as their name suggests , compact groups are small systems of several galaxies in a compact configuration on the sky .
the first example was found over one hundred years ago by stephan ( 1877 ) who observed it visually using the 40-cm refractor of the observatoire de marseille . stephan s quintet is a small group of five galaxies ,
three of which show strong tidal distortions due to gravitational interaction .
a second example was found 71 years later by seyfert ( 1948 ) from a study of harvard schmidt plates .
seyfert s sextet ( figure 1 ) is one of the densest groups known , having a median projected galaxy separation of only @xmath1 kpc ( the hubble constant @xmath2 km s@xmath3 mpc@xmath3 ) .
the palomar observatory sky survey ( poss ) provided a new and extensive resource for the systematic investigation of small groups of galaxies .
two catalogs , the _ atlas of interacting galaxies _
( vorontsov - velyaminov 1959 , 1975 ) and the _ atlas of peculiar galaxies _ ( arp 1966 ) , contain galaxies or galaxy groups selected on the basis of visible signs of interaction or peculiar appearance .
in addition to stephan s quintet and seyfert s sextet , these include many new compact groups , including a striking chain of five galaxies , vv 172 .
prior to these , shakhbazian ( 1957 ) had discovered a small dense cluster of 12 faint red galaxies that appeared so compact that they were initially mistaken for stars . over the next two decades , shakhbazian and collaborators examined over 200 poss prints covering 18% of the sky and cataloged 376 additional `` compact groups of compact galaxies '' ( shakhbazian 1973 , shakhbazian & petrosian 1974 , baier et al 1974 , petrosian 1974 , 1978 , baier & tiersch 1975 - 79 ) .
apart from occasional photographic or spectroscopic observations ( eg .
mirzoian et al 1975 , tiersch 1976 , massey 1977 , shakhbazian & amirkhanian 1979 , vorontsov - velyaminov et al 1980 , vorontsov - velyaminov & metlov 1980 ) these systems initially received little attention .
however , interest in them is growing .
although the majority seem to be small clusters , they share some of the properties , and pose some of the same questions , as do compact groups .    when redshifts were measured for galaxies in the first compact groups ( burbidge & burbidge 1959 , 1961a ) , surprises were found .
both stephan s quintet and seyfert s sextet contain a galaxy with a discordant redshift .
it seemed unlikely that a foreground or background galaxy would appear so often projected within such compact systems ( burbidge & burbidge 1961a ) .
this impression was further reinforced with the discovery of yet another discordant redshift in vv 172 ( sargent 1968 ) .
are these examples of physical association between objects of widely different redshifts , as has been advocated for many years by arp ( 1987 ) ?
even if the discordant galaxies are ignored , the velocity dispersions of these systems are generally higher than would be expected given their visible mass ( burbidge & burbidge 1959 , 1961b , 1961c , burbidge & sargent 1971 ) .
it was argued that such groups must be unbound and disrupting ( eg .
ambartsumian 1961 ) , although limber and mathews ( 1960 ) showed that the virial theorem could be satisfied for stephan s quintet , given the uncertainties in the projection factors , if the individual galaxy masses were considerably larger than those of isolated galaxies .
the observations can of course also be explained if the bulk of the mass is in a non - visible form . in hindsight , this was one of the earliest indications of the possible existence of dark matter in galactic systems .
a new problem emerged with the realization that bound groups would be unstable to orbital decay resulting from gravitational relaxation processes ( peebles 1971 ) .
a simple calculation indicated that the dynamical - friction timescale was much shorter than the hubble time ( hickson et al 1977 ) , as was soon confirmed by numerical simulations ( carnevali et al 1981 ) .
at the same time , it became increasingly clear that mergers played an important role in the evolution of many , if not all , galaxies ( press & schechter 1974 , ostriker & tremaine 1975 ) .
compact groups emerged as prime locations for investigations of the dynamical evolution of galaxies .
motivated by the desire for a homogeneous sample that could be subject to statistical analysis , rose ( 1977 ) , and later , hickson ( 1982 ) produced the first catalogs of compact groups having specific , quantitative , selection criteria .
subsequent detailed investigation , at many wavelengths , has produced a large body of observational data for the hickson catalog . as a result , it has now become possible to address some of the outstanding questions concerning the nature of compact groups and their role in galaxy evolution . not surprisingly , new questions have been raised and new controversies have appeared .
however , much progress has been made in resolving both old and new issues .
this review is organized as follows : in section 2 , the definition of a compact group is discussed , along with methods of identification and surveys that have been made . in sections 3 - 5 ,
observed properties of these systems are summarized and discussed .
sections 6 and 7 focus mainly on interpretation of the observations , and on implications of these results .
all work on compact groups of galaxies can not possibly be discussed in this short paper , although an attempt is made to touch upon most current topics .
other recent reviews of compact groups and closely related subjects include those by white ( 1990 ) , hickson ( 1990 , 1997 ) , whitmore ( 1992 ) , kiseleva & orlov ( 1993 ) , sulentic ( 1993 ) , and mamon ( 1995 ) .
by `` compact group '' , we mean a small , relatively isolated , system of typically four or five galaxies in close proximity to one another .
such groups do not necessarily form a distinct class , but may instead be extreme examples of systems having a range of galaxy density and population . because of this , the properties of the groups in any particular sample may be strongly influenced by the criteria used to define the sample .
the early surveys used qualitative criteria that , while successful in finding many interesting individual objects , do not easily allow one to draw broad conclusions about the groups as a whole .
thus , the focus in recent years has been on samples selected using specific , quantitative , criteria .
these criteria define the minimum number and magnitude range of the galaxies , and also consider the galaxy spatial distribution .
the use of quantitative selection criteria was pioneered by rose ( 1977 ) who searched for groups that have three or more galaxies that are brighter than a limiting magnitude of 17.5 , and that have a projected surface density enhancement of a factor of 1000 compared to the surrounding background galaxy density . searching an area of 7.5% of the sky , he found 170 triplets , 33 quartets , and 2 quintets .
unfortunately , the sample received little follow - up study .
sulentic ( 1983 ) re - examined the 35 rose groups which contain four or more galaxies and found that only a third actually satisfied the selection criteria .
this is testimony to the difficulty of visual searches .
a more fundamental problem is that the fixed magnitude limit in the selection criteria makes the sample susceptible to strong distance - dependent biases .    in an attempt to reduce such effects , hickson ( 1982 , 1993 , 1994 ) adopted a relative magnitude criterion , selecting systems of four or more galaxies whose magnitudes differ by less than 3.0 .
a distance independent ( to first order ) compactness criterion was employed : @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the mean surface brightness of the group calculated by distributing the flux of the member galaxies over the smallest circular area containing their geometric centers . to avoid including the cores of rich clusters , an isolation criterion was necessary so as to reject the group if a non - member galaxy , not more than 3 mag fainter than the brightest member , occurred within three radii of the center of the circle .
( a non - member galaxy is a galaxy which if included in the group would cause the group to fail one or more of the selection criteria . ) from a search of 67% of the sky ( all the poss prints ) , and using magnitudes estimated from the poss red prints , exactly 100 groups were found satisfying these criteria ( hereafter hcg s ) .
as the hcg sample is now the most widely studied , it is important to examine the biases introduced by the criteria , and by the visual search procedure .    any sample selected on the basis of surface density will suffer from geometric and kinematic biases .
the former occurs because non - spherical systems will be preferentially selected if they are oriented to present a smaller cross - sectional area ( eg .
prolate systems pointed towards us ) ; the latter because we will preferentially select systems that , owing to galaxy orbital motion , are momentarily in a more compact state ( transient compact configurations ) .
thus , a compact group might result from a chance alignment or transient configuration within a loose group ( mamon 1986 ) .
this question will be considered in more detail in section 6.2 .
other biases arise from the subjective nature of the search procedure .
the original catalog contains a few mis - identifications , such as compact galaxies mistaken for stars , and marginal violations of the isolation criteria .
in addition , when photometry was obtained for the galaxies in the catalog ( hickson et al 1989 ) , it was found that some groups would not satisfy the selection criteria if photometric magnitudes are used .
attempts to rectify these problems have been made by hickson et al ( 1989 ) and sulentic ( 1997 ) .
however , it should be emphasized that changes , such as using photometric magnitudes in the selection criteria , are not corrections to the catalog , but are actually the imposition of _ additional _ a postiori selection criteria .
the resulting subsample is by no means complete because the new criteria are applied only to the visually - selected hcg catalog and not to the entire sky .
because of the difficulty of identifying faint groups , the hcg catalog starts to become significantly incomplete at an integrated magnitude of about 13 ( hickson et al 1989 , sulentic & rabaa 1994 ) . a more subtle effect results from the difficulty of recognizing low - surface - brightness groups .
because of this , the catalog also becomes incomplete at surface brightnesses fainter than 24 ( hickson 1982 ) .
yet another effect is that groups may be more noticeable if the magnitude spread of their members is small .
thus , the catalog may also be incomplete for magnitude intervals greater than about 1.5 ( prandoni et al 1994 ) .
these effects are of critical importance in statistical analyses of the sample .
one immediate conclusion is that the actual number of groups which satisfy the selection criteria may be considerably larger than the number found by a subjective search .
it has recently become feasible to find compact groups by automated techniques .
mamon ( 1989 ) used a computer to search tully s ( 1987 ) catalog of nearby galaxies and identified one new compact group , satisfying hickson s criteria , in the virgo cluster .
prandoni et al ( 1994 ) applied similar criteria to digital scans of @xmath6 deg@xmath7 around the southern galactic pole and detected 59 new southern compact groups ( scgs ) .
observations are presently underway to obtain accurate photometry and redshifts for this sample ( iovino private communication ) .
the digitized palomar sky survey ii also offers new opportunities for the identification of compact groups ( de carvalho & djorgovski 1995 ) .
an alternative approach is to identify groups of galaxies from redshift information , as was first done by humason et al ( 1956 ) . with the advent of large - scale redshift surveys ,
it has become possible to identify a reasonably - large sample of compact groups in this way .
barton et al ( 1996 ) have compiled a catalog of 89 redshift - selected compact groups ( rscgs ) found by means of a friends - of - friends algorithm applied to a complete magnitude - limited redshift survey .
