the central parts of our galaxy were prospected by baade ( 1946 ) , in order to detect its nucleus , and to have an indication of the morphological type of our galaxy .
the so - called baade s window was revealed , and from variable stars identified in the field , the bulge stellar population was identified to be similar to that defined in baade ( 1944 ) as population ii . in the early 60s
the notion of a galactic bulge was already established ( e.g. courtes & cruvellier 1960 ) .
mcclure ( 1969 ) found that the bulge stars were super metal - rich compared to the stars nearby the sun .
whitford and rich ( 1983 ) confirmed the high metal content of bulge stars from individual star spectroscopy .
catalogues prepared along the decades show a steady growth of overall samples of globular clusters ( hereafter referred to as gcs ) , together with photometric and spectroscopic information . cannon ( 1929 ) used the harvard plate spectra to give integrated spectral types of 45 globular clusters .
mayall ( 1946 ) measured radial velocities of 50 globular clusters , and the integrated spectral types of 40 of them . kinman ( 1959 ) listed 32 gcs with indication of metallicity from their integrated spectra ; morgan ( 1959 ) directed efforts on a relatively bright sample of 13 bulge gcs , now known to be metal - rich .
surveys with schmidt plates since the 60s provided the palomar and eso star clusters , among others .
terzan ( 1968 and references therein ) significantly increased the number of central gcs by reporting new faint ones in the bulge direction .
these discoveries provided an important sample of gcs in the bulge .
other studies of gc overall samples were presented by van den bergh ( 1967 ) , zinn ( 1985 and references therein ) , bica & pastoriza ( 1983 ) .
webbink ( 1985 ) provided a catalogue of 154 gcs and candidates , with an important impact on subsequent observational efforts .
more recently , harris ( 1996 , updated in 2010 , hereafter harris10 ) reports properties for 157 gcs .
it is interesting to see how the notion of gcs pertaining to the bulge and their spatial distribution evolved in the last decades .
frenk & white ( 1982 ) found evidence that metal - rich gcs formed a bar - like structure .
based on metallicity , scale height , and rotational velocities available at that time , armandroff ( 1989 and references therein ) interpreted a sample of low galactic latitude metal - rich gcs as belonging to a disk system .
minniti ( 1995 ) instead , from metallicity and kinematics of gcs in the central 3 kpc ( about 20@xmath1 ) from the galactic center , found evidence for these gcs to belong to the bulge .
ct ( 1999 ) derived metallicities and radial velocities from high resolution spectroscopy for a significant sample of gcs within 4 kpc from the galactic center .
he concluded that metal - rich gcs are associated with the bulge / bar rather than the thick disk .
an important step in the understanding of the nature of the bulge gcs was presented by ortolani et al .
( 1995 ) , where the metal - rich gcs ngc 6528 and ngc 6553 were found to have an old age , identical to the bulk of the bulge field stars and comparable to that of the halo clusters .
barbuy et al . (
1998 ) derived new results and summarized the properties of 17 gcs in the bulge projected within 5@xmath1 of the galactic center .
they concluded that these clusters shared comparable properties with the bulge field stars , including not only metal - rich gcs but also intermediate metallicity ones .
they also found that there are no clusters in a strip 2.8@xmath1 wide centred at about 0.5@xmath1 south of the galactic plane .
several comprehensive recent reviews have addressed the stellar populations , both field and gcs , in the galactic bulge ( e.g. harris 2001 ; rich 2013 ; gonzalez & gadotti 2015 ) .
these reviews address also comparisons of the galactic bulge with external galaxies .    in the following
we describe recent advances on detailed chemical abundances , distances , kinematical properties and hints on possible association with subsystems in the central region of the galaxy .
we also prepare for the future by defining a bulge gc sample , which includes suggestions for future studies , in terms of unstudied objects .
in particular it is clear that proper motion derivation is still needed for most gcs .
in the past , angular distances from the galactic center were the basis for selecting bulge gcs in the central parts of the galaxy ( e.g. zinn 1985 ; barbuy et al .
1998 ) .    as a first approach we selected clusters with angular distances below 20@xmath1 .
our next step was to use the galactocentric distances of the clusters , given that now they are more reliable - see harris10 .
we adopted a distance to the galactic center of 8 kpc ( bobylev et al .
2014 ; reid et al .
2014 ) . for selecting the clusters we have experimented different distances from the galactic center of 6 , 5 , 4 and 3 kpc .
in each case , we checked for bulge clusters and halo intruders . we conclude that a cutoff of 3 kpc is best in terms of isolating a bona - fide bulge cluster sample , with little contamination .
we finally applied a metallicity filter : zoccali et al .
( 2008 ) , hill et al .
( 2011 ) , ness et al .
( 2013 ) , rojas - arriagada et al .
( 2014 ) have shown that the lower metallicity end of the bulge is around [ fe / h]=-1.3 .
this is confirmed with the findings by pietrukowicz et al .
2012 , 2015 ) , dkny et al .
( 2013 ) and lee ( 1992 ) , all of them having demonstrated that there is a peak of rr lyrae with [ fe / h]=-1.0 , centrally concentrated and spheroidal ( except for pietrukowicz et al .
2015 that found it to be elongated ) , corresponding to an old bulge .
we verified that gcs with [ fe / h ] @xmath2 -1.5 corresponded to well - known halo clusters in most cases .
criteria using the space velocity v , as proposed by dinescu et al .
( 1997 , 1999a , b , 2003 ) , and casetti - dinescu et al .
( 2007 , 2010 , 2013 ) , are only feasible if proper motions are available , besides radial velocities . in particular dinescu et al .
( 2003 ) verified the classification of clusters as members of different galaxy components in terms of kinematics .
the use of this criterion is possible for about a third of the gcs , at the present stage .
gaia results in a few years will bring higher precision , and new data for a number of gcs .
a few groups are applying proper motion cleaning to bulge clusters ( e.g. dinescu et al . 2003 ; rossi et al .
therefore carretta et al .
( 2010 ) criterion of space velocity v values to select stellar populations , is not possible presently for having only the radial velocity in many cases , but may be applicable in a few years .    in table [ tab1 ]
we present the selected bulge clusters , following the criteria explained above .
djorgovski 1 is added to the list , because it was in the barbuy et al .
( 1998 ) s list , and the distance available in harris10 , based on infrared data , is probably overestimated .
the clusters are ordered by right ascension , to be compatible with harris10 .
the distances from the sun are from harris10 mainly based on the visual magnitude of the hb , while valenti et al .
( 2007 ) give distances based on isochrone fitting in jhk .
we also report distances derived from the galactic center , as given by harris10 . for kronberger 49 , not listed in harris10 ,
data are from ortolani et al .
the distance derivation is crucial in order to get the position of the clusters relative to the galactic center and the bar . in most cases , for a cluster located inside the bar , its orbit is trapped , given the high mass of the bar . in fact
more than half the bulge mass is in the bar , and for this reason , the bulge clusters that show low kinematics are trapped ( rossi et al .
2015a ) . given the old age of the clusters it is likely that they were formed before the bar , and later trapped .
the dynamical behaviour of such clusters was illustrated for hp  1 ( ortolani et al .
2011 ) , and for 9 gcs by rossi et al . ( 2015b ) , all of them showing a low maximum height .      in table [ tab2 ] we list possible intruders to our main selection , as well as limiting cases , and we collected a few more gcs with other distance and metallicity criteria .
subsamples are classified as follows :    \a ) probable halo intruders with [ fe / h]@xmath2 - 1.5 : we found 6 gcs with distances to the galactic center smaller than 3 kpc ( our selected bulge volume ) , but with metallicity lower than [ fe / h]@xmath2 - 1.5 , and besides with very high spatial velocities ( dinescu et al . 1999a , 2010 ) , all pointing to perigalactic locations of halo gcs .
\b ) outer bulge shell with distances 3@xmath2r@xmath24.5 kpc : this surrounding bulge shell does probably contain true bulge gcs , that should be near apogalacticon .
interestingly , the few space velocities availabe ( dinescu et al
. 1999a , cudworth & hanson 1993 ) for this sample are rather low .
\c ) outer bulge shell intruders : five gcs are located in this shell b ) , but showing low metallicities , as for example m22 , having also a high velocity typical of halo , like in group a ) .
\d ) metal - rich gcs ( [ fe / h]@xmath3 - 1.0 ) beyond r@xmath34.5kpc : this sample corresponds to the ones that conveyed the idea of `` disk globular clusters '' ( e.g. armandroff 1989 ) .
many of these key and well - known gcs do not have space velocities derived so far .
this would be of great interest to constrain the possibility to link them to the thick disk .
\e ) intruders to d ) .
data for fsr 1767 are from bonatto et al .
( 2007 , 2009 ) .
\f ) little studied gcs without enough parameters : probably key objects for future analysis ( sect .
[ sect7 ] )      terzan 5 was identified to have at least two stellar populations and given its high mass , it was proposed to be a stripped dwarf galaxy ( ferraro et al .
2009 ; massari et al .
saracino et al .
( 2015 ) concluded that liller 1 is as massive as terzan 5 or @xmath4 centauri .
these massive clusters have absolute magnitudes around m@xmath0@xmath5 - 10 .
on the other hand , the faintest bulge gcs are as faint as m@xmath0@xmath5 - 4 , such as terzan 9 and al  3 .
these magnitudes are comparable to those of the ultra - faint galaxies ( e.g. mcconnachie 2012 ; bechtol et al .
2015 ) .    by multiple stellar populations we refer to different metallicities [ fe / h ] in a same cluster .
for most clusters there are hints of two populations , but no difference in metallicity .
a comprehensive discussion on na - o anticorrelation was given by gratton et al .
( 2015 ) , where differences between red and blue horizontal branch stars allow to derive some important conclusions .
see further discussions on multiple populations revealed by na - o anticorrelations in sect .
since this effect appears to be present for most clusters , this is incorporated in the definition of globular clusters , and it is not a concern in the present work .
distances of bulge gcs are mainly based on the horizontal branch ( hb ) luminosity level .
the calculation of distances depends on 3 basic inputs : ( 1 ) the hb absolute magnitude , ( 2 ) the reddening , and ( 3 ) the reddening law .
these three datasets slightly depend on the metallicity .
the hb absolute magnitude may also depend on the he abundance .
the current statistics is based mostly on the distances reported in harris10 , where the hb level is given by the relation : m(hb)=0.16[fe / h]+0.84 .
in harris10 if the hb level is not available , specific references are used .
this relation is somewhat different from that used by barbuy et al .
