self - organized criticality may be the underlying cause of power laws in a wide range of natural and man - made phenomena  @xcite .
systems exhibiting self - organized criticality naturally approach a critical state , without any intrinsic time or distance scales .
the critical point is reached without any fine - tuning of parameters .
this is unlike most critical points seen in physics  for example , the ising model is only critical at a single , very specific , temperature .
this lack of fine - tuning is essential if we are to understand power laws in nature , where no fine - tuning is possible .
since the concept of self - organized criticality was first introduced by bak , tang , and wiesenfeld in 1987 , a number of models have been developed to investigate this phenomenon  @xcite .
however , the original model , the two - dimensional , isotropic , abelian sandpile model ( asm ) , is still one of the simplest and most interesting of the models . the asm is simple and robust , which are necessary features for any model of self - organized criticality . while natural phenomena are quite complex , any model that seeks to explain the ubiquity of power laws in nature must , paradoxically , be very simple ; if we are to have a robust model for the generation of power laws , we must neither have finely - tuned parameters , nor finely - tuned rules .
the asm is defined on a lattice of sites , and is described by a toppling matrix @xmath1 , whose dimension is equal to the number of sites in the sandpile .
the sandpile evolves stochastically .
in each time step , a grain of sand is added to a random site .
then , sites are checked for stability .
if the number of grains at a site @xmath2 is greater than @xmath3 , then the site @xmath2 is unstable , and topples , losing @xmath4 grains , while every other site @xmath5 gains -@xmath6 grains .
( generally , @xmath7 is zero except when @xmath5 neighbors @xmath2 . ) typically , models are conservative , which means that each toppling in the bulk conserves the total number of grains ( @xmath8 ) . only for topplings along the boundary , where grains can fall off the edge , can the total number of grains change .
we continue toppling unstable sites until no sites are unstable .
then , we begin a new time step , and again add a grain to a random site .
the asm is surprisingly tractable  @xcite .
we only briefly cover some of the essential points here  for comprehensive reviews , see  @xcite .
after a large number of time steps , the asm reaches a well - defined distribution of states . of the stable height configurations , some are transient , and occur with probability zero after a long amount of time .
all other states are recurrent , and occur with equal probability .
dhar showed that the total number of recurrent states is just @xmath9  @xcite .
this is also equal to the number of spanning trees that can be drawn on the lattice , showing a connection between the sandpile and spanning tree problems  @xcite .
these statements hold for all asms , which define a large class of models .
now , we specialize to the two - dimensional , conservative , isotropic asm , which is defined on a two - dimensional square lattice , where each site has a maximum height of four , and where upon toppling at any site , one grain is sent to each of the site s four neighbors .
furthermore , we work in the limit where the lattice is infinite .
the two - dimensional , isotropic , spanning tree problem is equivalent to the central charge -2 logarithmic conformal field theory ( @xmath10 lcft )  @xcite , which has the simple gaussian action @xmath11 , where @xmath12 and @xmath13 are complex grassman variables .
the @xmath10 lcft is described in  @xcite .
while the two - dimensional , conservative , isotropic asm is just one of many possible asms , it is the original , standard , model  @xcite , and it is reasonable to simply refer to it as `` the asm , '' which we do for the remainder of this paper .
calculations of correlation functions , using methods to be described in the next section , have confirmed that there is a relationship between the asm and @xmath10 lcft .
two - point correlation functions of unit height variables decay as @xmath14 in the bulk  @xcite , as do all two - point height correlations along open and closed boundaries  @xcite ; these correlations can be understood as equivalent to correlations of lcft operators .
furthermore , calculations of certain three - point correlation functions of heights along closed boundaries , and all multipoint correlations of heights along open boundaries , have allowed lcft field identifications for heights along boundaries  @xcite .
the asm is not robust to all perturbations . if we relax the constraint that the model be conservative , and instead allow grains to be lost in any bulk toppling ( i.e. allow dissipation ) , correlations decay exponentially , and we are taken off the critical point  @xcite .
the condition of conservation can be considered a `` natural '' one , rather than one requiring `` fine - tuning . ''
deeper probes of the the conformal structure can be obtained by looking at correlations both on and off the critical point .
mahieu and ruelle calculated a number of off - critical correlation functions of certain height configurations , known as weakly allowed clusters ( wacs ) , and used their correlation functions to propose field identifications for the 14 simplest wacs  @xcite .
they found that their correlation functions could be explained by assuming that all 14 wacs took the form    @xmath15    the coefficients @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , and @xmath20 vary from wac to wac .
@xmath20 is the probability for the cluster at the critical point , and @xmath21 is the mass , a measure of how far the model is from the critical point .
the correlation functions that they used were mostly two - point functions along horizontal or diagonal axes , as well as some three - point and four - point functions for the two simplest wacs .    while these calculations provide strong evidence for the identification of the asm with the @xmath10 lcft , and the field identification in eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep ] ) , the fact that only specific correlations were considered limits the range of the identification . it would be surprising if new orientations of correlation functions , or new wacs , were found to be inconsistent with eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep ] ) ; but the calculations in  @xcite do not rule this possibility out . more importantly , since each correlation function in  @xcite required a new and separate calculation , it is hard to understand , mathematically , why these results occured . while their end results showed that certain correlations of wacs in the asm are equal to correlations of eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep ] ) in the lcft , it was not mathematically transparent as to why this should be . nor was it clear why , or if , the same coefficients would appear in other properties , such as off - boundary correlations , or correlations with defects .    here , we calculate all correlation functions of all local bond modifications ( lbms ) , for arbitrary numbers and types of lbms at arbitrary positions ( far from one another ) ; our calculations confirm that all lbms should receive the field identification in eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep ] ) . by lbms , we mean any set of local changes in the sandpile toppling rules . for the asm at the critical point
, we will assume that the lbms are conservative ( do not create or destroy grains ) .
since all wacs can be calculated by lbms , our results automatically include all correlations of wacs .
while the wacs are the most important types of lbms , and the easiest to find probabilities of , in numerical simulations , we generally discuss our results in terms of lbms , to emphasize the generality of our results .
we give closed form expressions for @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath22 and describe methods that allow rapid calculation of these coefficients . while a computer is needed for the calculation of specific @xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 coefficients , the general calculations can be done by hand .    by showing how calculation for all lbms can be done at once
, we make the mathematical structure clearer .
for example , we can quickly see why the coefficients @xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 appear in other properties .
we illustrate this by looking at off - boundary lbm probabilities , and correlations with bond defects ( either in the bulk , or along a boundary ) .
interestingly , we find that some bond defects are represented by a lcft operator with a scaling dimension of four ; this is , to the best of our knowledge , the first dimension four operator found in the asm .    while our calculations have been done in both the normal asm , and the asm with dissipation , we focus our discussion on the simpler analysis at the critical point , and only discuss the more complicated massive correlations in the last section , and in the appendices .
the methods used in this paper are not powerful enough to calculate probabilities and correlations for any height configurations .
even the calculation of the probability for a site to have height two requires much more complicated methods  @xcite , and the correlation function of two height two variables remains unknown .
this is because the condition for a site to have height two involves a nonlocal condition .
as already stated , the most important lbms are those used to calculate properties of wacs  @xcite .
wacs are related to forbidden subconfigurations ( fscs ) .
an fsc is a height configuration over a subset of sites @xmath23 , such that for every site @xmath24 , the number of neighbors of @xmath2 in @xmath23 is greater than or equal to the height at @xmath2 .
fscs are important because asm height configurations are recurrent if and only if they have no fscs  @xcite .
a wac is a height configuration that contains no fscs , but becomes a fsc if any height in the wac is decreased by one .
three wacs are shown in the left side of figure  [ fig : wacs ] .
wacs are analytically tractable because it turns out that the number of sandpiles with a particular wac is equal to the number of recurrent states in a sandpile with modified toppling rules  @xcite .
there are actually several different ways to modify the toppling rules to obtain the wac probability .
the simplest is to , for each connected piece of the wac , remove all but one of the bonds connecting it to the rest of the lattice
the modified lattices corresponding to the wacs are shown in the right side of figure  [ fig : wacs ] .
( see  @xcite for a discussion of other ways in which the sandpile can be modified to obtain the wac probabilities . ) in these modified sandpiles , grains of sand can not flow along the removed bonds ; to continue to conserve the number of grains during each toppling , the condition for instability must be decreased at the sites at the end of the removed bond .
these changes result in a new toppling matrix @xmath25 .
as already stated , the number of recurrent states in the asm is @xmath9 .
the number of recurrent states that have the wac is given by @xmath26 .
( we discuss this equivalence further in section  [ sec : wac.lbm.issues ] . )
so the bulk probability for the wac is given by    @xmath27    where we have defined @xmath28 and @xmath29 .
@xmath30 is the well - studied lattice green function ( at the critical point ) ; exact expressions are known for the green function between nearby sites , and asymptotic expressions for the green function between distant sites  @xcite .
while @xmath1 , @xmath31 , and @xmath30 all have large dimensions ( equal to the number of sites ) , @xmath32 is zero outside of a finite collection of sites .
when the bond between @xmath2 and @xmath5 is removed , @xmath33 and @xmath34 are both increased by 1 , while @xmath35 and @xmath36 are both decreased by 1 . for example , for the unit height probability , we have    @xmath37    here @xmath2 is the site fixed at height one , while @xmath38 , @xmath39 , and @xmath40 are the three sites that @xmath2 has been disconnected from .    for any wac , the fact that @xmath32 is finite - dimensional means that the height probability can be found by calculating a simple , finite - dimensional , matrix determinant . all wacs thus correspond to lbms . however , many lbms do not correspond to wacs .
lbms are simply any sandpile modifications that can be modeled with a @xmath32 matrix that is conservative ( every row and column sums to zero ) and symmetric .
our analysis gives all correlations of lbms , which thus automatically gives all correlations of wacs .
for an @xmath41-point correlation function of lbms , we can still use this method .
the only difference is that the removed bonds are located in @xmath41 distant clusters ; this is illustrated in figure  [ fig : wac.correlation ] .
removal of bonds in this fashion will give @xmath42 and @xmath43 block matrix structures .
for example , for a 3-point function , we will have    @xmath44    @xmath45 is the modification to the toppling matrix for the set of bonds removed about the @xmath46 lbm .
@xmath47 is the green function matrix between sites of the @xmath46 lbm , and its elements are @xmath48 .
