neutrals play an important role in the evolution of the weakly ionized solar chromosphere where the number density of neutrals can vastly exceed the number density of protons . therefore , modeling the neutral - ion interactions and studying the effect of neutrals on the ambient plasma properties is an important task for better understanding the observed emission lines and the propagation of disturbances from the photosphere through the chromosphere and transition region into the solar corona .
previous theoretical analysis and recent spectral analysis of raster scans with iris data , for instance in mg ii h 2803- chromospheric spectral line , commonly show the occurrence of double - peaks in the spectroscopic lines , which could be explained only with the presence of neutrals @xcite .
the solar chromosphere and transition region regulate the mass , energy and momentum transfer from the underlying photosphere and convection zones into the upper atmospheric layer , known as the corona .
it is well - known that the complexity of the chromosphere is related to its partially ionized plasma , which does not fulfill local thermodynamical equilibrium . due to chemical reactions such as impact ionization ,
the hydrogen gas in the chromosphere varies from predominantly neutral to predominantly ionized , which has important consequences on the fluid behavior of the plasma and can significantly affect the magneto - thermodynamics descriptions . as we follow the decreasing plasma density and pressure gradients through the chromosphere the plasma behavior changes from highly collisional to weakly collisional and the system transitions from gas - pressure dominated to magnetically driven .
these observed plasma properties affect the propagation of magneto - hydrodynamic waves through the chromospheric layer and influence the deposit of energy and related plasma heating there .    up to now
, the numerical modeling of plasma field properties and wave propagation within the solar chromosphere extensively includes different sets of multi - dimensional mhd simulations @xcite as well as improved mhd models .
the latter include partial ionization effects by including an ambipolar diffusion term in the generalized ohm s law and in the energy equations , as considered by @xcite .
previously , the effects of partial ionization and their consequence on the chromospheric magneto - thermodynamics have been considered by using generalized ohm s law in extended mhd approach @xcite or in a radiative - mhd models , based for example on the bifrost code @xcite which combines mhd equations with non - grey and non - lte radiative transfer and thermal conduction along magnetic field lines @xcite . adding the effects of partial ionization leads to additional chromospheric heating , which depends on the geometry of the model chromospheric magnetic field , as the ambipolar diffusion term is proportional to the perpendicular current @xcite .
alternatively , the multi - fluid simulations which are discussed in this paper more rigorously account for partial ionization effects by considering neutrals as a separate species , which relaxes the possible limitations of state - of - the - art improved mhd approximations .    recently ,
more attention has being drawn to the consequences of ion - neutral interactions on the propagation of mhd waves throughout the chromosphere @xcite .
analytical calculations have suggested that the dominant presence of neutrals in the chromosphere would lead to an over - damping of the alfn waves there , which would change their commonly expected energy deposit in the corona @xcite . nevertheless , there are no rigorous calculations of partial ionization effects on the propagation and damping of alfvn , fast and slow magnetosonic in a reactive gravitationally stratified collisional media and their interaction with the surrounding plasma . in this respect ,
the present model provides a first attempt to consider such interactions within chemically reactive multi - fluid simulations .    to pursue this goal
we have developed two - dimensional two - fluid simulation setups to study the interaction between charged particles and neutrals in a reactive gravitationally stratified collisional media .
the model is a variation of the two - fluid approach recently developed by @xcite to study chromospheric reconnection in a reactive media , where the gravitational force has been neglected and only constant temperature and densities have been considered . in this work
we have extended the model by @xcite to include the observed temperature and density stratification .
in addition , considering pure hydrogen plasma , we have removed the additional charge exchange terms introduced by @xcite , which in the absence of heavy ions simply translate into elastic collisions @xcite .
separate mass , momentum and energy conservation equations are considered for the ions and the neutrals .
furthermore the interaction between the two fluids is determined by the elastic collisions and the chemical reactions ( e.g. impact ionization and radiative recombination ) , which are provided as additional source terms .
to initialize the system we consider an ideal gas equation of state with equal initial temperatures for the electrons , ions and the neutrals , but different density profiles for the charged and neutral particles species .
the initial temperature and density profiles are height - dependent and follow vernazza - avrett - loeser ( hereafter val c ) atmospheric model @xcite for the solar chromosphere . to avoid unphysical outflows and artificial heating we have search for a chemical and collisional equilibrium between the ions and the neutrals , eliminating the initial hydrodynamic pressure imbalances .
next , we have considered the ion - neutral interactions in a partially ionized magnetized plasma with an initial magnetic profile , corresponding to a homogeneous magnetic flux tube .
the magnetic field profile is not force - free and introduces additional pressure gradients in the upper chromosphere .
finally we include an external velocity driver and simulate the propagation of magnetosonic waves through the photosphere and the chromosphere .
in this section , we describe in details our two - fluid model , where the protons and electrons are described within a single - fluid mhd description neglecting the electron inertia terms . a separate second fluid is used to describe the evolution of neutrals , which interact with the plasma via elastic collisions , impact ionization and radiative recombination .
the numerical schemes , the model equations and the initial conditions are explained in the subsections below .
the 2d two - fluid numerical simulations are carried out using a fully coupled multi - fluid / maxwell solver @xcite which has been implemented within coolfluid @xcite .
the latter is an open source platform for high - performance scientific computing @xcite , featuring advanced computational models / solvers for tackling re - entry aerothermodynamics @xcite , simulation of experiments in high - enthalpy facilities @xcite , ideal magnetohydrodynamics for space weather prediction @xcite , radiation transport by means of ray tracing and monte carlo @xcite algorithms , etc .
the temporal evolution of the multi - fluid equations is based on an implicit second - order three - point backward euler scheme , while the spatial derivatives are calculated using a state - of - the - art second - order finite volume method for unstructured grids .
the algebraic system resulting from a newton linearization is solved by means of a generalized minimal residual ( gmres ) algorithm complemented by a parallel preconditioner ( additive schwartz method ) as provided by the petsc library @xcite .
the maxwell solver is fully relativistic and includes a divergence - cleaning correction @xcite to ensure that the magnetic field remains divergence - free .
the discretization of the convective fluxes are based on a upwind advection upstream splitting method ( ausm+up scheme ) for the multi - fluid equations and on a modified steger - warming scheme for the maxwell counterpart .
the numerical solver is explained in great details in @xcite .    for the purpose of studying wave excitation by photospheric drivers we use a subsonic inlet at the lower boundary with prescribed electromagnetic fields , ion and neutral velocities .
the value of the temperature at the lower boundary is imposed and the pressure for both plasma and neutrals is extrapolated to ensure zero pressure gradient at the lower boundary .
for the side boundaries and at the top we use supersonic outlet with open boundary conditions , which allows the generated perturbation to propagate out of the simulation domain .      here
we present the model equations for the two - fluid treatment , with mhd protons and electrons and a separate fluid description for the neutrals . the continuity , momentum and energy equations for the reactive and resistive viscous plasma and the neutrals are presented below .
the change of plasma and neutral mass density is governed by the interplay of ionization and recombination rates : @xmath0 where the @xmath1 and @xmath2 are the mass density of protons and neutrals , @xmath3 and @xmath4 are the corresponding velocities , and @xmath5 and @xmath6 are the ionization and recombination rates , which satisfy @xmath7 and @xmath8 .
the explicit formulas for the ionization rates and the corresponding cross - sections for the chemical reactions are presented below in a subsection devoted to describe the initial chemical equilibrium .
the momentum equations for the plasma and the neutral fluids are given by : @xmath9 where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the corresponding pressures for the ions and the neutral fluid .
the first equation describes the momentum transfer of the mhd plasma , including both charged particles ( protons and electrons ) , therefore the gradient of the electron pressure @xmath12 is included in the plasma flux . in this study
the electron inertia terms are neglected .
furthermore we assume charge neutrality @xmath13 and equal temperatures between the two charged particles @xmath14 .
the stress tensor for both ions and neutrals follows the standard expression @xcite : @xmath15,\ ] ] where @xmath16 is the dynamic viscosity coefficient . for the ions we select @xmath17
$ ] and for the neutrals @xmath18 $ ] .
the current in the lorentz force is given by the generalized ohm s law presented below and the gravity force in the chromospere is well approximated by a constant solar acceleration in vertical direction @xmath19 .
the elastic collisions between the ions and neutrals are described for example in @xcite @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the center of momentum mass .
@xmath22 is the collisional frequency in hz which depends on the average temperature @xmath23 and the collisional cross - section @xmath24 .
recent estimates , which are based on atomic physics calculations , show that the temperature dependence of the collisional cross - sections in the selected chromospheric region is insignificant @xcite .
therefore for the purpose of our study we have selected constant cross - sections @xmath25 $ ] as considered in @xcite .
for the purely electron - hydrogen plasma which is considered here with no heavy ions , the effect of the charge exchange is reduced to regular elastic collisions @xcite and therefore it is not taken into account separately , as done for example in @xcite . the momentum transfer due to inelastic collisions is discussed in more details in the next subsection .
the corresponding energy conservation laws for the charged and neutral fluids follow the equations : @xmath26 @xmath27 where , in eq .