galaxies having projected separations of @xmath8 kpc or less and line - of - sight velocity differences of 1000 km s@xmath3 or less are connected and the sets of connected galaxies constitute the groups . the numerical values were chosen to best match the characteristics of the hcg sample , and indeed , many of those rscgs that have at least four members are also hcgs .
there are some significant differences , however : because foreground and background galaxies are automatically eliminated by the velocity selection criteria , this technique is more effective at finding groups in regions of higher galaxy density , which would fail the hcg isolation criterion .
this criterion requires that the distance to the nearest neighbor be at least as large as the diameter of the group .
the rscg criteria , on the other hand , require only that the nearest - neighbor distance be larger than the threshold distance ( @xmath8 kpc for the rscgs ) , which may be considerably smaller
. it will therefore allow the inclusion of groups that are physically less isolated ( and therefore less physically distinct ) than would the hcg criterion .
one would also expect that the numbers of groups found in a given volume by the less - restrictive rscg criteria to be larger than by the hcg criteria , as seems to be the case . while the redshift - selection method compliments the hcg angular - selection technique , one should keep in mind that it also selects groups according to apparent ( projected ) density  the velocity information serves only to reject interlopers .
thus it will be subject to some of the biases discussed above . also ,
because the galaxy sample used is magnitude - limited , rather than volume - limited , there will be redshift - dependent biases in the rscgs .
however , the well - defined selection criteria and the completeness of the sample , should allow a quantitative determination of the effects of this bias .
the space distribution and environment of compact groups provides important clues to their nature .
the median redshift of the hcgs is @xmath9 , placing most of them at distances well beyond the virgo cluster ( hickson et al 1992 ) .
a cursory inspection reveals that they are fairly uniformly distributed and show no preference for rich clusters .
this is at least partly due to the isolation criterion .
however , galaxies in rich clusters have rather different kinematical and morphological properties than do those in compact groups , so one might justifiably argue that small clumps of galaxies within clusters are not compact groups .    a natural question is whether or not compact groups are associated with loose groups .
rood & struble ( 1994 ) observed that 70% of the hcgs are located within the bounds of cataloged loose groups and clusters .
studies of the distribution of galaxies in redshift space ( vennik et al 1993 , ramella et al 1994 , sakai et al 1994 , garcia 1995 , barton et al 1996 ) indicate that compact sub - condensations do occur within loose groups and filaments .
vennik et al ( 1993 ) and ramella et al ( 1994 ) find that most hcgs are indeed associated with loose groups .
while the above studies show that compact groups trace large - scale structure , it is also clear that they prefer low - density environments .
sulentic ( 1987 ) , rood & williams ( 1989 ) , kindl ( 1990 ) , and palumbo et al ( 1995 ) have examined the surface density of galaxies surrounding the groups .
they generally agree that about two - thirds groups show no statistically significant excess of nearby neighbors .
this is not inconsistent with the redshift - space results because most of the hcg associations identified by ramella et al ( 1996 ) contain fewer than 5 excess galaxies .
thus while compact groups are associated with loose groups and filaments , these tend to be low - density and sparsely - populated systems .
are the galaxies in compact groups in any way distinct from those in their immediate environments ?
rood & williams ( 1989 ) and kindl ( 1990 ) both found that compact groups , including those in rich environments , contain a significantly smaller fraction of late - type ( spiral and irregular ) galaxies than do their neighborhoods .
this result is of particular importance to the question of the physical nature of compact groups , discussed below in section 6 .
in addition , many independent studies have found significant differences between galaxies in compact groups and those in other environments .
these are examined in section 5 .
the first studies of individual compact groups ( burbidge & burbidge 1959 , 1961b , 1961c , burbidge & sargent 1971 , rose & graham 1979 , kirshner & malumuth 1980 ) indicated short dynamical times and mass - to - light ratios intermediate between those of galaxies and rich clusters . however , because of the small number of galaxies , estimates of the space velocities and physical separations of galaxies in individual groups are highly uncertain .
meaningful dynamical conclusions about systems containing only four or five galaxies requires statistical analysis of large homogeneous samples .    by 1992
, velocities had been measured for almost all 462 galaxies in the hcg catalog ( hickson et al 1992 ) .
the distribution of galaxy velocities , relative to the median of each group , is shown in figure 2 .
it can be seen that the majority of velocities fall within a roughly gaussian distribution of standard deviation @xmath10 km s@xmath3 ( the sharp peak at zero velocity results from the use of the median ) .
this characteristic velocity is quite similar to velocity dispersions found in loose groups , and much smaller than typical velocity dispersions in rich clusters .
in addition to the gaussian core , a flat component is seen in the velocity distribution of figure 2 .
this is expected as some galaxies which are not physically related to the group will appear projected on the group by chance .
this component contains about 25% of the total number of galaxies . whether of not chance projection
can account for such a large number of `` discordant '' galaxies is still a matter of some debate , and is discussed further in section 6.1 .    for a system of characteristic linear size @xmath11 and internal velocity @xmath12 ,
a characteristic dynamical time is @xmath13 .
a characteristic mass density is @xmath14 , from which one can estimate the total mass within the region occupied by the galaxies . after removing galaxies
whose velocities differ from the group median by more that 1000 km s@xmath3 , hickson et al ( 1992 ) found that @xmath15 and obtained a mean mass - to - light ratio of @xmath16 ( solar units ) for the hcgs .
similar values were found for several shakhbazian groups ( tikhonov 1986 , amirkhanian & egikian 1987 , amirkhanian 1989 , lynds et al 1990 , amirkhanian et al 1991 ) .
since the mass - to - light ratios of individual hcg galaxies is on the order of @xmath17 ( rubin et al 1991 ) , the galaxies appear to contain only @xmath18% of the total mass .
the spatial distribution and luminosities of the member galaxies provides further clues to the nature of compact groups .
if they are primarily projections or transient configurations , the luminosity function should be the same as that of the parent systems , and the spatial distribution of the galaxies should be consistent with a random distribution .
if they are bound physical systems , the luminosity function and spatial distribution might show features that reflect the origin or subsequent evolution of compact groups .
the shapes of compact groups were first investigated by arp ( 1973 ) who concluded that galaxy `` chains '' were unusually predominant . however , rose ( 1977 ) determined that the ellipticities of his groups were consistent with a random distribution of galaxies . using the larger hcg sample , hickson et al ( 1984 ) and
malykh & orlov ( 1986 ) reached the same conclusion as arp
the groups are typically more elongated than would be a random distribution of galaxies .
an immediate consequence of this result is that compact groups can not easily be explained as random projections or chance crossings , as this would largely erase any inherent ellipticity of a parent loose group . from static simulations ,
hickson et al ( 1984 ) concluded that the observed ellipticities are best matched by three - dimensional shapes that are intrinsically prolate .
the same result was found by oleak et al ( 1995 ) in a recent study of the shapes of 95 shakhbazian compact groups .
these conclusions , however , are not unique .
hickson et al ( 1984 ) also found the shapes to be consistent with those seen in dynamical simulations of compact groups seen in projection as subgroups within loose groups .
in addition , one must always be concerned about possible selection biases .
it may be that highly elongated groups ( such as vv 172 ) are more easily noticed in visual searches
. it will be interesting to see if these results are confirmed by studies of groups found by automated searches .
if the intrinsic shapes of compact groups are related to their formation process , one might expect to see a relationship between the orientation angle of a group and the environment .
palumbo et al ( 1993 ) examined the environments of the hcgs , and found that the orientations of the major axes of the groups were consistent with an isotropic distribution .
if compact groups are not simply projection effects , they might be expected to show a centrally - concentrated surface density profile , as is seen in clusters of galaxies . although the number of galaxies in individual compact groups is small , with a large sample it is possible to estimate a mean profile . by scaling and superimposing
the hcgs , hickson et al ( 1984 ) found evidence for central concentration .
mendes de oliveira & girard ( 1994 ) , using a similar analysis , concluded that the mean surface density profile is consistent with a king ( 1962 ) model with typical core radius of 15@xmath19 kpc .
most recently , montoya et al ( 1996 ) have analyzed the profiles of the 42 hcg quartets which have accordant redshifts .
their technique uses the distribution of projected pair separations and thus avoids assumptions about the location of the group center .
they find a smaller core radius ( @xmath20 kpc for a king model ) .
the fact that montoya et al ( 1996 ) find a consistent density profile for all groups , without any scaling , is particularly interesting .
this would not be expected if most groups are chance alignments within loose groups .
it also implies that compact groups have a unique scale , which seems counter to the concept of hierarchical clustering .
montoya et al ( 1996 ) suggest that this arises as a result of a minimum mass density and velocity dispersion that is required for the groups to be virialized ( mamon 1994 )
.      there have been several studies of the morphological types of galaxies in compact groups ( hickson 1982 , williams & rood 1987 , sulentic 1987 , hickson et al 1988b ) .
most studies agree that the fraction @xmath21 of late type galaxies is significantly less in compact groups than in the field .
hickson et al ( 1988b ) find @xmath22 for the hcgs ; prandoni et al ( 1994 ) obtain @xmath23 for the scgs .
both these values are substantially lower than those found for field galaxy samples ( @xmath24 , gisler 1980 , nilson 1973 ) .
also well established is morphological type concordance , observed in both the hcgs and scgs ( sulentic 1987 , hickson at al 1988b , prandoni et al 1994 ) .
a given compact group is more likely to contain galaxies of a similar type ( early or late ) than would be expected for a random distribution .
white ( 1990 ) has pointed out that such concordance could result from a correlation of morphological type with some other property of the group .
the strongest such correlation found to date is between morphological type and velocity dispersion ( hickson et al 1988b ) .
as figure 3 shows , groups with higher velocity dispersions contain fewer late - type ( gas - rich ) galaxies .
they also tend to be more luminous .
the importance of velocity dispersion , in addition to local density , on the galaxy morphology had previously been emphasized by de souza et al ( 1982 ) .
a crucial clue is that the morphology - density relation seen in clusters and loose groups ( dressler 1980 , postman & geller 1984 , whitmore & gilmore 1992 ) is not the dominant correlation in compact groups ( hickson et al 1988b ) , although some effect is present ( mamon 1986 ) .
this suggests that the velocity dispersion is more fundamental , ie of greater physical relevance to the formation and evolution of galaxies in compact groups , than is apparent physical density .