@xmath49 , @xmath50 is the green function matrix between the sites of the @xmath46 and @xmath51 lbms , and its elements are given by the bulk green function ,    @xmath52    where @xmath53 is the euler - mascheroni constant  @xcite .
we work in the limit where the lbms are all very far from each other  we assume that any two of the @xmath41 lbms are the same order - of - magnitude , @xmath54 , apart .
since the green function diverges as @xmath55 with increasing @xmath56 , calculation of @xmath57 initially looks very difficult .
however , every row of every @xmath45 sums to zero  this follows from the manner in which we constructed @xmath45 , and reflects the fact that grains of sand are still conserved in each toppling in the bulk of the modified sandpile .
this implies that parts of @xmath49 that depend only on the column index make no contribution to @xmath58 , and thus no contribution to the correlation function , @xmath57 .
so we only care about differences ( discrete derivatives ) of green functions between columns of @xmath49 , and the elements of @xmath49 are effectively @xmath59 , rather than @xmath60 .    for lbms , every @xmath45 is symmetric , so every column of every @xmath45 sums to zero . using the matrix identity @xmath61
, this in turn means that the parts of @xmath49 that depend only on the row index make no contribution to the probability .
this is , in effect , like taking another discrete derivative of the green function , so that the elements of @xmath49 are effectively @xmath62 .    to make this concrete ,
suppose that the local origin of the @xmath46 lbm is located at @xmath63 , and the local origin of the @xmath51 lbm is located at @xmath64 .
the @xmath46 lbm covers a set of sites at locations @xmath65 , relative to @xmath63 , and the @xmath51 lbm consists of a series of sites at locations @xmath66 , relative to @xmath67 .
( @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 are all @xmath48 . )
then , the elements of @xmath49 all have the form @xmath72 .
the last two paragraphs show that we only need the parts of @xmath49 that depend on _ both _ the row _ and _ column indices .
that is , we only need the parts of the green function that depend on _ both _
@xmath65 _ and _ @xmath66 , and can drop all other terms . expanding eq .
( [ eq : bulk.green ] ) in powers of @xmath73 , we find that the lowest - order term not dropped is    @xmath74    the green function can thus be treated as @xmath62 for correlations of lbms . for more general local arrow diagrams , such as those that appear in the calculations involving the height two variable  @xcite , the @xmath42 matrices are not symmetric , and we can no longer drop the parts of @xmath49 that depend only on the row index .    to get the connected @xmath41-point function from @xmath57 ,
we need to pick at least one element off the block diagonal in every block row of @xmath30 , and in every block column of @xmath30 .
this means , at the minimum , picking @xmath41 elements off the block diagonal of @xmath30 , resulting in a leading - order contribution to the correlation function of @xmath75this is the universal part of the correlation function .
mahieu and ruelle showed that for two - point functions , the constraint of picking only two elements off the block diagonal allows the correlation function to be written as  @xcite    @xmath76    similarly , they found that the leading - order contribution to the three - point probability is    @xmath77    more generally , for an @xmath41-point correlation , if only @xmath41 terms are picked off the block diagonal , then the connected correlation function is given by    @xmath78 \sum_s { { \rm trace}}\left\ { \prod_{x=1}^n   \left [ { { { \mathbb i}}\over{{\mathbb i}+{\bf b}_{u_{s(x ) } } { \bf g}_{u_{s(x)}u_{s(x ) } } } } { \bf b}_{u_{s(x ) } } { \bf g}_{u_{s(x)}u_{s(x+1 ) } } \right ] \right\ } \
, \label{eq : general.trace.formula}\end{aligned}\ ] ]    where @xmath79 is summed over all one - to - one mappings from @xmath80 to @xmath80 , and we identify @xmath81 with @xmath82 .
mahieu and ruelle wrote eqs .
( [ eq : mr.trace.2]-[eq : mr.trace.3 ] ) in different , but equivalent , forms .
@xmath83    is the bulk probability of the @xmath46 lbm .
( note that the two trace terms of eq .
( [ eq : mr.trace.3 ] ) are actually equal .
we have written the three - point function in this form to make clear how the form generalizes for @xmath41-point functions . )
we can rewrite eq .
( [ eq : green.r2.expansion ] ) as    @xmath84    @xmath85 is the column vector of the horizontal positions of the sites of the @xmath46 lbm , relative to the @xmath46 local origin ( i.e. , the elements of @xmath85 are @xmath48 ) .
@xmath86 is the corresponding vector of vertical positions . @xmath85 and @xmath86 are both length @xmath87 , where @xmath87 is the number of sites needed to represent the @xmath46 lbm with the methods of the previous section ( e.g. @xmath88 for the unit height variable ) .
we insert eq .
( [ eq : g.decompose ] ) into eq .
( [ eq : general.trace.formula ] ) . for each of the @xmath41 @xmath49 s
, we can pick any of the four matrices of eq .
( [ eq : g.decompose ] ) , resulting in @xmath89 terms . in each of these @xmath89 terms ,
each @xmath49 has been replaced with the product of a column vector and a row vector . using the cyclicity of the trace to move one row vector at the end of the trace to the start of the trace
, we see that each matrix @xmath90 is bracketed by a row vector to its left , and a column vector to its right , producing a @xmath91 matrix .
so each of the @xmath89 terms is the product of @xmath41 numbers .
we can represent the decisions as to which terms of eq .
( [ eq : g.decompose ] ) to pick by representing @xmath49 with a @xmath92 matrix , @xmath93 . the possible ways to bracket @xmath90 can be represented with a @xmath92 matrix , @xmath94 .
we have    @xmath95    we have defined    @xmath96    then , the correlation function of @xmath41 lbms is given by    @xmath97    where the other trace terms are derived by permutations of @xmath98 , as in eq .
( [ eq : general.trace.formula ] ) .
we can compare this to correlation functions of fields in the @xmath10 lcft .
mahieu and ruelle proposed that the wacs are represented , at the critical point , by    @xmath99    ( the `` c '' term in eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep ] ) only appears off the critical point . )
we can compute connected @xmath41-point correlations of these fields in the @xmath10 lcft .
we use the formulation of the @xmath10 lcft where the action is    @xmath100    where we do nt integrate over zero modes in expectation values . since the theory is gaussian , to calculate correlation functions we simply need to take wick contractions .
the relevant nonzero ones are    @xmath101    each term of eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep.critical ] ) has one @xmath12 , and one @xmath13 .
the only difference between terms is whether the derivative on the @xmath12 is holomorphic or antiholomorhic , and whether the derivative on the @xmath13 is holomorphic or antiholomorphic .
we can use a @xmath92 matrix to represent the choice of which terms of @xmath102 are picked :    @xmath103    the contractions of eqs .
( [ eq : crit.contraction.1]-[eq : crit.contraction.2 ] ) can then be represented with the matrix    @xmath104    the contribution to the correlation function where the @xmath13 of the 1st lbm contracts with the @xmath12 of the 2nd lbm , the @xmath13 from the 2nd lbm contracts with the @xmath12 of the 3rd lbm , and so on , is    @xmath105    other contractions give other permutations , just as in eq .
( [ eq : npt.trace.form ] ) . finally , @xmath106 differs from @xmath107 only by a matrix rotation , which will not affect the trace , if we make the following identifications :    @xmath108    so the traces in eq .
( [ eq : npt.trace.form ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : lcft.critical.trace ] ) are equal , and all lbms are indeed represented by the field in eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep.critical ] ) .
these formulas for the coefficients have the appropriate transformation properties under @xmath109 rotations , and x and y reflections .
( technically , the overall sign of eq .
( [ eq : a ] ) is still undetermined at this point , since all correlation functions have even numbers of @xmath16 s . to determine the signs of the @xmath16 s we need to look at at least one massive correlation function .
we can do this by consulting the massive three - point function of the unit height variable in  @xcite , or more broadly , by looking at the general massive correlations in section  [ sec : dissipation.general ] . )
@xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 , can be calculated on a computer with eqs .
( [ eq : a]-[eq : b2 ] ) and eqs .
( [ eq : cu.kk]-[eq : cu.ll ] ) .
evaluating eqs .
( [ eq : cu.kk]-[eq : cu.ll ] ) , as written , requires taking a matrix inverse , which can be computationally time - consuming for larger lbms .
the calculation can be made substantially faster with the following matrix identity , which we state without proof :    @xmath110    this identity holds for any vectors @xmath111 and @xmath112 , and c - number @xmath113 .
it allows us to compute the @xmath114 s in eqs .
( [ eq : cu.kk]-[eq : cu.ll ] ) as matrix determinants , which is faster than computing matrix inverses .
furthermore , we note that , in general , certain combinations of rows ( and columns ) of @xmath45 will sum to zero , which means that we can perform a matrix rotation to reduce the size of the matrix determinant . with these methods ,
computation of @xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 for the ten simplest wacs takes roughly one hour , using mathematica on a computer with a 1.2 ghz processor .
the results agree with those found in  @xcite .
comparison with two of larger wacs , which they label @xmath115 and @xmath116 , requires a more detailed discussion of the mapping between wacs and lbms , which is done in the next section .
we illustrate the mapping between larger weakly allowed clusters and local bond modifications with the sandpile modification shown in figure  [ fig : s10.lattice.modification ] . in this modified sandpile
, a five - site cluster is separated from the rest of the sandpile , except by a single bond .
the number of states in the modified sandpile of figure  [ fig : s10.lattice.modification ] is equal to the number of states of the unmodified asm where decreasing the five - site cluster s leftmost site ( which we call @xmath2 ) from 2 to 1 makes the five - site cluster a fsc , _ and _ does not produce any larger fscs  @xcite .
the condition that the fsc produced be maximal is necessary for this equivalence , although this condition was not explicitly stated in  @xcite .
if changing the height of @xmath2 from 2 to 1 makes the five - site cluster a fsc , the original height configuration ( before this change ) must have been one of the four configurations shown in figures  [ fig : s10.mr ] and  [ fig : s10.actual.wacs ] . of these four configurations , the one in figure  [ fig : s10.mr ]
is not a wac , while the three in figure  [ fig : s10.actual.wacs ] are .
absent other conditions , the configuration in figure  [ fig : s10.mr ] does not have the same probability as the configurations in figure  [ fig : s10.actual.wacs ] .
the configuration in figure  [ fig : s10.mr ] is more likely , as an allowed configuration always stays allowed when a site height is increased . however , for some configurations of heights outside the five - site cluster , decreasing one of the three height two sites other than the one at @xmath2 , to height one , will create an fsc outside the five - site cluster , so that figure  [ fig : s10.mr ] is allowed , but figure  [ fig : s10.actual.wacs ] is not .    however , if we impose the condition that taking the height of @xmath2 from two to one should produce no fsc larger than the five - site cluster , then all four configurations in figure  [ fig : s10.mr ] and  [ fig : s10.actual.wacs ] are equally probable . with this condition ,
decreasing one of the height two sites in figure  [ fig : s10.mr ] can not possibly create an fsc outside the five - site cluster , since then the union of this fsc with the five sites would be a larger fsc upon decreasing the height of @xmath2 .    for a wac
, it can be shown that if any height is decreased , not only does the wac become a fsc , but it is not contained in any larger fsc .
therefore , for the three height configurations in figure  [ fig : s10.actual.wacs ] , the condition that the five - site fsc generated is maximal is automatic .
