high - energy heavy - ion collisions can produce a hot , dense , and deconfined nuclear medium , dubbed the quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) .
the thermodynamic states of a qgp can be specified by the axial chemical potential @xmath0 , besides the temperature @xmath1 and the vector chemical potential @xmath2 .
@xmath0 characterizes the imbalance of right - handed and left - handed fermions in a system , and a _ chiral _ system bears a nonzero @xmath0 .
chiral domains may be created locally in heavy - ion collisions through various mechanisms on an event - by - event basis ( e.g. topological fluctuations in the gluonic sector , glasma flux tubes , or fluctuations in the quark sector )  @xcite . in a noncentral collision , a strong magnetic field ( @xmath3  t )
can be produced ( mostly by energetic spectator protons )  @xcite , and will induce an electric current along @xmath4 in chiral domains , @xmath5 , which is called the chiral magnetic effect ( cme )  @xcite . on average , @xmath4 is perpendicular to the so - called reaction plane ( @xmath6 ) that contains the impact parameter and the beam momenta , as depicted in fig .  [
fig : overlap ] .
hence the cme will manifest a charge transport across the reaction plane .        in the presence of the cme and other modes of collective motions
, we can fourier decompose the azimuthal distribution of particles of given transverse momentum ( @xmath7 ) and pseudorapidity ( @xmath8 ) : 1 + 2v_1 , ( ) + 2v_2,(2 ) + ... + 2a_1 , ( ) + ... , [ equ : fourier_expansion ] where @xmath9 is the azimuthal angle of a particle , and @xmath10 . here the subscript @xmath11 ( @xmath12 or @xmath13 ) denotes the charge sign of the particle .
conventionally @xmath14 is called  directed flow " and @xmath15  elliptic flow "  @xcite .
the parameter @xmath16 ( with @xmath17 ) quantifies the electric charge separation due to the cme .
an anomalous transport effect can also occur when a chiral system undergoes a global rotation .
the fluid rotation can be quantified by a vorticity @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the flow velocity field . for a given vorticity @xmath20 , the chiral vortical effect ( cve )
induces a vector current @xmath21  @xcite .
while the cme is driven by @xmath4 , the cve is driven by @xmath22 in a chiral medium . here
the subscript
v " means  vector " , and can be , for example ,  @xmath23 " ( baryon ) or  @xmath24 " ( electron ) . in heavy - ion collisions , @xmath25 is typically larger than @xmath26 by an order of magnitude , making it easier to search for the cve via the baryonic charge separation than the electric charge separation .
hence the subscript @xmath11 in eq .
[ equ : fourier_expansion ] represents baryon or anti - baryon in the cve search .
another complementary transport phenomenon to the cme has been found and named the chiral separation effect ( cse )  @xcite , in which chiral charges are separated along the axis of the magnetic field in the presence of finite density of vector charge : @xmath27 . in a chirally symmetric phase , the cme and cse form a collective excitation , the chiral magnetic wave ( cmw ) , a long wavelength hydrodynamic mode of chiral charge densities  @xcite .
the cmw , a signature of the chiral symmetry restoration , manifests itself in a finite electric quadrupole moment of the collision system , where the  poles " (  equator " ) of the produced fireball acquire additional positive ( negative ) charge  @xcite .
this effect , if present , will be reflected in the measurements of charge - dependent elliptic flow .
there are other chiral magnetic / vortical effects such as the chiral electric separation effect ( cese )  @xcite and the chiral vortical wave ( cvw )  @xcite ; see ref  @xcite for a recent review on these effects .
this article reviews the experimental results in the past decade to search for the chiral magnetic / vortical effects in high - energy heavy - ion collisions : evidence for the initial magnetic field and vorticity in sec .
[ sec : drive ] , the observation of the electric ( baryonic ) charge separation in sec .
[ sec : cme ] ( sec .
[ sec : cve ] ) , and the manifestation of the electric quadrupole moment in sec .
[ sec : cmw ] .
an outlook for future development is discussed in sec .
[ sec : outlook ] .
we may intuitively regard the magnetic field ( vorticity ) as the driving force of the cme ( cve ) , while the chirality imbalance is the initial condition , and the electric ( baryonic ) charge separation is the manifestation .
a rough estimate of the initial magnetic field gives @xmath28 , where @xmath29 , @xmath30 is the impact parameter , and @xmath31 is the lorentz factor .
therefore a typical au+au collision at @xmath32 gev produces @xmath33 .
many computations have attempted to quantify the electromagnetic field on the event - by - event basis ( see e.g.  @xcite ) , in terms of the spatial distribution , the orientation fluctuation as well as the dependence on colliding nuclei , centrality and beam energy .
a major uncertainty in theoretical calculations of the magnetic field @xmath4 is its duration in the qcd fluid created in the heavy - ion collision ( see e.g.  @xcite ) .
the time dependence of @xmath4 after the impact of the two nuclei crucially depends on whether / when / how a conducting medium may form and the lifetime of the magnetic field may be elongated .
the electric conductivity  @xcite and the time evolution of the quark densities  @xcite can be studied via directed flow of charged hadrons in asymmetric collisions , such as cu+au .
figure  [ fig : cuau ] illustrates the transverse plane for a cu+au collision with @xmath34 fm  @xcite .
the difference in the number of protons creates a strong electric field in the initial stage of the collision , pointing along the arrow in the figure .
the lifetime of the electric field might be very short ( e.g. @xmath35 fm/@xmath36 from ref .
@xcite ) , but the electric charges from quarks and antiquarks that are present in the early stage of the collision would experience the coulomb force and lift the degeneracy in @xmath14 between positively and negatively charged particles  @xcite : v_1^ = v_1 d_e , where @xmath37 denotes the azimuthal angle of the electric field , and the coefficient @xmath38 characterizes the strength of dipole deformation induced by the electric field and is proportional to the electric conductivity of the medium . here
@xmath14 represents the rapidity - even component of directed flow that is dominant in asymmetric collisions , while in symmetric collisions @xmath14 conventionally denotes the rapidity - odd component .     of positive and negative particles and the difference between the two as functions of @xmath7 in @xmath39 cu+au and au+au collisions  @xcite .
the phsd model calculations  @xcite for charged pions with and without the initial electric field ( ef ) are presented for comparison . ]     of positive and negative particles and the difference between the two as functions of @xmath7 in @xmath39 cu+au and au+au collisions  @xcite .
the phsd model calculations  @xcite for charged pions with and without the initial electric field ( ef ) are presented for comparison . ]
figure  [ fig : v1 ] shows recent star measurements of charge - dependent @xmath40 and the difference @xmath41 as functions of @xmath7 in @xmath39 cu+au and au+au collisions  @xcite . for @xmath42 gev/@xmath36 , @xmath41 seems to increase with @xmath7 .
the @xmath40 results from au+au collisions have much smaller values , roughly by a factor of 10 , than those in cu+au .
note that @xmath43 in au+au collisions is similarly small  @xcite .
