energy dynamics of electrons belonging to pfll : @xmath181 is rapidly decaying function of time : @xmath182 at @xmath183 , as it follows from eqs .
( [ renorm ] )  -  ( [ polarization ] ) .
the integration over field @xmath149 then results in an exponential @xmath184 , with the hamiltonian of density - density interaction , @xmath185 the operator ( [ heint ] ) acts within the fock space of pfll , and the renormalized pair interaction @xmath20 is related to @xmath186 by @xmath187 substitution of eq .
( [ renorm ] ) into eq .
( [ us ] ) yields : @xmath188 here the static dielectric function @xmath189 describes the renormalization of the bare coulomb potential due to the integrated out degrees of freedom .
this function can be easily found with the help of eqs .
( [ fullepsilon ] ) and ( [ stat ] ) , and it has the form @xmath190 \label{simpleepsilon}\ ] ] for the large filling factor @xmath191 and for values of wave vector @xmath38 much smaller than fermi wave vector , @xmath70 . in eq .
( [ simpleepsilon ] ) , @xmath31 is the bohr radius and @xmath192 is the zeroth order bessel function .
asymptotic behavior of the renormalized potential @xmath20 was discussed in sec .
[ peds ] , see also fig .
[ figpot ] .
the term @xmath177 from eq .
( [ almostthere ] ) can be taken into consideration by means of the perturbation theory using the small parameters @xmath193 and @xmath194 .
we show in appendix [ ap0 ] that this operator generates term of the effective hamiltonian which is linear in density .
this linear term can be trivially included into the free electron hamiltonian @xmath195 by a shift of the chemical potential .    finally , substituting the resulting expression for @xmath115 in eq .
( [ heff ] ) and restoring the zeeman energy term , we obtain the expression for the effective hamiltonian : @xmath196 where @xmath197 is defined by eq .
( [ heint ] ) , the explicit expression for the shifted chemical potential @xmath198 is presented in appendix [ ap0 ] , see eq .
( [ mufinal ] ) , and the thermodynamic potential @xmath199 of the electrons on the filled landau levels is given by eq .
( [ omegafinal ] )
. we will not need concrete values of @xmath198 and @xmath199 in the further calculations .
hamiltonian ( [ he ] ) is the main result of this section .
the physical meaning of this hamiltonian is that the low - frequency dynamics of the system is described by the electrons belonging to the upper landau level .
interaction between these electrons is renormalized due to the large polarizability of all the other landau levels .
let us now discuss the condition of the validity of the approximations we made .
as we mentioned earlier , the saddle point approximation can be justified only if the characteristic value of the fluctuations of the auxiliary field @xmath149 is small enough .
below we show that the fluctuations at all the spatial and time scales are parametrically small for a weakly interacting electron system at large filling factors .
the magnitude of the fluctuations localized within the spatial range @xmath200 and within the time interval @xmath201 can be estimated from eqs .
( [ almostthere ] ) and ( [ renorm ] ) as @xmath202 further estimates depend on the relation between the scale @xmath200 and the cyclotron radius @xmath47 .
if this spatial scale is large , @xmath203 , only the dipole transitions between the nearest landau levels are induced .
the corresponding off - diagonal matrix elements of the hamiltonian are of the order of @xmath204 .
the mixing of the landau levels by the field @xmath149 is small if @xmath205 combining eq .  ( [ estimate ] ) with eq .
( [ shfl ] ) and using the results ( [ fullepsilon ] ) and ( [ hydrodynamic ] ) for the dielectric function , we find the condition of small fluctuations    [ cond ] @xmath206 therefore , the long - range fluctuations are not `` dangerous '' in the weak magnetic field regime .
let us now analyze the short range fluctuations , @xmath207 . in this case transitions between distant landau levels
are possible , and the requirement of the smallness of fluctuations coincides with the standard one for the validity of the random phase approximation at zero magnetic field , @xmath208 thus , the saddle point approximation is valid for the weakly interacting electrons in a weak magnetic field .    in the following sections
, we will apply the effective hamiltonian ( [ he ] ) to describe various physical effects associated with the pfll .
in this section , we evaluate the ground state energy and thermodynamic density of states @xmath209 as a function of the filling factor of the partially filled landau level @xmath210 .
we consider explicitly the case @xmath211 .
system at the filling factors @xmath212 can be analyzed with the help of the electron - hole symmetry , and the the thermodynamic density of states for this case can be obtained from the results for @xmath213 by the replacement @xmath214 .
we assume that the ground state is spin polarized at @xmath215 , and thus omit the irrelevant zeeman term@xcite .
the chemical potential @xmath198 for the given electron concentration on the pfll @xmath216 is found by differentiating the ground state energy of hamiltonian ( [ he ] ) with respect to the number of electrons @xmath217 : @xmath218 where @xmath219 is the wave function of the ground state of the system with @xmath217 electrons on the pfll .    evidently , it is sufficient to consider only the filling factors @xmath220 . at larger
filling factors , @xmath221 , one can use the electron - hole transformation within the spin sublevel , @xmath222 , and study the system of holes with the filling factor @xmath223 described by the hamiltonian @xmath224\ !