there is much evidence that interaction is occurring in a large fraction of galaxies in compact groups .
the strongest direct support comes from kinematical studies .
rubin et al ( 1991 ) found that two thirds of the 32 hcg spiral galaxies that they observed have peculiar rotation curves .
these show asymmetry , irregularity and in some cases extreme distortion , characteristic of strong gravitational interaction .
this result has recently been challenged by mendes de oliveira et al ( preprint ) who obtained h@xmath25 velocity maps for 26 hcg spiral galaxies and found that only 1/3 showed abnormal rotation curves .
they suggest that the difference is due to the more - complete spatial sampling of their data .    in their study ,
rubin et al ( 1991 ) observed 12 hcg elliptical galaxies and detected nuclear emission in 11 of them .
this high fraction suggests that interactions and mergers may be supplying gas to these galaxies .
this idea received independent support from radio observations in which neutral hydrogen emission was detected in three compact groups which contain only elliptical galaxies ( huchtmeier 1994 ) .
zepf & whitmore ( 1993 ) found that elliptical galaxies in compact groups tend to have lower internal velocity dispersions than do ellipticals in other environments having the same effective radii , absolute magnitudes and colors .
they therefore do not lie on the fundamental plane defined by other elliptical galaxies .
this discrepancy correlates with isophote shape in that those galaxies that have `` disky '' or irregular isophotes tend to have lower velocity dispersion .
both zepf & whitmore ( 1993 ) and bettoni & fasano ( 1993 , 1995 , 1996 , fasano & bettoni 1994 ) report that hcg elliptical galaxies are less likely to have `` boxy '' isophotes , and more likely to have irregular isophotes .
such effects are consistent with results of simulations of tidal encounters ( balcells & quinn 1990 ) .
the luminosity function of compact groups was first estimated by heiligman & turner ( 1980 ) .
they examined a sample consisting of stephan s quintet , seyfert s sextet and eight more compact groups from the arp and vorontsov - velyaminov catalogs , and concluded that compact groups contain relatively fewer faint galaxies than does a comparable field galaxy sample .
analysis of the relative luminosities within individual hcgs ( hickson 1982 ) , and studies of several shakhbazian groups ( kodaira et al 1991 ) , showed a similar effect , although tikhonov ( 1987 ) found a luminosity function similar to that of field and cluster galaxies .
the larger hcg sample allows the question of the galaxy content of compact groups to be addressed with greater certainty . the standard technique for determination of the luminosity function weights each galaxy by @xmath26 , where @xmath12 is the volume of the smallest geocentric sphere containing the group , and @xmath27 is the volume of the largest such sphere within which the group could have been detected . using this approach sulentic and rabaa ( 1994 )
obtained a luminosity function for hcg galaxies similar to that of field galaxies .
however , mendes de oliveira and hickson ( 1991 ) argued that the standard calculation does not address the selection effects of the hcg sample .
for example , the luminosity range within an individual group is limited by the 3-mag range of the selection criteria .
because of this , fainter galaxies within compact groups are not included in the catalog . in order to account for such biases they used a modeling technique in which galaxies were drawn from a trial luminosity function and assigned to groups .
redshifts were given to each group according to the observed distribution , and groups that failed to meet the hcg selection criteria were rejected .
the luminosity distribution of the resulting galaxy sample was then compared to the observations and the process repeated with different trial luminosity functions .
their best - fit luminosity function is deficient in faint galaxies , although a normal field - galaxy luminosity function is not excluded .    to avoid the selection problem , ribeiro et al ( 1994 ) obtained deeper photometry for a subsample of the hcgs in order to include the fainter galaxies explicitly .
since redshifts are not known for these galaxies , a correction for background contamination was made statistically .
the luminosity function that they obtained is similar to that of field galaxies .
most recently , the luminosity function for the rscgs has been computed by barton et al ( 1996 ) .
they find it to be mildly inconsistent with that of field - galaxies , in the same sense as that of mendes de oliveira & hickson ( 1991 ) for the hcgs .
figure 4 summarizes these estimates of the luminosity function of compact galaxies in terms of the schechter ( 1976 ) parameters @xmath28 and @xmath29 .
how do we interpret these apparently conflicting results ?
prandoni et al ( 1994 ) have argued that the hcg catalog is biased toward groups with a small magnitude range @xmath30 , because the scgs have a larger fraction of high @xmath30 groups .
however , it is not known what fraction of such groups are physically real , as few redshifts have yet been obtained .
such a bias could affect the luminosity function of mendes de oliveira & hickson ( 1991 ) , particularly at the faint end , but it is not evident that the bias is sufficient to account for the apparent faint - galaxy deficit .
on the other hand , the small sample used by ribeiro et al ( 1994 ) may not be representative of compact groups in general .
hickson ( 1997 ) points out that the ribeiro et al ( 1994 ) sample has a spiral fraction of 0.60 , substantially higher than that of the whole hcg catalogue , and contains 7 of the 16 hcgs found to be in a high density environment by palumbo et al ( 1995 ) .
this suggests that the their sample has more than the usual amount of field galaxy contamination .
de carvalho et al ( 1994 ) , note that the faint galaxies form a more extended distribution than do the brighter galaxies .
thus they may be a dynamically distinct component , or simply unrelated field galaxies .
finally , the redshift - selected rscg sample also shows mild evidence for a faint galaxy deficiency .
while the faint end of the lf in compact groups appears to be depleted , there is evidence that the bright end may be enhanced .
limber and matthews ( 1960 ) were the first to remark that `` the members of stephan s quintet are to be classed among the brightest of galaxies '' .
it is possible that this may be in part due to interaction - induced star formation , at least for the spiral galaxies . on the other hand mendes
de oliveira & hickson ( 1991 ) compared their luminosity function of elliptical galaxies in compact groups with those in the virgo and coma clusters ( as reported by sandage et al 1985 and thompson & gregory 1980 ) and found that that the compact - group ellipticals have a luminosity enhancement of more than 1 mag compared to cluster ellipticals .
sulentic and rabaa ( 1994 ) find a similar enhancement in their morphological - type - specific luminosity function .
this suggests that compact group elliptical galaxies may have a unique formation mechanism .    from the luminosity function
, one can estimate the contribution of compact groups of galaxies @xmath31 to the total galaxian luminosity density @xmath32 .
mendes de oliveira & hickson ( 1991 ) obtained a ratio of @xmath33 . applying the same analysis to the luminosity function of ribeiro et al ( 1994 ) gives a ratio of 3.3% .
for the rscgs , the figure is comparable : for groups of four or more galaxies , barton et al ( 1996 ) obtain a compact group abundance of @xmath34 mpc@xmath3 which leads to a luminosity density ratio of approximately 3% .
these are surprisingly high figures considering the short dynamical times of most compact groups .
evidence is accumulating that tidal interactions play an important role in triggering starburst activity in galaxies ( eg .
maccagni et al 1990 , campos - aguilar & moles 1991 , kormendy & sanders 1992 , sanders & mirabel 1996 ) .
compact groups , with their high galaxy density and evident signs of galaxy interaction should be ideal systems in which to study such effects .
many hcgs do in fact contain galaxies showing starbursts or harboring active galactic nuclei ( agn ) . for example , hcg 16 is found to contain a seyfert 2 galaxy , two liners , and three starburst galaxies ( ribeiro et al 1996 ) .
hcg 31 contains five galaxies showing signs of recent starburst activity ( rubin et al 1990 , iglesias - pramo & vlchez preprint ) .
seyfert galaxies are also found in hcg 77 , 92 , 93 and 96 .
the general degree of star formation activity in compact group galaxies can be determined from infrared observations . to date
, studies have been based primarily on data from the iras satellite .
hickson et al ( 1989 ) found sources in 40 hcg from a search of the point source catalog .
they concluded that the ratio of far - infrared - to - optical luminosity is greater by about a factor of two in compact group galaxies , compared to that of isolated galaxies .
this result was disputed by sulentic and de mello rabaa ( 1993 ) who argued that the low spatial resolution of the data made the assignment of infrared flux to individual galaxies ambiguous .
they concluded that redistribution of the flux could result in little or no infrared enhancement , a conclusion echoed by venugopal ( 1995 ) .
however , in cases of doubt , hickson et al ( 1989 ) identified the infrared galaxy on the basis of radio emission .
the well - known correlation between infrared and radio continuum emission makes it unlikely that the results are much in error .
analysis of improved data ( eg . allam et al 1996 ) should soon resolve questions about the identifications and infrared fluxes .
the resolution problem can be avoided by considering the infrared colors of the sources instead of the infrared / optical ratio .
zepf ( 1993 ) compared the ratio of 60 @xmath35 m to 100 @xmath35 m fluxes of compact group galaxies with those of isolated galaxies and also with those of galaxies believed to be currently merging .
he found that the compact group sample was significantly different from both other samples , and estimated that about 1/3 of the compact group galaxies had warm colors ( larger 60/100 @xmath35 m ratios ) similar to those of merging galaxies .
another approach to interpreting the infrared results was taken by menon ( 1991 ) who emphasized that the strong correlation between radio and infrared radiation indicates that these likely originate from a common region . in compact group spirals the radio emission is primarily nuclear whereas in isolated spirals it originates in the disk .
if this is also true for the infrared flux , there must be an enhancement of the infrared / optical ratio , in the nuclear region , of more than an order of magnitude .
this idea is supported by recent millimeter - wavelength observations ( menon et al 1996 ) in which co emission is detected in 55 of 70 iras - selected hcg galaxies . the inferred ratio of infrared luminosity - to - h@xmath36 mass showed an enhancement which correlates with the projected nearest - neighbor distance .
further clues are provided by radio continuum studies .
nonthermal emission from spiral galaxies can arise from both disk and nuclear sources .
disk emission is predominantly due to supernova remnants and is thus related to the star formation rate .
nuclear emission can arise both from star formation and from an active nucleus .
menon ( 1995 ) observed 133 spiral galaxies in 68 hcg , and found that overall they typically show less continuum emission than those in isolated environments , which is consistent with the neutral hydrogen observations .
however , when considering the nuclear regions alone , the radio emission is found to be an order of magnitude higher compared to isolated spirals .
the implication is that star formation and/or agn activity is substantially enhanced in the nuclear regions of many compact group spiral galaxies .