( however , for the configuration in figure  [ fig : s10.mr ] it is not . ) therefore , the probability associated with the modified sandpile in figure  [ fig : s10.lattice.modification ] is four times the probability of any of the three wacs in figure  [ fig : s10.actual.wacs ] .
it is also four times the probability of the height configuration in figure  [ fig : s10.mr ] , if we impose on this configuration the condition that decreasing the height of @xmath2 should produce no fsc larger than the five - site cluster ( although clearly this is not as physically interesting ) .    in  @xcite ,
the configurations that they labelled @xmath115 and @xmath116 were not wacs .
once they are modified to be wacs with the same shape , our values for @xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 , obtained with the methods of the previous section , agree with theirs .
although we chose a specific sandpile modification , the discussion is easily generalized .
generally , consider sandpile modifications similar to those in figure  [ fig : s10.lattice.modification ] , which separate a cluster of sites from the rest of the sandpile , except for one linking site .
there will be @xmath117 possible height configurations in the cluster that become fscs if the height of the linking site is reduced .
some of these will be wacs and some will not .
the probability associated with the lattice modification will be @xmath117 times the probability for any individual wac .
( it will also be @xmath117 times the probability for any of the other height configurations , given the condition that decreasing the height of the link site should produce no fsc larger than the cluster in question . )
these issues did not need to be discussed for the simpler wacs , such as those in figure  [ fig : wacs ] ( or the other wacs of  @xcite ) .
for each of the sandpile modifications in the right side of figure  [ fig : wacs ] , only one corresponding wac height configuration is possible ( @xmath118 ) .
these methods allow us to quickly determine the effects of a number of defects or boundary conditions on all lbms , and see that each time , we obtain the same coefficients . in many cases , a defect or boundary changes the green function matrix in a manner such that the change factorizes , taking the form @xmath119 , for some vectors @xmath111 and @xmath112 .
( [ eq : if.g.factorizes ] ) then shows that the effects of the change can be written as a linear combination of the @xmath114 s , and thus as a linear combination of @xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 .
for example , consider the probability for an lbm located a distance @xmath120 from a boundary ( open or closed ) .
let the boundary be at @xmath121 , and @xmath122 be the coordinate along the boundary .
then the green function is modified to  @xcite    @xmath123    placing the local origin of the lbm at ( 0,y ) , the green function between points @xmath65 and @xmath66 , relative to this local origin , where @xmath68 , @xmath70 , @xmath69 and @xmath71 are all @xmath48 , is    @xmath124    in the @xmath125 , the top sign is for closed boundaries , and the bottom sign is for open boundaries . as with eq .
( [ eq : green.r2.expansion ] ) , we have only kept terms that depend on both @xmath65 and @xmath66 ( otherwise , there would be terms of @xmath126 and @xmath127 ) . then , using eq .
( [ eq : if.g.factorizes ] ) , keeping only terms of @xmath128 , and using the definitions in eqs .
( [ eq : a]-[eq : b2 ] ) and eqs .
( [ eq : cu.kk]-[eq : cu.ll ] ) , we immediately see that the probability for the lbm is    @xmath129    this agrees with results for the unit height variable found in  @xcite .
we have also used the methods described here to investigate bond defects in the asm .
we change the toppling matrix from the defect - free matrix @xmath130 to    @xmath131    if @xmath132 and @xmath133 are adjacent sites , and @xmath134 , then this corresponds to removing the bond between @xmath132 and @xmath133 . if @xmath135 , this corresponds to adding a bond between @xmath132 and @xmath133 .
the green function is the inverse of the toppling matrix , and the effects of this perturbation can be calculated by summing a geometric series .
the result is    @xmath136    where    @xmath137    the correction to the green function factorizes , just as in eq .
( [ eq : if.g.factorizes ] ) , and the corrections to the lbm probabilities again depend on the same coefficients . if the two ends of the bond defect are at @xmath63 and @xmath138 , where @xmath139 and @xmath140 are both @xmath48 , then from eqs .
( [ eq : cu.kk]-[eq : cu.ll ] ) , eqs .
( [ eq : a]-[eq : b2 ] ) , and eq .  ( [ eq : if.g.factorizes ] ) , the probability for a lbm of type @xmath141 at @xmath142 , for @xmath143 , is    @xmath144    this is consistent with identifying the bond defect with    @xmath145
it was shown in  @xcite that any local arrow diagram along an open boundary is represented in the lcft by the operator    @xmath146    where @xmath147 is the vector of distances perpendicular to the boundary .
the arguments there worked for _ any _ local arrow diagram ( not just those corresponding to lbms ) , and similarly to our arguments in section  [ sec : wac.npoint ] , used the fact that the green function along open boundaries falls off as @xmath148 . along closed boundaries ( and in the bulk ) , the green function grows as @xmath149 , so the situation is more complicated , and not all operators are proportional to @xmath150 .
( see , for example , the operators for the height two and three variables along closed boundaries , given in  @xcite .
) however , we can now derive an expression similar to eq .
( [ eq : open.general.field ] ) for lbms along closed boundaries .
the green function for two sites on a closed boundary , and @xmath151 apart , was found in  @xcite , using eq .
( [ eq : green.closed ] ) , to be    @xmath152    using the recursion relation @xmath153 on this equation , we can extend eq .
( [ eq : green.closed.expansion.1 ] ) for points @xmath48 from the boundary :    @xmath154    ( @xmath155 , @xmath156 , @xmath157 , and @xmath158 are all @xmath48 . ) the green function diverges as @xmath149 , but if we are calculating correlations of lbms along closed boundaries , we can use the arguments of section  [ sec : wac.npoint ] to see that we only care about the parts of the green function matrix that depend on both the row and the column indices . the part of eq .
( [ eq : green.closed.expansion.2 ] ) that depends on both @xmath159 and @xmath160 is    @xmath161    using logic identical to that in the bulk case , we can use the @xmath162 part , to derive field identifications for lbms along closed boundaries :    @xmath163    @xmath164 is the vector of position coordinates parallel to the boundary .
we now introduce a bond defect of strength @xmath165 , along an open or closed boundary , between sites @xmath166 and @xmath167 , that are @xmath48 apart .
these bond defects can be analyzed as in the previous section . along an open boundary , the bond defect is represented by    @xmath168    if @xmath169i.e . if the bond defect has a vertical component . on the other hand , if the bond defect is purely horizontal , it is represented by    @xmath170    a purely horizontal bond along an open boundary is represented by a dimension four operator .    for closed boundaries ,
the bond defect is represented by    @xmath171    if the bond has a horizontal component .
if the bond is purely vertical , it is represented by    @xmath172    along closed boundaries , it is the purely vertical bonds that have dimension four .
we have verified these field identifications of bond defects with more general calculations , involving multiple fields and multiple bond defects .
this required generalizing eq .
( [ eq : green.bond ] ) for multiple bond defects . however , the generalization is straightforward , and not particularly instructive , so is not shown here .
we now consider the addition of dissipation . as explained in the introduction , this takes the asm off the critical point , as shown by both numerical simulations , and an exact analysis  @xcite .
the toppling matrix becomes    @xmath173    now , with each toppling in the bulk of the sandpile , @xmath174 grains of sand are lost .
if we set @xmath175 , we get back the original , critical asm .
it should be noted that the interpretation of the continuous @xmath176 limit is potentially problematic .
the modification to @xmath1 described in eq .
( [ eq : delta.dissip ] ) is only sensible for integer @xmath174 .
it can be extended to rational @xmath174  @xcite . however , for @xmath174 rational , but not an integer , the interpretation of the sandpile modifications ( i.e. the @xmath32 matrix ) associated with a wac is changed , so that what is meant by taking a limit of infinitesimally small , rational @xmath174 is unclear .
however , presumably the fact that the massive results are good for all integers @xmath177 can justify an analytic continuation to @xmath175 .
regardless , we are certainly able to formally expand all correlation functions in taylor series about @xmath175 , which is what we do here .
@xmath174 defines an effective mass @xmath21 for the sandpile , where @xmath178  @xcite .
@xmath179 can be thought of as the lattice spacing . in looking at off - critical correlations of lbms
, we are interested in correlation functions where the number of lattice spacings between any two of the lbms is @xmath180 . taking the @xmath181 limit then defines the way in which we simulataneously take @xmath176 and distances between lbms to infinity .    for the off - critical sandpile , as discussed in  @xcite
, we can use the same methods as before to calculate correlations , with two modifications .
first , we need to use a different @xmath32 matrix than before .
previously , we required that our sandpile modifications be conservative , which meant that the each row and each column of @xmath32 summed up to zero .
however , for the massive sandpile we will often want to consider nonconservative @xmath32 s .
( for the unit height variable , the sandpile modification in eq .
( [ eq : b.unit.height ] ) will no longer restrict the height of @xmath2 to 1 , but rather to any height from 1 to @xmath182 . )
we are most interested in lbms associated with wacs .
if we want to force the heights to the heights of the wac , the @xmath32 matrix must be changed to    @xmath183    @xmath184 is the @xmath32 matrix that would be used for this wac for the non - dissipative asm ( e.g. eq .  ( [ eq : b.unit.height ] ) ) , and    @xmath185    by `` in the wac height configuration , '' we mean in the set of sites whose heights are fixed , and not in one of the bordering sites needed to to form the @xmath32 matrix ( e.g. , for the unit height configuration , only one site is `` in the wac height configuration '' ) . more generally , for other lbms
, @xmath186 is the nonconservative part of the @xmath32 matrix .
second , we need to use a new green function between lattice sites . as always , the green function is given by the inverse of the toppling matrix . in appendix  [ sec : massive.green ] , we calculate the green function in the limit @xmath176 , when the distance between two sites scales as @xmath187 , and find that it approaches @xmath188 , where @xmath189 is the modified bessel function of the second kind .
the asymptotic expansion in @xmath187 is then    @xmath190    we have not calculated the @xmath191 functions , because they turn out to not affect the universal parts of any correlation functions . in principle
, they can contain bounded functions of @xmath187 , such as @xmath192 , but we have not explicitly indicated this @xmath174-dependence , since it does not affect our analysis .