@xmath41 in au+au is consistent with zero .
calculations for charged pions from the parton - hadron - string - dynamics ( phsd ) model  @xcite , which is a dynamical transport approach in the partonic and hadronic phases , are compared with the data .
the phsd model calculates two cases : charge - dependent @xmath40 with and without the initial electric field ( ef ) . in the case with
the ef switched on , the model assumes that all electric charges are affected by the ef and this results in a large separation of @xmath40 between positive and negative particles as shown in fig .
[ fig : v1](a ) . in fig .
[ fig : v1](b ) , the calculations of the @xmath40 with and without the ef are shown together , but note that the ef - on calculation points are scaled by @xmath44 .
after scaling by @xmath44 , the model describes rather well the @xmath7 dependence of the measured data for @xmath42 gev/@xmath36 .
this qualitative evidence for the strong initial electric field in asymmetric collisions provides an indirect evidence for the strong initial magnetic field in heavy - ion collisions that could leave an imprint on the final - stage particles .
the vorticity is induced by the global rotation of the qgp in heavy - ion collisions . in a noncentral collision
, the majority of the global angular momentum , @xmath45 , is carried away by spectator nucleons . however , a considerable fraction ( about @xmath46 of @xmath45 could remain in the qgp and be approximately conserved in time  @xcite .
this implies a relatively long duration of the vortical effects . on average
, the angular momentum is pointing in the out - of - plane direction , so the cme and cve are very much alike in terms of their experimental observables . attempts to computate local vorticity @xmath20 and its space - time distribution have also been made  @xcite .
experimentally global polarization of hyperons such as @xmath47 provides a measure for both the plasma vorticity and the magnetic field . whereas the vortical effects will generate a positive polarization for both @xmath47 and @xmath48 , the coupling of the hadronic magnetic dipole moment to the magnetic field will generate a positive contribution for @xmath47 and a negative one for @xmath48 .
therefore , a splitting between @xmath47 and @xmath48 polarization will be a direct evidence for the strong initial magnetic field .
recently , preliminary star measurements  @xcite have reported the first observation of global @xmath47 and @xmath48 polarization in heavy - ion collisions . at @xmath49 gev ,
the signal is on the order of a few percent , and displays a weak beam - energy dependence .
the average polarization over @xmath47 and @xmath48 evidences the plasma vorticity , while the splitting observation requires much higher statistics to be delivered in the second beam energy scan ( bes - ii ) program at rhic  @xcite to signify the magnetic field .
the future search for evidence for the initial magnetic field ( vorticity ) is proposed via photon ( vector meson ) polarization measurements  @xcite .
the initial magnetic helicity ( @xmath50 ) of the collision system can be quite large and bears opposite signs in the upper and lower hemispheres .
owing to the chiral anomaly , the helicity can be transferred back and forth between the magnetic flux and fermions as the collision system evolves , so that the magnetic helicity could last long enough to yield photons with opposite circular polarizations in the hemispheres above and below the rp  @xcite . a similar asymmetry in photon polarization
can also result from the initial global quark polarization  @xcite , which could effectively lead to a polarization of photons  @xcite .
this local imbalance of photon circular polarization could be observed in experiments , e.g. , by studying the polarization preference with respect to the rp for photons that convert into @xmath51 pairs  @xcite .
similarly , vector mesons that decay into two daughters can also have their polarization preferences measured with the scheme outlined in ref .
@xcite , and the helicity separation in this case originates from vorticity  @xcite .
the discovery of the cme in high - energy heavy - ion collisions would confirm the simultaneous existence of ultra - strong magnetic fields , chiral symmetry restoration and topological charge changing transitions .
the experimental searches for the cme have been carried out extensively in the past decade at rhic and the lhc .
this section will introduce the observables pertinent to the electric charge separation induced by the cme , present the experimental results and discuss the background contributions due to the coupling of elliptic flow and other physics mechanisms .      from event to event ,
the signs of the @xmath0 values are equally likely , and the signs of finite @xmath52 and @xmath53 will flip accordingly , leading to @xmath54 .
figure  [ fig : a1 ] presents the star measurements of @xmath55 with the @xmath56 harmonic event plane reconstructed from spectator neutrons  @xcite .
these results indicate no significant charge dependence in all centrality intervals , with the typical difference between positive and negative charges less than @xmath57 .     for positive and negative charges versus centrality for au+au collisions at @xmath58 gev  @xcite .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ]    one therefore has to search for the cme with charge - separation _ fluctuations _ perpendicular to the reaction plane , e.g. , with a three - point correlator  @xcite , @xmath59 , where the averaging is done over all particles in an event and over all events . in practice ,
the reaction plane is approximated with the  event plane " ( @xmath60 ) reconstructed with measured particles , and then the measurement is corrected for the finite event plane resolution .
the expansion of the @xmath31 correlator , @xmath61 reveals the difference between the _ in - plane _ and _ out - of - plane _ projections of the correlations .
the first term ( @xmath62 ) in the expansion provides a baseline unrelated to the magnetic field . the background contribution ( @xmath63 )
is suppressed to a level close to the magnitude of @xmath15  @xcite .
the star collaboration first measured the @xmath31 correlator with the @xmath64 harmonic event plane for au+au ( shown with crosses in fig .
[ fig : gamma ] ) and cu+cu ( not shown here ) collisions at @xmath65 and @xmath66 gev with data from the 2004/2005 rhic runs  @xcite .
all the results have been found to be in qualitative expectation with the cme : the opposite - charge ( @xmath67 ) and the same - charge ( @xmath68 ) correlations display the  right " ordering .
the opposite - charge correlations in cu+cu collisions are stronger than those in au+au , possibly reflecting the suppression of the correlations among oppositely moving particles in a larger system .
star also presented @xmath7 and @xmath69 dependences of the signal .
the signal has a @xmath69 width of about one unit of rapidity , consistent with small chiral domains .
the signal is found to increase with the pair average @xmath7 , and it was later shown  @xcite that the radial flow expansion can explain this feature .
similar @xmath31 results for 200 gev au+au and 2.76 tev pb+pb were observed by the phenix collaboration  @xcite and the alice collaboration  @xcite , respectively .
phenix also employed a multiparticle charge - sensitive correlator , @xmath70  @xcite , and their preliminary results showed a concave @xmath70 distribution , also evidencing the charge separation effect .
the background from conventional physics was studied with heavy - ion event generators mevsim  @xcite , urqmd  @xcite and hijing  @xcite ( with and without an elliptic flow afterburner implemented ) .
none of these generators could achieve reasonable agreement with the data .
however , these generators do not provide particularly good descriptions of heavy - ion collisions , so the fact that they fail to describe such subtle effects as charge separation provides only somewhat limited support for a cme interpretation of the data .
gev  @xcite .
the grey bars reflect the conditions of @xmath71 gev/@xmath36 and @xmath72 applied to @xmath31 . ]
gev  @xcite .
the grey bars reflect the conditions of @xmath71 gev/@xmath36 and @xmath72 applied to @xmath31 . ]
the charge - separation signal was cross - checked with data from the 2007 rhic run ( shown in fig .