\left[\hat{\rho}_n^h(\mbox{\boldmath $ r_2 $ } ) - n_h^n\right]\ ! : .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath225 is the hole density operator @xmath226 and @xmath227 is the average density of holes at the pfll .
the first term in @xmath197 corresponds to the shift of the chemical potential of the completely filled landau level due to the exchange interaction@xcite : @xmath228 here @xmath229 is the projector operator on the pfll@xcite . the integration in eq .  ( [ exch ] ) can be performed with the help of the explicit form ( [ property ] ) for @xmath229 . under the conditions ( [ cond ] ) , the calculation yields @xmath230    it follows from eq .
( [ hh ] ) that filling of one spin sublevel results in the shift @xmath231 of the chemical potential .
this enables us to find the average thermodynamic density of states which is defined by the relation @xmath232 with the help of eq .
( [ exch1 ] ) , we obtain @xmath233^{-1}. \label{thermdensity}\ ] ] it is worth noticing , that the thermodynamic density of states ( [ thermdensity ] ) does not depend on magnetic field at all .
we will see below that for a broad range of filling factors of the pfll @xmath234 , the actual value of the thermodynamic density of states is close to the average one given by eq .
( [ thermdensity ] ) .    the true ground state of the hamiltonian ( [ he ] ) for non - integer filling factors is not known . in order to estimate the ground state energy , we use the hartree - fock trial function analogous to that used by maki and zotos@xcite for the lowest landau level @xmath235 where @xmath236 is the normalized one - electron wave function of a coherent state@xcite on the pfll with the guiding center localized about point @xmath237 . in the landau gauge ,
@xmath238 , @xmath239 , this function has the form @xmath240{\bf z}/2\ell^2+ixy/2\ell^2 } g\left({\mbox{\boldmath $
r - r$}}\right ) , & \nonumber\\ & g\left(\mbox{\boldmath $ r$}\right)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{n!}}\left(\frac{x - iy}{\sqrt{2}\ell}\right)^n e^{-{\bf r}^2/4\ell^2}. & \label{coherentstate}\end{aligned}\ ] ]    the overlap between two functions ( [ coherentstate ] ) rapidly decreases with the distance between their guiding centers : @xmath241{\bf z}/2\ell^2}e^{-({\bf r}_1-{\bf r}_2)^2/4\ell^2}. \label{overlap}\ ] ] equation ( [ overlap ] ) shows that the overlap is exponentially small even when the distance between the guiding centers is smaller than @xmath47 and the electrons are not separated in space .    for small filling factors
@xmath242 , we can choose the guiding centers @xmath243 separated by the distance much larger than the magnetic length @xmath7 which enables us to neglect the non - orthogonality of the coherent states .
then , the expression for the energy @xmath244 given by eq .  ( [ mu ] ) acquires a simple form @xmath245 where hartree @xmath246 and fock @xmath247 potentials are given by @xmath248 ^ 2 e^{-q^2\ell^2+i{\bf qr } } } \label{hartree}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath249 ^ 2 e^{-q^2\ell^2-{\bf q}{\bf r}-{\bf r}^2/2\ell^2}},\nonumber\\ \label{fock}\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively . here
@xmath250 is the laguerre polynomial@xcite .
we used eqs .
( [ renpotential ] ) and ( [ coherentstate ] ) , when deriving eqs .
( [ hartree ] ) and ( [ fock ] ) .
small corrections appearing due to the non - orthogonality of the functions ( [ coherentstate ] ) were discussed in ref .  .
now , the energy given by eq .
( [ hf_energy ] ) should be minimized with respect to the positions of the guiding centers @xmath251 .
the best configuration corresponds to the guiding centers arranged in a triangular lattice@xcite .
below we present analytical results for the energy of the variational ground state ( [ trialfunction ] ) in different domains of filling factor @xmath252 .
_ dilute system , @xmath253 _  in this case , the lattice constant @xmath254 is large , @xmath255 , so that the fock potential ( [ fock ] ) is exponentially small and the hartree term @xmath256 coincides with the interaction potential @xmath257 . in this limit
, two situations may be distinguished .
for an extremely dilute system , @xmath258 , the lattice constant is larger than @xmath259 , and therefore the coulomb potential is not renormalized . in this case , the ground state energy coincides with that of the wigner crystal on a neutralizing background , @xmath260 where @xmath261 is a numerical constant @xcite , and @xmath262 is the number of states on a landau level .
the use of eq .
( [ mu ] ) immediately yields for the thermodynamic density of states in this regime @xmath263 the negative thermodynamic density of states for an analogous system was considered earlier in ref ..    for a moderately dilute system @xmath264 , the typical distance between electrons on the pfll is much smaller than @xmath259 . at such distances
the potential of interaction is strongly renormalized by the screening and it is given by eq .
( [ potlong ] ) . with the logarithmic accuracy
the energy of the system is given by @xmath265 \label{dilute_energy}\ ] ] and , correspondingly , the thermodynamic density of states for moderately dilute system takes the form : @xmath266    _ `` dense '' limit , @xmath267 _  in this case the distance between the nearest guiding centers is smaller than @xmath47 .
the asymptotic behavior of the hartree and fock potentials depends on the relation between the magnetic length @xmath7 and the bohr radius @xmath268 .
we restrict ourselves to the case @xmath269 , or @xmath270 which enables us to simplify eqs .
