there is no currently accepted scenario for the formation of the parent bodies of primitive meteorites which accounts for the most obvious of their properties .
these properties ( reviewed by scott and krot 2005 and discussed in more detail in section 2.1 ) include ( a ) dominance by aerodynamically well - sorted mineral particles of sub - mm size ; ( b ) class - to - class variation in well - defined physical , chemical , and isotopic properties ; ( c ) a spread of 1 myr or so between the formation times of the oldest and youngest objects found in the same meteorite ; ( d ) a spread of 1 - 3 myr in radiometric ages of different meteorite types ; and ( e ) a dearth of melted asteroids , with model results for even some melted asteroids which imply myr delays in formation relative to ancient minerals . in recent years , meteoritic evidence has appeared for some very early - formed planetesimals , which represent a minority of both meteorites and asteroids .
this implies that primary accretion started early and continued for several million years - thus , it was fairly inefficient and did not run quickly to completion .
most current models for this  primary accretion " stage ( reviewed by cuzzi and weidenschilling 2006 and dominik et al 2007 ) can be classified as either ( a ) incremental growth , where large particles sweep up smaller ones by inelastic collisions involving porous surfaces , and growth proceeds hierarchically ; or ( b ) instability , where physical sticking is irrelevant and collective effects drive collapse to km - sizes or larger on very short timescales . those who favor instability models , most of which rely on gravity and
occur in a particle - rich nebula midplane , are concerned by the poorly understood sticking of mineral particle aggregates and the apparent difficulty of growing beyond meter size due to rapid inward migration and collisional disruption .
those who favor incremental growth have noted that midplane instability models are precluded by even very weak global turbulence , and that , in the dense midplane layers that form when turbulence is absent , incremental accretion is at low relative velocity and the meter - size barrier is not a problem .
however , the most sophisticated models of incremental accretion in nonturbulent nebulae find it to be _ so _ efficient that large planetesimals grow in only @xmath0 years throughout the asteroid belt region ( weidenschilling 2000 ) , a short time which is difficult to reconcile with constraints ( a - e ) above .
a third class of scenario suggests that a complex interplay between several nonlinear processes - turbulence , pressure gradients , and gravity - may concentrate appropriately sized particles and lead to planetesimal growth ( cuzzi et al 2001 , 2005 , 2007 ; johansen et al 2006 , 2007 ) .
scenarios which involve preferentially meter - sized objects encounter concerns about whether meter - sized objects can survive their own high - velocity mutual collisions in this sort of turbulent environment ( _ cf .
_ sirono 2000 , langkowski et al 2007 , ormel et al 2007 ) .
however , in principle , such boulder - concentration scenarios can proceed independently in the same environment as discussed in this paper , where we focus on mm - size particles .
most of the above scenarios provide no natural explanation for observed meteorite properties ( a ) and ( b ) above .
in particular , the evidence for the h chondrite class ( and perhaps all the ordinary chondrites ) suggests that entire asteroids of 10 - 100 km diameter formed directly from a physically , chemically , and isotopically homogeneous mix of dust - rimmed particles of similar size ( section 2.1 ) . in this paper
, we outline a possible path by which entire batches of mm - size , aerodynamically sorted particles might proceed directly in turbulence ( even if sporadically ) to planetesimals having the properties outlined above .
we find that sufficiently large and dense clumps of mm - size particles can form by turbulent concentration such that , even if classical gravitational instability ca nt operate , their self - gravity may still allow them to survive disruptive forces and slowly sediment into a  sandpile " planetesimal .
this simple analytical model is backed up by some numerical simulations that support the basic idea . in sections 2.2 and 2.3
, we review the most relevant physics that determines the properties of dense , particle - rich zones or clumps in turbulent nebulae . in section 3
, we address the fate of these dense clumps using analytical and numerical models of their evolution .
we derive the combination of size and mass density a clump must have to evolve into a  sandpile " having some degree of internal strength . in subsequent stages not modeled here , we imagine that collisions and thermal sintering transform these sandpiles into the cohesive rocky parent bodies we see today .
however , in the outer solar system , lower energy collisions and weaker thermal processing might well allow planetesimals to retain their initial low - strength states , as seen for some cometary objects ( _ eg .
, _ asphaug and benz 1996 ) .
one can extract a number of clues from primitive ( unmelted ) meteorites regarding the primary accretion process by which their parent bodies first formed ( scott and krot 2005 , taylor 2005 ) . for the best evidence , one must look back through extensive subsequent evolutionary stages .
even unmelted bodies in the 100 km size range have incurred extensive collisional evolution ( bischoff et al .
2006 ) , producing compaction , fragmentation , and physical grinding and mixing on and beneath their surfaces , which may obscure the record of primary accretion .
model studies ( _ e.g. _ , petit et al 2001 , kenyon and bromley 2004 , 2006 ; bottke et al 2005 ; chambers 2004,2006 ; weidenschilling and cuzzi 2006 ) suggest that the collisional stage occurred after dispersal of the nebula gas allowed the orbital eccentricities of primitive bodies to grow .
we are concerned with an earlier stage , when the still - abundant nebula gas led to a more benign environment with fewer and gentler collisions .
the direct products of primary accretion might be most clearly visible in the rare  primary texture " seen in some cm ( metzler et al 1992 ) and co ( brearley 1993 ) chondrites . in these objects , or more specifically in unbroken fragments within them , the texture consists of similarly - sized , dust - rimmed particles packed next to each other as if gently brought together and compressed , with no evidence for local fracturing or grinding .
even after collisional effects associated with subsequent stages of growth have blurred this signal , perhaps even mixing material from different parent bodies , evidence remains in the bulk properties of all chondrite classes .
chondrite classes are defined by their distinctive mineral , chemical , and isotopic properties ( _ e.g. _ grossman et al 1988 , scott and krot 2005 , weisberg et al 2006 ) .
large samples of material with a quite well defined nature were accumulated at one place and/or time , and material of a quite different , but equally well - defined , nature was accumulated at another place and/or time into a different parent body . amongst the most obvious aspects of these class properties is a dominance within chondrites of sub - mm size mineral particles ( generically  chondrules " ; grossman 1988 , jones et al 2000 , 2005 ; connolly et al 2006 ) which are aerodynamically well - sorted .
aerodynamic sorting of chondrite components was first emphasized by dodd ( 1976 ) , hughes ( 1978 , 1980 ) , and skinner and leenhouts ( 1993 ) , and has since been discussed by a variety of authors ( see cuzzi and weidenschilling 2006 for a summary of the observations and arguments supporting aerodynamics ) .
chondrules have a size which varies from class to class , but is distinctive and narrowly defined within a given class or chondrite .
the evidence suggests that chondrules do not comprise merely a thin surface layer swept up by a large object ( scott 2006 ) . in the case which we suggest as an archetype , the h - type ordinary chondrite parent body is widely believed to be a 100 km radius object ( perhaps the asteroid hebe ) , initially composed entirely of a physically , chemically , and isotopically homogeneous mix of chondrules and associated material , which was thermally metamorphosed by accreted @xmath1al to a degree which varied with depth , into an onion - shell structure , and subsequently broken up in several stages ( taylor et al 1987 , trieloff et al 2003 , mcsween et al 2002 , grimm et al 2005 ) .
bottke et al ( 2005 ) conclude from models of collisional evolution in the primordial ( massive ) and the current ( depleted ) asteroid belt , that the primordial asteroid mass distribution was dominated by objects having diameter of around 100 km , rather than having a powerlaw size distribution somewhat like that of the current population .
we see the essential challenge as understanding how such a large object can be assembled from such a homogeneous mixture of mm - size constituents , while other objects ( arguably the parents of the l and ll type ordinary chondrites as well , and logically then the parents of the chondrites of all classes ) are assembled from distinct , yet comparably homogeneous , ensembles of qualitatively similar particles .
moreover this assembly , or primary accretion , phase of nebula evolution must persist for a duration of 1myr or more between the formation times of the oldest and youngest meteorites ( wadhwa et al 2007 ) and even of objects found in the same meteorite .
the @xmath2 1 myr age spread between ancient refractory inclusions ( cais ) and chondrules is well known ( russell et al 2006 ) , but there may even be a comparably extended age spread between different chondrules in a given meteorite ( kita et al 2005 ) .    in recent years , radiometric dating of achondrites ( melted meteorites ) has revealed some early - formed ( and early melted ) planetesimals ( kleine et al 2005 , 2006 ) .
one expects early formation and melting to go together , because objects larger than only 10 km or so , which accreted at the same time that refractory inclusions formed ( 4.567 byr ago ) , would have incorporated their full complement of @xmath1al and would have melted ( latourette and wasserburg 1998 ; woolum and cassen 1999 , hevey and sanders 2006 ) .
thus , early accretion implies melting , and lack of melting requires late accretion .
model results imply that , to avoid complete melting , 100 km bodies must accrete only after a typically 1.5 - 2 myr delay relative to ancient cai minerals ( reviewed by mcsween
et al 2002 and ghosh et al 2006 ) . while unknown selection and sampling effects may influence the limited meteorite data record , spectral analysis of the entire asteroid database
also suggests that melted asteroids are rare .
that is , while debate continues as to whether small amounts of melt might be found on the surfaces of many asteroids , which might be caused by impacts ( _ e.g. _ gaffey et al 1993 , 2002 ) , only vesta and a handful of other examples of fully melted basaltic objects have been found in spite of extensive searches ( binzel et al 2002 ; moskovitz et al 2007 ) .
put together , this body of information suggests that primary accretion started early but continued for several million years - thus , it was inefficient , or at least sporadic . by comparison ,
midplane incremental accretion in a nonturbulent nebula accretes numerous ceres size bodies and tens of thousands of 10 - 100 km size objects in only @xmath3 years ( weidenschilling 2000 ) ; thus , it is highly efficient .
models suggest that the density , temperature , and composition of the nebula evolved significantly over several million years ( bell et al 1995 , dalessio et al .
