the most massive stars begin their lives in the darkest recesses of giant molecular clouds , obscured from our view by a thick veil of dust and gas .
most of the time the earliest stages of massive star formation can not be observed at visual wavelengths , and in many cases even the near - infrared emission from these protostars can not escape .
we owe much of our ignorance of the massive star formation process to the fact that we have a very limited range of wavelengths at our disposal with which to observe these youngest stages of massive stellar evolution .
the problem is further compounded by the fact that massive ob stars ( @xmath1 8 m@xmath2 ) are relatively few in number and , like all stages of massive stellar evolution , the formation process proceeds very quickly .
it is therefore difficult to catch massive stars in the act of forming .
additionally , there is the problem of observing these objects with sufficient angular resolution .
massive star - forming regions generally lie at kiloparsec distances , making them more than an order of magnitude farther away than the closest low - mass star - forming regions .
furthermore , the percentage of binaries and multiple star systems increases as a function of mass ( larson 2001 ) , and consequently it is believed that the vast majority of massive stars do not form alone .
it is this combined distance and multiplicity problem that makes it difficult to resolve and study in detail a single massive star in its earliest years of formation .
observations that have been extremely helpful in the study of massive stars have been cm - wavelength radio continuum and molecular line emission observations .
interferometric arrays can observe with subarcsecond angular resolution the radio continuum emission from the photoionized region in the near - stellar environment around young massive stars .
these compact or ultra - compact ( uc ) regions are thought to exist @xmath310@xmath4 years after the formation of a massive star ( de pree , rodrguez , & goss 1995 ) . until recently
, this was the earliest observed phase of massive star formation .    in order to understand better their formation process , we need to observe massive stars at ages even younger than 10@xmath4 years .
this means trying to observe sources before they develop uc regions , which in most of the cases limits our window of continuum observations to a relatively narrow wavelength regime from the mid - infrared ( @xmath33 @xmath0 m ) to the millimeter ( @xmath31 mm ) .
observing sources in this `` high mass protostellar object '' ( hmpo ) phase presents a challenge since the best resolutions achievable throughout most of this wavelength range ( namely the far - infrared to the sub - millimeter ) have , until recently , been on the order of a few to tens of arcseconds .
however , the bright molecular line emission from these sources would still be observable with high angular resolution radio interferometers .
hot cores of compact and dense molecular gas have been known to exist in massive star forming regions for several decades now ( e.g. , wilson , downes , & bieging 1979 ) . some of these `` hot molecular cores '' ( hmcs ) are simply externally heated knots of material , but others may have stars forming at their centers .
recently some hmcs have been gaining serious attention as possibly forming extremely young massive stars at their centers ( cesaroni et al .
1994 ; kurtz et al .
walmsley ( 1995 ) proposed that these types of hmcs are undergoing an intense accretion phase which prevents the development of a uc region .
since these types of hmcs do not possess radio continuum emission and are internally heated by massive protostars , they fit into the category of hmpos .
though the compositions of these sources are beginning to be understood in detail through the molecular line studies ( e.g. , rodgers & charnley 2001 ) , continuum observations remain few because of the angular resolution problem .
however , continuum observations from the mid - infrared to millimeter have the potential for revealing valuable information about the massive star formation process . models of the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) of hmcs have been developed under the assumption that they have a central massive star undergoing spherical accretion of a free - falling envelope of dust and gas ( osorio , lizano , & dalessio 1999 ) .
the success of these models in fitting the observable characteristics of hmcs gave strong support to the hypothesis that some of these objects were true hmpos ( i.e. , not starless hmcs ) in a stage previous to the development of an uc region .
however , for that work , only mid - infrared upper limits were available in most of the sources .
since the mid - infrared range of the sed is highly sensitive to the geometry of the source ( i.e. , degree of flattening ) , in principle , these kinds of observations would allow testing of more sophisticated models , with a degree of detail similar to that of those that have been developed for low - mass protostars ( e.g. , osorio et al .
2003 ) .
recently , observations by de buizer ( 2004 ) and de buizer et al .
( 2003 ) have identified four candidate hmpos that have been observed in the mid - infrared with high - angular resolution .
these hmpo candidates lie in areas of high mass star formation , as evidenced by nearby uc regions .
in fact in two of these four cases , high spatial resolution observations from 8 m telescopes were needed to simply isolate the mid - infrared emission of the hmpos from the nearby uc regions .
this means that , though more sensitive than what is achievable from the ground , data from infrared satellites like _ msx _
( @xmath35@xmath5 at 8 @xmath6 , @xmath313@xmath5 at 21 @xmath6 ) , and even the _ spitzer space telescope _
( @xmath32@xmath5 at 8 @xmath6 , @xmath36@xmath5 at 24 @xmath6 ) , are in general not adequate for these studies because of their relatively poor angular resolutions .
by being able to isolate emission from the hmpo alone , mid - infrared observations from ground - based 8 to 10m - class telescopes represent a invaluable tool in the study of these earliest stages of massive star formation .
in this article we present new sub - arcsecond mid - infrared observations of three of the four candidate hmpos identified by de buizer ( 2004 ) and de buizer et al .
the fourth hmpo candidate , g305.20 + 0.21 , will be the subject of a following article . using the gemini south telescope we imaged these three hmpo candidates through up to 11 filters , sampling their seds over the entire 225 @xmath0 m infrared atmospheric window .
our motivation for performing these observations was to sample the seds of hmpos with sufficient spectral resolution and coverage to accurately test new sed models .
these models use envelopes that take into account deviations from spherical geometry in their inner region due to rotation and at large scales due to natural elongation of the source . by matching these models to the data we attempt to `` back out '' of the models detailed physical parameters for these earliest stages of massive stellar life . in this way
, we hope to be able to learn some details about the massive star formation process during these highly obscured stages , as well as the strength and limitations of the non - spherical sed models .
observations were carried out at gemini south over the time period between 2003 september and 2004 november .
imaging was performed with the thermal - region camera and spectrograph ( t - recs ) .
the instrument employs a raytheon 320@xmath7240 pixel si : as ibc array which is optimized for use in the 726 @xmath0 m wavelength range , but can perform with modest sensitivity in the 25 @xmath0 m wavelength range as well .
the pixel scale is 0.089@xmath5/pixel , yielding a field of view of 28@xmath88@xmath721@xmath86 .
sky and telescope subtraction were achieved through the standard chop - nod technique .
images were performed with _
k _ , _ l _ , and _ m _ filters , as well as six narrowband silicate filters encompassing the full 10 @xmath0 m _ n_-band spectral window , and two narrowband filters within the 20 @xmath0 m _ q_-band spectral window .
effective central wavelengths for these filters and their spectral range are given in table 1 .
for g11.94 - 0.62 and g45.07 + 0.13 we also have images from de buizer et al .
( 2003 ) through the _ q3 _
( @xmath9=20.81 @xmath0 m , @xmath10=19.9921.64 @xmath0 m ) filter from the nasa infrared telescope facility ( irtf ) using the instrument mirlin .
table 1 also lists the on - source integration times through each of the t - recs filters for each hmpo candidate field .
in addition , this table lists the standard star used to flux calibrate each image , and the assumed flux density for that standard through the given filter .
these assumed standard star flux densities were found by convolving the spectral irradiance templates of the stars from cohen et al .
( 1999 ) with the given t - recs filter transmission profile .
flux densities were derived for each filter for the hmpo candidate as well as any other mid - infrared sources on the field .
tables 2 - 4 list the flux densities for all sources .
these flux densities are quoted with their 1-@xmath11 total error , which is a quadrature addition of the statistical variation from the aperture photometry ( due to the standard deviation of the background array noise ) and the flux calibration error .
usually the flux calibration error is found from the variation of the standard star flux throughout the course of the night , however our observations were taken piece - wise on many nights throughout several semesters .
flux calibration was therefore achieved by observing a standard star at a similar airmass just before or after the observation of the target science field .
therefore , we do not have calibration variability statistics for each filter on each night the data were taken .
the calibration factor [ ratio of accepted flux in janskys to analog - to - digital converter units ( adus ) per second per pixel ] derived from the standard star observations through each filter varied little throughout 14 months of data collection , and so we use here the standard deviation of the calibration factor over this 14 month period as the flux calibration error .
this can be considered an extremely conservative estimate of the errors , taking into account a wide variety of atmospheric and observing conditions that affect flux calibration .
most filters have modest flux calibration errors ( for mid - infrared observations ) with standard deviations between 2 and 10% .
flux calibration through certain filters is more difficult due to the presence of various atmospheric absorption lines contaminating the filter bandpass , some of which can be highly variable .
those filters most affected are the 7.7 @xmath0 m ( 21% ) , 12.3 @xmath0 m ( 19% ) , 18.3 @xmath0 m ( 15% ) , and 24.6 @xmath0 m ( 23% ) filters .
furthermore , the continuum observed through these filters may be affected by the presence of certain spectral features common to young stellar objects .
in particular , the 12.3 @xmath0 m continuum flux densities for the targets may be skewed to higher values due to the presence of bright [ neii ] lines at 12.8 @xmath0 m ( see for instance , faison et al .
the 18.3 @xmath0 m and 20.8 @xmath0 m observations can also be skewed high or low depending on the presence in either emission or absorption of the 18 @xmath0 m silicate feature .
the three sources below were chosen because they are among the only hmpo candidates known to be bright in the mid - infrared ( de buizer 2004 , de buizer et al .
2003 ) and are sufficiently far enough away from nearby regions to be studied in detail without confusion .
all three sources are thought to be hmpos primarily because they are sources found in regions of known high mass star formation yet have no uc emission of their own , and all are coincident with molecular maser emission which is thought to trace massive star formation and its processes .
each source has further unique evidence indicating that it is a hmpo , which we discuss in detail below .
a summary of the observations for each object will also be discussed in this context .      of the four sources identified as mid - infrared bright hmpo candidates by de buizer ( 2004 ) and de buizer et al .
( 2003 ) , the status of the source in g11.94 - 0.62:drt03 1 as a genuine hmpo is the most uncertain .
however the hmpo candidate in g11.94 - 0.62 satisfies , at the very least , the minimum criteria outlined at the beginning of this section .
drt03 1 was found as an unresolved mid - infrared source in the survey of de buizer et al .
