spheroidal stellar populations , such as elliptical galaxies and the halos and bulges of spiral galaxies , contain a significant fraction of all stars in the local universe .
the ages and metallicities of halo stars in these galaxies provide some of the most important observational clues to the formation and earliest evolution of galaxies , whether through studies of globular star clusters ( gcs ) or , in more nearby galaxies , the individual halo stars .
below , we broadly summarize what is currently known about the ages and metallicities of stars in the spheroids of nearby galaxies .
the spheroid of the milky way has two components , a centrally concentrated bulge composed of more metal - rich stars , and an extended , lower density halo consisting of more metal - poor stars .
the halo of the galaxy shows substructure , with ( at least ) two chemically distinct components .
stars of the ` inner halo ' have a mean [ fe / h]@xmath2 @xcite , while stars in the ` outer halo ' ( r@xmath315 kpc ) are more metal - poor , with a mean [ fe / h]@xmath4 @xcite .
the halo also contains many stellar streams and tidal debris that are probably the remnants of previously accreted satellite galaxies ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
the globular clusters in the galaxy have a weak metallicity gradient inside @xmath510 kpc , with no such trend apparent beyond 10  kpc out to the most distant cluster located at @xmath6120 kpc @xcite .
the stars and gcs in the halo of the milky way appear to be mostly old , with ages between 11 and 13  gyr @xcite , indicating that the dominant era of accretion in the milky way took place soon after formation @xcite .
detailed studies of the stars in m31 suggest that this galaxy has had a more active , recent accretion history when compared with the milky way .
m31 has a markedly metal - rich inner spheroid component @xcite that is dominated by substructure @xcite .
m31 accreted a relatively massive satellite galaxy only @xmath7  gyr ago @xcite , and has had other many more minor interactions @xcite as well .
deep images taken with the _ hst _ , which reach below the main sequence turnoff region for ancient stars in m31 , indicate the presence of metal - rich , intermediate age stars ( @xmath8  gyr ) in fields located at deprojected distances of 11 , 20 , and 35 kpc , with a larger contribution from older , more metal - poor stars increasing at larger distances @xcite .    beyond @xmath9  kpc and extending out to at least @xmath10  kpc ,
the halo of m31 is dominated by metal - poor stars with [ fe / h]@xmath11 @xcite , and this component too has copious substructure @xcite .
little is known about the ages of these stars except for the recent work of @xcite who studied the m31 gc mgc1 , which is located at a projected galactocentric distance of @xmath12120 kpc .
the cmd of this cluster reveals a metal abundance of [ m / h]@xmath122.3 and a horizontal branch morphology that is consistent with those of milky way gcs at this metal abundance , suggesting a similar age .
studies of stars in the spheroids of several more distant elliptical galaxies suggest that metal - rich stars dominate out quite far , probably to at least 10 - 15@xmath13 .
ngc  5128 has a largely metal - rich population at radii of 8 - 33  kpc @xcite .
even further out , an analysis of the colors of rgb stars , which are sensitive to metallicity , and the colors and luminosities of the agb bump and the rc , which are sensitive to both metallicity and age , suggests that stars in ngc  5128 at @xmath14  kpc have largely intermediate to old ages , with @xmath15  gyr @xcite .
the halos of ngc  3377 and ngc  3379 have a wide range of metallicity , with a significant fraction of metal - rich stars , although metal - poor stars begin to dominate the spheroid of ngc  3379 beyond @xmath16 .
the lack of stars brighter than the rgb suggests that ngc  3377 and ngc  3379 contain few young , bright agb stars @xcite . like ngc  3379 , a dominant population of metal - poor stars have been found in the spheroid of the edge - on spiral galaxy ngc  891 @xcite .
m81 is an earlier - type spiral ( sab ) than either the milky way or m31 .
however , studies of the resolved stars in the outskirts of m81 have already shown that it too is a complex mix of stellar populations . @xcite
used 9 archival wfpc2 images of m81 to show that the number density of rgb and agb stars decreases with galactocentric radius , eventually flattening out at a ( deprojected distance ) of @xmath17  kpc .
they attribute the stars interior to this as part of the thick disk , and stars beyond this as part of the halo .
cmds of fields interior to 25  kpc reveal relatively young stars @xcite , and older rgb stars with a relatively large range in metallicity ( @xmath18 < 0 $ ] ; mouhcine  2005 , williams  2009 ) .
these stars are likely located in the disk , either thin or thick , of m81 .
more recently , @xcite found a flattending of the stellar density profile beyond @xmath19  kpc ( deprojected ) from m81 , with more metal - poor stars ( [ m / h]@xmath20 ) than in the interior fields , again indicating that the halo dominates at these distances .
the only constraint on the _ ages _ of stars in the halo of m81 comes from the measurement of absorption line strengths in globular clusters , which suggest ages that are indistinguishable from the gcs in the galaxy , within the significant uncertainties ( @xmath21  gyr ) @xcite .    in this work ,
we study the metallicities and ages of stars in a field in m81 that lies at a projected distance of 19  kpc , using observations taken with the advanced camera for surveys on @xmath0 .
these data are among the deepest available for a portion of m81 .
the rest of this paper is organized as follows : section  2 presents the data and reduction ; section  3 presents the cmd for our field and discusses general features ; section  4 presents a new determination of the distance to m81 from the tip of the rgb , and averages this with previous distance determinations to give our adopted value ; section 5 discusses the red clump , and section  6 presents an estimate of the metallicities and ages of stars in our m81 field . section  7 presents some new results on a small population of blue stars discovered in our field , and section  8 discusses the results in terms of the formation of m81 , as well as our main conclusions .
observations of m81 were obtained with the wide field channel ( wfc ) of the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) on - board the @xmath0 , for program go-10604 ( pi : sarajedini ) . a single acs / wfc pointing covering @xmath22
was centered at @xmath23 , @xmath24 ( j2000.0 ) , at a projected distance of 18  from the center of m81 , or 19 kpc at the adopted distance of 3.7  mpc ( see section 4 ) .