( 1998 ) in their catalogue of 17 inner bulge clusters , adopted from jones et al .
( 1992 ) : m(hb)=0.16[fe / h]+0.98 .
this latter relation gives an hb level of about 0.14 magnitudes fainter , producing as well smaller distance moduli , but this difference is negligible when compared to other uncertainties .
it is also important to point out that the main difference between harris10 and barbuy et al .
( 1998 ) values , is that the latter was based on optical cmds only .
the list of distances also makes use of the jhk colour - magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) when it is considered more reliable .
finally the catalogue by bica et al .
( 2006 ) uses basically the same assumptions as harris10 .
_ reddening and reddening law : _ the reddening is a key parameter in the derivation of the distances based on the photometric technique . for most of the low latitude bulge gcs ,
an error of 5% in reddening produces a typical error of @xmath615% in the absorption , which propagates with the same fraction to the distance modulus . in harris10
the reddening has been derived from webbink ( 1985 ) , zinn ( 1985 ) and reid et al .
the standard reddening law ( r@xmath0=3.1 ) has been used to derive the visual absorption .
bica et al .
( 2006 ) uses basically the same input values , but they converted e(b - v ) into a@xmath0 using r@xmath0=3.1 for clusters with [ fe / h]@xmath2 - 1.0 and r@xmath0=3.6 for [ fe / h]@xmath3 - 1.0 following grebel and roberts ( 1995 ) , and r@xmath0 values have been interpolated in the intermediate metallicity interval . in principle
this choice should produce shorter distances than harris10 for high metallicity clusters .
a different computation was performed for most of the inner bulge clusters presented in barbuy et al .
a1 of dean et al .
( 1978 ) was used to convert e(v - i ) to e(b - v ) and then the reddening dependence of r@xmath0 on e(b - v ) as given in olson ( 1975 ) has been used to convert e(b - v ) into a@xmath0 : r@xmath0=3.1 + 0.05([fe / h ] ) .
independent distances and reddening values have been obtained by valenti et al .
( 2007 ) for 37 bulge clusters , using infrared jhk photometry .
the main advantage of the jhk derived distances is that the reddening vs. absorption ratio is almost constant even if r@xmath0 varies ( fitzpatrick 1999 ; cardelli et al .
the comparison of the optical vs. ir distances give a chance to probe the reddening law , in the optical regime , in the direction of the galactic bulge .
figure [ fig2 ] shows the distance differences between different r@xmath0 values versus reddening .
the absolute magnitude of the horizontal branch m(hb ) is assumed to be of m(hb)=0.68 for [ fe / h]=-1.0 , at e(b - v)=0 .
therefore at the distance of the galactic center , assumed here to be of 8 kpc , the distance modulus is m - m=14.5 , and m(hb)=14.5 + 0.68=15.18 .
so for the zero point we assume : e(b - v)=0 , m(hb)=15.18 .
we use 12 clusters in common with valenti et al .
( 2007 ) , and adding terzan 9 ( ortolani et al .
1999 ) . from this sample , an average distance difference of d(ir)-d(optical )
= 0.65 kpc has been derived . in the infrared sample
we have also 3 clusters ( terzan 4 , terzan 5 and ngc 6528 ) with data from hst / nicmos ( ortolani et al .
2007 ) . in these cases
we adopted an average value between nicmos and valenti et al .
( 2007 ) . at an average distance of 8 kpc ,
the 0.65 kpc difference is equivalent to about 0.3 mag . in distance modulus .
conclusions from fig .
2 are : a ) it is clear that the optical data produce shorter distances , in particular at high reddening ; b ) in order to get comparable infrared and optical distances , we have to adopt an average total - to - selective absorption r@xmath0=3.2 .
this average value is slightly lower than that adopted in barbuy et al .
( 1998 ) of r@xmath0=3.39 ( see their table 4 ) , but it is still higher than the standard r@xmath0=3.1 value , and it is in agreement with recent studies of the reddening law in different conditions of reddening , metallicity and intrinsic colours of the stars ( hendricks et al . 2012 ; mccall 2004 ) .
a further test can be performed following racine & harris ( 1989 ) and barbuy et al .
( 1998 ) , plotting v(hb ) as a function of reddening .
assuming that , on the average , the inner bulge clusters ( within 3 kpc from the galactic center ) are concentrated around this distance , the hb level should be related to the reddening by means of a slope r@xmath0 .
this is plotted in fig .
[ fig2 ] , which is the updated version of fig . 5 in barbuy et al .
this analysis includes 12 clusters plus an arbitrary point at e(b - v)=0 and v(hb)=15.18 , which should correspond to the v(hb ) at 8.0 kpc from the sun , with [ fe / h]=-1.0 , m@xmath0=0.8 , as explained above .
therefore the best fit is 3.3 @xmath2 r@xmath0 @xmath23.1 .
the higher slope of r@xmath0=3.6 seems too steep .
this confirms that a choice of an average reddening value of r@xmath0=3.2 is adequate and that the baricentric distance from the sun of the considered clusters should be around 8.0 kpc .
finally , we address a few comments on the distance of uks  1 , since there is disagreement between different authors .
we employed 4 sets of data : a ) nicmos data ( ortolani et al .
2001 , 2007 ) , measured relative to ngc 6528 , assumed to be at a distance of d@xmath7 = 7.7 kpc , results in ( m - m)@xmath8= 14.43 . assuming that both clusters have a similar metallicity , and the hst / nicmos reddening law
, we get d@xmath7 = 15.8 kpc for uks  1 ; b ) nicmos data measured relative to liller 1 , assuming for liller 1 a distance of d@xmath7 = 8.1 kpc ( from ( m - m)@xmath8=14.55 , saracino et al .
2015 ) ; given a @xmath9(m - m)@xmath8=1.02 , we get ( m - m)@xmath8=15.57 and a distance of d@xmath7 = 13.0 for uks  1 ; c ) assuming minniti et al .
( 2011 ) absolute reference for the hb colour and magnitude m@xmath10=-1.65 , j - k=0.71 ( from a study of red clump calibrated stars with hipparcos data ) , and using nicmos calibrated data , we obtain j@xmath11=17.96 . from m(hb)@xmath12
= -0.94 and a@xmath12=2.78 , obtained from the comparison with liller 1 ( saracino et al . 2015 ) , we get ( m - m)@xmath8=18.63 - 2.78=15.85 , and d@xmath7 = 14.8 kpc ; d ) from liller 1 ( saracino et al .
2015 ) , but with a recalculated absolute distance from minniti et al .
( 2011 ) values of m(hb)@xmath10 and j - k(hb ) , we have : ( m - m)@xmath8(liller 1)=14.85(d@xmath7 = 9.33 kpc ) , and ( m - m)@xmath8=14.85@xmath131.02=15.87 and d@xmath7 = 14.9 kpc for uks  1 .
all these methods give an average of d@xmath7 = 14.6 kpc for uks  1 , as reported in table [ tab1 ] .
the metallicity distribution of bulge clusters as given in table [ tab1 ] is shown in fig .
it shows a peak around [ fe / h]@xmath5 - 1.0 , suggesting that this population is intrinsically significant . that such an old bulge stellar population is important ,
is confirmed by studies of rr lyrae by lee ( 1992 ) , dkny et al .
( 2013 ) , pietrukowicz et al .
( 2012 , 2015 ) . also , from the metallicity distribution function of field stars by zoccali et al .
( 2008 ) , ness et al .
( 2013 ) , and rojas - arriagada et al .
( 2014 ) , this moderate metallicity corresponds to the lower end of the metallicity distribution function ( mdf ) of the bulge bulk field stellar population .
table [ tab3 ] shows the chemical abundances for a subset of gcs from table [ tab1 ] , that have available high spectral resolution abundance analyses .    _
carbon and nitrogen : _ c and n show the expected anticorrelation due to cno processing along the red giant branch .
two clusters with low n abundances should be further studied since this is not expected .    _
odd - z elements na , al _ a crucial issue concerns possible na - o anticorrelation , which would indicate the presence of a second stellar generation . as a matter of fact
, most gcs are presently being found to have at least two stellar generations , except possibly the least massive clusters . a threshold in mass for a second generation not to occur is presently estimated to be at 3 - 4@xmath1410@xmath15 m@xmath8 ( r.g .
gratton , private communication ) , or in other words , essentially all gcs should show the na - o anticorrelation .
the second generation is detected via na - o , mg - al anticorrelations , and also by the presence of both cn - strong and cn - weak stars ( carretta et al .
the origin of these chemical anomalies is probably hot bottom burning ( hbb ) ( ventura et al .
2013 ) in massive asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) first generation stars , with yields ejected in the internal cluster medium , and incorporated by the second generation stars , the latter showing these anomalies . a thorough discussion on the origin of multiple stellar populations in globular clusters is given in renzini et al .
( 2015 ) . from table [ tab3 ]
we see that very few of the bulge clusters were investigated in terms of na and al .
in fact , four stars analysed by barbuy et al .
( 2014 ) show no na - o anticorrelation ( see their fig .
6 ) , however more stars have to be analysed for a firm conclusion .
an important investigation on this matter was carried out by gratton et al .
( 2015 ) , where 17 bhb and 30 rhb stars of ngc 6723 were analysed .
it was found that rhb and intermediate - bhb stars appear to belong to a first generation , showing o - rich and na - poor abundances , whereas the bluest of the bhb stars show lower oxygen and higher na ( four bhb stars show [ o / fe]=+0.23 and [ na / fe ] = + 0.11 ) , in contrast with the mean values given in table [ tab3 ] .
gratton et al .
( 2015 ) consider that extended blue hb stars might correspond to a second generation of lower mass stars .
_ alpha - elements o , mg , si , ca , ti _ in fig . [ fig7 ] are plotted the abundances of these alpha elements vs. [ fe / h ] , including the abundances for the bulge sample , as given in table [ tab3 ] , compared with abundances for 57 field bulge giant stars from lecureur et al .
( 2007 ) , gonzalez et al .
( 2011 ) and barbuy et al .
( 2015 ) , and 58 bulge dwarf stars from bensby et al .
the oxygen abundances are as given in barbuy et al .