2005 , ciesla and cuzzi 2006 ) .
thus one expects the properties of forming planetesimals to change with _ time _ even though the chemical , isotopic , and mineralogical properties of the mixture of solids from which they formed might have been fairly uniform in _ space _ at any _ given _ time ( see cuzzi et al 2003 and ciesla 2007 for more detailed discussions ) .
reality might have been even more complicated - there is some evidence that chondrites of very distinct chemical and isotopic properties might have formed at roughly the same time ( kita et al 2005 ) , suggesting a combination of spatial _ and _ temporal gradients .    in this paper
we present the overview of a scenario by which accumulation of a well - defined particle mix into a large planetesimal - making it a  snapshot " of the local nebula mix - might occur sporadically or inefficiently in weak turbulence , over an extended period of time and throughout the terrestrial planet region .
the challenge for the future is to show that the accretion processes discussed here can _ quantitatively _ account for the mass needed to build planetesimals of the mass needed to create planetary embryos and planets during the age of the nebula ( chambers 2004 , 2006 ; cuzzi et al 2007 ) .      a variety of astronomical and meteoritical evidence supports weak , but widespread and sustained , nebula turbulence . the observed abundance of small particles at high altitudes above the midplane in many visible protoplanetary nebulae for millions of years
is most easily explained by ongoing turbulence - both to regenerate the small grains in collisions and to redistribute them to the observed altitudes ( dullemond and dominik 2005 ) .
the survival of ancient , high - temperature mineral inclusions ( cais ) in chondrites , in spite of their tendency to drift inwards towards the sun , can also be explained by turbulent diffusion ( cuzzi et al 2003 , 2005 ) .
moreover , the recent discovery by stardust of both high- and moderate - temperature crystalline silicates in comet wild2 ( brownlee et al 2007 , zolensky et al 2007 ) can be easily understood in this way ( ciesla 2007 ) .
it remains a subject of active theoretical debate as to how , or even whether , the nebula can maintain itself in a turbulent state .
ongoing dissipation by molecular viscosity @xmath4 on the smallest , or kolmogorov , lengthscale requires a production mechanism to continually generate turbulent kinetic energy .
although the very existence of ongoing disk accretion into the star , with the ensuing gravitational energy release , provides an ample energy source , the vehicle for transferring that energy into turbulent gas motions is undetermined .
baroclinic instabilities require substantial opacity at thermal wavelengths , but might be suitable to generate turbulence during the fairly opaque chondrule - cai epoch in the inner solar system ( klahr and bodenheimer 2003 ) .
the widely accepted magnetorotational instability ( mri ) ( stone et al 2000 ) may or may not be precluded at the high gas densities of the inner solar system ( turner et al 2007 ) .
the role of pure hydrodynamics operating on radial shear remains unclear , because keplerian disks are nominally stable to linear ( small ) perturbations ( balbus et al 1996 , stone et al 2000 ) .
however , a number of current theoretical studies suggest turbulence might indeed be present ( _ eg . _ arldt and urpin 2004 , busse 2004 , umurhan and regev 2004 , dubrulle et al 2005 , afshordi et al 2005 , mukhopadhyay et al 2005 , mukhopadhyay et al 2006 ) .
much of this recent work focusses on nonlinear ( finite amplitude ) instabilities occurring at the very high reynolds numbers characterizing the nebula , which are well beyond the capability of current numerical and even laboratory models .    ,
of particles having local concentration factor larger than some value of @xmath5 ( from cuzzi et al 2001 ; see also section 2.3 ) .
the curves with symbols represent comparison of the predictive theory described in cuzzi et al ( 2001 ) with 3d numerical simulations at moderate reynolds numbers ; the curves without symbols are extension of the same theory to nebula conditions denoted by their values of @xmath6 .
concentration factors @xmath7 of chondrule precursors
( leading to @xmath8 ) are fairly common for a range of nebula turbulent intensities ( denoted by @xmath6 ) , and help explain lack of chondrule isotopic fractionation ( cuzzi and alexander 2006 ) . in this paper
we focus on the much less common , but much denser , regions towards the bottom right side of the plot ( @xmath9 or @xmath10 ) .
more general pdfs which separate out the role of vorticity and incorporate the effect of particle mass loading are discussed in section 2.3 and appendix a. , width=297,height=297 ]    in this paper , we simply assume the presence of weak nebula turbulence .
the intensity of turbulence may be characterized by a nondimensional parameter @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the velocity of the most energetic eddies and @xmath13 is the sound speed .
values of @xmath6 in the range @xmath14 are consistent with observed nebula lifetimes , and can be sustained by only a few percent of the gravitational energy released as the nebula disk flows into the sun .
one then estimates the most energetic ( largest ) eddy size as @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is the nebula vertical scale height , or disk thickness . a cascade to smaller scales ensues ,
where the smallest ( kolmogorov ) eddy scale is @xmath17 1 km and @xmath18 for @xmath19 is the nebula reynolds number ( cuzzi et al 2001 ) .
it has been found both numerically and experimentally that particles of a well defined size and density are concentrated into very dense zones in realistic 3d turbulence ( eaton and fessler 1994 ) .
the optimally concentrated particle has a gas drag stopping time @xmath20 which is equal to the overturn time of the kolmogorov scale eddies . in the nebula , @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the particle radius and material density , and @xmath13 and @xmath24 are the gas sound speed and density .
the kolmogorov eddy frequency @xmath25 scales with the orbital frequency @xmath26 as @xmath27 , and particles are most effectively concentrated when @xmath28 ( eaton and fessler 1994 ) .
chondrule - size silicate particles are concentrated for canonical nebula properties if @xmath29 ; moreover the _ shape _ of the concentrated particle size distribution is parameter - independent , and agrees very well with that of chondrules ( paque and cuzzi 1997 , cuzzi et al 2001 ) .
we define the concentration factor @xmath30 , where we denote the local volume mass density of particles as @xmath31 and @xmath32 is its nebula average value , and the particle mass loading @xmath33 . for instance , figure 1 ( cuzzi et al 2001 ) shows the probability distribution function ( pdf ) for @xmath5 determined from numerical simulations at moderate reynolds number ( curves with symbols ) and predicted for plausible nebula reynolds numbers ( curves without symbols ) .
note that the volume fraction having @xmath34 is quite substantial , which helps explain some mineralogical and isotopic properties of chondrules ( cuzzi and alexander 2006 ) .
is different from the definition in cuzzi and alexander ( 2006 ) , which is equivalent to @xmath35 , where @xmath36 is the fractional abundance of solids to hydrogen gas by mass .
thus values of @xmath37 in cuzzi and alexander ( 2006 ) are the equivalent of @xmath38 - a much more common occurrence than the situation we study here .
