one of the most important diagnostics in understanding the evolution of galaxies is the star - formation rate ( sfr ) .
the evolution of the sfr of galaxies can give clues as to how galaxies were enriched with heavy elements , how they build up their stellar mass through cosmic time , and helps us to understand the bolometric output of galaxies .
at redshift @xmath7 , when the universe was just @xmath8 3gyr old , star - formation activity in the universe was at its peak and galaxies were in the process of assembling most of their stellar mass ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
studying this critical epoch is essential to gaining a better understanding of the evolution of the progenitors of the local galaxy population .    the ultra - violet ( uv ) continuum ( 1500 to 2800 ) intensity of a galaxy is one of the most commonly used diagnostics for the sfr as it is observable over a wide range of redshifts and intrinsic luminosities .
it is sensitive to massive stars ( @xmath9 ) , making it a direct tracer of current sfr . by extrapolating the formation rate of massive stars to lower masses , for an assumed form of the initial mass function ( imf )
, one can estimate the total sfr @xcite .
another widely used diagnostic for measuring the sfr is nebular emission , with h@xmath1 being the most common because of its higher intensity compared to the other hydrogen recombination lines such as h@xmath10 , pa@xmath1 , pa@xmath10 , etc . , and it is easier to interpret than the ly@xmath1 line .
h@xmath1 is an `` instantaneous '' tracer of sfr because it is sensitive only to the most massive stars ( @xmath11 ) .
however , it becomes more challenging to observe h@xmath1 from the ground at @xmath12 because the line is redshifted to the near - ir where the terrestrial background is much higher than at optical wavelengths .
the main disadvantage of using uv / optical luminosities as tracers of the sfr is their sensitivity to dust attenuation .
the dust absorption cross - section is larger for shorter wavelengths and choosing the appropriate attenuation curve to correct the observed luminosities plays an important role in determining intrinsic physical quantities . aside from the assumed attenuation curve ,
the geometry of dust with respect to the stars can lead to different color excesses , @xmath13 , between the ionized gas and the stellar continuum .
@xmath13 is the color excess measured between the _ b _ and _ v _ bands , @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the total extinction at wavelength @xmath16 in magnitudes .
in particular , the nebular recombination lines arise from the hii regions around the most massive o and early - type b stars ( with masses of m@xmath17 and main sequence lifetimes of @xmath18myr ) . on the other hand , for a salpeter imf , solar metallicity , and a constant or rising star - formation history , the uv continuum in starburst galaxies originates from stars over a broader range of mass that includes later - type b stars with lifetimes @xmath19myr @xcite .
these older non - ionizing stars have more time to migrate to regions of lower dust density in the galaxy , while h - ionizing stars with shorter lifetimes do not have enough time to escape from their dusty birthplace or let the parent molecular clouds to dissipate . as a result , the nebular lines can be subject to a higher degree of reddening than the uv continuum .
@xcite found that the nebular emission is more attenuated than the stellar continuum at the same wavelengths for a sample of local uv - bright galaxies .
subsequently , @xcite studied a similar sample of local galaxies and argued that the _ color - excess _ is 2.27 times larger for the nebular emission lines than for the stellar continuum .
this relationship was derived under the assumption that the calzetti curve is applied to the stellar continuum and a galactic extinction curve is applied to the nebular emission lines . in a separate study
, @xcite found that for an sdss sample of @xmath20 galaxies , @xmath21 , both assuming a @xcite extinction curve .
there have been several studies of relative attenuation of the stellar continuum and nebular regions in high - redshift galaxies . in most of the high - redshift studies ,
the calzetti curve is assumed for both the nebular and stellar regions .
frequently , the @xcite relation between the stellar and nebular @xmath13 is used to correct the nebular lines , while this relation was originally derived based on using a galactic extinction curve for the nebular lines . at present
it is unclear what type of attenuation curve should be applied to the nebular regions .
these issues are discussed in detail in @xcite .    at @xmath7
, @xcite selected a sample from various imaging surveys in the optical , near - ir , mid - ir , and sub - millimeter regime , with sed - derived sfrs of @xmath8 10 - 1000 @xmath22 and stellar masses @xmath23 , assuming a chabrier imf . in their study ,
the predicted h@xmath1 luminosities from the best - fit sed models for 62 galaxies were compared with the observed line luminosities measured from integral field spectroscopy .
the latter were then corrected for reddening assuming the @xmath24 returned from stellar population modeling of their galaxies .
@xcite found that assuming a factor of two redder color excess towards the hii regions relative to the stellar continuum yielded the best agreement between the predicted and observed h@xmath1 luminosities .
similarly , @xcite investigated 25 star forming galaxies at @xmath7 and compared the h@xmath1 sfrs , dust - corrected by the calzetti attenuation curve , with the sed modeled sfrs .
they showed that h@xmath1 sfrs are consistent with the sed sfrs , provided that @xmath25 when assuming the calzetti curve for both .
@xcite presented two galaxies at redshifts @xmath26 and 2.024 , and added ten other galaxies at similar redshifts from @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite to compare a@xmath27 derived from the balmer decrement ( @xmath28 ) with a@xmath29 derived from the sed models , both assuming the calzetti curve .
the only two galaxies with detected h@xmath10 line measurements showed evidence for higher nebular attenuation , but about half of the non - detections were consistent with equal attenuation for the nebular and stellar regions . in @xcite
, h@xmath1 attenuation was investigated through several comparisons for a sample of optically - selected star - forming galaxies at @xmath7 .
aided with near - infrared spectroscopic observations , @xcite used the balmer decrement along with the calzetti curve to correct the h@xmath1 sfr .
the dust - corrected sfr was then compared with the h@xmath1 sfr corrected by the sed color - excess and also with the sfrs inferred from uv , ir , radio , and x - ray .
the comparisons yield contradictory results .
their analysis favored a higher nebular color - excess for galaxies with larger intrinsic sfrs .    in separate studies , @xcite and @xcite used a large sample of uv - selected galaxies at @xmath7 and corrected both the h@xmath1 and uv sfrs with the color - excess derived from the best - fit sed models and applied the calzetti attenuation curve .
they showed that using different color excesses for the continuum and lines generally resulted in h@xmath1-inferred sfrs that over - predicted those calculated from the dust - corrected uv emission and direct ir measurements .
the apparently conflicting results mentioned above may be reconciled if the relation between the nebular and stellar color - excesses depends on the physical properties of galaxies , such as their sfrs @xcite or specific sfrs @xcite .
for example , @xcite showed that the ratio of the line optical depth to the continuum optical depth decreases with increasing ssfr and at ssfr@xmath30 the line - to - continuum optical depth ratio reaches the @xcite ratio assuming the @xcite attenuation curve .
@xcite investigated the attenuation of the nebular regions at @xmath31 using the balmer decrement from stacked _ hst _ grism spectra assuming the calzetti curve , and found no strong trend of @xmath32 with sfr or ssfr .
in @xcite study , at ssfr@xmath33 the ratio is consistent with 1 .
the primary goal of this paper is to understand the relationship between the uv and h@xmath1 emission in high - redshift star - forming galaxies , with a large sample that is immune to uncertainties in slit loss corrections that affects the h@xmath1 flux estimation ( c.f . * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the small sample sizes inherent in previous spectroscopic studies of h@xmath1 @xcite , and not subject to the bias of selecting high equivalent width objects from narrow - band selected samples @xcite .
we consider in our analysis only spectroscopically - confirmed galaxies , enabling us to estimate the h@xmath1 flux from broad - band photometric excess techniques without the additional uncertainties that plague photometric redshifts @xcite .
the impact of nebular lines on the broad - band photometry was known and studied for many years . using the photometric excesses to determine the line strengths
was pioneered by @xcite , where they showed that the excess in _
3.6@xmath3 m relative to the sed model continuum is due to the redshifted h@xmath1 emission line for their sample of galaxies at @xmath34 .
@xcite also investigated a sample of galaxies at the same redshift range of @xcite and inferred the h@xmath1 emission line strengths by comparing the observed flux in _
3.6@xmath3 m band and the continuum flux as expected from the sed model .
following that , @xcite verified the photometric excess technique by applying it to a small sample of 9 galaxies at @xmath35 ; for 8 galaxies the [ o iii ] line fluxes inferred by the same technique as @xcite were within a factor of 2.5 of the spectroscopically measured [ o iii ] fluxes .
an additional advantage of our study is that we include ir data to independently assess the dust - obscured sfr .
comparing h@xmath1 , uv , and ir - inferred sfrs in a statistical sense allows us to understand how to correct extinction - sensitive measures of sfr for the effects of dust .
the outline of this paper is as follows . in  [
sec : sample ] we discuss the properties of our sample , the assumptions that have been made to model the stellar populations using the rest - frame uv to near - ir photometry , the _ spitzer_/mips photometry and stacking method .
a detailed description of how we estimated the h@xmath1 line flux is provided in  [ sec : sec3 ] .
the analysis of the mips 24@xmath3 m data and ir luminosities is described in  [
sec : irlum ] . in
[ sec : sec5 ] we compare the two different tracers of sfr - h@xmath1 and uv - and discuss the dust correction recipe most consistent with our measured values .
 [ sec : sec6 ] focuses on combining sfr diagnostics ( e.g. , h@xmath1 and uv with ir ) to deduce bolometric sfrs .
the results are summarized in  [ sec : sum ] . throughout this paper ,
a @xcite imf is assumed and a cosmology with h@xmath36 = 70 km s@xmath37 mpc@xmath37 , @xmath38 = 0.7 , and @xmath39 = 0.3 is adopted .
all magnitudes are given in the ab system @xcite .
the galaxies used in this study are drawn from a parent sample that is part of an imaging and spectroscopic survey of uv - selected galaxies at z @xmath8 2 - 3 @xcite .
the galaxies were selected based on the bx , bm , and lyman break galaxy rest - uv color criteria @xcite , where @xmath40 optical data were obtained with the palomar large format camera ( lfc ) or keck low resolution imaging spectrograph ( lris ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) .
rest - uv spectroscopic follow - up with keck / lris was conducted for galaxies brighter than @xmath41 @xcite .
near - ir @xmath42 and @xmath43 imaging was obtained using the palomar / wirc and magellan / panic instruments @xcite .