( [ hartree ] ) and ( [ fock ] ) , @xmath271 for the range of distances @xmath272 .
the resulting potential @xmath273 is a smooth function of @xmath274 at @xmath275 .
this enables us to find the analytical expression for the ground state energy ( [ hf_energy ] ) in the region @xmath276 .
first , we can approximate @xmath277 , as the potential varies only logarithmically over the lattice cell .
second , we notice that the spatial average of the hartree potential is exactly equal to the average of the bare potential @xmath20 , and these two terms cancel each other in eq .
( [ hf_energy ] ) for @xmath244 . finally , the integral of the fock potential is proportional to the exchange shift , @xmath278 , see eq .
( [ exch1 ] ) .
the resulting energy of the system is @xmath279 , } & \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] which yields the thermodynamic density of states of the form @xmath280^{-1}\times } & \nonumber \\ & \displaystyle{\left[1-\frac{3\sqrt{2 } } { 32\pi r_s\ln \left(r_s^{-1}\right ) } \left(\delta\nu n\right)^{-1}\right ] . } & \label{dtd}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the leading term in eq .
( [ dtd ] ) coincides with eq .
( [ thermdensity ] ) .
the filling factors @xmath281 can be considered similarly by using the electron - hole symmetry , see eq .
( [ hh ] ) , and the trial function of type ( [ trialfunction ] ) .
the overall dependence of the thermodynamic density of states on the filling factor is shown in fig .
the value of the one electron spectral density @xmath282 can be measured in the tunnelling experiments@xcite . for the electron states on the pfll ,
@xmath283 is defined by relations : @xmath284 here , @xmath285 is an eigenstate of the _ full _ hamiltonian ( [ initial_h ] ) , @xmath286 is the corresponding eigenvalue and @xmath287 stands for the ground state of the system . functions @xmath288 and @xmath289 describe the introduction of an extra electron or an extra hole onto the pfll respectively .
we are interested in the spectral density at energies @xmath290 .
all the behavior of the system at such low energies can be described by the effective hamiltonian ( [ he ] ) . following the method of sec .
[ sec : hamiltonian ] , we can express the spectral density ( [ sddef ] ) in terms of the eigenstates of the _ effective _ hamiltonian as @xmath291 where @xmath292 denotes the eigenstates of the effective hamiltonian ( [ he ] ) and @xmath293 is the corresponding eigenvalue , @xmath294 is the ground state .
the @xmath295-factor in eq .
( [ sdeff ] ) describes the overlap between the low - energy eigenstates of the full hamiltonian and the eigenstates of the effective hamiltonian .
the value of @xmath295-factor coincides with the quasiparticle weight for a @xmath296 degenerate plasma in the absence of the magnetic field , @xmath297 now we use eq .
( [ sdeff ] ) to evaluate the spectral density .
our analysis is based on the trial function ( [ trialfunction ] ) .
even though we are not able to find the details of the energy dependence of the spectral density , this approach provides a reliable estimate for the energy scales involved .    because the trial function ( [ trialfunction ] ) is constructed from the coherent states ( [ coherentstate ] ) , it is convenient to rewrite eq .
( [ sdeff ] ) in terms of the operators @xmath298 , see eq .
( [ c_s_creation ] ) , creating or annihilating an electron in the coherent state :    [ sdc ] @xmath299    here we used the representation of the projection operator in terms of the coherent states ( [ coherentstate ] ) : @xmath300    let us concentrate below on the calculation of the spectral density for the hole excitations @xmath289 .
( the calculation procedure for @xmath288 is similar and will be briefly outlined later . )    at small time @xmath301 , expression ( [ sdcs2 ] ) can be approximated by the formula @xmath302
^ 2\right ) \label{sdcs_exp}\ ] ] with parameters @xmath303 \right|0\right>}{\left<0\left| \psi_{\bf r}^\dagger\psi_{\bf r } \right|0\right>}};\label{e } \\ & & \displaystyle { \left[d({\bf r})\right]^2   = \frac{\left<0\left|\psi_{\bf r}^\dagger \left[{\hat{h}_{eff}},\left[{\hat{h}_{eff}},\psi_{\bf r } \right]\right ] \right|0\right>}{\left<0\left|\psi_{\bf r}^\dagger \psi_{\bf r } \right|0\right > } - \left[e^- ( { \bf r})\right]^2 . } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] substitution of eq .
( [ sdcs_exp ] ) into eq .
( [ sdcs ] ) gives the result @xmath304 ^ 2 } \!\right\ } \label{sdfinal}\ ] ] for the spectral density .
now we use maki - zotos trial state ( [ trialfunction ] ) to find the functions in the integrand in eq .
( [ sdfinal ] ) . at a small filling of the pfll , @xmath305 ,
we obtain with the help of eq .
( [ overlap ] ) @xmath306 which describes the `` density of the centers of orbits '' in the wigner crystal .
energy @xmath307 defined in eq .
( [ e ] ) turns out to be independent on the position @xmath237 because all the electrons in the wigner crystal have the same energy : @xmath308 here the hartree - fock energy @xmath309 is defined by eq .
