analyses of the impulsive phase of solar flares detected in various electromagnetic wavelength ranges are important for understanding the acceleration and propagation of particles .
the accelerated electrons reveal their presence e.g. in hard x - ray and radio emissions , and cause rapid heating of the chromosphere and subsequent emission in the hydrogen h@xmath1 line .
one of the key questions is the form of the accelerated electron distributions .
their determination from the hard x - ray spectra depends not only on the emission mechanism but also on the processes affecting the propagation of the particles . as suggested by brown , emslie , and kontar ( 2003 ) , it is the mean electron flux distribution @xmath3 depending only on the bremsstrahlung cross section that should be used as a reference for both observational hard x - ray spectral analyses and theoretical models of electron acceleration and propagation .
the mean electron flux distribution can be determined either by inverting the photon spectra ( johns and lin , 1992 ; piana et al . , 2003 ) or by a forward fitting method usually assuming a power - law form of @xmath3 ( holman et  al . , 2003 ) .
observed hard x - ray spectra also contain a contribution of photons backscattered in the photosphere and this will modify the calculated @xmath3 ( bai and ramaty , 1978 ; alexander and brown , 2002 ) .    besides the x - ray emission ,
numerous types of radio emission in the metric and decimetric range are usually observed during flares .
they provide further information about the acceleration and propagation of the electron beams and plasma parameters in the emission region  ( karlick , 1997 ) .    according to standard solar flare models ( e.g. dennis and schwartz , 1989 ) ,
the accelerated electrons provide one of the mechanisms for the flare energy transport from the release site to the lower atmospheric layers .
as the accelerated electrons propagate along the magnetic field lines toward the photosphere , they lose their kinetic energy mainly via coulomb collisions ( brown , 1971 ) in the lower corona and chromospheric layers . the chromospheric response to the beam energy deposition determines the characteristics of optical and uv emission from the flare loops .
numerical models of chromospheric response to pulsed electron beam heating ( e.g. canfield and gayley , 1987 ; heinzel , 1991 ) predict the time correlation of hard x - ray and h@xmath1 emission recently analysed e.g. by trottet et al .
( 2000 ) and wang et al .
their results show that hard x - rays and h@xmath1 intensities in some flare kernels exhibit time correlations in the time range from subseconds to  @xmath210  s.    some flare models ( e.g. heyvaerts , priest , and rust , 1977 ; cargill and priest , 1983 ) and observations ( czaykowska et al . , 1999 )
suggest that h@xmath1 kernels are located between the upflows of the beam heated plasma and the downflows of the cool plasma in the loops disconnected from the reconnection site
. the leading edges of the h@xmath1 emission close to the newly reconnected loops are supposed to be also heated by the accelerated particles , which are detectable e.g. as the hard x - ray sources .
comparison of the spatial distribution of yohkoh hard x - ray sources and h@xmath1 flare kernels was done by e.g. asai et al .
they found that many h@xmath1 kernels brighten successively during the evolution of the flare ribbons , but only a few radiation sources were seen in the hard x - ray images .
they suggest that this discrepancy may be the result of the low dynamic range capability of the yohkoh hard x - ray telescope .    in this paper , we analyse the impulsive phase of the august 20 , 2002 solar flare , which is characterised by a very flat photon spectrum at the x - ray burst maximum ( spectral index @xmath4 ) .
similar flat spectra have been reported , e.g. by nitta , dennis , and kiplinger ( 1990 ) and frnk , hudson , and watanabe ( 1997 ) .
the event presented here is the first such flat spectrum spectrum observed with the high energy resolution of the reuven ramaty high energy solar spectroscopic imager ( rhessi ) ( lin et al . , 2002 ) .
we show the influence of photons backscattered in the photosphere on the determination of the mean electron flux distribution and compare results obtained by inversion and forward fitting methods .
we also study the spatial correlation of h@xmath1 emission and its time changes with hard x - ray sources . in section 2
we describe the global behaviour of the event with regard to hard x - ray and radio fluxes .
sections 3 and 4 present the rhessi , h@xmath1 and magnetic field observations , methods , and results .
finally , the results are discussed in section 5 and the conclusions are given in section 6 .
the analysed flare is well suited for a multi - wavelength study of the electron propagation because its observations provide a set of simultaneous data of comparable time and spatial resolution in the wavelengths directly related to the accelerated particles : rhessi hard x - ray spectra and images , h@xmath1 images ( kanzelhhe observatory ) , and radio and microwave fluxes ( bern , ondejov , and zrich facilities ) .
the flare was detected by goes satellites on august 20 , 2002 .
it started at 08:25  ut and reached its maximum at 08:26  ut as an m3.4 flare .
the 1b h@xmath1 flare was reported in noaa ar 0069 at s10w38 , starting at 08:25  ut , peaking at 08:26  ut , and ending at 08:37  ut .     from the fluxes at 4299  mhz ( ondejov ) and 988  mhz ( zrich ) .
attenuators states a0 , a1 , and a3 and the time interval in which the derivative of h@xmath1 intensity was analysed are indicated by the lines at the top of the rhessi data plot .
the abrupt changes in rhessi flux in the 12  -  25  kev energy band at @xmath2  08:25:17  ut and @xmath2 08:25:41  ut are caused by the attenuator changes ( a0  @xmath5  a1 and a1  @xmath5  a3 , respectively ) at these times.,scaledwidth=94.0% ]    a global overview of the flare evolution in dm / m radio waves and rhessi x - rays is shown in figure  [ fig_hsi_radio ] .
the rhessi flare was first detected at 08:24:32  ut with the increase in flux in the 12  -  25  kev energy band .
then , with some time delays ( at @xmath2  08:24:45  ut ) , bursts in higher and higher energy bands followed . during the starting phase of the x - ray emission at 08:24:30  -  08:25:08
ut , no radio bursts were observed in the dm / m range .
the first weak and narrowband emission ( nbe ) in the dm - range was registered at 08:25:08  ut in the 2000  -  2200  mhz frequency range , followed by the type iii burst below 500  mhz at 08:25:16  ut .    the most energetic part of this flare occurred during the time interval 08:25:15  -  08:25:50  ut , when significant hard x - ray emission was detected up to 7  mev ( see also data from the song instrument on board coronas - f ; myagkova , priv . comm . ) and microwave emission up to 89.4  ghz .
the turn - over frequency between optically thick and thin part of the radio emission was shifted to values between 19.6 and 50  ghz . at that time
the radio emission in the dm - range also reached the maximum and a very fast drifting ( @xmath2  -4000  mhz s@xmath6 ) and short - lasting ( @xmath2  0.1  s ) type iiid burst ( relativistic type iii burst - see poquerusse , 1994 ) was observed in the 400  -  1000  mhz range at 08:25:31.8  ut . in the decimetric range ( 2000  -  4500  mhz )
this phase was characterised by broadband pulsations .
rhessi x - ray data were analysed with the rhessi data analysis software ( hurford et al . , 2002 ; schwartz et al . , 2002 ) . during the flare ,
different attenuators were automatically placed in front of all detectors to absorb soft x - rays and reduce pulse pile - up .
the attenuator states a0 , a1 , and a3 ( no attenuator , thin attenuator , and both thick and thin attenuator , respectively ) are indicated on figure  [ fig_hsi_radio ] .
corrections for the effects of the different attenuator states are available for all times except when the attenuators are moving , a period of @xmath2  1  s.      image reconstruction was performed with both the clean and the pixon algorithms using data from the front segments of the detectors .
detector 7 was used only for the images in the energy bands above 7  kev due to its energy threshold of about 7  kev .
detector 1 and 2 mainly added noise to the images indicating that there was no significant source structure with an angular scale finer than @xmath2 4 arcsecond . therefore , these detectors were excluded .
the clean algorithm was used for obtaining morphology and time evolution of x - ray sources , see sections  [ spatial ] and [ tder ] , figures  [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_low ] , [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_high ] , and [ fig_haderiv_hsi ] .
since there was no source component as large as or larger than fwhm of the detector 8 ( 107  arcsec ) , the imaging fields of view in all clean images were set smaller than this fwhm and consequently detectors 8 and 9 were also not used in the clean image reconstruction .    the pixon algorithm ( puetter and pia 1994 ; metcalf et al . , 1996 )
is known to suppress spurious sources and to have high photometric accuracy ( metcalf et al . , 1996 ;
alexander and metcalf , 1997 ) .
we have used the pixon imaging technique for imaging spectroscopy at the burst maximum , see section  [ flatspectrum ] .
we analysed data summed over the eight front segments .
detector 2 was excluded since its energy threshold is about 20  kev and its energy resolution is about 10  kev .
the data were corrected for pulse pile - up and decimation .
full 2d detector response matrices , each corresponding to the applied attenuator state , were used to convert input photon fluxes to count rates .
the response matrix accounts for the efficiency and resolution of the detectors , the absorption by the attenuators , grids , and all other material above the detectors , and all other known instrumental effects ( smith et al . , 2002 ) .
the time bin for rhessi spectra was 2  s ( @xmath7 a half rotation ) , which ensures that the rapid modulation produced by the grids does not have any distorting effect on the spectra .
the rhessi spectra were analysed in the time interval 08:25:10 - 08:26:00  ut and were fitted from 8  kev up to typically 400  kev , depending on the signal - to - noise ratio .
rhessi data of this flare were contaminated by an electron precipitation starting at 08:16  ut and detected up to 300  kev .
therefore , a special care was taken to estimate the background due to the electron precipitation in the 12  -  300  kev energy range while standard techniques were used at other energies . in the 12  -  40  kev energy range ,
the background was estimated using count rates from the onboard charged particle detector whose lower threshold ( 50  kev ) is generally triggered during electron precipitation events ( smith et al . , 2002 ) .
analysing several precipitation events which occured on other orbits two days before and after the flare , we have found a good correlation between the particle count rate and the front count rate in this energy range .
therefore , count rates from the particle detector can serve as a proxy for the bremsstrahlung of the precipitating electrons as detected by germanium detectors in this energy band .    at higher energies the germanium detector count rates during the precipitation event
are generally dominated by the bremsstrahlung that originates from the electrons interacting in the earth s atmosphere and generally does not follow the time history of the particle count rate ( smith , priv . comm . ) .
having taken this into account , the precipitation component in the 40  -  300  kev energy range was estimated with a cubic fit to the shoulders of the precipitation event detected before and after the flare .
the uncertainty of the estimated precipitation component in the 12  -  300  kev energy range was estimated to be @xmath8 . despite this high value , any residual precipitation component in the background subtracted
count spectra in the 12  -  300  kev energy range is @xmath9 at the edges of the analysed time interval and decreases to several percent with the increasing flare flux .
thus , the precipitation event does not affect our results in the analysed time and energy range .      in order to evaluate the power - law indices of the photon spectra and to make comparisons with previous works
, we adopted a standard photon spectrum model @xmath10 consisting of a double power - law non - thermal component @xmath11 ( e.g. lin and schwartz , 1987 ) and a maxwellian isothermal component @xmath12 : @xmath13 .