] not surprisingly , the volume fraction decreases for larger @xmath5 . in this work we focus on the less abundant , but higher mass density , concentrations towards the lower - right hand side of the pdf .
the turbulent concentration pdfs of figure 1 did not allow for the feedback of the concentrated particles on the gas .
this  mass loading " would be expected to damp gas turbulent motions once the particle mass density significantly exceeds that of the gas , and lead to a saturation of concentration at some value .
recent work which _ includes _ the feedback effects , through drag , of particle density on the damping of turbulence , has shown that values of @xmath39 can indeed be achieved - although less commonly than in the unloaded models such as shown in figure 1 .
this _ cascade model _ of turbulent concentration ( hogan and cuzzi 2007 ) is summarized in appendix a. based on these results , we adopt @xmath40 as an upper bound in all stability and evolution modeling .
the ability of gravity to overwhelm opposing forces is a well - known theme in astrophysics , dating back 80 years to early studies of star formation by jeans . over 30 years ago
, gravitational instability ( gi ) of solids in a dense layer near the nebula midplane was proposed to lead directly to solid planetesimals on a dynamical timescale ( the orbit time ) ( safronov 1969 , goldreich and ward 1973 ) .
traditional gi thresholds require the dynamical ( collapse ) time of a dense region @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the gravitational constant , to be shorter than both the transit time due to random velocity and the local shear ( vorticity ) timescale ( toomre 1964 ) .
these arguments imply that gi occurs when the local particle density exceeds a few times the roche density @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is the solar mass and @xmath45 is the distance from the sun ( safronov 1991 , cuzzi et al 2001 ) . however , this scenario is frustrated by self - generated midplane turbulence even if the nebula is not globally turbulent ( _ e.g. _ weidenschilling 1980,1995 ; cuzzi et al 1993,1994 ; johansen et al 2007 ) . that is , a dense layer of cm - size and larger particles orbits at a different velocity than the pressure - supported gas , leading to a vertical velocity shear which becomes turbulent and stirs the particle layer .
a more recent flavor of gi requires the particles to be small enough that the particle - rich midplane acts as a single fluid , like fog , so that its vertical density stratification stabilizes it against self - generated turbulence ( sekiya 1998 , sekiya and ishitsu 2001 , youdin and shu 2002 , sekiya and takeda 2003 , youdin and chiang 2004 ) . because the particles must be very small to satisfy this _
one - phase _ requirement ( mm - size and smaller ) , their settling towards the midplane is frustrated by even the faintest breath of nebula turbulence ( @xmath46 ) .
if the particles are prevented from settling into a sufficiently dense layer that their mass density can stratify the total density ( eg , dubrulle et al 1995 , cuzzi and weidenschilling 2006 ) , the conditions needed to trigger the instability are never achieved .    in the following subsections ,
we study the evolution of a dense clump such as might form towards the lower right domain of figure 1 , albeit in a simplified way .
we treat a clump as an isolated object when in reality it exists in a context of surrounding material of varying density . in section 4
, we discuss the implications of more realistic conditions .
the role of the _ gas pressure _ in gi for nebula particles has been almost universally ignored , even though its importance was pointed out decades ago by sekiya ( 1983 ) .
we encountered it ourselves independently . to test our gi thresholds , we initially ran numerical models of static , but very dense , clumps ( @xmath47 ) , expecting them to collapse with gravitational free - fall or dynamical collapse times @xmath48 and velocities @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is the clump diameter .
we assumed a spherically symmetrical dense particle clump with density @xmath31 , embedded in gas with density @xmath24 , where @xmath51 .
instead , only very slow shrinkage ensued .
we suspected that the collapse was being artificially blocked by our incompressible code .
we then developed a fully compressible 1d model which confirmed our incompressible calculations and clearly demonstrated a much higher , gas - pressure - dependent @xmath37 threshold for gi in the limit when @xmath52 .
results from the model are shown in figure 2 .
is like a mach number .
nebula values of @xmath13 and @xmath24 lie in the top set of nearly linear curves , allowing only slow inward sedimentation on the timescale @xmath53 ( for @xmath54 ) .
that is , under nebula conditions of gas density and temperature , and particle loading , the gas behaves as if it were incompressible and prevents dynamical timescale gi for particles with stopping time much less than the dynamical collapse time.,width=297,height=240 ]    * figure 2 * shows results from this fully compressible model , illustrating how @xmath55 is required for traditional ( dynamical timescale ) instability to occur . the initial condition was a gaussian blob having density distribution @xmath56 .
slow shrinkage of the particles through the gas is seen in the stable ,
incompressible " regime where nebula parameters lie , well within the flat curves at the top of the plot with @xmath57 for @xmath58 km , @xmath59cm / s , and @xmath60 g @xmath61 .
the high value of @xmath62 required for true dynamical timescale collapse ( given the chosen value of @xmath40 ) would require smaller gas sound speed or larger clump size @xmath50 and gas density @xmath24 , by orders of magnitude .    the slow shrinkage in the stable regime results from particles sedimenting inwards towards their mutual center under their own self - gravity at their terminal velocity @xmath63 , where @xmath64 is the local gravitational acceleration due to the clump s mass , and @xmath65 is the particle stopping time .
thus @xmath66 for @xmath52 , and the  sedimentation " timescale is @xmath67 roughly 30 - 300 orbit periods at 2.5 au for 300@xmath68 radius chondrules and @xmath69 ; that is , much longer than @xmath70 .
it seems inappropriate to describe this slow ongoing evolution as an instability - certainly in midplane scenarios where it was slow vertical sedimentation by individual particles toward the midplane that produced the  unstable " situation in the first place , and where only further slow sedimentation transpires .
the situation is more akin to star formation mediated by ambipolar diffusion than by traditional gravitational instability .
gas pressure even precludes the safronov - goldreich - ward gi in the form it was originally proposed , where cm - sized particles were envisioned ( although @xmath53 would be faster for literally cm - sized particles , and more closely approaches @xmath70 ) .
the results of sekiya ( 1983 ) have apparently been overlooked by all subsequent workers , who have invariably assumed a toomre - safronov - goldreich - ward type _ particle _ ensemble which is decoupled from the gas , and stabilized ( on small scales ) only by particle random velocities .
this gas pressure constraint is , however , crucial for particles in the chondrule size regime where @xmath71 an hour and @xmath72 a year , and must be applied to all gi models involving chondrule - sized particles .
the good news is that for the interesting range of nebula gas density and particle concentration values , the gas _ does _ actually behave as if it were incompressible ( validating the use of an incompressible code in numerical models such as shown in section 3.4 ) .
the physics is easily understood in the one - phase regime @xmath73 .
the particles feel no direct pressure force , but are firmly trapped to the gas which does . the ( inward ) gravitational force is dominated by particles for @xmath74 .
the particles drag and compress the gas with them as they begin to collapse under their self - gravity , producing a radial gas density gradient @xmath75 ; this translates into a large outward _ pressure _
gradient @xmath76 which acts on the gas , and thereby also on the strongly coupled particles .
the gravitational force per unit volume is @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the clump mass and @xmath79 its radius .
after some incipient shrinkage and compression occurs , the outward pressure gradient force per unit volume becomes roughly @xmath80 , where @xmath13 is the gas sound speed .
then for gi to be possible , @xmath81 , giving the criterion for gi as @xmath82 , where @xmath83 .
@xmath84 is like an inverse mach number @xmath85 , where @xmath86 .
an alternate ( perturbation ) approach compares the incremental changes @xmath87 and @xmath88 associated with a small gravitationally induced shrinkage characterized by @xmath89 .
it is straightforward to show ( for @xmath90 ) that @xmath91 under nebula conditions .
thus the clump is  stiffened " by pressure and even a small incremental shrinkage is self - limiting . inspection of * figure 2 * shows small oscillations which suggest that a formal linear stability analysis might lead to an improved stability criterion ; this is , however , beyond the scope of the present paper .    for @xmath92 a few @xmath93 km and @xmath60 g @xmath61 ( desch et al 2005 ) , @xmath94 .
this criterion for gi can be compared with the traditional criterion for ( marginal , or maximal ) instability which is widely used as _
the _ criterion for gravitational instability , roughly twice the roche density @xmath43 ( goldreich and ward 1973 , safronov 1991 , cuzzi et al 1993 ) .
the ratio of the two thresholds is : @xmath95 for @xmath96 to @xmath97 . for the midplane gis which have been widely discussed in the past ( reviewed by cuzzi and weidenschilling 2006 ) , @xmath98 km ,
so the traditional gi criterion falls short by a factor of more than @xmath99 ( _ cf . _
sekiya 1983 ) !
this degree of mass concentration is unlikely under any plausible circumstances , especially for particles which are already well trapped to the gas . for the ubiquitous dense clumps we discuss here , which form at all elevations , @xmath100 km .
thus the pressure - supported gas phase prevents the tightly coupled particles from undergoing gi until the particle mass loading is hundreds of times larger than the traditional gi criterion ( which is on the order of the roche density @xmath101 ) .
nevertheless , sekiya ( 1983 ) also noted that when @xmath31 is in the range usually cited for gi ( a few times @xmath101 , or @xmath102 a few hundred ) , a 3d  incompressible mode " arises which , while not explicitly stated , we interpret as retaining an identifiable cohort of particles . an  incompressible mode " might resemble a blob of water oscillating in zero - gravity .
dense zones which result from turbulent concentration are candidates for such incompressible modes , even at mass loadings too low to induce actual gi . however , the fate of such slowly evolving entities in the presence of likely perturbations has never been explored .
below we discuss the least avoidable , most pervasive disruptive perturbation which such clumps would encounter once they form , which we believe to be ram pressure disruption due to systematic velocity differences between the dense zones and the gas , and then derive conditions under which these clumps can survive to become planetesimals .
several kinds of perturbation by the enveloping nebula gas might disrupt a dense clump before the slow sedimentation of its constituent particles towards their mutual center ( on the timescale @xmath53 ) can produce a moderately compact object .    perhaps the simplest to discuss and dismiss are turbulent pressure , velocity , and/or vorticity _ fluctuations _ encountered by the clump .
turbulent pressure fluctuations on the scale @xmath50 have typical intensity @xmath103 , where @xmath104 is certainly smaller than the fluctuating velocity @xmath105 of the largest eddy ( the dominant energy - containing eddy ) .