the specific pointing was chosen to lie along the southwestern semi - minor axis , beyond the radius suggested as the edge of m81 s thick disk @xcite , where the surface brightness of m81 is still high enough that we can determine a meaningful metallicity distribution from rgb stars .
figure  1a shows the location of our acs pointing .
it also shows the wfpc2 field studied by @xcite , which falls on the edge of the suggested thick disk in m81 , at a projected distance of 12.8  ( 14 kpc ) from the center of m81 .
figure  1b shows our pointing superposed on hi contours from @xcite ; while our field is outside of m81 s purported thick disk ( at a deprojected distance of 30 - 34 kpc ) , it still lies along the line - of - sight with some of the many hi filaments that exist outside m81 s optical disk @xcite .
while some of this hi has been tidally stripped from m81 by encounters with m82 and ngc  3077 , probably @xmath25  myr ago @xcite , velocities of the hi towards our field are consistent with rotation of the m81 disk ( m.yun , private communication ) .
our field was observed on 2005 sept .
11 - 13 for 5 orbits ( 2 images per orbit ) in the f606w filter and 9 orbits ( 2 images per orbit ) in the f814w filter , using a standard 4-point dither pattern .
each individual exposure had an exposure time of 1247s , leading to a total exposure time of 12470s in the f606w filter , and 22446s in the f814w filter .
we retrieved the pipeline flatfielded images from the @xmath0 archive as well as the pipeline - processed multidrizzled combined images from subsets of the data .
photometry was performed with the acs module of the dolphot software package @xcite , which is specifically designed for point - source photometry of objects in the individual flt images , which were taken directly from the @xmath0 archive .
object detection and photometry was performed on all exposures simultaneously , using one of our deep @xmath26 drizzled images ( derived from a subset of 8 images ) as the reference frame .
the dolphot parameters were set to the recommended values given in the dolphot user s guide , which includes psf - fitting using pre - derived psfs , as well as the calculation and application of cte correction @xcite and aperture corrections .
the instrumental magnitudes were converted to the vegamag @xmath0 photometric system by adopting the revised zeropoints ( for data taken before july 4 , 2006 ) of 26.420 for f606w and 25.536 for f814w , which differ by @xmath27 mag from the values originally published by @xcite .
we refer to magnitudes in this system by their filter name ( @xmath28 and @xmath29 ) , and in cases when we need to convert to the johnson - cousins systems refer to the filters as @xmath30 and @xmath31 .
we determined the photometric completeness limits and associated errors in our point - source photometry by adding and remeasuring 60,000 artificial stars in the acs images .
the artificial stars have a range of magnitude ( 24 @xmath32 31 ) and color ( @xmath33 ) .
the pritchet interpolation function @xcite    @xmath34    was used to fit the binned completeness fractions @xmath35
( @xmath36 number of stars detected / number of stars added ) as a function of magnitude . here
, @xmath37 is a parameter that measures the rate of decline of @xmath38 at @xmath39 , and @xmath39 is defined as the 50% completeness limit . to account for completeness variations in both color and magnitude , we used only the bluest stars ( @xmath40 ) to determine the f814w completeness fraction @xmath41 , and redder stars ( @xmath42 ) to derive @xmath43 . the limiting magnitude ( @xmath44 ; * ? ? ? * ) for each filter is @xmath45 and @xmath46 .
we selected point sources in our field as follows .
first , we restricted our sample to objects with a dolphot category consistent with stars ( obtype=1 )
. of the sources that met this criterion , only those that were measured on at least 8 of the 10 individual f606w images , and on at least 15 of the 18 individual f814w images were retained , yielding a list of 13,858 sources over the entire acs field . to remove remaining , slightly resolved objects
, we applied the following cuts : @xmath47 ( from the psf fitting ) , and a crowding parameter crowd @xmath48 mag , where the latter rejected objects whose magnitudes are likely to be affected by neighboring sources .
finally , we kept only those objects with sharpness values within an empirically - derived hyperbolic function : @xmath49 .
all of these criteria were chosen based on visual inspection of sources on the acs images .
the @xmath28@xmath29 versus @xmath29 color - magnitude diagram ( cmd ) for the 9081 remaining objects ( representing our ` cleaned ' sample of stellar objects in the m81 field ) is shown in the left panel of figure  2 , with the cmd of all objects _ rejected _ by the chi / sharp / crowd cuts plotted in the right hand panel .
the photometric errors derived from the artificial star experiments , as well as the 50@xmath50 photometric completeness levels , are also plotted in the left - hand panel .
comparison of the two plots shows that the vast majority of rejected objects do not correspond to the sequences visible in the ` clean ' cmd , lending credence to our choice of classification criteria .
we note that some true stellar sources will be removed by our somewhat stringent selection criteria , but since we are most interested in those objects with the best quality photometry , these are acceptable ` losses ' .
the cleaned cmd extends from above the tip of the first ascent red giant branch ( trgb ) to one magnitude below the horizontal branch ( hb ) .
stars on the red giant branch are older than a few gyr .
the hb has a morphology which is predominantly redward of the rr lyrae instability strip , although we can not unambiguously detect an extended blue horizontal branch due to the presence of a small population of blue stars ( @xmath28@xmath510 ) , which will be discussed in section 7 .
in fact , the red hb resembles a red clump ( rc ) most commonly seen in relatively young ( down to @xmath52  gyr ) and/or metal - rich stellar populations .
an analysis of the rgb and rc stars is presented in section 5 .
there is a small but noticeable population of stars above the trgb , likely asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) stars of intermediate age ( @xmath125 to 10 gyr ) . from the besanon galaxy model of @xcite
, we estimate that there should be @xmath53 ( foreground ) stars from the milky way with @xmath54 and @xmath55@xmath56 in our field of view , so the vast majority of stars in our m81 field in this color and magnitude range belong to m81
. we will explore these populations in more detail in the upcoming sections .
we determine the luminosity function of the rgb stars in our field by defining an ` rgb zone ' and thereby excluding stars far from the rgb sequence .
we use the z=0.0001 and z=0.004 models of @xcite to provide a general guide to the shape of the rgb in both color and luminosity , after first making the models redder and bluer by 0.05 mag to accomodate photometric uncertainties ; see figure 3 .