( [ hf_energy ] ) , and the second term describes the neutralizing background .
the parameter @xmath310 is also independent of @xmath274 and it is given by @xmath311 ^ 2 .
\label{width}\ ] ] because none of the parameters in the exponent in eq .
( [ sdfinal ] ) depend on @xmath312 , the integration can be easily performed , and it yields : @xmath313    let us now discuss the physical meaning of the energies @xmath314 , @xmath315 . after an electron
is removed from the pfll , the system acquires extra energy equal to @xmath316 due to the interaction between the hole and all the electrons of the pfll . if all the other electrons of the pfll were `` frozen '' , this state would give a contribution @xmath317 to the spectral density .
( classical model of the frozen electrons was used in ref . for the electrons on the lowest landau level . )
however , the state formed right after the tunnelling is not an eigenfunction .
the decay of this initial state leads to the finite quantum width @xmath318 of the spectral density , see fig .
[ figds ] a.    to find the region of applicability of expression ( [ sdfinal1 ] ) we notice that the expansion in @xmath301 we used in eq .
( [ sdcs_exp ] ) is valid for @xmath319 .
the characteristic time determining the value of the integral in eq .
( [ sdcs ] ) can be estimated as @xmath320 ) is applicable for @xmath321 . at the boundary of applicability , the spectral density ( [ sdfinal1 ] ) is proportional to @xmath322 $ ] , and therefore eq .  ( [ sdfinal1 ] ) describes the main contribution to the spectral density only if @xmath323 . substituting the explicit expression for hartree - fock potential ( [ hf_energy ] ) into eqs .
( [ energies ] ) and ( [ width ] ) , we see that the ratio @xmath324 is maximal at @xmath325 , where its value is @xmath326 .
furthermore , we believe that the use of the hartree - fock function sets the upper limit for @xmath315 . this is because trial function ( [ trialfunction ] ) does not take into account the correlations in the motion of centers of orbits , and thus overestimates zero - point fluctuations of the electron density .
the use of a more sophisticated@xcite trial function , or of a phenomenological model that has the correct spectrum of excitations of the wigner crystal@xcite would restrict the summation in eq .
( [ width ] ) to the nearest neighbors only , and further reduce the value of @xmath315 .
the spectral density of holes has a sharp peak , because a hole corresponds to a vacancy in the wigner crystal .
in contrast , the tunnelling electron may create an interstitial at an arbitrary position in the elementary cell .
this gives rise to a finite width of the spectral density @xmath288 , even for the `` frozen '' , @xmath327 , crystal .
the energy band for an interstitial is given by @xmath328\!- \!n_e^n \!\int \!d^2\mbox{\boldmath $ r$}u(r ) - \!\mu^\ast .
\label{e+}\ ] ] the leading term in the quantum width @xmath315 for electrons does not depend on @xmath237 , and it is still given by eq .
( [ width ] ) .    to calculate the spectral density @xmath288
, one can use eq .
( [ sdfinal ] ) with @xmath307 and @xmath329 replaced by @xmath330 and @xmath331 respectively .
the width of the electron spectral density is determined by the energy band ( [ e+ ] ) .
the abrupt edge of the spectral density at @xmath332 is smeared only by a small quantum width @xmath315 , see fig .
[ figds ] a.    the minimal energy necessary to create an interstitial , @xmath333 , is of the order of energy @xmath334 needed to create a vacancy .
therefore the difference @xmath335 exceeds significantly @xmath315 and thus determines the pseudogap in the spectral density ( [ sddef ] ) . using eqs .
( [ energies ] ) , ( [ e+ ] ) , and the asymptotic behavior of the hartree - fock potential @xmath336 , see sec .
[ sec : td ] , we obtain the width of the pseudogap for different filling factors : @xmath337 } , \quad & n^{-3}r_s^{-2}\ll   \delta\nu \ll n^{-1}\\ \displaystyle{\frac{\hbar\omega_c}{2n } \ln\left(nr_s\right ) } ,   \quad &   n^{-1 } \ll \delta\nu \ll 1/2 , \end{array } \right .. \label{gapas}\ ] ] the leading term in the width of the gap agrees with the result of ref . for the broad range of filling factors @xmath338 . the overall dependence of the characteristic energy scales on the filling factor @xmath252 is shown in fig .
[ figds ] b.    it is important to notice that in the dominant region of filling factors , @xmath339 , the width of the gap @xmath55 is determined by the renormalized interaction ( [ potlong ] ) at distances @xmath340 , which are large compared to the characteristic distance between the electrons of pfll .
the gap is insensitive to the short range correlations in the wave function of the ground state .
therefore , we anticipate that the value of @xmath55 we found is robust : it is not an artifact of the maki - zotos trial function , but it should be the same ( with logarithmic accuracy ) for any state homogeneous on the macroscopic scale @xmath341 .
in this section we analyze the simplest excitations of the pfll at @xmath342 .
this problem is similar to the one studied in ref .  .
the only difference is that the interaction potential is renormalized due to the polarizability of the other landau levels .
our goal is to study how this renormalization affects the spin excitations .
the energy of the fully spin polarized ground state@xcite @xmath343 at @xmath344 is @xmath345 where @xmath278 is defined by eq .