( mahieu and ruelle found , for @xmath193 and @xmath194 , eq .
( [ eq : g.k0.expansion ] ) , and the specific forms of @xmath195 and @xmath196  @xcite .
they found that @xmath197 for these angles , so it is possible that @xmath197 for all @xmath198 , although we have not investigated this . )
we decompose @xmath49 as a sum of four @xmath199 matrices :    @xmath200    @xmath201 is a matrix in which every element is identical .
@xmath202 and @xmath203 are matrices in which the elements depend only on the row index , or only on the column index .
parts of @xmath43 which can not be written in these forms go into @xmath204 .
all four of these matrices are taylor series in @xmath205 , whose @xmath48 terms depends only on the taylor expansion of @xmath188 , and whose higher order terms in @xmath205 depend on @xmath195 , @xmath196 , etc . . .
for example every element of @xmath201 is @xmath206 .
the elements of @xmath202 and @xmath203 depend on only the coordinates in the @xmath46 lbm , or on only the coordinates in the @xmath51 lbm , and thus require one derivative ( finite difference ) of the green function .
the elements of @xmath204 require two or more derivatives of the green function .    for correlations at the critical point
, we saw that @xmath201 , @xmath202 , and @xmath203 could all be ignored in calculating lbm correlations .
however , the arguments there relied on the fact that every row and every column of every @xmath45 summed to zero . that no longer holds here , and we thus need to reconsider which terms of the green function we need to keep .
we expand the correlation functions in powers of @xmath174 , and look for the lowest , nonzero , power of @xmath174 .
as with critical correlations , to prove the validity of eq .
( [ eq : general.trace.formula ] ) , we need to show that the lowest - order term of the @xmath41-point function only comes from the parts of @xmath57 with @xmath41 terms off the block diagonal .
however , the proof is much harder in this case ; we sketch the proof in appendix  [ sec : massive.trace.formula ] .    similarly to eq .
( [ eq : green.r2.expansion ] ) , we need to taylor expand    @xmath207    then , just as in eq .
( [ eq : g.decompose ] ) , we can write @xmath49 as a sum of terms , each of which is the product of a length @xmath87 column vector and a length @xmath208 row vector . defining @xmath209 to be the vector of length @xmath87 , all of whose entries are 1 , we have    @xmath210    in the ellipses , we have dropped not only terms of @xmath211 and higher , but all terms with @xmath195 or @xmath196
. the terms with @xmath195 or @xmath196 are not necessarily higher - order in @xmath174 than the terms shown .
@xmath195 contributes terms of @xmath212 to @xmath213 , and terms of @xmath214 to @xmath215 , @xmath216 , @xmath217 , and @xmath218 .
@xmath196 contributes terms of @xmath214 to @xmath213 .
similarly to eq .
( [ eq : crit.n.matrix ] ) , we represent @xmath49 with a @xmath219 matrix , @xmath220 , where each element of @xmath220 represents a different choice of row vector and column vector :    @xmath221    to save space , we have here abbreviated @xmath222 and @xmath223 .
now , while some of the terms depending on @xmath195 and @xmath196 are @xmath212 and @xmath214 , they are higher order terms in @xmath201 , @xmath202 , @xmath203 , and @xmath204 , and thus are higher order in the specific matrix elements of @xmath220 that they contribute to .
we will later see that this justifies dropping them .    just as in section
[ sec : wac.npoint ] , when each off - diagonal green function matrix is replaced by the product of a column vector and a row vector , each @xmath224 is bracketed by a row vector to its left and a column vector to its right , producing a @xmath91 matrix .
we thus get a matrix , @xmath225 , similar to the @xmath94 of eq .
( [ eq : crit.m.matrix ] ) .
@xmath225 is @xmath219 , rather than @xmath92 , because the vectors bracketing @xmath224 to the left and to the right can now be @xmath85 , @xmath86 , or @xmath209 .    in principle , when calculating @xmath225 , @xmath45 and @xmath47 should be the matrices for the massive sandpile .
however , we only need most elements of @xmath225 in the limit @xmath176 ( this will be justified shortly ) . in this limit ,
we replace @xmath45 with @xmath226 , and the elements of @xmath47 with the normal , well - known , critical green function .
thus , to lowest - order , the elements of @xmath94 in @xmath225 are unchanged :    @xmath227    for the new entries of @xmath225 , it is not hard to show that    @xmath228    where @xmath229 is the probability for the lbm , and c is defined as the number of sites in the wac height configuration ( as defined below eq .
( [ eq : b.nc ] ) ) .
@xmath230 is the only element of @xmath225 where we need the @xmath214 term .
mahieu and ruelle defined @xmath19 as the coefficient in eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep ] ) , and observed that for the 14 wacs that they considered , @xmath19 always turned out to always be equal to the number of sites in the wac height configuration  @xcite .
we will see that our @xmath19 is the same as their @xmath19 , proving that their observation holds for all wacs .
we now have    @xmath231    the @xmath41-point correlation is given by    @xmath232    it is easy to now verify that the higher - order terms in @xmath174 in @xmath225 and @xmath220 that we dropped in eq .
( [ eq : n.dissip ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : m.dissip ] ) indeed give contributions of @xmath233 or higher to the @xmath41-point correlation , justifying the approximations used .
we now have all correlations of lbms in the asm with dissipation .
we can show that the correlations we have found are the same as the correlations of the field in eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep ] ) . mahieu and ruelle proposed that the appropriate massive extension of the lcft in eq .
( [ eq : lcft.action ] ) is  @xcite    @xmath234    this theory is still gaussian , with correlation functions    @xmath235    other two - point correlations can then be obtained by taking holomorphic or antiholomorphic derivatives .
then , just as in section  [ sec : wac.npoint ] , since the theory is gaussian , we can write the @xmath41-point correlation of eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep ] ) exactly . the result is formally identical to eq .
( [ eq : lcft.critical.trace ] ) , where the analogues of @xmath236 and @xmath237 in eqs .
( [ eq : f.critical]-[eq : h.critical ] ) are now @xmath219 ( since the @xmath12 and @xmath13 fields in eq .
( [ eq : lcft.rep ] ) may have holomorphic derivatives , antiholomorphic derivatives , or no derivatives at all ) . using the identifications in eq .
( [ eq : a]-[eq : b2 ] ) , and @xmath178 , the results agree with the correlation function in eq .
( [ eq : massive.npt.trace.form ] ) ( up to a proportionality factor , @xmath238 ) .
the green function for the asm with dissipation is the inverse of the toppling matrix @xmath1 , given in eq .
( [ eq : massive.delta ] ) . in the limit of an infinite lattice , this can be found by fourier transform  @xcite :    @xmath239    we are interested in this integral either for @xmath240 and @xmath41 both @xmath48 , or for @xmath240 and @xmath41 both proportional to @xmath187 , in the limit @xmath176 .
we saw in section  [ sec : dissipation.general ] , that for @xmath240 and @xmath41 both @xmath48 , we only needed @xmath241 , in the limit @xmath176 . but this is just the standard , dissipation - free , lattice green function , whose properties can be looked up in standard references  for example ,  @xcite .
so we only need to discuss the case where @xmath240 and @xmath41 are both proportional to @xmath187 :    @xmath242    in the limit @xmath176 , the exponential oscillates infinitely rapidly , so when multiplied by any function smooth in the limit @xmath176 , gives an integral of zero .
so no error is introduced by changing the region of integration to a small disc of radius @xmath243 about @xmath244 .
similarly , because    @xmath245    is smooth over this region , we can replace the first term with the second one .
changing to polar coordinates , the integral is    @xmath246    with a change of variables , the integral becomes    @xmath247    where @xmath189 is the modified bessel function of the second kind .    to find the leading - order critical limit , we take @xmath248 ( while @xmath249 is still large ) , and use @xmath250 , reproducing the first term of eq .
( [ eq : bulk.green ] ) .
in this appendix , we sketch the proof that the trace formula in eq .
( [ eq : general.trace.formula ] ) is valid for all @xmath41-point correlations of lbms off the critical point .
this requires showing that in the determinant @xmath57 , if we only want terms up to @xmath251 , we never need to pick more than @xmath41 terms off the block diagonal of @xmath252 . in other words , when we calculate the determinant with      where @xmath254 is summed over all permutations of @xmath255 , we never have more than @xmath41 of the @xmath256 s from the off - diagonal blocks . the off - diagonal blocks of @xmath252 all have the form @xmath257 , @xmath50 , where @xmath45 and @xmath49 can be written with eq .
( [ eq : b.dissip ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : g.dissip.general ] ) . since every row of @xmath258 sums to zero , @xmath259 , and @xmath260 .
the off - diagonal block can thus be written      ( we need the @xmath211 terms for the calculation of the correlation functions in section  [ sec : dissipation.general ] , but do not need their explicit form for this proof . ) since there are terms of @xmath212 in the off - diagonal blocks , naively , to get the @xmath251 contribution to the correlation function , we would need parts of the determinant with up to @xmath262 terms off the block diagonal .
so we need to explain why the terms with more than @xmath41 terms off the block diagonal in fact have all their contributions to the @xmath251 part of the correlation function cancel ( as well as why all the terms with lower powers of @xmath174 cancel ) .
we define a `` row matrix '' to be a matrix in which the entries depend only on the row index when we consider contributions to @xmath57 , we consider , for each contributing matrix element off the block diagonal , whether it is from @xmath263 , @xmath264 , @xmath265 , or from the elements of @xmath211 or higher .
we use several matrix theorems ; the first two are general , not referring specifically to @xmath32 or @xmath30 .
it is not hard to show      by `` zero contribution , '' we mean that while specific terms in eq .
( [ eq : determinant.definition ] ) may be nonzero , when all such terms are considered , they cancel .
theorem  [ thm:1 ] is easy to prove : if @xmath268 is the element from the @xmath266 block , and @xmath269 is the element from the @xmath267 block , we get a cancelling contribution from @xmath270 and @xmath271 .
it is somewhat harder to show the following theorem , which we state without proof :    suppose the @xmath272 block ( @xmath50 ) is a row matrix , every column of the @xmath273 block sums to one , and for every @xmath274 , every column of the @xmath275 block sums to zero .
then the determinant has zero contribution from the matrix elements of the @xmath272 block ; in other words , the determinant is unchanged if every element of the @xmath272 block is set to zero .