@xmath14 where @xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 are the photon energy , the break energy in kev , the power - law index below and above @xmath16 , and @xmath19 is for normalisation , respectively .
we used the forward fitting method and fitted the background subtracted x - ray spectra with the model spectrum @xmath10 .
the model spectrum was convolved with the full 2d detector response matrix to compute the model count spectrum .
parameters of the best fit model were found by searching for a minimum @xmath20 between the measured and the model count rate spectrum .
the lowest value of the power - law index @xmath17 was found at the burst maximum as seen in @xmath21 x - rays , at 08:25:22  ut , when it dropped to 1.8 .
note that this value lies outside of the range of common values of photon power - law index , @xmath22 , as reported e.g. by dennis ( 1985 ) .
the flatness of the spectrum does not result from the contamination by a generally flat spectrum of the precipitation event because the residual precipitation component in the background - subtracted count spectrum was estimated to be @xmath23 in the whole energy range at 08:25:22  ut .
hence , we believe that the flat spectrum is of solar origin .    this conclusion is further supported by the results from the imaging spectroscopy using the pixon imaging method ( hurford et al . , 2002 ) .
rhessi pixon images are constructed by finding the simplest model which is consistent with the counts observed during the time interval .
the model used included a source image and a component that accounts for the counts unmodulated by the grids .
this additional component prevents the unmodulated counts from being included in the source image .
thus , the pixon image is not contaminated by this background and the pixon image reconstruction provides an independent method of determining the spatially integrated flare spectrum .
we reconstructed the pixon images in several energy bands for 4.141  s ( @xmath2  1  spin period ) centred at the burst maximum ( 08:25:22  ut ) and determined a pixon photon spectrum from the total photon fluxes above the 10% contour level of the corresponding pixon image . since the uncertainty in the spectra from the image reconstruction is @xmath210% ( hurford , priv .
comm . ) , and the pixon photon spectrum agrees within uncertainties of the same order with the flat photon spectrum up to 300  kev ( i.e. the highest energy for which the sources were detectable ) , we may conclude that the background subtraction procedure , see section  [ spectroscopy ] , resulted in a solar count spectrum not significantly distorted by the precipitation component .
primary photons with energies larger than 15  kev emitted downwards have a high probability of being reflected due to compton backscattering in the photosphere .
these albedo photons then modify both the spectrum and the intensity of the observed hard x - rays . according to bai and ramaty ( 1978 ) ,
the reflectivity of a power - law photon spectrum from the isotropic source , which is assumed here , is a function of the photon energy and significantly depends on the photon spectral index @xmath24 .
the reflectivity peaks at @xmath25 and increases as @xmath24 decreases . the total photon spectrum , that is the primary one plus the component composed of the reflected photons , is then characterised by a lower @xmath24 than that of the primary spectrum . for a spectral index @xmath26 , the reflected photons at @xmath27  kev can be as high as 80% of the primary flux .
the amount of backscattered photons generally depends on the anisotropy of the primary hard x - ray source and the pitch - angle distribution of the beam electrons .
but , the dependency is rather weak due to strong angular smoothing effect of the bremsstrahlung cross section .
a detailed study of beam electron distributions is out of scope of this paper .
however , the assumption of isotropy of the hard x - ray source provides a lower limit for the photospheric albedo correction .    for this flare we studied the influence of the photospheric albedo correction on the mean electron flux distribution @xmath3 .
we used two approaches .
first , @xmath3 was approximated by a double power - law function @xmath28 where @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 , and @xmath35 are the electron energy , the low - energy cutoff , the break energy , the high - energy cutoff in kev , the power - law index below and above @xmath31 , and normalisation , respectively .
the mean electron flux distribution represents the density weighted electron flux distribution in the source , and its determination is equivalent to the determination of the electron flux distribution assuming thin - target bremsstrahlung @xmath36 ( brown , emslie and kontar , 2003 ) @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the mean intensity in the source volume @xmath39 , @xmath40 is the distance of the emitting source , and @xmath41 is the isotropic cross section for bremsstrahlung ( haug , 1997 ) . using the forward fitting method described in section  [ flatspectrum ] , the background subtracted photon spectra were fitted with a maxwellian isothermal component @xmath12 plus the thin - target bremsstrahlung @xmath42 of the electron flux model @xmath3 and the best - fit values of thermal plasma and electron flux parameters ( the fit provides @xmath43 ) were obtained .
@xmath32 was kept fixed at 7  mev since setting the parameter free did not significantly improve the fits .
second , the mean electron flux distribution function was derived by a regularised inversion procedure ( piana et al . , 2003 ;
kontar et al .
, 2004 , 2005a ) using the photon spectra ( determined with the forward fitting method ) as input .
electron energies were determined in the energy range typically 10  -  400  kev , the upper energy depending on the signal - to - noise ratio .
background subtracted photon spectra were corrected for photospheric albedo using the method of an angle dependent green s function for x - ray compton backscattering ( kontar et al . , 2005b ) , where the green s function represents the probability density of backscattering of a photon of initial energy @xmath44 into the observer s direction with energy @xmath15 .
this approach is independent of the spectral characteristics of the primary photon spectra and allows any form of the primary photon spectra to be deduced , not just a power - law spectrum     statistical plus systematic uncertainties .
best fit to the primary photon flux is composed of the isothermal @xmath45 and thin - target @xmath46 component .
bottom panel compares forward fitted @xmath43 derived from the total ( - - - ) and primary ( height 0.6ex depth -0.4ex width 1.5em ) photon spectrum .
low - energy cutoffs and their standard errors corresponding to the total and primary photon spectrum are @xmath47 and @xmath48 , respectively .
see section  [ comp_ff_inv ] for details on parameter error estimation.,scaledwidth=80.0% ]    as was done e.g. by bai and ramaty ( 1978 ) , and alexander and brown ( 2002 ) .
green s function for a given heliocentric angle ( 40 degrees for this flare ) can be applied to the primary photon spectrum but as a computational convenience we modify the detector response matrix to account for the photospheric albedo . in this way
it can be used straightforwardly in the forward fitting method ( kontar et al . ) because the result of the photon model multiplied by this new modified detector matrix is exactly the same as the result from the original detector matrix multiplied by the product of the albedo and the photon spectrum .
in addition to photospheric albedo , the rhessi x - ray spectra generally contain a component from photons scattered in the earth s atmosphere .
the geometry of rhessi detectors is such that most of the photons scattered in earth atmosphere must first pass through the rear segments ( see figure 1 in smith et al . , 2002 ) . , where the photons are effectively absorbed ( the stopping depth of ge detectors for a photon of 30 kev is @xmath2 1 mm )
thus , only the photons coming from a forward semisphere can get directly into the front segments .
since rhessi is pointed towards the sun , the front segments are shielded by the rear ones from the earth scattered photons all the time when rhessi can see the sun apart from being at the terminator .
the studied flare was observed when rhessi was far from the terminator .
therefore , a correction for the earth albedo photons for actual zenith angle was neglected in the analysis .
the primary photon spectrum ( derived under the assumption of its isotropy ) together with the total photon spectrum at 08:25:22  ut ( burst maximum ) is shown in the top panel of figure  [ elow_albedo ] .
the photon spectra differ mainly below 100  kev , the primary spectrum is slightly steeper , @xmath49 , and exhibits less flattening below 50  kev than the total photon spectrum .
such an albedo correction significantly affects @xmath43 mainly at electron energies below 100  kev .
the bottom panel of figure  [ elow_albedo ] shows that a forward fitted @xmath43 consistent with the total photon spectrum has a high value of @xmath50 , which would represent a gap in energy between the thermal and electrons producing hard x - rays .
however , removing the contribution of the photospheric albedo photons results in a forward fitted @xmath43 with @xmath51 close to the photon energy where the thermal part of the photon spectrum joins the non - thermal part .
consequently , no reliable dip in @xmath43 is found .
the mean electron flux distribution @xmath43 corresponding to the primary photon spectrum at 08:25:22  ut derived from both the forward fitting method and the regularised inversion procedure are shown in the top panel of figure  [ albedo_ff_inv ] .
the ranges of parameter values were determined as a change @xmath52 while keeping the individual parameter fixed , where the level 8.2 encloses the region of joint confidence of 7 parameters with 68% confidence ( lampton , margon and bowyer , 1976 ; press et al . , 1992 ) .
uncertainties of the forward fitted @xmath43 were determined by multiple generations of the forward fit parameters lying within the same level of joint confidence .
@xmath531-@xmath54 limits of the regularised solution were found from multiple inversions of the primary photon flux data perturbed within corresponding statistical and systematic uncertainties .
the inversion method was studied in detail in kontar et al .
( 2004 ) , where various modelled input spectra were analysed .
middle and bottom panels of figure  [ albedo_ff_inv ] represent normalised and cumulative residuals of the primary @xmath55 and modelled photon spectrum @xmath56 .
normalised residuals are defined as @xmath57/\sigma(\epsilon)$ ] , where @xmath58 is the uncertainty in the primary photon spectrum and includes statistical plus systematic uncertainties .
deduced from forward fitting ( height 0.6ex depth -0.4ex width 1.5em ) and inversion ( * - - - * ) method for primary photon spectrum at 08:25:22  ut .
shaded area represents @xmath531-@xmath54 limits on the regularised solution , thin full lines correspond to 68% confidence strip for the forward fit solution . middle and bottom panels show normalised and cumulative residuals of the primary and modelled photon spectrum for the forward fitting method .
thin lines in the bottom panel represent @xmath531-@xmath54 limits for a random walk process .
, scaledwidth=70.0% ]    the error of the albedo correction method is @xmath59 , which is larger than @xmath58 but not included in it .
cumulative residuals are defined as @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is the @xmath62 energy bin used in fitting , and can be used to assess clustering of residuals in certain energy ranges ( piana et al . , 2003 ) .
normalised residuals of the best fit are limited to a 3-@xmath58 interval .
cumulative residuals show minor clustering in the photon energy range 20  -  80kev but they are well below @xmath531-@xmath54 limits of random walk ( @xmath63 ) , see full lines in bottom panel of figure  [ albedo_ff_inv ] . both normalised and cumulative residuals also indicate that assumed systematic uncertainties ( 5% in each energy bin ) are overestimated . adopting a lower value of 3% results in residuals distributed as expected for gaussian statistics with @xmath64 of them above the 1-@xmath54 level , but it does not modify @xmath43 significantly .    , and the low - energy cutoff @xmath30 of the mean electron flux distribution @xmath43 .
attenuator states a0 , a1 , and a3 are indicated by lines at the top of rhessi data plot . for display purposes
the rhessi count flux at the 300  -  500  kev band was scaled by a factor of 2 .