( [ exch1 ] ) .
the eigenstates of the hamiltonian with an extra electron or hole @xmath346 have the energies @xmath347 respectively .
equations  ( [ eh ] ) enable us to relate the width of the spin gap @xmath348 to the value of @xmath278 , i.e. @xmath349 . substituting @xmath66 in eq .
( [ gdef ] ) and using eq .
( [ exch1 ] ) , we obtain the result ( [ geff ] ) for the effective @xmath68-factor .
it is worth noticing that the effective @xmath68-factor is independent on @xmath45 in the limit of a weak magnetic field due to the thomas - fermi screening@xcite .
( without screening , this factor would logarithmically diverge with @xmath350 . )
the exchange enhancement is maximal if the filling factor is odd . when the both spin sublevels are either empty or completely filled ( @xmath75 is even ) , the spin splitting is determined by the bare @xmath68 - factor@xcite .
let us turn to the consideration of neutral excitations
spin waves@xcite which at @xmath342 are described by the wave functions : @xmath351 wave functions ( [ swf ] ) are eigenstates of the hamiltonian ( [ he ] ) with the energies @xmath352 where the energy of the spin wave @xmath353 is given by @xmath354 ^ 2 e^{-q^2\ell^2/2+i{\bf kq}\ell^2}. } & \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for small wave vectors , @xmath355 , the spin wave has a quadratic dispersion relation which is typical for ferromagnets : @xmath356 at @xmath357 the energy of the spin wave is determined by the bare @xmath68-factor in agreement with larmor s theorem .
it is worth mentioning that the long - wavelength domain of the spin wave spectrum is controlled by the bare coulomb interaction .
this is because the spatial scale @xmath358 important for the spectrum , see eq .
( [ wave ] ) , is much smaller than the screening radius @xmath268 .    in the region
@xmath359 the energy of the spin wave reveals oscillatory behavior @xmath360 . \label{waveint}\ ] ] here @xmath361 is a smooth function with asymptotes @xmath362    spin waves with extremely large wave vectors , @xmath363 , correspond to almost independent electron and hole , see eq .
( [ eh ] ) . in this limit , the energy
@xmath364 approaches @xmath66 : @xmath365
in this paper we constructed a theory describing low - energy excitations in a 2d electron liquid in a weak magnetic field .
we have shown that all the excitations with energy smaller than cyclotron energy @xmath2 can be described by the effective hamiltonian acting in the fock space of the partially filled landau level only .
starting from first principles , we obtained the explicit form of this hamiltonian by integrating out all the other degrees of freedom .
armed with this effective theory , we have been able to make important predictions : + 1 ) we found that the _ thermodynamic density of states _ is negative for non - integer filling factors . for a broad range of filling factors ,
the value of the thermodynamic density of states was found to be independent on the value of magnetic field , see eq .
( [ thermdensity ] ) . this effect may be revealed in magnetocapacitance measurements@xcite in the weak magnetic field regime .
+ 2 ) the _ tunnelling density of states _ was shown to have a gap at the fermi level . for
a broad range of filling factors , the width of the gap , see eq .
( [ gap2 ] ) , was shown to be consistent with that predicted by hydrodynamic approach of ref .  .
the gap can be observed in tunnelling experiments@xcite in a weak magnetic field .
evidence of suppression of the tunnelling density of states for the filling factors @xmath366 was reported recently by turner _
this suppression may be associated with the gap predicted by our theory .
however , the observed width of the gap is twice larger than that given by eq .
( [ gap2 ] ) .
+ 3 ) the _ exchange enhancement _ of the effective @xmath68-factor remains strong in the weak field regime , and at all odd filling factors it takes a universal value , see eq .
( [ geff ] ) .
we found that the energy scale of charge excitations is parametrically smaller than the energy scale for spin excitations .
this is qualitatively different from the situation at low filling factors , @xmath51 , where both these excitations are characterized by the same energy scale @xmath80 .
none of the aforementioned effects could be obtained in the framework of the landau quantization of the spectra of quasiparticles in the conventional fermi liquid theory .
this theory describes adequately the excitations with energies larger than @xmath2 .
thus , our description of the low - energy properties of interacting 2d electron gas is complementary to the fermi liquid picture .
helpful discussions with b.  l.  altshuler , b.  i.  halperin , a.  i.  larkin , l.  s.  levitov , yu .  b.  lyanda - geller , a.  h.  macdonald , b.  i.  shklovskii , and x.  zhu are acknowledged with gratitude .
we are thankful to f.  w.  j.  hekking for critical reading the manuscript and valuable comments .
this work was supported by nsf grant dmr-9423244 .
integration in eq .  ( [ polarization ] ) immediately yields @xmath368 , } \label{pol_arb_k}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath369 is the laguerre polynomial@xcite .
further simplification is possible for @xmath370 . under this condition
, we can use the asymptotic expression for the laguerre polynomial@xcite @xmath371^{m/2 } } , \label{laguerre}\ ] ] where @xmath372 is the bessel function .
this expression is applicable if @xmath373 . using eq .