this is generally consistent with a picture in which galaxy interactions remove gas from the outer regions of galaxies , while simultaneously allowing gas to flow inwards toward the nucleus , resulting in enhanced star formation in the nuclear region , and possibly fueling an active nucleus .
although there is a clear example of tidal interaction stimulating disk radio emission in at least one compact group ( menon 1995a ) , statistical evidence for a link between interactions and radio emission in compact groups is only now accumulating .
if interactions are stimulating nuclear radio emission , one would expect the radio luminosity to be correlated with some index describing the degree of interaction such as the projected distance to the nearest neighbor .
evidence in support of this was found by vettolani & gregorini ( 1988 ) who observed that early - type galaxies which have a high ratio of radio - to - optical emission show an excess of nearby neighbors .
a similar effect was observed by malumian ( 1996 ) for spiral galaxies in groups .
examining compact group galaxies , menon ( 1992 ) found that elliptical and s0 galaxies detected at a wavelength of 20 cm had closer neighbors than the undetected galaxies .
the effect was not found for spiral galaxies , but if one considers only the detected galaxies , there is a significant correlation between radio - to - optical luminosity and nearest neighbor distance for both early and late type galaxies ( tk menon , private communication ) .
continuum radio emission has also been detected in a number of hcg elliptical galaxies . unlike those found in cluster ellipticals , the radio sources are low - luminosity and compact . where spectral indices are available
, they indicate that the radio emission arises from an agn rather than from starburst activity ( tk menon , private communication ) . in the hcg sample
, there is a significant preference for radio - loud elliptical galaxies to be first - ranked optically ( menon & hickson 1985 , menon 1992 ) .
the probability of radio emission does not correlate with absolute luminosity , but instead correlates with _ relative _ luminosity within a group .
spiral hcg galaxies do not show this effect . although the tendency of radio galaxies in rich clusters to be first - ranked has been known for many years , it is surprising to find a similar effect in small groups , where the number of galaxies and luminosity range is small
, the gravitational potential well is much less clearly defined , and it is unlikely that any individual galaxy holds a central location . the effect of optical rank on radio emission had been previously noted in other small groups by tovmasian et al ( 1980 ) although these authors made no distinction between elliptical and spiral galaxies .
it is difficult to imagine any explanation for this result in which the compact group is not a true physical system .
it would appear that , regardless of absolute luminosity , only the first - ranked ( presumably the most massive in the group ) elliptical galaxy can develop a radio source .
stars stripped from galaxies by tidal forces should accumulate in the potential well of the group . and may be detectable as diffuse light . in an early photographic study , rose ( 1979 ) found no evidence for diffuse light in his groups , and was lead to the conclusion that most of his groups must be transient configurations .
however , bergvall et al ( 1981 ) were successful in detecting ionized gas and a common halo around a compact quartet of interacting early - type galaxies , and evidence for a common halo in vv 172 was reported by sulentic & lorre ( 1983 ) .
diffuse light can clearly be seen in hcg 94 , and has been found in hcg 55 ( sulentic 1987 ) , but pildis et al ( 1995b ) did not detect any in seven other compact groups .
analysis by mamon ( 1986 ) indicated that while the expected diffuse light should be detectable with modern techniques , it would generally be very faint .
estimates of the total amount of diffuse light in the detected groups are rather uncertain as they depend sensitively on subtraction of the galactic light , and the sky background .
deeper photometry and improved image processing techniques may yet reveal diffuse light in other compact groups ( sulentic 1997 ) .
the mass and distribution of cool galactic and intergalactic gas , can be obtained from observations of the 21-cm line of neutral hydrogen .
the first such study of a large sample of compact groups is that of williams & rood ( 1987 ) who found a median hi mass of @xmath37 .
they concluded that compact groups are typically deficient in neutral hydrogen by about a factor of two compared to loose groups .
this effect is consistent with similar deficit in continuum radio emission seen in the disks of compact group spiral galaxies ( menon 1995 ) , and suggests that interactions in compact groups has removed much of the gas from the galaxies .
simulations suggest that in addition to an outflow of gas , inflow also occurs which may fuel nuclear star - formation , as suggested by the strongly - enhanced radio emission seen in the nuclear regions of compact group spiral galaxies ( menon 1995 ) .
high - resolution studies of individual groups ( williams & van gorkom 1988 , williams et al 1991 ) showed clearly that the gas is not confined to the galaxies . in two of
three groups studied , the radio emission originates from a common envelope surrounding the group and in the third group there are signs of tidal distortion . these results strongly indicate that at least these compact groups are physically dense systems and not chance alignments or transient configurations in loose groups .
they also show that many groups have evolved to the point that gas contained within individual galaxies has been distributed throughout the group .
in contrast to the hi results , initial co - line observations of 15 compact - group galaxies ( boselli et al 1996 ) indicated a normalized molecular gas content similar to that of isolated spiral galaxies .
however , this result is based on normalizing the flux by the optical area of the galaxy , rather than by the infrared luminosity , and may be biased by the relatively small sizes of compact - group galaxies .
further co studies , currently in progress , should soon settle this question .
x - ray observations of hot gas in clusters of galaxies can reveal the amount , distribution , temperature and metallicity of the gas , as well as the relative amount and distribution of the total gravitating mass .
temperature , metallicity ( fraction of solar abundance ) , and bolometric luminosities are estimated by fitting a spectral model , such as that of raymond & smith ( 1977 ) to the data .
x - ray emission from compact `` poor clusters '' was first reported by schwartz et al ( 1980 ) , who concluded that their x - ray properties were similar to those of rich clusters . using the einstein observatory , bahcall et al ( 1984 )
first detected x - ray emission from stephan s quintet .
the x - ray map revealed that the emission is diffuse and not centered on individual galaxies .
however , we now know that most of this emission is associated with a shock front rather than gas trapped in the group potential well ( sulentic et al 1995 ) .
although several other groups ( bahcall et al 1984 , biermann & kronberg 1984 ) were detected by the einstein observatory , further progress required the improved sensitivity of the rosat x - ray observatory
.    pointed rosat observations revealed massive hydrogen envelopes surrounding the ngc 2300 group , a bright elliptical - spiral pair with two fainter members ( mulchaey et al 1993 ) , and hcg 62 , a compact quartet of early - type galaxies ( ponman & bertram 1993 ) , and showed that these systems are dominated by dark matter .
subsequent investigations detected x - rays from 18 additional compact groups , either from individual galaxies , or from diffuse gas ( ebeling et al 1994 , pildis et al 1995a , sarraco & ciliegi 1995 , sulentic et al 1995 ) .
these studies showed that the physical properties of individual systems span a wide range , but that the ratio of gas - to - stellar mass is significantly lower than in rich clusters .
moreover , the detected compact groups all contained a majority of early - type galaxies .
no spiral - rich groups were detected ( although mulchaey et al 1996b pointed out that they might be found from qso absorption spectra ) .
this result is consistent with the fact that x - ray - selected groups ( henry et al 1995 ) and loose groups ( mulchaey et al 1996a ) tend to be spiral poor , and led to the suggestion that spiral - rich compact groups might not be physically dense systems at all .
the most extensive x - ray study of compact groups to date is that of ponman et al ( 1996 ) .
these authors combined pointed and survey - mode observations of a complete sample of 85 hcgs and detected diffuse emission in 22 groups .
they conclude that , when the detection limits are considered , diffuse emission is present in at least 75% of the systems .
significantly , they detected diffuse emission in several spiral - rich groups . in these
the surface brightness is lower and the x - ray emission has a lower characteristic temperature , as would be expected given the lower velocity dispersions of spiral - rich compact groups .
the diffuse x - ray luminosity was found to correlate with temperature , velocity dispersion , and spiral fraction , but not with optical luminosity .
the last result suggests that the gas is mostly primordial and not derived from the galaxies .
the correlations with temperature and velocity dispersion appear to be consistent with a single relation for clusters and groups ( figure 5 ) .
the total mass in compact groups typically exceeds the stellar and gas mass by an order of magnitude .
pildis et al ( 1995 ) derived baryon fractions of 12 - 19% .
davis et al ( 1996 ) obtains 10 - 16% for the ngc 2300 group . these are comparable to the fractions found for poor clusters ( dellantonio et al ( 1995 ) and are about half the typical values found for rich clusters
. however , the derived baryon fraction depends sensitively on the radius within which it is measured and on the assumed background level ( henriksen & mamon 1994 ) .
both the total mass , which is dominated by dark matter , and the gas mass continue to increase with radius . consequently , both the baryon fraction and the gas fraction are poorly determined .
the contribution of compact groups to the x - ray luminosity function has been estimated by pbeb , who find that on the order of 4% of the total luminosity in the range @xmath38 erg s@xmath3 comes from hcgs .
this is higher than the contribution of hcg galaxies to the local optical luminosity density estimated at 0.8% by mendes de oliveira & hickson ( 1991 ) , but it is comparable to the value found by ribeiro et al ( 1994 ) .
the metallicity inferred for the x - ray - emitting gas in compact groups is relatively low .
pbeb obtain a mean metallicity of 0.18 solar , compared to the value , 0.3 - 0.4 solar , found in rich clusters .
this is comparable to the low value ( @xmath39 solar ) found for the ngc 2300 group ( davis et al 1996 ) .
these figures suggest that the gas is largely primordial , a result supported by the absence of a correlation between x - ray and optical luminosity .
however , given the limited spectral resolution of rosat , these low metalicities can not yet be considered secure . the higher spectral resolution and sensitivity of the asca satellite
should provide more definitive results .
recent observations of hcg 51 and the ngc 5044 group found metal abundances comparable to those of clusters ( fukazawa et al 1996 ) .
the nature of the discordant redshift members of compact groups has been a subject of debate for many years ( eg .
burbidge & burbidge 1961a , burbidge & sargent 1971 , nottale & moles 1978 , sulentic 1983 ) .
if the frequency of discordant galaxies is inconsistent with the statistics of chance projection , it might signify the need for new physical theories ( arp 1987 ) , or for gravitational amplification of background galaxies ( hammer & nottale 1986 ) .
initial estimates of the chance probability of finding discordant galaxies in groups like stephan s quintet , seyfert s sextet and vv 172 , were very small ( burbidge & sargent 1971 ) .
