their unusual physical and chemical properties , and their potential applications in a variety of nanotechnologies make carbon nanotubes ( cnts ) very interesting objects to technoscientists , @xcite despite possible health hazards .
@xcite in particular , cnts have been proposed to fabricate several different integrated - circuits elements and electromagnetic devices , such as transmission lines , @xcite interconnects , @xcite and nanoantennas .
@xcite the fabrications of a cnt - based amplitude modulator / demodulator @xcite and a fully integrated radio receiver @xcite have been reported .
references demonstrate the potential of cnts as emitters of terahertz and infrared radiation .
not surprisingly , the electromagnetic characteristics of cnt - based antennas have been examined in different frequency regimes ranging from the microwave to the visible .
cnt morphology has been demonstrated to play a crucial role , as evinced by reported research on single - wall cnts ( swcnts ) , @xcite @xmath0-cm - long one - dimensional chains of electrically connected swcnts , @xcite planar periodic structures of swcnts,@xcite cnt bundles @xcite , and cnt arrays.@xcite continuing in that vein , here we report our work on the performance of multiwalled cnts ( mwcnts ) as antennas .
a multiwalled cnt comprises @xmath1 concentric shells ( or tubes ) , each obtained by rolling a graphene sheet into a cylinder .
the number of shells in a mwcnt can range from 2 to 200 , and the distance between consecutive shells from @xmath2 to @xmath3 ,@xcite which is close to the interlayer distance in graphite ( @xmath4  ) .
the lattice structures of consecutive shells are generally uncorrelated with each other , and can even have different chiralities .
in fact , several experiments on mwcnts have indicated that often the different shells have different periodicities.@xcite two consecutive shells of an mwcnt are called commensurate ( incommensurate ) if the ratio of their unit - cell lengths along the cnt axis is rational ( irrational ) , indicating the presence ( absence ) of translational symmetry .
incommensurability affects the transport and optical properties of mwcnts .
@xcite    the critical issue when modeling the electromagnetic properties of an mwcnt is the intershell interaction leading to intershell electron tunneling or hopping .
published data , although very variable , shows a strong dependence on the intrinsic symmetries of the shells , which dictates selection rules for the elements of the tunneling matrix , as determined by the conservation laws for energy and momentum .
as may be expected , two incommensurate shells interact differently than two commensurate cells .
@xcite for example , the fermi momentums of two incommensurate shells do not coincide within the first brillouin zone and therefore the intershell tunneling vanishes .
@xcite    an isolated mwcnt can be modeled in several different ways .
@xcite considered an mwcnt as a set of coaxial , continuous , conducting cylinders accompanied by an appropriate kronig - penney - type potential in the radial direction .
dyachkov and makaev @xcite as well as tunney and cooper @xcite assumed the intershell interaction to be so small that each shell could be considered to be in a perturbed eigenstate of an swcnt .
a computer simulation with some input parameters extracted from experiment has also been reported.@xcite    following refs . and , we decided to neglect the contribution of the intershell tunneling to the radiation characteristics of an mwcnt . indeed , though intershell interaction in defectless finite - length double - wall cnts shifts optical band gaps and distorts the density of electronic states , it does not subvert the intrinsic type of conductivity ( either metallic or semiconductor);@xcite therefore , it would influence the radiation characteristics only slightly . as the presence of localized defects can dramatically increase intershell conduction ,
@xcite we restrict ourselves here to mwcnts with defect - free shells by neglecting intershell conduction .
analysis of the physical characteristics of cnt - based integrated circuits elements , such as antennas , must follow the general principles of electrodynamics and must account for the peculiar dispersion properties of electrons in cnts . a key element of the analysis is the formulation of the effective boundary conditions for the electromagnetic field on the cnt surface .
@xcite these boundary conditions are dictated by the microscopic model of cnt used .
hence , any attempt to describe an mwcnt with cross - sectional radius between @xmath5 and @xmath6  nm as a perfectly conducting rod @xcite can provide only rough estimates , and is inapplicable to mwcnts of small radius .
we adopt a proper microscopic model for mwcnts here . a relevant boundary - value problem for an mwcnt of finite length
is formulated in sec .
[ model ] . since the radiation characteristics of an mwcnt are determined by its waveguiding properties , the dispersion equation for guided - wave propagation on an infinitely long mwcnt
is derived in sec .
[ guided ] .
the boundary - value problem of sec .
[ model ] is solved numerically by an integral - equation technique in sec .
[ finite - length ] .
this approach is well established in antenna theory @xcite and has been successfully applied to swcnt antennas @xcite and almost circular bundles of closely packed swcnts .
@xcite section  [ num ] contains numerical results for guided - wave parameters ( slow - wave and attenuation ) and the scattering properties of mwcnt in a wide frequency range from the terahertz to the visible regimes .
sections  [ discus ] presents an assessment of the potential of an isolated mwcnt function as an optical nanoantenna .
concluding remarks are provided in sec .
[ concl ] .
an @xmath7 time - dependence is implicit , @xmath8 denotes the time , and @xmath9 is the angular frequency .
let us model an mwcnt as a multishell structure comprising @xmath1 coaxial , infinitesimally thin cylinders in free space .
each shell is achiral , i.e. , it has either a zigzag ( @xmath10 ) or an armchair ( @xmath11 ) configuration , with @xmath12 as an integer . therefore , our model is applicable to both semiconducting and metallic shells .
the sequence of armchair and zigzag shells in the mwcnt is arbitrary .
let the cylindrical axis of the chosen mwcnt be parallel to the @xmath13 axis of the cylindrical coordinate system @xmath14 .
the centroid of the mwcnt is assumed to coincide with the origin of the coordinate system .
let us enumerate shells in the mwcnt consecutively from @xmath15 to @xmath1 beginning from the innermost shell , so that their cross - sectional radii comply with the condition @xmath16 .
the cross - sectional radius @xmath17 of the outermost shell is assumed to be much smaller than the free - space wavelength .
the @xmath18-th shell , @xmath19 $ ] , possesses an axial conductivity per unit area denoted by @xmath20 .
the transverse current density in every shell is neglected .
intershell tunneling is also neglected , as mentioned in the previous section .    as electromagnetic fields with azimuthal symmetry are easily excited in an mwcnt by a uniform external field , we decided to restrict ourselves to azimuthally symmetric fields .
this restriction also holds for finite - length mwcnts in the long - wavelength regime ( sec .