, scaledwidth=94.0% ]    the best forward fit parameters for the primary spectrum are : emission measure @xmath65 , temperature @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , where @xmath72 is @xmath3 integrated from @xmath30 to @xmath32 . several parameters ( @xmath73 , @xmath30 , @xmath74 )
have significantly different , by a factor of 5 , estimates of high and low @xmath54 .
this behaviour is mainly due to the low value of @xmath33 because a decrease in @xmath30 and consequent increase in @xmath74 does not result in significant change in the modelled primary photon spectrum .
the primary photon spectrum is therefore , within uncertainties , consistent also with a mean electron flux distribution function without a low - energy cutoff as derived from the forward fitting method .
large uncertainties in @xmath73 are caused by the small number of data points in the thermal component of the spectrum ( see top panel of figure  [ elow_albedo ] ) .
the mean electron flux distribution deduced from the forward fitting agrees within uncertainties with the regularised solution up to @xmath2  200  kev .
the discrepancy at higher energies is caused by different high - energy cutoffs in the forward fitting and inversion methods .
the regularised solution was cut at 0.5  mev whereas the double power - law @xmath3 extended to @xmath75 .
the large uncertainties between 20 and 40 kev shown in figure  [ albedo_ff_inv ] result from the small number of electrons in this energy range and the fact that the photons are primarily from higher energy electrons .
a similar argument can be used to explain the deviation between the forward fit and regularised solutions above 100 kev .
the high value of @xmath32 used in the forward - fit solution introduces a contribution to the photon flux above 100 kev from the higher energy electrons not included in the regularised electron spectrum .    in the case of the total photon spectrum ,
i.e. without the albedo correction , the regularised solution indicates a dip within 1-@xmath54 limits in the energies below @xmath76  kev where the forward fitted solution resulted in a gap above the thermal component in @xmath77 , see figure  [ elow_albedo ] .
figure  [ fthin_time ] shows the time evolution of derived parameters @xmath33 and @xmath30 of the mean electron flux distribution corresponding to the primary photon spectra .
the power - law index @xmath33 decreases to its minimum of @xmath78 at the burst maximum ,
08:25:22  ut , and its time history generally shows a soft - hard - soft pattern between the photon flux and hardness of the spectra ( e.g. fletcher and hudson , 2002 ) .
low values of @xmath33 indicate a flat electron flux spectrum and this is confirmed by the regularised inversion method .
the low - energy cutoff @xmath30 lies within or close to the energies where the thermal component dominates @xmath77 distribution .
standard errors are of the order of the @xmath30 values .
therefore , no reliable dips or gaps in @xmath77 throughout the time interval could be established .
our analysis shows that the low - energy cutoffs above the energies of the thermal component are likely to be the result of the contribution of photospheric albedo photons and do not exist in real mean electron spectra .
to study the influence of the accelerated electrons on the h@xmath1 emission , we used full - disk h@xmath1 images covering the whole interval of the flare .
the images were acquired using a filter with 0.07  nm fwhm at kanzelhhe solar observatory in austria .
the time resolution of the data is 3  s and the spatial resolution is 2.2  arcsec / pixel .
the position of the solar centre and the spatial resolution were determined using the routines provided by a.  veronig .
details on the method can be found in veronig et al .
( 2000 ) .
the intensities from the flare site were scaled by the averaged quiet - sun area intensity i@xmath79 for every image separately .
the brightest parts of the flare area beginning at 08:25:20  ut are distorted by the saturation of detected intensities .
the saturated pixels are displayed with horizontal lines in the h@xmath1 images ( figures  [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_low ] , [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_high ] , and [ fig_haderiv_hsi ] ) .
the data set was further spatially coaligned using a technique developed for trace and eit data ( gallagher ) .
the cross - correlation of the h@xmath1 data set was done in the area of the nearby sunspot with respect to the chosen h@xmath1 image .
that sunspot area was not affected by the flare .
therefore , we assumed no time change of the h@xmath1 intensities during the analysed time interval in that area . the positional uncertainty of the h@xmath1 images was estimated to be of the order of 1 pixel ( 2.2  arcsec ) .
intensities ( grey scale ) and x - ray emission ( full line contours ) in the 7  -  12  kev ( first column ) and 12  -  25  kev ( second column ) energy ranges .
contours correspond to 50 , 70 , and 90 % of maximum of each rhessi clean image .
there were no detectable x - ray sources in the 12  -  25  kev energy range at 08:24:39  ut ( see the image in the top right corner ) .
mdi magnetic neutral lines are plotted as dashed lines .
the saturated h@xmath1 pixels are displayed with horizontal lines .
, scaledwidth=80.0% ]     intensities ( grey scale ) and x - ray emission ( full line contours ) in the 25  -  40  kev ( first column ) and 40  -  70  kev ( second column ) energy ranges .
contours correspond to 50 , 70 , and 90 % of maximum of each rhessi clean image .
there were no detectable x - ray sources in the 40  -  70  kev energy range at 08:24:48  ut ( see the image in the top right corner ) .
mdi magnetic neutral lines are plotted as dashed lines .
the saturated h@xmath1 pixels are displayed with horizontal lines . , scaledwidth=80.0% ]      the evolution of the hard x - ray sources overlayed with the h@xmath1 emission and mdi magnetic neutral lines is displayed in figures  [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_low ] and [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_high ] .
the rhessi flux was accumulated for 1  spin period ( 4.141  s ) .
the h@xmath1 images correspond to the middle of the rhessi imaging time range .
due to the saturation of the h@xmath1 intensities , the spatial evolution in the flare area is shown to 08:25:20  ut only .    at the very beginning of the flare ( at 08:24:39  ut , figure  [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_low ] ) , a single x - ray source is detected .
then it splits into two ( at 08:24:48  ut , figures  [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_low ] and [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_high ] ) and appears to be moving eastwards . later at 08:25:14  ut
, the x - ray emission starts to shift southwards and the sources split even into three components detectable in the energy range 40  -  70  kev . there is a difference in the positions of hard x - ray sources at lower and higher energy ranges detected at the same time .
the x - ray sources at higher energies tend to be located more to the south than the lower energy x - ray sources ( compare the positions of the sources in different energy bands at 08:25:14  ut and 08:25:20  ut in figures  [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_low ] and [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_high ] ) .
most of x - ray source maxima at energies above 12  kev are not spatially coincident with the brightest parts of the h@xmath1 emission .
rather they tend to be located near the north and eastern edges of the bright h@xmath1 kernels .
the h@xmath1 kernels form a semi - circle whose inner boundary is located near the magnetic neutral line .      to understand better the magnetic field topology near the flare site , the extrapolation of magnetic field in the current - free approximation ( dmoulin et al . , 1997 )
was made using the mdi magnetogram observed at 08:12:30  ut ( see figure  [ fig_mag ] ) .
10 , @xmath53  100 , and @xmath53  400  g ) are expressed by thin full and dashed lines , respectively .
a cut through the region of the neutral magnetic line indicated by the arrow is shown in the sketch in the top right corner ( here sizes of loops are not to scale).,scaledwidth=65.0% ]    the most interesting structure , indicated by an arrow in figure  [ fig_mag ] , is located along the magnetic neutral line , which is delineated by the above mentioned semi - circular h@xmath1 ribbon .
namely , this structure has a quadrupolar character in the sense of papers by uchida ( 1996 ) and hirose and uchida ( 2002 ) , i.e. low altitude loops in the close vicinity of the neutral line are between magnetic field lines with the opposite orientation and all is covered by extended overlying loops .
the preflare activity in the 1550    trace band was observed directly in the centre of the quadrupolar structure ( i.e. above the magnetic neutral line ) at 08:12:20  ut .
however , no 3  -  6  kev x - ray emission was detected by rhessi from this flare site at this time .
comparing figures  [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_low ] , [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_high ] and [ fig_mag ] , it can be seen that the flare started at the north end of this quadrupolar structure .
then the flare kernels appeared at the north - east boundary of the structure and the flare ends at the southern extremity of the quadrupolar structure .
we also note that the h@xmath1 ribbon and x - ray sources are shifted @xmath80  arcsec from the quadrupolar configuration of the extrapolated magnetic field lines .
we assumed that the locations of the optical flare that are directly affected by the electron beams might be recognised as areas of abrupt changes of the h@xmath1 intensity , @xmath81 , on a time scale of the order of seconds .
this assumption is supported e.g. by trottet et al .
( 2000 ) , who found correlation between hard x - ray flux and h@xmath1 intensities on time scales from seconds to tens of seconds .
therefore , the time derivative of @xmath81 may provide a technique to find such areas .
at the location [ 560,-280 ]  arcsec revealing the largest derivative of @xmath81 ( see figure  [ fig_haderiv_hsi ] ) .
thin lines show observed time histories at 3x3 pixel area , @xmath82 correspond to the average over that area , and the thick line is the resulting time history smoothed by 3-point box car .
intensities are scaled by the quiet sun intensity @xmath83 . ]
intensities ( full line contours ) overlayed on h@xmath1 images ( grey scale ) .
contours correspond to @xmath84 and @xmath85 of @xmath86 .
rhessi clean images at 25  -  40  kev and 40  -  70  kev are plotted as dotted and dashed contours at 50 and 90 % of maximum of each image .
the saturated h@xmath1 pixels are displayed with horizontal lines.,scaledwidth=78.0% ]    in order to suppress the effects of seeing and/or incorrect positions , h@xmath1 intensities were averaged over a @xmath87 pixel area and the resulting lightcurves were smoothed by a 3-point box car ( 9 s time resolution ) .
such smoothing was necessary to distinguish between the real changes and those which occurred randomly throughout the whole flare area .
the effects of the averaging and smoothing are shown in figure  [ fig_ha_time ] . due to the saturation of h@xmath1 data beginning at 08:25:20  ut , the time derivative of h@xmath1 intensity , @xmath86 ,
was studied in the time interval 08:24:33  -  08:25:20  ut ( see also the label in figure  [ fig_hsi_radio ] ) .
the maximum of @xmath86 was @xmath88 .
a threshold , @xmath89 , was estimated by fitting @xmath86 distribution outside of the flare area with the gauss distribution .
the threshold corresponds to 10 standard deviations from the mean of the fit and was adopted as the level of the reliable value of @xmath86 not affected by noise or seeing .