the ratio of even the largest eddy pressure fluctuations to the steady ram pressure from the headwind @xmath106 ( @xmath45 is the semimajor axis ) is @xmath107 . since @xmath108 and @xmath109 , @xmath110 unless @xmath111 .
nebula evolutionary timescales , and parameters leading to turbulent concentration of chondrule - sized particles in the asteroid belt region , imply @xmath112 depending on gas density and other properties ( cuzzi et al 2001 ) .
this suggests that turbulent velocity fluctuations on clump lengthscales play a small role .
we have run simulations of clumps settling in gravity with and without enveloping turbulence , and the typical evolutions are qualitatively similar .
we next address local _ average _ vorticities on the lengthscale of a clump .
it has long been known that local vorticity is a factor in gravitational instability ( toomre 1964 , goldreich and ward 1973 ) . because eddies much smaller than the largest scale of turbulence typically have larger vorticity than the keplerian shear commonly explored ( _ eg . _
toomre 1964 ) , this is a concern in principle . for example , in the inertial range , @xmath113 ( tennekes and lumley 1972 ) . then for @xmath100 km , @xmath15 and @xmath114 , @xmath115 .
however , turbulent concentration has the property that dense particle zones preferentially lie in zones of locally _ low _ vorticity compared to the average at their lengthscale ( eaton and fessler 1994 ) .
statistical studies ( hogan and cuzzi 2007 ) show that dense zones in high @xmath116 environments can form in regions with local vorticity 1 - 2 orders of magnitude smaller than the average value expected for that lengthscale ( see also figure 5 ) .
below we sketch how such a constraint is derived and applied .
a simplified requirement for gravitational binding of a clump of lengthscale @xmath50 and mass density @xmath31 , in the presence of local rotation at angular velocity @xmath117 , is @xmath118 . recalling that the local vorticity @xmath117 can vary by orders of magnitude from its average value @xmath119 , we normalize both sides of the above relationship between @xmath31 and @xmath120 by the average inertial range enstrophy @xmath121 , and define the normalized enstrophy @xmath122 .
this quantity provides the horizontal axis on figure 5 .
then the simple expression above can be rewritten as @xmath123 .
inertial range relationships can be used to express @xmath124 where @xmath125 is the kolmogorov scale and @xmath126 is some scaling factor . making use of @xmath127 as discussed earlier , and substituting nebula parameters at 2.5 au ,
we find that gravitational binding requires @xmath128 .
this constraint yields diagonal lines on plots of the sort shown in figure 5 ( for an example see cuzzi et al 2007 ) .
interesting regions of parameter space remain accessible to a degree that depends on quantitative modeling of the pdf @xmath129 .
obviously , more detailed numerical models of clumps in realistic turbulence are needed to assess these perturbations .
we will assume , for the purposes of this study , that turbulent pressure ( and associated vorticity ) fluctuations are a minor influence and that regions which are stable to their own local vorticity exist ( see cuzzi et al 2007 ) .
this leaves the dominant disruptive process , unavoidably shared by turbulent and laminar nebulae , as ram pressure disruption due to _ systematic _
velocity differences between the clump and the gas , as described below .
incidentally , survival against ram pressure gives the horizontal stability boundaries in figure 3 of cuzzi et al ( 2007 ) .
emplacing these constraints on pdfs obtained from cascade models is somewhat involved , and a full quantitative description of the situation is deferred to a future paper .      here , for simplicity
, we envision the evolution of a single , isolated dense clump with @xmath74 , merely as an example of one of the many dense clumps formed near the lower right hand corner of figure 1 .
the clump exerts a strong collective influence on the entrained gas , and the mixture experiences solar gravity as a unit .
it attempts to move as an individual large object relative to the nebula gas , dragging the entrained gas along .
for instance , a clump forming at some distance above the nebula midplane settles downward under the acceleration of the vertical component of solar gravity , whereas the surrounding gas remains under vertical hydrostatic balance .
also , nebula gas generally orbits at a slower velocity than the keplerian orbit velocity @xmath130 obeyed by massive particles .
this is because of its generally outward radial pressure gradient force @xmath131 , where @xmath45 is the distance from the sun , and @xmath132 ) .
thus , particles experience a headwind with magnitude @xmath133 a few @xmath93 cm / sec . these headwinds result in a ram pressure @xmath134 which can disrupt a strengthless clump .
for example , a dense drop of ink settling in a glass of water is quickly disrupted by the rayleigh - taylor instability and mixes with its surroundings ( thomson and newhall 1885 ) .
however , a dense drop of fluid _ with surface tension _ can avoid disruption and settle indefinitely at terminal velocity ( as do raindrops , or water in oil ) .
in this situation , the criterion for stability of a fluid droplet , which determines its terminal velocity and thence its size , is given by the weber number @xmath135 , where @xmath136 , and @xmath137 is the surface tension coefficient .
drops are disrupted when @xmath138 exceeds some critical value @xmath139 ( pruppacher and klett 1997 ) .
dense particle clumps in the nebula have no surface tension , but they do have self - gravity . by direct analogy with the droplet surface tension criterion , we define a _ gravitational weber number _ @xmath140 as the ratio of the ram pressure force per unit area to the self - gravitational force per unit area for a flattened disk , which is the initial stage of a strengthless spherical clump of diameter @xmath50 and particle density @xmath141 upon encountering a headwind @xmath142 ( thomson and newhall 1885 ) . for a disk of surface mass density @xmath143 ,
the gravitational force per unit area is @xmath144 .
then @xmath145 where @xmath146 is an effective drag coefficient for the clump , on the order of unity ( see appendix b ) .
@xmath147 can be written in other ways as well .
the orbit frequency at @xmath45 provides the useful relationship @xmath148 , where @xmath149 g @xmath61 at 2.5 au is different from safronov s ( 1991 ) roche density @xmath150 discussed earlier ] ; then @xmath151 by analogy with the more familiar surface tension case , there will be some critical _ gravitational _ weber number for stability @xmath152 , that is probably on the order of unity ( pruppacher and klett 1997 ) ; its value must be constrained by numerical experiments as described below .
then we require for stability against headwind disruption that @xmath153 or @xmath154 these expressions determine the combination of clump diameter @xmath50 and particle loading @xmath37 that will stabilize it against a headwind of magnitude @xmath155 .
the headwind due to nebula radial pressure gradient will occur even if a clump is at the midplane and has zero settling velocity ; this gives the lower limit on ram pressure that the clump must be stable against .
neglecting vertical settling restricts potentially stable clumps to lying within about 0.01 gas scale heights of the midplane , where the headwind @xmath156 is comparable to the vertical settling velocity .
this restriction must be factored into statistical estimates of planetesimal production ( see , e.g. cuzzi et al 2007 ) .    for typical nebula parameters ,
we assume gas density to be in the range @xmath157 g @xmath61 ( a nominal minimum mass value ) to @xmath97 g @xmath61 ( a more recent value supported by nebula evolution and chondrule formation ; _ cf . _ desch et al 2005 ) , semimajor axis @xmath158 cm ( 2.5 au ) , pressure gradient / headwind parameter @xmath132 ( see , _ eg . _ ,
nakagawa et al 1986 , cuzzi et al 1993 ) , and solar mass @xmath159 g . in this regime , @xmath160 km .
recall from section 2.3 and appendix a that mass loading limits the maximum achievable mass loading to @xmath10 .
a clump satisfying the above constraint , with @xmath161 km , would have the mass of a 10 - 100 km radius body of unit density - thus , these precursors can lead to quite sizeable objects .
this characteristic size range is intriguingly close to the roughly 50 km radius primordial building block size of bottke et al ( 2005 ) .
the very existence of _ any _ preferred size for the primordial population , if true , is an intriguing result .      to obtain a sanity check on the concepts of section 3.3 , and to constrain the ( unknown ) value of @xmath162 for this problem
, we developed a very simplified numerical model of a clump experiencing a steady nebula headwind from a more slowly orbiting , pressure - supported gas , using hill s approximation which transforms a cylindrical system into a cartesian system rotating at some mean rate @xmath163 - useful if the domain covers a sufficiently narrow radial and angular region that the curvature is negligible .
the overall orbital motion of particles ( the keplerian velocity ) is thus subtracted out , and the gas exhibits a small differential velocity because of its deviation from keplerian .
a particle clump under influence of the gas will slowly lag behind in the @xmath164 ( orbital ) direction , and slowly drift to smaller @xmath165 ( radial ) values , due to the gas headwind .
the model is not intended to be a high - fidelity representation of a realistic nebula situation , but merely to check the basic weber number model of section 3.3 .
the code evolves the velocity field of a two - phase system .
the gas is perturbed by a clump of particles , which are mutually attracted by gravitational forces and are themselves dragged by , and exchange momentum with , the gas .
the hill frame , with cartesian coordinates @xmath166 , represents a radially narrow region corresponding to some range of radius @xmath45 , orbital angle @xmath167 , and vertical distance @xmath168 , respectively .