[ energyplasma ] , electrons are considered to move at the ion speed @xmath28 .
for the momentum and energy evolution , an ideal gas equation of state is assumed with @xmath29 .
the adiabatic index for all species is considered equal @xmath30 .
the kinetic and internal energies for the protons and neutrals are given by @xmath31 the plasma heat flux vector includes contributions from both electrons and protons and takes into account conductivities parallel and perpendicular with respect to the direction of the external magnetic field @xcite .
assuming equal number density and temperature for the ions and electrons the plasma heat flux becomes @xcite : @xmath32 where the @xmath33 is the unit vector in the direction of the magnetic field .
the parallel and perpendicular heat conductivities @xmath34 and @xmath35 are calculated based on the classical transport theory @xcite : @xmath36 n_it_i,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 and @xmath38 accordingly are the temperature and density dependent collisional times for electrons and protons , @xmath39 and the corresponding cyclotron frequencies and @xmath40 .
the heat conduction for the neutral gas is unaffected by the magnetic field : @xmath41 where the isotropic heat conductance coefficient is set to @xmath42 $ ] as considered in @xcite .
the electromagnetic fields above are self - consistently evolved according to the full maxwell equations , which are complemented with the divergence cleaning electric @xmath43 and magnetic field @xmath44 potentials .
the full maxwell solver allows for propagation of high - frequency waves , which are neglected by the standard mhd approximation . the hyperbolic divergence cleaning procedure guarantees that the magnetic field remains divergence - free .
any deviations are instantaneously propagated out with the corresponding characteristic velocities @xmath45 and @xmath46 , where @xmath47 is the speed of light , and @xmath48 and @xmath49 are positive parameters as described in @xcite : @xmath50 in order to compare our results to existing mhd simulations of chromospheric wave propagation , in this study the current is computed by a simplified version of the generalized ohm s law , where we neglect the secondary effects of electron inertia @xmath51 , the hall term @xmath52 , the battery term @xmath53 , and the electron - neutral collisions @xmath54 . under these assumptions
the resistive ohm s law takes the simplified form : @xmath55 to compute the electrical resistivity , @xmath56 , we calculate both the collisional frequencies of electrons with ions and electrons with neutrals , @xmath57 , following the expressions @xcite @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the center of mass between electrons and ions , and @xmath60 , @xmath61 are the average temperatures .
the collisional cross - section between ions and electrons is computed from braginskii s expressions @xcite , @xmath62 , where @xmath63 is the debye length and @xmath64 is the approximate value of the coloumb logarithm in the chromosphere . the collisional cross - section for electron - neutral collisions
is taken to be @xmath65 $ ] , although quantitatively similar results are obtained when a smaller collisional cross - secion is used with @xmath66 $ ] .
the conductivity is inversely proportional to the electrical resistivity @xmath67 .      in order to model the reactive inhomogeneous chromospheric plasma , we initialize the code with a height - dependent temperature profile , given by the original val c chromospheric model @xcite . the val c model , as well as the more recent follow - up chromospheric models @xcite
, do not distinguish between the temperature of molecular hydrogen and protons , and provide a single temperature profile for the single ionized hydrogen and the neutrals .
the lack of observational data for the separate temperature profiles of neutrals and ions poses a problem for a realistic non - lte multi - fluid modeling . therefore to best relate to the existing global atmospheric models within our two - fluid description we have assumed initially isothermal plasma with @xmath68 .
the initial density profiles for the neutrals has also been adopted from val c model @xcite .
the initial proton density follows a modified val c profile , which assumes initial chemical equilibrium .
given the fact that our model is based on initially isothermal single ionized proton - electron plasma with neutral hydrogen and currently does not take into account chemical reactions which involve heavier species , adopting the val c atmospheric density profiles for the protons and neutrals results in a chemical imbalance between the ionization and the recombination rates .
this imbalance could be resolved if different temperature profiles for the protons and neutrals are assumed .
however such different temperature profiles are currently not provided by observations and including them would make the comparison to existing ( generalized ) mhd models more difficult .
the ionization and the recombination coefficients in @xmath69 $ ] for hydrogen plasma used in our study follow the expressions in @xcite @xmath70 where @xmath71 is a dimensionless parameter , which takes into account the temperature dependence of the ionization and recombination rates . in this expression
, @xmath72 is the electron temperature in ev , @xmath73ev is the ionization potential for hydrogen atoms and @xmath74 is a constant , which takes into account the influence of heavy ions and has been introduced to match the expected ionization rates @xmath75 , as predicted by the val c model @xcite .
we should note that despite the different functional form for the selected temperature range these ionization and recombination coefficients are practically identical to the ones proposed by voronov and smirnov @xcite , which have been used in the multi - fluid modeling by @xcite.    the ionization and recombination rates which account for the mass , momentum and energy transfer in the multi - fluid system read : @xmath76 in order to build a solid physical understanding of the reactive multi - fluid problem and for the sake of comparison to results from existing fluid theories , we have initialized the code assuming a chemical equilibrium , where the ionization and the recombination rates initially balance each other @xmath77 .
therefore , if we assume an initially isothermal plasma with temperature and neutral density profiles following the tabulated values from val c model @xcite , in order to maintain a chemical equilibrium for the neutrals we need to slightly modify the ion density profile .
figure  [ fig1:init_temp ] represents a 1d cut with the initial mass density and temperature profiles used in the simulations .
all plasma parameters vary with the heliocentric distance and the neutral density changes by 5 orders of magnitude .
the ions and neutrals are initially considered in thermal equilibrium with @xmath78 .
the modified plasma density in our model has similar shape to the inferred electron density presented in the chromospheric model by @xcite .
the initial profiles capture the photospheric temperature minimum around 500  km and the consequent temperature increase in the upper chromosphere .
the ionization level increases , as the neutral and ion densities become more comparable in the upper chromosphere .
the 2d contour plots of the initial temperature profile and its variation throughout the simulations are presented in the results section in figure  [ fig3:initt ] .
+ in the next section we present in details the results from the simulations and discuss their relation to previous models in the available literature .
our multi - fluid simulations are performed based on dimensional quantities and all results are provided in si units .
where necessary , an appropriate conversion from cgs or other units has been introduced to correct for the different expressions of the source terms and the transport coefficients as provided in the literature . for visualization purposes , we use cartesian grid , where the heliocentric distance is represented by the vertical @xmath79 axis , and the horizontal variations are given in @xmath80 direction .
the physical size of the box is @xmath81 mm by @xmath81 mm and we have used a moderate spacial resolution of 200 grid points in each direction .
we should note that increasing the resolution does not significantly affect the wave propagation , but increases initial force imbalance due to sharper gradients and results in stronger velocity outflows . in order to study the evolution of sound and magnetosonic waves in the chromosphere , we have adopted a simple gaussian magnetic field profile and a photospheric foot - point velocity driver used in mhd and improved partially ionized mhd models with ambipolar diffusion terms , as presented for example in @xcite : @xmath82    , title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0%],title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0%],title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ]
the magnetic field strength has been set to @xmath83 g , the flux tube is placed in the center of the domain at @xmath84 mm , and the width of the initial magnetic field foot - point has been selected to @xmath85 km as in @xcite .
the magnitude of the velocity driver is set to @xmath86 m/s as assumed in @xcite .
the period of the driver was set to @xmath87s , so that the corresponding frequency is @xmath88hz .
the time step used for the simulations varies between @xmath89ms and @xmath90s .
we should note that the selected initial magnetic field profile is divergence - free , but not force - free and it does carry some current . due to the low magnitude of the magnetic field considered here , the lorentz force associated with it is rather small .
i.e. of the order of @xmath91n . nevertheless this force becomes significant in the upper chromosphere , where the pressure gradient and the gravity are substantially reduced due to the depleted plasma density in this region .
these currents cause plasma expansion due to the current - related horizontal outflows in the upper chromosphere , resulting in plasma cooling , as described later in the paper .    to compare our results to previous mhd and generalized mhd simulations we have used several different initial simulation setups . in order to generate acoustic and magnetosonic waves in the photosphere ,
we have perturbed the horizontal and vertical velocity of the ions , as well as the horizontal and vertical velocities of the neutrals .
the main difference between applying the velocity driver on the ions and the neutrals is in the amplitude of the excited perturbations . since ions are much less abundant than neutrals , while perturbing the ion velocity we input less kinetic energy into the system : this generates smaller pressure gradients and results in less intense waves .
however , apart from their amplitude , all physical quantities ( e.g. wave properties , velocity and temperatures profiles ) remain the same .
therefore for a better representation , in the remaining of the paper we will concentrate on the case of velocity driver applied on the neutrals .
figure  [ fig2:mag_field ] describes the magnetic field profiles at two different times .
the initial magnetic field is given on the left panel and has a gaussian profile , following eq .
[ eqn : bfield ] .
it has a maximum magnitude of @xmath92 g inside the flux tube and zero value outside the tube .
the right panel describes the evolution of the magnetic field at a later stage at @xmath93s .
the evolution shows strong diffusion of the magnetic field at the location of the temperature minimum in the photosphere .
since the resistivity in our study is defined within the classical transport theory @xcite , it has a strong dependence on the temperature @xmath94 .
therefore the observed diffusion of the magnetic field is related to resistive dissipation and occurs in the region where the resistivity is strongest . the magnetic field diffusion in the upper part of the chromosphere is related to ohmic dissipation in the region where the lorentz force becomes comparable to the otherwise dominant pressure gradient .
the lower chromosphere is dominated by the pressure gradients , gravity and collisions . in the upper chromosphere
the current associated with the initial magnetic field profile leads to strong horizontal flows ( with maximum velocities of the order of 1 - 2 km / s ) , which result in expansion of the flux tube . towards the end of the simulations the flux tube opens up and starts to resemble the observed magnetic funnels .    as mentioned above in the upper chromosphere at @xmath95 mm , the expansion caused by the horizontal flows and the horizontal currents
leads to associated cooling and density depletion of the plasma inside the flux tube .
as the plasma cools , it becomes heavy .
inside the flux tube there is no current to push the plasma outwards and the matter starts to fall back towards the lower chromosphere .
this leads to an extended region with decreased plasma temperature and depleted density inside the flux tube .
figure  [ fig3:initt ] illustrates the initial vertical temperature profile ( left panel ) with homogeneous horizontal distribution and the onset of inhomogeneous horizontal profile ( right panel ) , due to the described expansion and related plasma cooling inside the magnetic flux tube . at @xmath93s
the velocity driver has already generated sound and fast magnetosonic waves and we observe symmetric oscillations in all physical quantities .
the vertical driver mixes the cooler plasma from the photosphere with the hotter regions in the mid and upper chromosphere , forming clear wave patterns . although shock waves are never formed within our study , as the waves propagate upward some compressional heating at the wave fronts
is observed . within the flux tube the compressional heating is overcome by the cooling caused by the expansion and the plasma there remains cooler .
some additional cooling is also observed near the temperature minimum in the photosphere where the magnetic field diffuses due to the enhanced resistivity .