the locations of @xmath90 are displayed on figure  [ fig_haderiv_hsi ] together with the rhessi clean images in the 25  -  40  kev and 40  -  70  kev energy bands .
x - ray sources in the 40  -  70  kev energy band are not shown in figure  [ fig_haderiv_hsi](a ) since no source at this energy band was detectable at that time .
these energy bands were chosen for comparison with @xmath86 for two reasons .
first , they were above the energies where the thermal component dominates x - ray emission , i.e. @xmath91 . secondly , the electrons bombarding the chromosphere need to have an energy greater than 25  kev to penetrate into the layers of h@xmath1 formation , e.g. in the f1 flare model by machado et al .
the rhessi clean images were reconstructed from data accumulated in 1  spin period .
the centre of each rhessi time interval corresponds to the observational times of h@xmath1 and @xmath86 .
the sites of the fast h@xmath1 intensity changes located in the northern part of the flare lie on the boundaries or inside of x - ray sources in the 25  -  40  kev and/or 40  -  70  kev energy range ( see figures  [ fig_haderiv_hsi](b ) and ( c ) ) .
however , we have found other areas that reveal abrupt changes in h@xmath1 intensity but are located well away from x - ray emission ( e.g. figure  [ fig_haderiv_hsi](a ) ) .
some of these areas even precede the position of x - ray emission as it moves to the south in time ( figures  [ fig_haderiv_hsi](c ) and ( d ) ) . the difference in the locations of @xmath86 and the x - ray sources
can not be explained by a spatial correlation with the x - ray sources at lower or higher energies .
there is no significant shift of the x - ray sources in the energy ranges from 3  -  7  kev to 7  -  12  kev or from 40  -  70  kev to higher energy bands ; the sources at energies from 7 to 25  kev are not located closer to the @xmath86 ( see figures  [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_low ] and [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_high ] ) either .    the fact that at 08:25:20  ut there are no locations of @xmath90 along the whole flare area may be the result of the saturation of the h@xmath1 data at this time ( areas covered by horizontal lines in figure  [ fig_haderiv_hsi ] ) .
although the described analysis technique does not eliminate the saturated pixels , they only affect the adjacent pixels and cause a decrease in @xmath86 .
the photon spectrum at the burst maximum of the august 20 , 2002 flare is , to our knowledge , the flattest ( @xmath0 ) yet detected by rhessi with its high energy resolution . to eliminate any distortion of the spectra ,
the background subtraction also included the estimation of the electron precipitation component , which has been done for the rhessi data for the first time .
the solar origin of such an unusually flat spectrum was confirmed by a comparison with the spectrum constructed from the rhessi pixon images .    using a new method of the photospheric albedo correction independent of the spectral form of the primary spectrum , we have proved the importance of the photospheric albedo correction in the case of the analysed flare .
we have shown that in this case of flat x - ray spectra , the photospheric albedo significantly affects the determination of the mean electron flux distribution @xmath43 , mainly the value of the low - energy cutoff .
the contamination of the flare spectra by the photospheric albedo photons may result in dips in @xmath43 indicated both by the forward fitting and inversion methods .
such dips could be misinterpreted as spectral features inherent to the acceleration / propagation processes of the energetic particles in the solar flares .
flares of flat hard x - ray spectra ( @xmath92 ) were previously analysed e.g. by nitta , dennis , and kiplinger ( 1990 ) and frnk , hudson , and watanabe ( 1997 ) .
all of these flares have weak thermal components ( goes class m3 or lower ) but intense non - thermal components up to several hundred kev with a flat part extending down to @xmath93  kev .
as was shown here , such photon spectra may correspond to a flat electron flux distribution with the low - energy cutoff close to the energy of the thermal electrons .    for the flares with spectral index around 3 it is the low - energy cutoff which determines the total energy content in the flare .
this happens when the largest contribution comes from the low energy particles .
however , for the flares with flat spectra @xmath94 it is not the case . assuming the collisional thick - target scenario ( brown 1971 )
, one can estimate the energy flux of the non - thermal electrons injected into the plasma . in this model , the injected electron flux distribution @xmath95}$ ]
is related to @xmath3 of equation  ( [ ffthin ] ) as ( brown and emslie , 1988 ) @xmath96 relative change of the non - thermal energy flux @xmath97}$ ] can be expressed @xmath98 adopting the spectral index @xmath99 and the low - energy cutoffs , @xmath100  kev , @xmath101  kev , consistent with the inferred flat spectrum , the ratio is @xmath102 .
thus , due to the flatness of @xmath43 , the low values of the low - energy cutoff do not cause a significant increase in the non - thermal energy flux .
the flat distribution function of non - thermal electrons , especially at low energies , implies that its derivative in the energy as well as in the velocity space is close to zero or even positive .
such a distribution function can be formed directly in the acceleration region ( e.g. by the acceleration in the direct electric field
holman , 1985 ) and/or modified by propagation effect , particle collisions in dense plasma , and by interactions of accelerated electrons with plasma waves ( melnik and kontar , 2003 ) . if the plasma waves are generated , then the radio emission can be observed at high frequencies , as in our case . however , detailed conditions in the radio source needed to confirm this idea are not known to us .    our analysis of the characteristics of the hard x - ray sources and the h@xmath1 and radio emission revealed several facts about the flare process .
first , the presented flare was weak in the metric range during the whole event , except for the short - lasting relativistic type iii burst ( radio manifestation of relativistic electrons ; klassen , karlick ' y , and mann , 2003 ) .
it resembles the march  6 , 1989 @xmath24-ray flare , which started as silent in radio waves below 800  mhz .
similarly to rieger , treumann , and karlick ( 1999 ) , we explain the lack of metric radio emission by closed geometry of the magnetic structure and a low altitude of the flare process .
additionally , the high value of the turn - over frequency , 19.6 - 50  ghz , of the radio emission indicates a strong magnetic field or a large depth of the emitting source ( benka and holman , 1992 ) , thus supporting this conclusion .
furthermore , the coalignment of the h@xmath1 and hard x - ray images with the magnetic field extrapolation shows that both the h@xmath1 kernels and the hard x - ray sources are located at the footpoints of the low altitude magnetic loops which are the part of the quadrupolar structure ( figure  [ fig_mag ] ) .
second , our results concerning the time and spatial correlation of the hard x - ray sources and h@xmath1 emission are partly in agreement with the prediction of solar flare models .
we have found that most of the x - ray emission maxima , mainly those at the energies above 12  kev ( corresponding to the x - ray emission of the non - thermal electrons ) , tend to be located on the northern and eastern edges of the h@xmath1 emission ( see figures  [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_low ] and [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_high ] ) .
this is consistent with the expectation that x - ray sources should be located on the external edges of h@xmath1 ribbons and similar to those reported by czaykowska et al .
( 1999 ) .
flare models also suggest that fast changes of h@xmath1 intensities might be located at positions of x - ray sources , i.e. at the areas which are bombarded by the suprathermal electrons . in some cases ,
this suggestion is confirmed by our analysis .
however , at some times the positions of the fast changes of h@xmath1 intensities do not spatially coincide with the x - ray sources ( see southern locations of @xmath86 in the bottom row of figure  [ fig_haderiv_hsi ] ) .
we propose that such h@xmath1 brightenings might be caused either by thermal conduction from a hot plasma located above , or by soft x - ray irradiation .
using the lowest energy ranges of rhessi ( 3  -  7  kev ) , we tried to find such a hot plasma at these places , but without any success .
however , we must point out that the time resolution of @xmath86 was 9  s. therefore to confirm the existence of these areas , more analyses and better quality data are needed .
finally , the time evolution of the positions of the hard x - ray sources may indicate the movement of the reconnection site .
this can be seen e.g. at 08:25:14  ut ( figures  [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_low ] and [ fig_ha_hsi_mdi_high ] ) when the hard x - ray sources of different energies are distributed along the h@xmath1 ribbon in such a way that the sources of higher energy are located further to the south - east direction .
such difference in the positions could be expected in a single flare loop when it would correspond to the height distribution of the hard x - ray sources along the loop as found in aschwanden , brown , and kontar ( 2002 ) .
however , this is not the case here because the extrapolation of the magnetic field shows no magnetic loop along the h@xmath1 ribbon .
the displacement of the h@xmath1 ribbon and x - ray sources from the quadrupolar configuration is not due to the positional errors in the h@xmath1 , mdi , and rhessi images , which are a factor of 2 and 4 smaller , respectively .
the offset could be caused by neglecting the electric currents in the current - free extrapolation .
although the linear force - free extrapolations show similar results , we can not exclude the presence of localised currents which deform the magnetic field structure .
we have demonstrated that the influence of the photospheric albedo on solar flare x - ray spectra must be considered in order to correctly assess the models of electron acceleration and propagation and generation of hard x - ray emission .
the inferred flat mean electron flux distribution could be the result of the acceleration process and/or modified by particle - wave interactions .
this explanation , however , remains speculative .
the accumulated information from the multi - wavelength observations of this flare shows that the flare process took place in the low altitude magnetic loops .
our analysis of h@xmath1 emission may indicate that the response of the lower atmosphere to the flare energy release is not restricted to the sites of propagation of the accelerated electrons .
one of the authors , jk , would like to give special thanks to the rhessi team at gsfc for their help and support during her stay there .
we are thankful to w.  otruba ( kanzelhhe solar observatory , austria ) and a.  veronig for providing h@xmath1 data and for valuable discussion on their analysis .
we also thank t.  metcalf for help with the pixon reconstruction , d.  zarro for preprocessing trace data , and p.  dmoulin for providing his code for the magnetic field extrapolation .
furthermore , we thank p.  messmer and t. lthi for the zrich and bern radio data , respectively .    this work was supported by nato science fellowships programme , the contract nas5 - 01160 , the grants iaa3003202 and iaa3003203 of the academy of sciences of the czech republic , the grants 205/02/0980 and 205/04/0358 of the grant agency of the czech republic , and the projects k2043105 and av0z10030501 of the astronomical institute .
aschwanden , m.  j. , brown , j.  c. , and kontar , e.  p. : 2002 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 210 * , 383 .
alexander , d. and metcalf , t.  r. : 1997 , _ apj _ , * 489 * , 422 .
alexander , r.  c. and brown , j.  c. : 2002 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 210 * , 407 .
asai , a. , masuda , s. , yokoyama , t. , shimojo , m. , isobe , h. , kurokawa , h. , and shibata , k. : 2002 , _ apjl _ , * 578 * , l91 bai , t. and ramaty , r. : 1978 , _ apj _ , * 219 * , 705 .
benka , s.  g. and holman , g.  d. : 1992 , _ apj _ , * 391 * , 854 .
brown , j.  c. : 1971 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 18 * , 489 .
brown , j.  c. and emslie , a.  g. : 1988 , _ apj _ , * 331 * , 554 .
brown , j.  c. , emslie , a.  g. and kontar , e.  p. : 2003
, _ apj _ , * 595 * , l115 cargill , p.
j. and priest , e.  r. : 1983 , _ apj _ , * 266 * , 383 canfield , r.  c. and gayley , k.  g. : 1987 , _ apj _ , 363 , 1999 czaykowska , a. , de pontieu , b. , alexander , d. , and rank , g. : 1999 , _ apj _ , * 521 * , l75 .
dmoulin , p. , bagal , l.  g. , mandrini , c.  h. , hnoux , j.  c. , and rovira , m.  g. : 1997 , _ astron . astrophys .