( 2003 ) located at the site of a water maser clump offset @xmath310@xmath5 from a cometary uc region .
drt03 1 has no detected cm radio continuum emission of its own .
however , g11.94 - 0.62 has not been observed with high spatial resolution molecular line imaging .
some molecular tracers have been discovered toward the region , like cs ( bronfman et al .
1996 ) and nh@xmath12 ( cesaroni , walmsley , & churchwell 1992 ) , but it is not known if this emission is related to the nearby uc region , the hmpo candidate , or both . while it is encouraging that some molecules have been found in the region , ch@xmath12cn ( a tracer of denser and hotter molecular material and indicator of the presence of hmcs ) has been searched for in the region and was not detected ( watt & mundy 1999 ) .
the uc region was also imaged at 2.7 mm by watt & mundy ( 1999 ) , but there was no detection at the site of drt03 1 .
de buizer et al . ( 2003 ) derive a lower limit to the bolometric luminosity for drt03 1 , finding that it is at least as bright as a b9 star .
though this spectral type is derived from an extreme lower limit to the bolometric luminosity , it does not appear that this source is a massive ( m@xmath1310@xmath14 ) protostar , but more likely an intermediate mass protostellar object .
if this is true , given its observational similarities to its higher mass counterparts , it will be interesting to study the similarities and differences in detail to learn more about the interrelation of the intermediate and high mass star formation processes .
it would also have interesting consequences for the hypotheses regarding excitation of water masers by lower mass ( non - ionizing ) stars ( forster & caswell 2000 ) .    our sensitive gemini mid - infrared observations of the region around g11.94 - 0.62 have revealed extended dust structure , the likes of which are not seen at any other spectral regime ( figure 1 ) . these images at the sub - arcsecond angular resolution of gemini confirm the results of the lower resolution observations of de buizer et al .
( 2003 ) that the mid - infrared morphology of the uc region is not cometary , as is seen in cm radio continuum emission ( wood & churchwell 1989 ) .
the hmpo candidate , drt03 1 , is clearly detected at shorter mid - infrared wavelengths but is only a 3-@xmath11 and 4-@xmath11 detection at 20.8 and 24.6 @xmath0 m , respectively .    with no information on the rayleigh - jeans side of the sed for the hmpo candidate alone
, we will not be able to constrain the models at the longer wavelengths .
table 2 lists the observed flux densities for the hmpo candidate as well as for the other mid - infrared sources in the field .
it is not clear if each of these mid - infrared sources house a stellar component or if they are simply knots of dust in an extensive region .
the hmpo candidate in g29.96@xmath150.02 is sufficiently well - studied to be considered a prototype .
the hot molecular component of this source was first discovered in the observations of cesaroni et al .
( 1994 ) . in this work ,
a hot ( t@xmath16@xmath13 50 k ) core of molecular material was detected , traced by nh@xmath12(4,4 ) line emission near to , but offset @xmath32@xmath5 from a cometary - shaped region .
this hot molecular core was found to be coincident with a cluster of water masers .
cesaroni et al .
( 1994 ) conjectured that this source , like the other hmcs in their survey , is internally heated by a developing massive protostar .
however , as was mentioned in the introduction , some hmcs could be externally heated by the nearby massive stars powering the uc regions . in the case of g29.96 - 0.02 ,
the millimeter line study of gibb , wyrowski , & mundy ( 2003 ) provided strong evidence that the hmc is internally heated .
therefore , the hmc in g29.96 - 0.02 appears to be a genuine hmpo .
the hmpo in g29.96 - 0.02 was directly imaged for the first time in the mid - infrared by de buizer et al .
( 2002 ) on the gemini north 8-m telescope .
the hmpo lies @xmath33@xmath5 away from the radio continuum peak of the bright region and the emission from the uc region peak can not be resolved from the hmpo on 4-m class telescopes ( watson et al .
however , the large aperture of gemini has sufficient resolving power in the mid - infrared ( @xmath30@xmath85 ) to pull in the peak of the dust emission from the region to allow direct observation of the hmpo .
even so , the resolved thermal dust emission from the region is still extensive , and therefore we can not avoid observing the hmpo overlaid on a diffuse background of emission ( figure 2 ) . following the technique outlined by de buizer et al .
( 2002 ) , one can fit this background emission and subtract it off , effectively leaving only the mid - infrared emission of the hmpo .
this technique was employed for the images obtained in the work presented here . in table 3
we present the flux densities for the hmpo candidates and the uc , as well as the flux density of the hmpo candidate without subtracting off the background due to the extended uc emission .
this was done so that it is transparent to the reader how much flux has been subtracted off , and what the absolute upper limits are for the flux densities of the hmpo candidate .    the g29.96 - 0.02 hmpo has been studied in great detail in molecular line studies ( e.g. , cesaroni et al .
1998 , wyrowski , schilke , & walmsley 1999 ; maxia et al . 2001 . )
however , other than the mid - infrared observations of de buizer et al .
( 2002 ) and those presented here , only a few continuum observations at other wavelengths exist .
this source has been observed at 1 and 3 mm by maxia et al .
however , as pointed out by de buizer et al .
( 2002 ) , there appears to be problems with these flux densities since they lead to a negative value ( see figure [ fig6 ] ) for the index of dust opacity , @xmath17 , whereas most models assume 1@xmath18@xmath17@xmath182 for @xmath19@xmath1200 @xmath0 m .
another observation at 3 mm was carried out by olmi el al .
they did not resolve the hmpo , and therefore there might be possible contamination from the nearby uc region .
they try to obtain the flux density of the hmpo at 3 mm , making a subtraction of the free - free contamination estimated from the 2 cm image .
this measurement together with the detection of the hmpo at 1.4 mm carried out by wyrowski et al .
( 2005 , personal communication ) indicate that g29.96 - 0.02 hmpo is a strong emitter at millimeter wavelengths .
listed as a `` known hot core '' in the review article of kurtz et al .
( 2000 ) , the hmpo in g45.07 + 0.13 gained attention mostly through the work of hunter , phillips , & menten ( 1997 ) .
however most of the observations by hunter , phillips , & menten ( 1997 ) are low spatial resolution continuum and molecular line maps observed towards uc regions . in the case of g45.07
+ 0.13 they found several molecular tracers , some believed to be in outflow , emanating from the location of the uc region .
hunter , phillips , & menten ( 1997 ) contest that there is a single star here , embedded in a molecular core , at a very early stage of development such that it has just begun to develop a uc region . for these reasons
it has been labeled a hot core .
the observations of de buizer et al .
( 2003 ) showed that there are three mid - infrared sources at this location , all within 8@xmath5 of each other .
the brightest mid - infrared source on the field is coincident with the uc region .
however , at a location @xmath32@xmath5 north of the uc region there is a group of water masers associated with a mid - infrared source that has no cm radio continuum emission ( figure 3 ) .
de buizer et al .
( 2003 ) showed that this northern mid - infrared source , drt03 3 , has a very bright mid - infrared luminosity of @xmath34@xmath710@xmath20 l@xmath21 .
assuming that the mid - infrared luminosity is equal to the bolometric luminosity ( a gross underestimate ) , drt03 3 has the equivalent luminosity of a b0 star .
we therefore have a source luminous enough to be a massive protostar , situated at the location of a group of water masers , yet this source has no cm radio continuum emission of its own .
for these reasons , de buizer et al .
( 2003 ) claim that drt03 3 is the true hmpo in this field .
although there are multiple sources of thermal dust emission present here , it does appear from the high spatial resolution cs maps of hunter , phillips , and menten ( 1997 ) that the stellar source powering the uc region is the only viable source of the outflow in the region ( contrary to what was stated by de buizer et al .
since no such tracers are seen coming from the hmpo candidate , this perhaps confirms the youth of the object , placing it in a stage of formation before the onset of an outflow .
while the resolution of the 800 and 450 @xmath0 m maps of hunter , phillips , & menten ( 1997 ) are too coarse to ascertain which mid - infrared source may be dominating the emission at these longer wavelengths , their higher resolution ( @xmath32@xmath5 ) 3 mm map shows no emission from the location of drt03 3 , though emission is detected towards the other two mid - infrared sources on the field .    our new observations of this field with gemini have revealed the presence of four more faint mid - infrared sources present ( figure 3 ) in addition to those already found by de buizer et al .
it appears that this may be a small cluster of star formation centered on the o9 star powering the uc region .
drt03 3 is seen at all 11 mid - infrared wavelengths , as is the uc region ( drt03 2 ) .
table 4 lists the flux densities for all mid - infrared sources on the field .
unfortunately , we have no detections of the hmpo candidate alone at any wavelength on the rayleigh - jeans side of the sed , and have to rely upon integrated flux density measurements from the whole region ( su et al .
2004 ) as upper limits to constrain the models .
we will calculate the sed of a hmpo by modeling it as an envelope of gas and dust that is freely falling onto a recently formed massive central star , which is responsible for the heating .
osorio , lizano & dalessio ( 1999 ) modeled the sed of a sample of such objects by assuming that the envelope has spherical symmetry . for that work ,
only upper limits were available for the mid - infrared flux densities of most of the sources . because this wavelength range is very sensitive to the geometry of the source , here we extend that work by including rotation and flattening of the envelope in the models , so that the results can be tested with the new mid - infrared data presented in this paper .
for this purpose , we have followed procedures similar to those already developed in low - mass star models ( osorio et al .
2003 ) .
envelopes with a density distribution such as that given by terebey , shu , & cassen ( 1984 , hereafter tsc envelopes ) assume that the rotation of the infalling material becomes important only in the vicinity of the centrifugal radius , @xmath22 , where @xmath23 is the angular velocity ( assumed to be constant and small ) at a distant reference radius @xmath24 , and @xmath25 is the mass of the central protostar .
the tsc envelopes are flattened only in the inner region , being essentially spherical in the outer region .
the inner regions ( @xmath26 ) of these envelopes are described by the solution of cassen & moosman ( 1981 ) and ulrich ( 1976 ) ( hereafter referred as cmu ) .
the solution is determined by specifying the velocities and densities at the ( distant ) reference radius @xmath24 , where the velocity is nearly equal to the radial free - fall value , with only a small azimuthal component corresponding to a constant angular velocity , and the density is set by the required mass infall rate @xmath27 . with these assumptions , the density of the inner envelope ( @xmath26 ) is given by @xmath28 @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the position angles with respect to the rotational symmetry axis of the system at radial distances from the central mass @xmath32 and @xmath24 , respectively . at large distances ( @xmath33 )
the motions are radial ( @xmath34 ) and the density tends to the density distribution for radial free - fall at constant mass infall rate . for @xmath35 , the motions become significantly non - radial , and the angular momentum of the infalling material causes it to land on a disk ( @xmath36 ) at distances @xmath37 .
therefore , @xmath38 is the largest radius on the equatorial plane that receives the infalling material .
a more complex description can be given in terms of intrinsically flattened envelopes , such as those with the density distribution resulting from the gravitational collapse of a sheet initially in hydrostatic equilibrium ( hartmann et al .