we should note that the cooling in the middle of the flux tube is a mhd effect and does not exist in pure hydrodynamic description , as proven by analogous test simulations performed without magnetic field . as we explained above the lorentz force at the upper chromosphere
becomes dominant over the gravity and the pressure gradient and the associated current results in horizontal outflows , which cause expansion and result in related cooling of the confined plasma inside the magnetic flux tube .
reactive hydrodynamic multifluid simulations with exactly the same plasma conditions except for the electromagnetic fields show no cooling at in the upper chromosphere and no significant change in temperature over all , apart from some cooling at the photospheric level , close to the initial temperature minimum .
we should note that in the extremely dense photospheric and chromospheric conditions the collisional frequency between ions and neutrals is very big . as a result
the collisional time is much shorter than any other dynamical timescales in the system and all initial differences between the different particle species practically immediately balance out , leading to a single dynamics for the evolution of their fluid velocities and temperature . in this respect
the effect of the electromagnetic fields on the electrons and ions is transported to the neutrals through frequent collisions , so that their temperatures and velocities become practically the same .
therefore in this plot and throughout the paper we will show single plots referring to the temperature and velocities for both species .
figure  [ fig : rhot0top ] shows the observed plasma cooling and the density depletion for both ions and neutrals at the top of the chromosphere , @xmath96 mm . the figure shows the initial constant values of the densities and temperature ( the constant straight lines ) and their depletion and decrease inside the flux tube in the course of evolution . as expected the minimum of the densities and the temperature is in the center of the flux tube . we should note that although originally only the ions are affected by the horizontal currents , due to the strong collisionality the neutrals follow the ions and their density and temperatures are also reduced .
the ion and the neutral densities decrease up to one order of magnitude inside the flux tube and their value outside the flux tube oscillates in time with the propagation of the magnetosonic waves . within 178 seconds the temperature and the densities outside the flux tube are higher than the initial values and the temperature inside the tube is reduced by two thousands kelvin from @xmath97k to as low as @xmath98k .
the figure shows the temperature and density profiles within the first 6 wave periods , before the waves reach the upper boundary . afterwards
the sound and the fast waves result in density and temperature oscillations with combination of additional heating / cooling and higher amplitude density fluctuations outside the flux tube .
regardless of the waves , the cooling and the density depletion inside the flux tube remain until the end of the simulations and are also present in simulations without initial driver .
we should note that the heating at the boundary of the flux tube might be related to ion - neutral interactions as modeled by generalized mhd models , where the heating due to ambipolar diffusion term is proportional to the perpendicular current .
such scenarios are discussed for example by @xcite .
figure  [ fig : uv ] shows an example of the horizontal and vertical velocity profiles at @xmath93s .
this time moment is not unique and has been randomly selected to illustrate the wave behavior as visible in the two velocity components .
both horizontal and vertical velocity components show symmetric contours typical for sound waves and fast magnetosonic waves propagating along the magnetic field lines . the vertical velocity component is higher than the horizontal velocity .
we can also see the change in the plasma velocity related to the distortion of the wave fronts along the flux tube , which becomes clearly visible in the upper chromosphere as we approach the alfvnic point where @xmath99 . in the upper chromosphere
the wave propagation is strongly affected by the magnetic field , and we observe a transition from fast to slow magnetosonic waves .
we should note that in both magnetized and hydrodynamic multi - fluid cases the initial val c atmosphere is slightly convectionally unstable and results in horizontal and vertical flows .
one of the reasons for that is that the local thermodynamical equilibrium assumption in their atmospheric model is not fully satisfied .
an additional reason is the fixed viscosity coefficients used in our model , which result in under - viscous plasma in the photosphere . within physical time of 700 seconds in both hydro and magnetized cases without initial wave driver , the maximum velocity amplitude is of the order of @xmath100km / s for the horizontal flows and 2 - 2.5km / s for the vertical flows .
typically the horizontal flows are within @xmath101 m/s . due to the induced horizontal currents
, the applied initial magnetic field profile enhances the horizontal flows in the upper chromosphere where the lorentz force dominates over the plasma and neutral gas pressure gradients and the plasma @xmath102 becomes close to unity . still without initial driver
the unstable convective flows are at least an order of magnitude smaller than the estimated sound speed throughout the photosphere and chromosphere , as well as the alfvn , slow ( tube ) and fast speeds ( calculated based upon the total ion and neutral density ) inside the magnetic flux tube .
figure  [ fig : vs ] shows the vertical profile of the sound speed @xmath103 and its variation in time in the center of the flux tube .
the different times have been selected to qualitatively represent the sound speed variations as a function of the initial velocity driver , whose period was set to @xmath104 seconds . within the first four wave periods
the sound speed decreases in the upper chromosphere , mainly due to the cooling and density depletion caused by the horizontal currents . within six wave periods
the sounds speed starts to oscillate with the amplitude of the driver throughout the entire chromosphere .
as the driven waves reach the @xmath99 region in the upper chromosphere above @xmath105 mm the period of the sound waves oscillations changes due to mode conversion .
in addition the density variations in the upper chromosphere increase as the waves reach the upper boundary , which results in higher amplitude sound waves at @xmath106s .
figure  [ fig : va ] illustrates the temporal evolution of the alfvn speed in the center of the magnetic flux tube based on the total plasma and neutral density , @xmath107 , where @xmath108 is the total density . at @xmath109 the aflvn speed profile is fully determined by the initial magnetic field and density profiles .
as the magnetosonic waves excited by the initial photospheric velocity driver propagate up in the chromosphere , they induce density variations which result in variations of the alfvn speed over time .
additionally the magnetic field diffuses both in the photosphere where the spitzer resistivity is highest and in the upper chromosphere , where the cross - section of the flux tube increases as the initial vertical flux tube starts to open into a magnetic funnel .
this opening leads to diffusion of the magnetic field and results in reduction of the alfvn speed over time .
we should note that the deliberate choice of plotting the alfvn speed based on the total density is made in order to compare the model results and expectations to existing mhd and generalized mhd theories , where the effect of the neutrals is treated as additional terms in the energy and momentum equations of the plasma , but the neutral density is not evolved separately and the plasma density is governed by the charged particles , protons and electrons . as expected due to the huge number density difference between the ions and neutrals , the alfvn speed based on the ion density inside the flux tube is much bigger and compared to it the plasma flows remain practically sub - alfvnic at all times in the entire simulation box .
apart from the sound and the alfvn speed we can also calculate the velocity of the slow magnetosonic waves or the so - called tube speed .
due to the high plasma density in the photosphere and the low chromosphere , the tube speed calculated in the middle of the magnetic flux tube at the lower boundary is only @xmath110 m/s .
similar to the alfvn speed it increases with height and at the top of the chromosphere it becomes more than 40km / s and becomes comparable to the sound speed .
while the sound speed inside the flux tube decreases in the time due to the observed cooling , the tube speed based on the total density gradually increases in height at all times .
the tube speed based on the ion density remains quasi conserved throughout the magnetic flux tube with a magnitude of approximately 40km / s throughout the chromosphere .
figure  [ fig : va_to_vs ] shows the ratio of the alfvn speed divided by the sound speed , which corresponds to the inverse square root of the plasma @xmath102 in the center of the magnetic flux tube .
the left panel shows the ratio , when the magnitude of the alfvn speed is calculated based on the total density including the contribution of the plasma and the neutrals .
the right panel shows the variation of the @xmath111 ratio when the alfvn speed is calculated based solely on the plasma density . clearly ,
if we consider only the density of the magnetized plasma , the entire chromosphere as well as most of the photosphere will be in a very low plasma @xmath102 regime , as @xmath112 .
on one hand the neutrals are not directly affected by the magnetic field and therefore they should not enter in the calculation of the alfvn speed . on the other hand the high collisional rate between ions and neutrals
forces the two species to move together and within an mhd picture only the total mass density plays a role . if we look at the @xmath111 ratio , when the alfvn speed is calculated based on the total density the plasma @xmath102 remains high in the entire photosphere and above until approximately @xmath105 mm in the upper chromosphere , where @xmath102 becomes of the order of unity . in the uppermost chromosphere @xmath113 ,
therefore in this region the magnetic field plays a role and the plasma is no longer governed by hydrodynamics .
the ratio of alfvn to sound speed on the left panel is very low close to the solar surface and increases with heliocentric distance . at the bottom of the chromosphere in the center of the magnetic flux tube
the alfvn speed is approximately two orders of magnitude slower than the sound speed . at 1 mm
it varies between 0.25 and 0.28 , depending on the simulation time . due to the magnetic field diffusion ,
the alfvn speed slightly descreases in time , which results in a lower @xmath111 ratio . at 1.5 mm
the ratio increases to 0.5 - 0.8 and close to @xmath114 mm the two speeds match , which in mhd models marks the threshold of plasma @xmath102 = 1 .
the highest ratio of the two speeds is reached at the top of the chromosphere and is of the order of 3.2 , which would correspond to a plasma @xmath115 in the single fluid description .
we should note that in the estimates above the alfvn speed is calculated based on the total mass density , which includes ions and neutrals .
when we consider the classical alfvn speed which was invented for fully ionized media and is based on the plasma fluid density only ( ions and electrons ) , then the flow becomes supersonic at much lower heights , approximately above @xmath116 km .
figure  [ fig : kinenneutrals ] depicts the altitudinal variation of the kinetic energy density of neutrals at the longitudinal position of the photospheric driver as a function of the driver period .
the left and the right panels represent different instances of time , which are proportional to the period of the initial driver . at @xmath109
there are no flows in the system and the kinetic energy for both species is zero . within the first six wave periods the kinetic energy in the photosphere and the lower chromosphere remains in phase with the period of the driver and the kinetic energy gradually decreases with distance as the neutral density gets depleted .
after the waves reach the upper chromosphere and cross the @xmath117 region the period of the velocity oscillations changes , which results in out - of - phase fluctuations for the kinetic energy of the neutrals .