however , we explicitly include stars brighter than the tip of the rgb , likely to be agb stars , by allowing a larger range of magnitudes than the model predictions .    in figure  4
, we show the @xmath29 luminosity function of the rgb in our field for those objects in the extraction region with @xmath57 , with a bin width of 0.08 , and uncertainties given by @xmath58 .
we do not make a correction for foreground stars , because we found in  3 that these are very sparse in this direction .
the red clump is clearly present at @xmath59 ; we will return to this feature in section 5 .      in order to interpret our cmd
further , we need to know the distance to m81 . here , we determine the distance from the tip of the rgb ( trgb ) in the @xmath31-band , which has proven to be an excellent distance indicator for metal - poor , old stellar populations @xcite . visual inspection of our cmd shows a transition in the number counts at @xmath60 , albeit with a small number of stars . while a small number of stars in the upper part of the rgb ( there are @xmath61 in our cmd ) can lead to a possible systematic bias in the determination of @xmath62 , @xcite have shown that with at least @xmath63 stars in the top magnitude of the rgb ( as is the case for our luminosity function ) , such biases are expected to be small .    to derive a quantitative estimate of the location of the rgb tip ,
we have employed the sobel edge - detection filter @xcite in order to find the strongest discontinuity in the bright part of our lf in figure 4 ( for the relatively small number of stars in the upper rgb , this simple edge - detection method should suffice for our purposes ) .
each object in the lf is modelled as a gaussian distribution with a dispersion equal to the expected photometric error .
we use the dispersion in the mean of the individual dolphot magnitudes as our photometric error . the resulting luminosity function @xmath64 is plotted at the top of figure 5 . to determine the location of the rgb tip
, we applied to this lf the edge - detection algorithm    @xmath65    where @xmath66 is the mean photometric error defined from our artificial star experiments @xcite .
the resultant response function is plotted in the bottom of figure 5 , and shows a peak at @xmath67 , where the small formal uncertainty reflects only the width of the sobel function peak .
converting to the @xmath31-band via the synthetic transformations of @xcite ( and using the revised zeropoints , as noted above ) , we find @xmath68 , where we have adopted an uncertainty of 0.03 mag in the transformation from @xmath29 to @xmath31 .
the true uncertainty in @xmath62 is almost certainly larger than that given above , since they do not include any uncertainties in the photometry itself .
the distance to m81 is determined by comparing the measured magnitude for the tip of the rgb found above with the predicted intrinsic magnitude , @xmath69 ( for [ fe / h]@xmath70 ) from @xcite .
this predicted value is very similar to @xmath71 ( random error ) derived by @xcite , and to @xmath72 ( for [ fe / h]@xmath73 ) from @xcite .
a comparison between observed and predicted @xmath74 magnitudes gives an observed distance modulus of @xmath75 for m81 , or an intrinsic value of @xmath76 ( @xmath77 mpc ) , where we have assumed a foreground extinction of @xmath78 ( using @xmath79 ; * ? ? ? * ) and adopted a 0.02 uncertainty in the foreground reddening to m81 .
this is consistent with determinations from independent trgb estimates and other methods , as discussed below .
several different techniques have been used previously to estimate the distance to m81 , leading to distance modulus estimates that differ by approximately 0.1  mag .
the period - luminosity relationship for cepheid variables is a robust way to determine the distance to nearby galaxies .
@xcite determined a value of @xmath80 for m81 , based on 30 cepheids discovered in m81 by @xcite , using @xmath0 observations .
more recently , @xcite determined a distance modulus of @xmath81 based on 11 cepheids , in good agreement with the distance determined by ferrarese et al . here , we adopt the mccommas   value as the cepheid based distance to m81
.    estimates of the distance to m81 based on the tip of the rgb method tend to give a range of values .
we found @xmath82 above , and @xcite derived a mean value of @xmath83 , based on fields which are interior to that used here .
however , @xcite derive a much shorter distance modulus of @xmath84 from their detection of the trgb in an m81 disk field , and @xcite derived a value of @xmath85 from deep photometry of an acs field in m81 s disk .    for this work ,
we adopt a distance of @xmath86@xmath87@xmath88@xmath89 ( @xmath90 mpc ) to m81 , which is the mean value of the five distance determinations described above ( 4 trgb values and the cepheid value ) .
the quoted error is the dispersion of the input values ( each of the individual distance determinations have similar uncertainties ) .
inspection of figure 2 shows a well - populated horizontal branch , indicating a population of relatively old stars .
while our data do not allow for a clean detection of a blue horizontal branch , the magnitude and color of the red clump ( rc ) allows us to estimate the age and metallicity of the dominant stellar population in our field , as shown in the next section .    to derive the photometric properties of the rc , we use only those stars with colors in the range @xmath91 ; a close - up of this part of the cmd is shown in figure 6 , along with the luminosity function of stars in this color range , where the rc is clearly visible . to derive the mean magnitude of this feature
, we fit the ` background ' lf immediately brighter and fainter than the rc as a linear function , and fit a single gaussian to the lf once the linear background has been subtracted off .
we note that the choice of bin size and the exact background fit have negligible effect on the mean magnitude determined for the rc clump .
the resulting fit ( and 1@xmath92 uncertainties ) yields @xmath93 . the gaussian width of @xmath94 , while consistent with the expected photometric errors from the artificial star experiments , does allow for some intrinsic spread in age and/or metallicity .
given our adopted distance modulus of @xmath86@xmath87@xmath88@xmath95 , the i - band absolute magnitude in this region of m81 is @xmath96 = 0.21 @xmath1 0.10 .
the location of the rc in our dataset is also consistent with the value derived by @xcite for their m81 outer disk field while we get @xmath97 .
the williams  field exhibits a mean age of 2 - 3 gyr and a metallicity of [ m / h]@xmath98 . in our field
( see next section ) we find a mean age of 9 gyr and a [ m / h]@xmath99 .
our m81 field is @xmath100 gyr older and @xmath101 dex more metal - poor than the williams field .
a change of @xmath102 dex makes the red clump 0.15 mag brighter and a change of + 6 gyr makes the red clump 0.17 mag fainter ( based on fig .