however , such probabilities were recognized to be difficult to determine reliably , because the a priori probability of _ any _ particular configuration of galaxies is also very small ( burbidge & sargent 1971 ) . only with a well - defined sample of groups and a complete characterization of selection effects ,
can meaningful estimates of the probabilities be made .
the explicit selection criteria of the hcg catalog in principal makes this sample suitable for a quantitative statistical investigation of the discordant - redshift question . sulentic ( 1987 )
first concluded that the number of discordant redshifts in the catalog is too large to explain by chance . on the other hand ,
hickson et al 1988a and mendes de oliveira ( 1995 ) , applying the selection criteria more rigorously , found no strong statistical evidence for this . their result
, however , may be biased by incompleteness in the hcg catalog : there seem to be too - few low surface brightness groups in the catalog , and the `` missing '' groups may have a higher fraction of discordant redshifts ( sulentic 1997 ) .    in order to address the incompleteness issue , iovino & hickson ( 1996 ) combined observational results from both the hcg and scg catalogs with monte - carlo simulations .
their technique exploits the unbiased nature of the scg catalog and the complete redshift coverage of the hcg sample .
they conclude that for all except the two highest - surface - brightness quintets ( stephan s quintet and seyfert s sextet ) , the number of discordant redshifts is consistent with chance projections .
for these two , the chance probabilities are low . however , for both of these systems there is independent physical evidence that the discordant galaxies are at the cosmological distances that correspond to their redshifts and are therefore not group members ( kent 1981 , wu et al 1994 ) .
one should not assume that the situation is now completely settled .
further studies will be possible when redshifts have been obtained for the scg galaxies .
there are still other questions that have not been adequately addressed , such as reported redshift quantization ( cocke & tifft 1983 ) .
however , at this point it appears that the frequency of discordant galaxies does not require a new interpretation of galaxy redshifts .
in fact , physical evidence suggests the opposite .
the discordant galaxies all have physical properties consistent with a cosmological distance .
for example those with higher redshift tend to be smaller and fainter than other members of the group , and vice versa ( mendes de oliveira 1995 ) .      because we can measure only three phase - space dimensions for galaxies in compact groups ( two components of position and one of velocity ) , the groups are subject to projection effects . because of this , they may not be physically dense , or even physically related systems .
the following interpretations have so far been suggested for compact groups :    1 .   transient dense configurations ( rose 1977 ) 2 .   isolated bound dense configurations ( sulentic 1987 , hickson & rood 1988 ) 3 .
chance alignments in loose groups ( mamon 1986 , walke & mamon 1989 , mamon 1995 ) 4 .
filaments seen end - on ( hernquist et al 1995 ) 5 .   bound dense configurations within loose groups ( diaferio et al 1994 , governato et al 1996 )    evidence for and against physical association and high density in the hcg sample , to 1988 , was summarized by hickson & rood ( 1988 ) , and by walke and mamon ( 1989 ) respectively . since that time , several new results have emerged . from an analysis of optical images , mendes
de oliveira & hickson ( 1994 ) concluded that 43% of all hcg galaxies show morphological features indicative of interaction and/or merging , and that 32% of all hcgs contain three or more interacting galaxies .
these percentages are likely to rise with more - detailed studies and sophisticated image analysis ( longo et al 1994 ) .
this high frequency of interactions observed in compact groups is difficult to reconcile with the chance alignment and filament hypotheses , even if the alignments contain physical binaries ( mamon 1995 ) .
the high fraction of hcgs showing diffuse x - ray emission is very strong evidence that a large fraction of these systems are physically dense , and are not transient configurations or projection effects . although the exact numbers are not final , due to the faintness of the sources and the problems of contamination by sources associated with the individual galaxies , it seems evident that many groups are dense bound systems .
the correlations seen between x - ray and optical properties , and the fact that the x - ray properties of compact groups are not inconsistent with those of clusters reinforces this conclusion .
ostriker et al ( 1995 ) have argued that the relatively low x - ray luminosities of compact groups might not be due to a low gas fraction , but instead could be understood if the groups are filaments seen in projection ( hernquist et al 1995 ) . however , ponman et al ( 1996 ) point out that in order to explain even the fainter compact groups , gas temperatures @xmath40 kev and densities @xmath41 @xmath42 would be required . these appear to be ruled out by both observations ( briel & henry 1995 ) and simulations ( diaferio et al 1995 , pildis et al 1996 ) .
even if compact groups are physically dense , they may not be as dense as they appear .
as mentioned in section 2 , a sample of groups selected on the basis of high apparent density will be biased by the inclusion of looser systems which appear more compact due to geometrical or kinematic effects .
is this bias large ?
its magnitude can be estimated as follows : consider @xmath43 galaxies randomly located within a circle of radius @xmath11 on the sky .
what is the probability @xmath44 that they will fall within some circular subarea of radius @xmath45 ?
the answer can be obtained using analytic expressions derived by walke & mamon ( 1989 ) . from their equations 1 and 6 ( setting @xmath46 and @xmath47 ) we obtain f(x , n ) = n!^n _ 0^x dr _ 0 ^ 1-r d where dn = 2^n-1 n r^2n-3(n-2 ) !
2ddr is the number of possible configurations with radius between @xmath48 and @xmath49 and distance from the center between @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
here we have neglected a small edge contribution that is unimportant for small values of @xmath52 ( walke and mamon s case 3 ) .
this gives f(x , n ) = n^2 x^2n-2 now , an observer would infer a galaxy space density that is higher by a factor @xmath53 , so the average apparent space density enhancement is < > & = & _ 0 ^ 1 dx + & = & _ 0 ^ 1 n^2 x^2n-5 dx + & = & 2n^2(n-1)(2n-5)(2n-3)(n-2 ) thus we expect to typically overestimate the space density by about a factor of 12.0 for triplets ( or quartets containing a physical binary ) , 3.2 for true quartets and 2.0 for quintets .
a key question that remains is the position of compact groups in the clustering hierarchy .
are compact groups distinct entities ( sulentic 1987 ) or an intermediate stage between loose groups and triplets , pairs and individual galaxies ( barnes 1989 , white 1990 , cavaliere et al 1991 , rampazzo & sulentic 1992 , diaferio et al 1994 ) .
some compact groups are purely projection effects , others may be small clusters ( ebeling et al 1995 ) , but most appear to be real .
it seems that they can arise naturally from subcondensations in looser groups , but further studies are needed to better determine both the observed space density of groups as a function of population and the timescales involved in the evolutionary process .
this question is related to that of the formation mechanism of compact groups .
two mechanisms have been discussed in the literature .
diaferio et al ( 1994 ) conclude that compact groups form continually from bound subsystems within loose groups .
this gains some support from the observation ( see section 3 ) that most hcgs are embedded in loose groups , although it is not obvious that these loose groups are sufficiently rich ( sulentic 1997 ) .
governato et al ( 1996 ) , proposed a model in which merging activity in compact groups is accompanied by infall of galaxies from the environment .
this naturally explains the observed mix of morphological types , and it allows compact groups to persist for longer times .    where do the shakhbazian groups fit in this picture ?
recent studies ( tikhonov 1986 , amirkhanian & egikian 1987 , amirkhanian et al 1988 , 1991 , amirkhanian 1989 , kodaira et al 1988 - 91 , stoll et al 1993 - 1996 ) show that these objects are typically compact clusters or groups of early - type galaxies .
although the systems were selected on the basis of red colors and compact appearance of their galaxies , both of these factors result from their large distances because k - corrections and contrast effects become significant .
the galaxies are in fact relatively normal , although luminous ( del olmo et al 1995 ) .
however , the number of blue ( gas rich ) galaxies in these systems does seem to be very small .
thus it appears the shakhbazian groups are mostly small clusters , possibly intermediate in physical properties between classical compact groups and clusters .
if the groups are dynamically bound , galaxy mergers should commence within a few dynamical times ( carnevali et al 1981 , ishizawa et al 1983 , barnes 1985 , ishizawa 1986 , mamon 1987 , 1990 , zheng et al 1993 ) . both n - body and hydrodynamic simulations indicate that the dark matter halos of individual galaxies merge first , creating a massive envelope within which the visible galaxies move ( barnes 1984 , bode et al 1993 ) .
kinematic studies of loose groups ( eg .
puche & carignan 1991 ) indicate that the dark matter is concentrated around the individual optical galaxies .
in contrast , the x - ray observations indicate that in most compact groups , the gas and dark matter is more extended and is decoupled from the galaxies .
this may explain the observation that galaxies in compact groups typically have mass - to - light ratios 30% to 50% lower than more isolated galaxies ( rubin et al 1991 ) .
is there any observational evidence that galaxies in compact groups are merging ? by 1982 it was evident that first - ranked galaxies in compact groups did not appear to be merger products , because the fraction of first - ranked galaxies that are type e or s0 is the same as for the general population of hcg galaxies ( hickson 1982 ) .
if mergers were a dominant effect , the first - ranked galaxies would be expected to be more often elliptical .
the same conclusion was reached by geller & postman ( 1983 ) who found that the luminosities of first - ranked galaxies were consistent with a single luminosity distribution for all group galaxies . of course
this may just mean that in small groups the first - ranked galaxy is not necessarily the most evolved .
rather , one should ask if _ any _ galaxies in compact groups show indications of merging .
the relative paucity of merging galaxies in compact groups was first noted by tikhonov ( 1987 ) , from a visual inspection of optical images .
zepf & whitmore ( 1991 ) realized that elliptical galaxies formed by recent mergers of gas - rich systems should have bluer colors than normal .
examining the hcgs , they found only a small enhancement in the fraction of early - type galaxies having blue colors , a conclusion reinforced by an independent study by moles et al ( 1994 ) . on
the other hand , caon et al ( 1994 ) argued that the large effective radii of compact group elliptical galaxies is indicative of an origin by merging or accretion of companions .
zepf ( 1993 ) estimated that roughly 7% of the galaxies in compact groups are in the process of merging .
this conclusion was based on roughly consistent frequencies of _ ( a ) _ optical signatures of merging , _
( b ) _ warm far - infrared colors , and _
( c ) _ sinusoidal rotation curves .
however , few galaxies show all of these effects simultaneously
. the merging fraction may thus be as high as 25% if one allows that any one of these criteria would be considered to be sufficient to indicate a merger ( hickson 1997 ) .