figure  [ fig::kinenions ] shows the kinetic energy density of ions as a function of height and the period of the initial driver . on the left panel
once again we can see that it takes about 6 periods for the waves to reach the upper chromosphere .
the drop in the kinetic energy around @xmath86 km is due to the trough in the initial density profile at this location , see figure  [ fig1:init_temp ] .
the currents induced by the lorentz force in the upper chromosphere cause some additional flows and different frequency velocity oscillations , which quickly become in phase with the initial driver as the driven oscillations reach the given height .
the right panel shows that at a later stage ( 358 seconds approximately correspond to 12 periods of the initial driver ) the ion kinetic energy fluctuations are fully in phase in the lower and middle chromosphere , and similar to the sound speed their period changes in the upper chromosphere above @xmath105 mm where the plasma @xmath102 becomes of the order of unity and below .
another aspect of the initial velocity driver is the effect of the induced oscillations on the chemical reactions in the system figures  [ fig : gammaion ] and [ fig : gammarec ] show 2d contour plots with the change of the ionization and the recombination rates induced by the initial driver .
the ionization becomes affected by the waves quicker than the recombination , which results in local loss of chemical equilibrium .
finally figure  [ fig : ionizrate ] shows the change of ionization fraction @xmath75 caused by the initial driver inside the magnetic flux tube .
due to the several orders of magnitude difference between the number density of ions and neutrals in the photosphere and the lower chromosphere the ionization fraction there remains almost unchanged by the driven oscillations . for heights @xmath118 1 mm where the ion mass density reaches a local maximum
we observe the onset of related fluctuations in the ionization rate .
the period of the oscillations changes in time and the relative number density of ions decreases in time in the upper chromosphere above @xmath105 mm , where the loss of chemical equilibrium results in recombination rate prevailing over the ionization .
within the fully 3d coolfluid framework we have used a two - fluid numerical simulation setup , which treat the charged particles within a generalized mhd approximation and considers a separate fluid of neutrals .
the two fluids are coupled through collisions and chemical reactions , such as impact ionization and radiative recombination .
the newly developed simulation module includes the effects of gravitational force imposed on the initial stratified density and temperature profiles , given by a modified val c chromospheric model .
our simulations take into account braginskii collisional transport coefficients with anisotropic heat conduction , spitzer - type resistivity and accounts for the basic chemical reactions in a hydrogen plasma .
we have initialized the simulations with a simple gaussian magnetic flux tube , which diffuses in time and opens starting to form a magnetic funnel . to compare to existing mhd and generalized mhd models
we have imposed initial thermal and chemical equilibrium .
we have included a photospheric velocity driver at the foot - point of the magnetic field , and have followed the evolution of the system in the presence of the driven sound and fast magnetosonic waves . within 5 minutes of simulated real time the initial driver induces loss of chemical equilibrium with dominant recombination in the upper chromosphere and gradual reduction of the ionization fraction in time .
regardless of the selected low magnitude of the magnetic field , we find significant heating of the higher chromospheric layers outside the magnetic flux tube with some overall cooling at low to mid - low altitudes .
significant cooling is also observed in the upper chromospheric layers inside the flux tube , where the temperature can be more than @xmath119k degrees cooler than the surrounding plasma outside the flux tube .
this cooling is partially counter - balanced by the heating due to the slightly unstable convecting atmosphere . the plasma heating observed at the wave fronts of the propagating fast magnetosonic fluctuations driven by the initial velocity driver as well as the heating outside the magnetic flux tube in the upper chromosphere account for a temperature increase of @xmath86k up to @xmath120k .
the observed heating strongly depends on the initial driver : the vertical velocity driver heats the chromospheric plasma more than the horizontal one . the horizontal velocity driver at the selected frequency in our case does not excite waves and does not lead to significant heating .
this comparison between the vertical and horizontal drivers significantly differs from the results of previous single fluid mhd studies of chromospheric wave propagation , where slow magnetosonic waves have been excited by the horizontal velocity driver @xcite . with both drivers we observe depletion of the number densities of ions and neutrals in the upper region of the magnetic flux tube , where the lorentz becomes important as the plasma @xmath102 and @xmath121 ratio increase .
as the alfvn speed becomes faster than the sound speed in the case of the vertical velocity driver we observe a mode conversion with transformation from fast to slow magnetosonic waves .    within our model
most of the net plasma heating outside the flux tube in the upper chromosphere is wave - based and is related to kinetic to thermal energy conversion as the wave fronts of the fast magnetosonic waves steepen . in the current plasma - neutral interactions we do not observe strong heating along the perpendicular component of the current , as expected from mhd models with partial ionization effect relying on ambipolar diffusion terms @xcite . within the current multi - fluid approach the plasma heating due to the partial ionization effects ,
if present , is either more isotropic and not bound to the direction perpendicular to the external magnetic field profile , or it is fully overcome by the dominant wave - based heating .
we should note that the partial ionization effects in our study are not very strong and the main energy source for heating are the excited magnetosonic fluctuations .
the role of the partial ionization could perhaps become more prominent for stronger magnetic fields .
although this paper does not discuss in details the redistribution of the different energy types and the conversion from kinetic to thermal energy , we have to mention that there is energy transport from the photosphere throughout the chromosphere .
apart from kinetic energy transported through the chromosphere in the form of waves , there is also an associated electromagnetic energy transfer .
the estimated poynting flux related to the fast magnetosonic waves is much stronger in the horizontal than in vertical direction .
however , we expect that to change whenever slow magnetosonic or alfvn waves are excited in the system , as already suggested by some preliminary model results . to further improve our model and make it better suitable for longer wave propagation studies we would consider implementing additional wave damping layer , similar to what had been proposed and implemented for mhd simulations by @xcite .
this work was supported by project grant c  90347 ( esa prodex 9 ) and fwo 12k1416n postdoctoral fellowship at cmpa , ku leuven .
this work was partially co - funded by projects goa/2015 - 014 ( ku leuven ) and g.0a23.16n ( fwo - vlaanderen ) .
the research leading to these results has also received funding from the european commission s seventh framework programme ( fp7/2007 - 2013 ) under the grant agreements solspanet ( project n 269299 , www.solspanet.eu ) , eheroes ( project n 284461 , www.eheroes.eu ) and swiff ( project n 263340 , www.swiff.eu ) .
a.  alvarez laguna is grateful to iwt phd fellowship for the support during this research .
avrett , e.  h. , & loeser , r.  2008 , , 175 , 229 - 276 moore , r.  l. , & fung , p.  c.  w.  1972 , , 23 , 78 cox , d.  p. , & tucker , w.  h.  1969 , , 157 , 1157 vernazza , j.  e. , avrett , e.  h. , & loeser , r.  1981 , , 45 , 635 de pontieu , b. , rouppe van der voort , l. , mcintosh , s.  w. , et al .
2014 , science , 346 , 1255732 de pontieu , b. , title , a.  m. , lemen , j.  r. , et al .
2014 , , 289 , 2733 peter , h. , tian , h. , curdt , w. , et al .
2014 , science , 346 , 1255726 pereira , t.  m.  d. , carlsson , m. , de pontieu , b. , & hansteen , v.  2015 , , 806 , 14 carlsson , m. , hansteen , v.  h. , gudiksen , b.  v. , leenaarts , j. , & de pontieu , b.  2016 , , 585 , a4 martnez - sykora , j. , de pontieu , b. , hansteen , v.  h. , & gudiksen , b.  2016 , , 817 , 46 martnez - sykora , j. , de pontieu , b. , hansteen , v. , & carlsson , m.  2015 , philosophical transactions of the royal society of london series a , 373 , 20140268 braginskii , s. i. 1965 , transport processes in a plasma , reviews of plasma physics , 1 , 205 .
brandenburg , a. & zweibel , e. g. 1994 the formation of sharp structures by ambipolar diffusion .
apjl , 427 , l91l94 .
( doi:10.1086/187372 ) cheung , m. c. m. & cameron , r. h. 2012 magnetohydrodynamics of the weakly ionized solar photosphere .
apj , 750 , 6 .
( doi:10.1088/0004 - 637x/750/1/6 ) fedun , v. , erdlyi , r. , & shelyag , s.  2009 , , 258 , 219 fedun , v. , shelyag , s. , & erdlyi , r.  2011 , , 727 , 17 fontenla , j.  m. , avrett , e.  h. , & loeser , r.  1993 , , 406 , 319 gent , f.  a. , fedun , v. , mumford , s.  j. , & erdlyi , r.  2013 , , 435 , 689 golding , t. p. , carlsson , m. & leenaarts , j.  2014 , 784 , 30 ( doi:10.1088/0004 - 637x/784/1/30 ) gudiksen , b.  v. , carlsson , m. , hansteen , v.  h. , et al .
2011 , , 531 , a154 hansteen , v. , de pontieu , b. , carlsson , m. , lemen , j. , title , a. , boerner , p. , hurlburt , n. , tarbell , t. d. , wuelser , j. p. et al .
2014 the unresolved fine structure resolved : iris observations of the solar transition region .
science , 346(6207 ) .
( doi:10.1126/science.1255757 ) hansteen , v. h. , carlsson , m. & gudiksen , b. 2007 3d numerical models of the chromosphere , transition region , and corona . in the physics of chromospheric plasmas ( eds p. heinzel , i. dorotov@xmath122c & r. j. rutten ) , vol .
368 of astronomical society of the pacific conference series , p. 107 .
hansteen , v. h. , de pontieu , b. , rouppe van der voort , l. , van noort , m. & carlsson , m. 2006 , dynamic fibrils are driven by magnetoacoustic shocks .
apj , 647 , l73l76 .
( doi:10.1086/507452 ) khomenko , e. , collados , m. , & felipe , t.  2008 , , 251 , 589 khomenko , e. , & collados , m.  2006 , , 653 , 739 khomenko , e. & collados , m.  2012 , , 747 , 87 ( doi:10.1088/0004 - 637x/747/2/87 ) shelyag , s. , khomenko , e. , de vicente , a. , & przybylski , d.  2016 , , 819 , l11 khomenko , e. , daz , a. , de vicente , a. , collados , m. , & luna , m.  2014 , , 565 , a45 leake , j.  e. and lukin , v.  s. and linton , m.  g. and meier , e.  t. , multi - fluid simulations of chromospheric magnetic reconnection in a weakly ionized reacting plasma , apj , vol .