8 of * ? ? ?
* ) , so they offset each other resulting in a rc absolute magnitude that is essentially unchanged . ] .
we note the presence of a small positive feature at @xmath103 ( adopted error based on the bin size used ) in the lf in figure 6 .
this feature is very likely the faint signal from the rgb bump  mag @xcite .
we do not see strong evidence for an agb bump here because of the relatively low number of stars in our field .
@xcite do see an agb bump , because their field contains many more stars , but do not observe an rgb bump , likely because their significantly larger range of metallicities and ages washes out this feature . ] , the location on the rgb where the hydrogen - burning shell crosses the discontinuity in chemical abundances remaining from the stars convective envelope @xcite .
the luminosity of the rgb bump depends on both the metallicity and the age of the stars , and will be used as a consistency check on our results in the next section .
the absolute magnitude of the red clump , as well as the shape ( slope ) and location ( color ) of the rgb are both sensitive to the age and metallicity of the stellar population .
however , the rgb is more sensitive to metallicity than to age , and the magnitude of the rc is more sensitive to age than to metallicity , so it is possible to use both features together to constrain the age and metallicity of the dominant population .
we compare the observations with the theoretical isochrones of @xcite , assuming scaled - solar abundance .
cmd as this makes use of the well - determined photometric zeropoints for the acs / wfc instrument .
however , the theoretical dependence of the red clump magnitude on metallicity and age is performed in the ground - based system as it requires knowledge of the median i - band rc magnitude for a population of stars , and these have only been constructed for the ground - based filters .
this is unlikely to introduce a significant systematic effect because the acs / wfc f814w passband closely matches its ground - based @xmath31-band counterpart .
we also note that the rgbs of the @xcite isochrones are identical to those of @xcite . ]
we first correct the colors and magnitudes using the values for reddening and distance noted above .
next , we assume an age and use the colors of rgb stars with @xmath104@xmath1052.0 to determine metallicity based on an interpolation within the @xcite grid of theoretical isochrones with 2.3@xmath106[m / h]@xmath1060.0 . figure 7 shows these theoretical rgbs overplotted on our m81 cmd for an age of 9 gyr .
the @xmath104@xmath1052.0 magnitude range is chosen to minimize the effect of asymptotic giant branch stars on the blue side of the rgb @xcite .
the resultant mean metallicity and the i - band absolute magnitude of the rc derived above , @xmath96 = 0.21 @xmath1 0.10 , are used in conjunction with the @xcite models for the median magnitude of the red clump stars to infer the age of the population .
this age estimate @xmath107 is then used to redetermine the mean metallicity from the rgb stars and the process is repeated .
this iterative procedure converges quickly and yields a mean metallicity of [ m / h ] @xmath108 ( random ) , @xmath10.11 ( systematic ) , where the latter value includes the influence of errors in the distance modulus and reddening .
the mean age of the dominant population is then @xmath86@xmath107@xmath88 = 9 @xmath1 2 gyr , where the quoted uncertainty reflects the error in the red clump magnitude , which is the dominant source of uncertainty .
the resultant metallicity distribution function ( mdf ) is shown in fig .
8 wherein the fitted gaussian profile gives a 1-@xmath92 width of 0.39 dex in [ m / h ] .
the dominant signal in the mdf is due to stars around @xmath109 to @xmath110 .
the artificial star tests we have performed suggest that the mean color error at @xmath111 is 0.032 mag , which corresponds to @xmath112 } \sim$ ] 0.12 dex based on the @xcite isochrones in the range 1.3@xmath106[m / h]@xmath1060.7 .
this suggests a significant fraction of the @xmath112}$ ] exhibited by the mdf is due to an intrinsic range in metallicity among the m81 stars in our field . in particular , subtracting the dispersion due to errors from the measured dispersion in quadrature yields an intrinsic abundance spread of @xmath112}$]= 0.37 dex .
it is also important to keep in mind that we have used scaled - solar isochrones for the determination of the mdf shown in fig .
the degree to which field stars in the m81 halo are enhanced in the @xmath37-capture elements is currently not known .
we can estimate the effect of such an enhancement on our mdf using the formalism of @xcite :    @xmath113 = [ fe / h ] + log(0.638f_{\alpha } + 0.362)\ ] ]    where @xmath114 represents the factor by which the @xmath37-elements are enhanced .
thus , if @xmath115$]=@xmath116 , then @xmath114=2 and our computed scaled - solar [ m / h ] values are larger than [ fe / h ] by @xmath117 dex .
we conclude this section by providing a series of consistency checks on our principle result , which is that the mean metallicity and age of stars in our m81 field are [ m / h]@xmath118 and @xmath119  gyr , respectively .
first , the location of the weak rgb bump ( described in the previous section ) at @xmath120 can be used to provide an independent estimate of the age / metallicity of the m81 field stars .
indeed , the rgb bump lies above the hb / rc for primarily old , more metal - poor populations @xcite . from our adopted distance modulus , an assumed mean color @xmath121 and @xmath122
, we find @xmath123 . from the relations in @xcite ( and adopting an additional 0.1 dex uncertainty in those relations ) , this translates to a metallicity [ fe / h]@xmath124 for an old , 12 gyr population , or a metallicity [ fe / h]@xmath125 for a 9 gyr population . while the uncertainties in these results are large , and the @xmath37 enhancement unknown , the age and metallicity derived from the rgb bump are broadly consistent with what we find from the location of the rc .
a further comparison of our derived value of @xmath126 with predicted values presented by @xcite ( their fig .
