lif is a ionic solid that is particularly transparent to short wavelength radiation due to its large band gap and hence is commonly used in optics for high - pressure and temperature experiments , such as those related to the development of pulsed power @xcite .
lif is also a component in molten salts frequently employed as high - temperature thermal fluids .
estimates of the transport properties of lif are important to both these applications .
specifically , in dynamic high - pressure experiments , a lif window maintains the pressure at the sample interface where velocimetry measurements are typically made . due to the extreme conditions , the necessary transmission properties are difficult to measure directly . in these experiments , a shock or a near - shock ramp compression with pressures up to 800
gpa @xcite is generated by a variety of means and the material response is measured using velocity interferometry , see , _ e.g. _ , refs
.. there are many efforts concentrating on estimating the optical properties of lif crucial to this measurement , see , _
e.g. _ , refs .. due to the short but finite timescale of dynamic material experiments , the thermal conductivity of lif windows can significantly affect the temperature measured at the sample interface . in this work ,
we focus on calculating this thermal conductivity at the extreme conditions relevant to these experiments with the goal of understanding the nonequilibrium energy transfer that governs their behavior .
the material properties of lif have been explored in experiments and simulation primarily nearer to ambient conditions .
for instance , thacher @xcite measured the sound velocity and thermal conductivity of lif at temperatures less than 100 k. at ambient pressure , [ thacher1967effect ] shows that the thermal conductivity of lif peaks at about 2 w / m - k near 20 k , where the quantum increase of heat capacity begins to be dominated by the decrease in conductivity due to umklapp scattering . andersson and bckstrm @xcite were able to measure the heat capacity and thermal conductivity of lif at room temperature up to pressures of 1 gpa .
they showed a linear dependence of thermal conductivity on pressure and measured a conductivity value of 16.3 w / mk at 1 gpa .
phase and other transitions can complicate measurements at higher temperatures and pressures .
given that the full phase diagram for lif is not known , smirnov @xcite computed an _ ab initio _ phase diagram of lif over pressures ranging from 0 to 500 gpa and temperatures ranging from 0 to 12000 k together with the elastic properties and associated debye temperatures .
smirov @xcite predicted that the structure of lif is the nacl - like arrangement b1 at low temperature and pressure but transitions to the cscl - like arrangement b2 at higher pressures and temperatures .
smirov correlated his results with experimental data by kormer @xcite and boehler _ et al . _
( see root _
et al . _
@xcite for a similar study of mgo where _ ab initio _ molecular dynamics and quantum monte carlo methods were also employed to predict a phase diagram at extreme conditions . )
boehler _ et al . _
@xcite studied the high pressure melting regime of lif with diamond anvil experiments and classical molecular dynamics ( md ) fitted to properties at standard temperature and pressure .
et al . _  [ clerouin2005ab ] used _ ab initio _ dynamics to estimate the optical properties of lif along the shock hugoniot where it transitions from a transparent solid to a reflective plasma .
et al . _
@xcite investigated lif melting with md using a potential tuned with _
ab initio _ data and compare to existing diamond anvil and shock experimental data .
in particular , belonoshko _ et al .
_  showed that density as a function of pressure and the radial distribution function computed with their potential compares well with trusted data .
they also make clear the distinction between thermal instability and melting especially for small systems at high pressures using a phase coexistence method . also using classical md , young
@xcite studied ion damage of lif crystals .
related to thermal properties of lif , nsslein and schrder @xcite calculated the dispersion and phonon density of states ( phdos ) via polarizable model of the inter - atomic interactions of lif at 0 k. dolling _ et al .
_  @xcite also calculated the phdos of lif via lattice dynamics and compared it to dispersion data derived from slow neutron inelastic scattering . in their work , the crystal has phonon content up to 20 thz with most of the low frequency content attributed to the f ion .
recently , stegailov @xcite calculated the phdos with density functional theory with the generalized gradient approximation and showed the onset of mechanical instability , which may lead to defect formation or melting , due to hot electrons when the electron temperature reaches 37,000 k. following this body of work , in this paper we use md together with the green - kubo ( gk ) formalism @xcite to estimate the thermal conductivity of lif at stresses on par with the elastic moduli and temperatures in excess of the melt temperature at ambient conditions . in particular , we investigate both volumetric and uniaxial deformation modes similar to ( non - hugniot ) ramp compression experiments .
( [ spataru2015ab ] makes a corresponding study of the optical properties of lif . ) generally speaking , classical md is well - suited to simulating ionic solids since essentially all heat propagates via phonons .
the related publications , refs .
, are the few examples of estimating the thermal conductivity of alkalis with classical md and typically focus on the thermal properties of molten salts with applications to high temperature thermal transfer fluids .
the strong ionic character of lif leads to the usual complications due to long range coulomb interaction , requiring dipole corrections and large cell sizes ; but the main issue is that md is highly reliant on empirical potentials .
there has been some work on suitable potentials for ionic solids like lif , typically of the buckingham @xcite or born / tosi - fumi @xcite forms .
a high quality potential parameterization for lif of another form was developed by ishii _
et al . _
@xcite but focussed on the properties of molten mixtures , see also refs .. on the other - hand , belonoshko _ et al . _
@xcite carefully constructed a tosi - fumi / born - mayer - huggins potential to suit high - pressure and temperature conditions by dropping the unstable terms in the full tosi - fumi form , and compared its behavior to literature and their own density functional theory ( dft ) results .
given the findings in [ belonoshko2000born ] , it was evident that the md potential may not transition to the most stable phase with changes in pressure and temperature but instead becomes stuck in a metastable state .
we used this fact together with a phase diagram independently calculated with dft to estimate thermal conductivity over pressures ranging from 100 to 400 gpa and temperatures ranging from 1000 to 4000 k. to compute the phase diagram , we follow smirnov s work @xcite and others @xcite and use plane augmented wave ( paw ) dft with the local density approximation ( lda ) instead of the linear muffin tin orbital method smirnov employed to estimate the zero temperature enthalpy and entropy of the phonon population . from a dynamical matrix calculated with dft , we are able to estimate the entropy component of the free energy with a quasi - harmonic model . the range of the free energy estimated with the quasi - harmonic model limited by the mechanical stability which we also estimated with the _ ab initio _ bond stiffnesses governing the phonon propagation .
in addition , we use the _ ab initio _ phdos to validate and recalibrate the belonoshko parameterization for thermal conductivity estimates .
given a definition of the heat flux @xmath0 , the thermal conductivity tensor @xmath1 can be obtained from the green - kubo formula dependent on the time - correlation of @xmath0 with itself : @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the system volume , @xmath4 is the temperature , @xmath5 is the boltzmann constant .