_ , * 325 * , 305 .
dennis , b.  r. : 1985 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 100 * , 465 .
dennis , b.  r. and schwartz , r.  a. : 1989 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 121 * , 75 .
frnk , f. , hudson , h. , and watanabe , t : 1997 , _ astron .
_ , * 320 * , 620 fletcher , l. and hudson , h. : 2002 , _ solar phys . _ , * 210 * , 307 .
haug , e. : 1997 , _ astron .
_ , * 326 * , 417 .
heinzel , p. : 1991 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 135 * , 65 . heyvaerts , j. , priest , e.  r. , and rust , d.  m. : 1977 , _ apj _ , * 216 * , 123 .
hirose , s. and uchida , y. : 2002 , in p.  c.  h.  martens and d.  p.  cauffman ( eds ) , _ multi - wavelenght observations of coronal structure and dynamics _
, yohkoh 10th anniversary meeting , p. 181 .
holman , g.  d. : 1985 , _ apj _ , * 293 * , 584 .
holman , g.  d. , sui , l. , schwartz , r.  a. , and emslie , a.  g. : 2003 , _ apj _ , * 595 * , l97 .
hurford , g.  j. , schmahl , e.  j. , schwartz , r.  a. , conway , a.  j. et al . : 2002 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 210 * , 61
. johns , ch .
m. and lin , r.  p. : 1992
, _ solar phys .
_ , * 137 * , 121 .
klassen , a. , karlick , m. , and mann , g. : 2003 , _ astron .
_ , * 410 * , 307 .
karlick , m. : 1997 , _ space science rev .
_ , * 81 * , 143 .
kontar , e.  p. , piana , m. , massone , a.  m. , emslie , a.  g. , and brown , j.  c. : 2004 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 225 * , 293 .
kontar , e.  p. , emslie , a.  g. , piana , m. , massone , a.  m. , and brown , j.  c. : 2005a , _ solar phys .
_ , * 226*. 317 .
kontar , e.  p. , mackinnon , a.  l. , schwartz , r.  a. , and brown , j.  c. : 2005b , _ apj _ , submitted .
lampton , m. , margon , b. , and bowyer , s. : 1976 , _ apj _ , * 208 * , 177 .
lin , r.  p. and schwartz , r.  a. : 1987 , _ apj _ , * 312 * , 462 .
lin , r.  p.
et al . : , 2002 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 210 * , 3 .
machado , m.  e. , avrett , e.  h. , vernazza , j.  e. , and moyes , r.  w. : 1980 , _ astron .
_ , * 242 * , 336 .
melnik , v.n . and kontar , e.p .
: 2003 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 215 * , 335 .
metcalf , t.r . ,
hudson , h.  s. , kosugi , t. , puetter , r.  c. , and pia , r.  k. : 1996 , _ apj _ , * 466 * , 585 .
nitta , n. , dennis , b.  r. , and kiplinger , a.  l. : 1990 , _ apj _ , * 353 * , 313 piana , m. , massone , a.  m. , kontar , e.  p. , emslie , a.  g. , brown , j.  c. , and schwartz , r.  a. : 2003 , _ apj _ , * 595 * , l127 .
poquerusse , m. : 1994 , _ astron .
astrophys . _ * 286 * , 611 . press , w.  h. , teukolsky , s.  a. , vetterling , w.  t. , and flannery , b.  p. : 1992
, _ numerical recepies in c : the art of scientific computing _ , 2nd ed . , cambridge university press , p. 684 puetter , r.  c.   and pia , r.  k. : 1994 , _ experimental astronomy _
, * 3 * , 293 .
rieger , e. , treumann , r.  a. , and karlick , m. : 1999 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 187 * , 59 .
schwartz , r.  a. , csillaghy , a. , tolbert , a.  k. , hurford , g.  j. , mctiernan , j. , and zarro , d. : 2002 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 210 * , 165 .
smith , d.  m. et al . : 2002 , _ solar phys .
_ , * 210 * , 33 .
trottet , g. , rolli , e. , magun , a. , barat , c. , kuznetsov , a. , sunyaev , r. , and terekhov , o. : 2000 , _ astron .
_ , * 356 * , 1067 .
uchida , y. : 1996 , _ adv .
space res . _
* 17 * , 19 .
veronig , a. , steinegger , m. , otruba , w. , hanslmeier , a. , messerotti , m. , temmer , m. , gonzi , s. , and brunner , g. : 2000 , _ hvar .
obs . bull .
_ , * 24 * , no . 1 , 195 .
wang , h. , qiu , j. , denker , c. , spirock , t. , chen , h. , and goode , p.  r. : 2000 , _ apj _ , * 542 * , 1080 .


the equilibrium ( thermodynamic ) isotope effect ( eie ) is defined as the effect of isotopic substitution on the equilibrium constant . denoting an isotopolog with a lighter ( heavier ) isotope by a subscript _
( _ h _ ) , the eie is defined as the ratio of equilibrium constants@xmath6 where @xmath7 _ _ _ _ and @xmath8 are molecular partition functions per unit volume of reactant and product .
we study a specific case of eie - the equilibrium ratio of two isotopomers . in this case , the eie is equal to the equilibrium constant of the isotopomerization reaction , @xmath9 where superscripts _
r _ and _ p _ refer to reactant and product isotopomers , respectively .
usually , equilibrium isotope effects are computed only approximately:@xcite in particular , effects due to indistinguishability of particles and rotational and vibrational contributions to the eie  are treated separately .
furthermore , the vibrational motion is approximated by a simple harmonic oscillator and the rotational motion is approximated by a rigid rotor . in general ,
none of the contributions , not even the indistinguishability effects can be separated from the others.@xcite however , at room temperature or above the nuclei can be accurately treated as distinguishable , and the indistinguishability effects can be almost exactly described by symmetry factors . on the other hand
, the effective coupling between rotations and vibrations , anharmonicity of vibrations , and non - rigidity of rotations can in fact become more important at higher temperatures .
for simplicity , from now on we denote these three effects together as  anharmonicity effects  and the approximation that neglects them the  harmonic approximation  ( ha ) . in some cases
the effects of anharmonicity of the born - oppenheimer potential surface on the value of eie can be substantial.@xcite ishimoto _
_ have shown that the isotope effect on certain barrier heights can even have opposite signs , when calculated taking anharmonicity effects into account and in the ha.@xcite    our goal is to describe rigorously equilibria at room temperature or above .
therefore , two approximations that we make are the born - oppenheimer approximation and the distinguishable particle approximation ( we treat indistinguishability by appropriate symmetry factors ) .
the error due to the born - oppenheimer approximation was studied for h / d eie by bardo and wolfsberg,@xcite and by kleinman and wolfsberg,@xcite and was shown to be of the order of 1 % in most studied cases . since we assume that nuclei are point charges , the born - oppenheimer approximation implies that the potential energy surface is the same for the two isotopomers .
the differences of born - oppenheimer surfaces due to differences of nuclear volume and quadrupole of isotopes can be important for heavy elements@xcite , but these are not studied in this work .
symmetry factors themselves result in an eie equal to a rational ratio , which can be computed analytically . in order to separate the symmetry contributions from the mass contributions to the eie , it is useful to introduce the reduced reaction free energy,@xmath10 where @xmath11 and @xmath12 are the symmetry factors discussed in more detail in sec .
[ sec : examples ] . to include the effects of quantization of nuclear degrees of freedom beyond the ha rigorously we use the feynman path integral representation ( pi ) of the partition function . the quantum reduced reaction free energy
can then be computed by thermodynamic integration with respect to the mass of the isotopes . to compute the derivative of the free energy efficiently
, we use a generalized virial estimator .
the advantage of this estimator is that its statistical error does not increase with the number of imaginary time slices in the discretized path integral .
as a consequence , converged results can be obtained in a significantly shorter simulation than with other estimators .
the ultimate goal would be to combine the path integral methodology with _ ab initio _ potentials .
however , since millions of samples are required , the computational expense results in the following  compromise :  first , the equilibrium isotope effects are computed using _ ab initio _ potentials , but as usual , within the ha . then all anharmonicity corrections are computed using the pi methodology , but with semiempirical potentials .
in other words , we take advantage of the higher accuracy of the _ ab initio _ potentials to compute the harmonic contribution to the eie and then make an assumption that the anharmonicity effects are similar for _ ab initio _ and semiempirical potentials .    after describing theoretical features of the method
, we apply it to hydrocarbons used in experimental measurements of isotope effects on [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen transfer reactions .
two of them were recently used by doering _
@xcite who reported equilibrium ratios of their isotopomers .
this allows us to validate our calculations as well as to discuss the apparent discrepancy in measurements of doering _ et al .
_ from a theoretical point of view .
the outline of the paper is as follows : in sec .
[ sec : method ] , we describe a rigorous quantum - mechanical methodology to compute the eie . section [ sec : examples ] presents the [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen shift reactions on which we test the methodology , explains how _ ab initio _ methods can be combined with the pi  to compute the eie , and discusses in detail symmetry effects in these reactions .
section [ sec : computational - details ] explains the implementation of the method in amber 10 and describes details of calculations and error analysis of our pimd simulations .
results of calculations are presented and compared with experiments in sec .
[ sec : results ] .
section [ sec : discussion - and - conclusions ] concludes the paper .
eie can be calculated by a procedure of thermodynamic integration@xcite with respect to the mass .
this method takes advantage of the relationship@xmath13,\label{eq : ti}\ ] ] where @xmath14 is the ( quantum ) free energy and @xmath15 is a parameter which provides a smooth transition between isotopomers @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
this can be accomplished , e.g. , by linear interpolation of masses of all atoms in a molecule according to the equation @xmath18 in contrast to the partition function itself , the integrand of eq .