given the small numbers of objects in these studies , it is fair to say that the fraction of merging galaxies is highly uncertain at present .
it seems safe to conclude that current observations do not rule out a significant amount of merging in compact groups .
detailed studies of individual compact groups can be quite revealing .
many galaxies that at first appear normal are revealed to have peculiar morphology or spectra when examined more closely .
many , perhaps most , compact groups clearly contain galaxies that are dynamically interacting .
however , the groups likely span a range of evolutionary states . at the extreme end
are high - density groups like seyfert s sextet , hcg 31 , hcg 62 , hcg 94 ( pildis 1995 ) and hcg 95 ( rodrigue et al 1995 ) in which we find strong gravitational interactions . at the other end
are lower density compact groups , such as hcg 44 , which most likely are in a less - advanced stage of evolution .
this picture is supported by radio observations : seyfert s sextet and hcg 31 are both embedded in extended hi clouds whereas in hcg 44 the hi is associated with individual galaxies ( williams et al 1991 ) .
it seems clear that the groups as we now see them can persist for only a fraction of a hubble time .
simulations indicate that merging should destroy the group on a time scale @xmath54 that is typically an order of magnitude larger than @xmath55 , depending on the distribution of dark matter ( cavaliere et al 1983 , barnes 1984 , navarro et al 1987 , kodaira et al 1990 ) and initial conditions ( governato et al 1991 ) . assuming that the groups are in fact bound dynamical systems
, we can draw two conclusions : _ ( a ) _ there must be an ongoing mechanism for forming or replacing compact groups , and _ ( b )
_ there must be a significant population of relics of merged groups .
what are the end - products of compact groups ?
it is tempting to identify them with field elliptical galaxies , following a suggestion first made by toomre ( 1977 ) .
simulations ( weil & hernquist 1994 ) indicate that multiple mergers in small groups of galaxies best reproduce the observed kinematical properties of elliptical galaxies . the resulting galaxies are predicted to possess small kinematic misalignments , which can be detected by detailed spectroscopic and photometric studies .
neverthess , it remains to be demonstrated that these merger remnants can reproduce the tight correlation between size , luminosity and velocity dispersion found in present - day elliptical galaxies .
if compact groups have lifetimes on the order of @xmath54 , and form continuously , then the number of relics , per observed group , is expected to be on the order of @xmath56 .
thus , the number of relics could exceed that of present day groups by as much as an order of magnitude .
mamon ( 1986 ) estimated that , if all hcgs are real , then the relics would account for about 25% of luminous field elliptical galaxies . as we have seen , the true space density of compact groups is uncertain by at least a factor of two , and may be underestimated because of selection biases .
there is then the potential problem of producing too many relics .
a second problem is the fact that the integrated luminosities of compact groups are typically a factor of three to four times greater than luminosities of isolated elliptical galaxies ( sulentic and rabaa 1994 ) .
it is possible that interaction - induced star formation has boosted the luminosities of some compact - group galaxies , and that some degree of fading of the merger product is expected .
however , at this point it is not clear whether or not the relics can be identified with isolated elliptical galaxies .    despite these problems , a fossil compact group may have actually been found .
ponman et al ( 1995 ) have detected a luminous isolated elliptical galaxy surrounded by diffuse x - ray emission which is consistent with the expected end - product of a compact group .
if more objects like this are found , it may be possible to compare their space density with that expected for compact group relics .
interactions are often implicated in the development of active nuclei in galaxies ( eg .
freudling & almudena prieto 1996 ) .
the hcg catalog includes several examples of compact groups containing both starburst galaxies and agn .
several recent examples of associations between starburst galaxies or agn and what appear to be compact groups have been reported : del olmo & moles ( 1991 ) have found a broad - line agn in shakhbazian 278 ; zou et al ( 1995 ) find that the luminous infrared source iras 23532 coincides with a compact group that includes a seyfert 1 as well as a starburst galaxy .
if this association extends to qsos , one would expect to find numerous compact groups at redshifts @xmath57 , where the comoving number density of qsos peaks ( eg .
hartwick & schade 1984 ) .
the tendency for qsos to have close companions has been known for some time ( eg . stockton 1982 , bahcall et al 1997 ) . recently
, several examples of compact groups associated with luminous infrared galaxies , agn and qsos at @xmath58 have been found using hst ( pascarelle et al 1996 , francis et al 1996 , matthews et al 1994 , tsuboi & nakai 1994 , hutchings 1995 , hutchings et al 1995 ) .
these observations provide support to the idea that tidally - triggered star formation is a predominant factor in the galaxy formation process ( lacey & silk 1991 , lacey et al 1993 ) . in this model disk star formation
occurs relatively late , after the compact group has formed and tidal interactions are strong .
this seems at least qualitatively consistent with the fragmentary nature of high - redshift galaxies observed with the hubble space telescope ( schade et al 1995 ) , although these fragments appear to be much less luminous and more irregular than most present - day compact group galaxies . the model also offers a possible explanation for the excess numbers of faint blue galaxies found in field galaxy count as dwarf galaxies undergoing star formation at a redshift of @xmath59 .
compact groups may possibly play a role in the formation of other systems .
we have seen that giant galaxies may be formed as the end product of compact - group evolution . at the other end of the scale ,
dwarf galaxies have physical properties distinct from normal galaxies , which suggests a unique formation mechanism .
one possibility is that they form during gravitational interactions from tidal debris ( duc & mirabel 1994 ) .
if this is the case , one would expect to find evidence for this in compact groups of galaxies .
from an examination of condensations in tidal tails , hunsberger et al ( 1996 ) concluded that the fraction of dwarf galaxies produced within tidal debris in compact groups is not negligible .
there is also evidence that star clusters form from tidal debris .
longo et al ( 1995 ) have found an excess population of unresolved blue objects around hcg 90 which appear to be recently formed star clusters .
these may be similar to the population of new star clusters recently reported in the merger remnant ngc 7252 ( whitmore et al 1993 ) .
because compact groups have a high galaxy surface density , they may form effective gravitational lenses .
gravitational amplification of background field galaxies was proposed by hammer and nottale ( 1986 ) as a possible explanation for the presence of the high - redshift discordant member of this group .
mendes de oliveira and giraud ( 1994 ) and montoya et al ( 1996 ) find that most hcgs are too nearby to produce strong lensing effects .
however , because the critical mass density required for strong lensing depends reciprocally on distance , analogous systems 5 - 10 times more distant should produce a non - negligible fraction of giant arcs .
studies of small groups may provide clues to the overall structure of the universe .
the baryon fractions found in clusters of galaxies appear to be inconsistent with a density parameter @xmath60 , unless the dark matter is more prevalent outside clusters ( white 1992 , babul & katz 1993 ) .
compact groups provide a means to study dark matter in such regions .
the baryon fractions found for compact groups do appear to be lower than those for clusters .
david et al ( 1995 ) argued that the gas is the most extended component ; galaxies being the most compact and the dark matter being intermediate .
they concluded that the baryon fraction approaches 30% on large enough scales , which is comparable to the values found for clusters .
given the constraints of standard big - bang nucleosynthesis this would imply that the density parameter @xmath61 is at most 0.2 .
on the other hand , the infall picture of compact - group evolution ( governato et al 1996 ) requires a high - density @xmath62 universe . in a low - density universe
the infall rate is insufficient .
as there is at present no other clear mechanism for avoiding the overproduction of relics by merging compact groups , this may be a strong argument for a high - density universe .    during the last two decades we have seen a resurgence of interest in compact groups . while initially little more than a curiosity , these systems are now viewed as potentially important sites of dynamical evolution , shaping the structure of many galaxies .
it now seems clear that while many compact groups are contaminated by projections , a large fraction of at least the high - surface - brightness hcgs are physically dense .
they form by gravitational relaxation processes within looser associations of galaxies .
the densest are generally in an advanced stage of evolution characterized by strong interactions , starburst and agn activity , stripping of stellar and dark matter halos , and merging .
they contain large amounts of dark matter and primordial x - ray - emitting gas trapped within the gravitational potential well .    despite this progress
, many questions remain unanswered .
what are the end products of compact group evolution , and do they have properties consistent with any know population of objects ? what is the space density of such relics ?
where do compact groups fit in the overall clustering hierarchy ?
what is their role in the evolution of galaxies both past and present ? given the current interest and research activity in this area , it is likely that many of these questions may soon be addressed .
it is a pleasure to thank the observatories of brera and capodimonte for hospitality during the initial work on this review .
i have benefitted from discussions with many individuals , but i would like to acknowledge particularly the contributions of a iovino , e kindl , g longo , g mamon , c mendes de oliveira , tk menon , g palumbo , h rood , and j sulentic .
i thank g mamon , a sandage and j sulentic for providing helpful comments on an earlier version of the manuscript .
financial support was provided by the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada and nato .
[ a]llam s , assendorp r , longo g , braun m , richter g. 1996 . _
_ 117:39 - 82 [ a]mbartsumian ba
66:536 - 40
[ a]mirkhanian as . 1989 .
ssr bjurak .
61:25 - 28 [ a]mirkhanian as , egikian ag .
1987 . _ astrofizika _ 27:395 - 97 [ a]mirkhanian as , egikian ag , silchenko ok .
_ pisma astron .
zh . _ 14:404 - 08 [ a]mirkhanian as , eghikian ag , tikhonov na , shakhbazian rk .
_ astrofizika _ 35:67 - 75 [ a]rp h. 1966 .
_ ap . j. suppl .
_ 14:1 - 20 [ a]rp h. 1973 . _
185:797 - 808 [ a]rp h. 1987 . _
quasars , redshifts and controversies _
, berkeley : interstellar media [ b]abul a , katz n. 1993 .
_ ap . j. lett . _ 406:l51-l54 [ b]ahcall jn , kirharos s , saxe dh , schneider dp . 1997 . _ ap .
j. _ 479 , in press [ b]ahcall na , harris de , rood hj .
_ 284:l29-l33 [ b]aier fw , petrosian , mb , tiersch h , shakhbazian rk .
_ astrofizika _ 10:327 - 35 [ b]aier fw , tiersch h. 1975 .
_ astrofizika _ 11:221 - 28 [ b]aier fw , tiersch h. 1976 . _ astrofizika _ 12:7 - 12 [ b]aier fw , tiersch h. 1976 . _ astrofizika _ 12:409 - 15 [ b]aier fw , tiersch h. 1978 .