22 ; based on models by @xcite ) are also consistent with a metal - poor population with an age of @xmath127 gyr .    as an additional check
, we compare our cmd with that for the galactic globular cluster ngc  362 , studied as part of the @xmath0 treasury project go-10775 @xcite .
this cluster has a metallicity of [ fe / h]@xmath128 ( on the @xcite scale ) , and an age of @xmath1210.5 gyr @xcite , and therefore provides a good reference for our field .
figure 9 shows our m81 photometry compared with the ngc 362 fiducial sequence derived from the hst treasury project data .
the latter has been shifted by @xmath129=13.12 and @xmath130=0.05 .
these are based on adopted values of @xmath131 and @xmath132 for ngc 362 @xcite and @xmath133 and @xmath134 for m81 .
we see good agreement between the location and shape of the ngc 362 fiducial and the locus of m81 stars along the red clump and the rgb .
the color distribution of m81 rgb stars is slightly bluer than the ngc 362 rgb fiducial , and is most evident within one magnitude of the m81 rgb tip .
this could be due to ngc 362 being slightly more metal - rich ( @xmath120.05 dex ) and somewhat older ( 1 to 2 gyr ) than the mean properties of the m81 field . taken together , these could account for a color difference of @xmath120.03 mag in @xmath135 on the rgb .
our cmd of the m81 halo field shows a ( small ) population of blue stars with @xmath136 , properties expected for young ( @xmath137  yr ) stars , but not for the stars in the halo of a spiral galaxy .
we have checked that these are genuine sources with blue colors .
they are clearly point - like and not obvious background galaxies , and are scattered throughout our acs field .
we conclude that these are likely individual , young stars associated with m81 .
furthermore , the rather sudden appearance of these objects at @xmath138 blueward of the dominant rgb suggests that these are not rgb or rc stars in m81 scattered due to large photometric errors .
an overlay of metal - rich ( z=0.008 ; [ m / h]@xmath139 ) isochrones from @xcite onto our cmd is shown in fig .
10 , and suggests that these blue stars have ages between @xmath140-@xmath141  myr .
what is the origin of these stars ?
they have colors and magnitudes similar to a stellar population seen in the cmd of an outer disk field in m81 ( figure 3 in * ? ? ?
potentially then , there is a sparse outer disk in m81 , which contributes a very small fraction of the stars observed in our field .
if these stars are an extension of the true outer disk of m81 , then the disk plane extends out @xmath634 - 40 kpc from m81 .
a second possibility is that these stars formed in the disk of m81 or in one if its companions , and then were carried to this location along with the hi tidal debris that is coincident with our field , likely as a result of the most recent galactic interactions between m81 , m82 and ngc 3077 , which occurred @xmath142 myr ago ( * ? ? ?
* see also weisz   2008 ) .
the observed hi gas along the line - of - sight to our acs field has a column density of only @xmath143@xmath144 @xcite .
recent ( @xmath145 myr ) star formation has been found not only in the outskirts of m81 itself @xcite but also in nearby tidal dwarf galaxies such as holmberg ix @xcite , bk3n @xcite , and in other nearby tidal debris @xcite .
however , in all of these cases , the recent star formation has occurred in areas with higher hi column densities ( @xmath146@xmath144 ) than that observed in our field , and is thus consistent with the lack of _ recent _ ( i.e. @xmath147  yr ) star formation in our field .
this is also consistent with the findings of @xcite , who find recent low - level star formation at levels @xmath148@xmath144 ) .
we note that while recent episodes of star formation in the outermost regions of late types galaxies have been observed at column densities similar to that in our field ( @xmath149@xmath144 ; e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , we do not see evidence of this in our ( small ) field .
we conclude that while we do see evidence for blue stars in our field , these make only a small contribution to the stellar population in our m81 field .
the main result from our analysis of a field at a ( projected ) distance of @xmath150 ( 19 kpc ) from the center of m81 , just beyond the suggested edge of the thick disk , is that the dominant population has a mean age of 9@xmath12 gyr and a peak metallicity of [ m / h]@xmath151 0.11 .
below , we discuss these results in the context of the formation history of m81 , and compare with results from the spheroids of other nearby galaxies .
the color distribution of stars on the rgb in our m81 field is relatively blue and rather narrow .
we derived the metallicity distribution of these rgb stars by comparing with theoretical isochrones , and find a mean [ m / h ] of 1.15 , with an intrinsic dispersion of 0.37 dex as shown in figure  8 .
our field is dominated by stars that are more metal - poor than stars located closer to the center of m81 ; indeed , our acs field contained the most metal - poor stars in any m81 field observed thus far . in figure  11 , we compare our mdf ( for an assumed age of 9 gyr ) with that determined by @xcite ( for globular cluster - like ages ; @xmath152  gyr for a field that is also along the southwest minor axis , but somewhat closer to the center of m81 with a projected distance of @xmath1214  kpc ( see figure 1 ) .
while the general shape for the mdf is similar in both fields , the mouhcine  field is clearly dominated by stars which are more metal - rich by @xmath153  dex than the stars studied here ( where we have already accounted for the differences in the assumed ages of the mdfs  adopting a slightly older ( by @xmath154  gyr ) age would effectively _ decrease _ the mean metallicity of our mdf by @xmath155  dex ; making the difference between the mdfs larger ) .
this metallicity difference is not likely to be due to uncertainties in the colors or in the adopted reddening values ; to match a 0.4 dex difference in [ m / h ] , our mean rgb would need to be redder by @xmath155 in ( @xmath156 . similarly , the mdfs of @xcite are more metal - poor than the outer ( thick ? ) disk field presented by @xcite , a field dominated by relatively old ( 2/3 of stars formed more than @xmath12 8 gyr ago ) but relatively metal - rich stars .
this sequence of declining metallicity with location indicates that either there is a strong metallicity gradient in the disk of m81 , or that our field ( as well as the mouhcine  field ) samples a different structural component of m81 than @xcite .
the markedly lower metallicity between our field and that of the outer disk of m81 , combined with the relatively old ages inferred for these stars ( discussed below ) and the lack of ( much ) recent star formation , provide tentative evidence that our field is largely dominated by stars in the _ halo _ of m81 , rather than in a thick disk .    in a recent wide - field study of bright stars in m81 s outer regions @xcite suggest the presence of a faint , structurally distinct component surrounding m81 with a mean metallicity [ m / h]@xmath157 ;
the large uncertainty is due to the rather limited part of the rgb observable in their ground - based data .