the bracket @xmath6 denotes the appropriate ensemble average , where it is important to note that @xmath7 in equilibrium . a microscopic formula @xcite for the heat flux @xmath0 is @xmath8 where the per - atom energy @xmath9 is formed from the kinetic energy of the atom @xmath10 and a reasonable partition of the total potential energy comprised of short - range bonds and long - range coulomb interactions to individual atoms @xcite , and the virial stress @xmath11 for atom @xmath10 in terms of fundamental quantities ( which is given in app.[app : virial ] ) .
classical molecular dynamics ( md ) provides the necessary positions @xmath12 , velocities @xmath13 , and forces @xmath14 , from the trajectories obtained by integrating newton s equations of motion , @xmath15 , given an initial configuration @xmath16 and atomic masses @xmath17 .
the total force @xmath18 on an atom @xmath10 is the sum of interatomic forces derived from an empirical potential @xmath19 . for ionic solids like lif ,
explicit charges @xmath20 are typically constant and located at ion cores .
a widely - used potential for ionic materials is the tosi - fumi / born - mayer - huggins ( tf / bmh ) potential @xcite,@xcite .
it is a combination of long - range coulomb and short - range @xmath21 ( repulsion ) pair - wise interactions @xmath22 for species @xmath23,@xmath24 with associated groups of atoms @xmath25,@xmath26 ; inter - atomic distance @xmath27 ; and charge @xmath28 for @xmath29 .
here , @xmath30 is the ( vacuum ) permittivity and @xmath31 is the elementary charge . of the empirical parameters : @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 and @xmath35 ,
the last two are related to dipole interactions and are set to zero for high pressure stability considerations by belonoshko _
et al . _
@xcite in their model of lif .
the periodic images participating in the coulomb forces on the atoms in the system extend well beyond the explicitly represented periodic box . for efficiency ,
the energy @xmath36 is decomposed into long ( _ reciprocal _
@xmath37-space ) and short ( real @xmath38-space ) components .
this decomposition is the essence of ewald summation and the particle - particle particle - mesh ( pppm ) method @xcite ( see app.[app : virial ] for more details ) .    to validate an empirical potential for calculation of thermal conductivity ideally all the properties related to the phonon population and propagation
would be compared with experimental or _
ab initio _ data . in lieu of a full comparison of the dispersion relationship for harmonic waves and related properties for anaharmonic interactions , we follow others in comparing the elastic constants and phonon density of states related to the phonon dispersion and wave speeds . as derived from the dispersion relationship of the material , the phonon density of states ( phdos )
is linked to the thermal conductivity of the material .
the dispersion relationship is determined by the matrix of bond stiffnesses @xmath39 , which is composed of sub - matrices of linearized force constants : @xmath40_{\alpha\beta }   = \left .
\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial { \mathbf{x}}_\alpha \partial { \mathbf{x}}_\beta } \right|_{{\mathbf{x}}_\alpha={\mathbf{y}}_\alpha }    = - \left .
\frac{\partial { \mathbf{f}}_\alpha}{\partial { \mathbf{x}}_\beta } \right|_{{\mathbf{x}}_\alpha={\mathbf{y}}_\alpha}\ ] ] referenced to a given lattice configuration @xmath41 @xcite . the dynamical matrix , a fourier transform of @xmath39 , results from applying a plane wave ansatz for the motion of the atoms about lattice positions @xmath41 : @xmath42_{\alpha\beta }   = \sum_{\boldsymbol{\ell } } \frac{1}{\sqrt{m_\alpha m_\beta } } { \mathbb{k}}_{\alpha\beta } \exp\left(-\imath { \mathbf{k}}\cdot \left ( { \mathbf{x}}_{\alpha } - { \mathbf{x}}_{\beta } - \boldsymbol{\ell } \right ) \right ) \ , \ ] ] where @xmath43 ranges across all periodic images of the unit cell including the original one .
the dynamical matrix determines the eigenvalues @xmath44 for a given propagation direction ( wave vector ) @xmath37 and polarization .
the phdos is constructed by sampling the eigenvalues @xmath44 of eq.([eq : dmat ] ) throughout the brillouin zone .
the same procedure can be used in the context of an _ ab initio _ density functional model of the material where the forces @xmath14 are the hellman - feynman forces .
the dynamical matrix also determines the ( linear ) phonon and long - wavelength elastic stability . the elastic moduli tensor @xmath45_{iajb }   =   \left[\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial { { \mathbf{f } } } \partial { { \mathbf{f } } } } \right]_{iajb } = \frac{1}{{\mathrm{v}}_0 } \left [ \sum_{\alpha,\beta } \frac{\partial^2 \phi } { \partial { { \mathbf{x}}_\alpha } \partial { { \mathbf{x}}_\beta } } : \frac{\partial { \mathbf{x}}_\alpha}{\partial { \mathbf{f } } } \frac{\partial { \mathbf{x}}_\beta}{\partial { \mathbf{f } } } \right]_{iajb } = \frac{1}{{\mathrm{v}}_0 } \sum_{\alpha,\beta } \left [ \left [ { \mathbb{k}}\right]_{\alpha \beta } \right]_{ij } \left [ { \mathbf{x}}_{\alpha } \right]_a   \left [ { \mathbf{x}}_{\beta } \right]_b\ ] ] is related to the tensor of bond stiffnesses @xmath39 and determines the stability in the continuum limit . here , @xmath46 is the deformation gradient , @xmath47 are the stress - free lattice sites , and @xmath48 .
see app.[app : stability ] for more details .
lif can change phase over a range of temperatures and pressures . to determine the relatively stable phase as a function of temperature @xmath4 and stress @xmath49 , estimates of the gibbs free energy @xmath50 : @xmath51 a legendre transform of helmholtz free energy @xmath52 , needs to be calculated for both b1 and b2 structures . here
, @xmath53 is the first piola - kirchhoff stress . assuming positive frequencies @xmath54 , the helmholtz free energy @xmath52 is commonly estimated with a quasi - harmonic ( qh ) model : @xmath55 which is based on the partition function of independent oscillators ( see _ e.g._[dove1993introduction](chap .
this model is composed of two zero temperature components : ( a ) the cohesive energy ( referenced to an infinitely dispersed state ) which can be equated with @xmath56 , and ( b ) the ( non - classical ) zero point / ground state energy of the phonons @xmath57 ; together with a third term : the temperature - entropy product approximated by the harmonic oscillator model . given the wide band - gap of lif
, we neglect the thermal electron contribution in this approximate model . clearly , an equation of state ( eos ) @xmath58 is necessary to transform the helmholtz free energy @xmath52 to the gibbs free energy @xmath50 . at zero temperature
the data needed to construct an accurate eos can be calculated with dft .
the change of stress with temperature can be estimated with the qh model eq.([eq : qh ] ) @xcite or from md simulations .
assuming a first order dependence of stress on temperature , we can use @xmath59 to form the necessary inverse @xmath60 .
since the systems of interest are cubic , the thermal expansion tensor @xmath61 , and hence only one coefficient @xmath62 needs to be determined to effect thermal expansion .