[ num1 ] ) .
the electric hertz vector @xmath21 is then governed by the helmholtz equation @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the unit vector along the @xmath13 axis , @xmath24 the free - space wavenumber , and @xmath25 is speed of light in free space ( i.e. , vacuum ) .
since @xmath26 depends only on @xmath27 and @xmath13 , the components of the electric and magnetic fields are as follows : @xmath28 @xmath29    on neglecting intershell tunneling , the two boundary conditions across the @xmath18-th shell are given by @xcite @xmath30 here @xmath31 is the axial current density on the surface @xmath32 , with @xmath33    the surface conductivity @xmath34 of the @xmath18-th isolated shell is available via quantum - transport calculations carried out in the tight - binding approximation as @xcite    @xmath35    where @xmath36 is the electron charge , @xmath37 is the normalized planck constant , and @xmath38 is the axial projection of quasi - momentum of an electron
. the integer @xmath39 $ ] labels the @xmath40-electron energy bands and the abbreviation @xmath41 restricts the variable @xmath38 to the first brillouin zone .
the time constant @xmath42 ( being the relaxation time ) is assumed to be equal to the inverse of the relaxation frequency @xmath43 .
the normalized matrix elements of the dipole transition between the conduction and valence bands , denoted by @xmath44 , are evaluated in the tight - binding approximation , after taking into account the transverse quantization of the charge carriers motion and the hexagonal structure of the graphene lattice .
@xcite    the first term on the right side of ( [ eq4 ] ) is the drude term corresponding to the intraband conductivity , while the second term describes the contribution of interband transitions between the valence and the conduction bands . the indexes @xmath25 and
@xmath45 refer to the conduction and valence bands , respectively .
the equilibrium fermi distribution functions @xmath46 \right\ } ^{-1}\ ] ] and @xmath47 \right\ } ^{-1}\ ] ] involve the temperature @xmath48 and the boltzmann constant @xmath49 .
the electron energies @xmath50 and normalized matrix elements of the dipole transition @xmath44 for zigzag ( @xmath10 ) cnt are given by @xcite @xmath51 and @xmath52\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively , where @xmath53 ev is the overlap integral , @xcite @xmath54 , and @xmath55  nm is the interatomic distance in graphene .
expressions for @xmath56 and @xmath57 for armchair ( @xmath11 ) cnts are available elsewhere .
let us recall that intershell tunneling is negligibly small so that @xmath58 can be represented as a superposition of @xmath1 independent functions ; furthermore , we seek a solution of ( [ eq1 ] ) in the form of a guided wave .
accordingly , @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the set of unknown coefficients and @xmath61 is the unknown guide wavenumber . with @xmath62 ,
the basis function @xmath63 is taken to satisfy the differential equation @xmath64       + \kappa^2 \phi_p(\rho ) =      0\ , , \quad p\in[1,n]\,,\ ] ] subject to the following boundary conditions at the surface @xmath32 : @xmath65 the appropriate solution of is @xmath66 where @xmath67 and @xmath68 are modified bessel functions of the zeroth order .    whereas the boundary condition ( [ boundary4 ] ) is automatically satisfied by ( [ eq5 - 5 ] ) and ( [ eq5 - 6 ] ) , ( [ boundary3 ] ) remains to be satisfied .
substitution of ( [ eq5 - 5 ] ) into ( [ boundary3 ] ) leads to a system of @xmath1 linear homogeneous equations with respect to the coefficients @xmath69 . a nontrivial solution of the system is provided by the dispersion equation @xmath70 the elements @xmath71 of the @xmath72 matrix @xmath73 are given by @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the kronecker delta .
the dispersion equation ( [ eq12 ] ) has @xmath1 @xmath76-roots , each corresponding to a guided wave in the mwcnt . from each @xmath76-root
, we can determine @xmath61 and the slow - wave coefficient @xmath77 .
let us now consider the scattering of an electromagnetic wave incident on a mwcnt of finite length @xmath78
. the scattered field can be described by ( [ elfield1 ] ) and ( [ elfield2 ] ) with the electric hertz vector satisfying the helmholz equation ( [ eq1 ] ) , the usual radiation condition , @xcite and the boundary conditions ( [ boundary3 ] ) and ( [ boundary4 ] ) .
the surface current density @xmath79 at @xmath80 is given by @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the @xmath13-component of the incident electric field .
as the intershell tunneling through the two ends of the mwcnt is negligible , the current density @xmath79 satisfies the edge conditions @xmath83 thereby expressing the absence of concentrated charges on the ends .
the boundary - value problem can effectively be solved by the integral - equation technique for the surface current density as follows .
@xcite    the potential @xmath84 must be linearly related to @xmath79 , @xmath19 $ ] , as @xmath85 where @xmath86 is the free - space green function for ( [ eq1 ] ) . setting @xmath87 in ( [ eq15a ] ) and making use of ( [ eqj ] ) , we arrive at the following system of @xmath1 integral equations with respect to unknown current densities : @xmath88   & & \label{eq18a }   { \displaystyle\quad + \,c_q \exp ( ikz ) + d_q \exp ( - ikz ) }   \\   & & \nonumber = \sum\limits_{p = 1}^{n } { \int\limits _ { - l / 2}^{l / 2 } { \left [ { \frac{2\pi i r_p } { \omega } g(z - { z}',r_p , r_q ) } \right . } } \\[5pt ]   & & \qquad +   \left .
{ \frac{i\delta _ { qp } } { 2k \sigma_p } \exp ( ik\vert z - { z}'\vert ) } \right ]   j_p ( { z}')d{z}'\,,\quad q\in[1,n]\ , .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath89 and @xmath90 are unknown constants to be determined from the edge conditions ( [ eq14a ] ) .    in the long - wavelength regime ( @xmath91 )
, the electromagnetic scattering properties of the mwcnt can be encapsulated in a polarizability tensor with only one nonzero component @xmath92 the integral on the right side of ( [ eq18a ] ) can be numerically handled by a quadrature formula .