_ h_-band ( f160w ) data were obtained with the _ hubble space telescope _
wfc3 camera @xcite .
all galaxies in the sample have coverage in at least one of the _ spitzer_/irac four channels ( 3.6 , 4.5 , 5.8 , and 8.0  @xmath3 m ; @xcite ) .
the objects are located in the goods - north field and 11 additional fields that were primarily selected to have one or more relatively bright background qsos for studying the interface between the intergalactic medium ( igm ) and galaxies at z @xmath8 2 - 3 @xcite .    out of the final sample of 2283 objects with spectroscopically confirmed redshifts ,
a subset of galaxies is selected based on the following criteria : ( 1 ) the galaxy must be covered by the _ k_-band imaging , ( 2 ) it must have a redshift in the range 2.08 @xmath44 z @xmath44 2.51 so that the h@xmath1 line falls into the _ @xmath2 _ band , and ( 3 ) it must be detected in at least two of the irac channels or one of the irac channels and either j or f160w bands .
the third condition ensures a more robust estimate of the stellar mass and the continuum level at 6564 .
furthermore , agns ( making up @xmath45 of the parent sample ) were identified by either strong uv emission lines ( e.g. , ly@xmath1 , civ ) or by a power law sed through the irac bands .
these agns are removed from our sample .
eventually , 262 galaxies remain that satisfy the aforementioned criteria .      for each galaxy in our sample
, the best - fit stellar population model is found by using the rest - frame uv through near - ir broad - band photometry .
as mentioned above , all the galaxies in our sample have spectroscopically - confirmed redshifts , thus removing a key degeneracy in the modeling of the stellar populations .
in addition , for a better estimation of stellar mass and age , all galaxies in our sample have at least two detections long - ward of the 4000 break - excluding _ @xmath2_-band .    c. charlot & g. bruzual ( 2007 ) models with a @xcite imf and solar metallicities are used for the fitting .
for each individual galaxy , different star - formation histories are assumed , including constant , exponentially declining , and exponentially rising with characteristic timescales of @xmath46 = 10 , 20 , 50 , 100 , 200 , 500 , 1000 , 2000 , 5000myr for exponentially declining and @xmath46 = 100 , 200 , 500 , 1000 , 2000 , 5000myr for exponentially rising histories .
ages are allowed to vary between 50myr and the age of the universe at the redshift of each galaxy .
the @xmath47 50myr limit corresponds to the typical dynamical timescale of star - forming galaxies at @xmath7 as inferred from velocity dispersion and size measurements of these galaxies @xcite . for interstellar dust obscuration
, the @xcite attenuation curve is used , allowing @xmath13 to vary between 0.0 and 0.6 .
the @xmath48 values have been determined for each set of observed broad - band and model magnitudes .
the best - fit model is determined through @xmath48 minimization .
there is generally no significant difference between the best - fit @xmath48 values of the six different population models ( constant , exponentially rising , and exponentially declining star - formation histories , for each considering all ages and ages greater than 50myr ) . as previous studies have shown , the assumption of declining star - formation histories at these redshifts results in systematically lower sed - inferred sfrs compared to the observed ir+uv sfrs @xcite .
furthermore , @xcite showed that assuming a constant star - formation history for @xmath7 galaxies predicts specific sfrs ( sfr / m@xmath49 ) at higher redshifts ( @xmath50 ) that are substantially larger than the observed values .
given these , we adopt the models that assume exponentially rising star - formation histories with ages greater than 50myr .
the sed models used to fit the observed magnitudes do not include nebular emission lines .
for example , the h@xmath1 line can significantly affect the photometry and we use its contribution to the _ k_-band to estimate the h@xmath1 line flux .
the [ o iii ] emission line is the other strong line which falls into the f160w filter given the redshift range of our galaxies .
only 20% of the galaxies have f160w observations , for which we did not correct the broadband photometry for the contamination .
the sed - inferred sfr of these galaxies is consistent with the sfr(uv ) estimates within the uncertainties . at this redshift ,
j band is contaminated by the [ o ii ] emission line , but this line is generally weaker than the h@xmath1 line and its effect on the sed inferred sfrs is negligible compared to the uncertainties .
, the typical [ o ii ] line flux is @xmath51  erg  s@xmath37  @xmath52 @xcite .
the ratio of the [ o ii ] flux to the typical j - band flux errors in our observations is only @xmath53 . ]      to further investigate the bolometric properties of our sample , we use _
spitzer_/mips 24@xmath3 m wherever available . out of 12 fields , goods - north @xcite , and four other fields ( q1549 , q1623 , q1700 , and q2343 ; reddy & steidel 2009 ) have mips 24@xmath3 m coverage to a typical 3@xmath54 depth of 10 - 15@xmath3jy .
photometry on 24@xmath55 images is performed by using point - spread function ( psf ) fitting with priors determined by the locations of the objects in the higher resolution irac images ( irac data exist in all fields ) .
a 40@xmath5640 pixel region centered on each target is extracted with pixel size of @xmath57 .
psfs are then fitted simultaneously to all known sources in the sub - image and one random background position .
this procedure is repeated many times to obtain sufficient statistics for proper background estimation based on the random background flux measurements .
the other source of uncertainty is poisson noise , which for objects in our sample is negligible compared to the background dispersion .
we remove objects whose photometry may be compromised due to blending with nearby sources , using the criteria specified in @xcite .
this results in 115 galaxies with secure psf fits .
out of 115 objects with mips data , 47 are detected with s / n  @xmath58 .
undetected objects , those with s / n  @xmath59 , are considered using either survival analyses or through stacking of the 24@xmath55 data .      throughout the paper ,
we employ a stacking method to determine the median 24@xmath3 m fluxes of objects that are individually detected and undetected , following the procedures described in @xcite .
we performed aperture photometry on the stacked images , and applied an aperture correction based on the @xmath60@xmath3 m psf .
the average background level and noise were determined by placing many apertures of the same size used for the stacked signal at random positions in the stacked image and measuring the average flux level and dispersion in flux of these `` background '' apertures .
furthermore , we used bootstrap resampling simulations to estimate the dispersion in the fluxes of objects contributing to each stack .
this was accomplished by creating 100 samples of random images in each bin and measuring the standard deviation of the median stacked fluxes .
the intrinsic dispersion in the stacked flux is larger than the background error by a factor of @xmath61 .
using the procedure discussed in  [ sec : sedfit ] , we fit all the photometry , excluding _ @xmath2_-band , in order to determine the continuum level at 6564 . the continuum magnitude is calculated by multiplying the best - fit sed model by the _ @xmath2 _ filter transmission curve .
the difference between the observed _ @xmath2_-band magnitude and the continuum magnitude is used to extract the h@xmath1 line flux as follows .
the observed _ @xmath2 _ magnitude is considered as the sum of the continuum and the h@xmath1 fluxes , while the sed - inferred _ @xmath2 _ magnitude represents only the continuum flux . assuming a gaussian form for the redshifted h@xmath1 line , the change between these fluxes will yield the h@xmath1 flux ( figure  [ fig : sed ] ) :    @xmath62    here , @xmath63 is the flux density of the h@xmath1 line in units of ergs@xmath37@xmath52hz@xmath37 , @xmath64 is the _ @xmath2 _ filter transmission curve , and @xmath65 and @xmath66 are the observed and the continuum magnitudes , respectively .
the h@xmath1 flux is corrected for contamination from the [ nii ] line based on the mass - dependent [ nii]-to - h@xmath1 flux ratios of @xcite .
the stellar masses are determined from the sed models and the corresponding [ nii ] line contamination , as listed in table  [ tab : nii ] , is used to correct the h@xmath1 flux .
the sfrs are then calculated using the @xcite relation to convert the h@xmath1 line luminosity to an sfr .
there are three main sources of uncertainty in the derived h@xmath1 fluxes .
the largest uncertainty is the photometric error .
the typical error in the observed _ @xmath2_-band magnitude is @xmath67 .
the second source of uncertainty is the [ nii ] correction .
the uncertainty on the @xcite [ n ii]-to - h@xmath1 line ratios ( see table  [ tab : nii ] ) is added in quadrature to the photometric error .
the third source of uncertainty is the error associated with the continuum flux . in order to account for this uncertainty , we estimated the continuum flux at 6564   from the best - fit model assuming six different star - formation histories : exponentially rising , exponentially declining , and constant , for each considering all ages and ages greater than 50myr . for 94% of the galaxies
the difference in the mean of the continuum fluxes assuming different star - formation histories to those assuming a rising star - formation history with ages @xmath68 50myr is less than 0.1 magnitude .
the average error in the estimated continuum magnitude is @xmath69mag , which is negligible compared to the observed _ @xmath2_-band magnitude errors . combining the three sources of uncertainty discussed above yields a typical relative error in h@xmath1 flux of @xmath70 .
cc @xmath71 & @xmath72 + 0.88  2.00 & @xmath73 + 2.00  3.69 & @xmath74 + 3.69  6.03 & @xmath75 + 6.03  8.82 & @xmath76 + @xmath77 & @xmath78 [ tab : nii ]    the equivalent width of the h@xmath1 line is estimated by dividing the h@xmath1 flux derived from equation  [ equ : ha ] by the continuum flux density at the wavelength of the h@xmath1 line :    @xmath79    the @xmath80 is the continuum flux density in units of erg  s@xmath37  @xmath52  @xmath37 that is estimated through the best - fit sed model , @xmath81 is the h@xmath1 line flux in erg  s@xmath37  @xmath52 , @xmath82 is the redshift of the galaxy , and @xmath83 is the rest - frame equivalent width in  .
we define whether a galaxy has a `` detected '' h@xmath1 line according to the following .
galaxies whose _ @xmath2_-band photometry exceeds the continuum level by more than the _
@xmath2_-band magnitude error are referred to as `` h@xmath1 detections '' .
galaxies where the _
@xmath2_-band photometry is consistent with the continuum level to within @xmath84@xmath54 are referred to as `` h@xmath1 non - detections '' , and an upper limit of @xmath85 above the measured k photometry is used for these objects . out of 262 galaxies in our sample , 149 are detections and 94 are non - detections
. there are 19 objects with _
@xmath2 _ magnitudes fainter than the continuum by more than @xmath85 .