as discussed in the introduction , we have based this study on the potential by belonoshko _
et al . _
this potential was specifically parameterized for high pressure states where the @xmath34 and @xmath35 parameters of the tf / bmh potential in eq.([eq : born ] ) , which cause instability , are set to zero . since belonoshko _
et al . _
@xcite were primarily concerned with investigating phase diagram and mechanical properties and we are employing the potential to estimate thermal conductivity , we compared the phdos resulting from the tf / bmh potential with the belonoshko _
et al . _
parameters to that from an _ ab initio _ calculation as a measure of the validity of phonon transmission . for the dft calculations , we employed the local density approximation ( lda ) , a plane augmented wave basis with cutoff 800 ev with standard pseudo - potentials @xcite , and 20@xmath6320@xmath6320 k - point monkhorst - pack grid , which were arrived at via convergence studies for the dynamical matrix and elastic moduli .
fig.[fig : pdos ] shows that the phdos ( calculated via the dft code vasp @xcite and the phonopy package @xcite ) is quite sensitive to compression and hence pressure .
the presence of negative frequencies in the phdos of compressed b2 structures also indicates that the b2 phase is unstable for lattice constant @xmath64 2.1    ( and number density @xmath65 0.215 @xmath66 ) .
we compared the phdos for simulations with 2@xmath632@xmath632 , 3@xmath633@xmath633 , and 4@xmath634@xmath634 unit cells with the correction based on born effective charges @xcite and found results essentially indistinguishable and hence we employed systems with 2@xmath632@xmath632 for the remainder of the calculations . for the comparison of the phdos derived from the belonoshko potential and that from dft , we picked the compressed b1 configuration with @xmath23= 3.285   ( corresponding to 2000 k , 200 gpa lattice constant based on the belonoshko parameterization ) as representative of our pressure - temperature region of interest .
given the poor match shown in fig.[fig : pdos_comparison ] , we re - tuned the potential to achieve a better correspondence , particularly of the peaks in the phdos , which is also shown in fig.[fig : pdos_comparison ] .
note that only changing li - f well depth resulted in stable modifications of the crystal that maintained a reasonably representative lattice constant : b1 : 4.051   ( original ) _ vs. _  4.206   ( modified ) , and b2 : 2.514   ( original ) _ vs. _  2.588   ( modified ) , at zero temperature .
the resulting and original parameters are given in table[tab : parameters ] .
l | r r | r r & a [ ev ] & b [ @xmath67 & a [ ev ] & b [ @xmath67 + li - li & 98.933 & 3.3445 & `` & '' + li - f & 401.319 & 3.6900 & 521.714 & `` + li - li & 420.463 & 3.3445 & '' & " +    regarding the possibility that lif can have b1 , b2 , and liquid phases over the pressure  temperature range of interest and these structural changes can influence the thermal conductivity , we adopted the approach to : ( a ) use dft to predict the appropriate phase for given stress and temperatures conditions , and ( b ) use this phase to initialize the md simulation which generally stays in this phase even if it is only meta - stable with respect to the empirical potential .
we did observe some deviations from this assumption , including defect formation and melting , which are noted in the results section . to this end ,
the qh model derived from the same dynamical matrix used to generate phdos was employed to estimate the relative free energy @xmath68 and thus the thermodynamic stability of the b2 phase relative to b1 .
this model is built upon direct _ ab initio _ estimates of the zero temperature enthalpy and limited in its range of validity by the mechanical stability of the phonon population at each particular deformation state . to construct the b1b2 phase diagram , first we constructed an equation of state .
we interpolated the function @xmath69 for b1 and b2 directly from dft data and estimated the thermal expansion coefficient @xmath62 from md data ( as opposed to from the qh model ) due to its full representation of anharmonic effects and its good correlation with measured values .
fig.[fig : pressure_density ] shows the relevant pressure versus density curves for a range of temperatures .
clearly , the finite - temperature md pressure curves are offset from the zero - temperature dft data so that positive thermal expansion coefficients are obtained and the bulk modulus for the md model are effectively the same as for the dft ; however , the zero - temperature equilibrium lattice constants do differ slightly .
our estimates of the expansion coefficient @xmath62 employed in eq.([eq : thermal_expansion ] ) are : b1 : 0.008056 gpa / k , b2 : 0.01164 gpa / k , for the original belonoshko parameterization , and b1 : 0.007411 gpa / k , b2 : 0.01082 gpa / k , for the modified parameterization . for reference ,
the measured coefficient of thermal expansion ( @xmath62 divided by the bulk modulus ) is 37 @xmath63 10@xmath70 /k @xcite at ambient conditions which corresponds to our estimate , 30 @xmath63 10@xmath70 /k , for the unmodified b1 potential . also apparent
is the fact that the b1 and b2 phase have similar mechanical responses with b2 being slightly , but distinctly softer than b1 at the same ( number ) density @xmath71 .
next , we ascertained the mechanical stability of the b1 and b2 phases through the _ ab initio _ estimates of the elastic moduli and phdos .
fig.[fig : stability ] shows the pressure and elastic moduli calculated from the dft data , and the derived stability moduli ( see app.[app : stability ] for details ) .
the results : ( a ) b1 is stable over the high pressure range we consider , and ( b ) b2 is only conditionally stable ( @xmath72 2.15  , @xmath73 0.2 atoms / @xmath66 ) based on linearized , long - wavelength elastic stability considerations , are comparable to the findings in [ smirnov2011abinitio](fig .
2 ) . coincide with those derived in app.[app : stability ] . ] examining phonon spectrum corresponding to the phdos data in fig.[fig : pdos ] gives a more detailed account of stability since each mode can be examined independently ( see app.[app : stability ] for a discussion of the connection between the two stability criteria ) . from the phdos
data , b2 is apparently stable for @xmath72 2.1  , which corresponds approximately to pressure @xmath74 120 - 130 gpa for the temperatures we consider .