@xcite parenthetically , the foregoing formalism was recently applied to almost circular , closely packed bundles of finite - length parallel , identical , metallic swcnts .
@xcite    a finite - length mwcnt functioning as a receiving antenna can be characterized by the antenna efficiency @xcite @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the scattered power and @xmath95 is the power lost to ohmic dissipation .      according to refs .   and
, surface waves in a cnt are strongly attenuated in the frequency regime of interband transitions .
therefore , the surface current density @xmath96 in an swcnt of radius @xmath97 exposed to an incident electric field @xmath98 obeys ohm s law @xmath99 very well , @xmath100 being the surface conductivity .
equation  ( [ ohm0 ] ) can be considered as the first born approximation .
@xcite    application of the first born approximation ( [ ohm0 ] ) to an mwcnt allows us to express the axial surface current density @xmath79 on the surface of the @xmath18-th shell as @xmath101\,.\ ] ] this expression can be justified as follows .
the electric field exciting the @xmath18-th shell is made of two components : ( i ) the electric field @xmath98 incident on the entire mwcnt and ( ii ) the sum of the electric fields radiated to the surface current densities @xmath102 , @xmath103 $ ] but @xmath104 . equation  ( [ ohm ] ) is justified if the first component is much larger than the second component at @xmath105 , i.e. , the condition @xmath106      & & \qquad\quad z\in\left[-l/2,l/2\right]\,,\quad      p\in\left[1,n\right]\ , ,      \label{condition}\end{aligned}\ ] ] holds true . substituting ( [ eq15a ] ) and ( [ ohm ] ) into ( [ condition ] )
, we arrive at the condition @xmath107   & & \nonumber   { \displaystyle\quad \ll \left| \frac{c}{2}\int _ { - l / 2}^{l / 2 } { e^{(0)}_{z } ( { r_p , z}')\exp ( ik\vert z - { z}'\vert ) d{z}'}\right|}\ , , \\[5pt ]      & & \qquad\quad z\in\left[-l/2,l/2\right]\,,\quad      p\in\left[1,n\right]\ , , \label{condition1 }   \end{aligned}\ ] ] for the applicability of the first born approximation .
we found that condition ( [ condition1 ] ) holds true for mwcnts that are not too thick ( i.e. , @xmath17 is sufficiently small ) in the frequency regime wherein the surface conductivities @xmath20 , @xmath19 $ ] , are mostly determined by interband transitions  the second term in ( [ eq4 ] ) .
we estimate that mwcnts with outermost radius @xmath108  nm satisfy ( [ ohm ] ) at frequencies in the mid - infrared and the visible regimes .
equation  ( [ ohm ] ) contradicts the edge conditions ( [ eq14a ] ) .
an analogous situation appears , for example , in the theory of diffraction by an aperture in an infinitesimally thin , perfectly conducting screen , wherein the exact solution must satisfy the meixner condition @xcite on the aperture edge but an approximate solution based on the huygens principle does not satisfy that condition .
however , the error is strongly localized in the vicinity of the edge of the aperture and does not influence the scattered field in the far zone . @xcite for our problem , ( [ ohm ] ) may be interpreted as a version of the huygens principle for an mwcnt : the scattered field is generated by secondary current densities induced by the incident electric field on the surfaces of all shells .
therefore , the applicability of ( [ ohm ] ) is unphysical only in the vicinity of the edges @xmath109 , but that should not affect the performance of the mwcnt as an antenna in the interband - transitions regime .    when the mwcnt is electrically thin in cross - section ( @xmath110 ) , the further approximation @xmath111 is permissible .
then the substitution of ( [ ohm ] ) in ( [ eq21a ] ) and ( [ eq21b ] ) yields @xmath112 @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the _ effective _ conductivity per unit length of an electrically thin mwcnt .
the condition ( [ condition1 ] ) leads to the inequality @xmath115 ; consequently , @xmath116    as determined by ( [ eq21c ] ) and ( [ eq21d ] ) , @xmath117 and @xmath118 are the same as for a thin - wire resistive antenna whose conductivity per unit length is equal to @xmath119.@xcite thus , an electrically thin mwcnt which satisfies the condition ( [ condition1 ] ) may be modeled as a thin homogenous cylinder with conductivity per unit length determined from ( [ sigm ] ) .
in order to present illustrative results , let us consider an mwcnt consisting of only zigzag shells .
a large number of such mwcnts are possible .
@xcite moreover , after a suitable modification of the effective boundary conditions ( [ boundary3 ] ) and ( [ boundary4]),@xcite the approach developed can be extended to mwcnts comprising shells with arbitrary chirality vectors .    for definiteness
, calculations were performed for two types of mwcnts , hereafter referred to as type a and type m , shown in fig .
the @xmath18-th shell in an mwcnt of type a is in the @xmath120 configuration ; hence , two consecutive semiconducting shells are followed by a metallic shell .
the @xmath18-th shell in an mwcnt of type m is in the @xmath121 confuguration ; hence , all @xmath1 shells are metallic .
the radius of the @xmath18-th shell is given by @xmath122 9\sqrt{3}pb/(2\pi)\ , , & \quad{\rm type\,\ , m } \end{array}\right.\,.\ ] ]        the frequency @xmath123 of the first interband transition for the @xmath18-th shell of the metallic type is determined by the energy difference between the lowest van hove singularity of the conducting band and the highest van hove singularity of the valence band .
thus , an analysis of the dispersion equation ( [ dispers1 ] ) for zigzag shells yields @xmath124/(2\pi\hbar ) \\ & \simeq & \upsilon _ f / ( \pi r_p   ) \ , ,   \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath125 is the @xmath40-electron velocity at the fermi level
. the frequency of the first interband transition for the @xmath18-th shell of the semiconducting type is determined by the minimal band - gap energy as @xmath126/3]/(2\pi\hbar)\\ & \simeq & \upsilon _ f / ( 3\pi r_p ) \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] wherein the sign have to be chosen so that @xmath127/3 $ ] is an integer .
thus , the frequency of the first interband transition is given by @xmath128 the foregoing formula has been confirmed by direct numerical simulation .