this metallicity is slightly higher than ( but consistent with ) the value found here .
dex ] our field is not located within the region surveyed by @xcite , but lies at a deprojected distance of 34 - 40  kpc from m81 , comparable to the distance of the fields used for their metallicity estimate .
this extended component has properties similar ( but not identical ) to either the milky way thick disk or the halo , making the exact nature of this structure somewhat uncertain .
future deep observations of m81 s outer regions will be needed to help establish the true nature of this feature .
we can compare the mdf that we derive for our 20  kpc field in m81 with the metallicities found for the spheroids / halos of other nearby galaxies . at galactocentric radii of @xmath158 kpc ,
similar to the location of our m81 pointing , the spheroid of m31 is dominated by a largely metal - rich ( [ fe / h]@xmath159 ) population @xcite .
the stars in the halo of the milky way are metal - poor , with typical [ fe / h ] values of @xmath160 to @xmath161 for the inner halo ( out to @xmath162  kpc ) @xcite and @xmath163 beyond this ( * ? ? ? * and references within ) .
the halo of the e / s0 galaxy ngc 3379 ( at a galactocentric distance of 33 kpc ) shows a broad metallicity distribution with a significant number of metal - poor ( [ m / h]@xmath164 ) stars @xcite .
in contrast , the large elliptical galaxy ngc 5128 has a metal - rich halo with [ m / h]@xmath165 to @xmath166 at _ all _ locations studied thus far , from 8 - 38 kpc @xcite .
similarly , the elliptical galaxy ngc 3377 also shows a largely metal - rich population at small galactocentric radii @xcite .    taken together , large , nearby galaxies exhibit a wide diversity of halo metallicities , showing no clear trends with parent galaxy mass or morphological type ( although there are suggestions that halo metallicity increases with galaxy mass , * ? ? ? * ) .
indeed , it appears that variations in the metallicity of halo stars _ even at different locations within a given ` halo ' _ could make any trends with parent galaxy properties difficult to quantify .
for example , the metallicity of stars in our single m81 field are similar to that of the ` halo ' of ngc 3379 , the ` outer halo ' of m31 , and the ` inner halo ' of the milky way ( assuming @xmath115\sim + 0.3 - 0.4 $ ] ) .
if we have indeed sampled the halo of m81 , an open question is whether an even more metal - poor population exists at larger galactocentric radii ; again , future studies of more distant m81 field would be worthwhile .
while our cmd does not reach the main sequence turnoff region , the most reliable age - sensitive feature in the cmd , it still holds clues to the dominant age of the stars in this region of m81 .
formal fits to the rc , rgb , and rgb bump give consistent estimates for the mean age of the stars of @xmath167  gyr .
the fact that we do not observe a strong population of blue horizontal branch stars is also consistent with these results .
we can compare the ages estimated for stars in the spheroids of different galaxies , although it should be noted that these estimates come from different techniques .
the dominant population of our m81 field is slightly younger but consistent with the mean ages ( 9.7 , 11.0 , and 10.5 gyr , for fields at distances of 11 , 21 , and 35 kpc from m31 ) of the m31 halo fields studied by ( * ? ? ? * and references within ) .
the halo of m31 also harbors globular clusters as old as those in the milky way @xcite ; however , the presence or absence of any radial age trends among this population is still largely an open question .
in contrast , the stars in our m81 field appear to be slightly younger ( by @xmath168  gyr , but just within the age uncertainties ) , than the oldest stars in the milky way halo @xcite , as our comparison with the globular cluster ngc 362 illustrated above . while there is an age spread of a few gyr among the milky way gcs with the inner halo clusters being older in the mean than those of the outer halo @xcite , the ages of globular clusters in m81 ( estimated from integrated spectra ) are indistinguishable from galactic globular clusters ( within the sizeable uncertainties * ? ? ? * ) . it should be noted that these clusters are all projected at smaller distances in m81 than the location of our field .
we note that our data do _ not _ rule out the presence of a minority population of older stars , as ancient as the majority galactic globular cluster system , in this region of m81 .    in the case of ngc 5128
, @xcite investigated the ages of field stars at a distance of 38  kpc using the magnitude of the rc , and found that it is consistent with an old population with a mean age of @xmath169 gyr , very similar to the ages that we observe in the m81 halo .
our age and metallicity results for halo stars in m81 are in broad agreement with predictions from some @xmath170cdm models @xcite , where the outer ( @xmath171 kpc ) halos of @xmath172 galaxies are expected to be formed from the accreted ( over a relatively long timescale ) debris of somewhat lower - mass progenitor galaxies than the more metal - rich systems that ( for instance ) resulted in the formation of the more metal - rich giant southern stream in m31 @xcite . in this scenario ,
the outer halos of luminous galaxies like m81 will have more metal - poor and somewhat younger combined stellar populations than that of the ( slightly ) older , more metal - rich inner halo / spheroid .
our results are broadly consistent with these predictions .
we have presented deep photometry of a field located 20 kpc from the center of m81 , believed to be dominated by halo stars .
the resulting cmd , based on hst / acs imaging , reveals a relatively blue rgb and a hb populated predominantly redward of the instability strip ( i.e. , a red clump ) . from the shape of the rgb ,
the magnitude of the red clump , and the location of the rgb bump , we derive a mean metallicity of [ m / h ] = 1.15 @xmath1 0.11 and an age of 9 @xmath1 2 gyr for the dominant population in this region of m81 s halo .
this is the lowest metallicity found for stars in any portion of m81 , almost certainly because our field is more distant than any other portion of m81 studied to date .
our age and metallicity results are broadly consistent with the predictions from @xmath170cdm models , which predict lower metallicities and younger mean ages for outer halos of spiral galaxies than for inner halos .
future studies that probe the metallicities and ages of stars even further out in the halo of m81 will allow for better constraints on the early formation of this galaxy .    a.s . and p.r.d . were supported through funds provided by nasa through grants ( go-10604.01-a and go-10604.02.a , respectively ) from the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , incorporated , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
the authors would like to thank andy dolphin and ben williams for their assistance with the photometric reductions with dolphot , and the anonymous referee for suggesting changes that improved the paper .