1994 ; hartmann , calvet , & boss 1996 ) .
these envelopes are flattened not only in their inner region , because of rotation ( as the tsc envelopes ) , but also at large scales due to the natural elongation of the cloud .
if the rotational axis is perpendicular to the plane of the self - gravitating layer , the density distribution of the infalling material will be axisymmetric and can be written as : @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the cmu density distribution for the same @xmath41 and @xmath38 , and @xmath42 is a measure of the degree of flattening ( hartmann et al .
the degree of flattening in these envelopes is measured by the parameter @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is the outer radius of the envelope and @xmath45 is the scale height .
hereafter , we will designate them as @xmath42-envelopes .
the scale of this density distribution can be set by using the parameter @xmath46 , defined as @xmath47 where @xmath48 is a reference radius .
this reference density corresponds to the density that a spherically symmetric free - falling envelope with the same mass accretion rate , @xmath27 , would have at the reference radius @xmath48 . in our modeling
, we will use @xmath49 au , and we will designate the reference density as @xmath50 .
the remaining parameters that define the density distribution of the @xmath42-envelopes are the centrifugal radius , @xmath38 , and the inclination of the polar ( rotational ) axis to the line of sight , @xmath51 . since @xmath42-envelopes are flattened not only in their inner region but also at large scales most of their material is accumulated over the equatorial plane , having an extinction lower than a tsc envelope of the same mass provided the line of sight is not oriented too close to the edge - on position .
therefore , a flattened @xmath42-envelope model predicts stronger near and mid - infrared emission and less deep absorption features than those predicted by a tsc envelope model of the same mass .
given that our sources are strong mid - infrared emitters , we will preferentially use the @xmath42-envelope density distribution to model our sources .
the temperature distribution along the envelope , as well as the sed from 2 @xmath0 m to 2 cm , are determined following the procedures described by kenyon , calvet , & hartmann ( 1993 , hereafter kch93 ) , calvet et al .
( 1994 ) , hartmann et al .
( 1996 ) , and osorio et al .
( 2003 ) . for a given luminosity of the central star , @xmath52 , which is assumed to be the only heating source ( i.e. , neglecting other possible sources of heating such as accretion energy from a disk or the envelope ) ,
the temperature structure in the envelope is calculated from the condition of radiative equilibrium , using the approximation of an angle - averaged density distribution .
nevertheless , the emergent flux density is calculated using the exact density distribution .
because we want to compare our results with high spectral resolution mid - infrared data , our model spectra wavelengths were finely sampled ( @xmath53log@xmath19 = 0.02 ) in the range 3 - 25  @xmath0 m in order to define with high spectral resolution the 10  @xmath0 m silicate absorption feature . outside this range , wavelengths were sampled at @xmath53log@xmath19 = 0.2 - 0.3 .
additionally , in order to make a proper comparison with the observations , we convolved our results with the t - recs filter transmission profile .
given that the spectral response of the filters is fairly constant , we do not find large variations ( only @xmath35% ) between the averaged and original spectrum .    in our models we use a recently improved dust opacity law , corresponding to a mixture of compounds that was adjusted by matching the observations of the well known low - mass protostar l1551 irs5 ( osorio et al . 2003 ) .
this mixture includes graphite , astronomical silicates , troilite and water ice , with the standard grain - size distribution of the interstellar medium , @xmath54 , with a minimum size of 0.005  @xmath0 m and a maximum size of 0.3  @xmath0 m .
the details of the dust opacity calculations are described by dalessio , calvet , & hartmann ( 2001 ) .    the inner radius of the envelope , @xmath55 , is taken to be the dust destruction radius , that is assumed to occur at a temperature of 1200 k , corresponding to the sublimation temperature of silicates at low densities ( dalessio 1996 ) .
the centrifugal radius is assumed to be considerably larger than the dust destruction radius in order to have a significant degree of flattening due to rotation in the inner envelope .
the outer radius of the envelope , @xmath44 , is obtained from our 11.7  @xmath0 m images .    in summary ,
once the dust opacity law and the inner and outer radius of the envelope are defined , the free parameters of our model are @xmath42 , @xmath50 , @xmath38 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 . in the following
, we will discuss on the contribution of these parameters to the resulting sed .      in order to illustrate the effect of the flattening of the envelope
, we have calculated the resulting sed for a tsc envelope and compared it with an @xmath56 envelope of the same mass .
the results are shown in figure 4 , where it can be seen that the flattened @xmath56 envelope predicts stronger near and mid - infrared emission , and less deep absorption features than the tsc envelope , both for low ( @xmath57 ) and moderately high ( @xmath58 ) inclination angles .
this behavior is a consequence of the flatter distribution of material in the @xmath56 envelope , resulting in an extinction lower than the tsc envelope over a wide range of viewing angles ( except for a nearly edge - on view , @xmath59 , where the behavior would be the opposite ) .
thus , in general , the flattened @xmath42-envelopes allow the escape of a larger amount of near and mid - infrared radiation , and consequently they predict stronger flux densities than the tsc envelopes in this wavelength range . since our sources are strong infrared emitters , in our models we will use @xmath42-envelopes with a significant degree of flattening , @xmath42 , of the order of 2 .
the observed seds of our sources are well sampled in the near and mid - infrared wavelength range . however , this wavelength coverage in insufficient for the models to determine the value of the bolometric luminosity ( that we take to coincide with the stellar luminosity , @xmath52 ) .
the bolometric luminosity is well constrained by the far - infrared data ( where the peak of the sed occurs ) , and to a less extent by the submillimeter or millimeter data .
unfortunately , the available far - infrared data for our sources do not have the appropriate angular resolution to avoid contamination from other nearby sources , and should be considered as upper limits , while millimeter data are only available for one of our sources .
therefore , in general , we constrain the value of the luminosity by fitting the mid - infrared data closer to the sed peak , that are helpful to set a lower limit for the luminosity .
on the other hand , the depth and shape of the silicate absorption feature ( which is very well delineated by our mid - infrared data ) determines the extinction along the line - of - sight , that in turn is related to the inclination angle , @xmath51 , the density scale , @xmath46 , and the centrifugal radius , @xmath38 .
the depth of the 10 @xmath0 m silicate absorption increases not only with the density scale of the envelope , but also with the inclination angle , since the extinction is much smaller along the rotational pole ( @xmath60 ) than along the equator ( @xmath59 ) ( see osorio et al .
thus , the behavior of the parameters @xmath46 and @xmath51 is somewhat interchangeable in the mid - infrared ( although such behavior is different at millimeter wavelengths ) . for instance , an envelope with a combination of low density and high inclination could have an extinction and mid - infrared emission similar to an envelope with a higher density but viewed pole - on .
therefore , for the sources where millimeter data are not available , it is difficult to constrain @xmath51 and @xmath46 simultaneously , and we will search for fits both for high as well as for low inclination angles .
the behavior of the sed with the centrifugal radius , @xmath38 , is more complex .
increasing the value of @xmath38 will widen the region of evacuated material , producing an overall decrease of the extinction along the line of sight , but , at the same time , it will result in a decrease of the temperature of the envelope , because the material tends to pile up at larger distances from the source of luminosity .
thus , depending on the wavelength range , one of the two effects will be the dominant . at short wavelengths , where the dust opacity is higher , it is expected that the lower extinction of the envelopes with large values of @xmath38 will result in an increase of the observed emission . at longer wavelengths , where the opacity is low enough ( except in the silicate absorption feature ) ,
the dominant effect is expected to be due to the decrease in the temperature , resulting in a decrease of the observed emission for larger values of @xmath38 .
this is illustrated in figure 4 , where it is shown that the emission of the envelope with @xmath61 au dominates in the near - infrared range , while the emission of the @xmath62 au envelope dominates at longer wavelengths .
as shown in the figure , this result is valid both for low and relatively high inclination angles , although we note that the point where the small @xmath38 envelope becomes dominant shifts slightly to longer wavelengths when increasing the inclination angle ( from @xmath63 m for @xmath57 to @xmath64 m for @xmath58 ) .
this shift occurs because envelopes seen at higher inclination angles are more opaque , thus requiring a longer wavelength ( where the opacity is lower ) for the small @xmath38 envelope to become dominant .    since we expect the value of @xmath38 to be of the order of the radius of a possible circumstellar disk , in our modeling we will explore a range of values for @xmath38 from tens to hundreds of aus , depending on the luminosity of the source .
the upper limit of this range is suggested by the highest angular resolution observations of disks reported towards massive protostars ( e.g. , shepherd , claussen , & kurtz 2001 ) , while the lower limit is set by the smallest values recently reported for protoplanetary disks around low - mass ysos ( rodrguez et al .
2005 ) .
from the values of the parameters obtained from our fits to the observed seds we can derive other physical parameters , such as the total mass of the envelope , @xmath65 , obtained by integration of the density distribution , and the mass of the central star , @xmath25 , derived from its luminosity , @xmath52 .
once the mass of the star is known , the mass accretion rate in the envelope , @xmath27 , can be derived from the value of @xmath46 .
yorke ( 1984 ) and walmsley ( 1995 ) proposed that some objects could be accreting material at a rate high enough to quench the development of an incipient hii region .
these objects would lack detectable free - free emission , being good candidates to be the precursors of the uchii regions . in the case of spherical accretion , it is easy to show that the critical mass accretion rate required to reduce the hii region to a small volume close to the stellar surface is @xmath66 , where @xmath67 is the hydrogen mass , and @xmath68 is the recombination coefficient ( excluding captures to the @xmath69 level ) .
we will adopt the value , @xmath70 , as a critical measure of the mass accretion rate required to `` choke off '' the possible development of an uc region . since we are assuming departures from spherical symmetry in our envelopes , in reality a more complex calculation would be required to accurately derive the corresponding critical mass rate .
however , for simplicity we will assume that if the ratio between the mass accretion rate in our envelope and the critical spherical mass accretion rate @xmath71 , it would indicate that photoionized emission is not expected to be detectable in the source .
in this section , we estimate the physical parameters of the three hmpo candidates by fitting our models to the observed seds , using also the available information on size and morphology inferred from the images . given that spherical envelopes do not appear to be able to account for the observed properties of the seds in the mid - infrared ,
we have modeled the sources using @xmath42-envelopes with a significant degree of elongation ( see discussion in @xmath724.2 ) . since the temperature distribution in the envelopes
is estimated using the approximation of an angle - averaged density distribution , valid for moderately elongated envelopes , we did not attempt to consider very high values of @xmath42 , that correspond to extremely elongated envelopes where the temperature calculations probably would not be accurate enough .
therefore , we explored values of @xmath42 around 2 , and in all three sources we were able to get good fits for @xmath73 .
we note that this value coincides with the one that provided the best fit for the low - mass protostar l1551-irs5 , after exploring a wide range of values of the @xmath42 parameter ( osorio et al .