( 2015 ) , where they were revised with respect to lecureur et al .
some discrepancy between the oxygen abundances from barbuy et al .
( 2015 ) and bensby et al .
( 2013 ) can be explained by the facts that : barbuy et al .
analysed red giants , using the forbidden [ oi]6300.31  line and bensby et al .
( 2013 ) analysed dwarfs , using the permitted triplet oi lines at 7771.94 , 7774.16 , 7775.39  lines .
solar oxygen abundances adopted were respectively @xmath16(o ) = 8.87 and 8.85 for barbuy et al . and bensby et al . , which would tend to invert the small shift between the two sets results .
all in all , given that the permitted oi lines are well - known to be subject to strong non - lte effects , and tend to overestimate the oxygen abundances , we can consider that there is a good agreement between the two sets of oxygen abundances .
the panels in fig [ fig7 ] indicate therefore that the alpha - elements o , mg , si and ca are overabundant by about [ o , mg , si , ca , ti / fe]@xmath50.3 to 0.4 dex for the more metal - poor stars .
the same is found for the field ( see also alves - brito et al .
2010 ; bensby et al . 2013 ) .
this implies early fast enrichment by core collapse supernovae snii , which in turn give a short timescale for bulge formation , where even the metal - rich clusters are old ( ortolani et al . 1995 ) .
_ heavy elements _ very few heavy element abundance derivation is available for individual stars of bulge gcs
. the heavy elements of first peak y , sr , zr , together with a few elements of the second peak ba , la , and the r - element eu , can reveal the nature of the first stars , or else to reveal if agbs were acting as important chemical contributors . a threshold of about [ ba / eu]=0.6 would be indicative if ba was produced by r- or s - process .
if [ ba / eu]@xmath30.6 , this could be a hint of early enrichment by massive spinstars , and the same applies to the ratios y / ba , sr / ba , and zr / ba ( frischknecht et al . 2015 ) .
these ratios were studied for the globular cluster ngc 6522 , by barbuy et al .
( 2009 ) , chiappini et al .
( 2011 ) , and ness et al .
( 2014 ) using giraffe spectra from the survey by zoccali et al .
barbuy et al .
( 2014 ) used new uves spectra observed in 2012 for four of the same stars , and these new results are reported in table [ tab3 ] .
sr lines are unreliable as shown by barbuy et al .
( 2014 ) , and ness et al .
( 2014 ) , superseding abundance values given in chiappini et al .
zr is difficult to derive : in table [ tab3 ] it is not reported given that it is only available for ngc 6522 , but it is worth mentioning that cantelli et al .
( 2015 , in preparation ) seems to detect a clear variation in zr abundances among 12 member stars of ngc 6522 observed with giraffe in 2012 .
the ratios from first to second peak of heavy elements can also be explained by production of s - process heavy elements in massive agb stars , and predicted relative ratios between different heavy elements was presented in bisterzo et al .
( 2010 , 2013 ) .
finally , it is possible that all heavy elements in old stars were produced by the r - process only , as first suggested by truran ( 1981 ) .        .
[ fig1 ]                            [ cols= " < , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > " , ]     [ tab4 ]
in this review we provide a state - of - the - art list of bulge globular clusters and their properties .
we tried to constrain their properties including their kinematics when available .
kinematics is becoming a key tool to identify their nature , and the link with the field stellar populations , within the complex substructures of the bulge .    in recent years
good progress in the knowledge of the globular clusters in the central parts of the galaxy has been achieved .
for spectroscopy the multi - object spectrographs in 8m - class telescopes have made it possible to derive chemical abundances for considerable numbers of stars .
progress in instrumentation thanks to e.g. imaging with mcao in the infrared ( mad / vlt , gems / gemini ) and hst / nicmos , made possible long time baseline of ccd data with excellent quality , allowing proper motion cleaning of cmds . finally , surveys with larger apertures such as the 4 m vista telescope , provided the discovery of new objects .
the vvv survey in particular has provided several new bulge globular clusters and candidates , to be explored in coming years .
much work is still needed as concerns bulge globular clusters , such as the monitoring of variable stars , in particular rr lyrae , to obtain deep cmds allowing age derivation , and the derivation of metallicities and chemical abundances from high - resolution spectroscopy .
the derivation of na and o abundances will be crucial to define if these very old clusters have a unique or multiple stellar generations .
these results should allow to better compare the bulge globular clusters with outer bulge , inner halo and outer halo ones .
alves - brito , a. , barbuy , b. , zoccali , m. et al .
2006 , a&a , 460 , 269 alves - brito , a. , melndez , j. , asplund , m. , ramrez , i. , yong , d. 2010 , a&a , 513 , a35 armandroff , t. 1989 , aj , 97 , 375 athanassoula , e. 2005 , mnras , 358 , 1477 baade , w. 1944 , apj , 100 , 137 baade , w. 1946 , pasp , 343 , 249 babusiaux , c. , gmez , a. , hill , v. et al .
2010 , a&a , 519 , 77 babusiaux , c. , katz , d. , hill , v. et al .
2014 , a&a , 563 , 15 barbuy , b. , bica , e. , ortolani , s. 1998 , a&a , 333 , 117 barbuy , b. , zoccali , m. , ortolani , s. , et al .
2006 , a&a , 449 , 349 barbuy , b. , zoccali , m. , ortolani , s. , et al .
2007 , aj , 134 , 1613 barbuy , b. , zoccali , m. , ortolani , s. , et al .
2009 , a&a , 507 , 405 barbuy , b. , chiappini , c. , cantelli , e. et al .
2014 , a&a , 570 , 76 barbuy , b. , friaa , a. , da silveira , c.r .
2015 , a&a , 580 , 40 bechtol , k. , drlica - wagner , a. , balbinot , e. et al .
2015 , apj , 807 , 50 bensby , t. , yee , j.c .
, feltzing , s. et al .
2013 , a&a , 549 , 147 bica , e. , pastoriza , m. 1983 , apssci , 91 , 99 bica , e. , bonatto , c. , barbuy , b. , ortolani , s. 2006 , a&a , 450 , 105 bisterzo , s. , gallino , r. , straniero , o. et al .
2010 , mnras , 404 , 1529 bisterzo , s. , travaglio , c. , wiescher , m. et al .
2013 , arxiv : 1311.5381 blitz , l. , spergel , d.n .
1991 , apj , 379 , 631 bobylev v. v. , mosenkov , a.v . , bajkova , a.t . , gontcharov , g.a .
2014 , astl , 40 , 86 bonatto , c. , bica , e. , ortolani , s. , barbuy , b. 2007 , mnras , 381 , l45 bonatto , c. , bica , e. , ortolani , s. , barbuy , b. : 2009 , mnras , 397 , 1032 borissova , j. , bonatto , c. , kurtev , r. et al .
2011 , a&a , 532 , 131 borissova , j. , chen , a. n. , ramirez alegria , s. , et al .
2014 , a&a , 569 , 24 bureau , m. , aronica , g. , athanassoula , e. et al .
2006 , mnras , 370 , 753 cannon , a.j . 1929 , bharo , 868 , 1 cardelli , j.a . ,
clayton , g.c . ,
mathis , j.s .
1989 , apj , 345 , 245 carretta , e. , cohen , j.g . ,
gratton , r.g . , behr , b.b .
2001 , aj , 122 , 1469 carretta , e. , bragaglia , a. , gratton , r.g .
2009 , a&a , 505 , 117 carretta , e. , bragaglia , a. , gratton , r.g .
2010 , a&a , 516 , 55 casetti - dinescu , d.i . , girard , t.m . ,
herrrera , d. et al .
2007 , aj , 134 , 195 casetti - dinescu , d.i . ,
girard , t.m .
, korchagin , v.i .
2010 , aj , 140 , 1282 casetti - dinescu , d.i . ,
girard , t.m .
, jlkov , l. et al .
2013 , aj , 146 , 33    clarkson , w. , sahu , k. , anderson j. et al .
2008 , apj , 684 , 1110 clarkson , w. , sahu , k. , anderson , j. et al .
2011 , apj , 735 , 37 chiappini , c. , frischknecht , u. , meynet , g. et al . 2011 ,
nature , 472 , 454 cohen , j.g . ,
gratton , r.g .
, behr , b.b . , carretta , e. 1999 , apj , 523 , 739 ct , p. 1999 , aj , 118 , 406 courtes , g. , cruvellier , p. 1960
, pohp , 5 , 3 cudworth , k.m . , hanson , r.b .
1993 , aj , 105 , 168 dean , j.f . ,
warpen , p.r . , cousins , a.j .
1978 , mnras , 183 , 569 dkny , i. , minniti , d. , catelan , m. et al .
2013 , apj , 776 , l19 dinescu , d.i . ,
girard , t.m . , van altena , w.f .
1997 , aj , 114 , 1014 dinescu , d.i . , van altena , w.f . , girard , t.m .
1999a , aj , 117 , 277 dinescu , d.i . ,
girard , t.m . , van altena , w.f .
1999b , aj , 117 , 1792 dinescu , d.i . ,
girard , t.m . ,
van altena , w.f . ,
lpez , c.e .
2003 , aj , 125 , 1373 feltzing , s. , johnson , r.a .
2002 , a&a , 385 , 67 ferraro , f.r . , dalessandro , e. , mucciarelli , a. et al .
2009 , nature , 462 , 483 fitzpatrick e.l . 1999 ,
pasp , 111 , 63 frenk , c.s . , white , s.d.m .
1982 , mnras , 198 , 173 frischknecht , u. , hirschi , r. , pignatari , m. et al . 2015 ,
mnras , submitted gratton , r.g . , lucatello , s. , sollima , a. et al .
2015 , a&a , 573 , a92 grebel , e.k . , roberts , w.j .
1995 , a&as , 109 , 293 gonzalez , o.a . , rejkuba , m. , zoccali , m. et al .
2011 , a&a , 530 , 54 gonzalez , o.a . , gadotti , d.a .
2015 , arxiv:1503.07252 , to appear in _ galactic bulges _ , eds .
laurikainen e. , peletier r. , gadotti d. harris , w.e .
1996 , aj , 112 , 1487 harris , w.e .
2001 , star clusters , saas - fee advanced courses , volume 28 .
isbn 978 - 3 - 540 - 67646 - 1 .
springer - verlag berlin heidelberg , 2001 , p. 223
hendricks , b. , stetson , p.b . , vandenberg , d.a .