( coincidently , belonoshko @xcite speculates that a b1b2 transition occurs at approximately 130 gpa , which is in the neighborhood of @xmath71 = 0.2 atoms / @xmath66 given fig.[fig : pressure_density ] . )
finally , we evaluated the free energy difference .
the zero - temperature energy ( enthalpy ) differences between b2 and b1 shown in fig.[fig : enthalpy ] display trends similar those shown in [ smirnov2011abinitio](fig.1 ) . using the qh model eq.([eq : qh ] ) , we calculate the zero point energy difference @xmath75 , omitted in [ smirnov2011abinitio ] , to be nearly uniformly 0.02 ev / atom over the pressure range we examined , and , hence , has no significant effect on the resulting b1-b2 phase separator . in fact , the change in zero - temperature enthalpy difference between the two phases over the given pressure range is dominated by the pressure - volume work . unlike [ smirnov2011abinitio](fig.6 ) which shows a transition to b2 at temperatures and pressures as low as 1500 k and 150 gpa
, we estimate that @xmath76 0.1 ev over the given @xmath4 and @xmath77 range so b1 is always relatively thermodynamically stable .
the contours of @xmath78 resemble the slope of b1-b2 separator in [ smirnov2011abinitio](fig.6 ) , and the elastic moduli as a function of pressure and phase are similiar .
the qh model of the free - energy difference is arguably better than debye model tuned by linear muffin tin data employed in [ smirnov2011abinitio ] since the qh model does not make assumptions about form of the dispersion relation ; however , its validity at these temperatures is suspect . as fig.[fig : thermal_displacement ] shows , the thermal displacements predicted by the qh model are large , but still much smaller than those given by md with similar elastic properties .
this data gives credence to the notion of thermal stabilization of apparently mechanically unstable phases . in this form of non - linear stability , at high temperatures atoms
primarily reside outside the zero - temperature minimum state which may be mechanically unstable and in nearby regions of the energy surface with positive curvature @xcite .
after these validation and phase determination procedures , we thermalized and pressurized lif lattices with a nos - hoover thermo - barostat ( using the classical md code lammps @xcite ) in order to obtain the equilibrium flux correlations necessary to estimate thermal conductivity .
after equilibration , we used 10 replica systems with initial conditions selected from the constant temperature - pressure equilibration simulations of constant energy dynamics to compute the average flux correlation .
after transients due to the relaxation from constant temperature dynamics subsided , samples of the correlations contributing to the average @xmath79 were collected every ten 0.5 fs time - steps as a last preliminary , given the spatial decomposition employed by pppm , we checked for finite size effects in the flux correlations .
fig.[fig : size ] shows that they are negligible with respect to the inherent noise even for periodic systems as small as 4@xmath634@xmath634 unit cells ; hence , in the following studies we used 4@xmath634@xmath634 systems and a real space/@xmath37-space decomposition cutoff @xmath80 nm for the pppm electrostatic solver .    ) .
this extrapolation is parallel but not coincident with the dft data ( black ) which implies that the md and dft models of lif have similar elastic elastic properties but different zero - temperature equilibrium lattice constants .
the inset shows corresponding data for the modified md potential .
for reference , the rose - vinet fits to the dft data are : b1 : @xmath81= 83.93 gpa , @xmath82= 4.594 gpa , @xmath23= 3.905  , and b2 : @xmath81= 78.42 gpa , @xmath82= 4.818 gpa , @xmath23= 2.464  , where @xmath81 is the zero - temperature bulk modulus , and @xmath23 is the corresponding lattice constant . for reference ,
the measured , ambient lattice constant is 4.03   @xcite ; , title="fig : " ]
using the green - kubo ( gk ) method described in sec .
[ sec : theory ] and the preliminaries given in sec .
[ sec : method ] , we compute the thermal conductivity for compressed states in two studies for different deformations of the lattice : ( a ) volumetric compression over a range of pressures @xmath77 = 100400
gpa and temperatures @xmath4= 10004000 k , and ( b ) uniaxial compression with normal stress 150 gpa to simulate conditions at the initiation of a ramp experiment .
since , at ambient pressure the measured debye temperature for lif is 732 k ( * ? ? ?
* table 12.1 ) and the melt is temperature 1121 k @xcite , our conditions are well within the classical regime and some of the states may melt .    in preliminary studies , we found the difference in the estimated conductivity with the modified _ vs.
_  the original belonoshko parameters was at most 10% over the range of interest and typically only 3% . since these differences were comparable to our error estimated from 10 replicas , we report conductivities derived from the original parameters .
we attribute these small differences between parameterizations with distinct phdos , and hence dispersion characteristics , to the observation that low frequency / long wavelength phonons carry most of the heat and in that range the phdos of the two parameterizations agree fairly well . in fact , g. chen and co - authors refs . showed that 90% of the heat in si at ambient conditions is carried by phonons with frequencies less than about 2 thz ( estimated from the reported 2 - 5 nm wavelength and the given elastic moduli ) .
first , we compared the conductivity estimated with md gk and a method directly employing _ ab initio _
data for b1 lif at constant volume ( @xmath23= 3.2  ) over the temperature range @xmath4=10004000 k. specifically , in the second method the boltzmann transport equation ( bte ) was parameterized with _
ab initio _ second and third order force constants derived from 2@xmath632@xmath632 , and 4@xmath634@xmath634 unit cell systems respectively and solved in the single mode relaxation time approximation .
see refs . for details , and the similar approach in [ li2014shengbte ] . given the differences in the methods , the results shown in fig.[fig : abinitio_comparison ] are comparable .
the md estimates are uniformly lower than those of the bte , which is consistent with fact that the md has a complete , albeit less exact , hamiltonian with no truncation of the phonon scattering interactions and the temperature is high enough for higher order and non - linear mechanisms beyond those captured by a single relaxation time to be significant .
also noteworthy , the thermal conductivity derived from the bte model displays perfect @xmath83 scaling , whereas the md estimates show slightly stronger decay with temperature .
fig.[fig : vol_cond ] shows the thermal conductivity estimated with md gk for pressures in the range 1400 gpa and temperatures 10004000 k , and table[tab : kappa ] gives the corresponding data for both the b1 and b2 phases . in fig.[fig :
vol_cond ] the phase of the samples used to create the contour plot are marked and a few of the high temperature , relatively low pressure systems melted . as can be seen in table[tab : kappa ] , the estimated thermal conductivity for the b1 and b2 phases have comparable values and same trends .
this is plausible given that the elastic properties of the two phases are similar and a simple kinetic model of thermal transport indicates that the resulting comparable sound speeds should lead to similar conductivities .
the same basic kinetic interpretation is consistent with the observations that the thermal conductivity increases with increased pressure due to higher wave speeds and with lower temperature due to relatively less scattering and longer phonon mean free path .
these trends are monotonic and have decreasing effect on the thermal conductivity .
although the belonoshko potential was tuned to high pressure conditions , we also calculated the thermal conductivity nearer ambient conditions .
the values we obtain , _
e.g._2.8@xmath840.2 w / mk at 1 gpa , 1000 k and 1.8@xmath840.2 w / mk at 1 atm , 1200 k ( melt , refer to table[tab : kappa ] ) are roughly comparable to the value 1.5 w / mk at 1 atm , 1150 k ( melt ) given by ishi _
et al . _  @xcite using a different empirical potential and the experimental measurements : 15.7 w / mk at 0.1 gpa , 16.3 w / mk at 1.0 gpa , 300 k @xcite , and 4.0 w / mk at 1 atm , 314
k @xcite of solid lif .      for this study , we compressed one direction of a b1 lif crystal while fixing the lateral dimension to a 4.02   lattice spacing to mimic initial phases of ramp compression with inertial confinement and examine the resulting differences in the thermal conductivity resulting from unequal principal strains .