[ fig : gamma ] )  @xcite .
the @xmath31 correlations from these data were measured with respect to both the @xmath56 harmonic event plane ( of spectators at large rapidity ) and the @xmath64 harmonic event planes at mid - rapidity .
using the @xmath56 harmonic event plane determined by spectator neutrons ensures that the signal is not coming from three - particle background correlations , and is due to genuine correlations to the reaction plane .
another test was carried out by replacing one of the two charged particles in @xmath31 with a neutral particle , e.g. @xmath73 , and the results show no separation between @xmath74 and @xmath75  @xcite .
thus the charge separation observed in the @xmath31 correlation between two charged particles is indeed due to the electric charge .
femtoscopic correlations are visible in the differential measurements of @xmath31 at low relative momenta , which are related to quantum interference (  hbt " ) and final - state - interactions ( coulomb dominated )  @xcite .
the difference between in - plane and out - of - plane correlations in the femtoscopic region can be due to a difference in the emission volumes probed by in- and out - of - plane parts
. such a difference may arrise from an azimuthally anisotropic freeze - out distribution coupled with flow . to suppress the contribution from femtoscopic correlations ,
the conditions of @xmath71 gev/@xmath36 and @xmath72 were applied to the three - point correlator , shown with the grey bars in fig .
[ fig : msc ] . excluding pairs with low relative momenta significantly reduces the positive contributions to opposite - charge correlations in peripheral collisions , but the difference between same- and opposite - charge correlations remains largely unchanged and consistent with the expectations of the cme .
the @xmath31 correlator weights different azimuthal regions of charge separation differently , i.e.  oppositely charged pairs emitted azimuthally at @xmath76 from the event plane ( maximally out - of - plane ) are weighted more heavily than those emitted only a few degrees from the event plane ( minimally out - of - plane ) .
it is a good test to modify the @xmath31 correlator such that all azimuthal regions of charge separation are weighted identically .
this may be done by first rewriting eq .
[ eq : threepoint ] as ( _ + _ -2_rp ) = ( m_m_s_s_)_in - ( m_m_s_s_)_out , [ eq : mmss ] where @xmath77 and @xmath78 stand for the absolute magnitude ( @xmath79 ) and the sign ( @xmath80 ) of the sine or cosine function , respectively .
in represents the cosine part of eq .
[ eq : threepoint ] ( in - plane ) and out represents the sine part ( out - of - plane )
. a modulated sign correlation ( msc ) is obtained by reducing the @xmath31 correlator  @xcite : ( ) ^2(s_s _ _ in - s_s__out ) .
[ eq : msc ] the modulated sign correlations are compared with the three - point correlator for au+au collisions at 200 gev in fig .  [
fig : msc ] .
it is evident that the msc is able to reproduce the same trend as the three - point correlator although their magnitudes differ slightly .
star also carried out another approach called the charge multiplicity asymmetry correlation ( cmac ) , whose methodology is similar to the msc , and yielded very similar results  @xcite .    .
charge independent results from the model calculations of mevsim  @xcite are shown as grey curves . ]
a further understanding of the origin of the observed charge separation could be achieved with a study of the beam - energy dependence of the correlation .
the charge separation effect depends strongly on the formation of the quark gluon plasma and chiral symmetry restoration  @xcite , and the signal can be greatly suppressed or completely absent at low collision energies where a qgp has significantly shortened lifetime or not even formed .
taking into account that the lifetime of the strong magnetic field is larger at smaller collision energies , this could lead to an almost threshold effect : with decreasing collision energy , the signal might slowly increase with an abrupt drop thereafter .
unfortunately , the exact energy dependence of the cme is not calculated yet .
figure  [ fig : lpv_bes ] presents @xmath67 and @xmath68 correlators as functions of centrality for au+au collisions at @xmath81 gev measured by star  @xcite , and for pb+pb collisions at 2.76 tev by alice  @xcite . in most cases , the difference between @xmath67 and @xmath68 is still present with the  right " ordering , manifesting extra charge - separation fluctuations perpendicular to the reaction plane . with decreased beam energy ,
both @xmath67 and @xmath68 tend to rise up starting from peripheral collisions .
this feature seems to be charge independent , and can be explained by momentum conservation and elliptic flow  @xcite .
momentum conservation forces all produced particles , regardless of charge , to separate from each other , while elliptic flow works in the opposite sense . for peripheral collisions ,
the multiplicity ( @xmath82 ) is small , and momentum conservation dominates .
the lower beam energy , the smaller @xmath82 , and the higher @xmath67 and @xmath68 . for more central collisions where the multiplicity is large enough
, this type of charge - independent background can be estimated with @xmath83  @xcite .
mevsim is a monte carlo event generator developed for star simulations  @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : lpv_bes ] , we also show the model calculations of mevsim with the implementation of @xmath15 and momentum conservation , which qualitatively describe the beam - energy dependence of the charge - independent background .
the difference between @xmath67 and @xmath68 seems to vanish at low collision energies , but the interpretation involves an ambiguity to be discussed in the sec  [ sec : kappa ] .
the @xmath31 correlator by construction contains the background terms @xmath84 and @xmath85 , and their difference was originally studied for the  flowing cluster " case  @xcite : v_2,cl , where @xmath86 is the cluster emission azimuthal angle , and @xmath87 and @xmath88 are the azimuthal angles of two decay products .
the flowing cluster can be generalized to a larger portion of or even the whole event , through the mechanisms of transverse momentum conservation ( tmc )  @xcite and/or local charge conservation ( lcc )  @xcite .
one useful tool to study the background is the two - particle correlator , @xmath89 , which ideally should be protortional to @xmath90 , but in reality is dominated by backgrounds . for example , the tmc effect leads to the following pertinent correlation terms in @xmath91 and @xmath31  @xcite : & & - , + & & - + & & v_2 , , where @xmath92 , and @xmath93 and @xmath94 represent the @xmath7- and @xmath95-weighted moments of @xmath15 , respectively . the subscript
f " denotes an average of all produced particles in the full phase space ; the actual measurements will be only in a fraction of the full space , denoted by
@xmath96 " .
the background contribution due to the lcc effect has a similar characteristic structure as the above  @xcite .
it is convenient to express @xmath31 and @xmath91 with a two - component framework  @xcite : & & = v_2 b - h , + & & = b + h , where @xmath97 and @xmath23 are the cme and background contributions , respectively . the background - subtracted correlator , @xmath97 , can be obtained from the ensemble averages of several observables : h^= ( v_2 - ) /(1+v_2 ) . the major uncertainty in the above expression , the coefficient @xmath98 , depends on particle charge combination and particle transverse momentum .
it may also depend on centrality and collision energy , reflecting slightly different particle production mechanism in different conditions .     as a function of beam energy for @xmath99 au+au ( pb+pb ) collisions  @xcite .
the systematic errors ( grey bars ) bear the same meaning as in fig .  [
fig : msc ] . ]     as a function of beam energy for @xmath99 au+au ( pb+pb ) collisions  @xcite .
the systematic errors ( grey bars ) bear the same meaning as in fig .
[ fig : msc ] . ]
figure  [ fig : kappa ] shows the @xmath98 values estimated for au+au collisions at 200 gev  @xcite , with the @xmath15 measurements by the phobos collaboration  @xcite , and with the @xmath15 calculations from the ampt model  @xcite . here only the tmc effect has been taken in account , and @xmath98 is typically within @xmath100 $ ] for @xmath101 .
the @xmath98 values attained this way will vary slightly if a smaller @xmath102 acceptance is involved . in reality , @xmath98 should be averaged over various mechanisms such as tmc , lcc and resonance decays .
the ampt model gives a more comprehensive estimate in fig .