760 , pg 109 , ( dec .
2012 ) meier , e.  t. and shumlak , u. , a general nonlinear fluid model for reacting plasma - neutral mixtures , physics of plasmas , vol .
19 , 7 ( 2012 ) leake , j.  e. and lukin , v.  s. and linton , m.  g. , magnetic reconnection in a weakly ionized plasma , arxiv e - prints , 1302.3287 ( feb .
2013 ) voronov , g. s. , atomic data and nuclear data tables , 65 , 1 , ( 1997 ) smirnov , b. m. , physics of atoms and ions , ( 2003 ) l. spitzer , physics of fully ionized gases , interscience , new york , ( 1956 ) soler , r. , ballester , j.  l. , & zaqarashvili , t.  v.  2015 , , 573 , a79 alvarez laguna a. , lani a. , mansour n. n. , kosovichev a. , poedts s. , a two - fluid computational model to study reconnection in reactive plasmas under chromospheric conditions , wccm xi , eccm v , ecfd vi , ( 2014 ) alvarez laguna a. , lani a. , deconinck h. , mansour n. n. , poedts s. , a fully - implicit finite - volume method for multi - fluid reactive and collisional magnetized plasmas on unstructured meshes , j. comp .
( 2016 )    lani a. , quintino t. , kimpe d. , deconinck h. , vandewalle s. , poedts s. , the coolfluid framework : design solutions for high - performance object oriented scientific computing software , in : v.  s. sunderan , g.  d. van albada , p.  m.  a. sloot , j.  j. dongarra ( eds . ) , computational science iccs 2005 , vol .  1 of lncs 3514 , emory university , springer , atlanta , ga , usa , 2005 , pp . 281286 .
lani a. , quintino t. , kimpe d. , deconinck h. , vandewalle s. , poedts s. , reusable object - oriented solutions for numerical simulation of pdes in a high performance environment , scientific programming . special edition on poosc 2005 14  ( 2 ) , 111139 ( 2006 )    lani a. , villedieu n. , bensassi k. , kapa l. , vymazal m. , yalim m.  s. , m.  panesi , coolfluid : an open computational platform for multi - physics simulation and research , in : aiaa 2013 - 2589 , 21th aiaa cfd conference , san diego ( ca ) ( 2013 )      panesi m. , lani a. , magin t. , pinna f. , chazot o. , deconinck h. , numerical investigation of the non equilibrium shock - layer around the expert vehicle , aiaa paper 2007 - 4317 , 38th aiaa plasmadynamics and lasers conference , miami ( florida ) ( 2007 )              garicano mena j. , pepe r. , lani a. , deconinck h. , assessment of heat flux prediction capabilities of residual distribution method : application to atmospheric entry problems , commun .
17  ( 3 ) , 682702 ( 2015 )      zhang w. , lani a. , chew h. b. , panesi m. , `` modeling of non - equilibrium plasmas in an inductively coupled plasma facility '' , 45 th plasmadynamics and laser conference , aiaa 2014 - 2235 , atlanta ( ga ) ( 2014 )    yalim m.  s. , vanden abeele d. , lani a. , quintino t. , deconinck h. , a finite volume implicit time integration method for solving the equations of ideal magnetohydrodynamics for the hyperbolic divergence cleaning approach , jcp 230  ( 15 ) , 61366154 ( 2011 )        c .- d . ,
ommes p. , and schneider r. , a three - dimensional finite - volume solver for the maxwell equations with divergence cleaning on unstructured meshes , _ computer physics communications _ , 130:83117 ( 2000 )    balay s. , abhyankar s. , adams m.  f. , brown j. , brune p. , buschelman k. , dalcin l. , eijkhout v. , gropp w.  d. , kaushik d. , knepley m.  g. , mcinnes l.  c. , rupp k. , smith b.  f. , zampini s. , and zhang h. , petsc web page , http://www.mcs.anl.gov/petsc ( 2015 )


two bodies kept at different temperatures and separated by a vacuum gap experience a radiative heat transfer mediated by photons .
this energy exchange is limited by the well known stefan - boltzmann s law in the far field , i.e. when the distance separating the bodies is large compared to the thermal wavelength @xmath0 , of the order of @xmath1 m at ambient temperature .
the pioneering works of rytov  @xcite , polder and van hove  @xcite first showed that this limit can be surpassed in the near - field regime , as a result of the tunneling of evanescent waves .
in particular , the heat transfer can exceed the one between two blackbodies ( i.e. the ideal far - field scenario predicted by stefan - boltzmann s law ) even of several orders of magnitue when the materials support surface resonances , such as plasmons in metals ( typically lying in the ultraviolet range of frequencies ) and phonon - polaritons in dielectrics ( typically in the infrared ) @xcite . since the contribution of each field mode to radiative heat transfer is weighted by the planck thermal distribution , negligible in the ultraviolet range at ordinary temperatures , dielectrics supporting surface resonances
are typically the best candidates to maximize the heat flux .    stimulated by the theoretical developments ,
several applications have been proposed for radiative heat transfer , ranging from thermophotovoltaic  @xcite or solar thermal  @xcite energy conversion , to heat - assisted data storage @xcite , nanoscale cooling  @xcite , and the recent emerging field of thermotronics @xcite . on the experimental side ,
the theoretical predictions have been verified during the last decade both in the plane - plane and sphere - plane configuration , for a wide range of distances , going from some nanometers to several microns  @xcite .
recently , the idea of manipulating the heat flux through the manipulation of some external parameters have attracted a remarkable attention .
in fact , both the control of the overall value of the flux and its spectral properties can be extremely relevant for several applications , and in particular for energy conversion . in the spirit of a manipulation thourgh geometrical properties ,
structured surfaces have been the topic of many theoretical investigations .
more specifically , by considering both 1d and 2d periodic gratings , both the radiative heat transfer  @xcite and the casimir force at and out of thermal equilibrium  @xcite have been studied by employing a variety of theoretical approaches .
it has been shown that gratings represent indeed a tool to modify , both by reducing and amplifying , radiative heat transfer , as well as to influence its spectral properties . concerning the casimir force
, it must be mentioned that the force between a sphere and a dielectric  @xcite or a metallic  @xcite grating has been recently measured and theoretically investigated  @xcite .    in the domain of radiative heat transfer ,
metallic gratings deserve ideed a special attention .
in fact , although , as mentioned above , surface resonances for a metal typically have ultraviolet frequencies , the presence of a periodically structured pattern can result in the presence of new surface resonances , referred to a spoof plasmons  @xcite , whose frequency can be adjusted as a function of the grating parameters and can be brought , for realistic values of the grating lenghtscales , in the infrared region , thus contributing to the flux .
based on this behavior , the authors of ref .
have recently theoretically predicted a high enhancement of the flux between two identical gold gratings .
a similar study has been performed for 1d and 2d metallic gratings in refs .  , and more recently in ref .  .
in these papers the reflection upon each grating has been described by means of the fourier modal method ( fmm )  @xcite , equipped with the factorization rule introduced in ref .  .
it is worth stressing that , since the radiative heat transfer is calculated as an integral with respect to both frequency and wavevector , the choice of the method used to derive the grating reflection operators can drastically affect the computational time as well as the results .
this paper is precisely devoted to the study of radiative heat transfer between two gold gratings .
we present and discuss a modification to the fmm technique , known as adaptive spatial resolution  @xcite ( we will in the following refer to this modified method as asr ) , a technique specifically introduced to accelerate the convergence .
this method has also been shown to overcome the known instabilities appearing for metallic gratings  @xcite .
with respect to previous works , we extend here this technique to deal with arbitrary conical incidence .
based on this approach , we provide a detailed study of the influence of the grating depth on the overall value of the flux as well as on its spectral properties .
we also compare our results to part of the works mentioned above on heat transfer between metallic gratings .
we show that ( 1 ) the asr technique produces a dramatic increase of the convergence rate ( thus implying a drastic reduction of computational time ) and ( 2 ) the numerical results for heat transfer considerably differ from results previously obtained using the standard fmm .
the paper is structured as follows . in sec .
[ secintro ] we present our physical system , describing also our notation and main definitions . in sec .
[ secmethods ] we discuss in detail the adaptive spatial resolution .
then , in sec .  [ secnumerics ] we present our numerical results , by studying the radiative heat transfer between two gold gratings as a function of the grating height .
we finally give in sec .
[ secconcl ] some conclusive remarks .
the system we are going to address consists of two 1d lamellar gratings separated by vacuum , as shown in fig .  [ figgeometry ] .
the two gratings are structured along the @xmath2 axis , translationally invariant along the @xmath3 axis , and separated by a vacuum gap of thickness @xmath4 along the @xmath5 axis .
the two gratings share the same period @xmath6 , while they can have in general different filling fractions @xmath7 ( see fig .