the compression direction was chosen to be @xmath85 , since this direction lacks surface polarization .
the lateral directions were @xmath86 ( equivalent to @xmath85 ) and @xmath87 , respectively .
the compressions @xmath88 examined corresponded to normal stresses 150 gpa in the compressed dimension ( note that 75 gpa md crystal was unstable and a dislocation formed ) and temperature range 10003000 k. it was not possible to predict which phases were thermodynamically stable over this deformation  temperature range since we predicted that b2 has unstable phonons over the range we examined .
the phdos for b1 , fig.[fig : uniaxial_pdos ] , shows that the compressed direction becomes stiffer ( the sound speed is roughly inversely proportional to slope of phdos ) and higher frequency content is added to the phonon spectrum .
fig.[fig : uniaxial_anisotropy ] shows stress response to these conditions and corresponding anisotropy of the thermal conductivity of the b1 structure .
note that the initial lattice constant is not equilibrium at the given temperatures which immediately induces the anisotropy shown .
also the lateral stresses become nearly equal but distinct from the normal stress in the compressed direction as the structure loses perfect crystallinity .
fig.[fig : uniaxial_conductivity ] shows that the normal conductivity follows similar trends with temperature and pressure as in the volumetric compression case , namely in this state the highest conductivities are at the highest pressures and lowest temperatures .
the data for this study is tabulated in table[tab : uniaxial_kappa ] .
in summary , we found that the thermal conductivity of lif at high temperatures and pressures is only marginally dependent on phase and ranged from about 5 w / mk to 70 w / mk over the range 10004000 k and 100400 gpa .
for our purposes , the fact that the two expected phases ( b1 and b2 ) have similar conductivity offsets the difficulties in determining their mechanical and thermodynamic stability .
our estimates are corroborated by the limited experimental data available as well as direct _ ab initio _ estimates of thermal conductivity .
we also found that the uniaxial deformation expected to result from inertia confinement of the targeted ramp compression experiments may lead to significant anisotropy in the thermal conductivity .
more rigorous treatment of the relative phase stability exist in the literature than the method we selected , notably [ monserrat2013anharmonic ] which focussed on the influence of the anaharmonic phonon energy and [ desjarlais2013first ] which adapts the phase coexistence technique of [ lin2003two ] to finite temperature dft calculations , which may shed light on phase transitions from b1 at high temperatures and pressures . since our findings indicate that these transitions are unlikely over our temperature and pressure range of interest , whereas the formation of defects appear at relatively low uniaxial compression we intend to pursue investigation of the influence of defects on the thermal conductivity of solid lif next .
we thank luke shulenberger , catalin spataru and thomas mattsson for helpful guidance and appreciate the use of lammps @xcite , vasp @xcite , and phonopy @xcite .
this work was supported by the nnsa advanced simulation and computing - physics and engineering models program at sandia national laboratories .
sandia is a multiprogram laboratory managed and operated by sandia corporation , a wholly owned subsidiary of lockheed martin corporation , for the u.s .
department of energy s national nuclear security administration under contract no .
de - ac04 - 94al85000 .    10    sandia national laboratories , http://www.sandia.gov / z - machine/. , 2015 .
de  fratanduono , tr  boehly , ma  barrios , dd  meyerhofer , jh  eggert , rf  smith , dg  hicks , pm  celliers , dg  braun , and gw  collins .
refractive index of lithium fluoride ramp compressed to 800 gpa .
, 109(12):123521 , 2011 .
pa  rigg and ym  gupta .
real - time x - ray diffraction to examine elastic
plastic deformation in shocked lithium fluoride crystals .
, 73(12):16551657 , 1998 .
md  knudson , dl  hanson , je  bailey , ca  hall , jr  asay , and c  deeney .
principal hugoniot , reverberating wave , and mechanical reshock measurements of liquid deuterium to 400 gpa using plate impact techniques .
, 69(14):144209 , 2004 .
bm  lalone , ov  fatanov , jr  asay , and ym  gupta .
velocity correction and refractive index changes for [ 100 ] lithium fluoride optical windows under shock compression , recompression , and unloading . , 103(9):093505 , 2008 .
dg  hicks , tr  boehly , pm  celliers , jh  eggert , sj  moon , dd  meyerhofer , and gw  collins .
laser - driven single shock compression of fluid deuterium from 45 to 220 gpa .
, 79(1):014112 , 2009 .
bj  jensen , db  holtkamp , pa  rigg , and dh  dolan .
accuracy limits and window corrections for photon doppler velocimetry . , 101(1):013523 , 2007 .
pa  rigg , md  knudson , rj  scharff , and rs  hixson . determining the refractive index of shocked [ 100 ] lithium fluoride to the limit of transmissibility .
, 116(3):033515 , 2014 .    catalin  d spataru , luke shulenburger , and lorin  x benedict .
ab initio many - body green s function calculations of optical properties of lif at high pressures . , 92(24):245117 , 2015 .
philip  d thacher .
effect of boundaries and isotopes on the thermal conductivity of lif .
, 156(3):975 , 1967 .
s  andersson and g  backstrom .
thermal conductivity and heat capacity of single - crystal lif and caf@xmath89 under hydrostatic pressure .
, 20(35):5951 , 1987 .
n.  a. smirnov .
ab initio _ calculations of the thermodynamic properties of lif crystal . , 83:014109 , 2011 .
sb  kormer
. optical study of the characteristics of shock - compressed condensed dielectrics .
, 11(2):229254 , 1968 .
reinhard boehler , marvin ross , and david  b boercker .
melting of lif and nacl to 1 mbar : systematics of ionic solids at extreme conditions .
, 78(24):4589 , 1997 .
seth root , luke shulenburger , raymond  w lemke , daniel  h dolan , thomas  r mattsson , and michael  p desjarlais .
shock response and phase transitions of mgo at planetary impact conditions .
, 115(19):198501 , 2015 .
j  clerouin , y  laudernet , v  recoules , and s  mazevet .
study of the optical properties of shocked lif .
, 72(15):155122 , 2005 .
a.  b. belonoshko , r.  ahuja , and b.  johansson .
molecular dynamics of lif melting . , 61(18):1192811935 , 2000 .
d.  a. young .
molecular dynamics simulation of swift ion damage in lithium fluoride .
, 225:231240 , 2004 .
v  nsslein and u  schrder .
calculations of dispersion curves and specific heat for lif and nacl using the breathing shell model .
, 21(1):309314 , 1967 .
g  dolling , hg  smith , rm  nicklow , pr  r vijayaraghavan , and mk  wilkinson .
lattice dynamics of lithium fluoride .
, 168(3):970 , 1968 .
v.  v. stegailov .
stability of lif crystal in the warm dense matter state .