we removed these galaxies from our discussion due to their _
@xmath2 _ photometry being inconsistent with the photometry from adjacent bands .
rest - frame equivalent widths as a function of the error of the observed _ @xmath2_-band magnitude .
the circles are detected galaxies and are color coded based on their observed h@xmath1 fluxes ( uncorrected for extinction ) .
the red triangles show @xmath85 upper limits . detecting the h@xmath1 emission
requires that the observed _
@xmath2 _ magnitude lies more that @xmath85 above the underlying continuum , where @xmath85 is defined by the _ @xmath2 _ magnitude error .
the _ @xmath2 _
magnitude includes the light both from the h@xmath1 emission line and the brightness of the continuum at 6564  .
there is a tight correlation between the continuum brightness and the _
@xmath2 _ magnitude error ; the fainter continuum results in larger uncertainty in the observed magnitude . as a result , there are more undetected objects with large _ @xmath2_-band errors .
on the other hand , the brightest h@xmath1 objects have bright continuum and small _ @xmath2_-band uncertainties . the deficiency of objects in the upper - left corner is mainly because very bright h@xmath1 objects that also have bright continuum are rare.,scaledwidth=50.0% ]    as discussed in  [ sec : intro ] , our method of computing h@xmath1 fluxes and ews has the advantage of being immune to slit - loss corrections . our sample covers a wide range of h@xmath1 fluxes and ews .
figure  [ fig : ew - omagerr ] shows the distribution of h@xmath1 ews and fluxes as a function of the _ @xmath2 _ magnitude @xmath85 uncertainty .
the detection of h@xmath1 with the method adopted here depends on both the h@xmath1 line flux and the brightness of the continuum at 6564  . as we have defined detections to be those objects where the _ @xmath2 _ magnitude exceeds the continuum level by more than @xmath85 , the number of undetected objects increases for objects that are fainter in the continuum ( figure  [ fig : ew - omagerr ] ) .
fluxes of the objects in common between our sample and that of @xcite .
the diamonds are the detected objects and downward arrows show @xmath86 upper limits , as discussed in the text .
the fluxes are measured based on the difference between the observed and the continuum _
@xmath87 _ magnitudes predicted from the best - fit model .
the error bars are dominated by the uncertainty in the observed _
@xmath87 _ photometry .
the @xcite spectroscopic fluxes are multiplied by a factor of 2 to account for slit losses .
the dashed line denotes the one - to - one relationship.,scaledwidth=50.0% ]    the h@xmath1 observed fluxes of 44 objects in common with the @xcite spectroscopic sample are compared in figure  [ fig : fluxcompare ] .
the @xcite spectroscopic fluxes are multiplied by a factor of two to account for slit losses and the aperture used to extract the spectra @xcite .
the slit loss correction factor applied to the spectroscopic fluxes depends on various factors such as the accuracy of the astrometry , the size of the object convolved with the seeing at the time of observation in comparison with the size of the slit , and the accuracy of the mask alignment during the observation .
as noted in @xcite , the factor of two slit - loss correction is an average estimate and the slit losses will of course vary from object to object , likely accounting for some of the scatter in figure  [ fig : fluxcompare ] . on the other hand , while broadband photometry has its advantages , our _ @xmath2_-band measurements suffer from a larger measurement ( random ) uncertainty relative to the other methods given the depth of our ground - based images .
although most of the detected h@xmath1 fluxes in this study ( the black symbols in figure  [ fig : fluxcompare ] ) are higher that the spectroscopic fluxes , about half of the sample is estimated as upper limits ( the red arrows ) . considering both the detections and non - detections , the broad - band estimated fluxes are generally consistent with the spectroscopic fluxes . to quantify the degree of the correlation we conduct a generalized kendall s tau ( @xmath46 ) statistic .
the generalized kendall s @xmath46 rank correlation coefficient is a non - parametric test that permits non - detections in both variables ( here , our estimated h@xmath1 fluxes ) .
kendall s @xmath46 correlation coefficient for our flux estimation with the @xcite measurements , excluding the one outlier object , is @xmath46 = 0.17 , with significance of p - value = 0.11 .
uv luminosities are calculated using the fluxes of the best - fit sed models at 1700 .
the @xcite relation to convert the uv luminosity ( over the wavelength range 1500 - 2800 ) to sfr applies only to galaxies where star formation proceeds for @xmath88myr . however , there are galaxies in our sample with inferred ages between 50 and 100myr . for these younger galaxies
, we used an age- and star - formation - history - dependent relation in the conversion of the uv luminosity to sfr , as discussed in @xcite .
the age - dependent conversion resulted in uv sfrs that are at most @xmath89 larger than the @xcite sfrs for young galaxies . throughout this analysis
, we also use sfrs inferred from the best - fit sed models . as expected , within the uncertainties , the sed sfrs
are highly correlated with dust corrected uv sfrs .
to estimate the bolometric luminosities of galaxies in our sample , we infer the infrared luminosity ( integrated between 8 - 1000  @xmath3 m ) as discussed below , and add this to the unobscured uv luminosity ( i.e. , observed uv luminosity ;  [ sec : uvlum ] ) , as in @xcite .
infrared luminosities , @xmath90 , are estimated by using the _
spitzer_/mips 24@xmath3 m observations .
the @xmath60@xmath3 m band is sensitive to the rest - frame 7.7  @xmath3 m pah emission , which correlates with @xmath90 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
to convert observed 24@xmath3 m magnitudes to total ir luminosity ( l@xmath91 ) , we used several dust sed templates , including those of @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
luminosities determined from the rest - frame 8  @xmath3 m flux density alone , regardless of the dust template used , tend to over predict l(ir ) , particularly for lirgs ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) and ulirgs ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . in order to account for the luminosity - dependent overestimation of the derived l(ir
) , we use a correction equation described in @xcite .
the correction is calculated by comparing the l(ir ) computed from 24 , 100 , 160@xmath3 m , and 1.4ghz fluxes , and the l(ir ) determined solely from 24@xmath3 m data for a similarly - selected sample of galaxies : @xmath92 all luminosities are in l@xmath93 .
equation[equ : it - tot ] is based on the @xcite models .
there is a factor of @xmath61 variation in l(ir ) derived from 24@xmath3 m data using @xcite and @xcite dust templates ( e.g. , see * ? ? ?
however , once corrected using the appropriate equations similar to equation[equ : it - tot ] , all the templates result in l(ir ) estimates that are consistent with each other and with the l(ir ) computed from 24 , 100 , 160@xmath3 m , and 1.4ghz fluxes , within the uncertainties of the measured ir luminosity as explained in
[ sec : sample - b ] ( see also * ? ? ?
in the subsequent analysis , we use infrared luminosities inferred from the @xcite templates .
the ir luminosity is converted to ir ( dust - obscured ) sfrs using the @xcite relation .
the sum of ir- and uv - inferred sfrs are then used to estimate the bolometric sfrs .
sfrs inferred from the uv luminosity and the h@xmath1 fluxes are shown in the left panel of figure  [ fig : sfrhauv ] . without dust corrections ,
the uv and h@xmath1 sfrs have a large discrepancy due to the smaller dust absorption cross - section at 6564 relative to that at 1700 ( see the inset panel in figure  [ fig : sfrhauv ] ) .
the main left panel of figure  [ fig : sfrhauv ] shows h@xmath1 and uv sfrs , both corrected for dust attenuation based on the calzetti attenuation curve and assuming that the same color - excess , @xmath13 , as derived from the best - fit sed model , applies to the stellar continuum and the nebular regions .
to better quantify the mean trend , measurements have also been performed in bins of uv dust - corrected sfr ( filled circles in figure  [ fig : sfrhauv ] ) .
the bins are @xmath94log(sfr@xmath95 ) = 0.3dex wide .
for all the galaxies in each bin , regardless of their redshift , we calculate the median flux densities in the observed filters . with the new set of median fluxes , the best - fit stellar population model is determined through @xmath48 minimization for the mean redshift of the galaxies in each bin .
the h@xmath1 and uv luminosities are then derived from the stacked sed in the same way as for individual galaxies ( see   [ sec : sec3 ] ) .
reported errors are calculated based on the @xmath86 standard error of the mean of the _ @xmath2 _ magnitudes contributing to each bin .
ccccccc @xmath96 & 26 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 + @xmath102 & 63 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & @xmath106 & @xmath107 + @xmath108 & 83 & @xmath109 & @xmath110 & @xmath111 & @xmath112 & @xmath113 + @xmath114 & 56 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 & @xmath117 & @xmath118 & @xmath119 + @xmath120 & 15 & @xmath121 & @xmath122 & @xmath123 & @xmath124 & @xmath125    [ tab : sfr ]    the appropriate dust corrections to apply to the nebular emission lines is still a subject of debate , as discussed in section  [ sec : intro ] .
the attenuation of the nebular lines and the uv stellar continuum are not completely decoupled as both arise from dust around massive stars . on the other hand ,
whether the color - excess is the same for the nebular and stellar regions ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) or not ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) in high - redshift galaxies has yet to be fully investigated .
@xcite found that @xmath126 for a sample of local star - forming galaxies . in the absence of direct measurements of the nebular color - excess ( e.g. , via the balmer decrement ) , this relationship can in principle be used to estimate the nebular color excess and apply a dust correction to the h@xmath1 line ; e.g. , @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the @xcite galactic extinction curve , assuming that the nebular regions in the high - redshift galaxies abide by such a dust curve .