periodic boundary conditions are used in all three dimensions .
the instantaneous navier - stokes ( eulerian ) equations describing the conservation of mass and momentum for the incompressible gas are expressed in the hill frame as ,    @xmath169    and    @xmath170    where @xmath171 is fluid velocity , @xmath24 is gas mass density , @xmath172 is gas viscosity , @xmath173 is local pressure ( which fluctuates along with gas velocity and vorticity variations ) , @xmath174 represents the ( constant ) global nebula radial pressure gradient , and @xmath175 is the kepler frequency vector .
this setup causes the gas to flow towards the clump in the @xmath164 direction at a uniform speed @xmath142 .
we are currently neglecting the keplerian radial shear term @xmath176 , where @xmath177 and @xmath178 , in the gas and particle equations to get a better comparison with our analytical stability model . the shear rate associated with this term @xmath179 , whereas a typical ( fluctuating ) local shear or strain due only to turbulent motions is @xmath180 . because the turbulent shear is so widely varying , and likely to be larger than the keplerian shear , in this study we neglect both of these complications , though they are both suitable avenues for future work .    in our code
, particles are followed in the lagrangian sense .
the term @xmath181 represents the force per unit mass imparted to the gas by the particles .
it has the general form @xmath182 where @xmath183 is the mean weighted particle velocity at a grid point , @xmath20 is the particle gas drag stopping time , and @xmath31 is the particle mass density . to obtain @xmath183 , a weighted sum is carried out over particles in the eight cell volumes adjacent to each fluid grid point .
weighting functions are used which vary inversely with the distance of the particle from the grid point ( squires 1990 , his section 5.1 ) .
because of the periodic boundary conditions , the wake of a clump can impinge artificially on the clump from the upwind direction . to avoid this
, we include the term @xmath184 in equation ( 6 ) as a `` sponge force '' per unit mass to restore the gas velocities downstream of the clump at the outflow boundary plane to their initial values @xmath185 ; this ensures constant inflow values at the upstream boundary plane .
the sponge force has the form @xmath186 where @xmath187 is some time scale .
the function @xmath188 is modeled as a sigmoid in the @xmath164 direction very near the outflow boundary .
the parameters of the sponge were determined through test runs with the goals of minimizing the sponge s spatial extent and maximizing its effectiveness without introducing numerical instabilities .
once determined , the same values were used for all production runs .    the ( lagrangian ) equation describing the motion of particle @xmath189 subject to the forces of gas drag and mutual gravity is ( again neglecting the keplerian shear term ) @xmath190 the term @xmath191 describing the drag force per unit mass on particle @xmath189 by the gas takes the form @xmath192 where @xmath193 is the gas velocity interpolated to the particle s position @xmath194 at time @xmath195 .    finally , the mutual gravity force per unit mass on each particle is @xmath196 where @xmath42 is the gravitational constant , and @xmath197 is the number of particles .
@xmath198 is the unit vector associated with the distance @xmath199 between particles @xmath200 and @xmath189 , and @xmath201 is a constant that softens the force at small separations to prevent numerical singularities , chosen to be comparable to a grid cell in extent .
( 6 ) and ( 9 ) are solved using psuedo - spectral methods commonly used to solve navier - stokes equations for a turbulent fluid ( canuto et al 1987 ) .
periodic boundary conditions are assumed and the number of nodes used in each direction is generally 128 , 256 , 128 with a spacing of @xmath202 . a fast fourier transform ( fft ) algorithm is used to evaluate the dynamical variables @xmath171 at the computational nodes .
a second - order runge - kutta scheme is used to time - advance the gas and particle velocities .
a third - order taylor series interpolation scheme is used to determine gas velocities at the particle positions from values at the eight nearest neighbor nodes .
the mutual gravity calculation is done in a brute force fashion with a @xmath203 algorithm to evaluate the force contributions from all particles .
the code is written in fortran 77 and is parallelized using openmp directives .
the fft calculations are done simultaneously on the planes perpendicular to the @xmath164 and @xmath204 axes , and all loops involving particle indices are parallelized . typically , 3000
superparticles " are used , but some runs used more than 20000 . each
superparticle " represents the dynamical effects , and typical response , of a large number of actual chondrules .
initially the particles are arranged in a uniform spherical clump .
the initial velocities for the gas and the particles inside and outside the clump are determined from the expressions in nakagawa et al . (
1986 ) : @xmath205 where @xmath206 .
the initial velocity of the gas outside the clump is found by setting @xmath207 in equation ( 12 ) : @xmath208 ; inside the clump the specific case value of @xmath37 is used in equations ( 12 ) and ( 13 ) to initialize the gas and particle velocities
.    runs with single particles of different @xmath20 were made to verify that the nakagawa et al .
( 1986 ) initial conditions are steady state solutions for the particle equations .
the wallclock time to evolve one integration step is 0.7 sec using 256 intel itanium 2 processors running at 1.5 gighertz .
the wallclock time to evolve 1 orbital period is 121 hours .
* figure 3 * shows how , as predicted by the simple theory of section 3.3 , certain combinations of clump mass loading @xmath37 and dimension @xmath50 remain stable against ram pressure disruption for nebula headwinds produced by a pressure gradient characterized by @xmath209 .
@xmath135 is dimensionless , and the second expression in eqn .
( 2 ) can be used to obtain the critical value of @xmath140 which separates stable from unstable configurations of the clump , @xmath210 , directly from measured values in code units ( see appendix b ) .
we expect that @xmath162 will be in the range 1 - 10 .
the combination of parameters in the stable case shown ( right panels ) gives @xmath211 ; if self gravity is turned off , the clump is disrupted in @xmath212 orbits , whereas it will sediment into itself on a timescale @xmath213 times as long ( see appendix b ) . in the stable cases ,
a dense core is seen to continually shrink and become denser throughout the run , even as material is shed from the periphery of the clump , such that the value of @xmath214 for the core continues to increase ( see appendix c , * figure 7 * ) .    ) ; bottom row : projected onto the @xmath215 plane ( @xmath216 projections are similar ) , with the gas inflow into the page . in the top left panel the open circle shows the initial size and position of the clump . after less than an orbit ,
ram pressure disrupts the gravity - free clump ( left ) but the gravitating clump is stable ( right ) and continuing to shrink inexorably , even while being eroded .
movies showing this evolution are available online ( see appendix c).,width=326,height=288 ]    the numerical clump models exhibit considerable erosion over the duration of the runs from a viscously stirred surface layer , and this gradual but inexorable mass loss might lead to their disruption if arbitrarily long runs were practical at this time .
however , as discussed in appendices b and c , this large amount of erosion is a gross overestimate of what would happen in the nebula , because numerical viscosity ( and consequently shear around the periphery of the clump ) plays a far larger role in the current numerical models that it ever would in the actual nebula .
that is , the viscously stirred and eroded surface layer in the numerical clumps contains orders of magnitude more mass than would be the case for a nebula clump of the size and density required to survive ram pressure disruption ( see appendix b ) . in appendix c
, we describe the movies from which * figure 3 * is taken and also show how the protected inner regions of the clumps are behaving exactly as predicted , both in stable and unstable regimes . for more realistic , larger clump @xmath217 in the nebula
, a far larger fraction of the clump mass will show this behavior rather than being artificially eroded .
the primary purpose of the numerical models is merely to provide an independent sanity check on the physics of our weber number model and obtain some idea of @xmath162 , which gives us an order - of - magniture estimate for the product @xmath214 which nebula clumps require to survive headwinds of a particular @xmath218 .
future coding improvements are needed to allow larger ( higher @xmath217 ) clumps which would more closely approach nebula conditions in terms of their balance between pressure forces and viscous forces ( see appendices b and c ) ; these improvements will probably include an implicit time advance for the drag terms and perhaps also a tree or particle - in - mesh code for the particles .
we have shown how self - gravity can stabilize dense clumps of mm - sized particles , which form naturally in 3d turbulence , against disruptive gas ram pressure on timescales which are sufficiently long for their constituent mineral grains to sediment towards their mutual centers and form physically cohesive  sandpiles " of order 10 - 100 km in size .
the essence of the result is a critical  gravitational weber number " on the order of unity , in which self - gravity plays the role of surface tension in more familiar situations such as raindrops .
characteristic mass densities and lengthscales are determined which meet this requirement .
we show numerical results which are in general agreement with the predictions of the simple theory , for isolated , spherical initial clumps .
the scenario we have sketched out leads from aerodynamically size - sorted nebula particles , having the properties of chondrules , to sizeable planetesimals formed entirely from such particles which contain a snapshot or grab - sample of the local particle mixture .
turbulent concentration first produces the dense zones of size - sorted particles .
the more common , less dense of these regions may provide typical chondrule melting environments ( cuzzi and alexander 2006 ) .
some of the less common , very dense zones , which we have shown elsewhere can achieve mass densities 100 times larger than that of the gas , have the potential to become planetesimals depending on their lengthscales , nebula location , and local vorticity .