, 50(1):3134 , 2010 .
l.  onsager .
reciprocal relations in irreversible processes .
i. , 37(4):405426 , 1931 .
l.  onsager .
reciprocal relations in irreversible processes .
ii . , 38(12):22652279 , 1931 .    m.  s. green .
markoff random processes and the statistical mechanics of time - dependent phenomena .
2 . irreversible processes in fluids . , 22:398413 , 1954 .
r.  kubo .
statistical - mechanical theory of irreversible processes .
i. general theory and simple applications to magnetic and conduction problems .
, 12:570586 , 1957 .
r.  kubo , m.  yokota , and s.  nakajima .
statistical - mechanical theory of irreversible processes .
ii . response to thermal disturbance .
, 12:12031211 , 1957 .
r.  zwanzig .
elementary derivations of time - correlation formulas for transport coefficients . , 40:25272533 , 1964 .
g  ciccotti , g  jacucci , and ir  mcdonald .
transport properties of molten alkali halides . , 13(1):426 , 1976
.    p.  j.  d. lindan and m.  j. gillan . a molecular dynamics study of the thermal conductivity of caf@xmath89 and uo@xmath89 .
, 3:39293939 , 1991 .
n.  galamaba and c.  a. nieto  de castro .
thermal conductivity of molten alkali halides from equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations .
, 120(18):86768682 , 2004 .
y.  ishii , k.  sato , m.  salanne , p.  a. madden , and n.  ohtori .
thermal conductivity of molten alkali metal fluorides ( lif , naf , kf ) and their mixtures .
, 118:33853391 , 2014 .
norikazu ohtori , mathieu salanne , and paul  a madden .
calculations of the thermal conductivities of ionic materials by simulation with polarizable interaction potentials .
, 130(10):104507 , 2009 .
mathieu salanne , dario marrocchelli , cline merlet , norikazu ohtori , and paul  a madden . thermal conductivity of ionic systems from equilibrium molecular dynamics .
, 23(10):102101 , 2011 .
yoshiki ishii , keisuke sato , mathieu salanne , paul  a madden , and norikazu ohtori .
thermal conductivity of molten alkali metal fluorides ( lif , naf , kf ) and their mixtures .
118(12):33853391 , 2014 .    y.  cherednikov , n.  a. inogamov , and h.  m. urbassek . influence of defects on extreme ultraviolet laser ablation of lif .
, 88:134109 , 2013 .
m.  tosi .
cohesive energy of the alkali halide crystals .
, 24(7):965967 , 1963 .
mp  tosi and fg  fumi .
ionic sizes and born repulsive parameters in the nacl - type alkali halides - ii : the generalized huggins - mayer form . , 25(1):4552 , 1964 .
g  jacucci , ir  mcdonald , and a  rahman .
effects of polarization on equilibrium and dynamic properties of ionic systems .
, 13(4):1581 , 1976 .    alfredo  a correa , lorin  x benedict , david  a young , eric schwegler , and stanimir  a bonev .
first - principles multiphase equation of state of carbon under extreme conditions .
, 78:024101 , 2008 .    alfredo  a correa , stanimir  a bonev , and giulia galli .
carbon under extreme conditions : phase boundaries and electronic properties from first - principles theory .
, 103(5):12041208 , 2006 .
md  knudson , mp  desjarlais , and dh  dolan .
shock - wave exploration of the high - pressure phases of carbon .
, 322(5909):18221825 , 2008 .
j.  h. irving and j.  g. kirkwood .
the statistical mechanical theory of transport processes .
iv . the equations of hydrodynamics .
, 18:817829 , 1950 .
k.  k. mandadapu , r.  e. jones , and p.  papadopoulos .
generalization of the homogeneous non - equilibrium molecular dynamics method for calculating thermal conductivity to multi - body potentials .
, 80(4):047702 , 2009 .    p.  k. schelling , s.  r. phillpot , and p.  keblinski .
comparison of atomic - level simulation methods for computing thermal conductivity .
, 65(14):14430612 , 2002 .    m.  l. huggins and j.  e. mayer .
interatomic distances in crystals of the alkali halides . , 1(9):643646 , 1933 .
m.  l. huggins .
lattice energies , equilibrium distances , compressibilities and characteristic frequencies of alkali halide crystals . , 5(2):143148 , 1937 .
m.  l. huggins .
errata : lattice energies , equilibrium distances , compressibilities and characteristic frequencies of alkali halide crystals .
, 15(4):212 , 1947 .
paul  peter ewald .
die berechnung optischer und elektrostatischer gitterpotentiale .
, 369(3):253287 , 1921 .
roger  w hockney and james  w eastwood . .
crc press , 2010 .
naoki karasawa and william  a goddard  iii .
acceleration of convergence for lattice sums .
, 93(21):73207327 , 1989 .
david  m heyes .
pressure tensor of partial - charge and point - dipole lattices with bulk and surface geometries .
, 49(2):755 , 1994 .
timothy  w sirk , stan moore , and eugene  f brown .
characteristics of thermal conductivity in classical water models .
, 138(6):064505 , 2013 .
paolo giannozzi , stefano de  gironcoli , pasquale pavone , and stefano baroni .
ab initio calculation of phonon dispersions in semiconductors .
, 43(9):7231 , 1991 .
g  kresse , j  furthmller , and j  hafner .
ab initio force constant approach to phonon dispersion relations of diamond and graphite .
, 32(9):729 , 1995 .
xavier gonze and changyol lee .
dynamical matrices , born effective charges , dielectric permittivity tensors , and interatomic force constants from density - functional perturbation theory .
55(16):10355 , 1997 .    martin  t dove . , volume  4 .
cambridge university press , 1993 .
cj  kimmer and re  jones .
continuum constitutive models from analytical free energies .
, 19(32):326207 , 2007 .
georg kresse and d  joubert . from ultrasoft pseudopotentials to the projector augmented - wave method .
, 59(3):1758 , 1999 .
university of vienna , http://www.vasp.at . , 2015 .
a  togo and i  tanaka .
first principles phonon calculations in materials science . , 108:15 , 2015 .
a. togo , kyoto university , http://atztogo.github.io/phonopy . , 2015 .
lewis  s combes , stanley  s ballard , and kathryn  a mccarthy .
mechanical and thermal properties of certain optical crystalline materials . , 41(4):215221 , 1951 .
smirnov @xcite apparently omits the pressure dependence despite deriving the pressure dependence of the stability moduli in an earlier co - authored publication @xcite .
nevertheless , the shear stability criteria used in ref.+ coincide with those derived in app.+[app : stability ] .
we also calculated the enthalpy difference with the generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) but it had a downward trend with pressure which we attributed to gga tendency to over - binding .
nikolas antolin , oscar  d restrepo , and wolfgang windl .
fast free - energy calculations for unstable high - temperature phases . , 86(5):054119 , 2012 .
bartomeu monserrat , nd  drummond , and rj  needs .
anharmonic vibrational properties in periodic systems : energy , electron - phonon coupling , and stress .