[ thm:2 ]    we note that @xmath263 and @xmath265 are both row matrices , and that every column of @xmath263 sums to zero , as does every column of @xmath264 .
then , repeatedly applying theorems  [ thm:1 ] and  [ thm:2 ] allows us to prove the following :    in the determinant @xmath57 , suppose the ( @xmath276 ) block ( @xmath277 ) has a contributing matrix element from @xmath278 .
then , in the terms that produce a nonzero contribution to the determinant , there is an ordered sequence of distinct block indices , @xmath279 , @xmath280 , such that for all @xmath281 , the @xmath282 block has a term from @xmath283 .
furthermore , either + 1 ) the @xmath284 block has a term of @xmath214 or higher .
+ or + 2 ) there is a term of order @xmath211 or higher in an off - diagonal block , @xmath285 .
+ a different @xmath286 block @xmath287 with a matrix element from @xmath288 will produce an ordered sequence of distinct block indices , @xmath289 , with no elements in common with @xmath290 .
theorem 3 shows that each term in the determinant of type @xmath292 can be associated with a distinct term of type @xmath293 or @xmath294 , so that @xmath295 .
the number of powers of @xmath174 from this contribution to the determinant is then _ at least _
so if we only want @xmath251 contributions to the correlation function we should never have more than @xmath41 terms off the block diagonal .
furthermore , we want a connected correlation function , so we should always have exactly @xmath41 terms off the block diagonal .
this concludes the proof that eq .
( [ eq : general.trace.formula ] ) is valid for off - critical @xmath41-point correlations .    to get strict equality in eq .
( [ eq : order.inequality ] ) , we need @xmath297 , @xmath298 , and @xmath299
. furthermore , the terms of type @xmath293 should be exactly proportional to @xmath300 .
the fact that @xmath298 means that in the diagonal blocks , @xmath301 , we can set @xmath175 at the start of our calculations , as already seen by other means in section  [ sec : dissipation.general ] .


during the last few years , a two - dimensional hexagonal lattice of carbon atoms known as graphene has attracted widespread attention owing to its unusual physical properties and promising applications @xcite . unlike conventional condensed matter systems , the quasiparticles in graphene are massless or very light particles which at low energies obey the relativistic dirac equation , where the speed of light @xmath0 is replaced with the fermi velocity @xmath1 ( see the monograph @xcite and review papers @xcite ) .
this makes the electronic properties of graphene highly nontrivial , and , specifically , results in the existence @xcite of a universal ( up to small nonlocal corrections ) frequency - independent conductivity @xmath2 in the limit of zero temperature .    the electrical conductivity of graphene was investigated in many theoretical papers using the current - current correlation functions in the random phase approximation , the two - dimensional drude model , the quasiclassical approach , the kubo formula , and boltzmann s transport theory ( see , e.g. , refs .
@xcite ) . at first , a few distinct values for the universal conductivity @xmath2 have been obtained by different authors ( see refs .
@xcite for a review ) depending on the order of limiting transitions in the used theoretical approach . at a later time , a consensus was achieved on the value @xmath3 @xcite . however , up to now there is no complete agreement between the results of the different approximate and phenomenological approaches to the conductivity of graphene at nonzero temperature , in the presence of nonzero mass - gap parameter and chemical potential . in doing so , the experimental results @xcite are not of sufficient precision for a clear discrimination between the various theoretical predictions .
quantum electrodynamics at nonzero temperature provides a regular way for describing the response of a physical system to the electromagnetic field by means of polarization tensor . for graphene with an arbitrary mass - gap parameter
@xmath4 an explicit expression for the polarization tensor in ( 2 + 1)-dimensional space - time was found in ref .
@xcite at zero temperature .
the temperature correction to the polarization tensor of graphene was derived in ref .
@xcite at the pure imaginary matsubara frequencies .
the results of refs .
@xcite have been used to calculate the casimir and casimir - polder forces @xcite in many real physical systems incorporating graphene sheets @xcite ( previously such calculations were performed by means of the density - density correlation functions of graphene , the spatially nonlocal dielectric permittivities , phenomenological drude model , etc .
the polarization tensor of graphene was also used @xcite to compare with theory the experimental data on measuring the casimir interaction in graphene systems @xcite , and very good agreement was obtained .    another representation for the polarization tensor of graphene valid over the entire plane of complex frequency was derived in ref .
it was applied to investigate the origin of large thermal effect in the casimir interaction between two graphene sheets @xcite and to calculate the reflectivity properties of gapless graphene @xcite . in ref .
@xcite the same polarization tensor allowed calculation of the reflectivity properties of graphene - coated substrates .
the derivation of the polarization tensor valid along the real frequency axis made it possible to investigate the electrical conductivity of graphene on the basis of first principles of quantum electrodynamics at nonzero temperature .
note that in ref .
@xcite explicit expressions for the polarization tensor at real frequencies were obtained only for a pure ( pristine ) graphene having a zero mass - gap parameter , whereas for a gapped graphene the respective expressions were presented in an implicit form .
because of this , as the starting point , the conductivity of pure graphene was investigated @xcite . in doing so ,
a few results obtained previously using different theoretical approaches have been reproduced , and several novel analytic asymptotic expressions and numerical results ( especially for the imaginary part of conductivity ) have been obtained .    in this paper
we apply the formalism of the polarization tensor to systematically investigate the electrical conductivity of gapped graphene on the solid foundation of quantum electrodynamics . for this purpose , an explicit form of the results of ref .
@xcite related to the case of nonzero mass - gap parameter is employed , which was found in ref .
it is known that quasiparticles in graphene may acquire some small mass @xmath5 under the influence of impurities , electron - electron interactions , and in the presence of substrates @xcite .
the conductivity of gapped graphene was studied in ref .
@xcite using the two - band model and in ref
.  @xcite using the static polarization function . at zero temperature
some analytic expressions for the conductivity of gapped graphene were obtained in refs .
@xcite , whereas ref .
@xcite contains the final results for both real and imaginary parts of conductivity in the local approximation .
we reproduce the zero - temperature analytic results of ref .
@xcite within the formalism of the polarization tensor and generalize them taking into account the effects of nonlocality .
specifically , it is shown that at zero temperature the real part of the conductivity of gapped graphene is equal to zero in the frequency region from zero to the characteristic frequency , which is slightly larger than @xmath6 due to nonlocal effects .
with increasing frequency the real part of conductivity decreases monotonously from @xmath7 to @xmath2 .    according to our results , nonzero temperature has a dramatic impact on the conductivity of gapped graphene .
thus , the real part of conductivity for frequencies larger than the characteristic frequency may be either decreasing or increasing function depending on the relationship between the mass - gap parameter and the temperature .
the imaginary part of the conductivity of gapped graphene varies from plus to minus infinity when frequency increases from zero to the characteristic frequency ( at zero temperature it varies from zero to minus infinity in the same frequency region ) .
we obtain the analytic asymptotic expressions and perform numerical computations for both real and imaginary parts of the conductivity of gapped graphene at nonzero temperature .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii , we present explicit expressions for the polarization tensor of gapped graphene along the real frequency axis . in sec .
iii , both real and imaginary parts of the conductivity of gapped graphene are derived at zero temperature .
sections iv and v investigate the impact of nonzero temperature on real and imaginary parts of the conductivity of gapped graphene , respectively . our conclusions and discussion
are contained in sec .  vi .
here , we present analytic results for the polarization tensor of gapped graphene along the real frequency axis derived in refs .
we also demonstrate how real and imaginary parts of the conductivity of graphene are expressed via imaginary and real parts of the polarization tensor , respectively .
both the longitudinal ( along the graphene surface ) and transverse ( normal to the graphene surface ) conductivities are considered .
the description of graphene using the polarization tensor in the one - loop approximation and the density - density correlation functions in the random phase approximation are equivalent @xcite .
the former method is , however , somewhat advantageous because it relies on well understood formalism of quantum field theory at nonzero temperature .
this allowed complete derivation of the polarization tensor of gapped graphene valid over the entire plane of complex frequency @xcite . in ref .
@xcite a more convenient form of this tensor especially along the real frequency axis has been obtained for a gapped graphene .    as usual , we notate the polarization tensor as @xmath8 , where @xmath9 , @xmath10 is the frequency of an electromagnetic wave , @xmath11 is the magnitude of the wave vector component parallel to graphene , and @xmath12 is the temperature .
we assume real photons on a mass - shell , so that the inequality @xmath13 is satisfied . it has been shown @xcite that only the two components of the polarization tensor of graphene are independent .
it is conventional to use @xmath14 and @xmath15 as the two independent quantities . for our purposes , however , it is more convenient to use the following combination @xmath16 as the second quantity .
we present @xmath14 and @xmath17 as the sums of zero - temperature contributions and temperature corrections @xmath18 the thermal corrections @xmath19 and @xmath20 vanish in the limit of zero temperature .
the analytic expressions for the polarization tensor of gapped graphene at @xmath21 were derived in ref .
@xcite . they result in @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the fine structure constant , the quantity @xmath24 is defined as @xmath25 and the function @xmath26 along the real frequency axis is given by @xcite @xmath27 { \rm arctanh}\frac{\hbar\omega\eta}{\delta } , & \hbar\omega<\frac{\delta}{\eta } , \\[3 mm ] \frac{2\delta}{c}-\frac{2\hbar\omega\eta}{c}\left[1 + \left(\frac{\delta}{\hbar\omega\eta}\right)^2\right ]
\left({\rm arctanh}\frac{\delta}{\hbar\omega\eta}+ i\frac{\pi}{2}\right ) , & \hbar\omega\geq\frac{\delta}{\eta}. \end{array } \right . \label{eq5}\ ] ] here , the energy gap @xmath28 and @xmath5 is the mass of a quasiparticle ( according to some estimations @xcite @xmath29 may achieve 0.1ev ) .    as is seen from eqs .
( [ eq3])([eq5 ] ) , under the condition @xmath30 the quantities @xmath31 and @xmath32 are real . if the condition @xmath33 is satisfied , they have both real and imaginary parts .
we now continue by considering the thermal corrections in eq .
( [ eq2 ] ) .
the imaginary parts of both @xmath19 and @xmath20 are also different from zero only under the condition @xmath33 @xcite .
the explicit forms are the following @xcite : @xmath34 & & \label{eq6 } \\ & & { \rm im}\delta_t\pi(\omega , k , t)= \frac{8\alpha\hbar\eta\omega}{v_f^2}\int_{u^{(-)}}^{u^{(+)}}\!\!\ !