@xcite    the frequency regime below the interband - transition regime for an mwcnt is dictated by the condition @xmath129 where @xmath130 while the condition @xmath131 establishes the frequency regime for long - range guided - wave propagation . as a result ,
the frequency regime wherein long - range guided waves can produce geometric ( antenna ) resonances is as follows : @xmath132    at frequencies in the regime @xmath133 , the interband transitions contribute strongly to the surface conductivity of each shell such that the real and the imaginary parts of this quantity are approximately equal in magnitude .
guided waves then get attenuated heavily . at frequencies in the regime @xmath134 , attenuation of guided waves is caused by fast electron relaxation in all shells .
let us now examine guided - wave propagation at @xmath135  thz in an infinitely long mwcnt of type a consisting of @xmath136 shells .
the relaxation time @xmath42 is taken to be vanishingly small .
the shells numbered @xmath137 are metallic .
all interband transitions for these shells occur at frequencies exceeding @xmath138  thz and therefore do not contribute to the effective conductivity ( per unit length ) of the mwcnt .
the imaginary part of the surface conductivity of a metallic shell is positive - valued and exceeds the real part in magnitude .
thus , the necessary condition for the long - range propagation of guided waves is satisfied .
the semiconducting shells labelled @xmath139 have negligible surface conductivity , and therefore do not influence the scattering properties of the chosen mwcnt at @xmath140  thz .
the surface conductivities of the semiconducting shells labelled @xmath141 are dictated mainly by the corresponding first interband transitions occurring at @xmath142  thz . at @xmath143  thz .
the imaginary parts of the surface conductivities of these shells are negative and several times smaller than the surface conductivities of adjacent metallic shells .
therefore , the surface current densities in these semiconducting shells are smaller and oppositely directed with respect to their counterparts in adjacent metallic shells .
the real parts of the surface conductivities of these semiconducting shells are high enough to cause large ohmic losses .
we considered only the two eigenmodes of guided - wave propagation in the chosen mwcnt with the smallest retardation , labeled as @xmath144 and @xmath145 .
they correspond to the two roots of the dispersion equation ( [ eq12 ] ) , identified as @xmath146 and @xmath147 , with the smallest real parts : @xmath148 . of all eigenmodes , these
two will mostly influence the scattering properties of the finite - length mwcnt , as discussed in sec .
[ num1 ] .
the radial dependences of @xmath149 and @xmath150 inside the mwcnt of type a for guided waves @xmath144 and @xmath145 are shown in fig .
[ fig2](a ) .
clearly , the axial component of the electric field is distributed over the entire cross section of the mwcnt .
the azimuthal component of the magnetic field is discontinuous across each metallic shell , in accordance with the boundary condition ( [ boundary3 ] ) .
the degree of discontinuity decreases as the shell number @xmath18 increases , in compliance with the generally decreasing magnitudes of @xmath151 in fig .
[ fig2](b ) . outside the mwcnt
, the radial distribution of the electric and magnetic fields is governed by the argument of the modified bessel function @xmath152 , whereby we conclude that the electromagnetic field is highly localized to the mwcnt .     and @xmath150 , ( b ) @xmath151 on the surfaces of the shells , and ( c ) the axial component of the time - averaged poynting vector , for guided waves @xmath144 and @xmath145 , in an mwcnt of type a with @xmath136 shells at @xmath135 thz , in the limit @xmath153 . the discrete points in ( b ) , corresponding to different shells , are joined together only to aid the eye .
, width=326 ]    the axial surface current density @xmath151 , @xmath19 $ ] , is shown in fig . [
fig2](b ) for guided waves @xmath144 and @xmath145 . in opposition to the radial distributions of the axial electric field ,
the magnitude of the current density is maximal on the innermost shell , and then strongly decreases with the increase of the shell number @xmath18 .
this behavior is in agreement with the @xmath154-dependence of the surface conductivity of a metallic swcnt of radius @xmath97 .
@xcite    figure  [ fig2](c ) shows the radial distribution of the axial component of the time - averaged poynting vector @xmath155 for @xmath144 and @xmath145 , inside the mwcnt and in the vicinity of its outermost shell .
the energy - flux density for @xmath144 is maximum near the surface of the innermost metallic shell and then slightly varies about some mean value between the 4@xmath156 and the 13@xmath156 shells .
the energy - flux density for @xmath145 is mostly concentrated between the two innermost metallic shells and then decreases very rapidly as @xmath157 .
clearly then , the two innermost metallic shells are dominant contributors to the retardation of both @xmath144 and @xmath145 .     and ( b ) @xmath158 on @xmath1 for guided waves @xmath144 and @xmath145 in mwcnts of type a and m , when @xmath135  thz and @xmath159 s. discrete points are joined by lines to aid the eye . , width=326 ]    the dependences of the real part of the slow - wave coefficient @xmath160 and the ratio @xmath161 of the guided waves @xmath144 and @xmath145 on the number @xmath1 of shells in mwcnts of types a and m are shown in fig .  [ fig3 ] .
the retardation coefficient @xmath162 for mwcnts of type m is higher than for mwcnts of type a of comparable @xmath17 , which is a significant observation in relation to the geometric resonances of finite - length mwcnts ( sec .
[ num1 ] ) .    for mwcnts of type m , @xmath163 increases as @xmath1 does . as @xmath1 increases
, the additional outmost shell has a lower influence on @xmath163 .
the increase of @xmath163 with increasing @xmath1 occurs until @xmath17 exceeds @xmath164 , per conditions ( [ eq14 ] ) and ( [ freq ] ) .
figure  [ fig3](a ) shows that , for guided waves @xmath144 and @xmath145 in mwcnts of type a , @xmath163    * increases with the addition of a metallic shell , but * decreases with the addition of a semiconducting shell .    for an mwcnt with small @xmath1
, @xmath162 is thus determined mostly by the metallic shells .
in contrast , for mwcnts with large @xmath1 , both @xmath162 and @xmath165 are strongly affected by the semiconducting shells of large radius .
this occurs because the semiconducting shells labelled @xmath166 have their first interband transitions near the chosen frequency of @xmath140  thz , and , consequently , the real and imaginary parts of their surface conductivities are large in magnitude .
an increase in the number of such shells greatly diminishes the parameters @xmath163 and @xmath167 of @xmath144 and @xmath145 in the mwcnts of type a. thus , _ interband transitions suppress guided - wave propagation in mwcnts_.      let us now move on to the scattering properties of finite - length mwcnts in the terahertz and the far - infrared frequency regimes . here
we focus only on the case when the incident electric field is parallel to the @xmath13 axis , thereby permitting us to investigate electromagnetic effects caused by the axial surface conductivities of the shells .     of mwcnts of type a and m for different lengths @xmath78 and number of shells @xmath1 .
the labels @xmath168 and @xmath169 denote the first geometric resonance  @xmath170 in ( [ eq15 ] )  of the guided waves @xmath144 and @xmath145 , respectively .