, dallora , m. 2012 , apj , 144 , 25 hill , v. , lecureur , a. , gmez , a. et al . 2011 , a&a , 534 , 80 ivanov , v. d. ; kurtev , r. ; borissova , j. 2005 , a&a , 442 , 195 jones , r.v . , carney , b.w .
, storm , j. , latham , d.w .
1992 , apj , 386 , 646 kinman , t.d .
1959 , mnras , 119 , 538 lecureur , a. , hill , v. , zoccali , m. et al .
2007 , a&a , 465 , 799 lee , j .- w . ,
carney , b.w .
, balachandran , s.c .
2004 , aj , 128 , 2388 lee , y .- w .
1992 , aj , 104 , 1780 lee , j.w .
2007 , revmexaa , 28 , 120 lee , y .- w . , joo , s .-
chung , c. 2015 , arxiv:1508.05942 martinez - valpuesta , i. , shlosman , i. , heller , c. 2006 , apj , 637 , 214 massari , d. , mucciarelli , a. , ferraro , f.r .
2014 , apj , 795 , 22 mayall , m. u. 1946 , apj , 104 , 290 mccall , m. 2004 , aj , 128 , 2144 mcclure , r.d .
1969 , aj , 74 , 50 mcconnachie , a.w .
2012 , aj , 144 , 4 mcwilliam , a. , zoccali , m. 2010 , apj , 724 , 1491 melndez , j. , barbuy , b. , bica , e. et al .
2003 , a&a , 411 , 417 minniti , d. 1995 , aj , 109 , 1663 minniti , d. , zoccali , m. 2008 , iau symp .
245 , p. 323 minniti , d. , hempel , m. , toledo , i. et al .
2011 , a&a , 527 , 81 moni bidin , c. , mauro , f. , geisler , d. et al .
2011 , a&a , 535 , 33 morgan , w.w . 1959 ,
aj , 64 , 432 muoz , r. r. , geha , m. , ct , p. et al .
2012 , apj , 753 , l15 nataf , d.m . ,
udalski , a. , gould , a. , fouqu , p. , stanek , k.z . : 2010 , apj , 721 , l28 ness , m. , freeman , k. , athanassoula , e. et al .
2013 , mnras , 432 , 2092 ness , m. , asplund , m. , casey , a.r .
2014 , mnras , 445 , 2994 ness , m. , freeman , k. , athanassoula , e. et al .
2013 , mnras , 430 , 836 olson , b.i .
1975 , pasp , 87 , 349 origlia , l. , rich , r.m . ,
castro , s. 2002 , aj , 123 , 1559 origlia , l. , rich , r.m .
2004 , aj , 127 , 3422 origlia , l. , valenti , e. , rich , r.m . 2005b , mnras , 356 , 1276 origlia , l. , valenti , e. , rich , r.m . ,
ferraro , f. 2005b , mnras , 363 , 897 origlia , l. , valenti , e. , rich , r.m .
2008 , mnras , 388 , 1419 origlia , l. , rich , r.m . , ferraro , f. et al .
2011 , apj , 726 , l20 origlia , l. , massari , d. , rich , r.m .
et al . 2013 , apj , 779 , l5 ortolani , s. , renzini , a. , gilmozzi , r. et al .
1995 , nature , 377 , 701 ortolani , s. , bica , e. , barbuy , b. 1999 , a&as , 138 , 267 ortolani , s. , barbuy , b. , bica , e. et al .
2001 , a&a , 376,878 ortolani , s. , barbuy , b. , bica , e. , zoccali , m. , renzini , a. 2007 , a&a , 470 , 1043 ortolani , s. , bonatto , c. , bica , e. , barbuy , b. : 2009 , aj , 138 , 889 ortolani , s. , barbuy , b. , momany , y. et al .
2011 , apj , 737 , 31 ortolani , s. , bonatto , c. , bica , e. et al .
2012 , aj , 144 , 147 pealoza , f. , pessev , p. , vsquez , s. et al .
2015 , pasp , 127 , 329 pfenniger , d. 1984 , a&a , 134 , 373 pietrukowicz , p. , udalski , a. , sosynski , i. et al .
2012 , apj , 750 , 169 pietrukowicz , p. , kozlowski , s. , skowron , j. et al .
2015 , arxiv:1412.4121 racine , r. harris , w.e .
1989 , aj , 98 , 1609 reid , m.j . , menten , k.m . ,
brunthaler , a. et al . , 2014 , apj , 783,130 renzini , a. , dantona , f. , cassisi , s. et al . 2015 , mnras , submitted rich , r.m .
2013 , planets , stars and stellar systems vol . 5 , by oswalt , terry d. ; gilmore , gerard , isbn 978 - 94 - 007 - 5611 - 3 .
springer science+business media dordrecht , 2013 , p. 271
rojas - arriagada , a. , recio - blanco , a. , hill , v. et al .
2014 , a&a , 569 , 103 rossi , l. , ortolani , s. , bica , e. , barbuy , b. , bonfanti , a. 2015a , mnras , 450 , 3270 rossi , l. , ortolani , s. , casotto , s. , barbuy , b. , bica , e. , 2015b , mnras , in preparation saracino , s. , dalessandro , e. , ferraro , f.r .
2015 , apj , 806 , 152 smith , h.a .
, wehlau , a. 1985 , apj , 298 , 572 terzan , a. 1968 , pohp , 10 , 4 truran , j. 1981 , a&a , 97 , 391 valenti , e. , ferraro , f. , origlia , l. 2007 , aj , 133 , 1287 valenti , e. , origlia , l. , rich , r.m .
2011 , mnras , 414 , 2690 valenti , e. , origlia , l. , mucciarelli , a. , rich , r.m .
2015 , a&a , 574 , 80 van den bergh , s. 1967 , aj , 72 , 70 vsquez , s. , zoccali , m. , hill , v. et al .
2013 , a&a , 555 , 91 ventura , p. , di criscienzo , m. , carini , r. , dantona , f. 2013 , mnras , 431 , 3642 webbink , r.f . 1985 , iau symposium 113 , p. 541 wegg , c. , gerhard , o. , portail , m. 2015 , mnras , 450 , 4050 whitford , a.e . , rich , r.m .
1983 , apj , 274 , 723 zinn , r. 1985 , apj , 293 , 424 zoccali , m. , renzini , a. , ortolani , s. et al .
2001 , aj , 121 , 2638 zoccali , m. , barbuy , b. , hill , v. et al .
2004 , a&a , 423 , 507 zoccali , m. , renzini , a. , ortolani , s. et al .
2003 , a&a , 399 , 931 zoccali , m. , hill , v. , lecureur , a. et al .
2008 , a&a , 486 , 177


the abundance - metallicity relation of low mass extremely metal - poor ( emp ) stars ( @xmath4 \la -3 $ ] ; @xmath5 \equiv \log_{10 }   ( n_{\rm x}/n_{\rm y } ) - \log_{10 } ( n_{\rm x}/n_{\rm y})_\odot$ ] where @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the abundances of elements x and y , respectively ) and very metal - poor ( vmp ) stars ( @xmath8 \la -2 $ ] ) has been clarified by observations of very high quality spectra ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this relation is expected to provide the information of supernovae ( sne ) of population ( pop ) iii ( the first generation ) massive stars ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) and the first stage of galactic chemical evolution ( gce ) ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the emp stars are considered to have suffered the injection of heavy elements from one or a few sne ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
a halo interstellar medium becomes gradually homogeneous with metallicity @xcite .
although recent studies of the star formation in the first stage of gce have been in progress , the characteristics of first generation stars , such as initial mass function , have not been clarified . in order to clarify such characteristics , we should investigate nucleosynthesis in the candidates of the first generation stars as well as the observed variations of the abundance distributions of the emp and vmp stars .
recent observations have indicated that the abundance ratios [ x / fe ] averaged in the metal - poor stars with @xmath4 \la -2 $ ] are between @xmath9 and 0.5 for most of observed elements @xcite .
their scatter around the average values deduced from the new observation is much smaller than found in earlier studies .
the elemental abundance distribution of the metal - poor stars is not so different from that of the solar - system composition .
therefore , the small scatter is considered to suggest primordial burst of high - mass stars or the very rapid mixing of matter from different bursts of early star formation .    from theoretical viewpoint ,
@xcite compared the pop iii hypernova ( hn ) yields with the abundance pattern of emp stars with the metallicity range @xmath10 < -3.5 $ ] in @xcite .
they adopted the mixing - fallback model for the hne .
the hn yields give good agreement with the observed abundances for c , na , mg , al , si , ca , ni , and zn . they also compared the pop iii sn and hn yields integrated over the salpeter initial mass function ( imf ) with the abundances of vmp stars in the metallicity range @xmath11 < -2.0 $ ] in @xcite .
they reproduced the observed trends of abundance ratios for c , o , na , mg , al , si , ca , cr , ni , and zn .
the sn and hn yields of n , k , sc , ti , mn , and co are short for explaining the observed yield ratios , although sc and ti may be improved in the high - entropy explosion models .
the yields of mn and co may be reproduced by the modification of electron fraction @xmath12 , of which value is still uncertain in the innermost region of sne and hne .
additional nucleosynthesis processes also remain open for these elements .    during a sn explosion ,
the collapsed core becomes extremely high temperature and high density , and neutrinos are produced through pair creation .
the neutrinos are almost thermalized by neutrino - nucleus scattering at the center .
they pass away through the neutrino sphere with carrying the gravitational binding energy of the core .
the neutrino irradiation lasts for about @xmath13 s. the total number of neutrinos emitted in a sn is very huge , i.e. , about @xmath14 .
the neutrinos interact with nuclei in the surrounding stellar material to produce new species of nuclei .
this is called the @xmath0-process .
the @xmath0-process is expected to be an important production process for some elements in pop iii sn explosions .
the @xmath0-process is important for the synthesis of light elements , li and b @xcite , f ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and some heavy neutron - deficient nuclei such as @xmath15la and @xmath16ta @xcite .
the @xmath0-process products are synthesized through the spallations by neutrinos from abundant seed nuclei .
it also produces protons and neutrons and their capture reactions also enhance the abundances of some elements . for pop iii sne ,
the seed nuclei are @xmath17-nuclei abundantly produced in complete and incomplete si burning during the explosions .