\frac{du}{e^{\beta u}+1 } \frac{(2cu-\omega)^2+v_f^2k^2[1-a(\omega , k ) ] } { \sqrt{v_f^2k^2a(\omega , k)-(2cu-\omega)^2 } } , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath35 and the integration limits are @xmath36 .
\label{eq8}\ ] ]          the above expressions ( [ eq2])([eq13 ] ) provide an exact representation for the polarization tensor of graphene at arbitrary frequency , wave vector , temperature and mass - gap parameter in the application region of the dirac model .
this opens up possibility for a comprehensive investigation of the conductivity of gapped graphene on the basis of first principles of quantum electrodynamics .
the point is that the longitudinal and transverse conductivities of graphene are directly connected with the respective density - density correlation functions @xcite .
the latter are expressed via the components of the polarization tensor @xcite . as a result ,
the longitudinal and transverse conductivities of graphene take the form @xcite
@xmath46    in the next sections , using these equations , the conductivities of gapped graphene are treated at both zero and nonzero temperature .
at @xmath21 the polarization tensor of gapped graphene is characterized by the quantities @xmath31 and @xmath32 which are presented in eqs .
( [ eq3])([eq5 ] ) .
we consider separately the real and imaginary parts of the conductivity .      according to eq .
( [ eq14 ] ) , the real parts of graphene conductivities at zero temperature are given by @xmath47    from eqs .
( [ eq3])([eq5 ] ) one obtains @xmath48 \theta(\hbar\omega\eta-\delta ) , \nonumber \\[-2 mm ] & & \label{eq16 } \\ & & { \rm im}\pi^{(0)}(\omega , k)= -\frac{\alpha\pi\hbar k^2\omega\eta}{c}\left[1 + \left(\frac{\delta}{\hbar\omega\eta}\right)^{\!\!2}\right ] \theta(\hbar\omega\eta-\delta ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath49 is the step function .    substituting eq .
( [ eq16 ] ) in eq .
( [ eq15 ] ) and taking into account that @xmath23 , one arrives at @xmath50 \theta(\hbar\omega\eta-\delta ) , \label{eq17 } \\ & & { \rm re}\sigma_{\bot}^{(0)}(\omega , k)={\sigma_0}{\eta } \left[1 + \left(\frac{\delta}{\hbar\omega\eta}\right)^{\!\!2}\right ] \theta(\hbar\omega\eta-\delta ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the universal conductivity of graphene is @xmath51    as is seen from eq .
( [ eq17 ] ) , in the frequency region satisfying the condition @xmath30 the real parts of the conductivities of gapped graphene are equal to zero .
note that the vanishing of the conductivity of gapped graphene at low frequencies was noted in many papers using various formalisms ( see , for instance , refs .
@xcite ) .    taking into account that @xmath13 , one obtains @xmath52 using eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) , we expand eq .
( [ eq17 ] ) in powers of the small parameter ( [ eq19 ] ) and in the lowest order find @xmath53\right\ } \theta(\hbar\omega\eta-\delta ) , \nonumber\\[-2 mm ] & & \label{eq20 } \\ & & { \rm re}\sigma_{\bot}^{(0)}(\omega , k)={\sigma_0}\left\ { 1+\left(\frac{\delta}{\hbar\omega}\right)^{\!\!2}- \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{v_fk}{\omega}\right)^{\!\!2}\left [ 1-\left(\frac{\delta}{\hbar\omega}\right)^{\!\!2 } \right]\right\ } \theta(\hbar\omega\eta-\delta ) . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ]    as is seen from eq .
( [ eq20 ] ) , @xmath54 and @xmath55 differ only in the first perturbation order in the small parameter ( [ eq19 ] ) and , thus , can be considered as equal for all practical purposes .
they are normalized to @xmath2 and plotted in fig .
[ fg1 ] as functions of @xmath56 .
note that in this and all the following figures computational results for the longitudinal and transverse conductivities are indistinguishable in the used scales .
because of this , they are always presented by a single line . in the region @xmath57 the conductivities of graphene are the monotonous functions decreasing from @xmath7 to @xmath2 when the frequency increases from @xmath6 to infinity .    in the local limit , where the results are independent on the wave vector , eq .  ( [ eq20 ] ) leads to @xmath58 note that in our case the same results are obtained from eq .
( [ eq20 ] ) taken at @xmath59 .
they coincide with the results presented in ref .
@xcite obtained in the framework of another approach .      using eq .
( [ eq14 ] ) , for the imaginary part of conductivity of graphene at zero temperature we obtain @xmath60    for the real part of the polarization tensor from eqs .
( [ eq3])([eq5 ] ) one finds @xmath61 where @xmath62 \left\ { \begin{array}{ll } { \rm arctanh}\frac{\hbar\omega\eta}{\delta } , & \hbar\omega\eta<\delta , \\ { \rm arctanh}\frac{\delta}{\hbar\omega\eta } , & \hbar\omega\eta\geq\delta .
\end{array } \right .
\label{eq24}\ ] ]    using the identity @xcite @xmath63 eq .  ( [ eq24 ] ) can be rewritten in the form @xmath64 \ln\left|\frac{\delta+\hbar\omega\eta}{\delta-\hbar\omega\eta } \right| .
\label{eq26}\ ] ]    substituting eqs .
( [ eq23 ] ) and ( [ eq26 ] ) in eq .
( [ eq22 ] ) , one arrives at @xmath65 , \nonumber\\[-2 mm ] \label{eq27 } \\ & & { \rm im}\sigma_{\bot}^{(0)}(\omega , k)=\frac{\sigma_0\eta}{\pi } \left[\frac{2\delta}{\hbar\omega\eta}- \frac{(\hbar\omega\eta)^2+\delta^2}{(\hbar\omega\eta)^2 } \ln\left|\frac{\delta+\hbar\omega\eta}{\delta-\hbar\omega\eta } \right|\right ] .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ]    from eq .
( [ eq27 ] ) it is seen that the nonlocal effects play equally small role in the imaginary parts of conductivity of graphene as in its real part . in the local limit
we have @xmath66 and eq .
( [ eq27 ] ) reduces to @xmath67 . \label{eq28}\ ] ] this coincides with the result presented in ref .
@xcite .    in fig .
[ fg2 ] we plot the imaginary part of the conductivity of graphene normalized to @xmath2 at @xmath21 as a function of the ratio of @xmath68 to the width of the gap @xmath4 . as is seen in fig .
[ fg2 ] , for any fixed @xmath4 the imaginary part of conductivity decreases monotonously from zero to minus infinity when frequency increases from 0 to @xmath6 and then increases to zero with further increase of frequency .
we start from the real parts of thermal corrections to the conductivities of graphene . according to eqs .
( [ eq2 ] ) and ( [ eq14 ] ) , they are given by @xmath69 recall that the quantities @xmath70 and @xmath71 ( and , thus , @xmath72 and @xmath73 ) are equal to zero under the condition @xmath30 . under the opposite condition @xmath33
they are given by eq .
( [ eq6 ] ) .
it is convenient to introduce another integration variable in eq .
( [ eq6 ] ) @xmath74 where @xmath75 is defined in eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) .
then eq .
( [ eq6 ] ) takes the form @xmath76 , \nonumber \\ & & \label{eq31 } \\[-2 mm ] & & { \rm im}\delta_t\pi(\omega , k , t)= 4\alpha\hbar\omega\eta\frac{k^2}{c } \int_{-1}^{1}\frac{d\tau}{\exp\left ( \frac{\hbar\omega}{2k_bt}+\gamma\tau\right)+1 } \left[\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\tau^2}}-a(\omega , k)\sqrt{1-\tau^2 } \right ] .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , the parameter @xmath77 is defined as @xmath78 it is equal to zero in the local limit .    expanding the exponent - containing fraction in the first formula of eq .
( [ eq31 ] ) in a series and calculating the integrals @xcite one obtains @xmath79 \nonumber \\ & & \label{eq33 } \\[-2 mm ] & & ~~ = -4\alpha\hbar\frac{ck^2}{\omega\eta } \sum_{n=1}^{\infty}(-1)^{n-1}e^{-\frac{n\hbar\omega}{2k_bt } }   \left\{\left[1-a(\omega , k)\right ] { i}_0(n\gamma)+ \frac{a(\omega , k)}{n\gamma}{i}_1(n\gamma)\right\ } , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath80 are the bessel functions of an imaginary argument .
substituting eqs .
( [ eq33 ] ) and ( [ eq34 ] ) with added @xmath82-functions in eq .
( [ eq29 ] ) , we obtain the exact expressions for the real parts of thermal corrections to longitudinal and transverse conductivities of gapped graphene at nonzero temperature @xmath83 { i}_0(n\gamma)+ \frac{a(\omega , k)}{n\gamma } { i}_1(n\gamma)\right\ } , \nonumber\\ & & \label{eq35 } \\[-2 mm ] & & { \rm re}\delta_t\sigma_{\bot}(\omega , k , t)=-{4\sigma_0}{\eta } \theta(\hbar\omega\eta-\delta ) \sum_{n=1}^{\infty}(-1)^{n-1}e^{-\frac{n\hbar\omega}{2k_bt } } \left [ { i}_0(n\gamma)- \frac{a(\omega , k)}{n\gamma } { i}_1(n\gamma)\right ] .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ]        as is seen from eq .
( [ eq38 ] ) , the real parts of thermal corrections to the conductivity of gapped graphene are mostly determined by the local contributions @xmath87 the nonlocal contributions in eq .
( [ eq38 ] ) become dominant only at very low temperature when the complete thermal correction is exponentially small .    by adding eqs .
( [ eq21 ] ) and ( [ eq39 ] ) , one arrives at the final expression for the real part of conductivity of gapped graphene at nonzero temperature in the local approximation @xmath88    in fig .
[ fg3](a ) we plot the real part of the normalized to @xmath2 longitudinal and transverse conductivities of graphene with the gap parameter @xmath89ev as a function of frequency ( measured in ev ) at different temperatures .
the lines from top to bottom correspond to @xmath90 , 100 , and 300k , respectively ( note that @xmath91k corresponds to @xmath92ev ) . to gain a better understanding , the region of very low frequencies
is shown in fig .
[ fg3](b ) on an enlarged scale .
according to fig .
[ fg3](a , b ) , the real part of conductivity decreases with increasing @xmath12 .
this is because the thermal correction to conductivity presented in eq .
( [ eq39 ] ) is negative . as is seen in fig .
[ fg3](a , b ) , the real part of the conductivity of graphene increases with increasing frequency and goes to @xmath2 .
this is , however , not a universal property , but is determined by chosen ( small ) value of the gap parameter .    to illustrate the latter statement , in fig .