_ astrofizika _ 14:279 - 82 [ b]aier fw , tiersch h. 1979 .
_ astrofizika _ 15:33 - 35 [ b]alcells n , quinn pj .
j. _ 361:381 - 93 [ b]arnes j. 1984 .
_ mnras _ 208:873 - 85 [ b]arnes je .
_ mnras _ 215:517 - 36 [ b]arnes je .
1989 . _ nature _ 338:123 - 26 [ b]arton e , geller mj , ramella m , marzke ro , da costa ln .
112:871 - 86 [ b]ergvall n , ekman a , lauberts a. 1981 . _ astron .
_ 95:266 - 77 [ b]ettoni d , fasano g. 1993 .
105:1291 - 307 [ b]ettoni d , fasano g. 1995 . _
astron . j. _
109:32 - 55 [ b]ettoni d , fasano g. 1996 . _
_ 118:429 - 39 [ b]iermann p , kronberg pp . 1984 .
_ physica scr .
_ t7:169 [ b]ode pw , cohn hn , lugger pm . 1993 . _ ap . j. _
416:17 - 25 [ b]oselli a , mendes de oliveira c , balkowski c , cayatte v , casoli f. 1996 .
_ 314:738 - 44 [ b]riel ug , henry jp . 1995 .
astrophys . _ 302:l9-l12 [ b]urbidge em . , burbidge gr .
130:23 - 25 [ b]urbidge em . , burbidge gr
66:541 - 50 [ b]urbidge em . , burbidge gr
. 1961b . _ ap . j. _
134:244 - 47 [ b]urbidge em . , burbidge gr
. 1961c . _ ap . j. _
134:248 - 56 [ b]urbidge em , sargent wlw . 1971 .
35:351 - 78 [ c]ampos - aguilar a , moles m. 1991 .
_ 241:358 - 64 [ c]aon n , capaccioli m , donofrio m , longo g. 1994 .
astrophys . _ 286:l39-l42 [ c]arnevali p , cavaliere a , santangelo p. 1981 .
_ ap . j. _
249:449 - 61 [ c]avaliere a , colafrancesco s , scaramella , r. 1991 .
_ ap . j. _
380:15 - 23 [ c]avaliere a , santangelo p , tarquini g , vittorio n. 1983 . in _ clustering in the universe ,
d gerbal , a mazure , pp .
gif - sur - yvette : ed . front .
[ c]ocke wj , tifft wg .
_ ap . j. _
268:56 - 59 [ d]a costa ln , geller mj , pellegrini ps , latham dw , fairall ap , marzke ro , willmer cna , huchra jp , calderon jh , ramella m , kurtz mj , _ ap . j. lett . _
424:l1-l4 [ d]avid lp , jones c , forman w. 1995 . _ ap .
j. _ 445:578 - 90 [ d]avis ds , mulchaey js , mushotzky rf , burstein d. 1996 .
_ ap . j. _
460:601 - 11 [ d]e carvalho rr , djorgovski sg 1995 .
soc . _ 187:53.02 [ d]e carvalho rr , ribeiro alb , zepf se .
_ 93:47 - 63 [ d]ellantonio ip , geller mj , fabricant dg . 1995 .
110:502 - 12 [ d]el olmo a , moles m. 1991 .
_ 245:27 - 30 [ d]el olmo a , moles m , perera j. 1995 . in _ groups of galaxies
_ , asp conference series , 70:117 - 126 [ d]e souza re , capelato hv , arakaki l , logullo c. 1982 . _ ap . j. _ 263:557 - 63 [ d]iaferio a , geller mj , ramella m. 1994 . _ astron . j. _
107:868 - 79 [ d]iaferio a , geller mj , ramella m. 1995 .
109:2293 - 304 [ d]ressler a. 1980 .
_ ap . j. _
236:351 - 65 [ d]uc p - a , mirabel if . 1994 .
_ , 289:83 - 93 [ e]beling h , mendes de oliveira c , white da . 1995
. _ mnras _ 277:1006 - 32 [ e]beling h , voges w , boehringer h. 1994 . _ ap . j. _
436:44 - 55 [ f]asano g , bettoni d. 1994 . _ astron .
107:1649 - 67 [ _ ap . j. _ ]
457:490 - 99 [ f]reudling w , almudena prieto m. 1996 . _
_ 306:39 - 48 [ f]ukazawa y , makishima k , matsushita k , yamasaki n , ohashi t , et al
_ 48:395 - 407 [ g]arcia a. 1995 .
_ 297:56 - 60 [ g]eller mj , postman m. 1983 . _ ap . j. _
274:31 - 38 [ g]isler g. 1980 .
85:623 - 25 [ g]overnato f , chincarini g , bhatia r. 1991 .
_ ap . j. _ 371:l15-l18 [ g]overnato f , tozzi , p , cavaliere a. 1996 .
_ ap . j. _
458:18 - 26 [ h]ammer f , nottale l. 1986 .
_ 155:420 - 22 [ h]eiligman gm , turner el . 1980 .
_ ap . j. _
236:745 - 49 [ h]enriksen mj , mamon ga . 1994 .
_ ap . j. lett .
_ 421:l63-l66 [ h]enry jp , gioia i m , huchra jp , burg r , mclean b , et al . 1995 .
_ ap . j. _
449:422 - 30 [ h]ernquist l , katz n , weinberg dh . 1995 .
_ ap . j. _
442:57 - 60 [ h]ickson p. 1982 .
_ ap . j. _
255:382 - 91 [ h]ickson p. 1990 . in _
paired and interacting galaxies , _ int . astron .
union colloq .
huntsville , al : nasa marshall space flight center [ h]ickson p. 1993 . _ ap .
lett . & commun .
_ 29:1 - 207 [ h]ickson p. 1994 .
_ atlas of compact groups of galaxies _ , basel : gordon & breach [ h]ickson p. 1997 .
_ ap . lett . & commun .
_ in press [ h]ickson p , kindl e , huchra jp . 1988a . _ ap .
j. _ 329:l65-l67 [ h]ickson p , kindl e , huchra jp . 1988b . _ ap .
331:64 - 70 [ h]ickson p , kindl e , auman jr .
_ 70:687 - 98 [ h]ickson p , mendes de oliveira c , huchra jp , palumbo gg
399:353 - 67 [ h]ickson p , menon tk , palumbo ggc , persic m. 1989 . _ ap .
341:679 - 84 [ h]ickson p , ninkov z , huchra jp , mamon ga . 1984 . in _ clusters and groups of galaxies _ , ed .
f mardirossian , g giuricin , m mezzetti , pp .
dordrecht : reidel [ h]ickson p , richstone do , turner el .
213:323 - 26 [ h]ickson p , rood hj . 1988 . _ ap . j. _ 331:l69-l72 [ h]uchtmeier w. 1994 .
_ 286:389 - 94 [ h]unsberger sd , charlton jc , zaritsky d. 1996 .
_ ap . j. _
462:50 - 56 [ h]umason ml , mayall nu , sandage ar . 1956 .
61:97 [ h]utchings jb 1995 .
109:928 - 34 [ h]utchings jb , crampton d , johnson a. 1995 .
109:73 - 80 [ i]ovino a , hickson p. 1996 .
_ mnras _ in press [ i]shizawa t. 1986 .
_ astrophys .
space sci .
_ 119:221 - 25 [ i]shizawa t , matsumoto r , tajima t , kageyama h , sakai h. 1983 .
_ 35:61 - 76 [ k]ent sm
_ 93:554 - 57 [ k]indl e. 1990 .
a photometric and morphological study of compact groups of galaxies and their environments , ph.d .
thesis , university of british columbia , vancouver , canada , 168 pp .
[ k]irshner rp , malumuth em .
236:366 - 72
[ k]iseleva lg , orlov vv . 1993 . _
vistas astron .
_ 36:1 - 30 [ k]odaira k , doi m , ichikawa s - i , okamura s. 1990 .
_ 1:283 - 95 [ k]odaira k , iye m , okamura s , stockton a. 1988 .
_ 40:533 - 45 [ k]odaira k , sekiguchi m , sugai h , doi m. 1991 .
_ 43:169 - 76 , [ k]ormendy j , sanders db .
390:l53 - 56 [ l]acey c , guiderdoni b , rocca - volmerange b , silk j. 1993 . _
402:15 - 41 [ l]acey c , silk j. 1991 . _
381:14 - 32 [ l]imber dn , mathews wg .
132:286 - 305 [ l]ongo g , busarello g , lorenz h , richter g , zaggia s. 1994 . _ astron . astrophys .
_ 282:418 - 24 [ l]ongo g , grimaldi a , richter g. 1995 .
astrophys . _
299:l45-l48 [ l]ynds cr , khachikian ee , amirkhanian as .
_ pisma astron .
zh . _ 16:195 - 98 [ m]accagni d , gioia i m , henry jp , maccacaro t , vettolani gp
100:1461 - 67
[ m]alumian vh . 1996 .
317:101 [ m]alykh sa , orlov vv . 1986 .
_ astrofizika _ 24:445 - 51 [ m]amon ga .
307:426 - 30 [ m]amon ga
j. _ 321:622 - 44 , [ m]amon ga .
_ 219:98 - 100 [ m]amon ga
. 1990 . in _ paired and interacting galaxies , _ int .
union colloq .
huntsville , al : nasa marshall space flight center [ m]amon ga .
1995 . in _ groups of galaxies ,
_ asp conf .
70:83 - 94 [ m]arzke ro , huchra jp , geller mj . 1944 .
_ ap . j. _
428:43 - 50 [ m]assey p. 1977 .
_ 89:13 - 18 [ m]atthews k , soifer bt , nelson j , boesgaard h , graham jr . , et al .
_ 420:l13-l16 [ m]endes de oliveira c. 1995 .
_ mnras _ 273:139 - 45 [ m]endes de oliveira c , giraud e. 1994 .
_ ap . j. _ 437:l103-l106 [ m]endes de oliveira c , hickson p. 1991 . _ ap .
380:30 - 38 [ m]endes de oliveira c , hickson p. 1994 .
_ ap . j. _
427:684 - 95 [ m]enon tk .