thus , the @xmath0-process in pop iii sne will produce additional some odd-@xmath1 elements .
we note that most of the nucleosynthesis calculations including the @xmath0-process have been carried out using spherical explosion models @xcite . although the total neutrino energy should be close to the gravitational binding energy released from the collapsing core , properties of the neutrinos are still uncertain .
the properties strongly depend on explosion mechanism but details of the mechanism have not been clarified . on the other hand ,
aspherical explosions have been investigated recently ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in such a case , aspherical structure of neutrino sphere can be formed and the properties of the neutrinos are also still uncertain . therefore , the dependence of the abundances of pop iii sne and hne on neutrino properties should be investigated .    in this study , we focus on the effect of the @xmath0-process on the production of odd-@xmath1 iron - peak elements , sc , mn , and co , during pop iii sn and hn explosions .
we calculate the sn nucleosynthesis including the @xmath0-process .
then , we investigate the dependence of the abundances of sc , mn , and co in the sn ejecta on the energy of neutrinos , the stellar mass , and the explosion energy .
sc , mn , and co are expected to be at least partly synthesized through the @xmath0-process .
we also indicate whether the abundance ratios of sc , mn , and co to fe reproduce those observed in the emp stars when we take into account the @xmath0-process .    in  2
we explain stellar evolution models and the explosion models of sne and a hn .
we also describe the nucleosynthesis models including the @xmath0-process and the neutrino irradiation models . in
3 we show the abundance distributions of sc , mn , and co in the ejecta of the sn and hn models . we explain additional production of these elements through the @xmath0-process . in
4 we explain the effect of the @xmath0-process on the abundance ratios of sc , mn , and co to fe and the dependence on the neutrino irradiation strength .
we also compare our results with the abundance ratios observed in the emp stars . in  5
we discuss other production processes of sc , mn , and co proposed in recent studies and the effect of the @xmath0-process .
finally , we summarize this study in  6 .
we calculate the evolution of population iii stars for initial masses of 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 from zero - age main - sequence to the onset of the core collapse .
we use a henyey - type stellar evolution code including a nuclear reaction network with about 300 isotopes to calculate detailed nucleosynthesis and energy generation .
the input physics is the same as the models used in @xcite .
sn explosions are calculated using a hydrodynamical code of spherically symmetrical piecewise parabolic method @xcite .
we set the explosion energy of the 15 and 25 @xmath2 sn models to be @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the explosion energy in units of @xmath20 ergs .
we also calculate the explosion of a hn for the 25 @xmath2 star model with @xmath21 .
the location of the mass cut of the sn explosions is determined as follows .
for the 15 @xmath2 star model , we set the location of the mass cut at @xmath22 ( @xmath23 being the mass coordinate of a star ) to obtain the ejected @xmath24ni mass of 0.07 @xmath2 . in the case of 25 @xmath2 sn , we set the mass cut location at @xmath25 , so that large ( co , zn)/fe ratios are obtained .
this location corresponds to the bottom of the layer where electron fraction @xmath12 is close to 0.5 @xcite .
a large amount of @xmath24ni is produced in the region of @xmath26 ( see  3.2 for details ) .
since the location of the mass cut is deep , this model ejects the @xmath24ni mass of 0.36 @xmath2 .
this model corresponds to a sn with the explosion energy of @xmath27 and yielding a large @xmath24ni amount ( @xmath28(@xmath24ni)@xmath29 ) such as sn 2005bf @xcite .
note that the mixing - fallback model is not applied to these cases .    in the case of the 25 @xmath2 hn model
, we apply the mixing - fallback model @xcite .
this model approximates aspherical effects of hn explosions @xcite . during aspherical explosion
, the central core of a star first collapses .
then , jet - like explosion ejects the surrounding stellar materials .
some of the materials in an inner region may fallback to the central core from off - axis direction of the jet .
there are three parameters in the mixing - fallback model ; the initial mass cut @xmath30(ini ) , the outer boundary of the mixing region @xmath31(out ) , and the ejection factor @xmath32 .
the initial mass cut corresponds to the mass of the initially collapsing core .
the outer boundary of the mixing region corresponds to the location where the surrounding materials infall to the core during the explosion .
the ejection fraction is the ejected material fraction in the mixing region .
details of the mixing - fallback model have been described in @xcite .
the values of the mixing - fallback parameters should be related to the explosion features such as asphericity and energy deposition rate @xcite .
however , the explosion mechanism has not been clarified .
therefore , we determine these parameter values similar to case a in @xcite . the location of the initial mass cut is set as @xmath33 , which is the bottom of the @xmath34 layer .
this condition deduces large zn / fe ratio @xcite .
the outer boundary of the mixing region is determined as @xmath35 where the mass fraction of @xmath24ni decreases to @xmath36 .
the ejection factor is determined as @xmath37 in order to yield [ o / fe ] = 0.5 .
the electron fraction in complete and incomplete si burning regions is not modified in this study .
the @xmath24ni mass of each explosion model is listed in table 1 .
a huge amount of neutrinos are emitted during sn explosions . for
spherically symmetrical sn explosions , neutrinos are emitted isotropically from the neutrino sphere and carry the majority of gravitational energy of a proto - neutron star . on the other hand , aspherical sne and jet - like explosion would emit neutrinos anisotropically . in this case neutrino irradiation may be very strong in a specific direction .
since we assume spherically symmetrical sn explosions ,
we assume isotropic neutrino emission .    the strength of the neutrino flux is determined by the total neutrino energy .
the adopted values of the total neutrino energy are @xmath38 ergs , @xmath39 ergs , and @xmath40 ergs .
the first value corresponds to normal neutrino irradiation and is almost equal to the gravitational binding energy of a 1.4 @xmath2 neutron star @xcite .
we assume that the neutrino luminosity decrease exponentially with time .
the decay time of the neutrino luminosity is set to be 3.0 s.    the spectra of the sn neutrinos are assumed to obey fermi distribution with zero chemical potentials .
the temperatures of @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 , @xmath44 are set to be @xmath45 mev/@xmath46 and 4 mev/@xmath46 , respectively .
this set of the neutrino temperatures is the same as in @xcite and @xcite .
we note that @xcite provided the sn yields adopting the @xmath41 and @xmath42 temperature of @xmath47 mev and @xmath48 ergs .
therefore , we briefly mention the yields obtained using this parameter set .
detailed nucleosynthesis during the sn explosions is calculated by postprocessing using a code of @xcite to which the @xmath0-process reactions in @xcite were added .
we should note that the evolution of neutrino luminosity and energy spectra of hne may be different from that of sne . the neutrino emission from rapidly accreting disks surrounding black holes during gamma ray bursts and
hne has been investigated ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
they showed that @xmath49 and smaller amount of @xmath50 are mainly emitted from the accretion disks with slightly hard energy spectra compared with those from proto - neutron stars .
however , the evolution of neutrino emission during hn explosions is still largely uncertain . on the other hand ,
the main contribution of the @xmath0-process is neutral - current interactions , which do not depend on neutrino flavors @xcite .
furthermore , the yields of the @xmath0-process products depend on both neutrino energy spectra and the total neutrino energy . roughly speaking
, a larger total neutrino energy corresponds to harder neutrino energy spectra @xcite .
therefore , we set the total neutrino energy as a parameter
.    the value of total neutrino energy @xmath51 ergs may be too large even in the hn model .
if an element is not produced abundantly through the @xmath0-process with @xmath51 ergs , the @xmath0-process contribution should be very small for the production of the element .
ccccc no neutrinos & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 + @xmath56 & @xmath52 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 + @xmath39 & @xmath60 & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 + @xmath40 & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & @xmath67 + @xmath56 ( @xmath68=8 mev ) & @xmath52 & @xmath69 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 + no neutrinos & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 & @xmath75 + @xmath56 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 + @xmath39 & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 + @xmath40 & @xmath84 & @xmath58 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 + @xmath56 ( @xmath68=8 mev ) & @xmath76 & @xmath87 & @xmath63 & @xmath88 + no neutrinos & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 + @xmath56 & @xmath89 & @xmath93 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 + @xmath39 & @xmath89 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 + @xmath40 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 + @xmath56 ( @xmath68=8 mev ) & @xmath89 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath83 +
we explain the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co as well as the contribution of the @xmath0-process for their production .
figure 1@xmath105 shows the distributions of the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co in the 15 @xmath2 sn model without taking into account the @xmath0-process . in this figure ,
the main product in the range of @xmath106 is @xmath24ni . in this region a large amount of iron - peak elements are produced through complete si burning .
we call this region the ni layer . in the region outside the ni layer ,
incomplete si burning occurs during the explosion and a large amount of si as well as a smaller amount of iron - peak elements are produced .
we call this region ( @xmath107 ) the si / s layer
.    the characteristics of the mass fractions and main production sites of sc , mn , and co without the @xmath0-process are explained as follows .    1 .
small mass fraction of sc is produced at @xmath108 .
the mass fraction is about @xmath109 at the maximum .
most of sc is produced through incomplete si burning .
most of mn is produced in the si / s layer through incomplete si burning .
the mass fraction at the maximum is about @xmath110 , which is much larger than that of sc .
a part of mn is also produced in the ni layer but the mass fraction is much smaller .
co is also produced in the ni layer .
the mass fraction of co is about @xmath111 throughout this layer .
hereafter we consider the effect of the @xmath0-process on the production of sc , mn , and co. figures 1@xmath112 and 1@xmath113 show the distributions of the mass fractions taking into account the @xmath0-process with @xmath114 ergs and @xmath40 ergs , respectively .
[ [ sc ] ] sc ^^    we see that additional sc is produced in the si / s layer ( @xmath115 ) and in the ni layer .
the mass fraction of sc is less than @xmath109 .
most of the sc is first produced as @xmath116ti and @xmath116v . in the ni layer
, a large amount of @xmath117ti is produced through complete si burning . at the same time
, @xmath116ti and @xmath116v are partly produced through neutron- and proton - captures of @xmath117ti . without the @xmath0-process ,
however , the produced @xmath116ti and @xmath116v are smoothly captured or decomposed again during the explosion . with the @xmath0-process
, additional protons are produced through the @xmath0-process , so that some @xmath116v is produced again by the proton capture .