@xmath19 is a thermodynamic average and therefore can be computed by either monte carlo or molecular dynamics simulations .
classically , the eie is trivial and eq . can be evaluated analytically .
when quantum effects are important , this simplification is not possible . to describe quantum thermodynamic effects rigorously
, one can use the path integral formulation of quantum mechanics.@xcite in the path integral formalism , thermodynamic properties are calculated exploiting the correspondence between matrix elements of the boltzmann operator and the quantum propagator in imaginary time.@xcite in the last decades , path integrals proved to be very useful in many areas of quantum chemistry , most recently in calculations of heat capacities,@xcite rate constants,@xcite kinetic isotope effects,@xcite or diffusion coefficients.@xcite    let @xmath20  be the number of atoms , @xmath21 the number of spatial dimensions , and @xmath22 the number of imaginary time slices in the discretized pi ( @xmath23 gives classical mechanics , @xmath24 gives quantum mechanics ) .
then the pi representation of the partition function @xmath25 in the born - oppenheimer approximation is @xmath26,\label{eq : pi_qr}\\ c & \equiv\left(\frac{p}{2\pi\hbar^{2}\beta}\right)^{npd/2}\prod_{i=1}^{n}m_{i}^{pd/2}.\label{eq : pi_prefactor}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath27 is the set of cartesian coordinates associated with the @xmath28@xmath29 time slice , and @xmath30 is the effective potential @xmath31 the @xmath22 particles representing each nucleus in @xmath22 different imaginary time slices are called `` beads . ''
each bead interacts via harmonic potential with the two beads representing the same nucleus in adjacent time slices and via potential @xmath32 attenuated by factor @xmath33 with beads representing other nuclei in the same imaginary time slice . by straightforward differentiation of eq .
we obtain the so - called thermodynamic estimator ( te),@xcite @xmath34 a problem with expression is that its statistical error grows with the number of time slices .
a similar behavior is a well known property of the thermodynamic estimator for energy,@xcite where the problem is caused by the kinetic part of energy .     of imaginary time slices in the path integral .
all results obtained by 1 @xmath35 long simulations ( with the time step 0.05 @xmath36 ) of compound * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * ( @xmath38 ) using gaff force field , normal mode pimd , and nos - hoover chains of thermostats . [
fig : gve_te_values ] ]       of imaginary time slices in the path integral .
all results obtained by 1 @xmath35 long simulations ( with the time step 0.05 @xmath36 ) of compound * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * ( @xmath38 ) using gaff force field , normal mode pimd , and nos - hoover chains of thermostats .
note that the rmse of the gve is not only non - increasing ( as expected from theory ) , but in fact decreases slightly with increasing @xmath22 , which is due to the decrease of correlation length.[fig : gve_te_errors ] ]    the growth of statistical error of the thermodynamic estimator for energy is removed by expressing the estimator only in terms of the potential and its derivatives using the virial theorem.@xcite in our case , a similar improvement can be accomplished , if a coordinate transformation , @xmath39 is introduced into eq . prior to performing the derivative . here
, the `` centroid '' coordinate is defined as    @xmath40    in other words , first the `` centroid '' coordinate @xmath41 is subtracted , and then the coordinates are mass - scaled . resulting generalized virial estimator ( gve)@xcite takes the form    @xmath42 .
\label{eq : gve}\ ] ]    its primary advantage is that the root mean square error ( rmse ) of the average , @xmath43 , is approximately independent on the number of imaginary time slices @xmath22,@xmath44 in this equation @xmath45 denotes the length of the simulation and @xmath46 is the correlation length .
the convergence of values and statistical errors of both estimators as a function of number @xmath22 of imaginary time slices for systems studied in this paper is discussed in section [ sec : computational - details ] .
as expected , up to the statistical error they give the same values as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : gve_te_values ] . nevertheless , when quantum effects are important , and a high value of @xmath22 must be used , the gve is the preferred estimator since it has much smaller statistical error and therefore converges much faster than the te ( see fig .
[ fig : gve_te_errors ] ) .
thermodynamic average in eq . can be evaluated efficiently using the path integral monte carlo ( pimc ) or path integral molecular dynamics ( pimd ) . in pimc ,
gradients of @xmath47 in eq .
result in additional calculations since the usual metropolis monte carlo procedure for the random walk only requires the values of @xmath47 .
this additional cost can be , however , reduced either by less frequent sampling , or by using a trick in which the total derivative with respect to @xmath15 ( not the gradients ! ) is computed by finite difference.@xcite in case of pimd , the presence of gradients of @xmath47 in eq .
does not slow down the calculation since forces are already computed by a propagation algorithm .
although in principle , a pimc algorithm for a specific problem can always be at least as efficient as a pimd algorithm , in practice it is much easier to write a general pimd algorithm and so pimd is usually the algorithm used in general software packages .
since pimd was implemented in amber 9,@xcite we have implemented the methodology described above for computing eies into amber 10.@xcite this implementation is what was used in calculations in the following sections . in pimd , equation is augmented by fictitious classical momenta @xmath48 ,    @xmath49.\label{eq : pi_qp}\ ] ]    the normalization prefactor @xmath50 is chosen in such a way that the original prefactor @xmath51 in eq . is reproduced when the momentum integrals in eq .
are evaluated analytically .
the partition function is formally equivalent to the partition function of a classical system of cyclic polyatomic molecules with harmonic bonds .
each such molecule represents an individual atom in the original molecule and interacts with molecules representing other atoms via a potential derived from the potential of the original molecule.@xcite this system can be studied directly using well developed methods of the classical molecular dynamics .
it is useful to see how the general path integral expressions , , and behave in the low and high temperature limits . as temperature decreases ,
the difference of the reduced free energies of isotopomers approaches the difference of their zero point energies ( zpes ) .
therefore , still assuming that indistinguishability is correctly described by symmetry factors , the low temperature limit of the eie is equal to @xmath52,\label{eq : eie_low_temp}\ ] ] where @xmath53 denotes the zpe .
at high temperature , the system approaches its classical limit . in this limit
, we can set the number of imaginary time slices @xmath23 , and the eie can be computed analytically using partition function , which becomes@xmath54.\end{split}\label{eq : q_class}\ ] ] again , for isotopomers the mass dependent factors cancel out upon substitution into eq . , along with all other terms except for the integrals .
although the born - oppenheimer potential surface is the same for all isotopomers , the integrals do not cancel out since the integration is not performed over the whole configuration space , but only over parts attributed to reactants or products .
particles are treated as distinguishable in the classical limit and the volumes of the configuration space corresponding to reactants and products are generally different .
after the reduction , eie becomes exactly equal to the ratio of the symmetry factors ,    @xmath55
we examine the eie for four related compounds . the parent compound ( 3__z__)-penta-1,3-diene ( compound * 1 * ) is the simplest molecule to model the [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen shift reaction .
two of its isotopologs , tri - deuterated ( 3__z__)-(5,5,5-@xmath56h@xmath37)penta-1,3-diene ( * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * ) and di - deuterated ( 3__z__)-(1,1-@xmath56h@xmath5)penta-1,3-diene ( * 1 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * ) ( see fig . [
fig : equlibrium_pent ] ) were used by roth and knig to measure an unusually high value of the kinetic isotope effect ( kie ) on the [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift reaction with respect to the substitution of hydrogen by deuterium.@xcite this result pointed to a significant role of tunneling in [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen transfer reactions .
subsequently , much theoretical research was devoted to the study of this reaction .
here we calculate final equilibrium ratios of products of this reaction , which , to our knowledge , were not theoretically predicted so far .
hydrogen shift reaction in ( 3__z__)-(5,5,5-@xmath56h@xmath37)penta-1,3-diene ( * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * ) and in ( 3__z__)-(1,1-@xmath56h@xmath5)penta-1,3-diene ( * 1 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * ) .
if all contributions except for those due to symmetry factors @xmath58 and @xmath59 were neglected , one would obtain approximate equilibrium constants @xmath60 and @xmath61 in both cases.[fig : equlibrium_pent ] ]    two other compounds , 2-methyl-10-(10,10-@xmath56h@xmath5)methylenebicyclo[4.4.0]dec-1-ene ( * 2 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * ) and 2,4,6,7,9-pentamethyl-5-(5,5-@xmath56h@xmath5)methylene-11,11a - dihydro-12_h_-naphthacene ( * 3 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * ) ( see fig . [
fig : equilibria_cyclic ] ) , were recently used by doering _
_ to confirm and possibly refine the experimental value of the kie on the [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift.@xcite in contrast to ( 3__z__)-penta-1,3-diene * * ( * * compound * 1 * ) , where the s-_trans _ conformer incompetent of the [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift is the most stable , pentadiene moiety in compounds 2 and 3 is locked in the s-_cis _ conformation .
this not only increases the reaction rate , but also rules out the ( very small ) effect of the eie on the kie due to the shift in s-_cis_/s-_trans _ equilibrium . for both molecules doering _
et al . _ reported final equilibrium ratios of isotopomers . despite the similarity of compounds
* 2 * and * 3 * , these ratios are qualitatively different . indeed ,
one motivation for measuring eie in compound * 3 * was that doering _ et al . _
suspected that in the case of * 2 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * the equilibrium ratio might be modified by unwanted side reactions , mainly dimerizations .
one of our goals is to elucidate this discrepancy from the theoretical point of view .        as can be seen in figs .
[ fig : equlibrium_pent ] and [ fig : equilibria_cyclic ] , the final equilibrium of the [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift reaction of all examined compounds can be described as an outcome of two reactions .
the second reaction ( leading from deuterio - methyl - dideuterio - methylene to dideuterio - methyl - deuterio - methylene in tri - deuterated compounds and from dideuterio - methyl - methylene to deuterio - methyl - deuterio - methylene in di - deuterated compounds ) produces a mixture of species that differ by the orientation of the mono - deuterated methylene group . due to a high barrier for rotation of this group
, the two products can not be properly sampled in a single pimd simulation .
therefore an additional pimd simulation is necessary , as shown on the example of * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * in fig .
[ fig : pimd-3steps - pent ] .
the reduced free energy of the second step is then calculated as @xmath62,\label{eq : f_red_2step_pimd}\ ] ] where 1/2 is the ratio of symmetry factors and @xmath63 and @xmath64 stand for equilibrium constants obtained by the second and third pimd simulations , respectively .
together they represent the second reaction step .     hydrogen shift reaction in ( 3__z__)-(5,5,5-@xmath56h@xmath37)penta-1,3-diene ( * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * ) .
half white , half black spheres represent deuterium atoms .
the methyl group , in contrast to methylene , rotates during simulations .