[ fg4 ] we plot the real parts of the conductivities of graphene with the larger gap parameters equal to ( a ) @xmath93ev and ( b ) @xmath94ev as the functions of frequency .
the lines from top to bottom are plotted for @xmath90 , 100 , and 300k , respectively .
as is seen in fig .
[ fg4](a ) , at @xmath95 and 100k the real part of conductivity increases , but at @xmath96k it decreases with increasing frequency .
figure  [ fg4](b ) illustrates what is happening with an increase of the gap parameter to @xmath94ev . in this case
the real part of conductivity at @xmath90 and 100k decreases with increasing frequency , whereas at @xmath91k it becomes nonmonotonous due to an interplay of two factors in eq .
( [ eq40 ] ) . with further increase of the gap parameter ( up to @xmath97ev or larger ) the real part of conductivity becomes monotonously decreasing at all considered temperatures , whereas the values of @xmath98 at @xmath90 and 100k become indistinguishable .
the imaginary parts of thermal corrections to the conductivity of graphene are obtained from eqs .
( [ eq2 ] ) and ( [ eq14 ] ) @xmath99    at first we consider the frequency region @xmath30 . here , the real parts of the temperature corrections to the polarization tensor are presented by eq .
( [ eq9 ] ) .
thus , the exact expressions for @xmath100 and @xmath101 in this region are given by eqs .
( [ eq9 ] ) and ( [ eq41 ] ) .
the total imaginary part of the conductivity is given by @xmath102 where @xmath103 is defined in eq .
( [ eq27 ] ) .
we expand eq .
( [ eq9 ] ) up to the first order in a small parameter ( [ eq19 ] ) and find @xmath104 , \nonumber \\[-2 mm ] & & \label{eq43 } \\ & & { \rm re}\delta_t\pi(\omega , k , t)=8\alpha\hbar k^2 \int_{\delta/(2\hbar c)}^{\infty}\frac{du}{e^{\beta u}+1 } \left[1+\frac{\delta^2+(\hbar\omega)^2}{4(\hbar cu)^2- ( \hbar\omega)^2}\right ] .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ]    substituting these equations in eq .
( [ eq41 ] ) , one arrives at equal results for @xmath100 and @xmath101 in the local approximation @xmath105 . \label{eq44}\ ] ] similar to sec .
iv , it can be shown that the nonlocal corrections to @xmath106 are negligibly small .
the total imaginary part of the conductivity of graphene in the local approximation is given by @xmath107 where @xmath103 and @xmath108 are given by eqs .
( [ eq28 ] ) and ( [ eq44 ] ) , respectively .    note that under the condition @xmath109 we can obtain simple asymptotic expression for @xmath108 in eq .
( [ eq44 ] ) . for this purpose
we take into account that the main contribution to the integral is given by @xmath110 and that the condition @xmath109 in the frequency region under consideration leads to @xmath111 as well .
then , one can neglect by the second term in square brackets of eq .
( [ eq44 ] ) as compared to unity and , after the integration , arrive at @xmath112    as is seen from eqs .
( [ eq28 ] ) and ( [ eq44 ] ) , the imaginary part of the conductivity of gapped graphene is negative , whereas the thermal correction to it is positive .
this means that the total imaginary part of the conductivity may change its sign at some frequency .
numerical computations confirm this conclusion .
we have computed @xmath113 normalized to @xmath2 as a function of @xmath10 in the region @xmath114 at room temperature @xmath91k in two ways : by eqs .
( [ eq9 ] ) , ( [ eq27 ] ) , ( [ eq41 ] ) , and ( [ eq42 ] ) , i.e. , using the exact polarization tensor with several selected values of @xmath11 , and by eqs .
( [ eq28 ] ) , ( [ eq44 ] ) , and ( [ eq45 ] ) , i.e. , in the local approximation , with nearly coincident results . in fig .
[ fg5](a ) the normalized imaginary part of conductivity of graphene with the gap parameter @xmath115ev is shown as a function of frequency in the region @xmath114 ( the latter is marked by the vertical dashed line ) . as is seen in fig .
[ fg5](a ) , @xmath113 varies from infinity at zero frequency to minus infinity when @xmath116 .
it has a root at some @xmath68 close to @xmath4 . for better vizualization , in fig .
[ fg5](b ) we show an immediate vicinity of the frequency @xmath117 on an enlarged scale .
the root of @xmath113 is @xmath118ev .
the behavior of @xmath108 at @xmath119 is determined by the thermal correction @xmath108 , whereas the behavior in the limiting case @xmath116 is caused by the imaginary part of conductivity at zero temperature @xmath103 ( compare with fig .
[ fg2 ] ) .    for comparison purposes , in fig .
[ fg6 ] the computational results for @xmath113 at @xmath91k , @xmath114 are shown also for a larger gap @xmath97ev . as is seen in fig .
[ fg6 ] , in this case the root of @xmath113 , @xmath120ev , is much more separated from the border frequency @xmath121 than in fig .
[ fg5 ] ( see below for the discussion of the frequency region @xmath57 ) .
we are coming now to the imaginary parts of the conductivities of graphene @xmath113 under the condition @xmath57 .
the imaginary parts of the thermal corrections , @xmath108 , are again given by eq .
( [ eq41 ] ) where , however , the quantities @xmath38 and @xmath39 are expressed by eqs .
( [ eq10])([eq13 ] ) .
these expressions , together with the contribution at zero temperature in eq .
( [ eq27 ] ) , are used below in numerical computations .
it is possible also to obtain the asymptotic expressions valid under certain additional conditions .
thus , according to ref .
@xcite , at relatively high frequencies satisfying the condition @xmath122 one obtains @xmath123 where @xmath124 is the riemann zeta function .
substituting these equations in eq .
( [ eq41 ] ) , we have @xmath125    if @xmath126 and @xmath127 the following asymptotic expressions are valid @xcite @xmath128 then from eq .
( [ eq41 ] ) one arrives at @xmath129    the complete imaginary part of the conductivity of gapped graphene under respective conditions is obtained by summing eqs .
( [ eq48 ] ) and ( [ eq50 ] ) with eq .
( [ eq28 ] ) .
now we present the results of numerical computations using the exact formulas ( [ eq10])([eq13 ] ) , ( [ eq27 ] ) , and ( [ eq41 ] ) . in figs .
[ fg5](a ) and [ fg5](b ) the computational results for @xmath113 normalized to @xmath2 are presented in the frequency region @xmath130ev at room temperature @xmath91k . in fig .
[ fg6 ] similar results are shown for graphene with the gap parameter @xmath97ev . as is seen in figs .  [ fg5](a , b ) and [ fg6 ] , in the frequency region @xmath131 the imaginary part of @xmath132 varies from minus infinity to zero with increasing frequency , i.e. , qualitatively in the same way as at zero temperature . by comparing figs .  [ fg5](a ) and [ fg6 ] it is seen that for a larger gap parameter @xmath113 faster approaches to zero with increasing frequency .
it can be seen that fig .
[ fg6 ] in the frequency region @xmath131 is in a rather good agreement with the asymptotic expression ( [ eq50 ] ) added to the zero - temperature contribution ( [ eq28 ] ) .
this is in accordance with the application conditions of eq .
( [ eq50 ] ) .
in the foregoing , we have investigated the conductivity of gapped graphene described by the dirac model on the basis of first principles of quantum electrodynamics . in doing so
, no input parameter has been used .
both cases of zero and nonzero temperature have been considered .
the longitudinal and transverse conductivities of graphene were expressed via the components of the polarization tensor in ( 2 + 1)-dimensional space - time valid over the entire plane of complex frequency @xcite .
this is a microscopic description in the sense that the polarization tensor eventually represents the response of individual electronic excitations to the electromagnetic field .    at zero temperature ,
we have confirmed the analytic expressions ( [ eq21 ] ) and ( [ eq28 ] ) for both real and imaginary parts of the conductivity of graphene obtained earlier in the local approximation @xcite .
we have also generalized these expressions in eqs .
( [ eq17 ] ) and ( [ eq27 ] ) taking into account nonlocal effects .
the exact expressions for the real parts of thermal corrections to the real parts of conductivities of gapped graphene at zero temperature are defined in eq .
( [ eq35 ] ) .
the small role of nonlocal effects is demonstrated in eq .
( [ eq38 ] ) . finally , simple analytic expression for the real part of the total conductivity of gapped graphene at any temperature
is given by eq .
( [ eq40 ] ) . according to our results ,
the real part of conductivity is equal to zero for @xmath114 . in the frequency region
@xmath57 the real part of conductivity takes some value @xmath133 belonging to the interval @xmath134 at @xmath121 and goes to @xmath2 with increasing frequency .
the value @xmath133 depends on the values of the temperature and gap parameter .    for the imaginary parts of thermal corrections to the imaginary parts of conductivities of gapped graphene at zero temperature ,
the exact expressions are obtained in eqs .
( [ eq41 ] ) and ( [ eq9 ] ) in the frequency region @xmath30 . in the local approximation , the simple eq .
( [ eq44 ] ) is obtained , as well as the asymptotic expression ( [ eq46 ] ) .
the most important impact of temperature on the imaginary part of conductivity of gapped graphene is that it goes to infinity when the frequency vanishes ( at @xmath21 the imaginary part of conductivity goes to zero with vanishing frequency ) .    in the frequency region
@xmath33 the exact expressions for the imaginary parts of thermal corrections are given by eqs .
( [ eq41 ] ) and ( [ eq10])([eq13 ] ) .
the simple asymptotic expressions in this case are given in eqs .
( [ eq48 ] ) and ( [ eq50 ] ) . in all cases
, the results of numerical computations performed using the exact formulas are in a very good agreement with that using the local approximation and with the asymptotic expansions in their areas of application . in the limiting case @xmath135 all the results of this paper smoothly transform into the previously obtained ones for pure graphene @xcite .
finally , we conclude that the description of graphene by means of the polarization tensor calculated using the first principles of quantum electrodynamics at nonzero temperature in ( 2 + 1)-dimensional space - time turns out to be very fruitful not only in the casimir effect , but also for a better understanding of more conventional physical phenomena , such as the reflectivity and conductivity properties of graphene . in this respect
it would be interesting to apply the results of the recent ref .
@xcite for theoretical description of electrical conductivity of graphene with nonzero chemical potential using the formalism of the polarization tensor .
the work of v.m.m .  was partially supported by the russian government program of competitive growth of kazan federal university .