[ [ mn ] ] mn ^^
we see the increase in the mass fraction of mn in the ni layer by about three orders of magnitude compared with the case without the @xmath0-process .
the mass fraction in the si / s layer also increases by about a factor of 1.4 . during the sn explosion ,
mn is produced as @xmath118co .
the amount of @xmath118mn originally produced in the sn is much smaller . in the si / s layer ,
@xmath118co is produced by @xmath119fe(@xmath120co or photodisintegration from @xmath24ni .
when the @xmath0-process is considered , @xmath118co is also produced through @xmath24ni(@xmath121co after the production of @xmath24ni through complete and incomplete si burning . since the decay time of the neutrino luminosity is longer than the time scale of si burning , the neutrino irradiation proceeds after ceasing si burning .
[ [ co ] ] co ^^    when we consider the @xmath0-process , the mass fraction of co increases by about a factor of three throughout the ni layer . the main production region of co
is not changed when we consider the @xmath0-process .
most of co is produced as @xmath122cu and about @xmath123 of @xmath122co is produced as @xmath122ni .
we see increase in the mass fractions of @xmath122cu and @xmath122ni similarly in the ni layer .
most of @xmath122cu and @xmath122ni are produced through the captures of protons and neutrons by @xmath124ni .
the protons and neutrons are produced through the @xmath0-process even after the cease of complete si burning .
therefore , the additional production raises the mass fraction of co.      we also consider the case of larger neutrino irradiation with @xmath56 ergs .
the distributions of the mass fractions are shown in fig .
we see that the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co in the ni layer are larger by a factor of @xmath125 than those in the case of @xmath48 ergs .
the dependence of the obtained mass fractions on the total neutrino energy is slightly smaller than the linear one . in this case
all three elements are mainly produced in the ni layer although mn is mainly produced in the si / s layer in the case of the former cases .
the mass fractions of the 25 @xmath2 sn model without the @xmath0-process is shown in fig .
2@xmath105 . in this figure ,
the ni layer where complete si burning occurs is in the range between @xmath126 and @xmath127 in the mass coordinate . the si / s layer which suffered incomplete
si burning is between @xmath127 and @xmath128 .
the ejected masses of these layers are larger than the corresponding layers in the 15 @xmath2 sn model .
the distributions of the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co in the 25 @xmath2 sn model are roughly similar to those of the 15 @xmath2 sn model .
most of sc is produced in outer part of the si / s layer ( @xmath129 ) .
mn is mainly produced in the si / s layer , too .
most of co is produced in the ni layer .
the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co with the @xmath0-process of @xmath48 ergs are shown in fig .
when we consider the @xmath0-process , their increase is seen in the ni layer . for sc
, the mass fraction reaches about @xmath130 .
it is about @xmath131 for mn but the main mn production is still in the si / s layer .
increase in the abundance by the @xmath0-process is seen in the si / s layer . for co ,
the abundance increases by about a factor of two .
the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co in the case of a larger neutrino irradiation ( @xmath51 ergs ) are shown in fig .
we obtain larger ones for sc , mn , and co. the mass fraction of sc in the ni layer is about @xmath132 , which is larger than that of the 15 @xmath2 sn . for mn and co ,
the abundances in the ni layer are close to those of the 15 @xmath2 sn .
the increase in the mn abundance in the si / s layer is also seen .
we explain effects of the @xmath0-process on the production in the 25 @xmath2 hn model with @xmath133 .
figure 3@xmath105 shows the distribution of the mass fractions in the 25 @xmath2 hn model without the @xmath0-process .
the mass coordinate ranges of the ni and si / s layers are @xmath134 and @xmath135 , respectively .
the mass contained in each of the two layers for the 25 @xmath2 hn is larger than that of the corresponding layer of the 25 @xmath2 sn model .
we see that the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co in each burning region are not so different from those in the 25 @xmath2 sn ; most of sc and mn are produced in the si / s layer and co is produced in the ni layer .
the average value of the co mass fraction in the ni layer is larger than that in the 25 @xmath2 sn .
the distribution of the mass fractions in the 25 @xmath2 hn model with the @xmath0-process ( @xmath48 ergs ) is shown in fig . 3@xmath112 .
increase in the mass fraction by the @xmath0-process is mainly seen for sc and mn .
as shown in the cases of the sne , additional sc is produced in the ni layer .
in addition , some mn is also produced in there .
since the range of the ni layer is large , the contribution from the ni layer is larger than that from the si / s layer in this case . on the other hand , clear effect of the @xmath0-process
is not seen for co.    figure 3@xmath113 shows the mass fractions in the 25 @xmath2 hn model with larger neutrino irradiation ( @xmath51 ergs ) . as same as the sn case , the sc abundance in the ni layer is larger by about a factor of ten than that in the case of the normal neutrino irradiation ( @xmath48 ergs ) .
the mass fraction of mn is similarly larger . in the si / s layer
, the mn amount also increases . on the other hand ,
the mass fraction of co does not so change even with large neutrino irradiation .
co is produced through complete si burning in the ni layer and most of it is not decomposed during the explosion .
since hne produce large amount of co even without neutrino irradiation @xcite , the additional production through the @xmath0-process hardly affects the co production .
we have shown that some amounts of sc , mn , and co are produced through the @xmath0-process and the following capture reactions of neutrons and protons .
this additional production increases the total abundances of these elements in pop iii sn and hn explosions .
hereafter we show the distributions of abundance ratios in the 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 sn and the 25 @xmath2 hn models .
we also compare our results with the observed abundances of low mass emp stars . as a reference of the observed abundances , we use the abundance ratios to fe averaged in the data of 22 low mass halo stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath136 in @xcite .
we show the abundance ratios in the 15 @xmath2 sn model in fig .
the ratios of [ sc / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , and [ co / fe ] are listed in table 1 .
the abundance ratios of the three elements are much smaller than the corresponding solar ratios . for other elements , the abundance ratios of odd-@xmath1 elements are smaller than those of the even-@xmath1 elements in the neighbors . when we consider the @xmath0-process , the ratios [ sc / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , and [ co / fe ] increase by @xmath137 dex ( see table 1 ) .
thus , the @xmath0-process raises the abundances of these elements .
since the fe abundance is not altered by the @xmath0-process , the increase in the abundance ratios is due to the increase in the abundances by the @xmath0-process .
larger irradiation of neutrinos enhances the abundances of these elements . in the case of @xmath40 ergs ,
the abundance ratios for mn and co are larger than the corresponding solar ratios ( see table 1 and fig .
the abundance ratios of v , mn , and co are larger than those of the even-@xmath1 elements ti , cr , and fe , respectively .
we see that [ sc / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , and [ co / fe ] for @xmath138 ergs and @xmath40 ergs increase by @xmath139 dex and @xmath140 dex , respectively , compared with those with @xmath48 ergs .
the total neutrino energies with @xmath141 ergs and @xmath40 ergs are three times and ten times larger than that with @xmath142 ergs .
simple consideration leads to that the abundances of odd-@xmath1 elements produced through the @xmath0-process are proportional to the neutrino flux , i.e. , the total neutrino energy .
numerical simulations of the @xmath0-process show that this property is approximately correct .
the reaction rates of the @xmath0-process are proportional to the total neutrino energy . at the same time ,
production rates of protons and neutrons produced through the @xmath0-process are also proportional to the total neutrino energy .
the increase in the production rates brings about the increase in the production of odd-@xmath1 elements through proton- and neutron - captures . however , decomposition rates of the odd-@xmath1 elements through proton- and neutron - captures also increase .
thus , the abundances produced through the @xmath0-process increase less than proportional to the total neutrino energy .
we compare the obtained [ sc / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , and [ co / fe ] with the corresponding observed results .
the observed [ sc / fe ] averaged in 22 low mass emp stars is 0.06 .
this value is slightly larger than the solar ratio and is still much larger than the calculated abundance ratio even in the case of the largest neutrino irradiation . for mn , the observed [ mn / fe ]
is @xmath143 .
this abundance ratio is larger than the ratio without the @xmath0-process and is reproduced by the result with the @xmath0-process of the normal neutrino irradiation ( @xmath48 ergs ) . on the other hand , the mn / fe ratio in the case of @xmath51 ergs is much larger than the largest value in the observed ratios .
the observed [ co / fe ] is 0.31 , which is larger than the solar ratio . it is larger than the value in the sn model even with the largest neutrino irradiation .
figure 5 shows the abundance ratios of the 25 @xmath2 sn model .
when we do not consider the @xmath0-process , the abundance ratios of sc , mn , and co are much smaller than the corresponding solar ratios ( see also table 1 ) .
the @xmath0-process also enhances the production of these elements .
when we consider the @xmath0-process , the sc / fe ratio in this model is larger than that in the 15 @xmath2 sn model .
this is because the seed nucleus of @xmath116v , i.e. , @xmath117ti , is abundantly produced in complete si burning for the 25 @xmath2 sn .
however , the sc / fe ratio is smaller than the observed ratio even in the case of the largest neutrino irradiation . on the other hand ,
the mn / fe ratio in this model well reproduces the observed ratio in the case with the @xmath0-process of normal neutrino irradiation .
the model with the largest neutrino irradiation ( @xmath51 ergs ) overproduces mn .
the observed co / fe ratio is reproduced by the 25 @xmath2 sn model with the largest neutrino irradiation @xmath51 ergs ; large neutrino irradiation is required similarly to the 15 @xmath2 sn case .
figure 6 shows the distribution of the abundance ratios of the 25 @xmath2 hn model with @xmath144 . in this model we considered mixing - fallback as described in  2.1 .
when we do not consider the @xmath0-process , the [ sc / fe ] and [ mn / fe ] are @xmath145 and @xmath146 , respectively ( see also table 1 ) .
the mn / fe ratio is much smaller than the corresponding ratios in the other two models .
mn is mainly produced in the si / s layer without the @xmath0-process ( see fig .
3@xmath105 ) , whereas the range of the ni layer in the hn is larger than in the 25 @xmath2 sn . on the other hand , the co / fe is larger than those in the other sn models ( see also table 1 ) . as shown in fig .