[ fig : kappa ] via @xmath103 , where the numerator is solely due to flow backgrounds . for the centrality range of @xmath104 , where the statistical uncertainties are small
, the @xmath98 values thus obtained are close to those estimated with the @xmath15 information .    figure  [ fig : h_bes ] shows @xmath105 as a function of beam energy for @xmath99 au+au ( pb+pb ) collisions  @xcite .
@xmath106 is depicted with the solid line . in both cases of @xmath98
, @xmath107 demonstrates a weak energy dependence above 19.6 gev , and tends to diminish from 19.6 to 7.7 gev , though the statistical errors are large for 7.7 gev .
this may be explained by the probable domination of hadronic interactions over partonic ones at low energies .
a more definitive conclusion may be reached with a more accurate estimation of @xmath98 and with higher statistics at lower energies in the proposed phase ii of the rhic beam energy scan program , as illustrated by the shaded band in fig .  [
fig : h_bes ] .     as a function of @xmath15 for various centrality selections within the @xmath108 centrality range in u+u collisions ( left ) and au+au collisions ( right ) .
@xcite ]     as a function of @xmath15 for various centrality selections within the @xmath108 centrality range in u+u collisions ( left ) and au+au collisions ( right ) .
@xcite ]    uranium nuclei have been collided at rhic in order to study the dependence of multiplicity production , flow , and the cme on the initial overlap geometry  @xcite .
early ideas hold that the prolate shape of uranium nuclei would make it possible to select nearly fully overlapping events with large elliptic flow values , but with small magnetic fields
. however , owing to fluctuations , the square of the magnetic field is not particularly small .
measurements of very central collisions also demonstrated that the number of produced particles does not depend as strongly on the configuration of the collisions as anticipated in the two - component multiplicity model , leaving the experiments with a significantly reduced ability to independently manipulate the flow and the magnetic field  @xcite .
figure  [ fig : gamma_v2 ] shows measurements of @xmath109 for the @xmath108 centrality range in 193 gev u+u ( left ) and 200 gev au+au collisions ( right )  @xcite . in both u+u and au+au collisions , the signal increases roughly with @xmath15 .
this initial observation may suggest that the charge - separation observable is dominated by a @xmath15 dependence .
however , the charge separation goes to zero while @xmath15 is still sizable in central au+au and central u+u collisions .
model calculations show that the quantity @xmath110}$ ] as a function of eccentricity exhibits the same trend  @xcite : although @xmath111 remains large owing to fluctuations , @xmath112}$ ] goes to zero as @xmath113 and @xmath6 become decorrelated in very central collisions .
so while fluctuations in central collisions force the participant eccentricity ( positive - definite ) away from zero , the decorrelation of @xmath113 and @xmath6 drives @xmath110}$ ] to zero .
the data therefore appear to be in better agreement with a cme interpretation than a flow background interpretation .
a phenomenological study for extrapolating both signal and background from au+au to u+u collisions was done in ref .
@xcite .
another measurement that can clarify the origin of the charge - dependent correlations and the role of the background was suggested  @xcite : the correlations measured with respect to the @xmath114 harmonic event plane , @xmath115 , should not contain any contribution from the cme , but it should include the effect of the flow - related background . the correlations due to the background in this case are expected to be somewhat smaller in magnitude as the @xmath114 harmonic flow is not that strong as the elliptic flow .
the preliminary results of such measurements by alice are presented in fig .
[ fig:4th - harmonic ]  @xcite with the same - charge and opposite - charge pair correlations relative to the @xmath114 harmonic event plane as functions of centrality ( left ) , and the charge - dependent parts with respect to the @xmath64 and @xmath114 harmonic event planes ( right ) .
the correlations relative to the @xmath114 harmonic event plane are very weak and suggestive of small background contributions .
detailed simulations have to be performed to draw more definite conclusion from this measurement .
harmonic event plane as functions of centrality .
( right panel ) comparison of the charge - dependent parts in correlations with respect to the @xmath64 and @xmath114 harmonic event planes .
@xcite ]     harmonic event plane as functions of centrality .
( right panel ) comparison of the charge - dependent parts in correlations with respect to the @xmath64 and @xmath114 harmonic event planes .
the chiral vortical effect ( cve ) is related to the cme , and its experimental manifestation is the baryonic charge separation , instead of the electric charge separation , perpendicular to the reaction plane . as a result ,
the three - point @xmath31 correlator is still applicable , only now between two ( anti)baryons .
however , if both particles are ( anti)protons that carry also electric charges , there will be an ambiguity due to the possible signal arising from the cme .
the study of the @xmath31 correlator with an electrically neutral baryon , such as @xmath47 , will provide more conclusive evidence for the baryonic charge separation effect .
correlation of @xmath47-@xmath116 ( @xmath48-@xmath117 ) and @xmath47-@xmath117 ( @xmath48-@xmath116 ) as functions of centrality in au+au collisions at 200 gev  @xcite . ]
correlation of @xmath47-@xmath116 ( @xmath48-@xmath117 ) and @xmath47-@xmath117 ( @xmath48-@xmath116 ) as functions of centrality in au+au collisions at 200 gev  @xcite . ]
although ( anti)@xmath47 s are electrically neutral , it is still a question whether the strange quarks behave the same way as the up / down quarks in the chiral dynamics during the collision .
if the answer is no , then ( anti)@xmath47 s may still act like electrically charged particles in the @xmath31 correlation .
figure  [ fig : lambda_h ] shows the @xmath31 correlation of @xmath47-@xmath118 ( @xmath48-@xmath119 ) and @xmath47-@xmath119 ( @xmath48-@xmath118 ) as functions of centrality in au+au collisions at 200 gev  @xcite .
note that ( anti)protons have been excluded from the charged hadrons in the correlation to avoid any possible cve contribution . tentatively assuming @xmath47s ( @xmath48s ) are positively(negatively)-charged
, we find that the  same - charge " and  opposite - charge " correlations are consistent with each other , which means no charge - dependent effect .
the message is twofold : first , from the @xmath120 correlations  @xcite we learn that the different behaviors of same - charge and opposite - charge particle correlations as shown in fig .