2003 ) .    given the incomplete and non - uniform coverage of the observed sed , the fitting process can not be automated and should be carried out manually on a case - by - case basis . as was already mentioned in the previous section ,
the luminosity is well constrained by the peak of the sed , that is expected to happen in the far - infrared .
unfortunately , at present , far - infrared observations do not reach the angular resolution required to properly isolate the emission of these distant sources from contamination of other sources in their vicinity .
therefore , in general , the far - infrared data are considered only as upper limits and we have to use the mid - infrared data to obtain a range of possible values for the luminosity .
thus , the general strategy was to first run a set of models with increasing luminosities until we found a value that was able to reproduce the observed mid - infrared flux density near the peak of the sed and consistent with the millimeter and submillimeter data .
once an approximate value of the luminosity was found , we proceeded to run a set of models to find the density scale , which is then basically determined by the millimeter and submillimeter data points . when the density scale was fixed , we ran models with different inclinations in order to find the best fit to the absorption feature in the mid - infrared , which is particularly sensitive to the value of the inclination angle . finally , we refined the modeling by testing a range of possible values of the centrifugal radius .
if the data point coverage of the sed is good enough we should end this process with essentially one final model ( the `` best fit model '' ) that is able to reproduce the observed data points within the constrains imposed by the observational uncertainties . in the case
that only upper limits are available in the millimeter and submillimeter domain , the density scale and inclination angle can not be constrained simultaneously , and in this case we present two fits , one for a low inclination angle , and a second one for a high inclination angle . the value of the centrifugal radius not well constrained in this case either . however , on the basis of an additional analysis of the quality of the data points and the peculiarities of each source ( see discussion of individual sources ) we attempt to favor one of the fits as the best fit model
.    table [ tbl5 ] lists the values of the parameters of our best fit models : the inner , outer and centrifugal radii of the envelope , the stellar luminosity , the reference density at 1 au , and the inclination angle .
our best - fit model seds are shown in figures [ fig5 ] , [ fig6 ] , and [ fig7 ] .
table [ tbl6 ] lists other derived parameters for each source : the mass of the envelope , its temperature at a radius of 1000  au , the mass and spectral type of the central protostar , the mass accretion rate , the rate of ionizing photons , and the critical mass accretion rate .
these parameters have been derived following the procedures explained in the footnotes to the table .
this hmpo has been observed through continuum measurements at millimeter ( watt & mundy 1999 ) , submillimeter ( walsh et al . 2003 ) , and mid - infrared wavelengths .
the submillimeter data will be used in our modeling only as upper limits , since they have been obtained with a large beam ( @xmath74-@xmath75 ) and therefore it is not possible to separate the emission of the nearby uc region from that of the hmpo .
likewise , the millimeter flux densities will be used also as upper limits , since the analysis of watt & mundy ( 1999 ) suggests that the millimeter emission observed towards this source corresponds to free - free emission of the nearby uc region with a negligible contribution from dust .    in general , to constrain the physical parameters of the sources , we use the observed sed as well as the information on size and morphology given by the images .
however , the g11.94@xmath150.62 hmpo source appears unresolved in the near and mid - infrared images ( see figure  [ fig1 ] ) and therefore , we have only an upper limit for its size .
because we considered the far - infrared , submillimeter and millimeter data only as upper limits , the luminosity of this source is constrained essentially by the data at wavelengths near 20  @xmath0 m , that indicate that this is a low luminosity source .
we obtain a value of 75 @xmath76 for the luminosity of this object , corresponding to a a0 star of 5 @xmath14 .
since we only have upper limits for the flux densities in the submillimeter - millimeter wavelength range , we can not constrain the density and inclination simultaneously . therefore , we searched for fits both at low ( @xmath51=20@xmath77 - 30@xmath77 ) and high inclination angles ( @xmath51=50@xmath77 - 60@xmath77 ) . at low inclination angles , we obtained a quite good fit for @xmath7830@xmath77 , @xmath79 g @xmath80 , and @xmath81 au ( dot - dashed line in figure  [ fig5 ] ) , but this model predicts too much emission at 18.3 and 24.6 @xmath0 m .
in order to reproduce the observational data in the 18 - 25 @xmath0 m wavelength range , we require models with a high inclination angle . our best fit model is obtained for a high inclination angle , @xmath82 , with @xmath83 2@xmath84 g @xmath80 ( @xmath85 ) , and @xmath81 au ( solid line in figure [ fig5 ] ) .
we can obtain reasonable fits for @xmath86 g @xmath80 and @xmath87 au .
for example , a model with @xmath88 au is also feasible ( dotted line in figure [ fig5 ] ) .
however , we favor the @xmath81 au model ( solid line in figure [ fig5 ] , and tables 5 and 6 ) because it reproduces better the flux densities shortward of 8.7 @xmath0 m and the depth of the 10 @xmath0 m silicate absorption feature .    for our favored model , the ratio @xmath89 ( see table 6 ) .
therefore , the source could not develop a detectable region .
furthermore , since the luminosity obtained in this model is quite low , free - free emission from the hmpo would be hardly detectable , even in the case of a negligible accretion rate . thus , g11.94 - 0.62 is not luminous enough to be considered as a hmpo .
most likely , given the low temperature of the envelope ( @xmath90  k ) , it would be better considered as a `` warm core '' that is forming an intermediate - mass star , with an infall rate more than one order of magnitude higher than the typical infall rates of low - mass protostars ( see kch93 ) .
the g29.96 - 0.02 hmpo is the only source of our sample that appears to be associated with strong millimeter emission .
thus , for this source we have both infrared and millimeter data to constrain better the models .
the strong millimeter emission suggests a dense or luminous envelope .
in addition , the relatively strong near - infrared emission observed suggests that the envelope should be seen nearly pole - on , since in this direction there is a decrease of the density with respect to the equatorial plane that allows the escape of near - infrared radiation .
a reasonable fit ( solid - line in figure [ fig6 ] ) , explaining simultaneously the strong millimeter emission as well as the near - infrared flux densities , is obtained by assuming an extremely dense ( @xmath91 g @xmath80 ) , and therefore very massive envelope ( @xmath92 ) , with a centrifugal radius of @xmath93 au , seen with a low inclination angle ( @xmath94 ) , and heated by a luminous ( @xmath95 ) b1 star ( see tables 5 and 6 ) . this value of the luminosity is a lower limit , since it is the smallest value that is consistent with the mid - infrared and millimeter data points , and we estimate that it can be higher up to a factor of three .
likewise , we estimate that the uncertainty in the density scale is @xmath330% , and that the range of plausible values is @xmath96 for the inclination angle , and @xmath97 au for the centrifugal radius .
note that the 9.7 @xmath0 m data point is only an upper limit , and therefore it does not set the depth of the silicate absorption feature . also , we want to point out that we have not attempted that our models reproduce the exact values of the observational data points in the millimeter range , due to the problems discussed in  [ g29db ] and because errors are not available for some of these data points .
our best fit model predicts that the flux density at 3.9  @xmath0 m should be lower than the value observed .
we think that the excess of flux density observed at wavelengths shorter than 3.9  @xmath0 m could be due to scattered light in a cavity carved out by the outflow associated with g29.96@xmath150.02 hmpo ( gibb et al .
in fact , gibb et al . (
2004 ) suggest that scattered light in g29.96@xmath150.02 hmpo could be dominant even at 18 @xmath0 m .
however , our models show that the emission from 4 - 18  @xmath0 m can be reproduced as dust emission from an infalling flattened envelope , and that scattered light may only be dominant for wavelengths shorter than @xmath34  @xmath0 m .    from table 6
we see that the ratio @xmath98 .
thus , we do not expect the development of an region in the g29 hmpo .
this is consistent with the lack of strong free - free emission at the position of the source .    in order to illustrate the relevance of the millimeter constraints , in figure [ fig6 ] we show an additional model ( dotted - line ) , obtained by fitting only the mid - infrared observations .
for this model , we obtain a value of the luminosity of only 2400 @xmath76 , a density scale of @xmath99 g @xmath80 and an envelope mass of @xmath3 98  @xmath14 .
this set of parameters fits very well the mid - infrared data ; however the model predicts far too little emission at long wavelengths , underestimating by almost one order of magnitude the luminosity and mass .
these results illustrate that both millimeter as well as mid - infrared data are required in order to determine reliable values of the derived parameters .
it is worthwhile to mention that our models can fit the observed sed with a value of @xmath100 au , considerably smaller than the size of the elongated structures observed towards the g29.96 - 0.02 hmpo ( @xmath101 10,000 au , olmi et al .