@xmath129 is the absolute extinction of the h@xmath1 emission line , and @xmath130 is the sed - inferred stellar color excess .
we investigate several of the more commonly used dust - correction recipes , as described below .
the h@xmath1 sfrs are corrected using five different methods :    1 .   the calzetti attenuation curve for both gas and stars , but 2.27@xmath56 larger color - excess for the nebular lines than the stellar continuum ( as we call it `` different @xmath13 '' ) , 2 .   the calzetti attenuation curve for the stellar continuum , and the @xcite galactic curve for the nebular lines assuming 2.27@xmath56 larger color - excess , 3 .   the calzetti attenuation curve for the stellar continuum , and an smc extinction curve @xcite for the nebular lines assuming 2.27@xmath56 larger color - excess , 4
the calzetti attenuation curve for both gas and stars , and the same color - excess ( as we call it `` equal @xmath13 '' ) , and 5 .   the calzetti attenuation curve for the stellar continuum , an smc extinction curve @xcite for the nebular lines assuming the same color - excess .
we choose to compare these different dust - correction scenarios for the stacked values instead of the individual galaxies as the former represent an average over many points including both detected and undetected quantities , each of which may be relatively uncertain .
the results are plotted in the right panel of figure  [ fig : sfrhauv ] and are reported in table  [ tab : sfr ] .    to summarize , these are the values that are used to correct the observed h@xmath1 sfrs in each model according to equation  [ diffatt ] : @xmath131 in these equations , @xmath13 is the sed - inferred color - excess observed for the stellar continuum and a@xmath132 is the total nebular extinction at 6564  .    in model ( a ) with a larger color excess for the nebular regions with the calzetti curve , h@xmath1-inferred sfrs
are significantly larger than uv sfrs .
taking the average of the sfr(h@xmath1 ) ( model a ) to the corrected sfr(uv ) in the five bins of sfr(uv ) indicated in tables  [ tab : sfr ] yields a value of @xmath133 which shows a @xmath134 discrepancy from unity .    using either model ( c ) or ( d ) , results in sfr@xmath135 that are in good agreement with sfr@xmath136 .
model ( b ) reproduce systematically higher sfrs but is still consistent with the range of sfr@xmath136 in higher bins , and model ( e ) estimations are lower than expected .    based on the data provided in table  [ tab : sfr ] and the right panel of figure  [ fig : sfrhauv ] , model ( d )
provides the best agreement between sfrs among the five models .
the average of the sfr(h@xmath1)-to - sfr(uv ) ratios in the five sfr(uv ) bins of this model shows less than @xmath85 discrepancy from unity .
this suggests that _ on average _ the best recipe to correct the h@xmath1-inferred quantities of star - forming galaxies at @xmath7 is to use @xmath137 with the calzetti reddening curve .
line luminosity as a function of bolometric sfr .
the stars indicate the average values in bins of sfr(sed ) .
galaxies with sfr(sed ) @xmath138 32 @xmath139  yr@xmath37 are in the first bin ; those with sfr(sed ) between 32 @xmath139  yr@xmath37 and 100 @xmath139  yr@xmath37 are in the middle bin ; and last bin consists of galaxies with sfr(sed ) @xmath47 100 @xmath139  yr@xmath37 .
the error in sfr(uv)+sfr(ir ) is determined by the dispersion error in ir luminosity of the objects contributing to each stack .
l(ir ) dispersion error is estimated through bootstrap resampling simulations .
the solid blue line is the best linear fit .
the slope of this fit gives us the conversion factor for l(h@xmath1)@xmath140-to - sfr@xmath141 relation .
the shaded area is the 68% confidence interval of our estimated slope .
the orange and dark - red dashed lines show the conversion factors of @xcite and @xcite , respectively . ]
as discussed above , a primary disadvantage of using h@xmath1 and uv sfr diagnostics is that we must account for dust extinction , though this is less of a problem for h@xmath1 as it is for the uv .
the attenuation curves ( e.g. , the @xcite curve ) that are used to correct the luminosities encode information regarding the dust grain size distribution and the geometrical distribution of dust with respect to stars ( e.g. , whether the dust is clumpy or uniform , a homogeneous mixture or a foreground screen , etc . ) . on the other hand ,
the ir luminosity is a direct tracer of dust and thus provides an independent and more robust diagnostic of dust attenuation .
adding the ir luminosity , which accounts for the obscured star formation , to the unobscured ( uv and h@xmath1 ) tracers of sfr can give a more reliable estimate of the bolometric sfr .      to convert the observed h@xmath1 luminosity to total sfr , the most commonly used calibration is that of @xcite , which is computed using an evolutionary synthesis model , assuming case b recombination with @xmath142=10,000k . in the absence of balmer decrement measurements ,
the observed h@xmath1 sfr must be corrected for dust with some assumption of the attenuation curve and color - excess of the ionized gas . in this section
, we examine the l@xmath132-to - sfr conversion by relying only on the observed data , without making any assumptions about the dust correction or electron temperature of the ionized gas . with this conversion
, one can use the h@xmath1 observed luminosity as a proxy for total sfr without assuming a dust attenuation curve and its associated uncertainties .
the conversion applies to stellar populations with constant star formation at least over 100myr . for bursty star formation histories over timescales shorter than 100myr ,
the h@xmath1 and uv+ir luminosities diverge as the h@xmath1 luminosity traces more instantaneous star formation over timescales of @xmath143myr , while ir+uv is not sensitive to the change of star formation on timescales @xmath144myr . here
, we are deriving the conversion factor based on the stacked data that represents the `` average '' quantities and thus should be used with caution for galaxies that may be undergoing bursty star formation .
bolometric sfr ( sfr(ir)+sfr(uv ) ) is plotted as a function of the h@xmath1 luminosity in figure  [ fig : lha ] . as both the h@xmath1 and ir measurements have non - detections
, we decided to bin the data with respect to the sed - inferred sfr .
we chose the bins so that in each bin the sfr(sed ) is consistent with the stacked sfr(ir)+sfr(uv ) within the uncertainties , because ultimately we are using sfr(ir)+sfr(uv ) to calculate the h@xmath1 luminosity - to - sfr conversion factor .
mips data are stacked in each bin and the total ir luminosity is extracted in the same way as for individual galaxies .
the uv and h@xmath1 luminosities are derived from the stacked seds .
a weighted least squares regression method is used to find the slope of the relation :    @xmath145    this relation can be used to convert the observed h@xmath1 luminosity in units of ergs@xmath37 to the bolometric sfr .
the factor given in @xcite and @xcite , to convert observed / intrinsic luminosity to observed / intrinsic sfr , is 7.9 @xmath146 @xmath139  yr@xmath37  erg@xmath37  s. @xcite reported a conversion factor of 6.3 @xmath146 @xmath139  yr@xmath37  erg@xmath37  s. these factors are computed using evolutionary synthesis models and are subject to those models uncertainties as well as the initial assumptions that went into these models , such as imf , star - formation history , and the stellar evolution and atmosphere models . for the same galaxy type and assumed imf , @xcite reports @xmath147 variation among different calibrations , which mainly reflects the sensitivity to the sed modeling stellar evolution input data . in our analysis , converting l(ir ) and l(uv ) to sfr still rely on the model assumptions , but previous studies have shown that in the absence of the balmer decrement measurements , the sum of sfr(ir ) and sfr(uv ) is the most reliable estimate of total sfr @xcite .
our derived slope for a salpeter imf is consistent with @xcite and @xcite within the errors .    excluding galaxies with ages @xmath138 100myr ( see   [ sec : sfrsed ] ) results in a best - fit slope of 7.8 @xmath148  yr@xmath37  erg@xmath37  s that is consistent with the slope found above .
m ; open blue circles include all objects and filled red circles include only those galaxies older than 100myr .
diamonds are individual detected objects and downward arrows represent @xmath149 upper limits in sfr(ir)+sfr(uv ) for the mips undetected galaxies .
young galaxies ( ages @xmath138 100myr ) are colored blue and galaxies with ages @xmath47 100myr are orange .
sfr(ir ) error bars are estimated through bootstrap simulations and show the dispersion in the sfrs contributing to each stack .
the last bin consists of galaxies with sfr(sed ) @xmath47 100 @xmath139  yr@xmath37 ; by removing young galaxies ( ages @xmath138 100myr ) about half of the sample in this bin is dismissed and we see the change between the two measurements ( including and excluding the young ones ) .
the dotted line indicates a one - to - one correspondence . ]
figure  [ fig : sed_bol ] shows the bolometric sfr vs. median sfr inferred from the best - fit sed model , in bins of sfr(sed ) .
both quantities are representative of the total sfr of the galaxies , the only difference being the method by which dust is accounted for .
the bolometric sfr , as mentioned before , is the sum of sfr(ir ) and sfr(uv ) , and is independent of any dust correction . on the other hand , for sfr(sed ) , the effect of dust is considered by using the calzetti attenuation curve in the sed fitting procedure .
we would like to determine whether for all types of galaxies at @xmath7 the bolometric sfrs agree with sed sfrs that are corrected by the calzetti attenuation curve .
we stack the mips data of individual detected and undetected galaxies in three bins of sfr(sed ) as described in
[ sec : sample - b ] .
the three bins in log(sfr(sed ) ) are @xmath138 1.5 , 1.5 to 2 , and @xmath47 2 , with respectively 44 , 56 , and 15 galaxies in each bin .
sfr(sed ) and sfr(uv ) are the median sfrs of the individual galaxies in each bin .
the results of stacking is shown with open blue circles in figure  [ fig : sed_bol ] . in the last two bins ,
the sed sfr is overestimated compared to the bolometric sfr . stacking the mips images for only objects that are inferred to be older than 100myr produces different results .
the number of objects in bins with galaxies older than 100myr reduces to 43 , 50 , and 8 , respectively from the lowest sfr(sed ) bin to the highest .
once we remove galaxies with ages @xmath138 100myr , sfr(sed ) agrees well with sfr(uv)+sfr(ir ) . an age - dependent l(uv)-to - sfr calibration ( as we use here )
does not decrease the difference between sfr(sed ) and the bolometric sfr for stacks of all galaxies .
it seems younger galaxies are at the same time less dusty ( smaller bolometric sfr ) but redder ( larger sfr(sed ) ) than their older counterparts .
these results are consistent with those of @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite , who find that galaxies with young stellar population ages are less dusty for a given uv slope than older galaxies
. an smc - like curve may be more appropriate for these galaxies .
one possibility is that young galaxies have larger dust covering fractions than older galaxies @xcite .
a large dust covering fraction makes the uv slope redder for a given amount of dust attenuation .
this study confirms that at @xmath7 the calzetti attenuation curve is applicable to star - forming galaxies older than 100myr , but a steeper attenuation curve may be necessary for the younger galaxies .
we have studied the multi - wavelength properties of a sample of @xmath8 200 galaxies with spectroscopically confirmed redshifts at @xmath0 , to study the validity of commonly used dust correction recipes and to compare sfrs inferred from the h@xmath1 line luminosity , the uv continuum luminosity , and _
spitzer_/mips 24@xmath3 m measurements that are converted to the total ir luminosity . in this study
, we benefit from using the broad - band photometry excess techniques to determine the h@xmath1 fluxes and , hence , conduct a large sample of @xmath7 h@xmath1 measurements that is immune to uncertainties in the spectroscopic slit - loss corrections .
the galaxies properties are determined from stellar population model fitting to the rest - frame uv through near - infrared data .
the main conclusions are as follows .