( [ laguerre ] ) and introducing a new index @xmath374 we approximate expression ( [ pol_arb_k ] ) as : @xmath375 ^ 2\right ] .
} & \label{pol1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the terms giving the main contribution to the sum in eq .
( [ pol1 ] ) are characterized by value @xmath376 .
this enables us to approximate @xmath377 and perform the summation over @xmath378 .
@xmath379 ^ 2 .
\label{pol2}\ ] ] equation  ( [ pol1 ] ) can be transformed into an integral form : substituting the identity @xmath380 ^
2=\int_0^\pi \frac{dy}{\pi}\cos n y \ { \cal j}_{0}\left(2x\sin\frac{y}{2}\right ) \label{jsquared}\ ] ] into eq .
( [ pol1 ] ) and performing the summation over @xmath381 , one easily obtains : @xmath382 .
\label{pol3}\ ] ] equation ( [ pol3 ] ) enables one to obtain the asymptotic form of the polarization operator in different regimes . in the static limit , @xmath383 ,
one finds from eqs .
( [ pol3 ] ) and ( [ jsquared ] ) :    @xmath384 . \label{stat}\ ] ]    for the high - frequency domain , @xmath385 , only a small vicinity of the point @xmath386 contributes to the integral in eq .
( [ pol3 ] ) , and @xmath387 coincides with the result for 2d electron gas in the absence of the magnetic field:@xcite @xmath388 . \label{dynamical}\ ] ] in the hydrodynamic limit , @xmath389 , one can expand the bessel function in eq .
( [ pol3 ] ) in a taylor series , which yields @xmath390 .
\label{hydrodynamic}\ ] ] in the opposite limit , @xmath391 , the main contribution to the integral in eq .
( [ pol3 ] ) comes from the vicinities of points @xmath392 and @xmath393 .
the calculation gives @xmath394 , } & \nonumber\\ & \displaystyle{b(q,\omega)=1 + \frac{{q^2v_f^2 } \omega_c^2\left(4\omega^2 - q^2 v_f^2\right)}{8\left(\omega^2+q^2v_f^2\right)^3}. } & \label{shortrange}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
in this appendix we present the details of the derivation of the effective hamiltonian ( [ he ] ) .
we start from eq .
( [ almostthere ] ) .
we notice that operators @xmath179 and @xmath177 , see eqs .
( [ f1 ] ) and ( [ f2 ] ) , are integrals of the matsubara operators over the time interval @xmath395 $ ] .
let us divide this time interval into @xmath217 small intervals @xmath396 , m=1,2\dots m-1 $ ] , where @xmath397 and @xmath398 .
we imply that @xmath399 must be smaller than the characteristic time of the low - energy dynamics , but much larger than @xmath400 .
then , the chronologically ordered exponent in eq .
( [ almostthere ] ) can be factorized as @xmath401 where operators @xmath402 and @xmath403 have the form @xmath404[\tau_{m}-\xi^0]\right ) , } \nonumber\\ & & \displaystyle{\hat{f}_2^{(m ) } = \!\int\ !
d^3\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1 $ } \int\ ! d^3\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_2 $ } \left [ \bar{\psi}_n(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1^+$})\psi_n(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_2 $ } ) - 2g_n(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_2 $ } , \mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1 $ } ) \right ] \times } \nonumber \\ & & \displaystyle { \quad \phi(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1 $ } ) \tilde{g}_{0}(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_1$},\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_2 $ } ) \phi(\mbox{\boldmath $ \xi_2 $ } ) \theta\left([\xi^0_1-\tau_{m-1}][\tau_{m}-\xi^0_1]\right ) . }   \label{f2a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] definitions ( [ f2a ] ) differ from the corresponding definitions ( [ f1 ] ) and ( [ f2 ] ) by the constraint on the time domain of integration .
we do not need to impose an additional constraint on the time component of in the second of eqs .
( [ f2a ] ) because @xmath174 decays rapidly at @xmath405 , see eq .
( [ g0 ] ) .
now , we substitute eq .
( [ split ] ) into eq .
( [ almostthere ] ) and perform the integration over the field @xmath149 .
it yields @xmath406 where average @xmath407 of an arbitrary functional @xmath408 over the field @xmath149 is defined as @xmath409 the normalization factor @xmath410 describes the fluctuations of field @xmath149 around the saddle point : @xmath411 an explicit expression for @xmath412 is presented in subsection [ calomega ] .    because @xmath399 is small
, we can expand every factor in eq .
( [ lambdaap ] ) up to the first order in @xmath399 : @xmath413 this relation defines the operator @xmath414 .
let us notice that this operator actually does not depend on @xmath415 because it contains the same number of creation and annihilation operators taken at the same moment of time .
having this in mind , we substitute eq .
( [ expand ] ) into eq .
( [ lambdaap ] ) and obtain @xmath416 finally , we take the limit @xmath417 in eq .
( [ lambdaap1 ] ) and substitute the result in eq .
( [ heff ] ) .
it yields @xmath418    now , one has to perform the actual calculation of the average in the left hand side of eq .