372:419 - 23 [ m]enon tk
_ mnras _ 255:41 - 47 [ m]enon tk
110:2605 - 9 [ m]enon tk
_ mnras _ 274:845 - 852 [ m]enon tk , hickson , p. 1985 . _
j. _ 296 , 60 - 64 , [ m]enon tk , leon s , combes f. 1996 . _ bull . am .
188:4502 [ m]irzoian lv , miller js , osterbrock de .
1975 , _ ap .
196:687 - 8 [ m]oles m , del olmo a , perea j , masegosa j , marquez i , costa , v. 1994 . _
_ 285:404 - 14 [ m]ulchaey js , davis ds , mushotzky rf , burstein d. 1993 .
_ ap . j. lett . _ 404:l9-l12 [ m]ulchaey js , davis ds , mushotzky rf , burstein d. 1996a . _ ap .
456:80 - 97 [ m]ulchaey js , mushotzky rf , burstein d , davis ds .
1996b . _ ap . j. lett . _ 456:l5-l8 [ n]avarro jf , mosconi m , garcia lambas d. 1987 .
_ mnras _ 228:501 - 11 [ n]ilson pn .
_ uppsala general catalogue of galaxies , _ uppsala obs .
[ n]ottale l , moles m. 1978 .
_ 66 , 355 - 58 [ o]leak h , stoll d , tiersch h , macgillivray h. 1995 .
109:1485 - 89 [ o]striker jp , lubin lm , hernquist l. 1995 . _
j. _ 444:l61-l64 [ o]striker jp , tremaine sd .
_ 202:l113-l117 [ p]alumbo ggc , saracco p , hickson p , mendes de oliveira c , 1995 .
109:1476 - 84 [ p]alumbo ggc , saracco p , mendes de oliveira c , hickson p , tornatore v , baiesi - pillastrini gc . 1993 .
_ ap . j. _
405:413 - 18 [ p]alumbo g , saracco p , hickson p , mendes de oliveira c. 1995 . _ astron .
109:1476 - 84 [ p]ascarelle sm , windhorst ra , driver sp , ostrander ej , keel wc . 1996 .
_ ap . j. lett . _ 456:l21-l24 [ p]eebles pje .
_ physical cosmology . _ princeton : princeton univ .
press [ p]etrosian mb .
1974 . _ astrofizika _ 10:471 - 76 [ p]etrosian mb .
_ astrofizika _ 14:631 - 35 [ p]ildis ra .
455:492 - 96 [ p]ildis ra , bregman jn , evrard ae
. 1995a . _ ap . j. _
443:514 - 26 [ p]ildis ra , bregman jn , schombert jm
110:1498 - 506 [ p]ildis ra , evrard ae , bregman jn . 1996 .
112:378 - 87 [ p]onman tj , bertram d. 1993 .
_ nature _ 363:51 - 54 [ p]onman tj , allan dj , jones lr , merrifield m , mchardy i m , lehto hj , luppino ga .
_ nature _ 369:462 - 64 [ p]onman tj , bourner pdj , ebeling h , bohringer h. 1996 .
_ mnras _ 283:690 - 708 [ p]ostman m , geller mj . 1984 . _
281:95 - 99 [ p]randoni i , iovino a , macgillivray ht .
107:1235 - 44 [ p]ress wh , schechter p. 1974 .
_ ap . j. _
187:425 - 38 [ p]uche d , carignan c. 1991 .
_ ap . j. _
378:487 - 95 [ r]amella m , diaferio a , geller mj , huchra jp . 1994 . _ astron .
107:1623 - 28 [ r]ampazzo r , sulentic jw . 1992 . _ astron . astrophys .
_ 259:43 - 60 [ r]aymond jc , smith bw
_ 35:419 - 39 [ r]ibeiro alb , de carvalho rr , zepf se . 1994 . _ mnras _ 267:l13-l16 [ r]ibeiro alb , de carvalho rr , coziol r , capelato hv , zepf se .
_ 463:l5-l8 [ r]odrigue m , schultz a , thompson j , colegrove t , spight ld , et al .
109:2362 - 67 [ r]ood hj , struble mf . 1994 .
_ 106:413 - 16 [ r]ood hj , williams ba
339:772 - 82 [ r]ose ja .
211:311 - 18 [ r]ose ja
231:10 - 22 [ r]ose ja , graham ja . 1979 .
_ ap . j. _
231:320 - 26 [ r]ubin vc , ford wkj , hunter da . 1990 .
_ ap . j. _
365:86 - 92 [ r]ubin vc , hunter da , ford wkj . 1991 .
_ ap . j. suppl .
_ 76:153 - 83 [ s]akai s , giovanelli r , wegner g. 1994 .
108:33 - 43 [ s]andage a , binggeli b & tammann ga .
90:1759 - 71 [ s]anders db , mirabel if . 1996 .
_ 34:749 - 92 [ s]aracco p , ciliegi p. 1995 . _ astron .
_ 301:348 - 58 [ s]argent wlw
_ 153:l135 - 37 [ s]chade d , lilly sj , crampton d , hammer f , le fevre o , tresse l. 1995 . _
j. _ 451:l1-l4 [ s]chechter p. 1976 . _ ap .
203:297 - 306 [ s]chwartz da , schwarz j , tucker w. 1980 .
_ ap . j. _
238:l59-l62 [ s]eyfert ck .
j. _ 53:203 - 4 [ s]hakhbazian rk 1957 .
_ 177:11 [ s]hakhbazian rk 1973 .
_ astrofizika _ 9:495 - 501 [ s]hakhbazian rk , amirkhanian as . 1979 .
_ astrofizika _ 14:455 - 66 [ s]hakhbazian rk , petrosian mb .
_ astrofizika _ 10:13 - 20 [ s]tephan me .
mnras _ 37:334 - 39 [ s]tockton a. 1982 . _
257:33 - 39 [ s]toll d , tiersch h , oleak h , baier f , macgillivray ht . 1993a .
_ 314:225 - 67 [ s]toll d , tiersch h , oleak h , baier f , macgillivray ht . 1993b .
_ 314:317 - 60 [ s]toll d , tiersch h , oleak h , macgillivray ht
_ 315:11 - 61 [ s]toll d , tiersch h , oleak h , macgillivray ht . 1994b .
_ 315:97 - 150 [ s]toll d , tiersch h , braun m. 1996a .
_ 317:239 - 57 [ s]toll d , tiersch h , braun m. 1996b .
_ 317:315 - 32 [ s]ulentic jw . 1983 . _
270:417 - 21 [ s]ulentic jw . 1987 .
_ ap . j. _
322:605 - 17 [ s]ulentic jw . 1993 . in _ progress in new cosmologies : beyond the big bang
hc arp et al , pp .
new york : plenum press [ s]ulentic jw .
j. _ in press [ s]ulentic jw , de mello rabaa df . 1993 .
_ ap . j. _
410:520 - 25 [ s]ulentic jw , lorre jj .
_ 120:36 - 52 [ s]ulentic jw , pietsch w , arp h. 1995 .
_ 298:420 - 26 [ s]ulentic jw , rabaa cr
429:531 - 39 [ t]hompson la , & gregory sa .
242:1 - 7 [ t]iersch h. 1976 .
_ 297:301 - 3 [ t]ikhonov na .
_ soobsc . spets .
_ 49:69 - 84 [ t]ikhonov na
_ astrofizika _ 27:253 - 64 [ t]ovmasian gm , shakhbazian ets , shirbakian ms .
1980 . _ astrofizika _ 15:513 - 14 [ t]oomre a. 1977 . in _ the evolution of galaxies and stellar populations , _ ed .
bm tinsley , rb larson , pp .
new haven : yale univ .
[ t]suboi m , nakai n. 1994 .
jpn . _ 46:l179-l182 [ t]ully rb .
_ nearby galaxies catalog _ , cambridge : cambridge univ . press [ v]ennik j , richter gm , longo g. 1993 .
314:393- [ v]enugopal vr .
_ mnras _ 277:455 - 57 [ v]ettolani g , gregorini l. 1988 . _ astron .
_ 189:39 - 41 [ v]orontsov - velyaminov ba
_ atlas and catalog of interacting galaxies , _ vol 1 .
moscow : sternberg inst .
[ v]orontsov - velyaminov ba .
_ atlas of interacting galaxies , part ii _ , _ astron .
suppl . _ 28:1 [ v]orontsov - velyaminov ba , dostal va , metlov vg .
_ soviet astron .
_ 6:394 - 97 [ v]orontsov - velyaminov ba , metlov vg . 1980 .
_ soviet astr .
_ 6 , 199 - 201 [ w]alke dg , mamon ga . 1989 . _
_ 225:291 - 302 [ w]eil ml , hernquist l. 1994 .
_ ap . j. lett . _
431:l79-l82 [ w]hite sdm .
1990 . in _ dynamics and interactions of galaxies , _ ed .
r weilen , pp .
380 - 88 , heidelberg : springer - verlag [ w]hite sdm . 1992 . in _ clusters and superclusters of galaxies _ , nato advanced study institute , pp . 1 - 15 .
[ w]hitmore bc
. 1992 . in _ physics of nearby galaxies : _ nature _ or nurture ? , _
tx thuan , c balkowski , j tran thanh van , _
12th moriond astrophys . meet .
giv - sur - yvette : ed . front .
[ w]hitmore bc , gilmore dm
367:64 - 68 [ w]hitmore bc , schweizer f , leitherer c , borne k , robert c. 1993 . _
astron . j. _
106:1354 - 70 [ w]illiams ba , mcmahon pm , van gorkom jh .
101:1957 - 68 [ w]illiams ba , rood hj .
_ 63:265 - 94 [ w]illiams ba , van gorkom jh
95:352 - 55 [ w]u w , rabaa cr , sulentic jw 1994 .
soc . _ 26:1494 [ z]epf se .
407:448 - 55 [ z]epf se , whitmore bc . 1991 .
_ ap . j. _
383:542 - 49 [ z]epf se , whitmore bc . 1993 .
_ ap . j. _
418:72 - 81 [ z]epf se , whitmore bc , levison hf . 1991 . _
383:524 - 41 [ z]heng j , valtonen mj , chernin ad . 1993 .
105:2047 - 53
[ z]ou z - l , xia x - y , deng z - g , wu h. 1995 . _ astron . astrophys . _ 304:369 - 73