* by investigating several recipes for dust correcting the nebular emission lines , we find that assuming the same color excess of the ionized gas and the stellar continuum ( i.e. , @xmath150 ) , and assuming that the calzetti attenuation curve applies to both , results in the best agreement between sfr(h@xmath1 ) and sfr(uv ) . if we assume the calzetti curve to both the stellar and nebular regions but use @xmath151=2.27  @xmath152 , the corrected sfr(h@xmath1 ) measurements are inconsistent with the corrected sfr(uv)s at @xmath134 level , averaged on the five bins of sfr(uv ) ( see the right panel of figure  [ fig : sfrhauv ] ) . * using the available _
spitzer_/mips data for @xmath8 100 galaxies in our sample , we derive an observed l@xmath132-to - sfr@xmath141 conversion factor of @xmath153 @xmath139  yr@xmath37  erg@xmath37  s. this calibration is independent of any assumptions on the dust correction and can be used to convert the observed ( extincted ) h@xmath1 luminosity to a bolometric sfr when no dust attenuation measurements for the h@xmath1 luminosity is available . * by comparing the stacks of sfr(uv)+sfr(ir ) with the sed - inferred sfrs that are corrected for dust by the locally - derived calzetti curve we conclude that a steeper attenuation curve ( such as an smc curve ) may be necessary for galaxies younger than 100myr , as previous studies @xcite have found .
we find that applying the calzetti curve to the stacks of all galaxies , including the young ones , results in sfr(sed)s that are inconsistent with the sfr(uv)+sfr(ir ) at @xmath154 significance ( the sfr(sed ) in three mass bins of figure  [ fig : sed_bol ] are inconsistent with sfr(uv)+sfr(ir ) by 1 , 2 , and 3@xmath54 , from the lowest to highest mass bins respectively ) .
the young galaxies have redder uv slope and at the same time lower bolometric sfr compared to their older counterparts . as a result , applying the calzetti curve to the young galaxies overestimates the sed - inferred sfr when compared with their bolometric sfr .
the calzetti attenuation curve shows a good overall agreement for galaxies older than 100myr .    a more detailed investigation will include direct tracers of nebular dust extinction ( i.e. , the balmer decrement ) . in the future studies , we plan to investigate this aspect with the mosfire deep evolution field ( mosdef ) survey , which uses the near - ir multi - object spectrograph mosfire on the keck  i telescope to obtain spectroscopic measurements of the nebular emission lines for a sample of @xmath155 galaxies @xcite .
is thanks valentino gonzlez for useful discussions .
support for is is provided through the national science foundation graduate research fellowship under grant no .
nar is supported by an alfred p. sloan research fellowship .


the discovery of a new class of faint dwarf satellites around the milky way ( mw ; see e.g. , ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) ) and the andromeda galaxies ( m31 ; see e.g. , ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) ) has opened a new window for the study of the formation history of large spirals .
the new systems show a number of remarkable differences with respect to the `` classical '' dwarf spheroidals ( dsphs ) surrounding the mw and m31 : i ) they have much lower surface brightnesses ( @xmath11  mag ) , for which they were named `` ultra - faint '' dwarfs ( ufds ) ; ii ) they are very metal poor , with large dispersions and [ fe / h ] values as low as @xmath12 dex ( see * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
such extreme abundances are not observed among the classical dsphs where only a few stars with [ fe / h]@xmath13 have been detected @xcite compared to the large number found in the mw halo ; iii ) they generally contain rr lyrae stars that conform to the subdivision into oosterhoff types i ( oo i ) and ii ( ooii ; * ? ? ?
* ) d , whereas type ii ( oo ii ) clusters have @xmath14 d ] observed for field and cluster mw variables .
so far , the only exception among the ufds is canes venatici i ( cvn i , * ? ? ?
* ) , the brightest of the mw ufds , that , like the classical mw dsphs , has instead oosterhoff - intermediate ( oo - int ) properties ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) ; and , finally : iv ) the ufds discovered so far outnumber by almost a factor of two the classical dsphs , thus partially reducing the so - called `` missing satellites problem '' @xcite affecting the @xmath15-cold - dark - matter ( @xmath15cdm ) scenario of galaxy formation . with their properties
the ufds are potentially much better analogues than the classical dsphs of the `` building blocks '' that contributed to the formation of the two large spirals in the local group .
they have absolute luminosities similar to the globular clusters ( gcs ; @xmath16 mag , on average ) but they are much more spatially extended than gcs . with typical half - light radii of @xmath17 100 pc , in fact they equal in size the `` classical '' dsphs .
the ufds are found in groups on the sky ( see e.g. fig . 1 of * ? ? ?
* ) , have small velocity dispersions , and high mass - to - light ratios .
all ufds host an ancient population around 10 gyr old .
they have gc - like color - magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) resembling the cmds of metal - poor galactic gcs ( ggcs ) such as m92 ( ngc  6341 ) , m15 ( ngc  7078 ) and m68 ( ngc  4590 ) . some of the mw ufds have a distorted shape due to the tidal interaction with the mw .
we are carrying out an extensive observational campaign of the new mw and m31 ufds to study structural parameters and stellar population properties , as well as the variable stars of these systems .
we have already published results for bootes i ( boo i , * ? ? ?
* ) , cvn i @xcite , canes venatici ii ( cvnii , * ? ? ?
* ) , coma @xcite , leo iv @xcite , and ursa major ii ( umaii * ? ? ?
* ) among the mw ufds . with the only exception of cvn i
, all these dwarfs contain rr lyrae stars with pulsation periods suggesting an oo ii classification .
however , only boo i and cvn i contain sufficiently large numbers of variables to be safely classified into oosterhoff types .
the classification of the other ufds is less certain given the small numbers of variables they contain .
nevertheless , their few variables clearly tend to have oosterhoff type ii properties .
thus , in terms of stellar metallicity and pulsation properties of the variable stars , systems similar to the ufds , as they were at earlier times , could resemble the building blocks of the galactic halo .    in this paper
we extend our analysis to the hercules ufd galaxy ( r.a.@xmath18 , decl.@xmath19 , j2000.0 ) .
the galaxy was discovered by @xcite from the analysis of sdss data .
the cmd of hercules ( based on follow - up isaac newton telescope - int- data ) shows besides the red giant branch ( rgb ) , also blue and red horizontal branches ( hbs ) .
@xcite interpreted this evidence as a possible signature of multiple stellar populations present in the galaxy .
a number of studies have been devoted to this galaxy after the discovery paper .
cmds of hercules reaching well below the galaxy s main sequence turn - off were published by ( * ? ? ?
* in the @xmath1 and @xmath0 bands ) and ( * ? ? ?
* in the @xmath20 and @xmath1 bands ) , based on very wide - field observations obtained with the red and blue channels of the large binocular camera ( lbc ; @xcite ) of the large binocular telescope ( lbt ) .
according to the @xcite recovery of the galaxy s star formation history ( sfh ) , hercules is old ( @xmath21 12 gyr , with negligible star formation in the last 12 gyr ) and metal - poor ( [ fe / h]@xmath22 dex ) , with an intrinsic spread in metallicity and both [ fe / h ] = @xmath23 dex and @xmath24 dex populations contributing to the sfh . in the literature
there are several spectroscopic and photometric determinations of the metallicity of hercules .
these studies confirm that hercules shows a spread in metal abundance , with values of the mean metallicity @xmath25 } \rangle$ ] ranging from about @xmath262.0 to @xmath262.7 dex @xcite .
the line of sight towards the hercules dsph galaxy is heavily contaminated by galactic foreground stars , making it hard to determine membership from the cmd alone . even when radial velocities are added the selection remains uncertain , because the mean velocity of the hercules dsph galaxy coincides with the velocity of the thick disk ( @xcite ) .
indeed , in the @xcite cmd , based on strmgren photometry obtained with the wide field camera of the int , the rgb of hercules is not easily identified due to the halo foreground contamination .
these authors used the c1 index in the strmgren system to disentangle the galaxy s rgb and hb stars from the foreground contamination .
hercules appears to be highly elongated .
the galaxy s structural parameters were obtained by a number of different authors @xcite who , fitting different stellar profiles to their independent photometric datasets , found similar values for the galaxy s central position , position angle ( @xmath27 ) , and ellipticity ( @xmath28 ) , but rather different half - light radii . in a recent analysis ,
@xcite suggest that the density profiles of relaxed , tidally stripped dwarf spheroidals like hercules are better approximated by a plummer law .
moreover , @xcite clearly point out the need for deep photometry in order to properly constrain the structural parameters of the new faint mw satellites . in the following
, we shall adopt the structural parameters obtained by @xcite assuming a plummer stellar distribution , namely @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 .
hercules has no evidence of internal rotation , and a very low velocity dispersion of @xmath32 km s@xmath33 for @xcite or 3.72 km s@xmath33 for @xcite .
the explanation of such a large ellipticity in absence of a rotational support might imply that hercules is not in dynamical equilibrium due to strong tidal distortions ( see discussion in * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the latest studies estimate distances in the range of @xmath34 kpc to @xmath35 kpc ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and a total absolute magnitude ranging from @xmath36 mag to @xmath37 mag ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the study presented in this paper is based on @xmath38 photometric time - series imaging covering a field of view ( fov ) of @xmath39 ( see table  [ t : obs ] ) , extending well beyond hercules half - light radius .
these data have allowed us to obtain a complete inventory of the variable stars belonging to the galaxy and to trace the corresponding parent stellar populations .