( [ expand ] ) in order to find the operator @xmath414 .
it can be done by using perturbation theory .
the leading terms in the small parameters @xmath193 and @xmath194 are @xmath419 to find the operator @xmath420 , only terms linear in @xmath421 should be retained .
calculation of the right - hand side of eq .
( [ perturbation ] ) is carried out with the help of eqs .
( [ f2a ] ) and of the correlation functions of the field @xmath149 : @xmath422 the latter expression follows from eq .
( [ average ] ) and ( [ renorm ] ) . in the second of eqs .
( [ corphi ] ) , we explicitly separated a term which is singular at @xmath423 .      in eqs .
( [ f2av ] ) , @xmath425 coincides with the well - known exchange correction to the chemical potential : @xmath426 where @xmath174 is defined by eq .
( [ g0 ] ) , and @xmath427 are the correlation corrections to the chemical potential found in the random phase approximation : @xmath428 when deriving eqs .
( [ muex ] ) , ( [ muc ] ) , we use eqs .
( [ equal_times ] ) and ( [ g0 ] ) .
finally , substitution of eq .
( [ f2av ] ) into eq .
( [ perturbation ] ) enables us to find the operator @xmath414 .
comparing eq .
( [ apanswer ] ) and eq .
( [ he ] ) , we obtain the expressions for the parameters of the hamiltonian @xmath114 : @xmath429    the following subsections are devoted to the explicit calculation of the parameters of the effective hamiltonian in terms of the filling factor and interaction strength .
we will assume that condition ( [ cond3 ] ) is met .
equations  ( [ deltaomega ] ) , ( [ normalization ] ) and ( [ renorm ] ) yield @xmath430 with the help of eqs .
( [ fullepsilon ] ) , ( [ polarization ] ) and ( [ equal_times ] ) , one can transform eq .
( [ do ] ) into a more convenient form : @xmath431 expression ( [ omex ] ) corresponds to the first order exchange correction to the ground state energy , and @xmath432 .
equation  ( [ omc ] ) is the correlation correction to the ground state energy equivalent to the sum of ring diagrams@xcite .
first , we evaluate the exchange energy ( [ omex ] ) . using the explicit expression for the green s function ( [ g0 ] ) , the property of the landau level wave functions , @xmath433 and the identity for the laguerre polynomials , @xmath434 we obtain @xmath435 ^ 2 .
\label{omex1}\ ] ] integration in eq .
( [ omex1 ] ) can be easily performed , which yields for @xmath191 : @xmath436 . \label{omex2}\ ] ]    the first term in brackets coincides with the exchange energy of 2d electron gas at zero magnetic field , and the second term appears due to the confinement of the electron wave functions by the magnetic field .
the logarithmical factor @xmath437 arises due to the integration over relatively large spatial scales @xmath438 in eq .
( [ omex ] ) . on these scales ,
the screened interaction potential is significantly smaller than the bare potential appearing in eq .
( [ omex ] ) .
therefore , it is plausible to anticipate that the correlation term of the thermodynamic potential , which accounts for the screening effect , should partially compensate the large logarithmic factor in eq .
( [ omex2 ] ) , and lead to the replacement @xmath439 in the argument of the logarithm .
the calculation of the correlation energy ( [ omc ] ) explicitly demonstrates this .    in zero magnetic field
the contribution of the correlation energy@xcite is only of the order of @xmath440 .
the situation changes in the magnetic field , where a contribution proportional to @xmath441 appears .
this term arises mainly from integration over the domain of wave vectors @xmath442 in eq .
( [ omc ] ) , where we can use the asymptotic expression ( [ shortrange ] ) for @xmath172 .
it yields with the logarithmic accuracy @xmath443    finally , with the help of eqs .
( [ omex2 ] ) and ( [ omec2 ] ) , we obtain for the thermodynamic potential ( [ omegai ] ) , @xmath444 \right\}. } & \label{omegafinal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this result contradicts ref . where the contributions ( [ omex ] ) and ( [ omc ] ) were evaluated and a correction @xmath445 was obtained instead of @xmath446 .
we start from the calculation of the exchange correction to the chemical potential . with the help of eqs .
( [ g0 ] ) , ( [ property ] ) and ( [ lid ] ) we transform eq .
( [ muex ] ) to the form @xmath447 after integration in eq .
( [ muex1 ] ) we obtain for @xmath448 with logarithmic accuracy : @xmath449 the correlation shift of the chemical potential , eq .
( [ mup ] ) , is calculated with the help of eqs .
( [ property ] ) and ( [ renpotential ] ) . with the logarithmic accuracy ,
the calculation gives @xmath450 it can be checked by an explicit calculation that the other correlation correction to the chemical potential , @xmath451 , see eq .
( [ muc ] ) , contains an additional small factor in comparison with eq .
( [ mup2 ] ) : @xmath452 , and , therefore , it can be neglected . finally , with the logarithmic accuracy
, we have for @xmath198 appearing in eq .