, 87(14):144302 , 2013 .
sandia national laboratories , http://lammps.sandia.gov . , 2015 .
lc  carrison and cb  sclar .
the compressibility and thermal expansion of lif to 60 kbar and 600 c as determined by x - ray diffraction : report of progress . , 13:167 , 1971 .
a  pirth and jen slyom . ,
volume  1 .
springer science & business media , 2007 .
thomas  b douglas and james  l dever .
lithium fluoride : heat content from 0 to 900@xmath90 , the melting point and heat of fusion .
, 76(19):48264829 , 1954 .
c  dames and g  chen . thermal conductivity of nanostructured thermoelectric materials . in d.
m. rowe , editor , _ thermoelectrics handbook : macro to nano _
, page  42 .
crc press , boca raton , fl , 2006 .
keivan esfarjani , gang chen , and harold  t stokes .
heat transport in silicon from first - principles calculations .
, 84(8):085204 , 2011 .
atsushi togo , laurent chaput , and isao tanaka .
distributions of phonon lifetimes in brillouin zones . , 91(9):094306 , 2015 .
a. togo , kyoto university , http://atztogo.github.io/phono3y .
, 2015 .
wu  li , jess carrete , nebil  a. katcho , and natalio mingo . a solver of the boltzmann transport equation for phonons .
, 185:17471758 , 2014 .    michael  p desjarlais .
first - principles calculation of entropy for liquid metals .
, 88(6):062145 , 2013 .
shiang - tai lin , mario blanco , and william  a goddard  iii . the two - phase model for calculating thermodynamic properties of liquids from molecular dynamics
: validation for the phase diagram of lennard - jones fluids .
, 119(22):1179211805 , 2003 .
jacques hadamard . .
courier corporation , 1922 .
max born and kun huang . .
oxford university press , 1998 .
robin  john knops and ew  wilkes .
theory of elastic stability(liapunov functions application to stability analysis of dynamic systems and elastic bodies , considering eigenfunction method , maximum principle and energy criterion ) . , pages 125302 , 1973 .
frederick milstein and rodney hill .
theoretical properties of cubic crystals at arbitrary pressure iii . stability .
, 27(3):255279 , 1979 .    frederick milstein and rodney hill .
divergences among the born and classical stability criteria for cubic crystals under hydrostatic loading . , 43(19):1411 , 1979 .
jinghan wang , ju  li , sidney yip , simon phillpot , and dieter wolf .
mechanical instabilities of homogeneous crystals .
, 52:1262712635 , nov 1995 .
duane  c wallace . .
courier corporation , 1998 .
jw  morris  jr and cr  krenn .
the internal stability of an elastic solid .
, 80(12):28272840 , 2000 .
dm  clatterbuck , cr  krenn , marvin  l cohen , and jw  morris  jr .
phonon instabilities and the ideal strength of aluminum . , 91(13):135501 , 2003 .
krystyn  j. van  vliet , ju  li , ting zhu , sidney yip , and subra suresh . quantifying the early stages of plasticity through nanoscale experiments and simulations .
, 67:104105 , mar 2003 .
e  weinan and pingbing ming .
cauchy  born rule and the stability of crystalline solids : static problems . , 183(2):241297 , 2007 .
ronald  e miller and david rodney . on the nonlocal nature of dislocation nucleation during nanoindentation .
, 56(4):12031223 , 2008 .
tj  delph , ja  zimmerman , jm  rickman , and jm  kunz . a local instability criterion for solid - state defects . ,
57(1):6775 , 2009 .
tj  delph and ja  zimmerman .
prediction of instabilities at the atomic scale .
, 18(4):045008 , 2010 .
flix mouhat and franois - xavier coudert .
necessary and sufficient elastic stability conditions in various crystal systems .
, 90(22):224104 , 2014 .
jerome  harris weiner . .
courier corporation , 2012 .    a  cemal eringen and erdogan  s suhubi .
. academic press , 1974 .
javier bonet and richard  d wood . .
cambridge university press , 1997 .
g.  v. sinko and n.  a. smirnov .
calculations of elastic constants and thermodynamic properties of bcc , fcc , and hcp al crystals under pressure . , 14(29):6989 , 2002 .
although we employ the pppm method in sec .  [ sec : results ] the gist of how the virial stress and , hence , the heat flux is obtained is easier to explain in the context of the ewald sum ( * ? ? ?
7 ) : @xmath91 where the error function , @xmath92 , and its complement , @xmath93 , play the role of a blending / cutoff function with parameter @xmath94{v } $ ] , and @xmath95 is a relative position vector .
note we have used the fourier transforms @xmath96 = \sum_\alpha \exp \imath { \mathbf{k}}\cdot { \mathbf{x}}_\alpha$ ] and @xmath97 = \frac{1}{\|{\mathbf{k}}\|^2 } \exp\left ( -\frac{1}{4 } \|{\mathbf{k}}\|^2 \ell^2 \right ) $ ] .
it follows , after dropping the species subscripts @xmath98 for clarity , that the per - atom energy for pair potentials is @xmath99 _ cf .
_  [ heyes1994pressure](eq . 8) .
thus , the expression for the per - atom virial stress @xmath11 @xcite is : @xmath100 \frac{1}{r_{\alpha\beta}^3 }   { \mathbf{x}}_{\alpha\beta } \otimes { \mathbf{x}}_{\alpha\beta }    \\ & - \frac{2\pi}{\epsilon v } \sum_{{\mathbf{k}}\neq\mathbf{0 } } \left| \sum_\alpha q_\alpha \exp \imath { \mathbf{k}}\cdot{\mathbf{x}}_\alpha \right|^2 \frac{1}{\| { \mathbf{k}}\|^2}{\exp\left ( -\frac{1}{4}{\| { \mathbf{k}}\|^2 \ell^2}\right ) } \left [ { \mathbf{i}}- \left ( \frac{2}{\| { \mathbf{k}}\|^2 } + \frac{1}{2 } \ell^2 \right ) { \mathbf{k}}\otimes { \mathbf{k}}\right ] \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath101 is the identity tensor and @xmath102 , _ cf .