it is intriguing that our characteristic stabilized clump masses are not far from the mass inferred by bottke et al ( 2005 ) to represent a typical primordial object in the pre - dispersal , pre - erosional asteroid belt .
ultimately , the sandpiles resulting from completed sedimentation will become compacted further by inevitable collisions with other sandpiles , leading to today s fairly dense asteroids , while retaining a physical and chemical memory of their parent particle clumps .
the mechanism is easily extended to the unmelted aggregate particles of the outer solar system , where , however , if chondrules are absent , the size - sorting fingerprints of the process ( cuzzi et al 2001 ) might be less evident .
the conclusions of this paper differ from the suggestions in cuzzi et al ( 2001 ) , who focussed on the possible role of ultra - dense clumps with size comparable to a kolmogorov scale ( 0.1 -1 km ) . since that time
, hogan and cuzzi ( 2007 ) found that particle mass loading saturates the value of @xmath51 at a value of about 100 , redirecting our attention to larger clumps in the @xmath219 km size range .
clumps and fluid structures of these large sizes are much more accessible with numerical codes , both of the standard direct simulation type and the cascade type ( appendix a ) .    in this scenario ,
primitive bodies may not primarily represent spatial , but perhaps temporal , samples of the particulate contents of the nebula as its chemical , physical , and isotopic properties evolve over several myr . the temporal , as well as the spatial , variation in the physical , chemical and isotopic properties of the concentrated particles , which are being continually altered by thermal events and mineralogical alteration in the nebula gas ,
can then help account for class - to - class variations between the chondrite groups .
an implication of this drawn - out , inefficient process is that younger chondrite types should contain evidence of  leftovers " or  refugees " from earlier times , which escaped primary accretion .
several aspects of chondrite makeup are compatible with this implication .
of course , it is well known that ancient cai minerals and less - ancient , less refractory amoeboid olivine aggregates are found alongside much younger objects in the same chondrites ( _ eg .
_ scott and krot 2005 ) . also , the oldest chondrites ( cvs ) contain primarily type i chondrules ( which have an age observationally indistinguishable to that of cais ) and no ( more oxidized , heavier o - isotope ) type ii chondrules , while the younger ordinary chondrites contain a mixture of type i and type ii chondrules , some with hints of age variation even within a given chondrite ( kita et al 2005 ) .
the oldest and first - formed objects are all likely to have melted from their abundant @xmath1al ( kleine et al 2005 , 2006 ; hevey and sanders 2006 ) , producing differentiated achondrites and metallic objects , so it is no longer possible to dissect their primordial components .    of course , the real world is more complicated .
some complications are meteoritic : as only one example , co chondrites and ordinary chondrites appear to be about the same age ( younger than cv chondrites ) , but have very different chemical and isotopic properties ( kita et al 2005 ) , which would , in the context of this scenario , argue for some degree of spatial ( radial ? ) variation in the makeup of nebula particulates at that time anyway .    on the theoretical side , of course , self - consistent numerical models which follow clump evolution in realistic turbulence with headwinds and vertical settling need to be pursued , to check these preliminary assessments which make simplistic assumptions about the local headwind and assume isolated clumps .
several recent studies have found that transient  pressure ridges " arise in the gas in association with spiral density waves or vortical structures ( haghighipour and boss 2003 , rice et al 2004 , johansen et al 2007 ) ; in such regions , the local radial pressure gradient and headwind diminish ( other regions will have unusually _ large _ headwinds ) .
moreover , clumps do not exist in isolation , but more realistically as a dense core within a larger , less dense envelope which weakens the headwind felt by the dense clump core relative to the nebula average we characterize by @xmath209 .
both of these conditions would allow some clumps to survive with smaller @xmath214 .
other complications include interactions between different strengthless objects , leading to mergers or disruptions .
our stability criteria are most likely to be satisfied in a region fairly close to the nebula midplane ( @xmath220 , see section 3.3 ) , because at higher altitudes the vertical component of solar gravity leads to vertical settling of dense clumps at higher terminal velocities than are easily stabilized against . however ,
this vertical settling , even if it leads quickly to disruption of individual clumps , enhances the downward transport rate of small particles and increases the solid / gas ratio closer to the midplane from that generally predicted by simple 1d diffusion models ( _ eg .
_ , bosse et al 2006 ) .
all these effects have implications for the occurrence frequency of clumps of the requisite @xmath214 for stability .
quantitative statistical determinations of the volume fraction of stable clumps which can become planetesimals at any given time will use , for instance , approaches such as the cascade models described in appendix a. simplified , preliminary work exploring these factors indicates that , while the volume fraction of stable clumps is low at any given time ( so the process is clearly not an efficient one ) , accretion rates are roughly an earth mass per myr in the asteroid belt region ( cuzzi et al 2007 ) .
however , considerable work remains to establish the statistical formation rate of appropriate clumps capable of following this evolutionary path and to study the evolution of clumps in realistic turbulence , with variable headwind velocity and simultaneous vertical settling .
we thank j. eaton , m. gaffey , p. goldreich , w. hartmann , g. laughlin , k. sreenivasan , k. squires , and a. wray for very helpful conversations on various aspects of this research , and a. wray , a. dobrovolskis , p. garaud , and s. weidenschilling for thorough reviews of the original manuscript and a number of useful comments which have been included .
n. turner and a. carballido also provided useful comments on an earlier version .
this work was supported by a grant to jnc from nasa s planetary geology and geophysics program .
generous grants of cpu time from nasa s hec program were essential to the progress of this research ; we thank e. tu , k. schulbach , c. niggley and r. pesta in particular for their help along these lines .
we also thank j. chang for coding optimization assistance .
this aspect of our work incorporates two related and important concepts : that of _ intermittency _ , and that of a statistical cascade process . for instance
, it is widely known that dissipation of turbulent kinetic energy occurs at the kolmogorov scale ; it is less widely known that the spatial distribution of dissipation , like that of the particle concentration factor @xmath5 , is highly _
intermittent_. intermittent quantities are spatially and temporally unpredictable , and fluctuate increasingly with increasing reynolds number @xmath116 . however , the statistical properties of intermittent quantities like @xmath5 ( their probability distribution functions or pdfs ) are well determined on any lengthscale . in what follows , it will be necessary to distinguish between two closely related quantities : the concentration @xmath5 and the mass loading @xmath221 .
this is because the emergence of particle feedback on the gas due to mass loading ( @xmath37 ) , depends both on @xmath5 _ and _ on the initial value of @xmath32 .
it is ultimately @xmath5 that is evolved in the cascade , but _ how _ it evolves depends on @xmath37 .
so both quantities will be alluded to in parallel .    ; the parameter @xmath222 depends on the local mass loading @xmath37 ; larger @xmath222 indicates a narrower pdf @xmath223 .
open symbols : for particle concentration @xmath5 ; filled symbols : for enstrophy ( @xmath224 ) .
the small insets show @xmath223 at several values of @xmath37 . from hogan and cuzzi ( 2007).,width=297,height=240 ]     from the conditioned cascade model , for a 24-level case with initial @xmath225 .
the curves of figure 1 are the @xmath226averaged equivalent of this plot ( and show @xmath5 instead of @xmath37 ) , but do not include the effects of mass loading .
note the flattening or saturation at @xmath10 , reflecting the near - vertical asymptote of the conditioned-@xmath222 curve of figure 4 at @xmath10 .
a 24-level cascade is in the plausible range for clumps of size @xmath227 km in a nebula with @xmath228 . in this figure , the enstrophy @xmath229 is normalized to its mean value for the binning lengthscale ( from hogan and cuzzi 2007).,width=297,height=230 ]    in its inertial range , which is extensive at high @xmath116 , turbulence is a scale - free process that is often referred to as a cascade and inspired the approach of cascade modeling ( meneveau and sreenivasan 1991 ) .
the physics of transport of kinetic energy , vorticity , and dissipation from their sources at large scales is independent of scale until viscous processes enter at the smallest ( kolmogorov ) scale .
scale - independence and @xmath230independence are connected because @xmath116 determines the depth of the inertial range : @xmath231 ( tennekes and lumley 1972 ) .
cascade models simplify this complex , nonlinear , 3d scale - free process into a set of partition rules which are independent of scale , or of _ level _ in the cascade .
larger @xmath116 means a larger number of eddy spatial bifurcations ( or levels ) between @xmath232 and @xmath125 , and stronger fluctuations in intermittent properties ( meneveau and sreenivasan 1991 ) .
cascade models do nt preserve all the information of full 3d models ( such as the tubelike spatial structures characterizing vorticity ) but they do reproduce the statistical properties ( the pdfs ) , which are of primary importance for our problem . the successful use of such models to describe the intermittency of dissipation , and other quantities , in turbulence ( juneja et al 1994 , sreenivasan and stolovitsky 1995 ) led us to pursue a cascade model for turbulent concentration of particles .
a cascade model consists of a set of  multipliers " - fractions which define how a quantity of interest is unequally partitioned from a fluid parcel at some level , into its equal - sized subdivisions at the next level .