2003 ) and some other high - mass protostars ( 1000 - 30000 au , see cesaroni 2005 and references therein ) .
these structures have been interpreted by some authors as tracing large - scale disks or rotating toroids .
our results suggest that these structures could be naturally explained as infalling flattened envelopes ( with sizes of thousands of aus ) , rather than as large circumstellar disks .
the formation of such disks is expected to occur at a scale of the order of @xmath38 , which according to our models could be of the order of hundreds of aus .      in order to compare the predicted sed of the g45.07 + 0.13 hmpo with the data , we use the existing millimeter observations ( taken from su et al . 2004 ) only as upper limits , since they do not have an angular resolution high enough to separate the hmpo emission from that of the uc region .
therefore , we will restrict our comparison to our mid - infrared observations .
the g45.07 + 0.13 hmpo exhibits an anomalous spectrum because in spite of its deep silicate absorption ( indicative of a large extinction ) , it presents a very strong emission in the near - infrared range ( 4 - 8 @xmath0 m ) . for this source
, we also have considered models for both high and low inclination angles .
a model with a highly inclined envelope ( @xmath102 ) , a density scale of @xmath103 g @xmath80 , and a centrifugal radius of @xmath104270 au ( dotted line in figure  [ fig7 ] ) predicts too little emission at 4.7 @xmath0 m and shorter wavelengths , and also presents a silicate absorption feature that is too weak .
alternatively , an envelope with a lower inclination ( @xmath105 ) , a larger density scale ( @xmath106 g @xmath80 ) , and a centrifugal radius of @xmath104370 au ( solid line in figure  [ fig7 ] and table 5 ) reproduces better the emission at 4.7 @xmath0 m as well as the depth of the silicate absorption , although it still has problems in explaining the emission at the shortest wavelengths ( @xmath63 m ) . both models require the same luminosity ( @xmath107 @xmath76 ) , implying a b1 star of 13 @xmath14 .
we favor the low inclination model ( solid line in figure  [ fig7 ] and tables 5 and 6 ) because it can explain reasonably well most of values of the observed flux density .
as we discussed for the g29.96 - 0.02 hmpo case , the excess of flux density observed at wavelengths shorter than 3.9  @xmath0 m could be due to scattered light . by running other models with slightly different values of the parameters , and taking into account the upper limits set by the submillimeter and millimeter data
, we estimate uncertainties of @xmath108 in the inclination angle , a factor of two in the density scale and the centrifugal radius , and a factor of three in the luminosity with respect to the values given in table 5 .    for the values given in table 6 , a ratio @xmath109 is derived .
thus , as in the previous sources , the mass accretion rate for the g45.07 + 0.13 hmpo is high enough to quench the development of an uc region , that is consistent with the lack of detected free - free emission towards this hmpo .
we have obtained mid - infrared data for four hmpo candidates at gemini observatory .
these data have the subarcsecond angular resolution necessary to isolate the emission of the hmpo candidates from that of nearby sources .
the data are well - sampled across the entire 2 to 25 @xmath6 atmospheric windows , and particularly throughout the 10 @xmath6 absorption feature .
since this wavelength range is very sensitive to the source geometry , we have constructed a grid of sed models for the physical conditions ( density , temperature , luminosity ) expected for the early stages of massive star formation , and taking into account for the first time the rotation as well as the natural flattening of the infalling envelopes .
these models reach a degree of complexity comparable to those developed for low - mass protostars . using our mid - infrared data , as well as the far - infrared and millimeter constraints available in the literature
, we have fit the seds of the hmpo candidates in g11.94@xmath150.62 , g29.96@xmath150.02 , and g45.07 + 0.13 , inferring physical parameters for the infalling envelopes as well as for the central stars .      1 .
the hmpo candidate in g11.94 - 0.62 does not seem to be luminous enough to be considered as a hmpo .
most likely , it would be better considered as a `` warm '' core that is forming an intermediate - mass star , with an infall rate more than one order of magnitude higher than the typical infall rates of low - mass protostars .
2 .   the candidates g29.96@xmath150.02 and g45.07 + 0.13 appear to be genuine hmpos with high luminosities , @xmath110 , and high accretion rates , @xmath111-@xmath112  yr@xmath113 . these values of the mass accretion rate exceed by several orders of magnitude the critical value required to quench the development of an uc region . therefore , these sources appear to be in a very early stage , previous to the development of an uc region .
our models are able to fit the observed seds of the hmpos with values of the centrifugal radius of a few hundred aus , which are considerably smaller than the size of the elongated structures observed towards some high - mass protostars ( 1000 - 30000 au ) .
these structures have been interpreted by some authors as tracing large - scale disks or rotating toroids .
our results suggest that these structures could be naturally explained as infalling flattened envelopes ( with sizes of thousands of aus ) , rather than as large circumstellar disks .
the formation of such disks is expected to occur at a scale of the order of @xmath38 , which according to our models could be of the order of hundreds of aus .
our detailed modeling suggests that massive star formation can proceed in a way very similar to the formation of low - mass stars .
unfortunately , massive protostars are more distant than low - mass protostars , and the instrumentation currently available in the far - infrared and millimeter ranges does not reach the angular resolution necessary to separate the hmpo emission from that of other nearby sources . since these wavelength ranges are very important to constrain properly the physical parameters of the sources , such as the luminosity , in general our fit models are not unique .
new data in these wavelength domains would be most valuable to determine the physical conditions in the early stages of massive star formation .    based on observations obtained at the gemini observatory , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, under a cooperative agreement with the nsf on behalf of the gemini partnership : the national science foundation ( united states ) , the particle physics and astronomy research council ( united kingdom ) , the national research council ( canada ) , conicyt ( chile ) , the australian research council ( australia ) , cnpq ( brazil ) and conicet ( argentina ) .
gemini program identification numbers associated with the data presented here are gs-2003b - dd-7 and gs-2004a - q-7 .
m. o. acknowledges support from iau peter gruber foundation , junta de andaluca , mcyt ( aya2002 - 00376 , including feder funds ) , and aeci .
we thank g. anglada for useful discussions and helpful suggestions .
we also thank f. wyrowski for communicating us his 1.4  mm data on g29.96@xmath150.02 before publication .
finally , we would also like to thank our referee for his / her thoughtful review of our manuscript and useful comments .


apart from their extreme biological importance , proteins are also very interesting objects from the point of view of statistical mechanics .
they possess a very well defined native structure which they are able to find in a short time among a potentially huge number of competing ones , and in spite of many metastable states . how proteins reconcile the stability of the native structure with the requirement that this structure is rapidly reached constitutes the essence of the fascinating and still open protein folding problem @xcite
an interesting question is whether the property of folding is a generic property of randomly assembled polypeptidic chains , regardless of their biological function , or is a special property that has evolved through natural selection .
this kind of question makes the protein folding problem a bridge between theoretical biology and the statistical mechanics of disordered systems .
motivated by this , numerous authors have studied simple models of random heteropolymers @xcite , see @xcite for a review .    in the following
, we shall discuss only the ` random bond model ' introduced independently by garel and orland @xcite and by shakhnovich and gutin @xcite .
more precisely , in our numerical simulations we will study a lattice version of this model .
preliminary results of this work have already been presented in @xcite . a `` protein '' with @xmath3 `` amino acids '' is represented as a self - avoiding walk @xcite of @xmath4 steps on the simple cubic lattice .
each pair @xmath5 of non - bonded monomers on nearest neighbor lattice sites contributes to the total energy an amount given by an independent and identically distributed ( iid ) gaussian variable @xmath6 with mean @xmath7 and variance @xmath8 .
formally , one defines the contact map of configuration @xmath9 , @xmath10 , as the matrix of binary variables @xmath11 , with @xmath12 , such that _ ij()= \ {    ll 1 & + 0 &    .
[ contact ] the energy of the model can then be written as e(,\{b})=_i < j _ ij()b_ij , with @xmath13 . for a given realization of the interaction energies @xmath6 ( representing a protein sequence in the biological analogy ) , the partition sum @xmath14 at temperature @xmath15
can be formally computed as z_n\{b_ij } = _ c e^-e(,\{b})/k_bt , where the sum over configurations @xmath16 runs over all self - avoiding @xmath4-step walks .
obviously , the above expression depends only on the variables @xmath17 and @xmath18 , i.e. we have a two - parameter phase diagram in the variables @xmath0 and @xmath19 .
the main advantage in using @xmath0 as one of the independent variables instead of @xmath15 or @xmath20 is that we can pass continuously from positive ( repulsive , hydrophilic ) to negative ( hydrophobic ) @xmath0 .    as usual with random models
, we have to evaluate the quenched average of the free energy .
this is a very difficult task , while it is rather easy to perform an annealed average over the disorder . for several models of random spin systems
it is well known that such an annealed approximation becomes exact in the high temperature phase , in the thermodynamic limit and at sufficiently large dimension .
the same is thought to be true for the present model .
it was indeed predicted in @xcite that the annealed approximation becomes exact in 3 dimensions when the chain length tends to infinity . for this to be true
it is necessary that the overlap between two randomly chosen replicas with the same realization of disorder vanishes in the limit @xmath21 .
numerical tests of this prediction have been made in the past for chains of length @xmath22 , mostly by means of exact enumerations of maximally compact chains of length 27 @xcite .
these authors found deviations ( replica overlap is non - zero ) which seemed to decrease with @xmath4 .
a similar result even for @xmath23 was found in @xcite , where also monte carlo simulations of very short chains were used ( up to @xmath24 ) .
but it is clear that tests with such short chains can hardly be significant . in the present paper we shall present monte carlo simulations for chains of length up to @xmath25 .
these simulations are made with the perm algorithm developed recently by one of us @xcite , and applied successfully to a number of different polymer problems @xcite .
we study the corrections to the annealed approximation using two different approaches .
first , we compute them using the replica method and assuming replica symmetry , which is believed to hold for low disorder .
even if a full computation was not possible , the expected behavior was well confirmed by numerical simulations .
second , we notice that corrections to the annealed approximation in the weak disorder limit can be related exactly to the average overlap between pairs of homopolymers ( without any disorder ) .
we give strong theoretical arguments that this overlap does not vanish in the limit @xmath21 .
we also calculate it by means of monte carlo simulations . unlike in the previous case
, these simulations do not involve the averaging over the disorder and thus can be applied to larger systems .
the two methods agree with each other and show that the corrections to the annealed approximation are small in @xmath26 , but do not vanish in the thermodynamic limit .
deviations from the annealed approximation are larger in the coil ( high - temperature ) phase and very small in the collapsed ( globular ) phase .
the annealed approximation is presented in sec.2 and compared to results of monte carlo simulations . in order to explain the observed deviations , we study in sec.3 a scenario where the overlap is non - zero but replica symmetry is unbroken . we again compare theoretical predictions with simulation results .
the relationship between the weak disorder limit and homopolymer overlap is discussed in sec.4 .
additional thermodynamic considerations are presented in sec.5 , and our final conclusions are drawn in sec.6 . the perm algorithm used for the simulations is discussed in an appendix .
in thermodynamic systems with quenched disorder we have to consider the average of the free energy per monomer over individual realizations of disorder @xmath27 which formally is given by    f_n(b , ) = -1n -1n _ i < j db_ij e^-(b_ij - b)^2/2 ^ 2 z_n\{b_ij } .    as for most random systems
, this can not be evaluated in closed form . much easier to evaluate
is the annealed approximation f_n , ann(b , ) = -1n [ annealed ] obtained by taking the disorder average before taking the log . here
the gaussian integrals can be done explicitly , with the result = _
e^-(b-12 ^ 2)_i < j _ ij ( ) .
since this is the partition sum for a homopolymer with pair energy = b-12 ^ 2 , [ ann2 ] we see that @xcite f_n , ann(b , ) = f_n(,0 ) .