3@xmath105 , the hn provides a large amount of co through complete si burning .
the mass fraction of co in the ni layer is of order @xmath147 for the 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 sn models , and @xmath148 for the 25 @xmath2 hn .
when we consider the @xmath0-process , the abundance ratios of sc and mn increase with the total neutrino energy .
however , the co abundance scarcely changes even taking into account the @xmath0-process .
the @xmath0-process raises the abundances of sc and mn in the ni layer .
although it also enhances the co abundance there , the contribution from the @xmath0-process is hindered by large co production through complete si burning .
we also compare our results with the observed ones .
the obtained sc / fe ratio is smaller than the observed ratio . even in the case of the largest neutrino irradiation , the abundance ratio is smaller by about 0.5 dex .
the mn / fe ratio is marginally consistent with the observed ratio in the largest neutrino irradiation case . at the same time , the co / fe ratio is also marginally consistent with the observed ratio despite the @xmath0-process ; the smallest co / fe ratio is reproduced .
the hn model reproduces the observed mn / fe ratio when the @xmath0-process with large neutrino irradiation is taken into account .
it reproduces the observed co / fe ratio even without the @xmath0-process .
when we do not consider the @xmath0-process , the abundance ratios of sc / fe , mn / fe , and co / fe in the pop iii sne are smaller than the corresponding observed ratios . on the other hand ,
the observed mn / fe ratio is reproduced by the 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 sn models with the @xmath0-process .
the observed co / fe ratio is marginally reproduced by the 25 @xmath2 hn model even without neutrino irradiation .
thus , we can say that the @xmath0-process in the pop iii sne produce most of mn observed in low mass emp stars .
the @xmath0-process also produces sc but the abundance is still short of the reproduction of the observed sc / fe ratios .
hne may provide co being abundant enough to reproduce the observed co / fe ratios .
we briefly mention the abundance ratios in the case of the @xmath0-process with @xmath47 mev and @xmath48 ergs , which has been adopted in @xcite .
the abundance patterns in the 15 and 25 @xmath2 sn and the 25 @xmath2 hn models are shown as dotted lines in figs .
the values of [ sc / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , and [ co / fe ] are tabulated in table 1 .
the yields of sc , mn , and co in this neutrino parameter set are larger by about 0.1 dex than those in the case of @xmath45 mev .
they are still smaller than those in the case of @xmath45 mev and @xmath150 ergs .
therefore , the dependence on the neutrino temperature is not strong for the sc , mn , and co yields .
the abundance pattern of vmp stars are considered to reflect partly mixed interstellar materials in the early universe .
recently , the averaged abundance pattern of vmp stars with @xmath11 < -2.0 $ ] in @xcite has been reproduced by the pop iii sn and hn yields integrated over the salpeter imf function @xcite . however , the evaluated [ sc / fe ] and [ mn / fe ] are still short of the observed ratio .
we discuss the enhancement of these ratios by the @xmath0-process .
@xcite evaluated the sc / fe ratio as [ sc / fe ] = @xmath151 whereas the observed value is [ sc / fe ] = @xmath152 . in this study , we showed that the @xmath0-process raises the sc yield by 1.1 dex at the maximum .
however , this enhancement is still short for reproducing the observed value .
production sites other than the @xmath0-process is needed to reproduce it ( see  5.2 ) .
the [ mn / fe ] ratio observed in vmp stars is @xmath153 .
the evaluated value of [ mn / fe ] is @xmath154 .
when we take into account the @xmath0-process , this value increases by @xmath155 dex with @xmath48 ergs and @xmath156 dex with @xmath150 ergs .
the increase by the @xmath0-process with @xmath157 ergs will provide better fitting of the pop iii sn and hn yields to [ mn / fe ] in vmp stars .
the pop iii sn and hn models in @xcite indicate [ co / fe ] close to the lowest ratio in vmp stars ; [ co / fe ] = @xmath158 . taking into account the @xmath0-process with @xmath48 ergs ,
[ co / fe ] increases by @xmath159 dex in sne and it does not in hne .
this enhancement is enough to reproduce the average [ co / fe ] ratio in vmp stars .
the @xmath0-process of the pop iii sne and hne is one of the preferable sites of the mn and co in vmp stars .
we have shown that sc , mn , and co are produced through the @xmath0-process in the pop iii sne and hne . for other than mn , the @xmath0-process in the sne and hne does not produce large enough abundances to reproduce the abundances observed in low mass emp stars .
so , we will discuss other synthesis processes proposed in recent studies .
[ [ sc-1 ] ] sc ^^    _ aspherical explosions _    as shown in previous studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , spherically symmetrical sn and hn models do not provide enough amount of sc to reproduce the observed abundance of low mass emp stars . on the other hand , aspherical
explosion and jet - like explosion produce larger amount of sc @xcite . in the case of spherical explosions
, low - density structure enables to supply larger amount of sc @xcite .
thus , higher temperature and low density , which are realized by aspherical explosions , are one of the favorable environments to produce sc .
the amount of sc produced in sne and hne is also sensitive to @xmath12 in complete si burning region .
large @xmath12 value ( @xmath160 ) brings about a large amount of sc @xcite .
_ nucleosynthesis in innermost region of sne _    detailed thermal evolution of the innermost region of sn ejecta , i.e. , the neighbor of the `` mass cut  has not been solved strictly .
however , recent progress of hydrodynamical calculations has gradually revealed thermal evolution in such a deep region . at the same time , detailed nucleosynthesis in such a deep region has also been investigated .
@xcite investigated the nucleosynthesis in convective bubbles in the innermost region of sn ejecta and in early stage of neutrino - driven winds .
they used results of two - dimensional hydrodynamical calculations by @xcite .
@xcite examined the simulations of one - dimensional self - consistent treatment of core - collapse sne with modified neutrino cross sections to explode .
they also investigated the nucleosynthesis in the innermost region just above the mass cut produced self - consistently .
both of the studies showed that the electron fraction @xmath12 exceeds 0.5 in such regions , which enhances the production of sc . in the latter study , they took into account all charged - current weak - interactions that changes @xmath12 in the ejecta .
they obtained that the amount of sc with @xmath161 is produced in the innermost region with @xmath160 .
the sc / fe ratio evaluated in their study is slightly smaller than the averaged abundances observed in low mass emp stars @xcite .
thus , the sc / fe ratio is larger than our result .
they also showed that a significant amount of nuclei with mass of @xmath162 in this region , especially light @xmath163-nuclei such as @xmath164mo and @xmath165ru ( the @xmath166-process ; * ? ? ? * ) .
it is noted that the region of @xmath160 is convectively unstable so that the region will mix with outer smaller @xmath12 region in dynamical time scale .
however , they expected that the @xmath12 remains high in an average sense .
indeed , the former study took into account the convection in two - dimensional simulations and obtained @xmath160 .
we also note that neutral - current @xmath0-process reactions were not included in @xcite .
they also pointed out that neutrino - induced spallation reactions can change the final abundances of some nuclei .
we expect that these reactions enhance the abundance of sc and that the sc / fe ratio becomes close to the observed ratio .    it is also noted that materials blown off in neutrino - driven winds in early time after a sn explosion can achieve large @xmath12 value .
accordingly , the @xmath167-process can take place in the materials .
this synthetic process is strongly preferable for the production of the light @xmath163-nuclei @xcite .
however , the contribution of the @xmath167-process in neutrino - driven winds to sc production is small .
[ [ mn-1 ] ] mn ^^    the amount of mn produced in sne and hne is strongly sensitive to electron fraction @xmath12 in incomplete si burning region @xcite .
their hn models modifying @xmath12 value to @xmath168 produce enough amount of mn to reproduce the observed one in low mass emp stars . however , hn models , whose @xmath12 in incomplete si burning region is not modified , indicated that the amount of mn is less than the observed value .
aspherical explosions suppress mn production @xcite .
we have shown that the mn production during sn explosions is mainly due to the @xmath0-process rather than to the incomplete si burning .
the @xmath0-process with normal neutrino irradiation ( @xmath48 ergs ) in sne reproduces the mn / fe ratio averaged in low mass emp stars even without @xmath12 modifications . in the case of @xmath150 ergs
, the mn amount marginally reproduces the upper limit of the observed mn abundance . in the case of @xmath51 ergs , however , the sn models overproduce mn .
thus , the @xmath0-process in the pop iii sne is one of the main production processes of mn observed in low mass emp stars .
the observed abundance constrains the total neutrino energy @xmath169 in sne .
the observational constraint is @xmath170 ergs .
[ [ co-1 ] ] co
^^    a large amount of co can be produced through complete si burning in aspherical explosion @xcite .
for spherical explosions , @xcite pointed out that the co abundance is significantly enhanced for @xmath160 in the case of hne .
however , the co / fe ratio in @xcite is still smaller than the observed ratio in @xcite .
their model corresponds to a normal sn explosion .
therefore , hne ( @xmath171 ) with @xmath172 produce co of which amount reproduces observed co / fe ratio in low mass emp stars .
neutral - current @xmath0-process reactions may help additional production in the deep region just above the mass cut .
however , in the case of hne , large amount of protons are also produced through @xmath17-rich freeze out .
this effect may hinder the proton production by the @xmath0-process .
the nucleosynthesis in pop iii sne have been conducted in several groups . here
, we briefly compare with the abundances of sc , mn , and co of 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 pop iii sn models in @xcite , hereafter abbreviated to ww95 , ( z15a and z25b models ) and in @xcite , abbreviated to cl04 .
the sn nucleosynthesis models in ww95 include the @xmath0-process .
the temperature of @xmath41 in ww95 is assumed to be 8 mev , which is larger than the one adopted in this study .
the sn nucleosynthesis with updated physics inputs of ww95 has been shown in @xcite but the pop iii sn nucleosynthesis has not been calculated .
the nucleosynthesis models in cl04 do not include the @xmath0-process .
the explosion models in cl04 were set to be the ejected mass of @xmath24ni equal to 0.1 @xmath2 .