this paper is organized as follows : in section 2 we present the observations and the data reduction procedures ; section 3 is devoted to the variable stars , whereas the cmds and the implications for the structure of the hercules ufd are discussed in section 4 .
a new estimate of the distance to hercules based on the galaxy s rr lyrae stars is presented in section 5 . finally , the summary and conclusions in section 6 close the paper .
time - series observations in @xmath1 and @xmath0 of the hercules ufd were obtained over the period 2007 april to 2009 june , using a number of different telescopes .
the collected data and related telescopes / instrumental set - ups are summarized in table [ t : obs ] , where @xmath40 and @xmath41 are the number of frames in the @xmath1 and @xmath0 bands , respectively .
pre - reduction of the images was performed by following standard procedures ( bias subtraction and flat - field correction ) with iraf , except for the wfi data , for which the pre - reduction was carried out using the vst - tube pipeline @xcite .
we then performed psf photometry using the daophotiv / allstar / allframe packages ( @xcite ) .
after an accurate evaluation of the psf of each individual frame , a reference image was built by averaging all the available frames and a source catalogue was extracted from the stacked image .
the source list was then passed to allframe , in order to obtain a homogeneous photometry of all images simultaneously , thus providing @xmath42 and @xmath43 instrumental magnitude catalogues for each telescope .
typical internal errors of the single - frame photometry for stars at the hb magnitude level ( @xmath44 mag ) are of about 0.01 mag in both bands .    the absolute photometric calibration was derived using observations of standard stars in the landolt fields sa 101 , sa 107 , sa 110 and pg1323 @xcite , as extended by @xcite , which were obtained at the int during the night of 2007 april 22 .
errors of the absolute photometric calibration are @xmath45 and @xmath46 mag . as the various telescopes we have used define slightly different photometric systems ,
each individual dataset was tied to the int standard calibration independently .
the calibrated catalogues were then combined using daomaster @xcite to create a final list containing positions , robust intensity - weighted mean @xmath1 and @xmath0 magnitudes @xcite , and weighted average values of the @xmath47 and @xmath48 parameters parameter of each star is a robust estimate of the observed pixel - to - pixel scatter of the fitting residuals to the expected scatter , whereas the @xmath48 parameter is related to the intrinsic angular size of the astronomical objects , and for stellar objects should have a value close to zero @xcite . ] for all objects .
we have adopted @xmath49 and @xmath50 to select the stellar - like objects imaged in our total fov of about @xmath10 .
this selection is reliable for magnitudes brighter than @xmath9 24 mag , while the uncertainty increases at fainter magnitudes .
variable stars were identified from the @xmath1 and @xmath0 time - series data , separately .
first , we calculated the fourier transforms ( in the @xcite formulation ) of the stars having at least 12 measurements in each photometric band , then we averaged these transforms to estimate the noise and calculated the signal - to - noise ratios ( s / ns ) .
results from the @xmath1 and @xmath0 photometries were cross - correlated , obtaining a list of 860 stars with @xmath51 in both photometric bands ( see e.g. @xcite )
. a visual inspection of the light curves allowed us to confirm the variability of 10 of these candidates .
we also analyzed in detail all stars falling on the hb , in the region above the hb , where the anomalous cepheids are generally located , and in the blue straggler region , where one may expect to find variables of the sx phoenicis type .
no further variable stars were identified , thus confirming the reliability of our procedure to identify variable stars . to study the light curves we used the software graphical analyzer of time series ( gratis ; see e.g. , @xcite ) that , beyond confirming the variability for all the 10 candidates , also provided periods accurate to 4 - 6 decimal places for all of them .
the hercules variables include 1 anomalous cepheid ( ac ) and 9 rr lyrae stars , of which 6 are fundamental - mode ( rrab ) and 3 are first - overtone ( rrc ) pulsators .
classification and properties of the confirmed variable stars are summarized in table  [ t : rr ] , whereas their light curves are shown in figs .
[ f : fig1 ] and [ f : fig2 ] .
we have assigned to the variables increasing numbers starting from the galaxy center that was set at r.a.@xmath52 , decl.@xmath53 , j2000.0 @xcite .
time - series data for the variable stars are provided in table  [ t : pho ] .
the light curves are very well sampled , and show very little scatter , except for star v10 .
the star does not appear to be blended with other stars on the images .
we suspect that v10 might be affected by the blazhko effect @xcite .
we note that , according to the period , the ac ( star v2 ) could as well be a fundamental - mode rr lyrae star . however , the star s average magnitude is about 0.4 - 0.5 mag brighter than the hb level .
this occurrence , together with a too small amplitude for the star s short period , suggest that the variable either suffers from blending by a contaminant star or is , perhaps , an ac .
the photometric parameters @xmath47 ( goodness of the psf fitting ) and @xmath48 ( estimate of the object shape ) provided for v2 by the allframe package seem to rule out the presence of detectable companions around the star , thus favoring the ac hypothesis .
another possibility is that v2 could be an overluminous rrc as , for instance , v70 in the m3 ggc .
however , the period of v2 ( 0.53777 d ) is definitely longer than that of m3-v70 ( @xmath54 d , @xcite , @xcite ) .
on the other hand , the mean magnitude and the period of v2 are in very good agreement with the ac period - luminosity relations by ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) , @xcite and ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) , thus favoring an ac classification for v2 . finally ,
as described in section [ s : cmd ] , the ac classification is further supported by the comparison with evolutionary tracks .
the ac , all the rrc variables and three of the rrab stars lie inside the half - light radius of the hercules galaxy .
one rrab is just on the border of this region and the remaining two rrab stars lie well outside the half - light radius , with the farthest from the center being confirmed as a member by @xcite on the basis of both radial velocity and strmgren photometry ( see section [ s : cmd ] and figs .
[ f : cmd ] and [ f : ad ] for details ) .
all the rr lyrae stars fall on the hb of the hercules ufd , and their mean magnitude is consistent , within the errors , with the average luminosity of the hb inferred by fitting the galaxy cmd with the ridge line of the ggc m68 ( see section [ s : cmd ] for details ) .
the mean period of the rrab stars is @xmath55 d ( @xmath4=0.03 d ) , thus classifying hercules as an oosterhoff type - ii system .
[ f : bailey ] shows the position of the hercules rr lyrae stars on the @xmath0-band period - amplitude ( bailey ) diagram .
we have also reported the rr lyrae stars identified in the other mw ufds we have studied so far , for comparison .
rrab stars ( star symbols ) lie closer to the loci of the oo  ii systems ( from * ? ? ?
* solid line ) and the rrc stars fall on the long - period tail of the bell - shaped distribution defined by rrc stars in oo  ii systems ( see , e.g. , fig . 9 of @xcite , and fig . 4 of @xcite ) .      as shown by @xcite
, it is possible to use the shape of an rr lyrae @xmath0-band light curve to obtain an estimate of the star s metallicity .
we have performed a fourier decomposition of the @xmath0-band light curves of the variables in hercules and calculated amplitude ratios @xmath56 and phase differences @xmath57 .
we list in table [ t : fou ] these quantities up to the term @xmath58 .
the fourier parameters were then used along with the formulae provided by @xcite and @xcite for ab- and c - type rr lyrae stars , respectively , to obtain individual metallicities for the hercules rr lyrae stars , except for v10 whose light curve is too noisy for a reliable application of the jurcsik & kovacs method .
the metallicity estimates obtained with this technique are reported in column 2 of table  [ t : met ] ; they are on the @xcite scale .
these individual metallicities were transformed to the @xcite metallicity scale ( using the @xcite transformations for the ab - type variables , and the @xcite recalibration for the c - type rr lyrae stars , see column 3 of table [ t : met ] ) .
we then averaged these values ( weighted average ) to obtain our best estimate for the metallicity of hercules old population .
our resultant metallicity is @xmath25_{rr , c09 } } \rangle= -2.30 \pm 0.15 $ ] dex .
literature values for the hercules ufd s metal abundance are summarized in table [ t : lit_met ] .
they were obtained using a variety of different methods and span a rather large range .
in particular , we note that the values from @xcite and @xcite are photometric estimates based on fitting the galaxy s cmd with evolutionary tracks , while all other entries in the table are spectroscopic determinations .
specifically , the @xcite value is based on abundance analysis of medium - high resolution ( @xmath59 ) spectra of two stars in hercules .
the @xcite analysis is based on medium - resolution spectra of 30 red giants in hercules , and the measurement of the equivalent widths of the ca triplet absorption lines .
the @xcite study is a re - analysis of the @xcite spectroscopic data , based on an automated spectral synthesis technique .
this latter method likely provides systematically lower metallicities ( by @xmath60 dex ) , as discussed by the authors themselves ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
finally , in a recent study , @xcite confirm that a large metallicity spread ( @xmath61}\leq -2.0 $ ] dex , for an average value of [ fe / h]=@xmath62 dex ) exists in hercules , from the analysis of medium - high resolution ( @xmath63 ) spectra of 11 rgb stars .
however , taking into account only the red giants with metallicity measurements based on a significant number of iron lines ( @xmath64 ; four stars according to table  6 in @xcite ) , we obtain @xmath65}\rangle=-2.3 \pm 0.2 $ ] dex ( and a range of ( @xmath66}\leq -2.0 $ ] dex ) .
this value is in excellent agreement with our estimate from the rr lyrae stars . on this basis
, we will adopt the metallicity estimate @xmath67_{rr , c09 } \rangle$ ] obtained from the rr lyrae stars in the following analysis .
hercules reddening can be estimated from the galaxy s rr lyrae stars .
using the relation for rrab stars by @xcite , that connects the color excess to the star s b - band amplitude , the logarithm of the period and the metallicity , we obtain a mean color excess @xmath68 mag , where we have adopted the individual metallicities on the @xcite scale listed in table  [ t : met ] .
we also use the method by @xcite , which is based on the rr lyrae s @xmath69 color at minimum light , and obtain @xmath70 mag , by applying the metallicity - dependent relation by @xcite .
this estimate is larger than the previous value but , as already pointed out by @xcite and @xcite , sturch s method overestimates the color excess by 0.01 - 0.03 mag .
we therefore adopt @xmath71 mag for the reddening .
this is in very good agreement with the value of @xmath72 mag derived from the @xcite maps .