[ figgeometry ] ) .
finally , they have different grating heights @xmath8 , while the substrate below each structured region is assumed to be infinitely thick for both gratings .    .
the gratings , in general made of different materials , are infinite in the @xmath9 plane , and periodic in the @xmath2 direction with the same period @xmath6 .
they have corrugation depths @xmath10 ( @xmath11 ) , infinite thicknesses below the grating region , and lengths of the elevated part of the grating @xmath12 .
this defines the filling factors @xmath13.,width=321 ]    the two gratings , labeled with indexes 1 and 2 , are kept by some external heat source at constant temperatures @xmath14 and @xmath15 . among the numerous theoretical techniques developed to calculate the radiative heat transfer between them , we employ an approach based on the knowledge of the individual scattering operators of the bodies involved , recently introduced for systems involving two  @xcite and three  @xcite bodies .
this method is based on a plane - wave mode decomposition of the fields , each mode @xmath16 being identified by the direction of propagation @xmath17 along the @xmath5 axis , the polarization index @xmath18 [ assuming the values @xmath19 which respectively correspond to transverse electric ( te ) and transverse magnetic ( tm ) modes ] , the frequency @xmath20 and the transverse wavevector @xmath21 . in this description ,
the @xmath5 component of the wavevector @xmath22 is a dependent variable defined as @xmath23 in virtue of this mode decomposition , we define the trace of an operator @xmath24 as @xmath25 assuming that the external environment is thermalized with body 1 , the energy this body receives per unit surface and time is given by  @xcite @xmath26 , \label{defphi}\ ] ] where @xmath27 ( @xmath28 ) is the reflection operator of body 1 ( 2 ) for an incoming wave propagating in direction @xmath29 ( @xmath30 ) and we have defined @xmath31 moreover , in eq .   we have defined the population differences @xmath32 , with @xmath33 the intracavity operator @xmath34 and the projection operators @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the kronecker delta and being @xmath37 [ @xmath38 the projector on the propagative ( @xmath39 ) [ evanescent ( @xmath40 ) ] sector .
we remark that , as discussed in ref .  , the periodicity on the @xmath2 axis makes it natural to replace the mode variable @xmath41 with @xmath42 with @xmath41 taking values in the first brillouin zone @xmath43 $ ] and @xmath44 assuming all integer values .
based on eq .
, the calculation of the flux @xmath45 is now reduced to the problem of describing the field reflection upon each grating .
the details about the asr technique employed in this paper are discussed in detail in the next section .
the physical system we consider is shown in fig .
[ figgrating ] : it is a lamellar grating of period @xmath6 , invariant along the @xmath3 axis , with relative dielectric permittivity @xmath46 .
the grating is inlayed between two homogeneous media whose permittivities are @xmath47 ( input medium ) and @xmath48 ( output medium ) .
a monochromatic plane wave with frequency @xmath20 and parallel wavevector @xmath21 illuminates the structure . throughout the calculation ,
the vacuum wave number is denoted by @xmath49 and we assume a time dependence of the form @xmath50 . the particularity of the asr @xcite is the use of a new coordinates system @xmath51 in which the coordinate in the @xmath2 direction is stretched around the permittivity discontinuities .
this allows to better describe the permittivity jump , which is crucial in the case of metallic structures .
below , we derive the metric tensor and write the maxwell s equations associated to the coordinates change
. then we solve them in the three regions of space : @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
after , we derive the boundary conditions and obtain the fields amplitudes . based on the geometry depicted in fig .
[ figgrating ] , the reflection operator we are going to calculate is @xmath55 for a vacuum - grating inferface located at @xmath56 .
this operator will allow us to easily deduce @xmath27 and @xmath28 as described in detail below .     and
@xmath57 having uniform permittivity ( @xmath47 and @xmath48 , respectively ) and @xmath58 , having a periodic @xmath46.,width=321 ]      we start by observing that , in general , the presence of a lamellar grating naturally divides the period region @xmath59 $ ] by a set of discontinuity points @xmath60 with @xmath61 , with @xmath62 and @xmath63 . in view of the change of coordinates from @xmath2 to @xmath64
, we analogously define a set of points @xmath65 given by @xmath66 , i.e. uniformly distributed between @xmath67 and @xmath68 . for the explicit definition of the coordinate transformation @xmath69 we follow ref .   and write @xmath70 in each interval @xmath71 $ ] , with @xmath72 , where @xmath73 in these expressions @xmath74 being a control parameter , for which we take the value @xmath75 through all the numerical calculations presented in this paper .
the corresponding metric tensor is diagonal and reads @xmath76 , with @xmath77 .
thus maxwell s equations @xmath78 and @xmath79 become : @xmath80 @xmath81 with @xmath82 , @xmath83 being the impedance of vacuum .
we now derive from eqs .   and @xmath84 and @xmath85 and plug them into the other equations , obtained the following system for the tangential components of the fields : @xmath86 @xmath87 with @xmath88 and @xmath89 . next , following the procedure discussed more in detail e.g. in ref .
, we rewrite this systems of equations in the fourier space and truncate the series up to the truncation order @xmath90 , obtaining @xmath91 @xmath92 where @xmath93 $ ] , @xmath41 being defined in the first brillouin zone @xmath43 $ ] . in eq .   we have gathered in the column vectors @xmath94 and @xmath95 the @xmath96 fourier components of the fields @xmath97 and @xmath98 . moreover , we have introduced the toeplitz matrices @xmath99 ( resp . @xmath100 and @xmath101 ) defined in terms of the fourier coefficients of the function @xmath102 [ resp . @xmath103 and @xmath104 .
we can further simiplify the notation by introducing the following definitions @xmath105 which allow us to write @xmath106 in this equation , @xmath107 is a diagonal matrix containing the eigenvalues of @xmath108 and @xmath109 is the matrix of associated eigenvectors .
then the solution of eq .   can be expressed under the form @xmath110 and consequently [ from eq .  ] : @xmath111 where @xmath112 and @xmath113 are the amplitudes of the different waves traveling in the @xmath30 and @xmath29 directions , respectively .
the calculation presented here for the grating region , characterized by a periodic @xmath46 , can be directly applied to the homogeneous regions @xmath114 and @xmath57 as well . in this case , the framework can be simplified by observing that @xmath115 and @xmath116 , where for the input ( output ) region @xmath117 ( @xmath118 ) .
this directly leads to the introduction of the four additional matrices @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 , and @xmath122 . in order to simplify the boundary conditions ,
the solution in the output medium is modified as follows @xmath123 by means of the introduction of a phase factor .
having solved maxwell s equations in each region , we can now write down the boundary conditions at the interfaces @xmath56 and @xmath124 : @xmath125 and , denoting @xmath126 , @xmath127 in terms of the @xmath128-matrix algorithm , this gives @xmath129 and @xmath130 in the last two equations the unknowns are the amplitudes @xmath131 and @xmath132 of the incoming waves , @xmath133 and @xmath134 of the reflected and transmitted waves , and the amplitudes @xmath112 and @xmath113 of the field in the grating region , in which we have absorbed the factor @xmath135 .
this is irrelevant for our purposes , since we are only interested in the field amplitudes in the homogeneous media .
the final part of the calculation is straightforward ( see e.g. ref .  ) .
we define a chained @xmath128 matrix as  @xcite @xmath136 having introduced the associative operation @xmath137 , which for three square matrices @xmath138 , @xmath139 and @xmath140 of dimension @xmath141 is defined as @xmath142 where each matrix have been decomposed in four square blocks of dimension @xmath143 .
this @xmath128 matrix satisfies the relation @xmath144 thus its upper - left @xmath143 block , relating the reflected field @xmath133 to the incident one @xmath131 in the upper region , can be identified as the @xmath145 operator we are looking for in the @xmath146 reference system .
m , period @xmath147 m , filling fraction @xmath148 , infinite thickness below the grating region , and temperatures @xmath149k and @xmath150k .
the flux is calculated using both the fmm ( red dashed line ) and the asr ( black solid line ) , for different truncation orders @xmath90 .
the black dashed line corresponds to the asymptotic value obtained using the asr for @xmath151 , while the gray dot - dashed line is associated to a 10% error with respect to this asymptotic value.,width=302 ]      the steps described in the last section lead to the derivation of a reflection matrix @xmath145 , expressed in the transformed reference system @xmath146 . actually , the operator @xmath55 needed for the calculation of the flux given by eq .   has to be expressed not only in the standard @xmath152 cartesian reference , but also with respect to the basis of two polarization unity vectors @xmath153}_{\text{te}}^{\phi}(\mathbf{k}_n,\omega)&=\frac{1}{k_n}(-k_y\hat{\mathbf{x}}+k_{x , n}\hat{\mathbf{y}}),\\
\hat{\bbm[\epsilon]}_{\text{tm}}^{\phi}(\mathbf{k}_n,\omega)&=\frac{c}{\omega}(-k_n\hat{\mathbf{z}}+\phi k_{z , n}\hat{\mathbf{k}}_n ) , \end{split}\label{polvect}\ ] ] where @xmath154 and we have defined @xmath155 and @xmath156 . thus , the final reflection matrix @xmath157 takes the form @xmath158 where @xmath159 is the matrix associated with the transformation from @xmath146 to @xmath152 , whereas @xmath160 accounts for the transition from the ( te , tm ) basis to the canonical @xmath152 basis for fields propagating in the @xmath161 direction ( note that we have @xmath30 for the incident field and @xmath29 for the reflected one , as manifest from fig .  [ figgrating ] ) .    in order to derive @xmath159 , we start observing that we have , labeling throughout this section with a prime the fields in the @xmath146 coordinate system , @xmath162 and @xmath163 .
this means that the @xmath159 matrix will be block - diagonal and take the form @xmath164 moreover , since the coordinate stretch leaves the period unchanged , one just needs to express the @xmath96 vectors @xmath165 and @xmath166 as a function of @xmath167 and @xmath168 for a given value of @xmath20 and @xmath41 in the first brillouin zone , as @xmath169 and @xmath170 . starting from the fourier decompositions
@xmath171 we easily get @xmath172_{n , m}=\frac{1}{d}\int_0^ddu\,e^{i[k_{x , m}u - k_{x , n}x(u)]},\ ] ] and in an analogous way @xmath173_{n , m}=\frac{1}{d}\int_0^ddu\,f(u)e^{i[k_{x , m}u - k_{x , n}x(u)]}.\ ] ]    concerning the second transformation matrix @xmath160 , it represents a basic change of basis and its action is written as @xmath174 where the ( te , tm ) basis ( and thus the matrix @xmath160 ) depends on the propagation direction @xmath161 . using eq .  , the transformation matrix reads @xmath175      as stated at the beginning of our calculation , the @xmath55 operator we calculated is relative to a grating having its interface with vacuum at @xmath56 . as a consequence , in order to deduce the @xmath28 relative to grating 2 , we have to include a phase shift taking into account the fact that its vacuum - grating inferface coincides with the plane @xmath176 . as described e.g. in ref .  , the matrix elements of this modified operator are given by @xmath177{\displaystyle{\langle p,\mathbf{k},n,\omega|}}\mathcal{r}^-{\displaystyle{|p',\mathbf{k}',n',\omega'\rangle}}.\nonumber \end{split}\ ] ]    we now focus on the issue of deriving @xmath27 from the known operator @xmath55 .