( [ mustar ] ) the result : @xmath453    , edited by r. e. prange and s. m. girvin ( springer - verlag , new york , 1990 ) , 2nd ed .
a. h. macdonald and s. m. girvin , phys .
b * 33 * , 4009 ( 1986 ) ; r. morf and n. dambrumenil , preprint ( 1994 ) ; l. belkhir and j. jain , preprint ( 1994 )
. a. h. macdonald , phys .
b * 30 * , 4392 ( 1984 ) ; d. j. yoshioka , j. phys . soc .
japan , * 53 * , 3740 ( 1984 ) .
e. g. _ g. baym and c. pethick , _ landau fermi - liquid theory : concepts and applications _
( new york , 1991 ) .
earlier , the electron system for the large integer filling factors was considered in : a. p. smith , a. h. macdonald and g. gumbs , phys .
b * 45 * , 8829 ( 1992 ) .
i. l. aleiner , h. u. baranger and l. i. glazman , phys .
* 74 * , 3435 ( 1995 ) .
t. k. lee and j. j. quinn , phys .
b * 11 * , 2144 ( 1975 ) .
l. v. keldysh , pisma zh .
. fiz . * 30 * , 245 ( 1979 ) ( jetp lett . * 30 * , 224 ( 1979 ) ) .
d. s. fisher , phys .
b * 22 * , 1190 ( 1980 ) . s .-
e. yang and a. h. macdonald , phys
lett . * 70 * , 4110 ( 1993 ) ;   y. hatsugai , p .- a .
bares , and x. g. wen , phys .
71 * , 424 ( 1993 ) ;  song he , p. m. platzman , and b. i. halperin , phys .
lett . * 71 * , 777 ( 1993 ) ;  y. b. kim and x. g. wen , phys .
b * 50 * , 8078 ( 1994 ) . a. l. efros and f. g. pikus , phys . rev .
b * 48 * , 14694 ( 1993 ) .
p. johansson and j. m. kinaret , phys .
lett . * 71 * , 1435 ( 1993 ) ; phys .
b * 50 * , 4671 ( 1994 ) .
t. ando and y. uemura , j. phys .
japan * 37 * , 1044 ( 1974 ) . c. kallin and b. i. halperin , phys .
b * 30 * , 5655 ( 1984 ) . in the coordinate representation
the operators @xmath147 and @xmath454 have the form @xmath455 and @xmath456 respectively .
g. d. mahan , _ many particle physics _
( new york,1990 ) pp .
430 - 444 we believe that the electron system of the pfll has a maximal spin in the ground state . it was proven not to be the case for the lowest landau level [ see s. l. sondhi , a. karlhede , s. a. kivelson and e. h. rezayi , phys .
b * 47 * , 16419 ( 1993 ) ] where the states with the filling factors close to @xmath457 are associated with creation of topological defects
skyrmions at @xmath458 , or antyskyrmions at @xmath44 .
however , it was shown recently [ x. g. wu and s. l. sondhi , preprint ( 1995 ) ] that the ground state does not contain skyrmions at any @xmath252 for the landau levels with higher indices .
k. maki and x. zotos , phys .
b * 28 * , 4349 ( 1983 ) .
s. kivelson , c. kallin , d. p. arovas , and j. r. schrieffer , phys .
b * 36 * , 1620 ( 1987 ) . h. bateman and a. erdelyi , _ higher transcendental functions _ , mcgraw - hill book co. , 1953 .
l. bonsall and a. a. maradudin , phys .
b * 15 * , 1959 ( 1977 ) .
m. s. bello , e. i. levin , b. i. shklovskii , and a. l. efros , zh .
80 * , 1596 ( 1981 ) ( sov .
jetp * 53 * , 822 ( 1981 ) ) .
r. c. ashoori , j. a. lebens , n. p. bigelow and r. h. silsbee , phys .
rev . lett . * 64 * , 681 ( 1990 ) ; phys .
b * 48 * , 4616 ( 1993 ) ; j. p. eisenstein , l. n. pfeiffer , and k. w. west , phys .
lett . * 69 * , 3804 ( 1992 ) ; surf .
sci . * 305 * , 393 ( 1994 ) ; k. m. brown , n. turner , j. t. nicholls , e. h. linfield , m. pepper , d. a. ritchie , and g. a. c. jones , phys .
b * 50 * , 15465 ( 1994 ) .
n. turner , j. t. nicholls , k. m. brown , e. h. linfield , m. pepper , d. a. ritchie , and g. a. c. jones , preprint , ( 1995 ) .
p. k. lam and s. m. girvin , phys .
b * 30 * , 473 ( 1984 ) .
previously , the effect of screening on the effective @xmath68 - factor was considered in refs .   and , however , no explicit analytical expression was given .
a. bychkov , s. v. iordanskii , and g. m. eliashberg , pisma zh .
. fiz . * 33 * , 152 ( 1981 ) [ jetp lett . * 33 * , 143 ( 1981 ) ] .
j. p. eisenstein , l. n. pfeiffer , and k. w. west , phys .
b * 50 * , 1760 ( 1994 ) .
the evaluation of the analogous sum was performed by s. simon and b. halperin , phys .
b * 48 * , 17368 ( 1993 ) .
f. stern , phys .
lett . * 18 * , 546 ( 1967 ) .
t. ando , a. b. fowler , and f. stern , rev .
mod . phys .
* 54 * , 437 ( 1982 ) .
a. isihara and d. y. kojima , phys .
b. * 19 * , 846 ( 1979 ) .