the pdf of particle concentration factor @xmath5 is determined over all the numerous end - level outcomes of applying a multiplier @xmath233 ( chosen from its own pdf @xmath223 ) to each volume element as it bifurcates at each level of the cascade .
it has been observed that @xmath223 is independent of level in the turbulent inertial range ( sreenivasan and stolovitsky 1995 ) .
hence , multiplier pdfs determined from a direct numerical simulation ( dns ) at low @xmath116 ( with a relatively small number of levels ) , merely applied repeatedly over additional levels , can _ predict _ the properties at higher @xmath116 ( if nothing changes in the physics ) . our cascade model (
hogan and cuzzi 2007 ) uses a common form for @xmath223 : @xmath234 , where the parameter @xmath222 determines the width of @xmath223 ( sreenivasan and stolovitsky 1995 ) .
both the concentration @xmath5 and the vorticity @xmath120 are described by their own @xmath222-distributions .
multiplier pdfs with small @xmath235 are broad , and in them multipliers much different from @xmath236 occur with higher probability , producing a grainier , more intermittent spatial distribution .
pdfs with large @xmath237 are narrow and centered on @xmath236 ; because each  eddy bifurcation " then involves a nearly 50 - 50 partitioning , the resulting spatial distribution is nearly uniform and subsequent growth of @xmath37 becomes more difficult .    the cascade model can then be used to address the issue of how particle mass loading can affect the cascade - that is , change the physics as the cascade progresses .
this dependence is known as _ conditioning _ of a cascade .
we found that the process can be represented quite well as two separate _
one - phase _ conditioned cascades for @xmath5 and @xmath120 in which multiplier distributions @xmath223 for both @xmath5 and @xmath120 depend only on the local particle mass loading @xmath37 .
we used our full 3d numerical simulations to establish how @xmath222 for both these properties depends on local particle or fluid properties .
* figure 4 * shows conditioning curves for both @xmath5 and @xmath120 ( the latter expressed as enstrophy @xmath224 ) , as extracted from multiple 3d dns simulations at various @xmath116 as large as 2000 ( hogan and cuzzi 2007 ) . note how the multiplier pdfs extracted from the dns results ( shown using insets ) get narrower ( have larger @xmath222 ) as mass loading increases , choking off intermittency . in these runs ,
@xmath238 , so @xmath239 .
these results establish the upper limit @xmath10 which can be obtained by turbulent concentration , regardless of the initial value of @xmath240 . in the nebula , with a smaller initial @xmath240 , higher @xmath116 or deeper cascades ( and larger ensuing @xmath5 values )
are needed to reach this saturation point .    to determine the joint pdf of concentration @xmath5 and vorticity @xmath120 , we require not only the conditioned multipliers for @xmath241 and @xmath5 ( * figure 4 * ) , but also their spatial correlation .
hogan and cuzzi ( 2007 ) found , on average , a 70 - 30 preference for anticorrelation at each partitioning , consistent with previous observations that particle concentration zones avoid zones of high fluid vorticity ( squires and eaton 1990 , 1991 ; eaton and fessler 1994 ; ahmed and elghobashi 2000 , 2001 ) . including this partitioning asymmetry factor as a weighted coin gives us a two - phase ( particle - gas ) , conditioned cascade model which shows very good agreement with the joint pdf @xmath242 directly determined from our full 3d mass loaded simulations ( see hogan and cuzzi 2007 ) .
however , to match the full 3d dns simulations at @xmath243 , the cascade model needs only about 15 levels , taking about 10 cpu - hours ( for 1024 realizations ) compared to over 90000 cpu hours to converge our full 3d simulation .    using these conditioned multipliers and asymmetry factor , entire pdfs of particle concentration ( mass loading ) and vorticity can be generated for arbitrary numbers of levels ( arbitrary @xmath116 ) .
for example , the 24 level model of * figure 5 * ( from hogan and cuzzi 2007 ) is of direct relevance for @xmath219 km scale dense zones of interest for the nebula .
* figure 5 * illustrates the saturation of the particle concentration at @xmath244 and the fact that high @xmath37 occurs preferentially at low enstrophy or vorticity .
the upper left quadrant is of most interest for determining the _ numbers _ of clumps which can survive to become planetesimals ( see cuzzi et al 2007 for more details ) .
while the primary result of this paper - the existence of some stability regime determined by a critical gravitational weber number @xmath162 - can be expressed in a nondimensional way , some aspects of the results ( specifically the numerical results and the inferred value of @xmath214 for the nebula ) require us to pursue the relationship between nebula parameters and code units more deeply .
values in code units are denoted by primes below .
the fundamental quantities in the problem are ( 1 ) the gas and particle densities @xmath24 and @xmath141 ; ( 2 ) the clump diameter @xmath50 ; ( 3 ) the local orbit frequency @xmath245 where @xmath45 is the distance from the sun ; ( 4 ) the local radial pressure gradient @xmath246 , where @xmath165 is in the hill frame ; ( 5 ) the particle stopping time @xmath20 ; ( 6 ) the velocity of material in the hill frame @xmath247 , that is , relative to keplerian , where @xmath247 represents either the particle or gas velocity ; and ( 7 ) the gravitational constant @xmath42 .
the principal forces are the coriolis force due to the rotating frame @xmath248 , the pressure force @xmath249 , and the gas drag forces that couple the gas and particles ( section 3.3 ) .
the code unit of length is radians ( the domain is 2@xmath250 radians on the short dimension ( @xmath165 or @xmath204 ) and the grid cell size is therefore @xmath251 where @xmath252 is the number of grid points along that axis ) .
the code time unit ( ctu ) is @xmath253 where @xmath254 is the code value of rotation frequency ; thus the orbit period is @xmath255 in code time units or ctu .
we treat as equivalent @xmath256 .    as noted in section 3.3 , @xmath257 where @xmath149 g @xmath61 at 2.5 au ( note this is different from safronov s ( 1991 ) roche density @xmath150 ) . to normalize mass and mass density ( and ultimately establish the code value of the gravitational constant @xmath258 ) we assume a nebula gas mass density @xmath259 g @xmath61 ( minimum mass nebula ; cuzzi et al 1993 ) at 2.5 au
; then code quantities @xmath260 and @xmath261 , and @xmath262 .
also , in code units @xmath263 where @xmath264 is the actual orbit frequency at the region of interest .
then the gravitational constant in code units , @xmath258 , can simply be written as @xmath265 .
finally , the pressure force is written as    @xmath266 where @xmath267 is typical ( nakagawa et al 1986 ; cuzzi et al 1993 ) , @xmath268 .
then the dimensionless parameters @xmath37 and @xmath269 are set to satisfy various constraints of the code ( resolvable clump , adequate particle statistics , reasonable timescale , etc ) and @xmath270 is allowed to vary , to determine empirically the critical value of @xmath271 as the largest value of @xmath140 that remains stable .
that is , we want @xmath269 to be large enough such that the clump is well resolved , but not so large that it fills the entire cross section of the computational box . typically @xmath269 is only 10 - 20 grid cells so far , and as noted below , this exaggerates the viscous stresses and surficial erosion of material .
we want @xmath37 to be large enough that the clump is much denser than the gas , and we want a large enough number of particles to act like a continuum .
the value of @xmath20 should ensure that the clump sedimentation time @xmath53 is larger than its ram pressure disruption time @xmath272 ( see below ) , to provide a real test that self - gravity is preserving the clump rather than simple collapse .
the dynamical collapse time of the clump under its own self - gravity , and in the absence of gas pressure , is @xmath273 , or in code units @xmath274 .
the mass loading which produces a clump dynamical time comparable to the orbit time is then obtained using @xmath275 or @xmath276 , again in fair agreement with prior expectations .
however , gas drag prevents clump collapse on this timescale , as described in section 3.1 , and actual shrinkage takes a time @xmath53 ( eqn .
the number of orbits over which we need to follow the clump to ensure it really survives is roughly @xmath277 where we have used @xmath278 .
this expression can be assessed using real quantities , and is 30 - 300 orbits for particle radius 300@xmath68 and mass loading @xmath279 .
this behavior ( @xmath280 ) can be controlled in the code , once the other parameters are established as above , by adjusting the particle stopping time @xmath20 . because of long code run times , at present we are limited to stipulating only that the sedimentation time significantly exceeds the nominal ( self - gravity - free ) disruption time ; that is , @xmath281 , where @xmath282 this expression for the disruption time @xmath272 is derived from the ram pressure force ( sect 2.3 ) by setting the distance traveled in time @xmath195 by the windward half of the clump , under acceleration by the ram pressure force , equal to the clump diameter ( assuming the leeward half of the clump does nt get accelerated ) , and solving for @xmath195 .
the value of @xmath146 for our clumps is on the order of unity , as we verify below .
the code calls for some input viscosity @xmath283 ; with it , the reynolds number of the clump having diameter @xmath269 radians , in a headwind of speed @xmath284 ( in code units of radians per ctu ) , is @xmath285 where @xmath286 is the defined code viscosity ( radians@xmath287/ctu ) .