for simplicity , in the following we will always consider two identical gratings , i.e. having the same height @xmath8 and filling factor @xmath178 . in this case , when evaluating the flux given by eq .  , it is convenient to exploit the symmetry of the configuration and calculate ( for each frequency and wavevector ) only once the grating reflection matrix
. nevertheless , one must keep in mind that in our formalism the unit polarization vector associated to te polarization defined in eq .
is independent of the propagation direction @xmath161 along the @xmath5 axis , while the @xmath2 and @xmath3 components of the tm polarization vector are proportional to @xmath161 . since the @xmath2 and @xmath3 components are the ones which are conserved in the scattering process
, this implies that the reflection matrix @xmath27 coincides with @xmath55 in the diagonal blocks ( te , te ) and ( tm , tm ) , while the non - diagonal blocks ( te , tm ) and ( tm , te ) undergo an overall sign change .
this sign - change issue is irrelevant , of course , in the case of a planar slab , since this system does not mix the two polarizations , but it must indeed be taken into account when dealing with bodies producing a coupling between te and tm modes .
and the one for @xmath179 , i.e. the one between two planar slabs .
the two identical gratings have period @xmath147 m , filling fraction @xmath148 , infinite thickness below the grating region , and temperatures @xmath180k and @xmath181k .
our results ( black solid line ) are compared to the results of ref .
( red points ) .
the blue dot corresponds to a calculation using the asr but without inverting the sign of non - diagonal blocks of the reflection matrix ( see text for more details ) .
the inset shows a zoom of the same curve in linear @xmath8 scale.,width=321 ]        we are now ready to discuss our first numerical results .
these concern a couple of gratings having the same features used in ref .  .
the two gratings have filling factor @xmath148 , period @xmath147 m , temperatures @xmath180k and @xmath181k , and are placed at a distance @xmath182 m .
both gratings are made of gold , for which we have used a drude model @xmath183 where the plasma frequency and the dissipation rate are respectively equal to @xmath184ev and @xmath185mev .    in order to highlight the features of the asr technique , we start by calculating the flux for a given grating height @xmath186 m . as discussed in detail in ref .  , a crucial point when using the fmm technique is the choice of the truncation order @xmath90 , i.e. the number of diffraction orders taken into account in the fourier decomposition of the field , going from @xmath187 to @xmath90 .
the same issue applies of course to the asr method as well .
we show in fig .
[ figfmmasr ] the value of the flux @xmath45 as a function of the truncation order , both using the fmm ( red dashed line ) and the asr ( black solid line ) .
it is manifest that in both cases the first truncation orders give very different results , suggesting that @xmath90 has to be further increased .
nevertheless , starting from @xmath90 of the order of 5 , the two curves are dramatically different .
the curve corresponding to the asr technique very quickly converges to a stable result , and the points corresponding to @xmath188 are basically undistinguishable .
the dashed black line in the plot corresponds to the value obtained with the asr for @xmath151 , while the dot - dashed line is associated to a 10% error with respect to this result .
the results obtained with the fmm show a very different behavior .
first of all , up to @xmath189 , the obtained flux is non - monotonic , and has a quasi - oscillatory behavior .
moreovoer , even when becoming monotonic as a function of @xmath90 , the flux converges very slowly to its asymptotic value .
more specifically , for @xmath190 the error is of the order of 10% , while for @xmath191 ( the value used in ref .  )
it is of the order of 3% .
m , period @xmath192 m , filling fraction @xmath193 , infinite thickness below the grating region , and temperatures @xmath194k and @xmath195k .
the black solid line corresponds to our calculation using the asr , while the blue dashed line gives the result obtained without inverting the sign of non - diagonal blocks of the reflection matrix ( see text for more details ) .
the red points are extracted from ref .
.,width=321 ]    based on this discussion of the convergence , we use , in the following , a truncation order @xmath196 for the asr , with an associated relative error of the order of 1% on the integrated flux . using these parameters , as in ref .  , we study the heat transfer @xmath197 as a function of the grating height @xmath8 , and discuss the amplification factor @xmath198 with respect to the case @xmath179 , i.e. to the case of a planar slab .
the results are shown in the main part of fig .
[ figh ] for a very wide range of values of @xmath8 , going from @xmath179 to 1 mm , and compared with the ones ( red points ) calculated in ref .
from @xmath179 to 6@xmath199 m . while for @xmath200 nm the amplification factor is close to 1 , increasing @xmath8 produces a huge amplification of the heat flux . in particular
, the ratio @xmath198 grows monotonically with @xmath8 , and reaches a horizonal asymptotote around @xmath201 m , with a value slightly above 34 . in the inset of fig .
[ figh ] , we show the same curve in linear @xmath8 scale from 0 to @xmath202 m . as manifest from the plot , in spite of a qualitative agreement ,
the two curves are quantitatively different , with a disagreement going up to around 50% for @xmath203 m . for this value of the grating height
we have calculated the flux using fmm with @xmath191 and obtained a result in agreement within around 1% with the one coming from the asr with @xmath196 .
we conclude that the truncation order @xmath191 is large enough to assure a good convergence for the integrated flux using fmm .
thus , the difference between our results and the ones of ref .   does not seem to originate from an insufficient truncation order .
it is now instructive to investigate the evolution of the spectral properties of the heat flux as a function of the grating depth @xmath8 .
this behavior is illustrated in fig .
[ figgrid ] .
panel ( a ) shows the spectral flux @xmath204 for @xmath179 , i.e. in a slab - slab configuration .
it is well known that in presence of surface modes , while approaching the near - field regime the heat flux becomes more and more monochromatic at the resonance frequency of the mode  @xcite .
even if the distance @xmath182 m does not fully lie in this distance regime , a signature of the existence of such surface modes is already present .
nevertheless , this is not the case for two gold slabs , simply because the plasma frequency for gold is located well outside the window of frequencies contributing to the flux , defined by the planck function @xmath205 . as a result , the only non - monotonic behavior for the flux is observed in the low - frequency region @xmath206\,$]rad
/ s , shown in the inset of fig .
[ figgrid](a ) .
the spectral flux tends to increase at small frequencies as a result of the divergence of @xmath207 for @xmath208 , this growth being at some point compensated by the fact that each mode of the field carries an energy @xmath209 , tending to 0 for @xmath208 .
let us now focus on fig .
[ figgrid](b ) , where the grating heights @xmath210 m and @xmath211 m are taken into account .
we first remark that the non - monotonic behavior at low frequencies is still present , but with a decreased maximum value .
this feature remains basically unchanged for all the higher values of @xmath8 shown in fig .
[ figgrid ] .
the main feature of fig .
[ figgrid ] is anyway the appearance of two peaks in the spectral flux , sign of the existence of two surface modes , whose frequency depends on the grating height , coherently with the fact that these are indeed spoof plamons .
the participation of these new modes produces an overall flux amplification equal to 2 and 2.7 , respectively , for @xmath210 m and @xmath211 m .
an analysis of panel ( c ) of the same figure shows that increasing @xmath8 produces both a decrease of the frequency of spoof - plasmon modes and an amplification of the peak height .
as shown in fig .
[ figgrid](c)-(d ) the scenario becomes even more interesting for higher values of @xmath8 . in this case
more and more resonances enter the window of frequencies relevant for radiative heat transfer . this feature has been already discussed in ref .   by analyzing the heat - flux transmission coefficient for a given value of the wavevector @xmath212 .
we basically observe two resonances for @xmath213 m and @xmath214 m , while for @xmath215 m and @xmath216 m not only we start observing a comb of resonance frequencies , but we clearly see that the fact that they approach each other produces a constructive interference between them , increasing the overall value of @xmath204 in the frequency range considered .
this is even more evident in fig .
[ figgrid](f ) , where for @xmath217 m the frequency - comb behavior is manifest , as well as how this eventually produces a smooth asymptotic @xmath204 ( reached for @xmath218 mm ) which does not show any abrupt change with respect to @xmath20 .
this is the profile giving the asymptotic flux amplification close to 34 discussed above and shown in fig .
[ figh ] .    in order to compare further our results with previous works , we focus on a configuration studied in ref .  , namely the heat transfer between two identical gratings having height @xmath219 m , period @xmath220 nm and filling factor @xmath193 , placed at distance @xmath182 m .
the two chosen temperatures are @xmath194k and @xmath195k . in ref .
, the authors show the spectrum associated with this heat transfer ( calculated using the standard fmm ) from which we have extracted some points , shown in red in fig .
[ figspectrum ] .
we have applied our numerical scheme to this scenario and obtained the black curve shown in the same figure .
it is manifest that , while sharing the same qualitative behavior , the two curves considerably differ quantitatively , in particular in the region between the two main peaks . in order to try to explain this disagreement we have noticed that in one of their recent papers on this topic ( namely , ref .  )
, the authors clearly state that the fact that the two structures coincide implies that the two reflection operators @xmath27 and @xmath28 are equal .
as discussed above , this is actually not correct because of the fact that the unit polarization vector in tm polarization depends on the propagation direction @xmath161 .
nevertheless , we have performed a new calculation for the same structure , using the asr with @xmath196 , but omitting the sign change we need to deduce @xmath27 from @xmath221 .
the result so obtained is given by the blue dashed curve in fig .
[ figspectrum ] and clearly shows an impressively increased agreement with the red points .
thus , we interpret the difference between the two results as due to this sign change , missing in ref .   and related works .
moreover , it must be stressed that the results presented in ref .   also show an oscillatory behavior in frequency , in particular in the region between the two main peaks , which is completely absent in the results obtained by exploiting the asr , both with and without the sign change . in our opinion , this oscillations are a result of the well - known instabilities of the fmm when dealing with metals .    with the aim of further trying to explain the discrepancy with ref .   shown in fig .