@xcite indicate [ sc / fe]=@xmath98 for @xmath173 model ; the sc / fe is much larger than our result .
on the other hand , cl04 indicates sc / fe slightly larger than our results of sn models without the @xmath0-process ( [ sc / fe]=@xmath174 for 25 @xmath2 model ) .
although the sc / fe in ww95 is much larger than the other models , it is still smaller than the observed ratio . therefore , other synthesis processes such as discussed above are necessary for sc production .
the mn / fe shown in ww95 is smaller than the observed ratio ( [ mn / fe]@xmath175 ) . the 15 @xmath2 model in cl04 also indicates the mn / fe smaller than the observed one ( [ mn / fe]@xmath176 ) .
the 25 @xmath2 model in cl04 indicates larger mn / fe ratio , which is comparable to the observed one ( [ mn / fe]@xmath177 ) .
we showed that the @xmath0-process increases the mn abundance , but difference of stellar evolution models may affect the abundance .
the 15 @xmath2 models of ww95 and cl04 show [ co / fe ] of @xmath178 and @xmath179 , which are larger than the ratio of our sn models .
their 25 @xmath2 models indicate the co / fe similar to our results without the @xmath0-process .
the evaluated co / fe ratios are still short of the observed ratio , so that hne will have an important role for co production in the early universe .        among li ,
be , and b , @xmath180li and @xmath181b are mainly produced through the @xmath0-process .
when the @xmath0-process is not considered , the li / fe and b / fe ratios are much smaller than the corresponding solar ratio .
sn explosions with the neutrinos of @xmath182 ergs bring about li yield ratio of [ li / fe ] @xmath183 .
they also produce b of which yield ratio to fe is larger than the solar ratio . therefore , sn explosions may contribute to the b production in the early universe .
the @xmath180li is mainly produced as @xmath180be in the he - rich region .
the @xmath181b is produced as @xmath181c and @xmath181b in c - enriched oxygen layer and c - enriched he layer .
the li and b production in hne is less effective than that in sne .
higher maximum temperature in the he layer decomposes @xmath180be and @xmath181c produced through the @xmath0-process and the following @xmath17-captures .
in addition , strong explosion makes the region of c - rich oxygen layer small .
[ [ f ] ] f ^    the @xmath0-process is a main f production process in sne @xcite .
the f / fe ratio including the @xmath0-process is much larger than the one without the @xmath0-process .
the seed nucleus of f in the @xmath0-process is @xmath184ne .
most of f is produced in o and ne - enriched region .
stellar mass dependence of the f / fe ratio is small in the sn models . on the other hand ,
the hn model shows smaller f / fe ratio .
the hn explosion brings about stronger explosive ne burning , so that the o and ne - enriched region becomes smaller .
figures @xmath149 show that the @xmath0-process scarcely affects the yields of na and al .
furthermore , the yield ratios are much smaller than the observed ratios even in the case of the largest neutrino irradiation .
although the @xmath0-process enhances the abundances of na and al in incomplete si burning region , na and al are mainly produced in carbon and neon shells .
the yields produced in the outer two shells strongly depend on the nucleosynthesis in stellar evolution . @xcite
successfully reproduced relatively large [ na / fe ] and [ al / fe ] observed in two hyper - metal - poor stars .
they considered that the effect of overshooting during presn evolution and extensive matter mixing and fallback during sn explosions with small explosion energies .
[ [ v ] ] v ^    vanadium is mainly produced as @xmath185mn in incomplete si burning region in sne . in the case of the hn model
, it is mainly produced in complete si burning region .
additional production through the @xmath0-process from @xmath186fe in incomplete si burning region contributes to the enhancement of v in sne .
low metallicity stars with @xmath187 } \la -2 $ ] indicate the v abundance ratios of @xmath188 } \la 0.6 $ ] ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the average abundance ratio is reproduced by the 15 and 25 @xmath2 sn models with the @xmath0-process of @xmath189 ergs . in order to reproduce the v / fe ratios , strong neutrino irradiation in the sne
is favored . in the case of the hn model
, v is also produced through the @xmath0-process .
however , the produced abundance is much smaller than that produced in complete si burning region .
the chemical compositions of low mass emp stars are expected to be injected from one or a few sn or hn explosions evolved from population iii massive stars .
the abundance ratios of odd-@xmath1 elements to fe observed in these stars are close to the corresponding solar ratios . on the other hand ,
the abundances produced in complete and incomplete si burning in sn explosion models are still in short . in this study
, we investigated the @xmath0-process of odd-@xmath1 iron - peak elements , sc , mn , and co , in the sn and hn explosions of 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 pop iii stars .
then , we compared the abundance ratios of these elements in the sn and hn models with those observed in the emp stars .
the obtained results are summarized as follows .
1 .   sc , mn , and co are produced through the @xmath0-process and the following capture reactions of protons and neutrons in complete and incomplete si burning region of pop iii sne .
the produced amounts of these elements are roughly proportional to the total neutrino energy .
2 .   the observed mn / fe ratio averaged in low mass emp stars is reproduced by the 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 pop iii sn models with the @xmath0-process .
therefore , the @xmath0-process in pop iii sne is one of the main synthesis processes of mn observed in low mass emp stars .
the observed mn abundance constrains the total neutrino energy to @xmath170 ergs .
this @xmath169 value is roughly consistent with the gravitational binding energy of a typical neutron star . in the case of the 25 @xmath2 pop iii hn model ,
large neutrino irradiation enables to reproduce the observed mn / fe ratio .
3 .   the observed co / fe ratio is reproduced by the sn models . however , required total neutrino energy is @xmath190 ergs , which is larger than typical value of the gravitational binding energy of a proto - neutron star .
complete si burning in pop iii hne should be favorable to co production rather than the @xmath0-process of sne and hne .
although larger amount of sc is produced through the @xmath0-process , the sc / fe ratio is still smaller than the ratio observed in low mass emp stars .
explosive nucleosynthesis during aspherical explosions and in a deep region just above the mass cut would be favorable to produce sc and co. the @xmath0-process and the capture reactions of protons and neutrons may also enhance the production of sc , mn , and co in these environments .
we would like to thank anonymous referee for valuable comments .
numerical computations were in part carried out on general common use computer system at astronomical data analysis center ( adac ) of national astronomical observatory of japan .
this work has been supported in part by the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology , grants - in - aid for young scientist ( b ) ( 17740130 ) , and scientific research ( s ) ( 18104003 ) , ( c ) ( 16540229 , 18540231 ) .
t.y . was supported by the 21st century coe program `` exploring new science by bridging particle - matter hierarchy  in graduate school of science , tohoku university .
argast , d. , samland , m. , gerhard , o. e. , & thielemann , f .- k .
2004 , , 356 , 873 cayrel , r. , et al .
2004 , , 416 , 1117 chieffi , a. & limongi , m. 2004 , , 608 , 405 colella , p. & woodward , p.
r. 1984 , j. comput .
phys . , 54 , 174 domogatsky , g. v. , eramzhyan , r. a. , & nadyozhin , d. k. 1978 , in neutrino physics and neutrino astrophysics , ed .
m. a. markov et al .
( moscow : nauka ) , 115 frhlich , c. , et al . 2006a , , 637 , 415 frhlich , c. , martnez - pinedo , g. , liebendrfer , m. , thielemann , f .- k .
, bravo , e. , hix , w. r. , langanke , k. , & zinner , n. t. 2006b , , 96 , 142502 goriely , s. , arnould , m. , borzov , i. , & rayet , m. 2001 , , 375 , l35 heger , a. , kolbe , e. , haxton , w. c. , langanke , k. , martnez - pinedo , g. , & woosley , s. e. 2005 , phys .
b , 606 , 258 hix , w. r. & thielemann , f .- k .
1996 , , 460 , 869 honda , s. , aoki , w. , kajino , t. , ando , h. , beers , t. c. , izumiura , h. sadakane , k. , & takada - hidai , m. 2004 , , 607 , 474 iwamoto , n. , umeda , h. , tominaga , n. , nomoto , k. , maeda , k. 2005 , science , 309 , 451 iwamoto , n. , umeda , h. , nomoto , k. , tominaga , n. , thielemann , f .- k . , &
hix , w. r. 2006 , in international symposium on the origin of matter and evolution of galaxies 2005 , ed .
s. kubono et al .
( san francisco : aip ) , 409 janka , h .- th . , buras , r. , & rampp , m. 2003 , nucl .
phys . a , 718 , 269 kobayashi , c. , umeda , h. , nomoto , k. , tominaga , n. , & ohkubo , t. 2006 , , 653 , 1145 kotake , k. , sawai , h. , yamada , s. , & sato , k. 2004 , , 608 , 391 lattimer , j. m. & prakash , m. 2001 , , 550 , 426 maeda , k. & nomoto , k. 2003 , , 598 , 1163 mclaughlin , g. c. & surman , r. 2007 , , 75 , 023005 nomoto , k. , tominaga , n. , umeda , h. , kobayashi , c. , & maeda , k. 2006 , nucl .
a777 , 424 norris , j. e. , ryan , s. g. , & beers , t. c. 2001 , , 561 , 1034 pruet , j. , hoffman , r. d. , woosley , s. e. , janka , h .-
buras , r. 2006 , , 644 , 1028 pruet , j. , woosley , s. e. , buras , r. , janka , h .-
t . , & hoffman , r. d. 2005 , , 623 , 325 rauscher , t. , heger , a. , hoffman , r. d. , & woosley , s. e. 2002 , , 576 , 323 scheck , l. , plewa , t. , janka , h .- th . , kifonidis , k. , & mller , e. 2004 , , 92 , 011103 shigeyama , t. & tsujimoto , t. 1998 , , 507 , l135 tominaga , n. , maeda , k. , umeda , h. , nomoto , k. , tanaka , m. , iwamoto , n. , suzuki , t. , & mazzali , p. 2007a
, , 657 , l77 tominaga , n. , umeda , h. , & nomoto , k. 2007b , , 660 , 516 tominaga , n. , et al .
2005 , , 633 , l97 umeda , h. & nomoto , k. 2002 , , 565 , 385 umeda , h. & nomoto , k. 2005 , , 619 , 427 wanajo , s. 2006 , , 647 , 1323 woosley , s. e. , hartmann , d. h. , hoffman , r. d. , & haxton , w. c. 1990 , , 356 , 272 woosley , s. e. & weaver , t. a. 1995 , , 101 , 181 yoshida , t. , kajino , t. , & hartmann , d. h. 2005a , , 94 , 231101 yoshida , t. , kajino , t. , yokomakura , h. , kimura , k. , takamura , a. , & hartmann , d. h. 2006a , , 649 , 319 yoshida , t. , kajino , t. , yokomakura , h. , kimura , k. , takamura , a. , & hartmann , d. h. 2006b , , 96 , 091101 yoshida , t. , terasawa , m. , kajino , t. , & sumiyoshi , k. 2004 , , 600 , 204 yoshida , t. , umeda , h. , & nomoto , k. 2005b , , 631 , 1039