_  [ heyes1994pressure](eq .
many versions of the elastic moduli tensor exist at finite deformations like those investigated in this study and the elastic stability of crystal lattices and elastic materials has been well studied , see , _
e.g. _ , refs .. to connect continuum , elastic stability to atomic , phonon stability , we will assume the current positions @xmath12 are given by small time - varying displacements @xmath103 due to phonon modes superposed on large , static deformations characterized by a homogeneous deformation of the zero temperature , equilibrium lattice @xmath104 @xmath105 since a homogeneous deformation maintains equilibrium , @xmath106 , and hence the ( linearized ) newton equation governing the phonon modes is @xmath107 likewise , in the continuum limit , such that @xmath108 , the linearized balance of momentum @xmath109 governs the long - wavelength elastic waves .
here , @xmath110 is the mass density in reference configuration @xmath111 . since background stress @xmath112 is homogeneous the system is also in equilibrium at the continuum level .
the elasticity tensor @xmath113 of the first piola - kirchoff stress @xmath49 with respect to the deformation gradient has an atomic - level definition @xmath114_{ij } { \mathbf{e}}_i \otimes { \mathbf{x}}_\alpha \otimes { \mathbf{e}}_j \otimes { \mathbf{x}}_\beta = \frac{1}{v_0 } \sum_{\alpha,\beta } \left [ { \mathbb{k}}_{\alpha\beta } \right]_{ij } { \mathbf{e}}_i \otimes { \mathbf{x}}_\alpha \otimes { \mathbf{e}}_j \otimes { \mathbf{x}}_\beta \\ \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath115 .
further manipulation leads to @xmath116 \\ = & \frac{1}{v_0 } \sum_{a , b , c , d , i , j=1}^3 \left [ { \mathbb{c}}_{abcd } { \mathbf{f}}_{ia } { \mathbf{f}}_{jc } + { \mathbf{s}}_{bd } \delta_{ij } \right ]   { \mathbf{e}}_i \otimes { \mathbf{e}}_b \otimes { \mathbf{e}}_j \otimes { \mathbf{e}}_d \end{split}\ ] ] relating @xmath113 to the more familiar elasticity tensor @xmath117 of the symmetric second piola - kirchoff stress @xmath118 with respect to the lagrange strain @xmath119 _ cf .
_  [ weiner2012statistical](eq .
4.6.11 ) . using the chain rule @xmath120 , eq.([eq : bmom0 ]
) can be written as : @xmath121 based on the push - forward of @xmath113 ( * ? ? ?
4.2.34 ) : @xmath122_{ijkl } = \frac{1}{\det({\mathbf{f } } ) } \sum_{j , l }   \left [ { \mathbb{b}}\right]_{ijkl } \left[{\mathbf{f}}\right]_{jj } \left[{\mathbf{f}}\right]_{ll }   = \left [ { { \mathbbold{c}}}\right]_{ijkl } + \left [ { \boldsymbol{\sigma}}\right]_{ik } \delta_{jl}\ ] ] where @xmath123 is the push - forward of @xmath124 by the deformation gradient : @xmath125_{ijkl } = \frac{1}{\det({\mathbf{f } } ) } \sum_{i , j , k , l }   \left [ { \mathbb{c}}\right]_{ijkl } \left[{\mathbf{f}}\right]_{ii } \left[{\mathbf{f}}\right]_{jj } \left[{\mathbf{f}}\right]_{kk } \left[{\mathbf{f}}\right]_{ll}\ ] ]    the legendre - hadamard criterion for dynamic stability requires that all infinitesimal plane waves @xmath126 have real - valued wave speeds . here ,
@xmath23 and @xmath127 are the amplitude and polarization of the displacement ( such that @xmath128 ) , and @xmath129 and @xmath130 are the wave number and propagation direction ( such that @xmath131 ) .
this leads to an eigenvalue problem for the dyad @xmath132 and the strong ellipticity condition @xmath133_{ijkl } n_i p_j n_k p_l > 0\ ] ] this condition is satisfied when all the eigenvalues of the square matrix @xmath134 are all real and positive .
the moduli that vasp and other codes calculate are derivatives of the current , cauchy stress with respect to small strains about a given configuration , which is not @xmath123 . to connect @xmath135 to the moduli obtained from perturbing the system about a given ( not necessarily stress - free reference ) configuration , we start with the derivative of the cauchy stress with respect to a displacement @xmath136 about a deformed state @xmath137 @xmath138 \bar{{\mathbf{f } } } \bar{{\mathbf{s } } } \bar{{\mathbf{f}}}^t    + \frac{1}{\det({\mathbf{f } } ) }   \left [ \partial_{\mathbf{x}}{\mathbf{u}}\right ] \bar{{\mathbf{f } } } \bar{{\mathbf{s } } } \bar{{\mathbf{f}}}^t \\ & + \frac{1}{\det({\mathbf{f } } ) }                    \bar{{\mathbf{f } } } \ , \partial_{\mathbf{e}}\bar{{\mathbf{s } } } \bar{{\mathbf{f}}}^t \ , \frac{1}{2 }   \left [ \partial_{\mathbf{x}}^t { \mathbf{u}}+   \partial_{\mathbf{x}}^t { \mathbf{u}}\right ]   \bar{{\mathbf{f } } }   \bar{{\mathbf{f}}}^t + \frac{1}{\det({\mathbf{f } } ) }                    \bar{{\mathbf{f } } } \bar{{\mathbf{s } } } \bar{{\mathbf{f}}}^t ( \partial_{\mathbf{x}}^t { \mathbf{u } } ) \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] formed from the basic gteaux derivatives in [ bonetwood](eqs . 3.69 , 3.71 , and 3.76 ) .
we recognize that the third term on the right - hand side is @xmath123 and @xmath139 in the other terms , so that we can form the frchet derivative of the cauchy stress with respect to the small strain measure @xmath140 as : @xmath141_{ijkl } = - \bar{{\boldsymbol{\sigma}}}_{ij } \delta_{kl }   +   \delta_{il } \bar{{\boldsymbol{\sigma}}}_{jk }    +   \delta_{jk } \bar{{\boldsymbol{\sigma}}}_{il }    + { { \mathbbold{c}}}_{ijkl}\ ] ] which is the typical moduli calculated by finite differences or perturbation in terms of the current stress @xmath139 and push - forward of the tensor of the traditional elasticities @xmath124 to the current state .
eq.([eq : frechet ] ) is identical in form to corresponding equations in the often cited [ wang1995mechanical ] , and in the independently derived [ sinko2002ab ] , but differs in the interpretation as moduli about a deformed state finitely far from the relaxed , stress - free material .
when eq.([eq : frechet ] ) is combined with eq.([eq : smallbb ] ) , the stability requirement can be applied to : @xmath142_{ijkl}\ ] ] for our purposes it suffices to find the stability conditions for an orthotropic modulus tensor @xmath143 and a diagonal stress tensor @xmath144 .
following [ mouhat2014necessary ] , we obtain : @xmath145 where @xmath146 , @xmath147 ; @xmath148 , @xmath149 , @xmath150 ; and we have used @xmath151 to denote the components of @xmath152 $ ] using traditional voigt notation .
this reduces to @xmath153 for cubic symmetry and a hydrostatic pressure @xmath154 .
these stability criteria differ from those in [ wang1995mechanical ] and [ sinko2002ab ] in that the shear conditions are unaffected by the pressure and the volumetric instability criterion on the bulk modulus @xmath155 is offset by the pressure only .