( a ) @xmath171  s , ( b ) @xmath172  s.,width=326 ]    figure  [ fig4](a ) illustrates the frequency dependence of the imaginary part of the polarizability scalar @xmath173 in the long - wavelength regime ( @xmath174 ) for different lengths @xmath78 and shell numbers @xmath1 in mwcnts of type a and m. the labels @xmath168 and @xmath169 in this figure denote the first geometric resonance of the guided waves @xmath144 and @xmath145 , respectively . the geometric resonances occur at frequencies @xcite @xmath175 as we concluded from fig .  [
fig3](a ) , the retardation coefficient @xmath162 for mwcnts of type m is higher than for mwcnts of type a of comparable @xmath17 . therefore the first geometric resonance ( @xmath176 ) for the mwcnts of type m appears in fig  [ fig4](a ) at a higher frequency than for mwcnts of type a , both of the same length @xmath78 .
the resonance frequencies for @xmath144 and @xmath145 depend on @xmath78 nonlinearly . as an example , in fig .
[ fig4](a ) the resonance frequency of the mwcnt of type a increases by a factor of about @xmath177 ( from @xmath178 to @xmath179  thz ) while the length @xmath78 decreases by a factor of @xmath180 ( from @xmath181 to @xmath182  nm ) .
that is reflected in ( [ eq15 ] ) by the strong dependence of @xmath163 on @xmath183 , when @xmath183 is close to @xmath184 .
accordingly , the dependence of the frequency of the geometric resonance on @xmath78 is not explicit .
the first resonance of the mwcnt of type a and length @xmath185 nm at @xmath179-thz frequency is not strong , because condition ( [ eq14 ] ) is not satisfied for this mwcnt , and the guided wave is strongly attenuated .
we conclude that the resonance of an mwcnt antenna of type a or m near a given frequency are the most pronounced , if both ( [ eq14 ] ) and ( [ eq15 ] ) are satisfied .
figure  [ fig4](a ) contains the value of the antenna efficiency @xmath186 at the first geometric resonance for all mwcnts considered .
this antenna efficiency depends both on the type and the length of the mwcnt .
the antenna efficiency of an mwcnt is several time larger than that of an swcnt of the same length .
our calculations make us conclude that the restrictions on the mwcnt dimensions given by ( [ eq14 ] ) and ( [ eq15 ] ) do not permit an increase in @xmath186 at the first geometric resonance .
in contrast , the antenna efficiency of an almost circular bundle of closely packed swcnts can be increased up to unity , by increasing of number of metallic swcnts in the bundle .
@xcite    when conduction in an mwcnt is very diffuse , @xcite the relaxation time @xmath42 is close to that for graphite ( @xmath187  s ) .
then the conditions ( [ eq14 ] ) and ( [ eq15 ] ) can be fulfilled only for mwcnts of type m , and that too with @xmath188 nm and @xmath189 nm . figure  [ fig4](b ) shows the frequency dependence of @xmath190 of an mwcnt of type m with @xmath191 for @xmath192 s. the first geometric resonances of mwcnts of lengths @xmath193 nm and @xmath194 nm appear in the far - infrared ( @xmath195 thz ) and the mid - infrared ( @xmath196 thz ) regimes , respectively .
thus , antenna resonances are pronounced and can be experimentally observed for short mwcnts with several shells only in the far - infrared and mid - infrared regimes .      whereas secs .
[ num0 ] and [ num1 ] address the frequency regime @xmath197 wherein interband transitions are not possible , we now proceed to the interband - transitions regime of sec .  [ low - coupling ] , wherein the electromagnetic response properties of mwcnts are dominated by the interband transitions .
this regime , delineated by the condition @xmath198 , can very well lie in the visible part of the electromagnetic spectrum .
wang _ et al .
_ have published the only known report on the experimental observation of antenna resonances of mwcnts in the visible regime.@xcite in their experiment , interference patterns of light scattered from an array of finite - length mwcnts with @xmath199 nm were observed .
_ attributed the observed phenomenon to a _ length - matching _ antenna effect , which requires the spatial variations of the induced current density to satisfy the edge conditions ; furthermore , they assumed that a thick mwcnt has the same scattering response in the far zone as a perfect conducting cylinder with the same cross - sectional radius and length .
however , hao and hanson @xcite subsequently showed that the model of an mwcnt as a single cylindrical shell with typical surface conductivity given , e.g. , by ( [ eq4 ] ) , can not describe the experimental observation recorded in ref .  .
the reason is the low surface conductivity of the mwcnt shells , as given by ( [ eq4 ] ) . in the model of ref .
, however , the intershell electromagnetic coupling in the mwcnt was ignored , which is inappropriate if @xmath200  nm , as we pointed out in sec .
[ low - coupling ] .
the lacuna in the model of ref .   can be removed by implementing the integral - equation technique of sec .