[ f : cmd ] shows the @xmath0 , @xmath69 cmd of hercules obtained in the present study . in the left panel
we plot stellar - like objects within the galaxy s half - light radius ; in the right panel , instead , we show objects outside this region over our fov of @xmath10 .
all the rr lyrae stars have been plotted in the left panel of the figure including those falling outside the galaxy half - light radius .
the cmd reaches @xmath73 25 mag and appears to be heavily contaminated at each magnitude level by field objects belonging to the mw halo and disk , as well as by background galaxies .
our photometry reaches a few magnitudes deeper than the sdss photometry ( see fig . 2 of @xcite )
; while it is roughly 1 mag shallower than the photometry obtained using the lbt ( fig . 1 in @xcite , and fig . 8 in @xcite )
however , within the errors , it is consistent both in @xmath1 and @xmath0 , with the photometry reported in table 2 of @xcite .    in fig .
[ f : cmd ] , the main branches of the hercules cmd are barely distinguishable due to the overwhelming contamination by the mw field . to identify stars belonging to hercules we used the method that we have already successfully applied in our previous papers ( see e.g. , @xcite ) .
specifically , we used the mean ridgelines of the ggc m68 ( dashed black lines in figure [ f : cmd ] ) , obtained from @xcite @xmath74 photometry to fit the hb and rgb of the hercules ufd , by letting the m68 ridgelines vary within the values of the cluster reddening and distance modulus available in the literature
. the `` by eye '' best fit was obtained for a shift of @xmath75 mag in magnitude and @xmath76 mag in color .
we adopted m68 for identifying members of the hercules ufd because , like hercules , it is very metal - poor .
its metallicity , @xmath77_{m68 } } = -2.27 \pm 0.04 $ ] dex @xcite , is in very good agreement with the mean metallicity obtained in section [ s : met ] from the hercules rr lyrae stars .
furthermore , the cluster has a well - defined and tight rgb , as well as an extended hb including stars both redder and bluer than the rr lyrae instability strip ( @xcite ) , thus resulting better suited to identify the galaxy s hb than , for instance , m92 , which instead was used as a fiducial by @xcite . with this procedure we selected as most probable members of the hercules galaxy the sources lying within @xmath78 mag in @xmath69 from the ridgelines of m68 ( black dots in the left panel of figure [ f : cmd ] ) .
to account for the larger photometric errors , below @xmath79 mag we extended this range within @xmath80 mag of the ridgeline of m68 ( blue dots ) adopting for m68 a reddening value of @xmath81 mag @xcite the color shifts needed to match the hb and rgb of hercules imply a reddening of @xmath82 mag for the galaxy , in excellent agreement with the value obtained from the rrab stars ( see section [ s : met ] ) .
totally similar results are obtained using the ridgelines of the ggc m15 that is slightly more metal - poor than m68 and matches equally well the main branches of the hercules cmd , whereas the ridgeline of the metal - intermediate gc m3 ( ngc  5272 ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) is too red and would require a negative reddening to match the galaxy rgb .    with the help of m68 ridgelines , it is possible to determine the average luminosity of the hercules hb in the region of the so - called rr lyrae gap ( @xmath83 mag ) , and to locate the galaxy s main - sequence turnoff at @xmath84 mag .
our identification of hercules members is supported by the spectroscopic study of ( * ? ? ?
* stars ) and the spectrophotometric analysis of ( * ? ? ?
* stars ) , with membership to the hercules ufd confirmed by radial velocity measurements and , for @xcite s sample , also by strmgren photometry ( violet open circles in fig .
[ f : cmd ] ) .
the excellent agreement between these studies and our results supports the reliability of the procedure we have used to select hercules members and to identify the hb .
@xcite compared the galaxy s cmd with the ridge - line of the ggc m92 ( @xmath5 \sim -2.24 $ ] dex ) and m13 ( @xmath5 \sim -1.65 $ ] dex ) and concluded that the morphological features of hercules cmd are generally well described by the ridge line of the old , metal - poor globular cluster m92 . using suitable metal - poor evolutionary tracks and their deep lbt photometry to recover the galaxy s sfh , @xcite and @xcite find that hercules hosts a single old stellar population ( @xmath85 gyr ) , and shows no evidence of significant subsequent star formation events .
this is in contrast with the @xcite claim that hercules extended hb showing both a blue and a red component might be the signature of possible multiple stellar populations in the galaxy .
however , @xcite s argument can not be considered conclusive , as the morphology of the hb is driven by a complex interplay of different effects , traditionally known in the literature related to ggcs as the `` second parameter problem '' ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein )
. on the other hand , in the region of the cmd above the hb ( @xmath86 and @xmath87 mag ) , there seems to be an overabundance of stars that might represent the signature of an intermediate - age population in hercules . unfortunately
, the contamination by field stars in this region of the cmd is very high ( see right panel of fig . [
f : cmd ] ) , thus we can not reach any firm conclusion with our data .
an analysis of the existent literature data shows that the hb and the brighter portions of hercules cmd are very poorly populated in the lbt photometry of @xcite and @xcite , likely due to saturation effects , and can not be used to check the possible existence of such an excess above the hb .
however , an overabundance of stars brighter than the hb was observed in hercules also by @xcite , who investigated whether they might be variables , based on the magnitude variation in their few ( no more than 3 ) epoch data for the stars .
they provide a list of possible variable stars in their table 7 .
though we note that these candidate variables are not included in the @xcite final list of hercules members , we checked them in our time series photometry , and do not confirm their variability .
however , we have identified an ac variable in this region above the hb , star v2 ( asterisk in fig .
[ f : cmd ] , see section [ s : variables ] ) . in fig .
[ f : cmd_tracce ] we show an enlargement of the hb region of the cmd in fig . [ f : cmd ] ( with the same color coding ) , where we have plotted the helium burning evolutionary tracks of the stellar model database basti @xcite , for stellar masses in the range of 0.7 to 1.4 @xmath88 ( with a step of 0.1 @xmath88 ) and metal abundance @xmath89 . in particular , the thick ( black and green ) lines are the hb evolutionary tracks for 0.7 and 0.8 @xmath88 , respectively , whereas the thin ( grey ) lines are for @xmath90 including the range of masses corresponding to the hb turnover @xcite .
the magenta dot - dashed line represents the zero age horizontal branch ( zahb ) for the same chemical composition .
the location of the rr lyrae stars is consistent with the model predictions and suggests an evolutionary effect for some of them . on the other hand ,
the ac , star v2 , is , as expected , consistent with the evolution of a @xmath91 from the turnover region of the zahb .
the origin of acs is still debated ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * and references therein ) and the most widely accepted interpretations are : ( 1 ) they are young ( @xmath92 gyr ) single stars due to recent star formation ; ( 2 ) they formed from mass transfer in binary systems as old as the other stars in the same stellar system . our analysis does not allow us to discriminate between these two scenarios , however , we note that , in the first hypothesis , the comparison of v2 with the evolutionary tracks would suggest the existence in hercules of an intermediate - age population of stars as old as @xmath93 gyrs .    fig .
[ f : ad ] shows the position of the stars we consider to be members of the hercules galaxy in our fov .
symbols and color - coding are the same as in fig .
[ f : cmd ] , and the symbol size is inversely proportional to the object s magnitude .
the black ellipse corresponds to the half - light radius , the angle position , and the ellipticity obtained for hercules by @xcite .
this map confirms that the galaxy is elongated and has an irregular and extended shape .
likely , hercules was disrupted due to tidal interaction and is now embedded in the mw halo .
our discovery of two rrab variables outside the half - light radius , together with the spectrophotometric identification in the same external region of some stars with confirmed membership by @xcite , support the tidal interaction scenario .
[ f : adzoom ] shows an enlargement of the map in fig .
[ f : ad ] with the galaxy half - light radius region and all the variable stars identified in the present work .
the rr lyrae stars we have detected in hercules give us the opportunity to estimate the distance to the galaxy using these variables as standard candles .
the position of the hercules rr lyrae stars in the cmd is in satisfactory agreement with the fiducial - line hb of m68 , although with a significant spread .
the most deviating ( brightest ) of the rr lyrae variables , star v9 , is located well outside the galaxy s half - light radius ( see figs . [
f : ad ] and [ f : adzoom ] ) .
thus , its high luminosity could be caused by a projection effect .
the average magnitude of the rr lyrae stars lying inside the galaxy s half - light radius is @xmath94 mag ( average on 7 stars ) , where the error is the standard deviation of the mean . to obtain the absolute visual magnitude of hercules hb stars , we adopt for the slope of the rr lyrae magnitude - metallicity calibration the value @xmath95 } = 0.214 ( \pm 0.047)$ ] mag dex@xmath33 @xcite , and consider two different calibrations of the zero point . at [ fe / h]=@xmath96 dex
, we adopt : @xmath97 mag , that is based on the large magellanic cloud distance modulus of 18.52 @xmath98 mag of @xcite , and , alternatively , @xmath99 mag , from @xcite . adopting for metallicity and reddening the values derived in section [ s : met ] ( @xmath100_{rr , c09}\rangle}= -2.30 \pm 0.15 $ ] dex , and @xmath101 mag , respectively ) we obtain true distance moduli of @xmath102}=20.6\pm 0.1 $ ] mag ( @xmath103}=132 \pm 6 $ ] kpc ) , and @xmath104}=20.7 \pm 0.1 $ ] mag ( @xmath105}=138 \pm 6 $ ] kpc ) , for the @xcite and @xcite calibrations , respectively .
the errors on the distance values include the contribution of the uncertainties on the metallicity , the reddening , the adopted slope of the @xmath106}$ ] relation , and the average apparent visual magnitude of the hercules rr lyrae stars .
an additional estimate of the distance , based on the rr lyrae stars , can be obtained using the theoretical wesenheit relation in the @xmath38 bands , as defined by @xcite , with the assumption of a suitable evolutionary mass for the metallicity of hercules rr lyrae stars .
the resulting distance modulus of @xmath107 mag is in perfect agreement with @xmath102}$ ] .
moreover , a distance of @xmath108 kpc is in excellent agreement with the estimates by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and in statistical agreement with the distance by @xcite . on the other hand
, the distance @xmath105}$ ] appears to be only in statistical agreement with all previous determinations . to conclude this discussion
, we note that the very long estimate of @xmath109 kpc , obtained by @xcite is likely due to their hb mean magnitude being based on a few stars , of which some are variables observed at random phase , as we have confirmed in our study .
finally , the apparent distance modulus adopted in fig .