[ fig : pimd-3steps - pent ] ]      unfortunately , at present the pimd method can not be used in conjunction with higher level _ ab initio _ methods , due to a high number of potential energy evaluations needed .
semiempirical methods , which can be used instead , do not achieve comparable accuracy .
we therefore make the following two assumptions : first , we assume that the main contribution to the eie can be calculated in the framework of ha .
second , we assume that selected semiempirical methods are accurate enough to reliably estimate the anharmonicity correction
. the anharmonicity correction is calculated as @xmath65 with these two assumptions , we can take advantage of both pimd and higher level methods by adding the semiempirical anharmonicity correction to the ha result calculated by a more accurate method .
the ha value of @xmath66 is obtained by boltzmann averaging over all possible distinguishable conformations , @xmath67},\label{eq : f_red_ha}\ ] ] where @xmath68 is the number of `` geometrically different isomers '' of a reactant . by geometrically different isomers we mean species differing in their geometry , not species differing only in positions of isotopically substituted atoms .
@xmath69 is the electronic energy ( including nuclear repulsion ) of @xmath70 isomer , @xmath11 is the symmetry factor and @xmath71 are partition functions of the nuclear motion of @xmath11 isotopomers .
@xmath72 , @xmath12 , @xmath73 denote analogous quantities for the product .
although symmetry effects can be computed analytically , for the reactions studied in this paper they are nontrivial and so we discuss them here in more detail .
as mentioned above , we are interested in moderate temperatures ( above @xmath74 @xmath2 ) where quantum effects might be very important but the distinguishable particle approximation remains valid . in this case , effects of particle indistinguishability and of non - distinguishing several , in principle distinguishable minima , by an experiment can be conveniently unified by the concept of symmetry factor . in our setting
, we will call `` symmetry factor '' the product@xmath75 here , @xmath76 refers to the number of distinguishable minima not distinguished by the experiment and @xmath77 are the usual rotational symmetry numbers * * * * of symmetric rotors .
the symmetry numbers are present only if either the whole molecule or some of its parts are treated as free or hindered classical symmetrical rotors .
( in this case , the number of minima of the hindered rotor potential is not included in @xmath76 . ) the symmetry numbers are not present if rotational barriers are so high that the corresponding degrees of freedom should be considered as vibrations .
the concept can be illustrated on an example of the mono- and non - deuterated methyl group in a rotational potential with three equivalent minima 120@xmath78 apart . at low temperatures ,
when hindered rotation of the methyl group reduces to a vibration , the symmetry factor is determined only by @xmath76 . in the case of mono - deuterated methyl group
there are three in principle distinguishable minima corresponding to three rotamers , which are , as we suppose , considered to be one species by the observer . therefore @xmath79 . in the case of non - deuterated methyl
there is only one distinguishable minimum and @xmath80 . at higher temperatures , when the methyl group can be treated as a hindered rotor , its contribution to the symmetry factor
is determined only by rotational symmetry number @xmath81 , where @xmath82 for a mono - deuterated methyl group and @xmath83 for a non - deuterated methyl group . from definition ,
it is clear that the high and low temperature pictures are consistent and give the same ratios of symmetry factors .
partition functions @xmath84 and @xmath85 needed in calculation of the reduced free energy in eq . are computed as sums of partition functions of @xmath86 and @xmath87 isotopomers .
in this subsection , we will discuss the accuracy of four electronic structure methods used in our calculations .
ab initio mp2 and the b98 density functional method,@xcite both in combination with the 6 - 311+(2df , p ) basis set , were used for calculations within the ha .
semiempirical am1@xcite and scc - dftb@xcite methods were used in both ha and pimd calculations .
this allowed us to compute the error introduced by the ha .    aside from symmetry factors , the eie is dominated by vibrational contributions .
therefore we concentrate mainly on the accuracy of ha vibrational frequencies . according to merrick _ _ et al.,__@xcite who tested the performance of mp2 and b98 methods by means of comparison with experimental data for a set of 39 molecules , rmse of zpes is 0.46 @xmath88 at mp2/6 - 311+(2df , p ) and 0.31 @xmath88 at b98/6 - 311+(2df , p ) level of theory .
appropriate zpe scaling factors are equal to 0.9777 and 0.9886 respectively .
corresponding rmses of frequencies are 40 @xmath89 and 31 @xmath90 therefore , a slightly higher accuracy can be expected from the b98 functional .
the accuracy of both semiempirical methods is significantly worse than the accuracy of higher level _ ab initio _ methods . according to witek and morokuma ,
the rmse of am1 frequencies in comparison to experimental values for 66 molecules is 95 @xmath89 with frequency scaling factor equal to 0.9566.@xcite the error of vibrational frequencies obtained using scc - dftb depends on parametrization .
we tested two parameter sets : the original scc - dftb parametrization@xcite and the parameter set optimized with respect to frequencies by malolepsza _ _ et al.__@xcite ( further designated scc - dftb - mwm ) .
the error of vibrational frequencies calculated with the original scc - dftb parameters was studied by krger _ _
et al.__@xcite the mean absolute deviation from the reference values calculated at blyp / cc - pvtz for a set of 22 molecules was 75 @xmath89 .
the error of the reference method itself , as compared to an experiment with a slightly smaller set of molecules was 31 @xmath89 .
in the above mentioned study performed by witek and morokuma , rmse of 82 @xmath89 with scaling factor 0.9933 was obtained.@xcite the scc - dftb - mwm mean absolute deviation of experimental and calculated frequencies for a set of 14 hydrocarbons is indeed better and is equal to 33 @xmath89 instead of 59 @xmath89 for the original parametrization .
@xcite    the suitability of am1 , scc - dftb , scc - dftb - mwm , and several other semiempirical methods for our systems was tested by comparison of eie values in the ha and of potential energy scans with the corresponding quantities computed with mp2 and b98 .
results of this comparison are presented in the appendix .
the am1 method is shown to reproduce _ ab initio _ eies in the ha very well , but fails to reproduce scans of potential energies of methyl and vinyl group rotations .
therefore , in addition to am1 method we used the scc - dftb method , which is , among the semiempirical methods tested by us , the best in reproducing _
ab initio _ potential energy scans . on the other hand , compared to am1 , scc - dftb gives a worse eie in the ha .
statistical rmses of averages of pimd simulations were calculated from the equation @xmath91 where @xmath81 is the rmse of one sample .
correlation lengths @xmath46 were estimated by the method of block averages.@xcite at constant temperature , the correlation length decreases with increasing number of imaginary time slices .
also , for constant number of imaginary time slices , the correlation length decreases with increasing temperature .
finally , the correlation length stays approximately constant at different temperatures , if the number of imaginary time slices is chosen so that @xmath92 is converged to approximately the same precision . in our systems ,
correlation length is close to 3.5 @xmath93 .
the eie was studied at four different temperatures : 200 , 441.05 , 478.45 , and 1000 @xmath2 using the normal mode version of pimd.@xcite to control temperature , the nos - hoover chains with four thermostats coupled to each pi degree of freedom were used.@xcite .
different numbers @xmath22 of imaginary time slices had to be used at different temperatures , since at lower temperatures quantum effects become more important , and the number of imaginary time slices necessary to maintain the desired accuracy increases . to examine the required value of @xmath22 as a function of temperature we used the gaff force field.@xcite
whereas the accuracy of vibrational frequencies calculated using the gaff force field is relatively low [ rms difference of gaff and b98/6 - 311+(2df , p ) frequencies of compound * 1 * is equal to 125 @xmath89 ] , the potential should be realistic enough for the assessment of the convergence with respect to @xmath22 .
for example , the difference of potential energies @xmath95 between s-_cis _ and s-_trans _ conformations of compound * 1 * is 4.3 @xmath96 as compared to 2.7 @xmath96 obtained by mp2/6 - 311+(2df , p ) or 3.5 @xmath96 obtained by b98/6 - 311+(2df , p ) .    to check the convergence at 478.45 @xmath2 , we calculated values of the integral in eq . for the deuterium transfer reaction in
* 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * with 40 and 48 imaginary time slices ( using simpson s rule with 5 points ) .
their difference is equal to 0.00005 @xmath97 0.00040 @xmath96 .
this is less than the statistical error of the calculation on the model system , which itself is smaller than the error of production calculations , since the model calculation was 10 times longer than the longest production calculation .
therefore , taking into account the accuracy of production calculations , @xmath98 can be considered the converged number of imaginary time slices .
this is further supported by the observation of the convergence of the single value of the gve at @xmath38 .
the relative difference of gve values obtained with 40 and 48 imaginary time slices is equal to 0.22 @xmath97 0.02  % , whereas the difference between 40 and 72 imaginary time slices equals to 0.39 @xmath97 0.04  % .
the discretization error is asymptotically proportional to @xmath99 . by fitting this dependence to the calculated values
, we estimated the difference between the values for @xmath98 and for the limit @xmath24 to be less than 0.6  % .
this is only three times more than the difference between @xmath98 and @xmath100 .
therefore , if the integral converges similarly as the gve , we can use the aforementioned difference between 40 and 48 imaginary time slices as the criterion of convergence .
the convergence of the gve with the number of imaginary time slices is displayed in fig .
[ fig : gve_te_values ] . since 441.05
@xmath2 is close enough to 478.45 @xmath2 we used the same value of @xmath22 at this temperature . to check the convergence at 200 and 1000 @xmath2
, we observed only the convergence of the single value of the gve . at 200 @xmath2 the relative difference of gve values at @xmath38 obtained with @xmath101 and @xmath102
is 0.03 @xmath97 0.07  % . based on the comparison with the previous result ,
@xmath101 is considered sufficient . at 1000 @xmath2 , the relative difference of gve values at @xmath38 for @xmath103 and @xmath104 equals to 0.1 @xmath97 0.02 % , so that 24 imaginary time slices are used further .
the time step at 441.05 and 478.45 @xmath2 was 0.05 @xmath36 to satisfy the requirement of energy conservation .
at 200 and 1000 @xmath2 , a shorter step of 0.025 @xmath36 was used due to the increased stiffness of the harmonic bonds between beads at 200 @xmath2 and due to the increased average kinetic energy at 1000 @xmath2 .
the simulation lengths differed for different molecules . for both isotopologs of compound * 1 * simulation length of 1 @xmath35 ensured that the system properly explored both the s-_trans _ and the s-_cis _ conformations .
convergence was checked by monitoring running averages and by comparing the ratio of the s-_trans _ and s-_cis _ conformers with the ratio calculated in the ha .
the length of converged pimd simulations of compound * 2 * was 500 @xmath93 .
convergence was checked again using running averages and by visual analysis of trajectories to ensure that the system properly explored all local minima .
for compound * 3 , * the simulation length was 400 @xmath93 .
the integral in eq .
was calculated using the simpson s rule .