[ inteq ] .
therefore , we decided to examine the scattering properties of finite - length mwcnts of radius @xmath201 nm and @xmath202 nm in the visible regime , taking the intershell electromagnetic coupling into account ( but ignoring the intershell electron tunneling ) . as we discuss later in this subsection ,
our analysis confirms the absence of the length - matching antenna effect in the near - infrared and the visible regimes .
let us first analyze the effective conductivity per unit length of an electrically thin mwcnt , as estimated by ( [ sigm ] ) .
figure [ fig5 ] ( a ) presents the real part of @xmath203 as a function of @xmath1 for mwcnts in the near - infrared and the visible regimes .
this figure shows that , for swcnts ( @xmath204 ) and mwcnts with @xmath205 $ ] , @xmath203 has strong resonances .
the resonances weaken as @xmath1 increases and practically disappear for @xmath206 .
this trend can be explained in the following way . in the near - infrared and the visible regimes ,
the surface conductivity @xmath207 of the @xmath18-th shell , obtained from ( [ eq4 ] ) , has many resonances corresponding to van hove singularities .
as the resonances of different shells overlap , the weighted summation of the surface conductivities of all shells in ( [ sigm ] ) ensures that @xmath203 does not evince resonant behavior in the near - infrared and the visible regimes .
the conductivity per unit length of an isolated shell of radius @xmath208 nm also has a large number of closely spaced resonances so that , instead of discrete lines , a band appears in its spectrum .
as the surface conductivities of all mwcnt shells have a plasmon resonance @xcite in the ultraviolet regime at the free - space wavelength @xmath209 , @xmath210 for any mwcnt also has a resonance at this wavelength .
is variable , and @xmath211  s. note that @xmath212  nm .
( b ) real and imaginary parts of @xmath213 of an mwcnt of type m with @xmath214 shells in the near - infrared and the visible regimes . , width=326 ]    the real and imaginary parts of the effective per - unit - length conductivity @xmath203 for an mwcnt of type m with @xmath215 shells ( i.e. , @xmath216  nm ) are presented in fig .  [ fig5](b ) .
as this figure demonstrates , the real part of @xmath203 increases as the frequency increases and has a maximum near @xmath217 thz ( i.e. , @xmath218 nm ) , which is not a geometric - resonance frequency but , instead , is a plasmon - resonance frequency .
@xcite in the near - infrared and the visible regimes , the condition @xmath219 holds ; therefore , the chosen mwcnt can not support surface - wave propagation , which occurs for a metallic wire with @xmath220 according to ref .  .
we also found that the electric field exciting a particular shell differs very slightly from the electric field incident on the mwcnt , when @xmath221  nm and the frequency lies in either the near - infrared or the visible regimes , thereby implying that the electromagnetic coupling between the shells is slight .
the frequency dependence of the scattering power @xmath117 for such an mwcnt is the same as of @xmath222 , according to ( [ eq21c ] ) .
let us now carry on to electrically thick mwcnts ( with @xmath223  nm or @xmath224  nm ) .
for calculation of the electric current densities in their shells in the near - infrared and the visible regimes we used ( [ eq18a ] ) , with @xmath225 assumed to be independent of @xmath226 $ ] .
such an approximation is sufficient to ascertain whether geometric resonances of azimuthally symmetrical modes exist in thick mwcnts or not . of course
, @xmath213 can not be defined for electrically thick mwcnts .    in the near - infrared and visible regimes ,
the surface conductivity of a shell of large radius ( @xmath227 nm ) , in accordance with ( [ eq4 ] ) , does not depend on that whether shell is metallic or semiconducting .
therefore , though the plots in figs .
[ fig6]-[fig8 ] were made for thick mwcnts of type m , all results presented therein are qualitatively true for thick mwcnts of type a also .     versus free - space wavelength @xmath228 for mwcnts with @xmath229 ( solid line ) and @xmath230 shells ( dashed line ) and length @xmath231  nm . the scattered power for a perfectly conducting rod ( dotted line ) of cross - sectional radius 25 nm and length 350 nm
was calculated by solving ( [ eq18a ] ) with @xmath232 and @xmath233.,width=326 ]    in order to compare the electromagnetic responses of the chosen mwcnts and a perfectly conducting rod in the near - infrared and the visible regimes , we need to calculate the scattered power @xmath118 when the incident electric field is oriented parallel to the @xmath13 axis .
when we calculated the scattered power @xmath118 for mwcnts of type m , length @xmath231  nm , and @xmath234 ( @xmath235  nm ) or @xmath236 ( @xmath237  nm ) , resonances did not show up for @xmath238 $ ]  thz ( i.e. , @xmath239 $ ]  nm ) in fig .
[ fig6 ] . for comparison , the scattered power for a perfectly conducting rod of cross - sectional radius 25  nm and length 350  nm is also shown in fig .
this nanorod antenna , in contrast to the mwcnts , has a set of resonances determined by the condition @xmath240 where @xmath76 is a correction factor that slightly exceeds unity and is a function of the ratio of the length and the wavelength as well as of the ratio of cross - sectional radius and the length .
@xcite for the chosen nanorod antenna , the first resonance ( @xmath170 ) is characterized by @xmath241 and appears at @xmath242  thz ( i.e. , @xmath243  nm , which is confirmed by the dotted line fig .
[ fig6 ] .
the absence of antenna ( geometric ) resonances of the chosen mwcnts in the visible regime can be explained by the strong dissipation of electromagnetic energy in mwcnt shells and the small electromagnetic coupling between the shells , as discussed in sec .
[ low - coupling ] . therefore
, even an mwcnt with @xmath202 nm and comprising 140 shells can not support guided - wave propagation and , consequently , can not display the length - matching antenna effect .
the same conclusion is also true in the visible regime for swcnts @xcite and planar arrays of finite - length swcnts .
@xcite let us remark that a hypothetic multishell conductive structure with @xmath229 and @xmath244 nm can have an antenna resonance corresponding to @xmath176 in ( [ eq17 ] ) , provided the surface conductivity of every shell is five times that given by ( [ eq4 ] ) ; but such a structure has not been practically realized as yet .     on the number @xmath1 of shells in an mwcnt of type m and length @xmath231 nm at frequency @xmath245  thz ( visible regime).,width=326 ]    our approach , which is enhanced with respect to that of hao and hansen , @xcite can not explain the mwcnt antenna resonance reported by wang _
@xcite additional experiments are necessary to resolve the contradiction between interpretation of measurements proposed by wang _
et al . _ and the theoretical model of mwcnts developed here and based on ref .  .
the dependence of the antenna efficiency @xmath186 in the visible regime on the number @xmath1 of shells in the mwcnt is illustrated in fig .
the antenna efficiency increases with the number of shells and tends to unity for thick mwcnts ; indeed , @xmath246  thz , we calculated @xmath247 for @xmath234 , but @xmath248 for @xmath236 .      these days , thin metallic ( gold , silver , and aluminium ) wires of finite length
are considered to be promising for application as optical nanoantennas .