[ fig : gamma ] are really due to the electric charge , and therefore the null charge - separation effect in @xmath47-@xmath121 indicates that ( anti)@xmath47s manifest no electric charges in the @xmath31 correlation .
so the strange quarks inside seem to behave the same way as the up / down quarks in the chiral dynamics .
second , the @xmath47-@xmath121 correlation provides a baseline check for the @xmath47-@xmath116 correlation , and any possible signal in the latter should not come from the cme contribution .
figure  [ fig : lambda_p ] shows @xmath31 correlation of @xmath47-@xmath116 ( @xmath48-@xmath117 ) and @xmath47-@xmath117 ( @xmath48-@xmath116 ) as functions of centrality in au+au collisions at 200 gev  @xcite .
the same - baryonic - charge correlation has a different behavior from the opposite - baryonic - charge correlation from mid - central to peripheral collisions .
this baryonic charge separation with respect to the event plane is consistent with the expectation from the cve .
more investigations into the background contribution are needed .
for example , in analog with the local charge conservation , there could be the local baryonic charge conservation that plays a similar role as lcc when coupled to @xmath15 .
the magnitudes of the @xmath47-@xmath116 correlations are much larger than those of the @xmath121-@xmath121 correlations .
this is partially because the @xmath122 of baryons is higher than that of mesons , and the correlation strength increases with the average @xmath7 of the two particles in the correlation .
a future differential measurement vs the pair average @xmath7 and further correlations between identified particles may provide a better comparison of the correlation strength between the cme- and cve - related correlations .
the cmw is a signature of the chiral symmetry restoration in the qgp , and consists of actually two chiral gapless modes traveling at the same speed  @xcite : the right - handed ( left - handed ) wave transports the right - handed ( left - handed ) density and current in the direction parallel ( antiparallel ) to the @xmath4 direction . a more general analysis  @xcite studied various possible collective modes based on a non - neutral - background qgp ( i.e. with nonzero @xmath2 and/or @xmath0 ) in external electric and/or magnetic fields , and found a new type of collective motion , the chiral electric wave ( cew ) , arising from cese and propagating in parallel / antiparallel to the @xmath123 field . in symmetric collisions
there should be no net electric field on average , but asymmetric collisions like cu+au could provide a test ground for the cew measurements .       as a function of observed charge asymmetry and ( b ) @xmath15 difference between @xmath124 and @xmath125 as a function of charge asymmetry with the tracking efficiency correction , for @xmath126-@xmath127 au+au collisions at 200 gev  @xcite . ]
the cmw will induce a finite electric quadrupole moment of the collision system , with additional positive ( negative ) charge at the  poles " (  equator " ) of the produced fireball  @xcite .
this electric quadrupole , if boosted by radial flow , will lead to charge - dependent elliptic flow .
taking pions as an example , on top of the baseline @xmath128 , the cmw will lead to  @xcite v_2(^ ) = v_2^base(^ ) ( ) a_ch , [ eq : v2_slope ] where @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath131 are the quadrupole moment , the net charge density and the charge asymmetry of the collision event , respectively . as @xmath132 is always positive
, the @xmath133-integrated @xmath15 of @xmath124 ( @xmath125 ) should be above ( below ) the baseline owing to the cmw .
however , the baseline @xmath15 may be different for @xmath125 and @xmath124 because of several other physics mechanisms  @xcite .
therefore , it is less ambiguous to study the cmw via the @xmath133 dependence of pion @xmath15 than via the @xmath133-integrated @xmath15 .
taking @xmath126-@xmath127 200 gev au+au for example , pion @xmath15 is shown as a function of @xmath133 in panel ( a ) of fig .
[ fig : v2_a ]  @xcite .
@xmath124 @xmath15 increases with @xmath133 while @xmath125 @xmath15 decreases with a similar magnitude of the slope .
note that @xmath15 was integrated over a narrow low @xmath7 range ( @xmath134 gev/@xmath36 ) to focus on the soft physics of the cmw .
such a @xmath7 selection also makes sure that the @xmath122 is independent of @xmath133 and is the same for @xmath125 and @xmath124 , so that the @xmath15 splitting is not a trivial effect due to the @xmath122 variation .
this @xmath15 splitting was also confirmed by alice results for pb+pb collisions at 2.76 tev  @xcite .
the @xmath15 difference between @xmath124 and @xmath125 is fitted with a straight line in panel ( b ) .
the slope parameter @xmath135 , or presumably @xmath136 from eq .
[ eq : v2_slope ] , is positive and qualitatively consistent with the expectation of the cmw picture .
the fit function is nonzero at @xmath132 , indicating the @xmath133-integrated @xmath15 for @xmath124 and @xmath125 are different , which was also observed in ref .
@xcite .    the same procedure as above was followed by star to retrieve the slope parameter @xmath135 as a function of centrality for au+au collisions at 200 , 62.4 , 39 , 27 , 19.6 , 11.5 and 7.7 gev , as shown in fig .
[ fig : cmw_bes ]  @xcite .
a similar rise - and - fall trend is observed in the centrality dependence of the slope parameter for all the beam energies except 11.5 and 7.7 gev , where the slopes are consistent with zero with large statistical uncertainties .
it was argued  @xcite that at lower beam energies the @xmath133-integrated @xmath15 difference between particles and anti - particles can be explained by the effect of quark transport from the projectile nucleons to mid - rapidity , assuming that the @xmath15 of transported quarks is larger than that of produced ones .
the same model , however , when used to study @xmath137 as a function of @xmath133 , suggested a negative slope  @xcite , which is contradicted by the data .
as a function of centrality for au+au collisions at 7.7 - 200 gev  @xcite .
the grey bands represent the systematic errors . for comparison , we also show the urqmd calculations  @xcite and the calculations of the cmw  @xcite with different duration times . ]    to check if the observed slope parameters come from conventional physics , the same analysis of the monte carlo events from urqmd  @xcite was carried out . for au+au collisions at 200 gev ,
the slopes extracted from urqmd events are consistent with zero for the @xmath138-@xmath139 centrality range , where the signal from the real data is prominent .
similarly , the ampt event generator  @xcite also yields slopes consistent with zero ( not shown here ) .
on the other hand , the simplified cmw calculations  @xcite demonstrate a centrality dependence of the slope parameter similar to the data .
recently a more realistic implementation of the cmw  @xcite confirmed that the cmw contribution to @xmath135 is sizable , and the centrality dependence of @xmath135 is qualitatively similar to the data .
a quantitative comparison between data and theory requires further work on both sides to match the kinematic regions used in the analyses . for example , the measured @xmath133 only represents the charge asymmetry of a pseudorapidity slice ( @xmath140 ) of an event , instead of that of the whole collision system .
we expect @xmath133 for these two cases to be proportional to each other , but the determination of the ratio will be model dependent .
figure  [ fig : slope_alice ] shows a comparison in the slope parameter @xmath135 between star results for 200 gev au+au  @xcite and alice results for 2.76 tev pb+pb  @xcite .
overall , the slopes are surprisingly similar when considering the different collision energies and multiplicities , as well as the different kinematic acceptance : the star data estimated @xmath15 for charged pions with @xmath141 gev/@xmath36 and @xmath142 , while the alice data are for unidentified hadrons with @xmath143 gev/@xmath36 and @xmath144 .
one drawback with the measurement of @xmath145 is that the observed @xmath133 requires a correction factor due to the finite detector tracking efficiency .
a novel correlator  @xcite that is independent of efficiency was proposed , q_3 = q_3 - q_3 .
[ daq ] here @xmath146 and @xmath147 are the azimuthal angles of particles 1 and 2 , and @xmath148 is the charge ( @xmath149 ) of particle 3 .
the single brackets represent the average over particles and events , and the double bracket denotes the cumulant . in the absence of charge dependent correlations , the correlator should be equal to zero .
note that when the charge of the third particle is averaged over all particles in the event ( in the specified kinematic acceptance ) , the mean is equal to the charge asymmetry , i.e. @xmath150 .    the three - particle correlator ( as in eq .  [ daq ] ) for the @xmath64 harmonic was measured by alice and is presented in fig .