using the am1 potential , the gve was evaluated for five values of @xmath15 , namely for @xmath105 .
convergence was checked by comparison with values obtained using the trapezoidal rule .
since the dependence of the estimator on the parameter @xmath15 is almost linear , the difference between the two results remained well under the statistical error .
using the scc - dftb potential , the dependence on @xmath15 was less smooth .
as a result , nine equidistant values of @xmath15 were needed to achieve similar convergence . in one case , as many as 17 values of @xmath15 had to be used .
lcccc & 1@xmath106 step @xmath66 & @xmath107 & 2@xmath108 step @xmath66 & @xmath107   +    +   am1 ( pimd ) & 0.0395 & -0.0041@xmath970.0009 & -0.0154 & 0.0022@xmath970.0007 + scc - dftb ( pimd ) & 0.1245 & -0.0039@xmath970.0007 & -0.0616 & 0.0026@xmath970.0005 + b98 ( ha ) + @xmath109 & 0.0587 & & -0.0248 &   + mp2 ( ha ) + @xmath109 & 0.0770 & & -0.0338 &   +    + am1 ( pimd ) & -0.0283 & 0.0063@xmath970.0009 & 0.0191 & -0.0023@xmath970.0007 + scc - dftb ( pimd ) & -0.1142 & 0.0049@xmath970.0006 & 0.0610 & -0.0017@xmath970.0005 + b98 ( ha ) + @xmath109 & -0.0466 & & 0.0282 &   + mp2 ( ha ) + @xmath109 & -0.0645 & & 0.0372 &   +      the pimd calculations were performed using amber 10.@xcite the part of amber 10 code , which computes the derivative @xmath110 with respect to the mass was implemented by one of us and can be invoked by setting itimass variable in the input file .
several posible ways to compute the derivative are obtained by combining one of two implementations of pimd in ` sander ( ` either the multisander implementation or the les implementation ) with either the nos - hoover chains of thermostats or the langevin thermostat , with the normal mode or `` primitive '' pimd , and with the te or gve . calculating the value of @xmath110 for compound * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * using gaff force field , at @xmath38 , @xmath111 @xmath2 , and for several values of @xmath22
, we confirmed that all twelve possible combinations give the same result .
for example , fig .
[ fig : gve_te_values ] shows the agreement of the gve and te . nevertheless , the twelve methods differ by rmses of @xmath110 ( due to different statistical errors of estimators and correlation lengths ) and by computational costs .
as expected , the most important at higher values of @xmath22 is the difference of statistical errors of gve and te .
figure [ fig : gve_te_errors ] compares the dependence of the rmse of the gve and te on the number @xmath22 of imaginary time slices . for @xmath112 ,
the converged simulation with gve is approximately 100 times faster than with te .
less significant differences of rmses are due to differences in correlation lengths .
as expected , for primitive pimd with langevin thermostat the correlation length depends strongly on collision frequency @xmath113 of the thermostat .
the correlation length is approximately 450 - 500 @xmath36 for @xmath114 @xmath115 , falling down quickly to 120 - 150 @xmath36 for @xmath116 @xmath115 and to 5 @xmath36 for @xmath117 @xmath115 , then rising slowly again .
this can be compared to correlation length of 10 - 20 @xmath36 of the primitive pimd thermostated by nos - hoover chains of 4 thermostats per degree of freedom .
a smaller difference can be found between correlation lengths of the normal mode ( 3 - 8 @xmath36 ) and primitive pimd ( 10 - 20 @xmath36 ) .
all pimd calculations were performed in amber 10.@xcite all mp2 and b98 calculations as well as am1 and pm3 semiempirical calculations in the ha were done in gaussian 03 revision e01.@xcite dftb and scc - dftb calculations in the ha used the dftb+ code , version 1.0.1.@xcite scc - dftb harmonic frequencies were computed numerically using analytical gradients provided by the dftb+ code .
the step size for numerical differentiation was set equal to 0.01 @xmath118 .
this value was also used by krger _ _ et al.__@xcite in their study validating the scc - dftb method and their frequencies differed from purely analytical frequencies of witek _ _ et al.__@xcite by at most 10 @xmath89 . to diagonalize the resulting numerical hessian
, we used the ` formchk ` utility included in the gaussian program package .
( 3__z__)-penta-1,3-diene ( compound * 1 * ) is the simplest of examined molecules .
its non - deuterated isotopolog has three distinguishable minima : the s-_trans _ conformer , which is the global minimum and two s-_cis _ conformers related by mirror symmetry . strictly speaking , in pentadiene the s-_cis _ species
have actually _ gauche _ conformations due to sterical constraints . in their original experiments , roth and knig studied two isotopologs , * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * and * 1 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57*. the eies of both isotopologs were computed using the pimd methodology of sec .
[ sec : method ] at 478.45 @xmath2 .
resulting reduced free energies are listed in table [ tab : f_pentadiene ] .
note that the anharmonicity correction is very similar for am1 and scc - dftb methods , even though the main part of obtained in the ha ( substantially differs for the two methods .
this indicates that the corrections are fairly reliable in this case and can be used to correct results of higher level methods obtained in the ha .
the anharmonicity correction is as large as 20  % of the final value of the reduced free energy .
unfortunately , the difference between mp2 and b98 in the ha is still approximately four times larger than the anharmonicity correction .
.equilibrium ratios of [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift reactions of * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * and * 1 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * at 478.45 @xmath2 .
[ tab : eq_ratios_pentadiene ] [ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
to conclude , the combination of higher level methods in the ha with pimd using semiempirical methods for the rigorous treatment of effects beyond the ha proved to be a viable method for accurate calculations of eies . using the generalized virial estimator for the derivative of the free energy with respect to the mass we were able to obtain accurate results at lower temperatures in reasonable time ( @xmath0 times faster than with thermodynamic estimator ) , since the statistical error is independent on the number of imaginary time slices .
two semiempirical methods , am1 and scc - dftb , were used for calculation of the anharmonicity correction , both giving very similar results .
calculations showed , that the anharmonicity effects account up to 30 % of the final value of the reduced free energy of considered reactions .
the anharmonicity correction always decreases the absolute value of the reduced reaction free energy .
this is consistent with the qualitative picture in which higher vibrational frequencies of hydrogens are lowered by the anharmonicity of a potential more than lower frequencies of deuteriums .
this in turn is due to a higher amplitude of vibrations of lighter hydrogen atoms .
the lower difference between frequencies of unsubstituted and deuterated species results in the lower absolute value of the reduced reaction free energy .
unfortunately , the inaccuracy of the _ ab initio _ electronic structure methods used in our study is still of at least the same order as the anharmonicity corrections .    for isotopologs of compound * 1 * , we predicted equilibrium ratios and free energies of the [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen shift reaction .
a comparison with experimental results was not possible due to a low precision of the original measurement . for compound
* 2 * , the disagreement between theoretical and experimental data supports the suspicion by authors of the measurement that the accuracy of their results was compromised by dimerization side reactions . on the other hand , the agreement of theoretically calculated ratios with experimental observations in the case of compound * 3 * suggests that the isolation of the [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift reaction from disturbing influences was successfully achieved and the observed eie and kie can be considered reliable .
we acknowledge the start - up funding provided by epfl .
we express our gratitude to daniel jana for his assistance with scc - dftb calculations , to h. witek for providing us the set of frequency optimized scc - dftb parameters , and to j. j. p. stewart for the mopac2007 code used for testing the pm6 method .
to determine the suitability of semiempirical methods used in our pimd calculations , we first compared values of the eie in the ha .
the b98 and mp2 methods served as a reference .
as can be seen from fig . 6 in the paper , which shows the temperature dependence of @xmath66 of the first step of deuterium transfer reaction in * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * , the difference between b98 and mp2 at temperatures below 500 @xmath2 is close to 0.02 kcal / mol .
so is the difference between am1 and b98 methods . on the other hand , the scc - dftb method clearly overestimates the extent of eie compared to both higher level methods .
a very similar trend was observed in all examined reactions .
other semiempirical methods tested were pm3@xcite and scc - dftb - mwm , which are not included in fig . 6 in the paper for clarity
the pm3 method overestimates the eie similarly to scc - dftb , whereas the scc - dftb - mwm curve is somewhat closer to _ ab initio _ curves than the scc - dftb one . to conclude , from this point of view am1 is the preferred semiempirical method .
during simulations , the pentadiene molecule often passes two potential energy barriers .
these are the barrier for the hindered rotation of the methyl group and the barrier for the rotation of the vinyl group , which connects s-_trans _ and s-_cis _ conformations .
relaxed potential energy scans of these two motions were employed as the second criterion to assess the relevancy of semiempirical methods .
methods tested were mp2 , b98 , am1 , scc - dftb , scc - dftb - mwm , pm3 , rm1,@xcite pm3carb-1,@xcite pddg / pm3,@xcite and pm6.@xcite potential surface scans with pm3carb1 , rm1 , pm3/pddg methods were calculated using the public domain code mopac 6 .
pm6 potential surface scans were performed in mopac 2007.@xcite results for the methyl group rotation are shown in fig .
[ fig : methyl_scan ] .
the height of the am1 barrier is only 0.005 @xmath96 .
moreover , positions of minima do not agree with b98 and mp2 . on the other hand ,
the scc - dftb method matches higher level methods closely . from other semiempirical methods pm3 performs best in this aspect .
the height of the barrier is relatively well reproduced also by pddg / pm3 , rm1 and scc - dftb - mwm methods , but positions of extrema of the potential energy surface are incorrect .
figure [ fig : vinyl_scan ] shows potential energy scans of the s-_trans_/s-_cis _ rotation of the vinyl group .
again , the scc - dftb method matches higher level methods closely .
all other methods ( with the exception of dftb ) give too low barrier heights as well as too low energy differences between s-_trans _ and s-_cis _ conformations .
also note that the potential energy surfaces of pm3 and related methods ( pddg / pm3 and pm3carb-1 ) are not smooth in the gauche region .
this peculiarity of the pm3 potential surface can be seen also in the potential surface scan performed by liu _ _ et al.__@xcite      based on these results we concluded that none of the semiempirical methods except for scc - dftb is able to sufficiently improve the am1 potential energy surface .
whereas the frequency optimized variant of the scc - dftb method ( scc - dftb - mwm ) improves the eie in the ha , it does not retain the scc - dftb accuracy in the potential surface scans .
hence we decided to use the am1 and scc - dftb potentials for pimd calculations .
to conclude , am1 performs very well in ha , but it can not properly describe potential surfaces of the two rotational motions realized during simulations . on the other hand ,
scc - dftb gives worse results in ha , but it reproduces both barriers very well .