we assume an inertial range expression within the wake of the clump to determine the wake s kolmogorov scale : @xmath288 , and thus @xmath289 radians .
our highest resolution runs to date had a gas relative velocity @xmath290 38 radians / ctu and used a clump size @xmath291 radians .
the nominal kolmogorov scale associated with this flow is @xmath292 0.02 radians ( compared to the grid cell size of 0.05 - 0.1 radians ) ; the wake turbulence is thus under - resolved and the code s true viscosity is numerical : @xmath293 ( at the boundary of the clump ) .
while we are not concerned with the fine - scale details of the wake , this marginal resolution introduces some caveats .
the ratio of ram pressure force to viscous force ( both per unit area ) is , in general , @xmath294 where @xmath217 is the reynolds number of a clump , and we have approximated @xmath295 . because we are dominated by numerical viscosity , @xmath293 , thus in code units @xmath296 in many cases so far . for comparison ,
the reynolds number for _ nebula _ clumps of interesting sizes is @xmath297 .
this means that viscous stresses around the periphery of the clump , and the fractional depth of the viscous boundary layer , are grossly exaggerated in the numerical model relative to the actual nebula regime of interest .
the anomalously large role of ( numerical ) viscosity leads to anomalously large  erosion " from the surface of our numerical clumps , and degrades our results in the sense that potentially stable clumps _
might _ appear less stable , due to the erosive mass loss experienced over their sedimentation time .
going to higher resolution cases ( @xmath298 ) significantly ameliorated this effect but the problem has certainly not been entirely removed . another way to characterize
the degree of artificial erosion is to estimate the _ physical _ kolmogorov scale for the actual nebula / clump situation : for @xmath299 cm sec@xmath300 , @xmath301 km , and @xmath142=3800 cm / s , we find @xmath302 100 m , or @xmath303 of the size of a @xmath99 km clump , compared to a fractional size of perhaps @xmath304 or so in the code , as determined by numerical viscosity .
clearly , surface erosion is a much smaller effect in the nebula case than in our crude models .
while even at this resolution apparently stable configurations can be found , it would be desirable for future studies to improve on this situation .
_ clump drag coefficient @xmath146 : _ the drag coefficient of the clump is reynolds - number - dependent and must also be scaled to nebula values to obtain an estimate of @xmath214 . weidenschilling ( 1977 )
gave expressions for the drag force per unit area ( giving the pressure force per unit area ) , experienced by solid spheres of different @xmath217 in the stokes drag regime of interest here , as @xmath305 .
for @xmath306 , @xmath307 , or @xmath308 for @xmath309 , as in our code .
the large drag coefficient and ram pressure is partly due to low - pressure zones set up immediately behind particles in this range of @xmath217 . by comparison , for a solid sphere with @xmath310 as under nebula conditions , @xmath311 .
however , neither of these values might be entirely applicable to our clumps , which are not rigid spheres . in practice ,
we have determined @xmath146 empirically from observed values of @xmath272 with self gravity turned off . recalling that @xmath312 ,
we simply plot our estimate of @xmath272 , the point at which sizeable vortex - driven internal voids appear in the clump , against the combined parameter @xmath313 , giving @xmath314 as the slope of the best fit straight line ( * figure 6 * ) .
it seems that @xmath315 is a good assumption , but this calculation should be redone with higher resolution ( lower numerical viscosity ) codes . at nebula @xmath217 , @xmath146 could reach its theoretical high-@xmath316 value of 0.4 and this is what we assume in deriving @xmath214 .
finally then , the several stable cases we have run ( _ eg . _ figure 3 ) can be characterized by @xmath317= 38 rad / ctu , @xmath318 = 380 ( which corresponds to a minimum mass nebula local density @xmath319 at distance 2.5 au ) , @xmath320 , and @xmath321 radian , and while we have not as yet accurately determined the transition value of @xmath140 , a value @xmath322 is clearly stable . solving equation ( 4 ) of section 3.3 for @xmath214 under _ nebula _ conditions , _ assuming _ @xmath323 , taking @xmath324 for a high-@xmath217 situation and assuming a nominal @xmath325 , we find @xmath326 , independent of @xmath24 and neglecting a questionable coefficient of order unity ( because of the contribution of viscous stresses in our low-@xmath217 code ) .
foreseeable refinements ( specifically , lower numerical viscosity ) may increase @xmath162 ( the surface tension analogue gives @xmath327 ) and thus decrease the value of @xmath214 .
_ vs. _ the quantity @xmath328 ; the slope is then @xmath314 .
this determination is slightly qualitative as to when we judge the clump to be disrupted ; we decided to use the time at which vortex - driven voids first appear in a @xmath215 planar cross - section through the nominal center of the clump .
, width=297,height=268 ]
quicktime movies showing our time evolutions are available online at      with filenames as given below .
after publication , the movie files will also be available on the apj web site as mpgs .
each shows a dense clump in the hill frame , rotating at local keplerian velocity , with more slowly - orbiting gas impinging on the clump from its leading side .
the two left - hand panes show the view from along the radial axis ( in the @xmath329 plane ; top ) and along the vertical axis ( in the @xmath216 plane ; bottom ) .
the large right - hand pane shows the view from the orbitally leading direction ( in the @xmath330 plane ) .
the wake formed by the clump is easily visible in the two left - hand panes .
cases @xmath331 and @xmath332 are sampled at a similar time near their end - point in figure 3 .
file @xmath331 shows how a clump with no self - gravity is disrupted in about 1.5 code time units for the initial conditions chosen ( the orbit period is @xmath255 code time units ) , in agreement with our simple estimates of @xmath272 .
files @xmath332 and @xmath333 are intended to illustrate the same ( stable ) weber number case ( @xmath322 ) but we vary two constituent parameters of @xmath140 ( we decrease both the gas velocity and mass loading by a factor of three ) to illustrate similarity ; because of the specific parameters chosen , @xmath333 runs for a longer time , but is suffering considerable erosion towards the end of the run . nevertheless ,
as discussed below , it retains a dense core that continues to contract . as discussed in appendix b , more realistic cases , with higher numerical resolution , would have smaller numerical viscosity and incur less erosion .
case @xmath332 , while not run as long as @xmath333 , appears solidly stable with a dense core that is continuing to shrink at the end of the run .
note some interesting oscillatory behavior , such as hinted at in our 1d compressible runs ( figure 2 ) .
the simulations which created the movies referred to above can be used to assess the behavior of the central , dense regions of each clump in a quantitative manner . * figure 7 * has three panels , showing the time variation of some properties of the particles which lie within the central regions of the clump ( its densest fraction , as sampled out to some cumulative mass threshold ) . in the top panel ,
we show how much mass is being eroded from the clump overall ( particles moving faster than some comoving velocity threshold are assumed to have left the clump ) .
all three clumps are losing mass , naturally , but the non - gravitating clump 26 is losing it much more rapidly than the gravitating clumps 29a and 31a . in the central panel
we show the mean mass density as measured over some fraction @xmath334 of the clump mass lying at the highest densities ; in clumps 26 and 29a , we chose @xmath335 , and in clump 31a , we chose @xmath336 . in the nongravitating clump ,
the core density never increases and it quickly blows up , while the central regions of the gravitating clumps ( removed from the artificial mass erosion at their peripheries ) inexorably get denser at a steady and perhaps even slightly increasing rate ( an increasing rate is predicted by the simple model ) .
the lower panel shows the effective average radius of the region being sampled .
the non - gravitating clump never shrinks at all , but both gravitating clumps do .
moreover , as the gravitating clumps shrink , their density increases faster than their linear dimension decreases , so the product @xmath214 increases - causing them to become _ more _ stable as time goes on .
this is an argument for stability even in the presence of erosion .
as expected , the density growth timescale ( the sedimentation time @xmath53 of equation 1 ) is three times smaller for the denser clump of case 29a ( middle panel ) .
meanwhile , the apparent agreement of the variation of the fractional radius containing half of the mass seen between cases 29a and 31a in the lower panel is fortuitous , because the total masses of the clumps are changing ( and eroding ) at different rates and from different depths in the two cases .
nevertheless , the cores are both shrinking and becoming denser in the two stable cases .
the amount of erosion that is incurred from the margins of each clump is related to ( perhaps proportional to ) the thickness of the viscous boundary layer relative to the radius of the clump , which can be expressed in terms of the reynolds number .
as we have argued above in this appendix , actual nebula clumps capable of remaining stable would have reynolds numbers five orders of magnitude larger - impossible to study with numerical models .
the relevance of all viscous boundary layer effects , including the erosion that inflicts our current numerical runs , will decrease by that factor in the real situation .    ; bottom panel : effective radius containing mass fraction @xmath334 .
these results show that , away from the artificially perturbed perimeter regions , @xmath147-stable clumps are behaving as expected by the simple model , and @xmath147-unstable clumps do not show this behavior.,width=316,height=316 ]