[ f - annealed ]    therefore , all thermodynamic variables can be expressed in the annealed approximation in terms of an equivalent homopolymer with shifted interaction strength .
this relationship is easiest for those observables whose definition does not involve a derivative with respect to temperature , such as the gyration and end - to - end radii , and the density of non - bonded nearest neighbor contacts @xmath28 .
the latter is defined as the average number of nn .
contacts between non - consecutive monomers divided by @xmath4 . for these observables
, we have r_n , ann(b , ) = r_n(,0 ) [ r - ann ] and c_ann(b , ) = c(,0 ) , [ c - ann ] precisely as in eq.([f - annealed ] ) .    for energy @xmath29 and entropy @xmath30
the relations are less simple , since these involve derivatives of the free energy with respect to @xmath15 which are changed into derivatives with respect to @xmath0 and @xmath19 by our convention of using @xmath31 . for the energy per monomer it holds u_n , ann(b , ) = b-
^2 u_n(,0)= (b- ^2 ) c , [ u - anneal ] where we used the fact that the energy for homopolymers is @xmath32 .
for the specific entropy @xmath33 we use @xmath34 together with eq.([f - annealed ] ) , and obtain s_n , ann(b,)=s_n(,0 ) - ^22 u_n(,0 ) . [ s - anneal ]
the number of configurations with fixed @xmath28 should increase as @xmath35 for large @xmath4 , i.e. @xmath36 is the entropy density in the fixed-@xmath4 , fixed-@xmath28 ensemble . for homopolymers ,
the ensemble with fixed @xmath37 becomes equivalent to the fixed-@xmath28 ensemble in the limit @xmath21 , thus @xmath28 becomes a non - fluctuating function of @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and the above formula becomes simply s_n , ann(b,)= f()-^22c n , where @xmath39 is the solution of the saddle point equation f ( ) |_c = c = .
[ fprim ]    the condition for thermodynamic stability is that the second derivative of @xmath40 should be negative , corresponding to @xmath41 being minimal .
this is equivalent to requiring that the specific heat is positive .
in fact , the specific heat for a homopolymer is given by    c_v = bct =- b^2(^2fc^2)^-1 , [ cv ] which has been obtained by deriving both sides of eq.([fprim ] ) with respect to @xmath15 .
homopolymers with attraction between unbonded nearest neighbors show a collapse ( `` theta '' ) transition where the specific heat diverges .
thus we expect that the second derivative @xmath42 vanishes at the theta - point @xmath43 ( the precise value of the transition point depends on the lattice considered ) .
the annealed approximation is supposed to be valid both above and below the theta transition . at very low temperatures and very large disorder
, it has to break down since otherwise the entropy would become negative , according to eq.([s - anneal ] ) .
this signals another phase transition , the so - called freezing transition .
we shall not discuss this regime in this paper , but will treat it in a forthcoming publication .    since the theta point is a tricritical point @xcite ,
its upper critical dimension is d=3 .
therefore , we expect that in three dimensions the `` swelling factor '' is constant , r^2/ n const [ r - theta ] at the theta point , up to logarithmic corrections @xcite . here , @xmath44 is any measure of the size of the polymer , such as the end - to - end distance or the gyration radius .
we expect that this is still true for heteropolymers , as long as we are not yet in the frozen regime . while eq.([r - theta ] ) gives the most precise numerical estimate of the collapse transition ( with @xmath45 @xcite ) , estimates with similar precision can be obtained from the convexity of the free energy @xcite , and the volume dependence of the free energy in case of periodic boundary conditions @xcite .
the collapse line in the @xmath46-plot obtained from simulating chains of length @xmath47 is shown in fig.1 . here
the solid line is the annealed approximation .
we see that on this scale the annealed approximation seems perfect .
but this is not quite true .
much more precise tests can be performed by comparing directly both sides of eqs.([f - annealed ] ) to ( [ u - anneal ] ) .
typical plots obtained in this way are shown in figs.[fig : u_ann ] .
for each of these plots we used at least 300 realizations of disorder , and we got at least @xmath48 independent configurations for each disorder realization .
similar plots were made also for several other values of @xmath0 and @xmath19 .    in all these plots we see small but significant deviations .
these deviations are present both in the collapsed ( globular ) and in the open ( coil ) phase .
they depend only weekly on @xmath4 . therefore ,
even with our long chains and high statistics it is not clear whether they disappear for @xmath21 .
obviously , in order to proceed we need more refined theoretical predictions to compare with , and/or a more efficient way to do the disorder average .    before we do this
, we should point out that deviations from the annealed approximation were also found recently in a different model by trovato _
to go beyond the annealed approximation , we will use the replica trick = _ n0 - 1n .
[ rep ] alternatively , we could try a taylor expansion = - 12 ( /^2 -1 ) +  .
[ taylor ] this expansion is most likely divergent .
it is nevertheless useful since its first term gives already a good indication of the leading corrections .
also , it suggests the inequality f_n(b , ) f_n , ann(b , ) which can easily be derived exactly from convexity of the logarithm . the same inequality is expected to hold for @xmath49 .
this inequality is equivalent to the existence of a negative correlation between the average energy and the partition function . to use eq.([rep ] ) , we first have to evaluate disorder averages of @xmath50 for integer @xmath51 .
these are performed similarly to the average over @xmath14 , except that the gaussian integrals give formally rise to interactions between replicas @xcite , = _ c_1_n ( -_=1^n(_i < j_ij^)+ ^22_(_i < j_ij^_ij^ ) ) .
[ zn ] here the greek indeces @xmath52 and @xmath53 refer to the different replicas , @xmath54 is a configuration of replica @xmath52 , @xmath55 is its contact map and @xmath56 is given by equation ( [ ann2 ] ) .
the annealed approximation is equivalent to neglecting the two - replicas term .
to proceed , we define the variables c_=1n_i < j_ij^ , q_=1n_i < j_ij^_ij^ , [ cq ] which are respectively the density of contacts for the contact map @xmath52 and the overlap between two contact maps @xmath52 and @xmath53 .
the overlap is a measure of similarity , and it is equal to one if and only if the two contact maps coincide .
furthermore , we assume that , for large @xmath4 , the number of configuration @xmath57-tuples with @xmath58 contacts and mutual overlaps @xmath59 grows as [n(_=1^n f(c_)-_k=2^n _ k(\{c_},\{q _ } ) ) ] .
in other words , @xmath60 is the entropy loss per monomer when we impose that the replica @xmath61 with density of contacts @xmath62 has overlaps @xmath63 with the @xmath64 previous replicas .
this quantity can be measured , for instance for @xmath65 .
we can then write & & d\{c_}d\{q _ } + & & \ { n[_=1^n(f(c_)-c_)+^22 ( _ q_- _ k=2^n_k(\{c^},\{q _ } ) ) ] } + & & [-nnf_n(\{c^},\{q _ } ) ] .
[ exprep]here , @xmath66 is the free energy per monomer in a system with @xmath57 replicas . to evaluate it
, we approximate the integrals over @xmath62 and @xmath67 by their saddle points . we assume replica symmetry which is expected to hold for low disorder : the saddle point is assumed to be given by @xmath68 for all @xmath52 and @xmath69 for all pairs @xmath70 .
now , in order to obtain the correct free energy , we have to take the limit @xmath71 .
we obtain f(b,)=-f(c)+c+12 ^ 2 cq-(c , q ) .
[ f - saddle ] where @xmath72 is the average entropy gain per replica due to the condition that the overlap among all replicas is equal to @xmath73 .
note that this quantity is positive because , in the limit of vanishing @xmath57 , the number of terms in the sum is -1 . finally , we have to compute the values of @xmath28 and @xmath73 at which @xmath41 is evaluated by imposing two saddle point conditions :    & & f(c)c + ( c , q)c = + 12 ^ 2q [ eq_c ] , + & & 12 ^ 2c = ( c , q)q . [ eq_q ]    for @xmath74 ( homopolymer ) eq.([eq_q ] ) just means that the value of the overlap is the most probable one for a given @xmath28 , @xmath75 .
because of the normalization , it must be @xmath76 , thus the free energy of the homopolymer is just a special case of eq.([f - saddle ] ) .
moreover , since @xmath76 is an absolute minimum , also the derivative @xmath77 must vanish at that point , thus the saddle point equation for @xmath28 valid for the homopolymer is recovered for @xmath74 .
it also follows from this argument that the second derivatives of @xmath78 at the point @xmath79 must be non - negative .
notice that the free energy has to be maximized as a function of @xmath73 because this variable refers to a space with a negative number of dimensions in the limit @xmath71 .
we thus get a first condition of thermodynamic stability @xmath80 , which , from the above consideration , is expected to be fulfilled for @xmath19 small enough .
the situation is more complicated for the variable @xmath28 .
it enters both into the free energy of the replica interactions which has to be maximized for @xmath71 , and into the free energy of the homopolymer which has to be minimized , at least for @xmath74 .
we conjecture that the corresponding condition of thermodynamic stability is that the hessian determinant of the free energy respect to the variables @xmath28 and @xmath73 , @xmath81 , be non positive :    h(c , q)=(^2 fc^2 + ^2c^2 ) ^2q^2- (^2cq-1cq)^2 0 .
[ denom ]    for @xmath74 we have @xmath82 as for homopolymers .
in fact , at that point the first derivatives of @xmath78 vanish .
the hessian determinant vanishes also , because @xmath78 stays constant at the value zero along the line @xmath83 .
thus both conditions of thermodynamic stability are fulfilled at @xmath19 small enough .
the energy and entropy per monomer are obtained in the same way as in the annealed approximation .
we find & & u_n(b , ) = (b-^2(1-q))c , [ eq_ene ] + & & s_n(b,)= f(c)+(c , q)-^22c(1-q ) .