we would also like to thank tom brown and ben williams for providing comments on earlier versions of the manuscript , as well as michael siegel , min yun , katie chynoweth and mustapha mouhcine for helpful discussions .
abadi , m.  g. , navarro , j.  f. , & steinmetz , m.  2006 , , 365 , 747 alves , d.  r. , & sarajedini , a.  1999 , , 511 , 225 alves - brito , a. , forbes , d. a. , mendel , j. t. , hau , g. k. t. , & murphy , m. t. 2009 , , 395 , l34 allende prieto , c. , beers , t.  c. , wilhelm , r. , newberg , h.  j. , rockosi , c.  m. , yanny , b. , & lee , y.  s.  2006 , , 636 , 804 barker , m.k . , ferguson , a.m.n . , irwin , m. , arimoto , n. , & jablonka , p. 2009
, , in press bell , e.f . , 2008 , , 680 , 295 bellazzini , m. , ferraro , f.r . , & pancino , e. 2001 , , 556 , 635 brown , t.m . , ferguson , h.c . ,
smith , e. , kimble , r.a . , sweigart , a.v .
, renzini , a. , rich , r.m . &
vandenberg , d.a .
2003 , , 592 , l17 brown , t.m . ,
ferguson , h.c . ,
smith , e. , guhathakurta , p. , kimble , r.a . ,
sweigart , a.v .
, renzini , a. , rich , r.m . , & vandenberg , d.a .
2005 , , 130 , 1693 brown , t.m . ,
smith , e. , ferguson , h.c .
, rich , r.m .
, guhathakurta , p. , renzini , a. , sweigart , a.v . & kimble , r.a .
2006 , , 652 , 323 brown , t.  m. ,  2007 , , 658 , l95 brown , t.  m. ,  2008 , , 685 , l121 bullock , j.s . , & johnston , k.v .
2005 , , 635 , 931 carollo , d. , 2007 , , 450 , 1020 carretta , e. , & gratton , r.  g.  1997 , , 121 , 95 chapman , s.  c. , ibata , r. , lewis , g.  f. , ferguson , a.  m.  n. , irwin , m. , mcconnachie , a. , & tanvir , n.  2006 , , 653 , 255 chiboucas , k. , karachentsev , i.  d. , & tully , r.  b.  2009 , , 137 , 3009 dalcanton , j.  j. , et al .
2009 , , 183 , 67 davidge , t.j .
2008 , , 120 , 1145 de blok , w.  j.  g. , & walter , f.  2003 , , 341 , l39 decesar , m.  e. , durrell , p.  r. , ciardullo , r. , hurley - keller , d. , & feldmeier , j.j . 2004 , baas , 35 , 1396 de mello , d.f . ,
smith , l.j . ,
sabbi , e. , gallagher , j.s . , mountain , m. , & harbeck , d.r .
2008 , , 135 , 548 dolphin , a.e .
2000 , , 112 , 1383 dotter , a. et al . , submitted durrell , p.r . ,
harris , w.e . , & pritchet , c.j .
2001 , , 121 , 2557 durrell , p.r . ,
decesar , m.e . ,
ciardullo , r. , & feldmeier , j.j .
2004 , iau symposium 217 : recycling intergalactic and interstellar matter , eds .
duc , j. braine , e. brinks , 90 fardal , m.  a. , babul , a. , geehan , j.  j. , & guhathakurta , p.  2006
, , 366 , 1012 fardal , m.  a. , guhathakurta , p. , babul , a. , & mcconnachie , a.  w.  2007 , , 380 , 15 fardal , m.  a. , babul , a. , guhathakurta , p. , gilbert , k.  m. , & dodge , c.  2008 , , 682 , l33 ferguson , a.m.n . , irwin , m.j . ,
ibata , r.a . ,
lewis , g.f .
& tanvir , n.r .
2002 , , 124 , 1452 ferrarese , l. , 2000 , , 529 , 745 ferraro , f.  r. , messineo , m. , fusi pecci , f. , de palo , m.  a. , straniero , o. , chieffi , a. , & limongi , m.  1999 , , 118 , 1738 ferraro , f.  r. , montegriffo , p. , origlia , l. , & fusi pecci , f.  2000 , , 119 , 1282 fleming , d.e.b . ,
harris , w.e . ,
pritchet , c.j . , & hanes , d.a .
1995 , , 109 , 1044 font , a.  s. , johnston , k.  v. , guhathakurta , p. , majewski , s.  r. , & rich , r.  m.  2006 , , 131 , 1436 font , a.  s. , johnston , k.  v. , ferguson , a.  m.  n. , bullock , j.  s. , robertson , b.  e. , tumlinson , j. , & guhathakurta , p.  2008
, , 673 , 215 freedman , w.l . , 1994 , , 427 , 628 gilbert , k.  m. , et al .
2007 , , 668 , 245 girardi , l. , bressan , a. , bertelli , g. , & chiosi , c. 2000 , , 141 , 371 girardi , l. , bertelli , g. , bressan , a. , chiosi , c. , groenewegen , m.a.t . , marigo , p. , salasnich , b. , & weiss , a. 2002 , , 391 , 195 guhathakurta , p. , 2006
, preprint ( astro - ph/0502366 ) hammer , f. , puech , m. , chemin , l. , flores , h. , & lehnert , m.  d.  2007 , , 662 , 322 harris , w.  e.  2001 , saas - fee advanced course 28 : star clusters , 223 harris , g.  l.  h. , harris , w.  e. , & poole , g.  b.  1999 , , 117 , 855 harris , g.  l.  h. , & harris , w.  e.  2000 , , 120 , 2423 harris , w.  e. , & harris , g.  l.  h.  2002 , , 123 , 3108 harris , w.e . 1990 , , 102 , 949 harris , w.e . , harris , g.l.h . ,
layden , a.c .
, & stetson , p.b .
2007 , , 134 , 43 harris , w.e . , harris , g.l.h . ,
layden , a.c . , & wehner , e.m.h .