[ fig : threepart_alice ] as a function of centrality in pb+pb collisions at 2.76 tev gev  @xcite .
a substantial increase in the correlation strength is seen as the collisions become more peripheral , which can be caused by a combination of several factors .
for example , the magnetic field strength increases as the impact parameter increases , and this would cause the stronger correlations due to the cmw .
additionally , the lcc effect could play a role  @xcite , and neither of these necessarily comes at the expense of the other ; in principle the observable could have contributions from both of these and/or additional contributions from as yet unknown sources of correlation .
it was pointed out in ref .
@xcite that local charge conservation at freeze - out , when convoluted with the characteristic shape of @xmath151 and @xmath152 , may provide a qualitative explanation for the finite @xmath15 slope observed from data .
a realistic estimate of the contribution of this mechanism turns out to be smaller than the measurment by an order of magnitude  @xcite .
@xcite also proposes a test with the @xmath153 measurement , and the corresponding slope parameters for @xmath153 were reported by star to be consistent with zero  @xcite , which further suggests the smallness of this effect .
alice measured the three - particle correlator multiplied by @xmath154 for the @xmath155 harmonic and the @xmath114 harmonic  @xcite .
in both cases , the centrality dependence of the charge dependence is flat , in contrast to the @xmath64 harmonic that has a significant centrality dependence .
this may suggest a different nature of the correlation , or reflect a weaker centrality dependence of @xmath153 compared with that of @xmath15 .
future measurements of these higher harmonics with better precision will shed light on the true origin of this correlator .
a recent hydrodynamic study  @xcite suggested that simple viscous transport of charges , combined with certain specific initial conditions , might lead to a sizable contribution to the observed @xmath15 splitting of charged pions . in order for the results of pion splitting to resemble data , the authors had to assume a crucial relation between isospin chemical potential and the electric charge asymmetry , which needs to be verified .
furthermore , certain predictions of this model ( e.g. splitting for kaons ) appear to be not in line with current experimental information  @xcite . clearly whether such an idea works or not , would need to be thoroughly vetted by realistic viscous hydrodynamic simulations .
but all that said , this study poses a very important question : to make a firm case for the observation of anomalous charge transport via the cmw , the normal ( viscous hydrodynamical ) transport of charges should be quantitatively understood .
the confirmation of the experimental observation of several chiral anomalous effects will bring forth an exciting program to directly study the non - perturbative sector of qcd .
future experimental measurements should aim at more detailed study of the observed signals as well as understanding the background effects .
previous sections have covered a few such topics : initial magnetic field and vorticity , correlations with identified particles , higher - harmonic correlations , bes - ii and u+u collisions . in the following ,
we will focus on the event - shape engineering ( ese ) and isobaric collisions .
flow - related backgrounds could be potentially removed via ese  @xcite , with which _ spherical _ events or sub - events are selected , so that the particles of interest therein carry zero @xmath15 .
a previous attempt was made with the charge - separation observable of cmac ( roughly equivalent to @xmath31 ) , as a function of event - by - event  observed @xmath15 "  @xcite .
however , there are several issues in this approach that prevent a clear interpretation of the result . ref .
@xcite studied the flow vector @xmath156 of the sub - event of interest , a : q_x^a & = & _ i^n ( 2_i^a ) [ qx ] + q_y^a & = & _ i^n ( 2_i^a ) , [ qy ] and found that @xmath157 is a good handle on event shape .
( upper ) and @xmath158 ( lower ) as functions of @xmath157 , from ampt simulations .
@xcite the solid ( dashed ) line in the lower panel is a linear fit of the full ( open ) data points . ]
( upper ) and @xmath158 ( lower ) as functions of @xmath157 , from ampt simulations .
@xcite the solid ( dashed ) line in the lower panel is a linear fit of the full ( open ) data points . ]
figure  [ fig : ampt_v2_q2 ] shows the event plane resolution ( @xmath159 ) for the sub - events b1 and b2 ( upper ) , and the true elliptic flow @xmath160 and the corrected @xmath161 as functions of @xmath157 ( lower ) , from ampt simulations of @xmath162 au+au collisions at @xmath163 gev  @xcite . each ampt event has been divided into three sub - events according to pseudorapidity , @xmath8 : sub - event a contains particles of interest with @xmath101 , and sub - event b1(b2 ) serves as a sub - event plane using particles with @xmath164 ( @xmath165 ) .
flow fluctuation causes a positive correlation in flow between sub - events in the same event , and as a result , @xmath159 for sub - event b1 ( b2 ) increases with @xmath157 for sub - event a. the lower panel displays a discrepancy between @xmath160 and the corrected @xmath161 , owing to the difference between the reaction plane and the participant plane  @xcite , in terms of non - flow and flow fluctuation . what matters more is the fact that both @xmath15 values decrease with @xmath157 , and drop to @xmath166 , which demonstrates @xmath167 s capability of selecting spherical sub - events in the second harmonic .
the upper panel of fig .
[ fig : ampt_gamma_q2 ] presents the @xmath31 correlators multiplied by the number of participating nucleons , @xmath168 , as functions of @xmath157 , for @xmath162 ampt events of au+au collisions at 200 gev  @xcite . for both the same - charge and the opposite - charge correlators ,
the true @xmath169 and the corrected @xmath170 are consistent with each other within the statistical uncertainties .
this indicates that compared with @xmath15 , @xmath31 is less sensitive to non - flow or flow fluctuation . at larger @xmath157 ,
the opposite - charge correlators are above the same - charge correlators , suggesting a finite flow - related background .
the opposite- and same - charge correlators converge at small @xmath157 .
the lower panel shows @xmath171 vs @xmath157 , and again , the two observables seem to coincide .
linear fits to both observables yield small intercepts that are consistent with zero .
the finite @xmath172 values in ampt events are solely due to background contributions , so the disappearance of background is demonstrated when the  correctable " observable ( @xmath172 ) is projected to zero @xmath157 . ref .
@xcite has designed a promising recipe for future measurements to effectively remove flow backgrounds and restore the ensemble average of the cme signal .      to disentangle the possible cme signal and the flow - related backgrounds
, one can utilize experimental setups to either vary the backgrounds with the signal fixed , or vary the signal with the backgrounds fixed .
the former approach was carried out by exploiting the prolate shape of the uranium nuclei  @xcite .
however , it was found that the total multiplicity of detected hadrons is far less dependent on the number of binary collisions than expected  @xcite , so it is very hard to isolate tip - tip collisions ( that generate small @xmath15 ) from body - body collisions ( that generate large @xmath15 ) .
this significantly reduces the lever arm available to manipulate @xmath15 in order to separate flow backgrounds from the cme .        the latter approach ( with the @xmath15-driven backgrounds fixed ) can be realized , especially for mid - central / mid - peripheral events , with collisions of isobaric nuclei , such as @xmath173ru and @xmath174zr  @xcite .
ru+ru and zr+zr collisions at the same beam energy are almost identical in terms of particle production  @xcite , while the charge difference between ru and zr nuclei provides a handle on the initial magnetic field .
our current knowledge of the deformity ( @xmath175 ) of ru and zr is incomplete : e - a scattering experiments ( case 1 )  @xcite state that ru is more deformed ( @xmath176 ) than zr ( @xmath177 ) , while comprehensive model deductions ( case 2 )  @xcite tell the opposite , that @xmath178 is smaller than @xmath179 .
this systematic uncertainty has different impacts on the signal ( via the initial magnetic field ) and the background ( via the initial eccentricity ) to be discussed later . as a by - product , @xmath15 measurements in central collisions will discern which information source is more reliable regarding the deformity of the zr and ru nuclei .
figure  [ fig_mag](a ) presents the theoretical calculation  @xcite of the initial magnetic field squared with correction from azimuthal fluctuation of the magnetic field orientation , @xmath180}$ ] ( with @xmath181 the pion mass and @xmath182 the azimuthal angle of the magnetic field ) , for the two collision systems at 200 gev , using the hijing model  @xcite .