99 m.  i.  katsnelson , _ graphene : carbon in two dimensions _
( cambridge university press , cambridge , 2012 ) .
a.  h.  castro neto , f.  guinea , n.  m.  r.  peres , k.  s.  novoselov , and a.  k.  geim , rev .
mod . phys . * 81 * , 109 ( 2009 ) .
n.  m.  r.  peres , rev .
phys . * 82 * , 2673 ( 2010 ) .
s.  das  sarma , s.  adam , e.  h.  hwang , and e.  rossi , rev .
mod . phys . * 83 * , 407 ( 2011 ) .
a.  w.  w.  ludwig , m.  p.  a.  fisher , r.  shankar , and g.  grinstein , phys .
b * 50 * , 7526 ( 1994 ) .
t.  ando , y.  zheng , and h.  suzuura , j. phys .
. jpn . * 71 * , 1318 ( 2002 ) .
v.  p.  gusynin and s.  g.  sharapov , phys .
b * 73 * , 245411 ( 2006 ) .
m.  i.  katsnelson , eur .
j. b * 51 * , 157 ( 2006 ) .
k.  ziegler , phys .
97 * , 266802 ( 2006 ) .
k.  ziegler , phys .
b * 75 * , 233407 ( 2007 ) .
v.  p.  gusynin , s.  g.  sharapov , and j.  p.  carbotte , phys .
98 * , 157402 ( 2007 ) .
m.  trushin and j.  schliemann , phys .
* 99 * , 216602 ( 2007 ) .
l.  a.  falkovsky and a.  a.  varlamov , eur .
j. b * 56 * , 281 ( 2007 ) .
l.  a.  falkovsky and s.  s.  pershoguba , phys .
b * 76 * , 153410 ( 2007 ) .
m.  auslender and m.  i.  katsnelson , phys .
b * 76 * , 235425 ( 2007 ) . v.  p.  gusynin and s.  g.  sharapov , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 19 * , 026222 ( 2007 ) .
gusynin , s.  g.  sharapov , and j.  p.  carbotte , int . j. mod
b * 21 * , 4611 ( 2007 ) .
t.  stauber , n.  m.  r.  peres , and a.  k.  geim , phys .
b * 78 * , 085432 ( 2008 ) .
n.  m.  r.  peres and t.  stauber , int . j. mod .
b * 22 * , 2529 ( 2008 ) .
t.  g.  pedersen , a .-
jauho , and k.  pedersen , phys .
b * 79 * , 113406 ( 2009 ) .
m.  lewkowicz and b.  rosenstein , phys .
* 102 * , 106802 ( 2009 ) .
j.  j.  palacios , phys .
b * 82 * , 165439 ( 2010 ) .
l.  moriconi and d.  niemeyer , phys .
b * 84 * , 193401 ( 2011 ) . p.  v.  buividovich , e.  v.  luschevskaya , o.  v.  pavlovsky , m.  i.  polikarpov , and m.  v.  ulybyshev , phys .
b * 86 * , 045107 ( 2012 ) . .  b ' acsi and a.  virosztek , phys .
b * 87 * , 125425 ( 2013 ) . c.  a.  dartora and g.  g.  cabrera , phys . rev .
b * 87 * , 165416 ( 2013 ) . t.  stauber , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 26 * , 123201 ( 2014 ) .
t.  louvet , p.  delplace , a.  a.  fedorenko , and d.  carpentier , phys .
b * 92 * , 155116 ( 2015 )
. d.  k.  patel , a.  c.  sharma , and s.  s.  z.  ashraf , phys .
status solidi * 252 * , 282 ( 2015 ) .
m.  merano , phys .
a * 93 * , 013832 ( 2016 ) .
tan , y.  zhang , k.  bolotin , y.  zhao , s.  adam , e.  h.  hwang , s.  das  sarma , h.  l.  stormer , and p.  kim , phys .
lett . * 99 * , 246803 ( 2007 ) .
r.  r.  nair , p.  blake , a.  n.  grigorenko , k.  s.  novoselov , t.  j.  booth , t.  stauber , n.  m.  r.  peres , and a.  k.  geim , science * 320 * , 1308 ( 2008 ) .
z.  li , e.  henriksen , z.  jiang , z.  hao , m.  martin , p.  kim , h.  stormer , and d.  basov , nature phys . * 4 * , 532 ( 2008 ) . k.  f.  mak , m.  y.  sfeir , y.  wu , c.  h.  lui , j.  a.  misewich , and t.  f.  heinz , phys .
* 101 * , 196405 ( 2008 ) .
j.  horng , c .- f .
chen , b.  geng _ et al .
b * 83 * , 165113 ( 2011 ) .
m.  bordag , i.  v.  fialkovsky , d.  m.  gitman , and d.  v.  vassilevich , phys .
b * 80 * , 245406 ( 2009 ) . i.  v.  fialkovsky , v.  n.  marachevsky , and d.  v.  vassilevich , phys . rev .
b * 84 * , 035446 ( 2011 ) .
g.  l.  klimchitskaya , u.  mohideen , and v.  m.  mostepanenko , rev .
phys . * 81 * , 1827 ( 2009 ) .
m.  bordag , g.  l.  klimchitskaya , u.  mohideen , and v.  m.  mostepanenko , _ advances in the casimir effect _
( oxford university press , oxford , 2015 ) .
m.  bordag , g.  l.  klimchitskaya , and v.  m.  mostepanenko , phys .
b * 86 * , 165429 ( 2012 ) .
m.  chaichian , g.  l.  klimchitskaya , v.  m.  mostepanenko , and a.  tureanu , phys .
a * 86 * , 012515 ( 2012 ) .
g.  l.  klimchitskaya and v.  m.  mostepanenko , phys .
b * 87 * , 075439 ( 2013 ) . g.  l.  klimchitskaya , u.  mohideen , and v.  m.  mostepanenko , phys
. rev b * 89 * , 115419 ( 2014 ) .
g.  l.  klimchitskaya , v.  m.  mostepanenko , and bo e.  sernelius , phys .
b * 89 * , 125407 ( 2014 ) .
b.  arora , h.  kaur , and b.  k.  sahoo , j. phys .
b * 47 * , 155002 ( 2014 ) . k.  kaur , j.  kaur , b.  arora , and b.  k.  sahoo , phys .
b * 90 * , 245405 ( 2014 ) .
g.  l.  klimchitskaya and v.  m.  mostepanenko , phys .
b * 91 * , 045412 ( 2015 )
. g.  gmez - santos , phys .
b * 80 * , 245424 ( 2009 ) .
d.  drosdoff and l.  m.  woods , phys .
b * 82 * , 155459 ( 2010 ) .
d.  drosdoff and l.  m.  woods , phys .
a * 84 * , 062501 ( 2011 ) .
bo e.  sernelius , europhys . lett . * 95 * , 57003 ( 2011 ) . bo e.  sernelius , phys .
b * 85 * , 195427 ( 2012 ) . a.  d.  phan , l.  m.  woods , d.  drosdoff , i.  v.  bondarev , and n.  a.  viet , appl .
phys . lett .
* 101 * , 113118 ( 2012 ) .
g.  l.  klimchitskaya and v.  m.  mostepanenko , phys .
rev a * 89 * , 052512 ( 2014 ) .
a.  a.  banishev , h.  wen , j.  xu , r.  k.  kawakami , g.  l.  klimchitskaya , v.  m.  mostepanenko , and u.  mohideen , phys .
b * 87 * , 205433 ( 2013 ) .
m.  bordag , g.  l.  klimchitskaya , v.  m.  mostepanenko , and v.  m.  petrov , phys .
d * 91 * , 045037 ( 2015 ) ; * 93 * , 089907(e ) ( 2016 ) .
g.  l.  klimchitskaya and v.  m.  mostepanenko , phys .
rev b * 91 * , 174501 ( 2015 ) .
g.  l.  klimchitskaya , int .
a * 31 * , 1641026 ( 2016 ) .
g.  l.  klimchitskaya , c.  c.  korikov , and v.  m.  petrov , phys .
b * 92 * , 125419 ( 2015 ) ; * 93 * , 159906(e ) ( 2016 ) . g.  l.  klimchitskaya and v.  m.  mostepanenko , phys .
rev b * 93 * , 245419 ( 2016 ) .
g.  l.  klimchitskaya and v.  m.  mostepanenko , phys .
rev a * 93 * , 052106 ( 2016 ) .
k.  pyatkovsky , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 21 * , 025506 ( 2009 ) .
v.  p.  gusynin , s.  g.  sharapov , and j.  p.  carbotte , new j. phys . * 11 * , 095013 ( 2009 ) .
s.  a.  jafari , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 24 * , 205802 ( 2012 ) .
bo e.  sernelius , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 27 * , 214017 ( 2015 ) .
i.  s.  gradshtein and i.  m.  ryzhik , _ table of integrals , series and products _
( academic press , new york , 1980 ) . m.  bordag , i.  fialkovsky , and d.  vassilevich , phys .
b * 93 * , 075414 ( 2016 ) .
the real part of the conductivity of gapped graphene at zero temperature normalized to @xmath2 is shown by the solid line as a function of frequency divided by the width of the gap .
the dashed line illustrates the condition @xmath121 . ]     the imaginary part of the conductivity of gapped graphene at zero temperature normalized to @xmath2 is shown by the solid line as a function of frequency divided by the width of the gap .
the dashed line illustrates the condition @xmath121 . ]
( a ) the normalized to @xmath2 real part of the conductivity of graphene with the gap parameter @xmath89ev is shown as a function of frequency by the three lines plotted from top to bottom at temperature @xmath90 , 100 , and 300k , respectively .
the dashed line illustrates the condition @xmath121 .
( b ) the same is shown on an enlarged scale at low frequencies . ]     the normalized to @xmath2 real part of the conductivity of graphene with the gap parameter ( a ) @xmath93ev and ( b ) @xmath94ev is shown as a function of frequency by the three lines plotted from top to bottom at temperature @xmath90 , 100 , and 300k , respectively .
the dashed line illustrates the condition @xmath121 . ]
( a ) the normalized to @xmath2 imaginary part of the conductivity of graphene with the gap parameter @xmath115ev is shown as a function of frequency by the solid line plotted at temperature @xmath91k .
the dashed line illustrates the condition @xmath121 .
( b ) the same is shown on an enlarged scale in the vicinity of @xmath121 . ]     the normalized to @xmath2 imaginary part of the conductivity of graphene with the gap parameter @xmath97ev is shown as a function of frequency by the solid line plotted at temperature @xmath91k .
the dashed line illustrates the condition @xmath121 . ]