2007 , , 666 , 903 2007 , , 134 , 43 ibata , r. , irwin , m. , lewis , g. , ferguson , a.m.n . & tanvir , n. 2001 , , 412 , 49 ibata , r. , chapman , s. , ferguson , a.  m.  n. , lewis , g. , irwin , m. , & tanvir , n.  2005 , , 634 , 287 ibata , r. , martin , n.f . , irwin , m. , chapman , s. , ferguson , a.m.n . ,
lewis , g.f .
& mcconnachie , a.w .
2007 , , 671 , 1591 irwin , m.  j. , ferguson , a.  m.  n. , ibata , r.  a. , lewis , g.  f. , & tanvir , n.  r.  2005 , , 628 , l105 ivezi ,  . , et al .
2008 , , 684 , 287 juri , m. , et al .
2008 , , 673 , 864 kalirai , j.s .
2006 , , 648 , 389 karachentsev , i.d . ,
karachentseva , v.e . , & borngen , f. 1985 , , 217 , 731 karachentsev , i.d . ,  2002 , , 383 , 125 karachentseva , v.e . ,
karachentsev , i.d .
, & borngen , f. 1985 , , 60 , 213 klement , r. ,   2009 , , 698 , 865 lee , m.g . , freedman , w.l .
, & madore , b.f .
1993 , , 417 , 553 ma , j. , fan , z. , de grijs , r. , wu , z.,zhou , x. , wu , j. , jiang , z. , & chen , j. 2009 , , 137 , 4884 mackey , a. d. ,  2009 , , in press ( arxiv:0909.1456 ) madore , b.f .
, & freedman , w.l .
1995 , , 109 , 1645 makarova , l.n . ,
2002 , , 396 , 473 marin - franch , a. ,   2009 , , 694 , 1498 marigo , p. , girardi , l. , bressan , a. , groenewegen , m.a.t . ,
silva , l. , & granato , g. l. 2008 , , 482 , 883 maybhate , a. , masiero , j. , hibbard , j.  e. , charlton , j.  c. , palma , c. , knierman , k.  a. , & english , j.  2007 , , 381 , 59 mccommas , l.p . ,
yoachim , p. , williams , b.f . ,
dalcanton , j.j . ,
davis , m.r . , & dolphin , a.e .
2009 , , 137 , 4707 mcconnachie , a.w . , irwin , m.j . , ferguson , a.m.n . , ibata , r.a . ,
lewis , g.f . , & tanvir , n. 2004 , , 350 , 243 mcconnachie , a.w .
2009 , , 461 , 66 mouhcine , m. , & ibata , r. 2010 , , in press mouhcine , m. 2006 , , 652 , 277 mouchine , m. , ferguson , h.c . , rich , r.m . ,
brown , t.m . , & smith , t.e .
2005 , , 633 , 810 mouhcine , m. , rejkuba , m. , & ibata , r. 2007 , , 381 , 873 mould , j. , & kristian , j.  1986 , , 305 , 591 newberg , h.  j. , et al .
2002 , , 569 , 245 newberg , h.  j. , yanny , b. , & willett , b.  a.  2009 , , 700 , l61 pietrinferni , a. , cassisi , s. , salaris , m. , & castelli , f.  2004 , , 612 , 168 rejkuba , m. , greggio , l. , harris , w.e . , harris , g.l.h . , & peng , e.w .
2005 , , 631 , 262 rejkuba , m. , mouhcine , m. , ibata , r. 2009 , , in press richardson , j.  c. , et al .
2008 , , 135 , 1998 riess , a. 2003 , acs isr 2003 - 009 ( baltimore , stsci ) rizzi , l. , tully , r.b . , makarov , d. , makarova , l. , dolphin , a.e .
, sakai , s. , shaya , e.j .
2007 , , 661 , 815 robin , a.  c. , reyl , c. , derrire , s. , & picaud , s.  2003 , , 409 , 523 ryan , s. , & norris , j. 1991 , , 101 , 1865 sabbi , e. , gallagher , j.s . ,
smith , lj .
, de mello , d.f . , & mountain , m. 2008 , , 676 , l113 sakai , s. , madore , b.f . , &
freedman , w.l .
1996 , , 461 , 713 sakai , s. , & madore , b.f .
2001 , , 555 , 280 sarajedini , a. 2009 , in the ages of stars , iau symposium , vol .
258 , p. 221 sarajedini , a. , & jablonka , p. 2005
, , 130 , 1627 sarajedini , a. ,  2007 , , 133 , 1658 sirianni , m. ,  2005 , , 117 , 1049 schlegel , d.j . , finkbeiner , d.p . , & davis , m. 1998 , , 500 , 525 schroder , l. l. , brodie , j. p. , kissler - patig , m. , huchra , j. p. , & phillips , a. c. 2002 , , 123 , 2473 smith , m.  c. , et al .  2009 , , 399 , 1223 stetson , p.b .
1987 , , 99 , 191 stetson , p.b . , davis , l.e . , &
crabtree , d.r .
1990 , in asp conf .
ser . 8 , ccds in astronomy , ed .
jacoby ( san francisco : asp ) , 289 stetson , p.b .
1992 , in asp conf .
25 , astronomical data analysis software and systems i , eds .  d.m .
worral , c. biemesderfer , and j. barnes ( san francisco : asp ) , 297 thilker , d.  a. , et al .
2007 , , 173 , 538 tikhonov , n. a. , galazutdinova , o.a . , & drozdovsky , i.o .
2005 , , 431 , 12 weisz , d.  r. , skillman , e.  d. , cannon , j.  m. , dolphin , a.  e. , kennicutt , r.  c. , jr . ,
lee , j. , & walter , f.  2008 , , 689 , 160 williams , b.f . , 2009 , , 137 , 419 yanny , b. , et al .
2003 , , 588 , 824 yun , m.s . , ho , p.t.p . , & lo , k.y . 1994 , , 372 , 530 yun , m.s . 1999 , galaxy interactions at low and high redshift , iau symp .
d.sanders , 81 zinn , r. j. 1985 , , 293 , 424