@xcite however , the fabrication of long , high - quality , thin , single - crystal wires of cross - sectional radius less than 5 nm and with perfect cylindrical form ( i.e. , without breaks , bends , deformations , etc . ) is a difficult technological problem .
recently , cnts have been used as templates in order to promote the formation of high - quality single - crystal wires coated by perfect graphene cylinders .
@xcite this is an exciting possibility for a composite nanoantenna comprising a solid metallic core covered by concentric carbon shells .
clearly , such a structure is neither a metallic cylinder nor an isolated mwcnt .     and ( b ) the ratio @xmath249 on the number @xmath1 of carbon shells for a surface - plasmon wave in an mwcnt with a gold core .
the mwcnt is of type m , and its @xmath18-th shell has a @xmath250 zigzag configuration and radius @xmath251 , @xmath19 $ ] .
the gold core has a cross - sectional radius @xmath252  nm .
data for an isolated metal wire of cross - sectional radius @xmath253 is the same as for @xmath254 .
discrete points are joined by lines to aid the eye .
, width=326 ]    surface - plasmon waves in the infrared and the visible regimes can propagate along a metal wire .
@xcite surely , guided - wave propagation would be affected if the metallic wire were to be enclosed in an ensemble of concentric carbon shells .
the theoretical approach of sec .
[ guided ] can be applied to study the phenomenon of surface - plasmon waves as follows .
suppose that the metal core is of cross - sectional radius @xmath255 , the radius of the innermost shell of an mwcnt .
if @xmath253 is much less than the skin depth of the bulk metal and @xmath256 , then the metal core can be modeled as a solid cylinder with surface conductivity @xmath257 , @xcite where @xmath258 is the bulk volumetric conductivity of the metal . also , @xmath253 has to be higher than a critical value @xmath259 , which corresponds to the crystalline - noncrystalline transition in metals and separates the quasi - bulk behavior ( @xmath260 ) from the quasi - molecular behavior ( @xmath261 ) of a nanowire .
then , ( [ boundary3])([current ] ) also hold at @xmath262 with @xmath263 , and the procedures of sec .  [
guided ] are applicable .
we considered the propagation of surface - plasmon waves in an mwcnt with a gold core .
the bulk volumetric conductivity @xmath258 of gold was taken to follow the drude model with parameters given in ref .  .
the skin depth of gold in the visible regime is higher than @xmath264  nm .
the value @xmath265  nm for gold was obtained with first - principles calculations in ref .  .
so we assumed that @xmath266 nm @xmath267  nm .    figure  [ fig8 ] presents the dependences of @xmath163 and @xmath268 of a surface - plasmon wave on the number @xmath1 of shells in mwcnt of type m with a gold core of cross - sectional radius @xmath269  nm .
the @xmath18-th shell of the mwcnt has a @xmath250 zigzag configuration and radius @xmath251 , @xmath19 $ ] . in the near - infrared ( @xmath270 thz ) and the visible ( @xmath271 thz ) regimes , fig .  [ fig8](a ) shows that the retardation coefficient @xmath163 depends only slightly on @xmath1 . according to fig .
[ fig8](b ) , the value of @xmath272 is less than for an isolated metal wire ( @xmath254 ) and significantly decreases as @xmath1 increases .
these trends can be explained in the following manner .
the guided wave propagates partly inside the mwcnt and partly inside the gold core .
the dissipation in the mwcnt shells is high because the real and the imaginary parts of the surface conductivities of the shells in the interband regime are of comparable magnitudes .
this dissipation increases with frequency , in accordance with the frequency dependence of the effective per - unit - length conductivity of the mwcnt presented in fig .
[ fig5](b ) .
because of the weak electromagnetic coupling of cnt shells , the shells strongly absorb electromagnetic energy independently on each other  which explains the strong dependence of @xmath268 on @xmath1 .
furthermore , the weak coupling changes the radial electromagnetic field distribution of the surface - plasmon wave only slightly as @xmath1 increases , which explains the weak dependence of @xmath273 on @xmath1 .    the decrease of the magnitude of @xmath268 with increasing @xmath1 increasing implies the enhancement of @xmath117 , the power lost to ohmic dissipation , and consequently the decreasing of the antenna efficiency @xmath186 of an mwcnt with a metal core . however , if @xmath1 is not too large ( @xmath274 or @xmath275 ) some worsening of antenna properties may be justified by other advantages that the metal - core mwcnt may confer .
thus , an mwcnt can operate as an antenna in two different regimes .
the first is the _ drude - conductivity regime _ , wherein the motion of conduction - band electrons is responsible for radiation properties .
this regime has a distinct analogy with a classical radio - frequency wire antenna , as is clear from sec .
[ low - coupling ] and [ num1 ] .
the second regime is the _ interband - transitions regime _ , wherein quantum transitions of electrons between different energy states occur .
this regime was considered in sec .
[ num2 ] and does not have a classical analogy .
the frequency @xmath184 separates the drude - conductivity regime @xmath197 from the interband - transitions regime @xmath198 .
guided - wave propagation and geometric resonances of the guided waves are typical for macroscopic wire antennas .
the guided waves have a quasi - transverse - electromagnetic structure and are characterized by low retardation and low attenuation .
@xcite the existence of guided ( surface ) waves and geometric resonances also is typical for nanowire antennas in the drude - conductivity regime . @xcite
but the guided wave has strong retardation and high attenuation , so that the frequency of a geometric resonance is not connected to the free - space wavelength but to a shorter effective wavelength that depends on the material properties .
@xcite this general rule is also true for mwcnt antennas : fig .
[ fig3 ] shows that guided waves have strong retardation and high attenuation , and fig .