@xmath183 quantifies the magnetic field s capability of driving the cme signal in the @xmath31 correlator . for the same centrality bin ,
the ru+ru collision produces a significantly stronger magnetic field than zr+zr .
panel ( b ) of fig .
[ fig_mag ] shows that the relative difference in @xmath183 between ru+ru and zr+zr collisions is approaching @xmath184 ( case 1 ) or @xmath185 ( case 2 ) for peripheral events , and reduces to about @xmath186 ( both cases ) for central events .
figure  [ fig_mag](b ) shows the relative difference in the initial eccentricity , @xmath187 , obtained from the monte carlo glauber simulation .
@xmath187 is highly consistent with 0 for peripheral events , and goes above ( below ) 0 for the parameter set of case 1 ( case 2 ) in central collisions , because the ru ( zr ) nucleus is more deformed .
the relative difference in @xmath15 should closely follow that in eccentricity , so for the centrality range of interest , @xmath162 , the @xmath15-related backgrounds stay almost the same for ru+ru and zr+zr collisions .
@xcite further carried out the projection for the @xmath31 measurements in ru+ru and zr+zr at 200 gev ( 400 million events for each collision type ) , and concluded that a @xmath188 significance can be achieved for the relative difference in the observable between the two collision systems , assuming the flow backgrounds take up to two - thirds of the observable .
the results strongly suggest that the isobaric collisions can serve as an ideal tool to disentangle the signal of the chiral magnetic effect from the @xmath15-driven backgrounds .
the isobaric collisions may also be used to disentangle the signal of the cmw from background effects .
the physics of anomalous transport is at the heart of qcd as a non - abelian gauge theory .
the interplay of quantum anomalies with magnetic field and vorticity induces a variety of novel transport phenomena in chiral systems . in heavy - ion collisions ,
these phenomena make a unique probe to the topological properties of the qgp by measuring the charge dependence of the azimuthal distributions of the produced hadrons .
the experimental data from relativistic heavy ion collider at bnl and the large hadron collider at cern provide an evidence for the predicted effects , with magnitude consistent with theoretical estimates . there
exist known conventional backgrounds to all of these experimental observables .
however at present there is no compelling alternative explanation that can describe all of the data without invoking the anomalous chiral effects .
nevertheless , much remains to be done both in experiment and theory to substantiate the existing evidence , and we outlined a few such programs that hopefully will be accomplished in the near future .
we thank huan huang and other members of the ucla heavy ion physics group for discussions .
this work is supported by a grant ( no .
de - fg02 - 88er40424 ) from u.s .
department of energy , office of nuclear physics .
the authors declare that there is no conflict of interest regarding the publication of this paper .
d. e. kharzeev , l. d. mclerran and h. j. warringa , nucl .
a * 803 * , 227 ( 2008 ) .
d. kharzeev , phys .
b * 633 * , 260 ( 2006 ) .
d. kharzeev and a. zhitnitsky , nucl .
a * 797 * , 67 ( 2007 ) .
d. kharzeev , a. krasnitz and r. venugopalan , phys .
b * 545 * , 298 ( 2002 ) .
i. iatrakis , s. lin and y. yin , phys .
lett . * 114 * , 252301 ( 2015 ) .
k. fukushima , d. e. kharzeev and h. j. warringa , phys .
104 , 212001 ( 2010 ) .
a.  m.  poskanzer and s.  voloshin , phys .
c * 58 * , 1671 ( 1998 ) .
d. e. kharzeev and d. t. son , phys
* 106 * ( 2011 ) 062301 .
d. t. son and a. r. zhitnitsky , phys
d * 70 * 074018 ( 2004 ) .
m. a. metlitski and a. r. zhitnitsky , phys .
d * 72 * 045011 ( 2005 ) .
y. burnier , d. e. kharzeev , j. liao and h .- u .
yee , 052303 ( 2011 ) .
g. m. newman , jhep * 0601 * 158 ( 2006 ) .
x. g. huang and j. liao , phys .
lett . * 110 * , 232302 ( 2013 ) .
y. jiang , x. g. huang and j. liao , phys .
d * 91 * , 045001 ( 2015 ) .
y. jiang , x. g. huang and j. liao , phys .
d * 92 * , 071501 ( 2015 ) .
kharzeev , j. liao , s.a .
voloshin and g. wang , prog .
88 * , 1 ( 2016 ) .
a. bzdak , v. skokov , phys .
b * 710 * , 171 ( 2012 ) .
deng , x.g .
huang , phys .
c * 85 * , 044907 ( 2012 ) ; phys .
b * 742 * , 296 ( 2015 ) .
j. bloczynski , x.g .
huang , x. zhang , j. liao , phys .
b * 718 * , 1529 ( 2013 ) .
l. mclerran , v. skokov , nuclear phys .
a * 929 * , 184 ( 2014 ) .
x. guo , s. shi , n. xu , z. xu , p. zhuang .
u. gursoy , d. kharzeev , k. rajagopal , phys .
c * 89(5 ) * , 054905 ( 2014 ) .
k. tuchin , adv . high energy phys . * 2013 * , 490495 ( 2013 ) .
y. hirono , m. hongo , and t. hirano , phys .
c * 90 * , 021903 ( 2014 ) . v. voronyuk , v. d. toneev , s. a. voloshin , and w. cassing , phys .
064903 ( 2014 ) . l. adamczyk _
et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , arxiv:1608.04100
. b. i. abelev _
et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys .
* 101 * , 252301 ( 2008 ) .
y. jiang , z.w .
lin , j. liao , arxiv:1602.06580 .
baznat , k.k .
gudima , a.s .
sorin , o.v .
teryaev , phys .
c * 93 * , 031902 ( 2016 ) .
f. becattini _
_ , arxiv:1501.04468 .
f. becattini , l. csernai , d.j .
wang , phys .
c * 88 ( 3 ) * , 034905 ( 2013 ) .
s. floerchinger , u.a .
wiedemann , j. high energy phys .
* 1111 * , 100 ( 2011 ) .
gao , b. qi , s.y .
wang , phys .
d * 90 ( 8) * , 083001 ( 2014 ) .
isaac upsal _
[ star collaboration ] , j. phys .