[ eq - ent ] although this is obtained from the saddle point method which is exact only for @xmath21 , we can use eq.([eq_ene ] ) to obtain effective values of @xmath73 also for finite @xmath4 .
results are shown in fig.[fig : q]a .
it appears that @xmath73 decreases with system size , but its asymptotic value seems to be finite in the random coil phase .
this was confirmed by similar measurements at different values of @xmath84 .
thus the annealed approximation does _ not _ hold in the random coil phase .
the situation is more difficult for collapsed chains . in this case
it can not be excluded from fig.[fig : q]b that the overlap asymptotically vanishes , and thus the annealed approximation becomes exact in the thermodynamic limit .
however , simulations of systems of even larger size that will be presented in the next section show that this is not the case and that the corrections to the annealed approximation remain finite in the thermodynamic limit in both the coil and the collapsed phases , although in the latter phase they are rather small . as seen from fig.[fig : q]b , @xmath73 does not depend very much on @xmath19 in the collapsed phase and for large systems .    to obtain numerical estimates of @xmath85
, we subtract from eq.([f - saddle ] ) the analogous equation for homopolymers , and obtain f(b,)-f(,0 ) = ( c-)- [ f(c)-f()]+12 ^ 2cq -(c , q ) . expanding the difference @xmath86 in the difference @xmath87 and using @xmath88
, we get f(b,)-f(,0 ) = -12(c-)^2f()+12 ^ 2cq -(c , q ) + o((c-)^2 ) .
[ df ] this can be either evaluated directly , neglecting the last term .
alternatively , we can eliminate the term involving @xmath89 by subtracting from eq.([eq_c ] ) the analogous equation for homopolymers , which gives ( c-)f  ( ) = 12 ^ 2q-(c , q)c + o((c-)^2 ) .
[ df ] combining this with eq.([df ] ) and neglecting terms @xmath90 , we obtain finally f(b,)-f(,0 ) = c+c4 ^ 2q -12[(c , q)+(,q ) ] + o((c-)^2 ) .
[ eq - chi ] in fig.[fig : chi ] we show numerical values for @xmath91/2 $ ] obtained in this way .
we see that @xmath85 is very small but definitely not zero .
again we see that corrections to the annealed approximations are larger in the swollen phase than in the collapsed phase . indeed , this time it seems that the deviations have a finite limit for @xmath21 in both phases .
this conclusion is supported by measurements at other values of @xmath19 ( not shown here ) .
basically the same conclusions are also drawn from eq.([df ] ) , showing that @xmath78 depends weakly on @xmath28 and that eq.([df ] ) is very well satisfied .
in this section we will discuss the overlap of contact matrices for homopolymer chains and their relation to corrections to the annealed approximation in the weak disorder limit . consider the derivative of the free energy of a random heteropolymer with respect to @xmath1 , at @xmath74 . using eqs.([taylor],[zn ] ) and the results of sec.2 , we obtain _ = 0 = n^-1 _ = 0 = -12f_n(b,0)b + 12n _ _
1,_2_i < j ^1_ij^2_ij .
thus we have _ = 0 = 12 cq .
[ pair ] this could have been obtained of course also within the replica symmetric approach , but the above derivation shows that it is indeed a rigorous result involving neither approximations nor unjustified assumptions .
notice that this can not be generalized to @xmath92 , but in principle straightforward generalizations could be used to compute all higher derivatives _ = 0 ,
k = 1,2,3,  .
numerically , the rhs . of eq.([pair ] ) can be estimated by simulating pairs of chains simultaneously . for this we used a variant of the perm algorithm where we add monomers alternatively to the first and to the second chain @xcite .
in this way we guarantee that both chains have exactly the same length ( after having added an even number of monomers ) , and it is straightforward to estimate their overlap .    results from such simulations with chains of length up to 1400
are shown in fig.[fig : q0 ] .
these data agree nicely with extrapolations of the overlaps for @xmath93 shown in the last section .
they have much smaller statistical errors , since we do not have to average over any disorder explicitly .
this makes the present method much faster and allows us to study larger systems .
the curve for @xmath94 in fig.[fig : q0 ] shows clearly that the annealed approximation does not become exact for @xmath21 in the open coil phase .
the same is true ( although a bit less clear ) exactly at the @xmath95 point , as indicated by the curve for @xmath96 . for the collapsed phase ,
the evidence is not so clear .
the curves for @xmath97 and for @xmath98 both are much lower for large @xmath4 and continue to decrease . superficially , one might therefore conclude that the overlap disappears for @xmath21 . but
both these curves show a distinct upward curvature for the largest values of @xmath4 , indicating that the decrease will level off and @xmath99 tends to a finite constant for @xmath21 . to sustain this view
, we show in fig.[fig : cq ] the plots of @xmath100 as a function of chain length @xmath4 . in this case
it is evident that the curves are going to a non - zero value .
since the fraction of contacts is limited ( it holds @xmath101 on the cubic lattice ) , also @xmath102 should go to a non - zero value , and the decrease observed in fig.[fig : q0 ] is just a consequence of the fact that the average fraction of contacts is increasing , approaching its stationary value .
this conclusion is not , after all , very surprising .
it can be backed by an argument which could presumably , with some effort , be made rigorous . the density of contacts in a self - avoiding walk ( saw , corresponding to @xmath103 )
is dominated by short range contacts , i.e. by contacts @xmath5 with small @xmath104 .
the contribution of such a loop with fixed @xmath105 and @xmath106 depends weakly on the configuration of the chain far away from this monomer pair .
thus , if such a loop is present in one replica , it has a high chance to be present also in the other replica , even if the global structures of both replicas are entirely different .
notice that this argument depends crucially on the fact that it is the overlap between _ contact matrices _ which is of relevance , not the geometric overlap between configurations .
it seems that the authors of @xcite have missed this in an otherwise very similar argument which has led them to the opposite conclusion that the annealed approximation does become exact .    in collapsed chains
there are relatively more long range contacts , which explains why the annealed approximation is better  but still not exact  in that regime . for random heteropolymers with strong disorder , and
even more so for proteins , this argument suggests an increased overlap because of secondary structure .
for instance , an alpha helix produces an array of contacts @xmath107 , @xmath108 , where @xmath105 labels the position of the amino acid along the protein chain .
this enhances the overlap .
moreover , there is a finite probability that such contacts appear simultaneously even in the structures of two unrelated proteins .
thus the average overlap even in a large set of unrelated protein structure appears to attain a finite limit when the length of the chains increases @xcite .
the two saddle point equations for @xmath28 and @xmath73 can not be explicitly solved , because we lack an explicit expression for the functions @xmath36 and @xmath78 .
nevertheless , their qualitative behavior can be studied in more detail .
this is done in the present section .    deriving both equations ( [ eq_c],[eq_q ] ) with respect to the thermodynamic parameters @xmath37 and @xmath19 we can compute the derivatives of @xmath28 and @xmath73 as     ( c ) _ = ^2q^2 h(c , q ) 0 , & &  ( c ) _ = -h(c ,
q ) q  ( c c -q q ) .
[ der ] + (q ) _
= -^2cq-1cq h(c , q ) , & & (q ) _
= h(c , q )  [ c (^2 fc^2 + ^2c^2)- q (^2cq-1cq ) ] . where @xmath81 is given by eq.([denom ] ) .
from these , the specific heat can be computed as    c_v & = & u / t + & = & (b-^2(1-q))[(b-^2)c+ ] -^2c[(1-q)+(b-^2)q+ ] + & = & -1h(c , q)[^2fc^2(^2c)^2- 2 ^ 2fcq(^2c)(b-^2(1-q))+ ^2fq^2(b-^2(1-q))^2 ] + & & + ^2c(1-q ) , where @xmath109 is the free energy evaluated at the saddle point .
the three terms in the square brackets are the quadratic form whose determinant is expressed by @xmath81 .
since @xmath110 is positive , they would give a negative contribution to the specific heat if @xmath81 were positive .
thus it is justified to require that @xmath81 is negative in order to get thermodynamic stability .
the behavior of the thermodynamic derivaties ( [ der ] ) can be partly studied using the fact that the function @xmath78 attains its absolute minimum value @xmath111 along the line @xmath83 .
thus , assuming that it is an analytic function of @xmath73 for @xmath112 , it can be expressed in the form ( c , q)=_k=2^(q - q_0(c))^k _ k=2^(q - q_0(c))^k , [ chi_approx ] with @xmath113 . the typical overlap @xmath75 is a small quantity and it is a decreasing function of @xmath28 , or @xmath114 ( the prime indicates derivative with respect to @xmath28 ) .
the coefficients @xmath115 are expected to be quantities of order @xmath116 , as it will be argued later .
we also introduce the notation @xmath117 , @xmath118 , @xmath119 .
we can now develop the saddle point equations for @xmath28 close to the solution @xmath120 of the annealed approximation given by @xmath88 :    & &  ( ^2 fc^2+^22 ^ 2 q_0c^2 ) _ c = c (c - c)+ (^22q_0c ) _ c = c+ (_k=2^ (q - q_0(c))^k)_c = c=0 + & & _ k=1^(q - q_0(c))^k=12 ^ 2 . from these expressions
one sees that both @xmath121 and @xmath87 are quantities of order @xmath122 , thus corrections to the annealed approximation are small but finite for finite @xmath19 .
moreover , @xmath123 is positive for small @xmath19 . from eq.([chi_approx ] ) we find , to zero - th order in @xmath124 :    (c ) _ 0 & & (c ) _
+ (q ) _ 0 & & (q ) _
[c ^2 fc^2+a_2(c)q_0cq_0c ] [ chi(cq ) ] @xmath81 must be computed at the first order in @xmath124 , because the zero - th order term vanishes at the theta point @xmath43 at which @xmath125 vanishes .
the result reads :    h(c , q)- (q - q_0(c))c(a_2(c))^2 ^ 2 q_0c^2 .