[ fig4 ] presents geometric resonances at @xmath276 demonstrating thereby the effective wavelength to be shorter than free - space wavelength .
calculated data presented in fig .  [ fig3](a )
indicate that the retardation coefficient increases when the number of shells increases .
furthermore , the retardation coefficient is the highest for the @xmath144 mode in mwcnts of type m. that implies that a mwcnt with only metallic shells and operating in the @xmath144 mode offers attractive prospects for high antenna efficiencies in the terahertz regime .
the frequency @xmath184 , separating the drude - conductivity regime from the interband - transitions regime , depends on the detailed electronic and geometric attributes of the mwcnt .
according to ( [ freq ] ) , @xmath184 decreases as @xmath17 increases . as examples , for an mwcnt of type a , ( i ) @xmath277 nm and @xmath278  thz when @xmath279 , but ( ii ) @xmath280 nm and @xmath281  thz when @xmath282 . in the interband - transitions regime
@xmath283 , guided - wave propagation and geometric resonances are absent for both swcnts and mwcnts , which cardinally distinguishes this regime from the drude - conductivity regime .
as shown experimentally,@xcite the absorption and the scattering characteristics of an electrically thick mwcnt in the regime of optical transitions depend only slightly on the frequency .
this conclusion , also borne out by the data in fig .
[ fig6 ] , may be seem to be unexpected .
in fact optical transitions are resonance processes and the surface conductivities of swcnts and mwcnt shells have resonances corresponding to the van hove singularities .
but we found that the antenna parameters of electrically thin mwcnts are determined by the effective parameter @xmath203 defined in ( [ sigm ] ) .
the overlapping of a large number of resonances of the surface conductivities of the different shells leads to a smooth frequency dependence of @xmath203 .
such an effect is analogous to inhomogeneous broadening in an ensemble of all different harmonic oscillators .
thus , within the framework of our model , it is impossible to interpret the observation scattering resonances of random arrays of mwcnts with average outermost radius @xmath5  nm reported in ref .  .
the same conclusion emerged from the model of hao and hansen .
@xcite further experiments are required .
antennas are objects that transform a near - field into a far - field and vice versa .
the morphology of the near field of a nanoantenna possess a nanoscale , and is therefore determined by quantum size effects .
therefore the coupling of a nanoantenna with its near field is stronger than that of a macroscopic antenna with its near field ; as a result , the transformation of the near field to the far field by a nanoantenna is more difficult , and the antenna efficiency of a thin - nanowire antenna is low .
this property is inherent to different types of nanoantennas : swcnts @xcite , bundle of swcnts @xcite , metallic nanorods @xcite , and mwcnts as in fig .
[ fig4 ] . the antenna efficiency can be enhanced by increasing the number of shells in an mwcnt ( fig .
[ fig7 ] ) , the number of swcnts in a bundle ( fig . 7 in ref .  ) , and the cross - sectional radius of a metallic rod antenna ( fig . 1 in ref .   ) .
we can thus conclude that the small value of antenna efficiency is the fundamental physical characteristic of nanoantennas .
nevertheless , its antenna efficiency is tunable over a wide range .    in order to achieve antenna efficiency close to unity
, it is necessary to strongly suppress the influence of quantum size effects by ensuring that the cross - sectional radius is high .
note that , since quantum size effects are not pronounced in gold nanowires of cross - sectional radius of several tens of nanometers , such nanowire - based antennas are expected to possess properties analogous to macroscopic antennas .
the electromagnetic properties of mwcnts have only a slight frequency - dependence in the interband - transitions regime , per fig .  [ fig6 ] .
thus , and mwcnt can be considered to be a nanoantenna with sufficiently high @xmath284 ( @xmath285 in fig .  [ fig7 ] ) and a wide operating - frequency range in the visible regime .
such nanoantennas have properties similar to those of electrically small but macroscopic antennas in microwave regimes ( e.g. , short non - resonant dipoles ) . @xcite
to conclude , we modeled the shells of an mwcnt as impedance sheets with axially directed surface conductivity , ignored intershell tunneling of electrons but incorporated intershell coupling , in an integral - equation approach .
calculated data indicate that in a low - frequency regime called the drude - conductivity regime , wherein optical interband transitions do not occur , guided waves can propagate with low attenuation in an mwcnt which has metallic shells . in the same frequency regime
, the axial polarizability of a finite - length mwcnt has a resonant behavior due to the antenna - length matching effect .
however , the shells with surface conductivity due to interband transitions suppress guided - wave propagation
. due of the high dissipation in such shells , mwcnts with outermost radius @xmath286 nm can not possess resonant properties in the visible regime .
analysis of surface - plasmon - wave propagation in a mwcnt with a gold core shows that , in the near - infrared and the visible regimes , the shells behave effectively as lossy dielectric materials and suppress surface - wave propagation along the gold core .      *
the antenna efficiency @xmath186 of an mwcnt exceeds that of an swcnt but is less than that of an almost circular bundle of closely packed , metallic swcnts , provided that all three objects are of roughly the same outermost radius .
therefore , swcnt - bundles are the most promising candidates for terahertz and mid - infrared antennas . * an mwcnt with at least 4 shells is recommended for application as a nanoantenna with a wide operating - frequency range in the visible regime . *
filling the core of an mwcnt with a metal makes the mwcnt attractive as a nanoantenna , provided that the number of shells does not exceed 3 .
the model developed in this paper can be applied for an mwcnt with achiral shells and negligibly small intershell tunneling .
generalization of the boundary condition ( [ boundary3])-([eq4 ] ) is needed to take the chirality of shells and intershell tunneling into account .
this research was partially supported by intas under projects 05 - 1000008 - 7801 and 06 - 1000013 - 9225 , international bureau bmbf ( germany ) under project blr 08/001 , and the belarus republican foundation for fundamental research and cnrs ( france ) under project f07f-013 .
mvs thanks the world federation of scientists for a fellowship .
al acknowledges the charles godfrey binder professorship endowment at the pennsylvania state university for partial support .
s. a. maksimenko and g. ya .
slepyan , nanoelectromagnetics of low - dimensional structures , in _
nanometer structures : theory , modeling , and simulation _ ( a. lakhtakia , ed . ) , ( spie press , bellingham , wa , usa , 2004 ) , pp .
145 - 206 .
a. l. elias , j. a. rodriguez - manzo , m. r. mccartney , d. golberg , a. zamudio , s. e. baltazar , f. lopez - urias , e. munoz - sandoval , l. gu , c. c. tang , d. j. smith , y. bando , h. terrones , and m. terrones , nano lett . * 5 * , 467 ( 2005 ) .