* 736 * , 012016 ( 2016 ) .
star collaboration , star note * 0598 * , https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/star/starnotes/public/sn0598 .
a.h . tang and g. wang , phys .
c * 94 * , 024920 ( 2016 ) . y. hirono , d. e. kharzeev , and y. yin , phys .
d * 92 * , 125031 ( 2015 ) .
a. ipp , a. di piazza , j. evers , and c. h. keitel , phys . lett .
b * 666 * , 315 ( 2008 ) .
k. a. mamo and h. u. yee , phys .
d * 88 * , 114029 ( 2013 ) .
liang and x .-
wang , phys .
* 94 * , 102301 ( 2005 ) .
m. baznat , k. gudima , a. sorin , and o. teryaev , phys .
c * 88 * , 061901 ( 2013 ) .
deng and x .- g .
huang , phys .
c * 93 * , 064907 ( 2016 )    l. adamczyk _
et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys .
c * 88 * 064911 ( 2013 ) .
s. a. voloshin , phys .
c * 70 * , 057901 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0406311 ]
. b. i. abelev _
et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys .
103 * 251601 ( 2009 ) . 7
i. abelev _
et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys .
c * 81 * 54908 ( 2010 ) .
a. bzdak , v. koch and j. liao , phys .
c * 81 * 031901 ( 2010 ) .
n. n. ajitanand , s. esumi , r. a. lacey ( phenix collaboration ) , in : proc . of the rbrc workshops ,
vol.*96 * , 230 ( 2010 ) :  p- and cp - odd ects in hot and dense matter " . b. i. abelev , 021301 ( 2013 ) .
n. n. ajitanand , r. a. lacey , a. taranenko and j. m. alexander , phys .
c * 83 * 011901 ( 2011 ) .
r. l. ray and r. s. longacre , arxiv : nucl - ex/0008009 .
s. a. bass _ et al .
* 41 * 255 ( 1998 ) .
m. gyulassy and x .-
wang , comput .
* 83 * 307 ( 1994);x.n .
wang and m.gyulassy , phys .
d * 44 * 3501 ( 1991 ) .
f. zhao ( star collaboration ) , nucl .
a * 931 * ( 2014 ) 746 .
l. adamczyk _
et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys .
c * 89 * , 044908 ( 2014 ) .
l. adamczyk _
et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys .
* 113 * ( 2014 ) 052302 .
a. bzdak , v. koch and j. liao , phys .
c * 83 * 014905 ( 2011 ) .
s.  pratt , s.  schlichting and s.  gavin , phys .
c * 84 * , 024909 ( 2011 ) .
a. bzdak , v. koch and j. liao , lect .
notes phys . *
871 * 503 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1207.7327 [ nucl - th ] ] .
s.  schlichting and s.  pratt , phys .
c * 83 * , 014913 ( 2011 ) .
f. wen , l. wen and g. wang , arxiv:1608.03205 .
[ phobos collaboration ] , phys .
c * 83 * , 024913 ( 2011 ) .
b.b back _ et al . _ [ phobos collaboration ] , phys .
c * 72 * , 051901(r ) ( 2005 ) .
b. zhang , c.m .
ko , b .- a .
li and z .- w .
lin , phys .
c * 61 * , 067901 ( 2000 ) .
lin , c.m .
ko , b .- a .
li and b. zhang , phys .
c * 72 * , 064901 ( 2005 ) .
lin and c.m .
ko , phys .
c * 65 * , 034904 ( 2002 ) ;    a. j. kuhlman and u. w. heinz , phys . rev .
c * 72 * , 037901 ( 2005 ) .
s. a. voloshin , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 172301 ( 2010 ) .
l. adamczyk _
et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys .
* 115 * , 222301 ( 2015 ) .
gang wang _
[ star collaboration ] , nucl .
phys a * 904 - 905 * , 248c ( 2013 ) .
p. tribedy [ star collaboration ] ,  charge sensitive cumulants and flow in u+u collisions " , workshop on chirality , vorticity and magnetic field in heavy ion collisions , 2016 ; http://starmeetings.physics.ucla.edu/sites/default/files/pritwish_tribedy.pdf .
v. skokov , p. sorensen , v. koch , s. schlichting , j. thomas , s. voloshin , g. wang and h .- u .
yee , arxiv:1608.00982 .
j. bloczynski , x. g. huang , x. zhang and j. liao , nucl .
a * 939 * , 85 ( 2015 ) .
s. a. voloshin , prog .
67 * , 541 ( 2012 ) .
s. a. voloshin [ alice collaboration ] , nucl .
phys . a * 904 - 905 * , 90c ( 2013 ) .
gorbar , v.a .
miransky , i.a .
shovkovy , x. wang , phys .
d * 88 ( 2 ) * , 025025 ( 2013 ) .
j. c. dunlop , m. a. lisa and p. sorensen , phys .
c * 84 * , ( 2011 ) 044914 . j. xu , l. -w .
chen , c. m. ko and z. -w .
lin , phys .
c * 85 * , ( 2012 ) 041901 ( 2012 ) .
l. adamczyk _
( star collaboration ) , phys .
* 114 * , ( 2015 ) 252302 .
( alice collaboration ) , phys .
c * 93 * , 044903 ( 2016 ) .
l. adamczyk et al .
[ star collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 110 * , 142301 ( 2013 ) .
j. m. campbell and m. a. lisa , journal of physics : conference series * 446 * , 012014 ( 2013 )
. y. burnier , d.e .
kharzeev , j. liao , h .- u .
yee , arxiv : 1208.2537 ( 2012 ) .
h. yee and y. yin , phys .
c * 89 * ( 2014 ) 044909 .
s. a. voloshin and r. belmont , nucl .
phys . a * 931 * , 992 ( 2014 ) .
a. bzdak and p. bozek , arxiv:1303.1138 .
q .- y . shou [ star collaboration ] , nucl .
a * 931 * , 758 ( 2014 ) .
y. hatta , a. monnai and b. w. xiao , nucl .
a * 947 * , 155 ( 2016 ) .
shou [ star collaboration ] ,  charge asymmetry dependence of @xmath189 @xmath15 in au+au collisions at star " , workshop on chirality , vorticity and magnetic field in heavy ion collisions , 2016 ; http://starmeetings.physics.ucla.edu/sites/default/files/qiye_shou.pdf    j.  schukraft , a.  timmins and s.  a.  voloshin , phys .
b * 719 * , 394 ( 2013 ) .
j.  -y .
ollitrault , a.  m.  poskanzer and s.  a.  voloshin , phys .
c * 80 * , 014904 ( 2009 ) .
deng , x .-
huang , g .-
ma , g. wang , arxiv:1607.04697 .
s. raman , c. w. g. nestor , jr and p. tikkanen , atom .
data nucl .
data tabl .
* 78 * , 1 ( 2001 ) .
b. pritychenko , m. birch , b. singh and m. horoi , atom .
data nucl .
data tabl .
* 107 * , 1 ( 2016 ) .
p. moller , j. r. nix , w. d. myers and w. j. swiatecki , atom .
data nucl .
data tabl .
* 59 * , 185 ( 1995 ) .