[ hh ]    to proceed further , we first consider the simple case where the entropy @xmath78 depends only on the product @xmath117 representing the number of conditions that we have to impose in order to fix an overlap @xmath73 : @xmath126 .
this form was assumed in the work of shakhnovich and gutin @xcite .
as it is easy to see , under the above hypothesis @xmath127 coincides with the value predicted by the annealed approximation and it is independent of @xmath19 at fixed @xmath37 .
thus , in this case the annealed approximation would yield the correct value for the fraction of contacts .
however , our numerical results contradict this prediction .
the overlap @xmath73 is in this case an increasing function of @xmath19 , and its derivative with respect to @xmath37 is proportional to @xmath128 , which is expected to diverge at the theta point @xmath43 .
this fact can explain why the values of @xmath73 are much smaller in the collapsed phase than in the coil phase .
a better theory for the function @xmath78 was developed by plotkin , wang and wolynes @xcite .
they computed the entropy loss for two replicas with density of contacts @xmath28 being at overlap @xmath73 , @xmath129 , in the mean field approximation and in the collapsed phase .
although this can be different from @xmath78 , it is a good point for understanding its qualitative behavior .
unfortunately , we can not use the formula obtained in @xcite because of several reasons : first , the result is valid for finite @xmath4 and becomes pathologic as @xmath21 ; second , it is not given in the form of a differentiable function ; and third , it is assumed that the most probable overlap @xmath75 is zero in the thermodynamic limit , while our calculations show that this is not the case .
we shall however use the fact that @xmath78 is the sum of three contributions : the entropy loss due to imposing that @xmath130 contacts have to coincide , the loss due the fact that @xmath131 contacts have to be different , and a combinatoric factor counting the number of different choices of @xmath130 contacts among @xmath132 .
the last term can be approximated by @xmath133 $ ] , even if this is an overestimate , since not all of the combinations of different common contacts can be realized .
putting everything together we have :    ( c , q)=(c , cq)+c[qq+(1-q)(1-q ) ] [ plot ] . in the computation by plotkin _
_ the mixed second derivative of @xmath134 with respect to @xmath117 and @xmath28 vanishes .
this simplifies considerably formulas , and it will be assumed to hold for the rest of the paper .
we shall thus introduce the notation @xmath135 to denote the derivative of @xmath136 with respect to @xmath117 at fixed @xmath28 . comparing eq.([plot ] ) to eq.([chi_approx ] ) , we see that @xmath137 must be positive and that @xmath138 .
we also see that @xmath139 is likely to be a quantity of order @xmath140 , as it has been assumed above . for the higher order
coefficients one finds @xmath141 , as anticipated .
we have now to compute the derivatives of @xmath118 :    = -^2/cq^2/q^2= q_01+cq_0^(cq_0)(1-q_0 ) 0 , [ q ] in qualitative agreement with fig.[fig : cq ] . inserting the above result in the formulas ( [ chi(cq ) ] )
we see that the density of contacts decreases with @xmath19 at fixed @xmath37 .
this behavior is confirmed by our numerical results ( see fig.[fig : c_delta ] ) , which also show that the decrease is maximal for @xmath142 , as expected from the fact that @xmath143 vanishes at @xmath43 .
the overlap @xmath73 increases with @xmath37 at fixed @xmath19,as expected from eq.([chi(cq ) ] ) ( see fig.[fig : delta ] ) , and increases with @xmath19 at fixed @xmath37 , as expected from eq.([q ] ) ( see fig.[fig : delta ] again ) .
it can thus be understood why the overlap decreases with system size : as the number @xmath4 of monomers increases the importance of surface effects is reduced ( as @xmath144 ) and @xmath145 increases , thus decreasing the value of @xmath73 .
we now examine the condition of thermodynamic stability , @xmath146 . as it was already observed , since at the point @xmath147 both the gradient of @xmath78 and its hessian determinant vanish , we have @xmath148 . at the theta point
this quantity vanishes , and @xmath149 is given by the deviations from the annealed approximation .
three situations are possible : first , @xmath149 can be positive at the leading order in @xmath150 . in this case
the thermodynamic stability would be violated around the theta point , but our simulations do not show anything strange in this region .
second , the leading order in @xmath124 can be negative . in this case ,
the specific heat would not diverge anymore at the theta point for finite @xmath19 , but it would show a peak proportional to some negative power of @xmath124 . thus the disorder would smear out the thermodynamic singularity at @xmath43 , leaving unchanged the geometric characterization of the collapsed chains in terms of the gyration radius .
it is rather difficult , if not impossible , to test this scenario by means of simulations .
third , @xmath149 can vanish identically at @xmath43 .
it is easy to see that this condition , combined with the assumption that @xmath78 is of the form ( [ plot ] ) , is fulfilled if and only if @xmath151 is of the form    ^(cq)=(1-cq / bcq / a ) , [ chi_pr ] where @xmath152 , @xmath153 and @xmath154 are two constants , and @xmath28 is not too small so that the last inequality can be fulfilled . in this case
, one finds @xmath155 $ ] , and it is easy to check that all previous results are recovered , while @xmath156 vanishes for all @xmath73 and @xmath28 , including the theta point .    summarizing the discussion , we find that , if @xmath78 is of the form ( [ plot ] ) , two possibilities are open : either @xmath151 is given by eq.([chi_pr ] ) , in which case @xmath157 , or @xmath151 has a different form , in which case the specific heat is not anymore divergent at the theta point @xmath43 .
unfortunately , we are not able to decide among these alternatives .
we conclude this section showing in fig.[fig : chi27 ] , for the sake of completeness , the entropy loss @xmath129 obtained from simulations of homopolymer chains with @xmath158 . although the system size considered is definitely too small for quantitative considerations , the qualitative behavior is interesting and confirms the above considerations .
the entropy @xmath129 was computed from    _ 2(c , q)=-1np_2(c , q ) , where @xmath159 is the probability density for a pair of chains , both with density of contacts @xmath28 , being at overlap @xmath73 .
we have shown that the annealed approximation is very good but not exact for a particular model of random heteropolymers , and we have given simple physical arguments for it .
we have also computed the thermodynamics of the model using the replica symmetric approximation , and we have shown that such approach can explain very well , at least qualitatively , the observed deviations from the annealed approximation in the high temperature phase .
the replica symmetric calculation also leaves open , surprisingly , the possibility that the disorder could cancel the thermodynamic singularity at the theta point .
a numerical test of this possibility is very difficult , and it has been left out .    in our present study
we have not addressed the most interesting aspect of the model  the freezing of the system in a finite number of mesoscopic states .
this transition should represent some features of the folding transition taking place for protein structures .
instead , we have studied the model at higher temperatures and at smaller disorder .
this should however be of interest also in the context of the freezing , since it was conjectured @xcite that freezing can be described in this model by the random energy model , a prerequisite for which is that the annealed approximation is exact .    in the present simulations we have studied chains of length up to @xmath25 .
deviations from the annealed approximation decrease fast for small @xmath4 , which explains why studying very short chains has mislead several authors to the conclusion that these deviations vanish for @xmath21 .
but in the high - t ( open coil ) phase this decrease clearly stops , and deviations are roughly independent of @xmath4 for @xmath160 .
this is less clear in the collapsed phase .
but also there numerics , general arguments , and detailed calculations within a specific scenario with unbroken replica symmetry all indicate that these deviations will settle at a non - zero value for large @xmath4 .
this casts doubts on the validity of the random energy picture for protein folding .
there are of course a number of questions which are left open by the present study .
first of all , we have deliberately left out all questions related to freezing .
secondly , our treatment of sec.3 assumed that the overlap distribution is always dominated by a single peak .
this is most likely not true in the frozen regime , and the distribution of overlaps is certainly a most interesting object .
we shall address these questions in a forthcoming paper @xcite .
finally , we have studied only one particular model , where contact energies are independent gaussian variables .
several other models of random heteropolymers are studied in the recent literature @xcite , and several of them present very intersting open problems .
we are indebted to many colleges for useful discussions , in particular to h. frauenkron , w. nadler , h. orland , e. shakhnovich , a. trovato and m. vendruscolo .
this method which was first described in detail in @xcite is a chain growth method .
it is based on rosenbluth s idea of biased sampling @xcite , but it deviates from it by deleting ( ` pruning ' ) configurations with too low weight , and copying configurations with too large weight ( ` enrichment ' ) .
we remind the reader that the bias in the rosenbluth method requires each configuration to carry a non - trivial weight which builds up gradually as monomer by monomer is added .
in addition to this ` rosenbluth factor ' , there is also a boltzmann factor in the case of interacting polymers . the weights which control pruning / enrichment are the product of the two .
both pruning and enrichment are done while the chains grow , i.e. based on the actual ( incomplete ) weight factors . in some cases it is advantageous to use not the present weights but ( implicit ) estimates of future weights to control the algorithm @xcite , but this is not done in the present paper .
instead , we use some of the special tricks used for strongly collapsed systems in @xcite .
when the weight is too low , configurations are not simply killed ( this would imply systematic errors ) , but instead they are killed with probability 1/2 , and those which are not killed get their weights doubled .
similarly , in the case of cloning the weight is spread uniformly among all clones .
technically , cloning is performed by means of recursive subroutine calls .
a pseudocode of the basic algorithm is given in the appendix of @xcite .
the most important shortcoming of the rosenbluth method is that the distribution of weights can become extremely wide for large systems and at low temperatures .
the only exception is for interacting homopolymers on the simple cubic lattice at the theta point , where rosenbluth and boltzmann factors nearly cancel . in less favorable cases
even a very large statistical sample can be dominated by just a handful of high weight events , and statistical errors grow out of bounds .
even worse , in extreme cases the events which would carry ( in average ! )
most of the weight are so rare that they are missed completely with high probability , and the free energy is underestimated systematically .    pruning and
enrichment guarantee that the weights of individual configurations stay within narrow bounds , and the above can not happen .
but in very difficult situations ( large @xmath4 , low t , large disorder ) it may happen that due to cloning the configurations are strongly correlated , and the weights of clusters of such correlated configurations play essentially a similar role as the weights of individual configurations in the above discussion . in the following
we will call such a cluster which is composed of all configurations having a common root a ` tour ' . in order to check that the weights of tours do not become too uneven ,
we have measured in their distribution .
let us call the weights @xmath161 , and the distribution @xmath162 .
we are on safe grounds if this distribution is so narrow that @xmath162 and @xmath163 have basically the same support .
in particular , we should require that the maximum of @xmath163 occurs at such values where @xmath162 is still appreciable , and the distribution is well sampled .
we have verified that this is the case for all data shown in the present paper .
notice , however , that this is a very stringent requirement .
if it is were not satisfied , this would not necessarily mean that the data are wrong , since configurations within one tour are only partially correlated .
the generalization of this algorithm to pairs of chains growing simultaneously is straightforward @xcite .
one just has to add monomers alternatingly .
when the total number of monomers in both chains is even , the addition of the next monomer is attempted at chain 1 ; when this number is odd , the next monomer is added to chain 2 .