[ figh ] , we have recalculated using the asr one of the points of fig .
[ figh ] , the one having @xmath222 m , without the mentioned sign change .
the result is the blue dot in fig .
[ figh ] which , even if approaching the result of ref .  , still does not show a good agreement .
we have addressed the caclulation of the radiative heat flux between two gold gratings . to this aim
we have made use of the asr , a modified version of the fmm introduced to deal with the high dielectric contrast typical of metals .
we have shown that this technique produces a striking increase of the convergence rate , allowing us to obtain the heat flux at a distance of 1@xmath223 m with a truncation order as low as @xmath196 .
this implies a remarkable gain in computational time : to give an idea , for the grating parameters relative to fig .
[ figfmmasr ] , the calculation of the spectral flux at frequency @xmath224rad / s takes approximately 1 minute using the asr with @xmath196 on a parallel 3.4ghz 16-core machine , while 1.5 hours are needed using the fmm with @xmath191 .
since the required truncation order increases when decreasing the distance , the asr would allow to explore smaller separations , which would be prohibitive using the fmm .    by using this improved numerical method ,
we have made a detailed study of the heat - flux amplification as a function of the grating depth . by studying both the flux ratio and
the spectral properties , we have proved for our structure an amplification factor going up to 34 , explained in terms of the appearance of a comb of spoof - plasmon resonances .
we have then compared our results to some previous works , and highlighted a quantitative disagreement both in the integrated flux and in its spectral distribution . in some cases ,
we have argued that this disagreement is due to the incorrect assumption that the reflection matrices of the two gratings coincide .
our results show that the physics behind metallic gratings makes them ideal candidates for the manipuation of both the overall heat flux and its frequency components , both possibilities being very relevant for several applications such as thermophotovoltaic energy conversion . on a more technical side
, our discussion proves that the fmm can provide slowly - converging and unstable results in the presence of metals , while the asr represents a much more reliable approach even for high dielectric contrasts .
99 s. m. rytov , academy of sience press of ussr , moscow ( 1953 ) .
d. polder and m. van hove , phys .
b * 4 * , 3303 ( 1971 ) .
k. joulain _
et al . _ ,
rep . * 57 * , 59 ( 2005 ) .
r. s. dimatteo , p. greiff , s. l. finberg , k. a. young - waithe , h. k. h. choy , m. m. masaki , and c. g. fonstad , appl .
* 79 * , 1894 ( 2001 ) .
a. narayanaswamy and g. chen , appl .
. lett . * 82 * , 3544 ( 2003 ) .
m. laroche , r. carminati , and j .- j .
greffet , j. appl . phys .
* 100 * , 063704 ( 2006 ) .
s. basu , y .- b .
chen , and z. m. zhang , int .
j. energy res . *
31 * , 689 ( 2007 ) .
m. francoeur , m. p. meng , and r. vaillon , appl .
. lett . * 93 * , 043109 ( 2008 ) .
s. basu and z. zhang , j. appl .
* 105 * , 093535 ( 2009 ) .
r. m. swanson , science * 324 * , 891 ( 2009 ) . c. j. chen , _ the physics of solar energy _
( john wiley & sons , inc . ,
hoboken , 2011 ) .
w. srituravanich , n. fang , c. sun , q. luo , and z. zhang , nano lett .
* 4 * , 1085 ( 2004 ) .
b. guha , c. otey , c. b. poitras , s. fan , and m. lipson , nano letters * 12 * , 4546 ( 2012 ) .
p. ben - abdallah and s .- a .
biehs , aip advances * 5 * , 053502 , ( 2015 ) .
a. kittel , w. mller - hirsch , j. parisi , s .- a .
biehs , d. reddig , and m. holthaus , phys .
rev . lett . * 95 * , 224301 ( 2005 ) .
l. hu , a. narayanaswamy , x. chen , and g. chen , appl .
. lett . * 92 * , 133106 ( 2008 ) .
a. narayanaswamy , s. shen , and g. chen , phys .
b * 78 * , 115303 ( 2008 ) .
e. rousseau , a. siria , g. joudran , s. volz , f. comin , j. chevrier , and j .- j .
greffet , nature photon . * 3 * , 514 ( 2009 ) .
s. shen , a. narayanaswamy , and g. chen , nano letters * 9 * , 2909 ( 2009 ) .
t. kralik , p. hanzelka , v. musilova , a. srnka , and m. zobac , rev .
instrum . * 82 * , 055106 ( 2011 ) .
r. s. ottens , v. quetschke , s. wise , a. a. alemi , r. lundock , g. mueller , d. h. reitze , d. b. tanner , and b. f. whiting , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 014301 ( 2011 ) .
p. j. van zwol , l. ranno , and j. chevrier , phys .
* 108 * , 234301 ( 2012 ) .
p. j. van zwol , s. thiele , c. berger , w. a. de heer , and j. chevrier , phys .
* 109 * , 264301 ( 2012 ) .
t. kralik , p. hanzelka , m. zobac , v. musilova , t. fort , and m. horak , phys .
lett . * 109 * , 224302 ( 2012 ) .
et al . _ ,
nature * 528 * , 387 ( 2015 )
. b. song _
et al . _ , nature nanotechnology * 10 * , 253 ( 2015 ) .
r. st - gelais , l. zhu , s. fan , and m. lipson , nature nanotechnology * 11 * , 515 ( 2016 ) .
k. kloppstech _
et al . _ , preprint arxiv:1510.06311 ( 2015 ) . j. i. watjen , b. zhao , and z. m. zhang , appl .
lett . * 109 * , 203112 ( 2016 ) . s .- a .
biehs , f. s. s. rosa , and p. ben - abdallah , appl .
. lett . * 98 * , 243102 ( 2011 ) .
j. lussange , r. gurout , f. s. s. rosa , j .-
greffet , a. lambrecht , and s. reynaud , phys .
b * 86 * , 085432 ( 2012 ) .
r. gurout , j. lussange , f. s. s. rosa , j .-
hugonin , d. a. r. dalvit , j .- j .
greffet , a. lambrecht , and s. reynaud , phys .
b * 85 * , 180301(r ) ( 2012 ) . x. l. liu and z. m. zhang , appl .
. lett . * 104 * , 251911 ( 2014 ) .
j. dai , s. a. dyakov , and m. yan , phys .
b * 92 * , 035419 ( 2015 ) .
j. dai , s. a. dyakov , and m. yan , phys .
b * 93 * , 155403 ( 2016 ) .
j. dai , s. a. dyakov , s. i. bozhevolnyi , and m. yan , phys . rev .
b * 94 * , 125431 ( 2016 ) .
y. yang and l. wang , phys .
. lett . * 117 * , 044301 ( 2016 ) .
a. lambrecht and v. n. marachevsky , phys .
* 101 * , 160403 ( 2008 ) .
chiu , g. l. klimchitskaya , v. n. marachevsky , v. m. mostepanenko , and u. mohideen , phys .
b * 81 * , 115417 ( 2010 ) .
p. s. davids , f. intravaia , f. s. s. rosa , and d. a. r. dalvit , phys .
a * 82 * , 062111 ( 2010 ) .
f. intravaia , p. s. davids , r. s. decca , v. a. aksyuk , d. lpez , and d. a. r. dalvit , phys .
a * 86 * , 042101 ( 2012 ) . j. lussange , r. gurout , and a. lambrecht , phys .
a * 86 * , 062502 ( 2012 ) .
r. gurout , j. lussange , h. b. chan , a. lambrecht , and s. reynaud , phys .
a * 87 * , 052514 ( 2013 ) .
n. graham , phys .
a * 90 * , 032507 ( 2014 ) .
j. wagner and r. zandi , phys .
rev . a * 90 * , 012516 ( 2014 ) .
a. noto , r. messina , b. guizal , and m. antezza , phys .
a * 90 * , 022120 ( 2014 ) .
r. messina , p. a. maia neto , b. guizal , and m. antezza , phys .
a * 92 * , 062504 ( 2015 ) .
h. b. chan , y. bao , j. zou , r. a. cirelli , f. klemens , w. m. mansfield , and c. s. pai , phys .
* 101 * , 030401 ( 2008 ) .
y. bao , r. gurout , j. lussange , a. lambrecht , r. a. cirelli , f. klemens , w. m. mansfield , c. s. pai , and h. b. chan , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 250402 ( 2010 ) .
a. a. banishev , j. wagner , t. emig , r. zandi , and u. mohideen , phys .
lett . * 110 * , 250403 ( 2013 ) .
f. intravaia et al . , nat . comm . * 4 * , 2515 ( 2013 ) .
j. b. pendry , l. martn - moreno , and f. j. garcia - vidal , science * 305 * , 847 ( 2004 ) .
f. j. garca - vidal , l. martn - moreno , and j. b. pendry , j. opt . a : pure appl . opt . * 7 * , s97 ( 2005 ) .
h. kim , j. park , and b. lee , _ fourier modal method and its applications in computational nanophotonics _
( crc press , boca raton , 2012 ) .
g. granet , b. guizal , j. opt .
a * 13 * , 1019 ( 1996 ) .
g. granet j. opt .
a * 16 * , 2510 ( 1999 ) .
b. guizal , h. yala , and d. felbacq , opt .
express * 34 * , 2790 ( 2009 ) .
r. messina and m. antezza , europhys .
lett . * 95 * , 61002 ( 2011 ) .
r. messina and m. antezza , phys .
a * 84 * , 042102 ( 2011 ) .
r. messina , m. antezza , and p. ben - abdallah , phys .
* 109 * , 244302 ( 2012 ) .
r. messina and m. antezza , phys .
rev . a * 89 * , 052104 ( 2014 ) .
t. vallius , and m. honkanen opt .
express * 10 * , 24 ( 2002 ) .
g. granet , and b. guizal j. opt .
a * 13 * , 1019 ( 1996 ) .
j. dai , ph.d .
thesis , school of information and communication technology , kth royal institute of technology , 2016 .