[ f : cmd_tracce ] , @xmath110 mag , corresponds to a true distance modulus of 20.7 mag .
however , we should take into account the theoretical uncertainties on the luminosity of the zahb and , in particular , the remark by @xcite that , adopting updated conductive opacities , might cause an increase in the @xmath111 of about 0.06 mag at the metallicity of hercules , and a corresponding decrease in the inferred distance modulus . on this basis , and considering also the results of the theoretical wesenheit relation , we thus conclude that our most reliable estimate for the distance modulus of hercules is : @xmath112 mag .
in this paper we have presented the first time - series analysis of the hercules ufd . using a variety of telescope / instrument facilities we secured @xmath113 80 and 50 epochs in @xmath1 and @xmath0 .
these data allowed us to detect and characterize 9 rr lyrae stars ( 6 ab- and 3 c - type , respectively ) and one anomalous cepheid .
the same observations allowed us to build a deep cmd extending well beyond the galaxy s half - light radius .
the main results of this study are listed below :    * the average period of the ab - type rr lyrae stars , @xmath2p@xmath1140.68 d , qualifies hercules as an oosterhoff ii system , in good agreement with the vast majority of the ufds investigated so far .
this occurrence favors the hypothesis that the ufds could be the `` building blocks '' of the galactic halo , since the pulsation characteristics of their rr lyrae stars are in agreement with the properties of the mw halo variables .
* hercules cmd is dominated by a stellar population at least as old and metal - poor as the ggc m68 .
this result is in agreement with previous findings .
the hb shows some spread .
we also detected an overabundance of stars above the hb , thus confirming the previous finding by @xcite .
this , along with the detection of an anomalous cepheid very likely belonging to hercules , hints at the possible presence of an intermediate - age population about @xmath93 gyrs old in hercules . *
the spatial distribution of hercules stars confirms the elongated shape of this galaxy .
the signature that hercules is undergoing tidal disruption is provided by the absence of a clearcut difference between galaxy and field star properties , and by the presence of two rr lyrae stars lying well beyond the galaxy s half - light radius . *
the rr lyrae variables were used to obtain independent estimates of the metallicity , reddening and distance to hercules , for which we find [ fe / h]=@xmath115 dex , @xmath6 mag , and @xmath116 mag respectively , in very good agreement with literature values .
we thank an anonymous referee for carefully reading the paper and for providing comments that helped to improve the clarity of the manuscript .
financial support for this research was provided by cofis asi - inaf i/016/07/0 , by the agreement asi - inaf i/009/10/0 , and by prin inaf 2010 , ( p.i .
: g. clementini ) .
support for m.c . is provided by proyecto fondecyt regular # 1110326 ; basal center for astrophysics and associated technologies ( pfb-06 ) ; fondap center for astrophysics ( 15010003 ) ; the chilean ministry for the economy , development , and tourism s programa iniciativa cientfica milenio through grant p07 - 021-f , awarded to the milky way millennium nucleus ; and proyecto anillo act-86 .
has thanks the u.s .
nsf for support under grants ast0607249 and ast0707756 .
adn , d. , feltzing , s. , koch , a. , et al .
2009 , , 506 , 1147 adn , d. , eriksson , k. , feltzing , s. , et al .
2011 , , 525 , a153 baldacci , l. , clementini , g. , held , e.  v. , marconi , m. , & rizzi , l.  2004 , communications in asteroseismology , 145 , 32 belokurov , v. , zucker , d.  b. , evans , n.  w. , et al .
2006 , , 647 , l111 belokurov , v. , zucker , d.  b. , evans , n.  w. , et al .
2007 , , 654 , 897 belokurov , v. , walker , m.  g. , evans , n.  w. , et al .
2010 , , 712 , l103 benedict , g.  f. , mcarthur , b.  e. , feast , m.  w. , et al .  2011 , , 142 , 187 bersier , d. , & wood , p.
r.  2002 , , 123 , 840 blazhko , s. , 1907 , astron . nachr .
175 , 325 buonanno , r. , corsi , c. , bellazzini , m. , ferraro , f. r. , fusi pecci , 1997 , aj , 113 , 706 cacciari , c. , corwin , t. m. , & carney , b. w. 2005 , , 129 , 267 caputo , f. , & deglinnocenti , s.  1995 , , 298 , 833 carretta , e. , cacciari , c. , ferraro , f.  r. , fusi pecci , f. , & tessicini , g.  1998 , , 298 , 1005 carretta , e. , bragaglia , a. , gratton , r. , dorazi , v. , lucatello , s. , 2009 , a&a , 508 , 695 cassisi , s. , potekhin , a.  y. , pietrinferni , a. , catelan , m. , & salaris , m.  2007 , , 661 , 1094 catelan , m. , 2009 , ap&ss 320 , 261 clement & rowe 2000 , aj , 120 , 2579 clementini , g.  2010 , in variable stars , the galactic halo and galaxy formation , eds .
n. samus , c. sterken , l. szabados , sternberg astronomical institute publications , p. 111 , ( arxiv:1002.1575 ) clementini , g. , et al . , 2000 , aj , 120 , 2054 clementini , g. , gratton , r. g. , bragaglia , a. , carretta , e. , di fabrizio , l. , & maio , m. 2003 , aj , 125 , 1309 coleman , m. g. , et al . , 2007 , aj , 134 , 1938 dallora , m. , et al .
2006 , apj 653 , l109 dallora , m. , et al .
2012 , apj , accepted , arxiv:1203.5321 di criscienzo , m. , greco , c. , ripepi , v. , clementini , g. , dallora , m. , marconi , m. , musella , i. , federici , l. , di fabrizio , l. 2011 , , 141 , 81 di criscienzo , m. , marconi , m. , caputo , f. 2004 , apj 612 , 1092 durrell , p.  r. , & harris , w.  e.  1993 , , 105 , 1420 ferraro , f. r. , carretta , e. , corsi , c. e. , fusi pecci , f. , cacciari , c. , buonanno , r. , paltrinieri , b. , & hamilton , d. 1997 , a&a , 320 , 757 frebel , a. , kirby , e.  n. , & simon , j.  d.  2010 , , 464 , 72 giallongo , e. , ragazzoni , r. , grazian , a. , et al .
2008 , , 482 , 349 grado , a. , capaccioli , m. , limatola , l. , & getman , f.  2012 , memorie della societa astronomica italiana supplementi , 19 , 362 gratton , r. g. , carretta , e. , bragaglia , a. , lucatello , s. , dorazi , v. 2010 , a&a , 517 , 81 greco , c. , et al .
2008 , apj 695 , l83 johnson , j. a. , & bolte , m. 1998 , apj , 115 , 693 jurcsik , j. & kovcs , g. 1996 , a&a , 312 , 111 kaluzny , j. , hilditch , r.  w. , clement , c. , & rucinski , s.  m.  1998 , , 296 , 347 kapakos , e. , hatzidimitriou , d. , & soszyski , i.  2011 , , 415 , 1366 kirby , e. n. , simon , j. d. , geha , m. , guhathakurta , p. , & frebel , a. 2008 , apj , 685 , l43 kirby , e.  n. , guhathakurta , p. , bolte , m. , sneden , c. , & geha , m.  c.  2009 , , 705 , 328 kirby , e.  n. , guhathakurta , p. , simon , j.  d. , et al .
2010 , , 191 , 352 klypin , a. , kravtsov , a.  v. , valenzuela , o. , & prada , f.  1999 , , 522 , 82 koch , a. , mcwilliam , a. , grebel , e.  k. , zucker , d.  b. , & belokurov , v.  2008 , , 688 , l13 kuehn , c. , et al .
2008 , apj 674 , l1381 landolt , a.  u.  1992 , , 104 , 340 landolt , a.  u.  2009 , , 137 , 4186 lee , y .- w . , demarque , p. , zinn , r 1994 , apj , 423 , 248 marconi , m. , fiorentino , g. , & caputo , f.  2004 , , 417 , 1101 martin , n. f. , de jong , j. t. a. , rix , h .- w .
2008 , apj 684 , 1075 moore , b. , ghigna , s. , governato , f. , et al .  1999 , , 524 , l19 moretti , m.i . , et al . 2009 ,
apj 699 , l125 morgan , s.  m. , wahl , j.  n. , & wieckhorst , r.  m.  2007 , , 374 , 1421 musella , i. , et al .
2009 , apj 675 , l73 oosterhoff , p.  t.  1939 , the observatory , 62 , 104 pearrubia , j. , navarro , j.  f. , mcconnachie , a.  w. , & martin , n.  f.  2009 , , 698 , 222 piersimoni , a.  m. , bono , g. , & ripepi , v.  2002 , , 124 , 1528 pietrinferni , a. , cassisi , s. , salaris , m. , & castelli , f.  2004 , , 612 , 168 pietrinferni , a. , cassisi , s. , salaris , m. , & castelli , f.  2006 , , 642 , 797 richardson , j.c .
2011 , , 732 , 76 sand , d. j. , olszewski , e. w. , willman , b. , zaritsky , d. , seth , a. , harris , j. , piatek , s. , saha , a. , 2009 , apj , 704 , 898 schlegel , d. j. , finkbeiner , d. p. , & davis , m. 1998 , apj , 500 , 525 schwarzenberg - czerny , a. 1996 , , 460 , l107 simon , j. d. , & geha , m. 2007 , apj , 670 , 313 stetson , p.  b.  1987 , , 99 , 191 stetson , p.  b.  1994 , , 106 , 250 stetson , p.  b.  2000 , , 112 , 925 sturch , c.  1966 , , 143 , 774 tolstoy , e. , hill , v. , tosi , m.  2009 , , 47 , 371 walker , a. r. 1994 , aj , 108 , 555 walker , a.  r.  1998 , , 116 , 220 zinn , r. & west , m. j. 1984 , apjs , 55 , 45